Lack of adaptive response of gamma radiation for protection against neutron-induced teratogenesis

BACKGROUND: Although there are some reports on neutron teratology, there is little information on the adaptive response of gamma radiation for protection against neutron‐induced teratogenesis. This study examined whether or not a low dose of gamma radiation can induce an adaptive response in mouse fetuses exposed to a subsequent dose of neutrons in vivo. METHODS: Pregnant ICR mice were exposed to a priming dose of 0.3 Gy (0.9 Gy/min) of gamma rays on day 10.5 of gestation and challenged with 0.8 Gy (0.94 Gy/minute) of neutrons 24 hlater. The mice were sacrificed on day 18.5 of gestation. The fetuses were examined for mortality, growth retardation, and other morphologic abnormalities. RESULTS: The tail length in the 0.3 Gy of gamma rays + 0.8 Gy of neutrons group was significantly shorter than in the 0.8 Gy of neutrons group. Although there was no significant difference compared with the 0.8 Gy of neutrons group, the number of live fetuses in the 0.3 Gy of gamma rays +0.8 Gy of neutrons group was lower. There was no evidence of primed exposure‐related reductions in the malformed fetuses. Although there was no significant difference compared with the unprimed group, the number of malformed offspring in the primed group was higher. Furthermore, the incidence of kinked tail and adactyly was significantly higher in the primed mice than in the unprimed mice. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, this study shows that exposure to 0.3 Gy of gamma rays failed to induce an adaptive response of fetogenesis to a neutron challenge dose. Birth Defects Res (Part B) 83:502‐506, 2008. © 2008 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Bystander effects, adaptive response and genomic instability induced by prenatal irradiation

The developing human embryo and fetus undergo very radiosensitive stages during the prenatal development. It is likely that the induction of low dose related effects such as bystander effects, the adaptive response, and genomic instability would have profound effects on embryonic and fetal development. In this paper, I review what has been reported on the induction of these three phenomena in exposed embryos and fetuses. All three phenomena have been shown to occur in murine embryonic or fetal cells and structures, although the induction of an adaptive response (and also likely the induction of bystander effects) are limited in terms of when during development they can be induced and the dose or dose-rate used to treat animals in utero. In contrast, genomic instability can be induced throughout development, and the effects of radiation exposure on genome instability can be observed for long times after irradiation including through pre- and postnatal development and into the next generation of mice. There are clearly strain-specific differences in the induction of these phenomena and all three can lead to long-term detrimental effects. This is true for the adaptive response as well. While induction of an adaptive response can make fetuses more resistant to some gross developmental defects induced by a subsequent high dose challenge with ionizing radiation, the long-term effects of this low dose exposure are detrimental. The negative effects of all three phenomena reflect the complexity of fetal development, a process where even small changes in the timing of gene expression or suppression can have dramatic effects on the pattern of biological events and the subsequent development of the mammalian organism.     

Adaptive response in embryogenesis: IV. Protective and detrimental bystander effects induced by X radiation in cultured limb bud cells of fetal mice

The radioadaptive response and the bystander effect represent important phenomena in radiobiology that have an impact on novel biological response mechanisms and risk estimates. Micromass cultures of limb bud cells provide an in vitro cellular maturation system in which the progression of cell proliferation and differentiation parallels that in vivo. This paper presents for the first time evidence for the correlation and interaction in a micromass culture system between the radioadaptive response and the bystander effect. A radioadaptive response was induced in limb bud cells of embryonic day 11 ICR mice. Conditioning irradiation of the embryonic day 11 cells with 0.3 Gy resulted in a significant protective effect against the occurrence of apoptosis, inhibition of cell proliferation, and differentiation induced by a challenging dose of 5 Gy given the next day. Both protective and detrimental bystander effects were observed; namely, irradiating 50% of the embryonic day 11 cells with 0.3 Gy led to a successful induction of the protective effect, and irradiating 70% of the embryonic day 12 cells with 5 Gy produced a detrimental effect comparable to that seen when all the cells were irradiated. Further, the bystander effect was markedly decreased by pretreatment of the cells with an inhibitor to block the gap junction-mediated intercellular communication. These results indicate that the bystander effect plays an important role in both the induction of a protective effect by the conditioning dose and the detrimental effect of the challenge irradiation. Gap junction-mediated intercellular communication was suggested to be involved in the induction of the bystander effect.     

Radioadaptive response revisited

Radiation-induced adaptive response belongs to the group of non-targeted effects that do not require direct exposure of the cell nucleus by radiation. It is described as the reduced damaging effect of a challenging radiation dose when induced by a previous low priming dose. Adaptive responses have been observed in vitro and in vivo using various indicators of cellular damage, such as cell lethality, chromosomal aberrations, mutation induction, radiosensitivity, and DNA repair. Adaptive response can be divided into three successive biological phenomena, the intracellular response, the extracellular signal, and the maintenance. The intracellular response leading to adaptation of a single cell is a complex biological process including induction or suppression of gene groups. An extracellular signal, the nature of which is unknown, may be sent by the affected cell to neighbouring cells causing them to adapt as well. This occurs either by a release of diffusible signalling molecules or by gap-junction intercellular communication. Adaptive response can be maintained for periods ranging from of a few hours to several months. Constantly increased levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) or nitric oxide (NO) have been observed in adapted cells and both factors may play a role in the maintenance process. Although adaptive response seems to function by an on/off principle, it is a phenomenon showing a high degree of inter- and intraindividual variability. It remains to be seen to what extent adaptive response is functional in humans at relevant dose and dose-rate exposures. A better understanding of adaptive response and other non-targeted effects is needed before they can be confirmed as risk estimate factors for the human population at low levels of ionising radiation.     

Adaptive response in embryogenesis: II. Retardation of postnatal development of prenatally irradiated mice.

We previously reported that a priming dose of 0.3 Gy on gestation day 11 significantly increased the rate of living fetuses and reduced the incidence of congenital malformations caused by exposure to 5 Gy X rays on gestation day 12 in ICR mice. In the present study, postnatal development of the live offspring was investigated using a set of developmental and behavioral parameters. The offspring of the mice irradiated with 0.3 Gy generally showed a delay in the appearance of most of the physiological markers, impaired acquisition of neonatal reflexes, and alteration of adult behavior. However, an increase in body weight in the females was observed 4 weeks postnatally. In the offspring primed with 0.3 Gy followed by a challenging dose of 5 Gy prenatally, a high postnatal mortality was found, and all the survivors had various radiation-induced detrimental effects. The results indicated that the priming dose was advantageous to survival itself, but was disadvantageous to the health of survivor. The results also suggested that studying the whole animal can show the extent of the effects of radiation, i.e. quality of life, in a way that cellular or molecular studies cannot.     

Adaptive response in embryogenesis. III. Relationship to radiation-induced apoptosis and Trp53 gene status

We reported previously that a radiation-induced adaptive response existed in the late period of embryogenesis, and that radiation-induced apoptosis in the predigital regions was responsible for digital defects in embryonic ICR mice. To investigate the possible involvement of the Trp53 gene and radiation-induced apoptosis in radiation-induced adaptive responses in embryogenesis, the present study was conducted using Trp53 wild-type (Trp53(+/+)) and Trp53 heterozygous (Trp53(+/-)) embryonic mice of the C57BL/6 strain. The existence of a radioadaptive response in the Trp53(+/+) embryonic mice was demonstrated by irradiating the embryos with 5 or 30 cGy on embryonic day 11 prior to a challenging irradiation at 3 Gy on embryonic day 12. The two conditioning doses at 5 and 30 cGy significantly suppressed the induction of apoptosis by the challenging dose in the predigital regions of limb buds in the Trp53(+/+) embryonic mice, while no such effect was found in the Trp53(+/-) embryonic mice. These findings indicate that induction of a radioadaptive response in embryogenesis is related to Trp53 gene status and the occurrence of radiation-induced apoptosis.     

Induction of adaptive response by low-dose radiation in RIF cells transfected with Hspb1 (Hsp25) or inducible Hspa (Hsp70)

An adaptive response results in a reduced effect of a high challenging dose of a stressor after a smaller, inducing dose has been applied a few hours earlier. Radiation-induced fibrosarcoma (RIF) cells did not show an adaptive response, i.e. a reduced effect from a high challenging dose (2 Gy) of a radiation after a priming dose (1 cGy) had been applied 4 or 7 h earlier, but cells of a thermoresistant clone (TR) derived from RIF cells did. Since the expression of inducible Hspa (also known as Hsp70) and Hspb1 (also known as Hsp25) was different in these two cell lines, the role of inducible Hspa and Hspb1 in the adaptive response was examined. When RIF cells were transfected with inducible Hspa or Hspb1, both radioresistance measured by clonogenic assays and a reduction of apoptosis were detected. The adaptive response was also acquired by these two cell lines. The inducible Hspa transfectant showed a more pronounced adaptive response than the Hspb1 transfectant. Based on these results, it appears that inducible Hspa and Hspb1 are at least partly responsible for the induction of the adaptive response in these cells. Moreover, when inducible Hspa or Hspb1 was transfected into RIF cells, co-regulation of the two genes was detected. Heat-shock factor (Hsf) was found to be at least partially responsible for the induction of the adaptive response in these cells.     

Suppression of thymic lymphoma induction by life-long low-dose-rate irradiation accompanied by immune activation in C57BL/6 mice

The induction of thymic lymphomas by whole-body X irradiation with four doses of 1.8 Gy (total dose: 7.2 Gy) in C57BL/6 mice was suppressed from a high frequency (90%) to 63% by preirradiation with 0.075 Gy X rays given 6 h before each 1.8-Gy irradiation. This level was further suppressed to 43% by continuous whole-body irradiation with 137Cs gamma rays at a low dose rate of 1.2 mGy/h for 450 days, starting 35 days before the challenging irradiation. Continuous irradiation at 1.2 mGy/h resulting in a total dose of 7.2 Gy over 258 days yielded no thymic lymphomas, indicating that this low-dose-rate radiation does not induce these tumors. Further continuous irradiation up to 450 days (total dose: 12.6 Gy) produced no tumors. Continuously irradiated mice showed no loss of hair and a greater body weight than unirradiated controls. Immune activities of the mice, as measured by the numbers of CD4+ T cells, CD40+ B cells, and antibody-producing cells in the spleen after immunization with sheep red blood cells, were significantly increased by continuous 1.2-mGy/h irradiation alone. These results indicate the presence of an adaptive response in tumor induction, the involvement of radiation-induced immune activation in tumor suppression, and a large dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor (DDREF) for tumor induction with extremely low-dose-rate radiation.     

Environmental radiation as the conditioning factor for the survival of yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Whether natural radiation can be a conditioning factor for the growth and survival of a living organism was investigated using diploid yeast S. cerevisiae D7. Yeast cells were conditioned by growing them continuously for at least 100 generation in 3 different radiation background such as i) ambient radiation (1.1 mSv/y), ii) sub-ambient radiation (0.44 mSv/y, within a shielded chamber) and iii) an elevated background radiation (88 and 880 mSv/y in a gamma-field). At the end, the cells were challenged with 60Co gamma, 100 Gy and the viable fractions were determined. Conditioning the cells in 880 mSv/y and in ambient radiation, enabled the cells to reduce the deleterious effect of the challenging dose significantly (P < 0.05) compared to that of sub-ambient radiation. The cellular viability of yeast cultures seems to be influenced by the prevailing radiation background, apart from starvation. Comparatively, a rapid decline in viability was noticed when the cultures were incubated for 60 days in the shielded chamber. The results indicate that some amount of radiation equivalent to background level or little above is needed to confer fitness in biological systems against stress factors, including radiation. The adaptive dose for the diploid yeast was also determined by single exposure. The priming dose ranged from 0.01 to 1.2 Gy. An adaptive dose of 0.25 or 0.4 Gy, almost nullified the deleterious effect of the challenging dose. The adaptive response may have a greater role in the field of cancer therapy and in radiation risk assessment. Understanding the response of an organism at different radiation-background will be helpful for successful space management.     

Effect of low-dose irradiation on induction of an apoptotic adaptive response in the murine system

The aim of the study was to investigate the effect of low doses of irradiation on the induction of an apoptotic adaptive response in the murine system using C3H/HeJ mice bearing 8 mm syngeneic tumors, HCa-I and OCa-I. In OCa-I, the 0.05 Gy priming dose significantly reduced the 25 Gy-induced apoptosis by 30%, whereas this reduction was not seen in HCa-I. The analysis of apoptosis-regulating molecules showed that the application of a priming dose increased the radiation- induced p53 level in both tumors. No other regulators changed in OCa-I. However, in HCa-I, the application of a priming dose increased radiation-induced Bcl-XL and Bcl-XS, but not Bcl-2 or Bax. An apoptotic adaptive response induced by low-dose radiation was shown in one murine tumor, OCa-I and Bcl-XL and Bcl-XS appeared to be implicated. Received: 4 April 2001 / Accepted: 20 September 2001     

Critical target and dose and dose-rate responses for the induction of chromosomal instability by ionizing radiation.

To investigate the critical target, dose response and dose-rate response for the induction of chromosomal instability by ionizing radiation, bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)-substituted and unsubstituted GM10115 cells were exposed to a range of doses (0.1-10 Gy) and different dose rates (0.092-17.45 Gy min(-1)). The status of chromosomal stability was determined by fluorescence in situ hybridization approximately 20 generations after irradiation in clonal populations derived from single progenitor cells surviving acute exposure. Overall, nearly 700 individual clones representing over 140,000 metaphases were analyzed. In cells unsubstituted with BrdU, a dose response was found, where the probability of observing delayed chromosomal instability in any given clone was 3% per gray of X rays. For cells substituted with 25-66% BrdU, however, a dose response was observed only at low doses (<1.0 Gy); at higher doses (>1.0 Gy), the incidence of chromosomal instability leveled off. There was an increase in the frequency and complexity of chromosomal instability per unit dose compared to cells unsubstituted with BrdU. The frequency of chromosomal instability appeared to saturate around approximately 30%, an effect which occurred at much lower doses in the presence of BrdU. Changing the gamma-ray dose rate by a factor of 190 (0.092 to 17.45 Gy min(-1)) produced no significant differences in the frequency of chromosomal instability. The enhancement of chromosomal instability promoted by the presence of the BrdU argues that DNA comprises at least one of the critical targets important for the induction of this end point of genomic instability.     

Radioadaptive response for protection against radiation-induced teratogenesis

To clarify the characteristics of the radioadaptive response in mice, we compared the incidence of radiation-induced malformations in ICR mice. Pregnant ICR mice were exposed to a priming dose of 2 cGy (667 muGy/min) on day 9.5 of gestation and to a challenging dose of 2 Gy (1.04 Gy/min) 4 h later and were killed on day 18.5 of gestation. The incidence of malformations and prenatal death and fetal body weights were studied. The incidence of external malformations was significantly lower (by approximately 10%) in the primed (2 cGy + 2 Gy) mice compared to the unprimed (2 Gy alone) mice. However, there were no differences in the incidence of prenatal death or the skeletal malformations or the body weights between primed and unprimed mice. These results suggest that primary conditioning with low doses of radiation suppresses radiation-induced teratogenesis.     

Dose-rate effect on the induction of HPRT mutants in human G0 lymphocytes exposed in vitro to gamma radiation

The influence of dose rate on expression time, cell survival and mutant frequency at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) locus was evaluated in human G(0) peripheral blood lymphocytes exposed in vitro to gamma rays at low (0.0014 Gy/min) and high (0.85 Gy/min) dose rates. A cloning assay performed on different days of postirradiation incubation indicated an 8-day maximum expression period for the induction of HPRT mutants at both high and low dose rates. Cell survival increased markedly with decreasing dose rate, yielding D(0) values of 3.04 Gy and 1.3 Gy at low and high dose rates, respectively. The D(0) of 3.04 Gy obtained at low dose rate could be attributed to the repair of sublethal DNA damage taking place during prolonged exposure to low-LET radiation. Regression analysis of the mutant frequency yielded slopes of 12.35 x 10(-6) and 3.66 x 10(-6) mutants per gray at high and low dose rate, respectively. A dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor of 3.4 indicated a marked dose-rate effect on the induced HPRT mutant frequency. The results indicate that information obtained from in vitro measurements of dose-rate effects in human G(0) lymphocytes may be a useful parameter for risk estimation in radiation protection.     

Low doses of radiation decrease the level of spontaneous and gamma-induced chromosomal mutagenesis in bone marrow cells of mice in vivo

Low doses of ionizing radiation are known to induce adaptive response (AR), which is characterized in most cases by temporary nature, though the possibility of long-term persistence of AR is not ruled out. In this investigation we studied the effect of low doses of gamma-radiation on both high-dose radiation-induced and spontaneous level of cytogenetic damage throughout the life of mice. SHK male mice 2 months old were used. Priming doses of 0.1 and 0.2 Gy (0.125 Gy/min, gamma-radiation from 60Co) were used. A challenging dose of 1.5 Gy (1 Gy/min) was used in the experiments using a routine AR experimental design. The frequency of micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes in bone marrow cells of primed, primed and challenged, and control groups was assessed at various times of animal life span. It was shown that: a) single low-dose gamma-irradiation induces a cytogenetic AR which can be revealed at 1, 3, 6, 9, 12 months after priming; b) single low-dose gamma-irradiation decreases the cytogenetic damage to a level below the spontaneous rate at the end of lifetime (20 months) of animals; c) ability to induce adaptive response does not depend on the age of animals at the moment of priming irradiation. In conclusion, the mechanisms underlying AR not only protect from chromosome damage induced by high-dose irradiation but also may play a role in spontaneous mutagenesis during aging of animals.     

Low doses of very low-dose-rate low-LET radiation suppress radiation-induced neoplastic transformation in vitro and induce an adaptive response

The purpose of this study was to determine whether adaptation against neoplastic transformation could be induced by exposure to very low-dose-rate low-LET radiation. HeLa x skin fibroblast human hybrid cells were irradiated with approximately 30 kVp photons from an array of (125)I seeds. The initial dose rate was 4 mGy/day. Cell samples were taken at four intervals at various times over a period of 88 days and assayed for neoplastic transformation and the presence of reactive oxygen species (ROS). The dose rate at the end of this treatment period was 1.4 mGy/day. Transformation frequencies and ROS levels were compared to those of parallel unirradiated controls. At the end of 3 months and an accumulated dose of 216 mGy, cells treated with very low-dose-rate radiation were exposed to a high-dose-rate 3-Gy challenge dose of (137)Cs gamma rays, and the effects compared with the effect of 3 Gy on a parallel culture of previously unirradiated cells. Cells exposed to very low-dose-rate radiation exhibited a trend toward a reduction in neoplastic transformation frequency compared to the unirradiated controls. This reduction seemed to diminish with time, indicating that the dose rate, rather than accumulated dose, may be the more important factor in eliciting an adaptive response. This pattern was in general paralleled by a reduction of ROS present in the irradiated cultures compared to controls. The very low-dose-rate-treated cells were less sensitive to the high challenge dose than unirradiated controls, suggesting the induction of an adaptive response. Since there was a suggestion of a dose-rate threshold for induction suppression, a second experiment was run with a fresh batch of cells at an initial dose rate of 1 mGy/day. These cells were allowed to accumulate 40 mGy over 46 days (average dose rate=0.87 mGy/day), and there was no evidence for suppression of transformation frequency compared to parallel unirradiated controls. It is concluded that doses of less than 100 mGy delivered at very low dose rates in the range 1 to 4 mGy/day can induce an adaptive response against neoplastic transformation in vitro. When the dose rate drops below approximately 1 mGy/day, this suppression is apparently lost, suggesting a possible dose-rate-dependent threshold for this process.     

Acceleration of DNA-double strand rejoining during the adaptive response of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Newly developed constant-field low voltage electrophoresis (adapted for algae cells by us) was applied to quantify the induction and repair of nuclear DNA double-strand breaks, by measuring the movement of DNA out of the starting wells into the electrophoresis gel using a UV-gel scan and computer analysis of DNA-ethidium bromide fluorescense (Syngene; Gene tools). A cell-wall-less mutant strain of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CW15) was used; the DNA and proteins are easily accessible because of the lack of an outer cell wall. Our results showed that giving a small priming dose (50 Gy) led to a small acceleration of dsb rejoining. When the magnitude of the priming dose was progressively increased, there was a corresponding decrease in the fraction of damage remaining at 4 hours after radiation exposure (to a test dose of 500 Gy). This indicates an upregulated rejoining of dsb following exposure of cells to the priming dose, which may be related to the strong adaptive response in this organism. Protein synthesis inhibitors were found to reduce the rate of rejoining of dsb, and from earlier results are known to inhibit the adaptive response. Thus, the adaptive response is likely to be dependent on increased dsb rejoining and depends on de novo protein synthesis. The nature of these proteins has not yet been established. C. reinhardtii CW15 is an attractive model system in which to study the underlying mechanisms of the adaptive response to ionizing radiation, and its underlying link with dsb rejoining. The results are interesting both from a basic biological point of view, and as a means to further understand the response of tumour cells to radiation therapy since the adaptive response has been postulated to determine the shape of the "shoulder" region of the survival curve of cells at low doses of radiation.     

Cell cycle alteration, apoptosis and response of leukemic cell lines to gamma radiation with high- and low-dose rate

The aim of this work was to compare the effect of gamma radiation with sub-low dose-rate 1.8 mGy/min (SLDR), low dose-rate 3.9 mGy/min (LDR) and high dose-rate 0.6 Gy/min (HDR) on human leukemic cell lines with differing p53 status (HL-60, p53 deficient and MOLT-4, p53 wild) and to elucidate the importance of G2/M phase cell cycle arrest during irradiation. Radiosensitivity of HL-60 and MOLT-4 cells was determined by test of clonogenity. Decrease of dose-rate had no effect on radiosensitivity of MOLT-4 cells (D(0) for HDR 0.87 Gy, for LDR 0.78 Gy and for SLDR 0.70 Gy). In contrast, a significant increase of radioresistance after LDR irradiation was observed for p53 negative HL-60 cells (D(0) for HDR 2.20 Gy and for LDR 3.74 Gy). After an additional decrease of dose-rate (SLDR) D(0) value (2.92 Gy) was not significantly different from HDR irradiation. Considering the fact that during HDR the cells are irradiated in all phases of the cell cycle and during LDR mainly in the G2 phase, we have been unable to prove that the G2 phase is the most radiosensitive phase of the cell cycle of HL-60 cells. On the contrary, irradiation of cells in this phase induced damage reparation and increased radioresistance. When the dose-rate was lowered, approximately to 1.8 mGy/min, an opposite effect was detected, i.e. D(0) value decreased to 2.9 Gy. We have proved that during SLDR at first (dose up to 2.5 Gy) the cells accumulated in G2 phase, but then they entered mitosis or, if the cell damage was not sufficiently repaired, the cells entered apoptosis. The entry into mitosis has a radiosensibilizing effect.     

Ionizing radiation alters neuronal excitability in hippocampal slices of the guinea pig

To investigate the effects of ionizing radiation on an isolated neuronal network without complicating systemic factors, slices of hippocampus from the guinea pig were isolated and studied in vitro. Slices were irradiated with a 60Co source and compared to paired, sham-irradiated controls. Electrophysiological activity in the CA 1 population of pyramidal cells was evoked by stimulation of the stratum radiatum. Analysis of the somatic and dendritic responses suggested sites of radiation damage. Orthodromically evoked activity was significantly decreased in slices receiving greater than 75 Gy gamma radiation. The effects were dose and dose-rate dependent. At 20 Gy/min, doses of 50 Gy and greater produced synaptic impairment while doses of 75 Gy and greater also produced postsynaptic damage (i.e., the ability of the synaptic response to generate an action potential). A lower dose rate, 5 Gy/min, reduced the sensitivity of synaptic damage to radiation exposure; synaptic impairment required a dose of 100 Gy or greater at the lower dose rate. In contrast, postsynaptic damage was not sensitive to dose rate. This study demonstrates that ionizing radiation can directly affect the integrated functional activity of neurons.     

Dose-rate evidence for two kinds of radiation damage in stationary-phase mammalian cells

Survival based on colony formation was measured for starved plateau-phase Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells exposed to 250 kVp X rays at dose rates of 0.0031, 0.025, 0.18, 0.31, and 1.00 Gy/min. A large dose-rate effect was demonstrated. Delayed plating experiments and dose response experiments following a conditioning dose, both using a dose rate of 1.00 Gy/min and plating delays of up to 48 hr, were also used to investigate the alternative repair hypotheses. There is clearly a greater change in survival in dose-rate experiments than in the other experiments. Thus we believe that a process which depends on the square of the concentration of initial damage, and which alters the effect of initial damage on cell survival is being observed. We have applied the damage accumulation model to separate the single-event damage from this concentration-dependent form and estimate the repair rate for the latter type to be 70 min for our CHO cells. Use of this analysis on other published dose-rate studies also yields results consistent with this interpretation of the repair mechanisms.