The effect of growth at elevated CO2 concentrations on photosynthesis in wheat

Rising levels of atmospheric CO₂ will have profound, direct effects on plant carbon metabolism. In this study we used gas exchange measurements, models describing the instantaneous response of leaf net CO₂ assimilation rate (A) to intercellular CO₂ partial pressure (C_i), in vitro enzyme activity assay, and carbohydrate assay in order to investigate the photosynthetic responses of wheat (Triticum aestivum L., cv. Wembley) to growth under elevated partial pressures of atmospheric CO₂ (C_a). At flag leaf ligule emergence, the modelled, in vivo, maximum carboxylation velocity for RuBisCO was significantly lower in plants grown at elevated C_a than in plants grown at ambient C_a (70 Pa compared with 40 Pa). By 12 d after ligule emergence, no significant difference in this parameter was detectable. At ligule emergence, plants grown at elevated C_a exhibited reduced in vitro initial activities and activation states of RuBisCO. At their respective growth C_i values, the photosynthesis of 40-Pa-grown plants was sensitive to p(O₂) and to p(CO₂) whereas that of 70-Pa-grown plants was insensitive. Both sucrose and starch accumulated more rapidly in the leaves of plants grown at 70 Pa. At flag leaf ligule emergence, modelled non-photorespiratory respiration in the light (R_d) was significantly higher in 70-Pa-grown plants than in 40-Pa-grown plants. By 12 d after ligule emergence no significant differences in R_d were detectable.     

Reversibility of photosynthetic acclimation of swiss chard and sugarbeet grown at elevated concentrations of CO2

Although leaf photosynthesis and plant growth are initially stimulated by elevated CO₂ concentrations, increasing insensitivity to CO₂ (acclimation) is a frequent occurrence. In order to examine the acclimation process, we studied photosynthesis and whole plant development in swiss chard (Beta vulgaris L. Koch ssp. ciela) and sugarbeet (Beta vulgaris L. ssp. vulgaris) grown at either ambient or twice ambient concentrations of CO₂. In an initial controlled environment study, photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO₂ levels was observed in both subspecies 24 days after sowing (DAS) but was not observed at 42 and 49 DAS for sugarbeet or at 49 DAS for swiss chard. Although sugarbeet and swiss chard differed in root size and morphology, this was not a factor in the onset of photosynthetic acclimation. The reversal of photosynthetic acclimation that was observed in older plants grown at elevated CO₂, concentrations was associated with a rapid increase in root development (i.e. increased root: shoot [R/S] ratio), increased sucrose levels in sinks (roots) and no differences in total soluble leaf protein of either subspecies relative to the ambient CO₂ condition. In a second set of experiments, swiss chard and sugarbeet were grown in outdoor Plexiglass chambers at different times of the year (i.e. summer and early fall). Average 24-h temperature was 30.7 and 19.4°C for the summer and fall plantings, respectively. In agreement with the controlled environment study, lack of photosynthetic acclimation, determined from the response of photosynthesic rate to internal CO₂ concentration, was correlated with increased root biomass and sucrose concentration relative to the ambient condition. However, photo-synthetic acclimation was observed depending on the season, i.e. summer (swiss chard) or fall (sugarbeet), suggesting that acclimation was affected by environmental factors, such as temperature. Data from both experiments suggest that continued long-term photosynthetic stimulation may be dependent upon the ability of increased CO₂ to stimulate new sink development which would allow full utilization of the additional carbon made available in a high CO₂ environment.     

Growth in elevated CO2 protects photosynthesis against high-temperature damage

We present evidence that plant growth at elevated atmospheric CO₂ increases the high‐temperature tolerance of photosynthesis in a wide variety of plant species under both greenhouse and field conditions. We grew plants at ambient CO₂ (~ 360 μ mol mol ^{? 1}) and elevated CO₂ (550–1000 μ mol mol ^{? 1}) in three separate growth facilities, including the Nevada Desert Free‐Air Carbon Dioxide Enrichment (FACE) facility. Excised leaves from both the ambient and elevated CO₂ treatments were exposed to temperatures ranging from 28 to 48 °C. In more than half the species examined (4 of 7, 3 of 5, and 3 of 5 species in the three facilities), leaves from elevated CO₂‐grown plants maintained PSII efficiency (F_v/F_m) to significantly higher temperatures than ambient‐grown leaves. This enhanced PSII thermotolerance was found in both woody and herbaceous species and in both monocots and dicots. Detailed experiments conducted with Cucumis sativus showed that the greater F_v/F_m in elevated versus ambient CO₂‐grown leaves following heat stress was due to both a higher F_m and a lower F_o, and that F_v/F_m differences between elevated and ambient CO₂‐grown leaves persisted for at least 20 h following heat shock. Cucumis sativus leaves from elevated CO₂‐grown plants had a critical temperature for the rapid rise in F_o that averaged 2·9 °C higher than leaves from ambient CO₂‐grown plants, and maintained a higher maximal rate of net CO₂ assimilation following heat shock. Given that photosynthesis is considered to be the physiological process most sensitive to high‐temperature damage and that rising atmospheric CO₂ content will drive temperature increases in many already stressful environments, this CO₂‐induced increase in plant high‐temperature tolerance may have a substantial impact on both the productivity and distribution of many plant species in the 21st century.     

Sensing of atmospheric CO2 by plants

Abstract. Despite recent interest in the effects of high CO₂ on plant growth and physiology, very little is known about the mechanisms by which plants sense changes in the concentration of this gas. Because atmospheric CO₂ concentration is relatively constant and because the conductance of the cuticle to CO₂ is low, sensory mechanisms are likely to exist only for intercellular CO₂ concentration. Therefore, responses of plants to changes in atmospheric CO₂ will depend on the effect of these changes on intercellular CO₂ concentration. Although a variety of plant responses to atmospheric CO₂ concentration have been reported, most of these can be attributed to the effects of intercellular CO₂ on photosynthesis or stomatal conductance. Short-term and long-term effects of CO₂ on photosynthesis and stomatal conductance are discussed as sensory mechanisms for responses of plants to atmospheric CO₂. Available data suggest that plants do not fully realize the potential increases in productivity associated with increased atmospheric CO₂. This may be because of genetic and environmental limitations to productivity or because plant responses to CO₂ have evolved to cope with variations in intercellular CO₂ caused by factors other than changes in atmospheric CO₂.     

Changes in net photosynthesis and growth of Pinus eldarica seedlings in response to atmospheric CO2 enrichment

Pinus eldarica L. trees, rooted in the natural soil of an agricultural field at Phoenix, Arizona, were grown from the seedling stage in clear-plastic-wall open-top enclosures maintained at four different atmospheric CO₂ concentrations for 15 months. Light response functions were determined for one tree from each treatment by means of whole-tree net CO₂ exchange measurements at the end of this period, after which rates of carbon assimilation of an ambient-treatment tree were measured across a range of atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. The first of these data sets incorporates the consequences of both the CO₂-induced enhancement of net photosynthesis per unit needle area and the CO₂-induced enhancement of needle area itself (due primarily to the production of more needles), whereas the second data set reflects only the first of these effects. Hence the division of the normalized results of the first data set by the normalized results of the second set yields a representation of the increase in whole-tree net photosynthesis due to enhanced needle production caused by atmospheric CO₂ enrichment. In the solitary trees we studied, the relative contribution of this effect increased rapidly with the CO₂ concentration of the air to increase whole-tree net photosynthesis by nearly 50% at a CO₂ concentration approximately 300 μmol mol⁻¹ above ambient.     

The effect of an elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration on growth, photosynthesis and respiration of Plantago major

The effect of an elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentration on growth, photosynthesis and root respiration of Plantago major L. ssp. major L. was investigated. Plants were grown in a nutrient solution in growth chambers at 350 and 700 μl I⁻¹ CO₂ during 7 weeks. The total dry weight of the Co₂-enriched plants at the end of this period was 50% higher than that of control plants. However, the relative growth rate (RGR) was stimulated only during the first half of the growing period. The transient nature of the stimulation of the RGR was not likely to be due to end-product inhibition of photosynthesis. It is suggested that in P. major , a rosette plant, self-shading causes a decline in photosynthesis and results in an increase in the shoot: root ratio and a decrease in RGR. CO₂-enriched plants grow faster and cosequently suffer more from self-shading. Corrected for this ontogenetic drift, high CO₂ concentrations stimulated the RGR of P. major throughout the entire experiment.     

A mechanistic evaluation of photosynthetic acclimation at elevated CO2

Plants grown at elevated pCO₂ often fail to sustain the initial stimulation of net CO₂ uptake rate (A). This reduced, acclimated, stimulation of A often occurs concomitantly with a reduction in the maximum carboxylation velocity (V_c,max) of Rubisco. To investigate this relationship we used the Farquhar model of C₃ photosynthesis to predict the minimum V_c,max capable of supporting the acclimated stimulation in A observed at elevated pCO₂. For a wide range of species grown at elevated pCO₂ under contrasting conditions we found a strong correlation between observed and predicted values of V_c,max. This exercise mechanistically and quantitatively demonstrated that the observed acclimated stimulation of A and the simultaneous decrease in V_c,max observed at elevated pCO₂ is mechanistically consistent. With the exception of plants grown at a high elevated pCO₂ (> 90 Pa), which show evidence of an excess investment in Rubisco, the failure to maintain the initial stimulation of A is almost entirely attributable to the decrease in V_c,max and investment in Rubisco is coupled to requirements.     

Quantifying the response of photosynthesis to changes in leaf nitrogen content and leaf mass per area in plants grown under atmospheric CO2 enrichment

Previous modelling exercises and conceptual arguments have predicted that a reduction in biochemical capacity for photosynthesis (A_area) at elevated CO₂ may be compensated by an increase in mesophyll tissue growth if the total amount of photosynthetic machinery per unit leaf area is maintained (i.e. morphological upregulation). The model prediction was based on modelling photosynthesis as a function of leaf N per unit leaf area (N_area), where N_area = N_mass×LMA. Here, N_mass is percentage leaf N and is used to estimate biochemical capacity and LMA is leaf mass per unit leaf area and is an index of leaf morphology. To assess the relative importance of changes in biochemical capacity versus leaf morphology we need to control for multiple correlations that are known, or that are likely to exist between CO₂ concentration, N_area, N_mass, LMA and A_area. Although this is impractical experimentally, we can control for these correlations statistically using systems of linear multiple-regression equations. We developed a linear model to partition the response of A_area to elevated CO₂ into components representing the independent and interactive effects of changes in indexes of biochemical capacity, leaf morphology and CO₂ limitation of photosynthesis. The model was fitted to data from three pine and seven deciduous tree species grown in separate chamber-based field experiments. Photosynthetic enhancement at elevated CO₂ due to morphological upregulation was negligible for most species. The response of A_area in these species was dominated by the reduction in CO₂ limitation occurring at higher CO₂ concentration. However, some species displayed a significant reduction in potential photosynthesis at elevated CO₂ due to an increase in LMA that was independent of any changes in N_area. This morphologically based inhibition of A_area combined additively with a reduction in biochemical capacity to significantly offset the direct enhancement of A_area caused by reduced CO₂ limitation in two species. This offset was 100% for Acer rubrum, resulting in no net effect of elevated CO₂ on A_area for this species, and 44% for Betula pendula. This analysis shows that interactions between biochemical and morphological responses to elevated CO₂ can have important effects on photosynthesis.     

The effect of source or sink temperature on photosynthesis and 14C-partitioning in and export from a source leaf of Alstroemeria

The influence of source and sink temperature on leaf net C exchange rate (NCER), export, and partitioning in the C₃ monocotyledon Alstroemeria sp. cv. Jacqueline were examined. Leaf (i.e. source) temperature was varied between 12 and 35°C while source leaves were exposed to photorespiratory and nonphotorespiratory conditions during a 2-h steady-state ¹⁴CO₂ labelling period. Between 12 and 20°C, at ambient CO₂ and O₂, leaf NCER and export were similar with maximum rates of 9.71 ± 0.51 and 3.06 ± 0.36 μmol C m^-2 s^-1, respectively. Both NCER and export decreased above 20°C. At 35°C NCER was 30% of the rate at 20°C, but export was totally inhibited. Between 12 and 35°C, at the end of the 2-h feeding period, ¹⁴C was partitioned in the leaf as ethanol insolubles (3–10%), H₂O solubles (88–92%), and chloroform solubles (2–8%). However, above 25°C, less ¹⁴C was recovered in the starch fraction and more in the sugar fractions. At all temperatures, 86 to 94% of the labelled sugars was ¹⁴C-sucrose. In nonphotorespiratory conditions (i.e. 1 800 μI I^-1 CO₂ and 2% O₂). NCER and export were higher than the rates obtained at ambient CO₂ and O₂ at each temperature. Carbon dioxide enrichment sustained high NCER and export rates even at 35°C, Although CO₂ enrichment increased partitioning of ¹⁴C into starch, starch synthesis at 35°C was markedly reduced. Cooling the root-zone mass (i.e. a dominant sink) to 10°C, which simulated the commercial practice used to induce flowering, had no significant effect on source leaf NCER and export rates either during a 2-h steady-state labelling period or subsequently during a 21-h light-dark chase period. Furthermore, partitioning of ¹⁴C among leaf products at the end of the feed-chase period was not affected. Additional pulse and chase experiments using ¹¹CO₂ fed to source leaves of control and root-cooled plants showed that there was no difference in the direction of movement of ¹¹C-assimilates towards the flower or the root zone as a consequence of root cooling. Together, the data indicate that changing source strength, by manipulating photosynthesis and photorespiration, by varying the leaf temperature had a more profound effect on leaf export than manipulating sink activity.     

Responses to elevated CO2 of Flaveria linearis plants having a reduced activity of cytosolic fructose-1,6-bisphosphatase

Wide variation exists in the growth responses of C₃ plants to elevated CO₂ levels. To investigate the role of photosynthetic feedback in this phenomenon, photosynthetic parameters and growth were measured for lines of Flaveria linearis with low, intermediate or high cytosolic fructose-1,6-bisphosphatase (cytFBPase) activity when grown at either 35 or 65 Pa CO₂. The effects of pot size on the responses of these lines to elevated CO₂ were also examined. Photosynthesis and growth of plants with low cytFBPase activity were less responsive to elevated CO₂, and these plants had a reduced maximum potential for photosynthesis and growth. Plants with intermediate cytFBPase activity also showed a lower relative growth enhancement when grown at 65 Pa CO₂. There was a significant pot size effect on photosynthesis and growth for line 85-1 (high cytFBPase). This effect was greatest for line 85-1 when grown at 35 Pa CO₂, since these plants showed the greatest downward acclimation of photosynthesis when grown in small pots. There was a minimal pot size effect for line 84-9 (low cytFBPase), and this could be partly attributed to the reduced CO₂ sensitivity of this line. It is proposed that the capacity for sucrose synthesis in C₃, plants is partly responsible for their wide variation in CO₂ responsiveness.     

Interaction of elevated CO2 and O3 on growth, photosynthesis and respiration of three perennial species grown in low and high nitrogen

Seedlings of three species native to central North America, a C₃ tree, Populus tremuloides Michx., a C₃ grass, Agropyron smithii Rybd., and a C₄ grass, Bouteloua curtipendula Michx., were grown in all eight combinations of two levels each of CO₂, O₃ and nitrogen (N) for 58 days in a controlled environment. Treatment levels consisted of 360 or 674 μmol mol^-1 CO₂, 3 or 92 nmol mol^-1 O₃, and 0.5 or 6.0 m M N. In situ photosynthesis and relative growth rate (RGR) and its determinants were obtained at each of three sequential harvests, and leaf dark respiration was measured at the second and third harvests. In all three species, plants grown in high N had significantly greater whole-plant mass, RGR and photosynthesis than plants grown in low N. Within a N treatment, elevated CO₂ did not significantly enhance any of these parameters nor did it affect leaf respiration. However, plants of all three species grown in elevated CO₂ had lower stomatal conductance compared to ambient CO₂-exposed plants. Seedlings of P. tremuloides (in both N treatments) and B. curtipendula (in high N) had significant ozone-induced reductions in whole-plant mass and RGR in ambient but not under elevated CO_2. This negative O₃ impact on RGR in ambient CO₂ was related to increased leaf dark respiration, decreased photosynthesis and/or decreased leaf area ratio, none of which were noted in high O₃ treatments in the elevated CO₂ environment. In contrast, A. smithii was marginally negatively affected by high O_3.     

CO2 and intracellular pH

Abstract The experimental determination of cytoplasmic and vacuolar pH values is discussed. Despite variation in these values evidence indicates that intracellular pH values are normally regulated within narrow limits. The regulatory mechanisms proposed involve the metabolic consumption of OH^& and the active efflux of H ⁺. The evidence for intracellular pH modification in response to CO₂ hydration and the production of HCO^?₃ and H⁺ is examined. Theoretical calculations and experimental data indicate that CO₂ concentrations as high as 5% will lower intracellular pH. Conversely, variation in CO₂ levels around atmospheric concentrations is unlikely to perturb intracellular pH. High CO₂ levels are found in bulky tissues, and flooded root systems. Evidence is presented that the slow diffusion of dissolved CO₂ compared to gaseous CO₂ results in its accumulation. It is proposed that the accumulation of respiratory CO₂ may reduce intracellular pH values when plant tissues, cells or protoplasts are maintained in a liquid culture medium. Finally, the possible role of dark CO₂ fixation and organic acid synthesis in the regulation of intracellular pH is examined.     

Two mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana that become chlorotic in atmospheres enriched with CO2

Abstract. Two nonallelic, nuclear recessive mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. which become chlorotic when grown in an atmosphere enriched to 20000 cm³ CO₂ m^-3 have been isolated. For one of the mutants, chlorosis begins at the veins and gradually spreads to the interveinal regions. A minimum photon flux density of ca 50 μmol m^-2 s^-1 is required for this response. For the other mutant, the yellowing is independent of the light intensity and begins at the basal regions of the leaves and spreads to the tips. The injurious effects of CO₂ seem to be restricted to photosynthetic tissues, since root elongation and callus growth were not inhibited by a high atmospheric CO₂ concentration for either mutant. Neither mutant became chlorotic in a low O₂ atmosphere that suppressed photorespiration as effectively as the elevated CO₂ does. Thus, the mutations do not impose a requirement for photorespiration. The possibilities that the high CO₂-sensitive phenotypes are caused by an effect of CO₂ in stomata, on ethylene synthesis, or on mineral uptake are discussed but are considered unlikely.     

RuBPCO kinetics and the mechanism of CO2 entry in C3 plants

Abstract. The CO₂ partial pressure in the chloroplasts of intact photosynthetic C₃ leaves is thought to be less than the intercellular CO₂ partial pressure. The intercellular CO₂ partial pressure can be calculated from CO₂ and H₂O gas exchange measurements, whereas the CO₂ partial pressure in the chloroplasts is unknown. The conductance of CO₂ from the intercellular space to the chloroplast stroma and the CO₂ partial pressure in the chloroplast stroma can be calculated if the properties of photosynthetic gas exchange are compared with the kinetics of the enzyme ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (RuBPCO). A discrepancy between gas exchange and RuBPCO kinetics can be attributed to a deviation of CO₂ partial pressure in the chloroplast stroma from that calculated in the intercellular space. This paper is concerned with the following: estimation of the kinetic constants of RuBPCO and their comparison with the CO₂ compensation concentration; their comparison with differential uptake of ¹⁴CO₂ and ¹²CO₂; and their comparison with O₂ dependence of net CO₂ uptake of photosynthetic leaves. Discrepancy between RuBPCO kinetics and gas exchange was found at a temperature of 12.5 °C, a photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) of 550 μmol quanta m^?2 s^?1, and an ambient CO₂ partial pressure of 40 Pa. Consistency between RuBPCO kinetics and gas exchange was found if CO₂ partial pressure was decreased, temperature incresed and PPFD decreased. The results suggest that a discrepancy between RuBPCO kinetics and gas exchange is due to a diffusion resistance for CO₂ across the chloroplast envelope which decreases with increasing temperature. At low CO₂ partial pressure, the diffusion resistance appears to be counterbalanced by active CO₂ (or HCO₃) transport with high affinity and low maximum velocity. At low PPFD, CO₂ partial pressure in the chloroplast stroma appears to be in equilibrium with that in the intercellular space due to low CO₂ flux.     

Increased photosynthetic capacity of Scirpus olneyi after 4 years of exposure to elevated CO2

Abstract. While a short-term exposure to elevated atmospheric CO₂ induces a large increase in photosynthesis in many plants, long-term growth in elevated CO₂ often results in a smaller increase due to reduced photosynthetic capacity. In this study, it was shown that, for a wild C₃ species growing in its natural environment and exposed to elevated CO₂ for four growing seasons, the photosynthetic capacity has actually increased by 31%. An increase in photosynthetic capacity has been observed in other species growing in the field, which suggests that photosynthesis of certain field grown plants will continue to respond to elevated levels of atmospheric CO₂     

The respiratory source of CO2

Abstract Approximately half of the carbon plants fix in photosynthesis is lost in dark respiration. The major pathways for dark respiration and their control are briefly discussed in the context of a growing plant. It is suggested that whole-plant respiration may be largely ADP-limited and that fine control of the respiratory network serves to select the respiratory substrate and to partition carbon between the numerous possible fates within the network. The striking stoichiometry between whole-plant growth and respiration is reviewed, and the relationships between substrate-limited growth and ADP-limited respiration are discussed.