H-2 restriction specificity of T cells from H-2 incompatible radiation bone marrow chimeras: Further evidence for the absence of crucial influence of the host/thymus environment on the generation of H-2 restricted TNP-specific T lymphocyte precursors

Experiments were conducted to answer the questions related to (a) the role played by the antigen-presenting cells (APCs) present within the thymus and (b) the effect of radiation dose to the recipients on the H-2 restriction profile of TNP-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTLP) recovered from spleens and/or thymuses of H-2 incompatible radiation bone marrow chimeras (BMC). The H-2 restriction profile of intrathymically differentiating TNP-specific CTLPs was also analyzed in order to test an argument that donor-H-2 restricted CTLP detected in spleens of H-2 incompatible BMC were due to the extrathymically differentiated T cells under the influence of donor-derived lymphoreticular cells. The results indicated the following: (i) splenic T cells from B10(H-2^b)→ (B10(H-2^b) → B10.BR(H-2^k)) chimeras, which were constructed by irradiating primary BIO → B10.BR chimeras with 1100 R and reconstituting them with donor-type (B10) bone marrow cells as long as 8 months after their construction, manifested restriction specificities for both donor- and host-type H-2, (ii) splenic T cells from two types of (B10 × B10.BR)F₁→ B10 chimeras which were reconstituted after exposure of the recipients with either 900 or 1100 R with donor-type bone marrow cells generated both donor- and host-H-2 restricted TNP-specific cytotoxic T cells, and (iii) the TNP-specific CTLPs present in the regenerating thymuses of B10.BR → B10 and (B10 × B10.BR)F₁→ B10 chimeras 4 weeks after their construction were also shown to manifest both donor- and host-H-2 restriction specificities. The significance of these findings on the H-2 restriction profile of CTLP generated in BMCs is discussed.     

Study on the possible factors influencing the expression of H-2 restriction specificity and Ir phenotype of antigen-specific proliferative T cells with various types of radiation chimeras

To better understand the factors described previously as influencing the manifestation of H-2 restriction specificity and Ir phenotype of T cells from radiation bone marrow chimeras, we also examined H-2 restriction specificity (Ir phenotype) of antigen (DNP-OVA, (T, G)-A-L, (H, G)-A-L)-specific proliferative T cells generated in various types of H-2 incompatible radiation chimeras prepared under our specific-pathogen-free (SPF) condition. The results indicated the following: (a) T cells generated in F1----parent bone marrow chimeras preferentially manifested host-type H-2 restriction specificity and Ir phenotype, regardless of the radiation dose (8.70 vs 11.59 Gy); (b) T cells recovered from twice-reconstituted F1----(PA----PB) chimeras manifested primary host (PB)-type Ir phenotype; (c) T cells which were recovered from (B10.Thy-1.1 X B10.BR.Thy-1.1)F1----parent (Thy-1.2) bone marrow chimeras and treated with anti-Thy-1.2 plus complement to deplete host-derived T cells still manifested preferentially the restriction specificity for host-type H-2; (d) PA-derived T cells which had differentiated in a fully allogeneic host (PB) environment of (PA + PB)----PB chimeras manifested fully allogeneic host-type Ir phenotype; (e) T cells from F1----parent chimeras that were prepared with 13-day fetal liver cells also manifested host H-2-restricted Ir phenotype; and (f) host preference for Ir phenotype of antigen-specific proliferative T cells was observed even in the case of F1----parent bone marrow chimeras reconstituted with "intact" bone marrow cells. The data suggest that thymic APCs, surviving host T cells or the source of stem cells (adult bone marrow vs 13-day fetal liver), do not necessarily play a significant role in the manifestation of H-2 restriction specificity and Ir phenotype of T cells generated in H-2 incompatible radiation chimeras.     

T helper 2 and T follicular helper cells: Regulation and function of interleukin-4

Type 2 immunity is characterized by expression of the cytokines interleukin (IL)-4, IL-5, IL-9 and IL-13, which can function in mediating protective immunity in the host or possess a pathogenic role. T helper (Th) 2 cells have emerged to play a beneficial role in mediating anti-parasitic immunity and are also known to be key players in mediating allergic diseases. In addition to the Th2 cells, recent studies have identified T follicular helper (Tfh) cells as an alternative source of IL-4 to regulate type 2 humoral immune responses, indicating that Th2 and Tfh cells exhibit overlapping phenotypical and functional characteristics. Th2 and Tfh cells appear to utilize distinct mechanisms for regulation of IL-4 expression; however unlike Th2 cells, the regulation and function of Tfh-derived IL-4 is not yet fully understood. Understanding of the molecular mechanisms for IL-4 expression and function in both cell subsets will be beneficial for the development of future therapeutic interventions.     

Deletion of self-reactive T cells in nude mice grafted with neonatal allogeneic thymus

The cellular basis of tolerance induction has been investigated in BALB/c(H-2d, thy 1.2, M1s1b2a) nude mice grafted with thymus of neonatal AKR/J mice(H-2k,Thy1.1,M1s1a2b). The spleen cells from nude mice grafted with AKR/J thymus showed a significantly decreased level of primary cytotoxic T cell response when stimulated with AKR/J cells, although these cells lysed well target cells of a third party C57BL/6 when stimulated with C57BL/6 cells. Consistent with CTL responses, T cells bearing V beta 6, that is important for recognizing M1s1a-encoded products of the thymic phenotype, were virtually abolished in the spleen and lymph node cells of nude mice 8 wk after grafting with AKR/J thymus. However, a substantial number of V beta 6-bearing T cells were detected in the peripheral organs of nude mice 23 wk after grafting with AKR/J thymus and in those of nude mice grafted with AKR/J fetal thymus depleted of macrophages/dendritic cells by incubating with 2'-deoxyguanosine in vitro before grafting. On the other hand, T cells bearing V beta 3, which are selectively related to M1s2a-encoded products of the host phenotype, were expressed neither on the peripheral T cells of nude mice grafted with AKR/J thymus at any stage after grafting nor on those of nude mice grafted with 2'-deoxyguanosine-treated AKR/J thymus. These data suggested that both V beta 6 and V beta 3 T cells were eliminated in the thymus of nude mice grafted with AKR/J thymus, presumably on the basis of interaction with both of graft-derived persisting and host-derived hemopoietic cells in the thymus and that thymic epithelium appears to have little capacity to eliminate T cells reactive to minor lymphocyte stimulating-encoded products.     

Cognate interactions between helper T cells and B cells. V. Reconstitution of T helper cell function using purified plasma membranes from activated Th1 and Th2 T helper cells and lymphokines.

Th physically interact with B cells and produce lymphokines that influence B cell growth and differentiation. The respective contribution of cell contact and lymphokines to induction of B cell growth and differentiation was addressed using purified plasma membranes (PM) from resting Th (PMrest) and anti-CD3-activated Th (PMCD3) together with lymphokines. Results show that PMCD3, but not PMrest, induce 10% of resting B cells to enter the G1 phase of the cell cycle, with few B cells entering G1b and S/G2. The inclusion of IL-4, but not IL-2, IL-5, or IFN-gamma, amplifies the B cell response to PMCD3 by increasing the total percentage of activatable B cells to greater than 40% and inducing B cell progression into G1b, S, and G2. Direct comparison between PMrest and PMCD3 purified from Th1 and Th2 indicate that both Th1 and Th2 induce similar levels of B cell proliferation in the presence of IL-4. Further, the lymphokine requirements for B cell proliferation induced by PMCD3 from Th1 and Th2 is indistinguishable. B cell differentiation to IgM, IgG1, and IgG2a synthesis by PMCD3 required IL-4 and IL-5. Using lymphokine conditions that supported B cell differentiation, PMCD3 purified from Th1 and Th2 induced similar levels of IgM, and IgG1. Given the functional data on PMCD3 from Th1 and Th2, the data indicate that there are no substantive differences between Th1- and Th2-derived PMCD3, and that the major differences in the ability of viable Th1 and Th2 to activate B cells is the lymphokines produced by the cells.     

Epitopes associated with the MHC restriction site of T cells. I. Selective expression of Iat epitopes on H-2-restricted helper T cells

We previously established monoclonal antibodies (mAb) that are putatively directed to the I region of H-2k but are reactive only with T cells. Because of their specificity to the unique epitopes different from class II antigens, they are designated as anti-Iat reagents. The present study demonstrated that these anti-Iat inhibit the H-2k-restricted helper T (Th) cell function by acting on the very H-2 restriction site of both H-2k and H-2kxb F1 T cells. This was determined by both the cytotoxic treatment and blocking of antigen-primed Th cells. In the F1 Th population, only those restricted to H-2k were eliminated, leaving the H-2b-restricted Th cells uninhibited. The inhibition of the response was not due to the induction of suppressor T cells, but to the elimination of the function of radioresistant Lyt-1+,2- Th cells. Iatk epitopes were also found on an H-2k-restricted but not on H-2b-restricted Th cell clone established from the same H-2kxb F1 animal. None of the anti-Iatk were reactive with class II antigens on B cells. These results indicate that Iat epitopes are not directly encoded by the I region genes, but are associated with the H-2 restriction site of T cells, which see the self class II polymorphism. Thus, Iat epitopes are expressed clonally in high frequency on H-2k-restricted Th cells of F1, being excluded from the H-2b-restricted Th population. The relationship between Iat and T cell receptor molecules is unknown.     

The extent of self-MHC restriction of cytotoxic T cells in nude mice varies from mouse to mouse

There are conflicting results as to whether the response of athymic nude mice to TNP-modified self determinants is or is not H-2 restricted. We cultured spleen cells from 29 individual RNC (H-2k) nude mice with TNP-modified self determinants and tested the cultures for their ability to lyse TNP-modified self (RNC-TNP) and TNP-modified allogeneic (BALB/c-TNP) target cells. Each mouse was stimulated by two different protocols: either by the addition of TNP-modified irradiated nu/+ spleen cells or by TNP modification of the nude responder cells without addition of other cells. All mice could lyse RNC-TNP targets and about one-half could also lyse BALB/c-TNP targets, i.e., there was a 50:50 division between restricted and unrestricted responses. The magnitude of the response against RNC-TNP and whether the response was restricted were both independent of the method of stimulation. We conclude that H-2 restriction in these mice is imposed by an as yet unidentified environmental influence that can vary from one nude mouse to the next. The influence appears to act through negative selection because the modified self response is, if anything, higher in mice showing an unrestricted response.     

Antigen-specific helper T cells recognize determinants encoded in the H-2D region of the H-2 gene complex

Observations have frequently been interpreted as showing that the helper T cells which collaborate with alloantigen-specific cytotoxic T-cell precursors can only recognize antigens encoded in the I region of the H-2 gene complex. An experimental system is described here that allows analysis of the recognition repertoire of these helper cells. CBA helper T-cell precursors can be primed in vitro to antigens encoded in the H-2 ^b gene complex. These helpers can then be tested for the existence of a subset of helper cells which recognize antigens encoded in the D region of H-2 ^b haplotype. CBA thymocytes were used as a source of cytotoxic T-cell precursors that respond poorly in the absence of exogeneous helper activity. The source of alloantigen was varied by using irradiated spleen cells from various (BALB/c × recombinant)F₁ hybrid mice as stimulator cells. When the stimulator cell bears BALB/c determinants recognized by the cytotoxic T-cell precursor and also bears only the D region antigens of the H-2 ^b haplotype, an anti-BALB/c cytotoxic response is generated only if the anti-H-2^b helper population contains cells able to recognize H-2D^b. A positive cytotoxic response was obtained, indicating that helper cells are not limited to recognition of I region antigens and can efficiently recognize antigens encoded in the D region of the H-2 gene complex. This was confirmed by the demonstration of helpers specific for H-2D^d. We were unable to detect any evidence for Ia-restricted recognition of the H-2D alloantigens, suggesting that, as for cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), helper cell recognition of class I alloantigens is an unrestricted event.     

Clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells at the early stage of T cell development in thymus of radiation bone marrow chimeras

Sequential appearance of T cell subpopulations occurs in the thymocytes of irradiated C3H/He mice (H-2k, Mls-1b2a, Thy-1.2) after transplantation with bone marrow cells of AKR/J mice (H-2k, Mls-1a2b, Thy-1.1) (AKR----C3H chimeras). The donor-derived thymocytes of AKR----C3H chimeras on day 14 after bone marrow transplantation (BMT) contained a large number of blastlike CD4+CD8+ cells which represent relatively immature thymocytes, whereas those on day 21 after BMT consisted of small sized CD4+,CD8+ cells which represent a great part in normal thymocytes. To define the developmental stage at which clonal deletion of self-reactive T cells occurs in adult thymus, we followed the fate of V beta 6- or V beta 11-bearing T cells in the donor-derived thymocytes at the early stage of AKR----C3H chimeras. Mature thymocytes expressing high intensity of V beta 6 or V beta 11, which are involved in recognition of Mls-1a or MHC I-E gene products, respectively, were deleted from the donor-derived thymocytes on day 21. Immature thymocytes expressing low intensity of V beta 6 in CD3low thymocyte fraction decreased in proportion, whereas those expressing low intensity of V beta 11 rather increased in proportion in the donor-derived thymocytes of AKR----C3H chimeras from day 14 to day 21 after BMT. These results suggest that the clonal deletion of V beta 6-positive cells occurs just at the stage of immature CD3lowCD4+CD8+ cells, whereas the clonal deletion of V beta 11-positive cells may begin at the transitional stage from CD3lowCD4+CD8+ cells to CD3high single positive cells. Timing of negative selection of thymocytes may vary in distinct T cells capable of recognizing different self-Ag.     

Frequency of allogeneic helper T cells responding to whole H-2 differences and to an H-2K difference alone.

Limiting dilution analysis was used to determine the frequency of splenic T cells that are stimulated by alloantigen to give help in a primary antibody response to SRBC. Several haplotype combinations were tested. A semilogarithmic plot of the fraction of nonresponding culture as a function of the number of T cells added to excess B cells gave a straight line intercepting with the origin. Thus a single cell-type was limiting, which was required to help B cells respond to SRBC. The frequency of syngeneic precursors of T helper cells specific for SRBC ranged from 1/10,000 to 1/55,000 with a mean of about 1/20,000. Allohelpers generated by whole H-2 differences gave precursor frequencies that ranged from 1/1000 to 1/7000 with a mean of about 1/2500. Thus allohelpers to whole H-2 differences were approximately 8-fold more frequent than SRBC-specific helpers. When the stimulation was limited to the H-2K difference between the mutant B6.C-H-2ba and wild-type B6, frequencies of from 1/2600 to 1/7900 allohelpers were found with a mean of about 1/5000, approximately half the frequency of allohelpers to whole H-2 differences. Thus some, but probably not all, of the magnitude of allogeneic halp can be attributed to the high frequency of helper T cells that respond to a given alloantigen.     

Specificity of H-2-linked Ir gene control in mice: demonstration of T helper cells recognizing branched synthetic polypeptides in low responder mice

This report provides evidence for the presence of T helper cells capable of recognizing the polypeptide antigens T6-A--L and (H,G)-A--L in low responder mice of H-2k and H-2b haplotypes, respectively. Mice were primed in vivo with the T6-A--L-avidin-(H,G)-A--L complex or, in the case of T6-A--L in H-2k mice, with the cross-reactive and permissive antigen T6-S--L. T helper cells cooperating with DNP-primed B cells could be rechallenged in vitro with the DNP-conjugates of T6--A--L or (H,G)-A--L, although the cells were of low responder type with respect to these antigens. This implies that T cell-macrophage interaction required for restimulation is apparently not defective in these low responders. The implications of these results for the concept of Ir gene control are discussed.     

Host-determined T cell fine specificity for self-H-2 in radiation bone-marrow chimeras of standard C57BL/6 (H-2b) mutantHz1 (H-2ba), and F1 mice

Reciprocal radiation bone-marrow chimeras were produced between the standard C57BL/6 (=B6) and the mutant B6.C-H-2 ^ba (=Hz1) strain. When infected with vaccinia virus, these chimeras, as well as an (Hz1 × B6)= Hz1 chimera, produced cytotoxic cells that killed vaccinia-infected H-2K^kH-2D^b target cells but failed to kill virus-infected H-2K^bH-2D^d cells. Virus-infected (Hz1 × B6)F₁ B6 chimeras, however, killed both types of target. These experiments demonstrate strict T-cell specificity capable of differentiating between two molecules that apparently differ by a single amino acid substitution.     

A role for T helper 2 cells in mediating skin fibrosis in tight-skin mice.

Mice heterozygous for the tight-skin (Tsk) mutation develop skin fibrosis. Previous studies have implicated a role for the immune system and, specifically, CD4(+) T cells, in the etiology of skin fibrosis in Tsk/+ mice. We have recently shown that the administration of neutralizing anti-IL-4 antibodies to Tsk/+ mice prevented the development of skin fibrosis in these mice. Since IL-4 is a major cytokine produced by T helper 2 (Th2) cells, we investigated the role of Th2 cells in mediating skin fibrosis in Tsk/+ mice. Previous studies have shown that the development of Th2 cells in non-Tsk mice is abrogated in mice with null mutation for either the IL-4 or the Stat6 gene. In this study we showed that the polarization of CD4(+) T cells from Tsk/+ mice toward the Th2 lineage is also dependent on a functioning IL-4 or Stat6 gene. More importantly, the development of skin fibrosis in Tsk/+ mice was abrogated by the IL4(-/-) or the Stat6(-/-) mutation. We also determined whether alteration of the TCR repertoire in Tsk/+ mice, achieved by the introduction of TCR transgenes, was able to prevent the development of skin fibrosis in Tsk/+ mice. We found that the exclusive usage of the Vbeta8.2 gene segment by T cells was sufficient to prevent skin fibrosis in Tsk/+ mice. This result suggests that the exclusive use of this Vbeta gene segment by T cells may have prevented the development of fibrosis-causing Th2 cells.