Only UCP1 can mediate adaptive nonshivering thermogenesis in the cold.

Adaptive nonshivering thermogenesis may have profound effects on energy balance and is therefore therefore is a potential mechanism for counteracting the development of obesity. The molecular basis for adaptive nonshivering thermogenesis has remained a challenge that sparked acute interest with the identification of proteins (UCP2, UCP3, etc.) with high-sequence similarity to the original uncoupling protein-1 (UCP1), which is localized only in brown adipose tissue. Using UCP1-ablated mice, we examined whether any adaptive nonshivering thermogenesis could be recruited by acclimation to cold. Remarkably, by successive acclimation, the UCP1-ablated mice could be made to subsist for several weeks at 4C during which they had to constantly produce heat at four times their resting levels. Despite these extreme requirements for adaptive nonshivering thermogenesis, however, no substitution of shivering by any adaptive nonshivering thermogenic process occurred. Thus, although the existence of, for example, muscular mechanisms for adaptive nonshivering thermogenesis has recurrently been implied, we did not find any indication of such thermogenesis. Not even during prolonged and enhanced demand for extra heat production was any endogenous hormone or neurotransmitter able to recruit any UCP1-independent adaptive nonshivering thermogenic process in muscle or in any other organ, and no proteins other than UCP1-not even UCP2 or UCP3-therefore have the ability to mediate adaptive nonshivering thermogenesis in the cold.     

Molecular evolution of UCP1 and the evolutionary history of mammalian non-shivering thermogenesis

Background  

Uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) is a mitochondrial anion carrier, expressed in brown adipose tissue (BAT) of Eutherians. UCP1 is responsible for uncoupling mitochondrial proton transport from the production of ATP, thereby dissipating heat; it is essential for non-shivering thermogenesis (NST) in mammalian BAT. UCP1 orthologs have been identified in non-Eutherian mammals, fish and amphibians. Yet, UCP1 has a unique function in Eutherians in that it is necessary in the production of heat (NST). As such, this study aims to determine the evolutionary mode of UCP1 in Eutherians, where there is clear evidence of UCP1-dependent NST in BAT.     

Neofunctionalization of the UCP1 mediated the non-shivering thermogenesis in the evolution of small-sized placental mammals

The acquisition of UCP1-mediated non-shivering thermogenesis (NST) was an important event during the evolution of mammals. Here, we assessed the thermogenic neofunctionalization that occurred in the mammalian UCP1, by performing detailed comparative evolutionary genomics analyses (including phylogenetic and selection analyses) of the UCP family members across all major vertebrate classes. Heterogeneously distributed positive selection signatures were found in several UCPs, being preferably located in the mitochondrial matrix domains. Additionally, comparisons with non-mammalian orthologs showed increased evolutionary rates of the mammalian UCP1, not observable in the phylogenetically related UCP2 and UCP3 paralogs. Also, parallel signatures of episodic positive selection (ω > 1) were found in the ancestral branches of both Glires (rodents and lagomorphs) and Afroinsectivores (afrosoricids and macroscelids), underlining the importance of the UCP1 thermogenic activity in these mammalian groups. Finally, we hypothesize that the independent positive selection events that occurred in these two lineages resulted in two UCP1-mediated NST approaches, namely the cold acute response in the Glires and the reproduction success enhancement in the Afroinsectivores.     

UCP1 is essential for adaptive adrenergic nonshivering thermogenesis

Participation of brown adipose tissue [through the action of the uncoupling protein-1 (UCP1)] in adaptive adrenergic nonshivering thermogenesis is recognized, but the existence of a response to adrenergic stimulation in UCP1-ablated mice implies that a mechanism for an alternative adaptive adrenergic thermogenesis may exist. Here, we have used UCP1-ablated mice to examine the existence of an alternative adaptive adrenergic nonshivering thermogenesis, examined as the oxygen consumption response to systemically injected norepinephrine into anesthetized or conscious mice acclimated to different temperatures. We confirm that UCP1-dependent adrenergic nonshivering thermogenesis is adaptive, but we demonstrate that the adrenergic UCP1-independent thermogenesis is not recruitable by cold acclimation. Thus, at least in the mouse, no other proteins or enzymatic pathways exist that can participate in or with time take over the UCP1 mediation of adaptive adrenergic nonshivering thermogenesis, even in the total absence of UCP1. UCP1 is thus the only protein capable of mediating cold acclimation-recruited adaptive adrenergic nonshivering thermogenesis.     

Homeostatic non-shivering thermogenesis in man: facts and speculations

In this review it is considered up-to date researches of different forms of non-shivering thermogenesis that related to thermoregulatory and substrate homeostasis. Term "homeostatic non-shivering thermogenesis (HNST)" is proposed for explanation of facultative heat production stimulated by cold exposure, food intake and accumulation of lactate during intensive muscle load. There are common and different features of physiological activity displayed in three HNST types. Existence of these common points gets a probability to propose general physiological mechanisms of HNST realization. Between other candidates for HNST location brown adipose tissue (BAT) has real unquestionable advantage for this specific function. There is close relationship between thermogenic function in cold environment and diet-induced thermogenesis that allows to link two HNST types and BAT activity together. Here we present data indirectly confirming BAT functioning in processes of homeostatic normalization not due to cold acclimation or food intake. Also we give consideration to new data about BAT functional activity, its topographic body location, mechanisms of uncoupled respiration in different tissues in adult humans and methods of BAT diagnostics which include molecular marker using. We adduce a number of facts confirming our suggestion about BAT activity can be related to homeostatic normalization after physical load. At last, we bring forward experimental research program for examination of our hypothesis about BAT universal homeostatic function in humans.     

White adipose tissue contributes to UCP1-independent thermogenesis

Beta3-adrenergic receptors (AR) are nearly exclusively expressed in brown and white adipose tissues, and chronic activation of these receptors by selective agonists has profound anti-diabetes and anti-obesity effects. This study examined metabolic responses to acute and chronic beta3-AR activation in wild-type C57Bl/6 mice and congenic mice lacking functional uncoupling protein (UCP)1, the molecular effector of brown adipose tissue (BAT) thermogenesis. Acute activation of beta3-AR doubled metabolic rate in wild-type mice and sharply elevated body temperature and BAT blood flow, as determined by laser Doppler flowmetry. In contrast, beta3-AR activation did not increase BAT blood flow in mice lacking UCP1 (UCP1 KO). Nonetheless, beta3-AR activation significantly increased metabolic rate and body temperature in UCP1 KO mice, demonstrating the presence of UCP1-independent thermogenesis. Daily treatment with the beta3-AR agonist CL-316243 (CL) for 6 days increased basal and CL-induced thermogenesis compared with naive mice. This expansion of basal and CL-induced metabolic rate did not require UCP1 expression. Chronic CL treatment of UCP1 KO mice increased basal and CL-stimulated metabolic rate of epididymal white adipose tissue (EWAT) fourfold but did not alter BAT thermogenesis. After chronic CL treatment, CL-stimulated thermogenesis of EWAT equaled that of interscapular BAT per tissue mass. The elevation of EWAT metabolism was accompanied by mitochondrial biogenesis and the induction of genes involved in lipid oxidation. These observations indicate that chronic beta3-AR activation induces metabolic adaptation in WAT that contributes to beta3-AR-mediated thermogenesis. This adaptation involves lipid oxidation in situ and does not require UCP1 expression.     

UCP1 muscle gene transfer and mitochondrial proton leak mediated thermogenesis

Mitochondrial uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) mediates the thermogenic transport of protons through the inner mitochondrial membrane. This proton leak uncouples respiration from ATP synthesis. The current study assessed the possible contribution of UCP1 muscle gene transfer to impair mitochondrial respiration in a tissue lacking UCP1 gene expression. Rats received an intramuscular injection of plasmid pXC1 containing UCP1 cDNA in the right tibialis muscles, while left tibialis muscles were injected with empty plasmid as control. Ten days after DNA injection, mitochondria from tibialis anterior muscles were isolated and analyzed. UCP1 gene transfer resulted in protein expression as analyzed by inmunoblotting. Mitochondria isolated from UCP1-injected muscles showed a significant increase in state 2 and state 4 oxygen consumption rates and a decreased respiration control ratio in comparison to mitochondria from control muscles. Furthermore, UCP1-containing mitochondria had a lower membrane potential in those states (2 and 4) when compared with control mitochondria. Our results revealed that UCP1 muscle gene transfer is associated with an induced mitochondrial proton leak, which could contribute to increase energy expenditure.     

The mitochondrial calcium uniporter engages UCP1 to form a thermoporter that promotes thermogenesis

1. Download : Download high-res image (160KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Maximal thermogenic capacity and non-shivering thermogenesis in the South American subterranean rodent Ctenomys talarum

Subterranean rodents inhabit closed tunnel systems that are hypoxic and hypercapnic and buffer aboveground ambient temperature. In contrast to other strictly subterranean rodents, Ctenomys talarum exhibits activity on the surface during foraging and dispersion and hence, is exposed also to the aboveground environment. In this context, this species is a valuable model to explore how the interplay between underground and aboveground use affects the relationship among basal metabolic rate (BMR), cold-induced maximum metabolic rate (MMR), shivering (ST), and non-shivering thermogenesis (NST). In this work, we provide the first evidence of the presence of NST, including the expression of uncoupling proteins in brown adipose tissue (BAT), and shivering thermogenesis in Ctenomys talarum, a species belonging to the most numerous subterranean genus, endemic to South America. Our results show no differences in BMR, cold-induced MMR, and NST between cold- (15?°C) and warm- (25?°C) acclimated individuals. Furthermore, thermal acclimation had no effect on the expression of mitochondrial uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) in BAT. Only cytochrome c oxidase (COX) content and activity increased during cold acclimation. When interscapular BAT was removed, NST decreased more than 30?%, whereas cold-induced MMR remained unchanged. All together, these data suggest that cold-induced MMR reaches a maximum in warm-acclimated individuals and so a probable ceiling in NST and UCP1 expression in BAT. Possible thermogenic mechanisms explaining the increase in the oxidative capacity, mediated by COX in BAT of cold-acclimated individuals and the role of ST in subterranean life habits are proposed.     

Shivering and non-shivering thermogenesis in a marsupial,the eastern barred bandicoot (Perameles gunnii)

We investigated the metabolic rate of the Tasmanian marsupial, the eastern barred bandicoot, Perameles gunnii, before and after acclimation to cold temperature (5 °C) for a 2-week period. Although body temperature did not change significantly, we observed a significant increase in the metabolic rate (MR) when measured at 5 °C before and after cold acclimation. Nor-epinephrine had a significant effect on the metabolic rate when measured in the thermoneutral zone and when measured at 5 °C after cold acclimation; however, there was no significant increase when measured at 5 °C before cold acclimation. Nor-epinephrine also resulted in a small but significant decrease in body temperature. Electromyography (EMG) measurements were obtained before and after cold acclimation during shivering. Shivering decreased after two weeks of cold exposure indicating that the bandicoot had acclimated to that temperature. Nor-epinephrine (NE) significantly reduced shivering before but not after cold acclimation. The metabolic rate and shivering decreased in the adult eastern barred bandicoot after acclimation at 5 °C and nor-epinephrine had similar effects to cold acclimation. Our findings of minor changes in thermal conductance suggest that insulation differences were unlikely explanations for our results. These experiments indicate that this marsupial is able to increase its heat production by non-shivering thermogenesis.     

Activation by retinoids of the uncoupling protein UCP1

The uncoupling protein from brown adipose tissue (UCP1) is a transporter that catalyzes a regulated discharged of the mitochondrial proton gradient. The proton conductance in UCP1 is inhibited by nucleotides and activated by fatty acids. We have recently shown that all-trans-retinoic acid (ATRA) is a high-affinity activator of UCP1. In the present report, we have set to analyze the structural requirements for the ligands that activate UCP1 and particularly the specificity for different retinoids. For this purpose, we have developed a new protocol to determine the activity of UCP1 in respiring yeast mitochondria that can be adapted for high-throughput screenings. Our results evidence differences between the structural requirements for the activation by fatty acids and retinoids. Thus, although all active retinoids must possess a carboxylate, the introduction of additional polar groups renders them inactive. The linear and rigid structure of these molecules suggests the existence of a long hydrophobic binding pocket. We postulate that the access to the retinoid binding site must occur from the lipid bilayer and this could be at the interface between two transmembrane alpha-helices.     

Alkylsulfonates activate the uncoupling protein UCP1: implications for the transport mechanism

Fatty acids activate the uncoupling protein UCP1 by a still controversial mechanism. Two models have been put forward where the fatty acid operates as either substrate ("fatty acid cycling hypothesis") or prosthetic group ("proton buffering model"). Two sets of experiments that should help to discriminate between the two hypothetical mechanisms are presented. We show that undecanosulfonate activates UCP1 in respiring mitochondria under conditions identical to those required for the activation by fatty acids. Since alkylsulfonates cannot cross the lipid bilayer, these experiments rule out the fatty acid cycling hypothesis as the mechanism of uncoupling. We also demonstrate that without added nucleotides and upon careful removal of endogenous fatty acids, brown adipose tissue (BAT) mitochondria from cold-adapted hamsters respire at the full uncoupled rate. Addition of nucleotides lower the respiratory rate tenfold. The high activity observed in the absence of the two regulatory ligands is an indication that UCP1 displays an intrinsic proton conductance that is fatty acid-independent. We propose that the fatty acid uncoupling mediated by other members of the mitochondrial transporter family probably involves a carrier to pore transition and therefore has little in common with the activation of UCP1.     

The effect of pinealectomy on non-shivering thermogenesis and hibernation of the wyoming ground squirrel, Spermophilus elegans

1. 1.|Pineal gland removal (PX) performed on Wyoming ground squirrels (Spermophilus elegans) during the summer significantly lowered their non-shivering thermogenic (NST) response and impaired their ability to hibernate the subsequent winter.

2. 2.|This impairment was not observed in previous studies on squirrels PX'd later in the season. A period of responsiveness for involvement of the pineal gland in NST and hibernation is, therefore, presented.

3. 3.|Environmental signals translated by the pineal gland which influence the NST response do not appear to be thermal cues but are more than likely photic information.

4. 4.|Reduced impairment of the NST response was observed in squirrels PX'd for 3 yr compared to the 1st PX'd group. However, this may simply be a result of the 3-yr PX'd group being tested later in the hibernation cycle.

Correlation between torpor frequency and capacity for non-shivering thermogenesis in the Siberian hamster (Phodopus sungorus)

We investigated the correlation between torpor frequency and capacity for non-shivering thermogenesis (NST) in Siberian hamsters (Phodopus sungorus) during 25 weeks of acclimation to cold and short days. We hypothesized that torpor use is conditioned on the development of brown adipose tissue (BAT) capacity for NST. We found that (1) the degree of noradrenaline (NA)-induced hyperthermia was positively correlated with torpor frequency and its length and depth, and (2) the maximum response to NA occurred at the time of day when hamsters naturally arouse from torpor. The present study quantifies the correlation between torpor frequency and NST capacity and we suggest that a well-developed NST capacity is a prerequisite for the occurrence of torpor.