Accurate root length and diameter measurement using NIH Image: use of Pythagorean distance for diameter estimation

This report describes an image analysis algorithm to estimate the length versus diameter of washed root samples accurately. Image analysis was performed using a Macintosh computer and the public domain NIH Image program. The binary image of the roots was processed to get the thinned image to calculate the length of the roots. The pixels of the root in a binary image were then stripped off from around the periphery based on the pixel's Pythagorean distance from the nearest background pixel. The length of the remaining root in each stripping off process was calculated after the image was thinned. Images (300 dpi) of copper wire of 0.23, 0.5, 1.0 mm diameter were analyzed for verification of the usefulness of the procedure. The results showed that more than 93% of the wires in each diameter wire were calculated to be in diameter classes including the true diameter and its adjoining classes: 93.6% of the wires of 0.23 mm diameter appeared in the 0.098–0.38 mm diameter classes, 96.19% of the wires of 0.5 mm diameter appeared in the 0.38–0.61 mm diameter classes, and 96.17% of the wires of 1 mm diameter appeared in the 0.85–1.08 mm diameter classes. The proposed method was tested for primary and secondary roots of water-cultured rice (Oryza sativa L.) and it was proven that the method could provide accurate length and diameter measurements for each root order. In addition, it was found that the method could provide the lengths of the thick primary, thin primary, and secondary roots. The effectiveness of applying sharpening for the grayscale image before making the binary image is also discussed.     

Analysis of root images from auger sampling with a fast procedure: a case of application to sugar beet

Manual line-intersect methods for estimating root length are being progressively replaced by faster and more accurate image analysis procedures. These methods even allow the estimation of some more root parameters (e.g., diameter), but still require preliminary labour-intensive operations. Through a task-specific macro function written in a general-purpose image analysis programme (KS 300 – Zeiss), the processing time of root images was greatly reduced with respect to skeletonisation methods by using a high-precision algorithm (Fibrelength). This has been previously proposed by other authors, and estimates length as a function of perimeter and area of the digital image of roots. One-bit binary images were acquired, aiming at large savings in computer memory, and automatic discrimination of roots against extraneous objects based on their elongation index (perimeter²/area), was performed successfully. Of four tested spatial resolutions (2.9, 5.9, 8.8, 11.8 pixel mm^–1), in clean samples good accuracy in root length estimation was achieved at 11.8 pixel mm^–1, up to a root density of 5 cm cm^–2 on the scanner bed. This resolution is theoretically suitable for representing roots at least 85 m wide. When dealing with uncleaned samples, a thick layer of water was useful in speeding up spreading of roots on the scanner bed and avoiding underestimation of their length due to overlaps with organic debris. A set of fibrous root samples of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris var. saccharifera L.) collected at harvest over two years at Legnaro (NE Italy) was analysed by applying the above procedure. Fertilisation with 100 kg ha^–1 of nitrogen led to higher RLD (root length density in soil) in shallow layers with respect to unfertilised controls, whereas thicker roots were found deeper than 80 cm of soil without nitrogen.     

施肥对日本落叶松人工林细根直径、根长和比根长的影响

以辽宁东部山区16年生日本落叶松人工林为研究对象,探讨施肥对日本落叶松1～5级根序中细根直径、根长和比根长的影响.结果表明：随着根序等级的增加,日本落叶松细根平均直径和根长显著增加（P<0。05,P<0。01）、比根长则显著下降（P<0。01）.在日本落叶松的5级根序中,1级根的平均直径最细、根长最短、比根长最高,而5级根则相反;随着根序等级的增加,日本落叶松细根平均直径、根长和比根长的变异系数逐渐增大.除1级根外,土层对细根的平均直径、根长和比根长没有显著影响(P>0。05).与对照样地相比,施肥对各级细根平均直径、根长和比根长的影响主要表现在1～2级根上,对3级根序以上的细根影响不显著（P>0.05）.其中,施氮肥显著降低了1～2级根的平均直径（P<0.05）,施氮肥以及氮磷肥显著降低了表层土壤（0～10 cm）中1级根的平均根长（P<0.05）,表层土壤中细根的比根长在施氮肥的条件下显著增加（P<0.05）.     

Automated image analyses for separating plant roots from soil debris elutrated from soil cores

Historically, destructive root sampling has been labor intensive and requires manual separation of extraneous organic debris recovered along with the hydropneumatic elutriation method of separating plant roots from soils. Quantification of root system demographics by public domain National Institute of Health (NIH-Image) and Root Image Processing Laboratory (RIPL) image processing algorithms has eliminated much of the labor-intensive manual separation. This was accomplished by determining the best length to diameter ratio for each object during image analyses. Objects with a length to diameter ratio less than a given threshold are considered non-root materials and are rejected automatically by computer algorithms. Iterative analyses of length to diameter ratios showed that a 15:1 ratio was best for separating images of maize (Zea mays L.) roots from associated organic debris. Using this threshold ratio for a set of 24 soil cores, a highly significant correlation (r² = 0.89) was obtained between computer image processed total root length per core and actual root length. A linear relationship (r² = 0.80) was observed between root lengths determined by NIH-Image analyses and lengths determined independently by the RIPL imaging system, using the same maize root + debris samples. This correlation demonstrates that computer image processing provides opportunities for comparing root length parameters between different laboratories for samples containing debris.     

Accurate root length measurement by image analysis

Algorithms for estimating root length by image analysis should lead to results that have no systematic error (bias), be insensitive to preferential root orientation, valid across a wide range of sample sizes and adjust for overlap between roots in samples, to reduce the effort needed in spreading out root systems. We propose a new algorithm that forms a compromise between small bias and robustness (insensitivity to variation in sample size and preferential root orientation), and provide a simple way of dealing with root overlap. Image analysis was performed on a Macintosh computer using the public domain NIH Image program. The digital image of the root was processed to get the thinned image (skeleton). The numbers of orthogonally and diagonally connected pairs of pixels (N _o and N _d, respectively) in the skeleton were counted separately and used for length (L) calculation. A new length calculation equation was introduced so that the effect of orientation on length calculation was minimized; L=[N d ²+(N _d+N _o/2)²]^1/2+N _o/2. The maximum error due to orientation of a single line was evaluated for an ideal line, and the analysis revealed that the new equation was less affected by orientation than previous equations. Copper wire and rice (Oryza sativa L.) roots containing both primary and fine secondary root were measured manually and with image analysis. The two methods showed good agreement within 1.5%. The proposed image analysis method yielded length estimates with CV from 0.23 to 0.88%, which was lower than the CVs of the line-intersect method. Moreover, the lengths of overlapping samples were calculated correctly because the image analysis method distinguished an overlapping pixel from a thinned image, while the calculation with the line-intersect method showed underestimation because overlaps were not considered in that method. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

土壤增温与氮添加对杉木幼苗细根径级根长分布的影响

通过在福建省三明市陈大林业国有林场内开展土壤增温(增温5 ℃、不增温)和氮添加(不添加、4、8 g N·m^-2·a^-1)的交互试验(共6个处理),研究土壤增温、氮添加及二者交互作用对杉木细根径级根长分布的影响,用扩展模型可很好地拟合6个处理的径级根长分布(R²=0.97).结果表明: 增温使杉木细根总根长变小,但对细根直径影响不显著;氮添加使杉木细根总根长和直径均变小;增温和氮添加的交互作用对细根总根长有显著影响,但对细根直径无显著影响.6个处理细根径级根长分布均能用极值函数模型较好地拟合(R²>0.98).相关分析显示,直径<1 mm细根的比根长与极值模型拟合参数c值呈显著负相关,实际总根长与极值模型拟合参数b呈显著正相关.增温和氮添加及其交互作用可以影响杉木细根形态特征;极值模型拟合各处理径级根长分布所得参数在一定程度上可以反映细根形态特征对环境条件变化的响应.     

Relationships between root diameter,root length and root branching along lateral roots in adult,field-grown maize

Background and Aims Root diameter, especially apical diameter, plays an important role in root development and function. The variation in diameter between roots, and along roots, affects root structure and thus the root system’s overall foraging performance. However, the effect of diameter variation on root elongation, branching and topological connections has not been examined systematically in a population of high-order roots, nor along the roots, especially for mature plants grown in the field.Methods A method combining both excavation and analysis was applied to extract and quantify root architectural traits of adult, field-grown maize plants. The relationships between root diameter and other root architectural characteristics are analysed for two maize cultivars.Key Results The basal diameter of the lateral roots (orders 1–3) was highly variable. Basal diameter was partly determined by the diameter of the bearing segment. Basal diameter defined a potential root length, but the lengths of most roots fell far short of this. This was explained partly by differences in the pattern of diameter change along roots. Diameter tended to decrease along most roots, with the steepness of the gradient of decrease depending on basal diameter. The longest roots were those that maintained (or sometimes increased) their diameters during elongation. The branching density (cm^–1) of laterals was also determined by the diameter of the bearing segment. However, the location of this bearing segment along the mother root was also involved – intermediate positions were associated with higher densities of laterals.Conclusions The method used here allows us to obtain very detailed records of the geometry and topology of a complex root system. Basal diameter and the pattern of diameter change along a root were associated with its final length. These relationships are especially useful in simulations of root elongation and branching in source–sink models.     

Non-destructive measurement of wheat roots in large undisturbed and repacked clay soil cores

Summary Non-destructive observations of root growth and distribution can be obtained from counting root intercepts with observation tubers inserted in the root zone. This paper describes the technique of inserting clear acrylic tubes horizontally into large undisturbed and repacked soil cores. Counts of roots intersecting scribed lines on the sides of the tubes were made with a fibrescope. Comparison was made between observation root tubes of different diameter (25 and 38.5 mm).The r² values for the relationships between root intercept counts and destructively determined values of root length density (RLD) ranged from 0.78 to 0.96. The larger diameter tubes had higher r² values. Theoretical calibration of the technique does not appear to be possible since analysis indicated that fewer roots intersected the scribed lines on the observation tube than would have been expected from a non-disturbed, randomly distributed root system. It is not known if this discrepancy is due to non-randomness or to an artifact associated with the insertion of the observation tube. Roots were not more prolific at the edge of the soil cores. Comparison of values of root length per unit soil surface area, rates of downward root growth and water uptake rates were within the ranges previously reported for wheat roots of field crops grown on clay soils. Observed root growth and distribution was found to be sensitive to four soil and water treatments imposed. It is concluded that the technique will allow quantitative analysis of root growth and distribution in undisturbed soil cores.     

帽儿山天然次生林20个阔叶树种细根形态

 细根在森林生态系统C分配和养分循环过程中发挥着重要作用。细根形态不但影响养分和水分的吸收, 而且与细根寿命和周转有密切关系。因此, 研究森林树种的细根形态对了解根系结构与功能、预测寿命与周转具有重要理论意义。该文根据细根分枝等级划分方法, 研究了东北帽儿山天然次生林20个阔叶树种1～5级根直径、根长和比根长等形态指标。结果表明, 20个树种中, 除5个树种1级根直径略大于2级和比根长略小于2级根外, 其余15个树种均表现为1级根直径和根长最小、比根长最高, 随着根序增加, 直径和根长增加, 而比根长降低。20个阔叶树种前3级根的累积根长均占前5级根总根长的80%以上。9个内生菌根侵染的树种的平均直径、根长和比根长均大于11个外生菌根侵染的树种。     

不同分类系统下油松幼苗根系特征的差异与联系

植物根序和径级不仅反映细根的形态结构, 而且能反映根系的一些生理特征, 如细根寿命和周转等。该文以二年生油松(Pinus tabulaeformis)幼苗根系为研究对象, 系统比较了根序分类方法和径级分类方法在描述根系特征上的优缺点, 探索了两者之间的内在联系。结果表明: 二年生油松幼苗最多可包括6级根序, 直径的变化范围为0.169-3.877 mm。按根序划分, I-VI级根序的总根长和总根表面积主要集中在前3级根序, 这3级根序的根占总根长的78.77%和总根表面积的62.72%。前3级根序的比根长是后3级根序比根长的1.3-3.0倍, 比根面积是后3级比根面积的1.0-1.5倍。按常用的径级(以0.5、1.0、1.5和2.0 mm为阈值)划分方法, 油松幼苗大部分根系直径≤1.5 mm, 此区间细根的根长和根表面积占总根长的93.76%和总根表面积的84.35%。直径≤1.5 mm的细根平均比根长是>1.5 mm细根比根长的3-7倍, 比根面积的1.5-3.0倍。由于油松根序和径级之间有显著的指数关系, 依据径级最大程度反映根序的原则, 提出了新的径级划分方法, 即以0.4、0.8、1.3和2.0 mm为阈值对油松幼苗根系径级重新进行划分。此时, 上述区间可分别包括I级、II级、III级、IV级、V级根序中根尖数的93.22%、86.37%、75.96%、70.47%和76.67%。同时也可分别涵盖各径级根长的89.34%-70.83%、根面积的86.01%-76.12%以及体积的87.73%-76.12%。此时, 根系不同径级与根序之间可以建立起良好的对应关系。这些结果表明, 通过合理划分径级区间可以较好地反映根序 特征。     

Apical diameter and branching density affect lateral root elongation rates in banana

Thick roots elongate faster than thinner ones. However, within one species, the growth achieved by roots of a given diameter can be very variable, and root diameter can only be considered as a determinant of root potential elongation rate. As root elongation is highly correlated to carbon availability, it can be hypothesized that local competition for resources, expressed as the number of lateral roots per unit length (i.e. the branching density), modulates root elongation. Using novel methods in field conditions, we have estimated apical diameters, elongation rates and growth durations of nearly 3500 banana lateral roots, in a field experiment with high radiations and a shaded glasshouse experiment with low radiations. Apical diameters and branching densities were lower in the experiment with low radiation, but elongation rates were higher. In both experiments, mean elongation rates of first-order laterals and thick second-order laterals were negatively correlated with bearing root branching densities. It is hypothesized that, even though apical diameters were lower, low branching densities in the shaded glasshouse allowed enhanced lateral root elongation. In both experiments, second-order laterals elongated more slowly than first-order laterals of similar diameter. A specific effect of root order, independent of branching density and apical diameter, contributed to explain these slow second-order lateral elongation rates. Most lateral roots elongated between 9 and 21 days and growth duration was mainly correlated with root diameter.     

张广才岭西坡次生林不同生境胡桃楸幼树根系构型及细根特征

采用全根挖掘法对张广才岭西坡次生林林缘、林隙、林冠3种生境下5～6年生胡桃楸幼树根系构型及细根功能进行研究,分析根系拓扑指数、平均连接长度、根系分支前后横截面积比,以及细根化学成分,探索胡桃楸幼树根系构型对生境变化的响应。结果表明: 林缘下胡桃楸根系趋向于叉状分支(拓扑指数TI=0.68),林冠下则偏向于鲱鱼骨形分支(TI=0.79),林隙居于两者之间(TI=0.72)。林缘、林隙和林冠下根系平均连接长度差异不显著,根系分支前后横截面积比分别为1.06、1.04、1.07,不受根系直径变化的影响,符合Leonardo da Vinci法则。从林缘、林隙到林冠下,不同生境下同一根序细根的比根长、比表面积逐渐增大,N含量先降低再升高,而C含量和C/N则先升高再降低。从林缘、林隙到林冠下,胡桃楸根系通过减少次级分支和根系间的重叠,使其由叉状分支趋向于鲱鱼骨形分支,并通过增大比根长、比表面积和改变C、N含量应对环境的变化,提高根系对养分的吸收效率。     

Effects of root diameter,branch order,root depth,season and warming on root longevity in an alpine meadow

Fine root is of importance in biogeochemical cycles especially in terrestrial ecosystems. The lack of understanding of the factors controlling root lifespan has made accurate prediction of carbon flow and nutrient cycling difficult. A controlled warming experiment was performed in an alpine meadow on the northern Tibetan Plateau (near Nagchu Town). We used a minirhizotron technique to measure root dynamics in situ during the growing season of 2013 and 2014 and survival analyses to assess root lifespan and the effects of root diameter, branch order, birth season, root depth and warming on root lifespan. Root diameter, branch order and root depth were all positively correlated with root lifespan. With an increase in diameter of 0.1 mm, mortality hazard ratio of roots declined by 19.3 %. An increase in one level in branch order was associated with a decrease of 43.8 % in root death ratio. Compared with roots born in May–mid-July, the mortality hazard ratio of roots born in late July–August and September–October reduced by 26.8 and 56.5 %, respectively. In warming treatments, roots tended to be thinner, less branched and deeper, and there was a higher proportion of roots born in spring compared to ambient conditions. Warming shortened the median root lifespan 44 days. However, in single warming condition, root diameter had no significant influence on root lifespan. Root diameter, branch order, root depth and season of birth were all factors affecting root lifespan in the alpine meadow; however, root branch order was dominant.     

Longevity and turnover of roots in the shortgrass steppe: influence of diameter and depth

We used minirhizotrons to determine patterns of root longevity andturnover for the perennial bunchgrass Bouteloua gracilisinthe shortgrass steppe of eastern Colorado, USA. We hypothesized that rootlongevity would be partially controlled by root diameter, following previouslyobserved patterns in woody plants. In addition, we hypothesized that rootturnover would be greatest in surface soil horizons and decrease with depth dueto variation in soil moisture availability and temperature. Root longevity wascorrelated with root diameter. Median life span of roots > 0.4mm was approximately 320 days, while roots < 0.2mmhad a median life span of 180 days. There was approximately a 6%decreasein the likelihood of mortality with a 0.10-mm increase inroot diameter, controlling for the effect of depth in the soil profile. Rootlength production and mortality were highest in the upper20 cm of the soil profile and decreased with depth.However,because root length density also decreased with depth, there were nosignificantdifferences in turnover rate of root length among sampling intervals. Turnoverwas approximately 0.86 yr^–1 based on root length production,while turnover was 0.35 yr^–1 using root length mortality as ameasurement of flux. The imbalance between turnover estimates may be aconsequence of the time the minirhizotrons were in place prior to imaging or mayresult from our lack of over-winter measures of mortality. Our worksuggests that Bouteloua gracilis roots have complex lifehistory strategies, similar to woody species. Some portion of the root systemishighly ephemeral, while slightly larger roots persist much longer. Thesedifferences have implications for belowground carbon and nitrogen cycles in theshortgrass steppe.     

Relationships among root branch order, carbon, and nitrogen in four temperate species

The objective of this study was to examine how root length, diameter, specific root length, and root carbon and nitrogen concentrations were related to root branching patterns. The branching root systems of two temperate tree species, Acer saccharum Marsh. and Fraxinus americana L., and two perennial herbs from horizontal rhizomes, Hydrophyllum canadense L. and Viola pubescens Ait., were quantified by dissecting entire root systems collected from the understory of an A. saccharum-Fagus grandifolia Ehrh. forest. The root systems of each species grew according to a simple branching process, with laterals emerging from the main roots some distance behind the tip. Root systems normally consisted of only 4–6 branches (orders). Root diameter, length, and number of branches declined with increasing order and there were significant differences among species. Specific root length increased with order in all species. Nitrogen concentration increased with order in the trees, but remained constant in the perennial herbs. More than 75% of the cumulative root length of tree seedling root systems was accounted for by short (2–10 mm) lateral roots almost always <0.3 mm in diameter. Simple assumptions suggest that many tree roots normally considered part of the dynamic fine-root pool (e.g., all roots <2.0 mm in diameter) are too large to exhibit rapid rates of production and mortality. The smallest tree roots may be the least expensive to construct but the most expensive to maintain based on an increase in N concentration with order. Received: 25 November 1996 / Accepted: 27 March 1997     

水曲柳和落叶松不同根序之间细根直径的变异研究

细根直径大小和根序高低对细根寿命和周转估计具有重要的影响,研究不同根序之间的直径变异对认识细根直径与根序的关系具有重要意义。该文根据Pregitzer等(2002)提供的方法,研究了位于东北林业大学帽儿山实验林场尖砬沟森林培育实验站17年生水曲柳(Fraxinus mandshurica)和落叶松(Larix gmelinii)人工林细根1~5级根序的平均直径的变化、直径的最小值和最大值范围、直径的变异系数。结果表明,水曲柳和落叶松细根直径<2 mm时,包含5个根序,随着根序由小到大的增加,细根直径也在增大。各根序平均直径之间,存在较大的差异。在同一根序内,细根直径范围很大,水曲柳和落叶松一级根最小直径均<0.20 mm,最大直径分别<0.50 mm(水曲柳)和<0.70 mm(落叶松)左右。2~3级根序直径最小值在0.20~0.30 mm之间,最大值≤1.0 mm。5级根直径最小值<1.0 mm,最大值超过2.0 mm。随着根序等级增加,直径变异系数增大。一级根序的直径平均变异系数<10%,2~3级根序直径平均变异系数在10%~15%左右,4~5级根序直径的平均变异系数在20%~30%之间。因此,在细根寿命与周转研究过程中,必须同时考虑直径和根序对细根的寿命估计的影响。     

Patterns of variability in the diameter of lateral roots in the banana root system

The relative importance of root system structure, plant carbon status and soil environment in the determination of lateral root diameter remains unclear, and was investigated in this study. Banana (Musa acuminata) plants were grown at various moderate levels of soil compaction in two distinct experiments, in a field experiment (FE) and in a glasshouse experiment (GE). Radiant flux density was 5 times lower in GE. The distribution of root diameter was measured for several root branching orders. Root diameters ranged between 0.09 and 0.52 mm for secondary roots and between 0.06 and 0.27 mm for tertiary roots. A relationship was found between the diameter of the parent bearing root and the median diameter of its laterals, which appears to be valid for a wide range of species. Mean lateral root diameter increased with distance to the base of the root and decreased with branching density [number of lateral roots per unit length of bearing root (cm(-1))]. Typical symptoms of low light availability were observed in GE. In this case, lateral root diameter variability was reduced. Although primary root growth was affected by soil compaction, no effects on lateral root diameter were observed.     

海南岛4个热带阔叶树种前5级细根的形态、解剖结构和组织碳氮含量

细根具有复杂的分支系统, 以根序(root order)为取样单元的细根生理生态学研究正在成为根系生态学研究领域的重要内容。该研究以海南岛尖峰岭4个热带阔叶树种海南蕈树(Altingia obovata)、厚壳桂(Cryptocarya chinensis)、山杜英(Elaeocarpus sylvestris)和黄桐(Endospermum chinense)为研究对象, 测定了1-5级细根的形态、解剖结构和组织碳(C)、氮(N)含量, 旨在探讨这些根系特征之间的联系。研究表明: 4个树种的细根形态差异较大, 但在树种水平上直径、根长和组织密度均随着根序的升高而增加, 比根长则随着根序的升高而降低; 低级根(前2级根或前3级根)具有皮层组织, 是典型的吸收根, 而高级根皮层组织消失, 是典型的运输和储藏根; 影响直径大小最重要的因子是皮层厚度, 它可以解释细根直径变异的97%, 而维管束直径仅能解释细根直径变异的70%; 根组织N和C浓度受维管束-根直径比(维根比)的影响, 随着维根比增加, 组织N浓度显著降低, 组织C浓度显著升高。4个树种细根的C/N比的变异受组织N浓度的影响程度为76%, 而受C浓度的影响程度不足10%。上述结果表明, 细根的形态特征、解剖结构和组织化学含量之间存在着紧密联系, 这为我们理解根系结构与功能变异提供了重要依据。     

翅荚木人工林不同径阶间细根主要功能性状与根际土壤养分的关系

细根能敏感地感知土壤环境变化,对植物生长发育具有重要影响.以6年生翅荚木人工林为对象,对其不同径阶的细根主要功能性状与根际土壤养分特征及两者间关系进行分析.结果表明:细根生物量、根长密度与根体积密度均随径阶增加而增加,比根长与比根面积则随径阶增加呈先升高再下降后升高的趋势,根组织密度则与径阶大小不相关.不同径阶翅荚木根际土壤的pH值及含水率、全碳、全磷、铵态氮、硝态氮和总有效氮含量均存在显著差异,大径阶林木的根际土壤全碳、全氮、硝态氮、总有效氮含量相对较高,小径阶林木的根际土壤含水率、土壤全磷、铵态氮含量相对较高.土壤全氮、全碳、硝态氮和总有效氮含量与林木细根的生物量、根长密度、根体积密度呈显著正相关;土壤全磷与林木细根的根组织密度呈显著正相关,与比根长、比根面积呈显著负相关;土壤含水率与林木细根的生物量和根体积密度均呈显著正相关;根际土壤pH和林木细根的比根长、比根面积呈显著正相关,与根组织密度则呈显著负相关.研究结果可为翅荚木优良种质资源选育提供科学依据.     

亚热带常绿阔叶林89种木本植物一级根直径的变异

细根直径变异是根系形态变化的常见形式, 对细根变异研究具有重要意义。为了揭示亚热带天然常绿阔叶林一级根直径变异特征, 该研究选取福建省建瓯市万木林自然保护区天然常绿阔叶林的89种木本植物进行研究。每个树种选取胸径或地径相近的3株, 用完整土块法进行根系取样, 用根序法对根系进行分级。采用单因素方差分析分别检验叶片习性(常绿、落叶树种)、生长型(乔木、小乔木或灌木、灌木)和主要科之间一级根直径的差异; 通过计算Blomberg’s K值以检验系统发育信号; 利用线性回归方法, 分析科水平的分化时间与一级根直径的相关性。结果显示: 1)亚热带常绿阔叶林一级根直径变异系数为23%; 2)常绿树种与落叶树种一级根直径没有显著差异, 但灌木一级根直径显著小于小乔木或灌木、乔木; 3)一级根直径系统发育信号不显著, 科水平分化时间与一级根直径呈正相关关系。研究结果表明, 亚热带天然常绿阔叶林木本植物一级根直径变异受系统发育影响较小, 但受生长型影响, 表现为一定的趋同适应。