Natural cytotoxic cells and tumor necrosis factor activate similar lytic mechanisms

The lytic activity of natural cytotoxic (NC) cells has several characteristics which clearly distinguish it from other cell-mediated lytic activities and from most soluble cytolytic factors. An exception is the lytic activity mediated by tumor necrosis factor (TNF). In this paper, we report a detailed comparison of NC and TNF lysis of target cells which are used as prototype NC targets or TNF targets, and show that the two cytolytic activities have very similar, if not identical, lytic mechanisms. We present data showing that target cells which are NC-sensitive are also TNF-sensitive and that target cells which are NC-resistant are also TNF-resistant. Moreover, cells selected either in vivo or in vitro for NC resistance are selected for TNF resistance, and cells selected for TNF resistance are selected for NC resistance. The analysis of the kinetics of 51Cr release mediated by NC cells or by TNF show that both activities affect similar kinetics, in that there is no cell lysis for several hours after targets and effectors first interact. However, NC and TNF lytic activities can be distinguished. By using the cell lines 10ME or B/C-N as targets, it can be shown that whereas NC-mediated lysis is dependent on protein synthesis, TNF-mediated lysis is not. We also show that targets which are resistant to NC-mediated lysis because they express a protein synthesis-dependent resistance mechanism also require protein synthesis to resist TNF-mediated lysis, suggesting that the same resistance mechanism protects cells against both NC cells and TNF. Together, these data strongly support the hypothesis that NC cells and TNF activate the same lytic mechanism within target cells and that TNF may mediate the lytic activity of NC effector cells.     

Differences in the tumor necrosis factor-alpha-mediated lysis by fixed natural cytotoxic cells and fixed cytotoxic macrophages

TNF-alpha has been shown to be associated with macrophage cell membranes in such a way as to retain cytolytic activity despite fixation of the macrophage effector cells with paraformaldehyde. In this paper we report that, similar to cytotoxic macrophages, natural cytotoxic (NC) cells also use cell-associated TNF to lyse sensitive target cells. However, in contrast to fixed cytotoxic macrophages, NC cells do not retain cytolytic activity after fixation with paraformaldehyde. Additionally, the cytolytic activity of paraformaldehyde-fixed NC cells is not increased by incubation with LPS or by incubation with rTNF before fixation. Western blot analysis indicates that, unlike macrophages, NC cells use a smaller (17 kDa) constitutively active form of TNF. These results indicate that, although both macrophages and NC cells use effector cell-associated TNF to mediate lysis of sensitive targets, the way in which TNF is associated with these two types of effector cells must be different.     

Humans express natural cytotoxic (NC) cell activity that is similar to murine NC cell activity

The expression of natural cytotoxic (NC) activity is well defined in mice, but poorly defined in humans. In this paper we report that humans express naturally occurring cytotoxic cell activity that recognizes and lyses murine targets that are sensitive to lysis mediated by murine NC cells, but not murine targets that are resistant to lysis by murine NC cells. We present data showing that these naturally occurring human cytotoxic cells and murine NC cells have similar lytic mechanisms. Both the human cytotoxic cells described here, and murine NC cells, use tumor necrosis factor (TNF) to mediate the lysis of sensitive targets. Moreover, targets that resist murine NC-mediated lysis by a protein synthesis-dependent post-recognitive mechanism use a similar mechanism to prevent lysis mediated by naturally occurring human cytotoxic cells. In addition to the similarity of naturally occurring human cytotoxic cells and murine NC cells in their specificity and lytic mechanism, naturally occurring human cytotoxic cells and murine NC cells are also similar in that their activity is both associated with a monocyte lineage and age independent. Taken together, these data indicate that humans express NC activity.     

Resistance of primary CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes to lysis by cytotoxic granules from cloned T cell lines

Recent evidence has shown that cloned, murine CTL cell lines are resistant to the cytotoxic components of the toxic granules they release upon specific interaction with their target cells. Inasmuch as the resistance might be due to selection in culture over many months by repeated exposure to these cytolytic components (which are released repeatedly as a result of the cultured CTL being periodically stimulated by target cells), we asked whether primary CTL are also resistant. The primary CTL were elicited in vivo by i.p. injection of allogeneic tumor cells or in vitro by 5- to 6-day MLC or by 48-h exposure to the lectin Con A. The responding cells were separated into purified CD8+ (i.e., CD4-, CD8+) and purified CD4+ (i.e., CD4+, CD8-) T cell populations that were analyzed for cytolytic activity and for resistance to lysis by toxic secretory granules derived from cloned CTL cell lines. The CD8+ T cells were highly cytolytic and relatively resistant; they retained their cytolytic activity and were lysed to a minimal extent (0 to 10%) by quantities of isolated granules that lysed 80 to 90% of the P815 tumor cell line (tested as a representative standard cell line). The CD4+ T cells, in contrast, had only minimal cytolytic activity and were far more susceptible to granule-mediated lysis. Although the resistance of primary CD8+ T cells is impressive, it is not as pronounced as the resistance of the cloned CTL cell lines, indicating that during long-term culture there is some selection for increased resistance to granule-mediated lysis. In contrast to T cells (especially CD8+ T cells), Ia+ macrophages, isolated from primary immune peritoneal exudates, were highly susceptible to granule-mediated lysis.     

In vivo or in vitro selection for resistance to natural cytotoxic cell lysis selects for variants with increased tumorigenicity

Experiments were designed to test the hypothesis that transformed cells that are NC sensitive must escape NC activity if they are to grow as tumors in normal individuals. NC-resistant variants were selected either in vivo or in vitro from NC-sensitive cell lines that grow as tumors in immunodeficient mice but not in syngeneic normal mice. The tumorigenicity of cloned NC-resistant variants was compared with the parental cell lines and to cell lines that went through the selection procedure, but after cloning remained NC sensitive. Cloned NC-resistant cell lines derived from tumors that developed in x-irradiated nude mice after the injection of an NC-sensitive cell line are tumorigenic in normal mice, whereas cloned NC-sensitive cell lines derived from the same tumors are unable to grow as tumors in normal mice. Similarly, six of seven NC-resistant cloned cell lines independently isolated after in vitro selection for NC-resistance are tumorigenic in normal mice, whereas cloned NC-sensitive cell lines isolated from the same in vitro selected populations are not tumorigenic in normal mice. Thus, either the in vivo or in vitro selection of NC-resistant cells selects for cells tumorigenic in normal mice; these findings, along with our previous observations that selection for cells tumorigenic in normal mice selects for NC resistance, provide compelling evidence that escape from NC activity is required before some transformed cells can grow as tumors in normal mice.     

Tumor growth in vivo selects for resistance to tumor necrosis factor

The relationship between in vivo tumor growth and resistance to TNF in WEHI-164 cells has been examined. When a highly TNF-sensitive clone of WEHI-164 was grown in vivo in syngeneic mice it became resistant to rTNF such that a 4 to 5 log higher concentration of TNF was required to produce tumor lysis in vitro. When compared with an in vitro selected TNF-resistant variant, the in vivo selected line was significantly more tumorigenic. The resistant phenotype of both the in vivo and in vitro selected variants was stable in culture and both selected lines were also resistant to lysis by syngeneic spleen cells with natural cytotoxic activity. The parental clone and the two variants were equally sensitive to lysis by allo-CTL and expressed similar levels of MHC class I Ag. Resistance to TNF in the two variants was not a function of de novo production of TNF measured as supernatant TNF activity or TNF mRNA expression. These studies are the first to demonstrate that in vivo tumor growth results in resistance to TNF and therefore may have direct relevance to the efficacy of TNF in the treatment of human neoplasms.     

Tumorigenicity of persistently infected tumors in nude mice is a function of both virus and host cell type.

Although BHK-21 cells persistently infected with wild-type vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) are sensitive to natural killer (NK) cells and do not form tumors in athymic nude mice, BHK-21 cells persistently infected with a previously isolated mutant virus (VSV-P) are resistant to NK cells and form tumors in nude mice. We used this VSV-P mutant to persistently infect HeLa cells and mouse tumor cell lines. A mouse mastocytoma line (P815) persistently infected with VSV-P was similar to BHK-21 cells in that it was resistant to NK cell lysis and formed tumors in nude mice. However, neither HeLa cells nor mouse myeloma lines persistently infected with VSV-P were resistant to NK cell lysis in vitro, and neither formed tumors in nude mice. Rejection by nude mice of HeLa cells and mouse myeloma cell lines persistently infected with VSV-P could be ablated by rabbit antiserum to asialo-GM1, implicating NK cells in the in vivo rejection of these persistently infected tumors. These results suggest that NK cell recognition and killing of virus-infected cells in vivo and in vitro depend upon genetic contributions from both the virus and the host cell.     

Increased sensitivity to MHC-nonrestricted lysis of BL6 melanoma cells by transfection with class I H-2Kb gene

An H-2Kb- negative clone of BL6 melanoma (BL6-8) was transfected with neor, H-2Kb, or H-2IAk genes. In an 18-h cytotoxicity assay clones with high levels of H-2Kb Ag expression were found more sensitive to lysis by spleen cells of syngenic and allogeneic mice than H-2Kb low clones. NK cells were involved in the lysis of H-2Kb+ BL6 melanoma clones, with spleen cell cytotoxicity of mice increased after poly I:C stimulation or decreased after pretreatment with anti-asialo GM1 serum or NK1.1 mAb. Anti-TNF Ab were also able to reduce the cytotoxicity of normal spleen cells and completely abolished the cytotoxicity of the NK-depleted spleen cells suggesting involvement of NC cells in lysis of H-2Kb+ BL6 melanoma clones. Increase in sensitivity of H-2Kb+ BL6 cells to natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity was associated with the appearance of NK recognizable determinants as assessed by the cold target inhibition assay. All BL6 clones, irrespective of sensitivity to natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity, showed high sensitivity to lysis by LGL-derived granules. In contrast, all H-2Kb low BL6 clones were resistant and all H-2Kb highly positive clones were sensitive to lysis by TNF-alpha. When an H-2Kb highly positive clone was selected in vitro for resistance to TNF, it concomitantly showed increased resistance to cytotoxicity by spleen cells, confirming the importance of TNF in spleen cell cytotoxicity against H-2Kb+ melanoma cells. Taken together, the data indicate that class I H-2Kb but not class II H-2IAk gene product could increase the sensitivity of BL6 cells to lysis by NK and natural cytotoxic cells as well as TNF. We hypothesize that these effects could be due to pleiotropic effects of H-2Kb gene products on various biologic properties of BL6 melanoma cells some of which may be more directly involved in regulation of tumor cell sensitivity to lysis by NK and/or natural cytotoxic cells.     

Cytolytic activities of activated macrophages versus paraformaldehyde-fixed macrophages; soluble versus membrane-associated TNF.

Membrane-associated tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and soluble TNF were compared as to their lytic activities, and as to the kinetics of their expression by macrophages activated with LPS and/or IFN-gamma in the presence or absence of cycloheximide. EL 4 tumor cells, resistant and sensitive to lysis by recombinant TNF or membrane-associated TNF (paraformaldehyde (PF)-fixed activated macrophages) were used as targets. In the presence of cycloheximide the TNF-resistant S-EL4 cells were lysed by both TNFs. PF-fixed macrophages was cytolytic after 1 hr activation but not after 3 or more hours of activation. Their activity was totally inhibited by anti-TNF antibodies and was a composite of transmembrane (integral) TNF and soluble TNF conjugated to macrophage membrane TNF receptors. Treatment of the macrophages with glycine pH 3.0 buffer dissociated the conjugated TNF without affecting the integral membrane TNF. When macrophages were activated with LPS +/- IFN-gamma in the presence of cycloheximide or activated just with IFN-gamma their activity after fixation with paraformaldehyde was no longer detected. Nonfixed macrophages under these conditions still remained cytotoxic. Tumor cell susceptibility to membrane-associated TNF activity, in contrast to recombinant (soluble) TNF, was greatly reduced in the presence of nicotinamide, an inhibitor of ADP-ribosyltransferase, suggesting that the mechanisms of lysis by these TNFs may be different. The lytic activity of both TNFs was found to be receptor-dependent in that tumor cells, whose TNF binding sites were "down-regulated" by TPA, were rendered resistant to lysis by both membrane-associated and soluble TNFs.     

Cell-mediated and glucocorticoid-mediated target cell lysis do not appear to share common pathways

Target cell lysis by cytolyic lymphocytes follows a sequence of events that culminate in osmotic destruction of the target. Although it is clear that killer cell derived components play a crucial role in target cell lysis it is not clear to what extent the target itself is involved in its destruction. Recent observations have pointed to the possibility that glucocorticoid mediated and cell mediated lysis may utilize common pathways of cell lysis. In analyzing this question we found that cell lines that have nonfunctional glucocorticoid receptors like S49-78 and S49-88 are good targets for both NK and thymus-derived killer (TK) cells. Cell lines that are glucocorticoid sensitive such as Q1(4)6 are sensitive to NK-mediated lysis as its derivative HL4-6-3 which contains glucocorticoid receptors but is glucocorticoid resistant. An intriguing exception to this is the glucocorticoid-resistant mutant S49-4RD which is relatively resistant to both NK and TK lysis compared with parent S49. The resistance of S49-4RD to cell-mediated lysis we show here is most likely due to a defect in the target which results in its failure to trigger the cytolytic machinery in the killer cell rather than in its resistance to lysis per se. In support of this we demonstrate that lysis of S49-4RD by cytolytic granules from TK cells is normal. Moreover TK cells lyse S49-4RD as efficiently as its parent in the presence of the lectin Con A. The conclusion that S49-4RD has a defect in its ability to induce killer cells to initiate the cytolytic reaction is also in agreement with the finding that TK-S49-4RD conjugates show inefficient reorientation of the Golgi apparatus in the effector.     

Helper factor(s) augment in vitro induction of tumor-specific immunity

Helper factor supernatants derived from alloantigen-activated murine lymphocytes augment the generation of cytolytic effector cells to syngeneic tumor cells. The effects are dose dependent and vary with the syngeneic tumor cell system studied. The effector cells are specific for the tumor-associated antigen(s) utilized for their induction, and are sensitive to lysis with anti-T-cell serum (Thy 1.2), but are insensitive to lysis with an allogeneic anti-NK-cell serum. The helper factor supernatants also augment the production of a “tissue-culture-induced” cytolytic cell (cultured NK cell), which is resistant to treatment with both anti-Thy 1.2 and anti-NK serum.     

Thymic lymphomas mediate non-MHC-restricted, TNF-dependent lysis of the murine sarcoma WEHI-164

Tumor necrosis factor (TNF), lyses a range of sensitive tumor targets and has been shown to be the mediator of natural cytotoxic (NC) activity first described in our laboratory. In this report, we identify two thymic lymphoma cell lines which lyse the prototype NC target WEHI-164 and share characteristics of NC. R1.1E and L5178-27av lyse the WEHI-164 sarcoma in 18-hr 51Cr release assays via a TNF-dependent, non-MHC-restricted (R1.1E) mechanism although they do not constitutively produce TNF. NC- and TNF-resistant variants of WEHI-164 are resistant to lymphoma-mediated lysis. Expression of the ganglioside GD3 by the lymphomas correlates with their relative levels of lysis. Thus, GD3, which is known to have a role in T cell activation may be involved in recognition or triggering for TNF-dependent cell-mediated lysis.     

Evidence for the involvement of cytolytic macrophages in rejection of SV40-induced tumors

The potential role of cytolytic macrophages in in vivo resistance to tumors induced by simian virus 40 (SV40) was evaluated in two experimental systems. First, a cell line produced by sequential in vivo passage of SV40-transformed fibroblasts through syngeneic C3H/HeJ mice was found to develop both increased neoplastic character and resistance to macrophage-mediated lysis, suggesting in vivo selection pressure against the macrophage-sensitive phenotype. In the second approach, SV40-transformed cells from C3H.OL mice, a strain that fails to produce SV40-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL), were cloned, and the cloned cells were tested for susceptibility to macrophage cytolysis in vitro. Two clones SV-COL-E8 and SV-COL-F5, which represent the extremes of macrophage susceptibility and resistance, respectively, were tested for progressive growth in syngeneic C3H.OL recipients. Progression in vivo was found to correlate with resistance to macrophage cytolysis in vitro. Other in vitro measures of the neoplastic phenotype, cell division rate and anchorage-independent growth, did not predict the relative abilities of clones E8 and F5 to form tumors. Likewise, the cells were indistinguishable in their sensitivity to cytolysis by allogeneic CTL and by natural killer cells. Finally, the presence of activated macrophages in the peritoneum of mice rejecting a challenge of syngeneic SV40-transformed cells was confirmed in both CTL responder and nonresponder strains. These studies suggest that cytolytic macrophages are indeed generated during rejection of SV40-induced mouse tumors and that, in the absence of an effective anti-SV40 CTL response, resistance of the transformed cell to macrophage-mediated cytolysis can be a determining factor in in vivo tumor growth.     

Cytostatic and cytolytic effects of human recombinant tumor necrosis factor on human renal cell carcinoma cell lines derived from a single surgical specimen

The purpose of this study was to determine whether human tumor cell lines derived from a single tumor exhibit heterogeneous responses to the anti-tumor effects of human recombinant tumor necrosis factor (h-r-TNF). Several cell lines with different metastatic propensities have been established in culture from a single surgical specimen of a human renal cell carcinoma following different selection procedures in nude mice. The cell lines exhibited significant differences in in vitro susceptibilities to cytotoxic effects of TNF. Kinetic analysis of the interaction of TNF with susceptible renal carcinoma cells demonstrated that a short 30 min interaction of TNF with the cells is sufficient to produce significant lysis 72 hr later. One cycle of exposure of sensitive cells to h-r-TNF did not produce cells resistant to it, nor did the degree of sensitivity to h-r-TNF vary after one passage of the cells in nude mice. Tumor cell resistance to the effects of TNF did develop spontaneously after prolonged cultivation in culture. We conclude that tumor cells derived from a single human renal cell carcinoma exhibit a heterogeneous response to the cytotoxic effects of h-r-TNF.     

In vitro selection of a cell line for resistance to lysis by tumor necrosis factor-alpha selects for reduced tumorigenicity

Experimentally, TNF-alpha can mediate the hemorrhagic necrosis of certain tumors. Furthermore, evidence indicates that natural cytotoxic (NC) activity, a cell-mediated cytolytic activity that utilizes TNF-alpha in the lysis of target cells, is involved in preventing the outgrowth of certain NC/TNF-alpha-sensitive tumor cells. These observations raise the issue of whether soluble TNF-alpha normally serves as a tumor surveillance mechanism preventing the outgrowth of some tumors. To address this issue, we have used TNF-alpha to select TNF-alpha-resistant variants from the NC/TNF-alpha-sensitive mouse fibroblast cell line 10ME. Previously, we have demonstrated that 10ME is tumorigenic in immune-deficient mice but fails to form tumors in normal mice. Moreover, selection of NC-resistant variants from 10ME selects for both TNF-alpha resistance and tumorigenicity in normal mice. As cells that have been selected for NC resistance form tumors in normal mice, whereas the NC-sensitive parental cell line does not, it seems that escape from NC activity is sufficient to significantly increase the tumorigenic potential of the cell line. We show that the selection with TNF-alpha, although associated with NC resistance, does not increase the tumorigenic potential of 10ME cells but reduces it. Thus, NC activity appears to function as a mechanism to prevent tumor formation, and escape from NC activity allows for tumor formation; TNF-alpha does not have similar activity. Moreover, this suggests that NC activity is not equivalent to soluble TNF-alpha activity, but utilizes TNF-alpha more efficiently than soluble TNF-alpha, or NC activity involves both TNF-alpha and other effector mechanisms.     

Ultraviolet light-induced increase in tumor cell susceptibility to TNF-dependent and TNF-independent natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity

Previously we demonstrated that two consecutive in vitro irradiations of MCA 102 cells with high doses of UVC light (610 and 457 J/m2) resulted in a selection of a permanent line MCA 102UV that manifested high sensitivity to natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity (NCMC). In the present study analysis of the effector cells involved in lysis of these tumor cells was performed by comparing the cytotoxicity of normal spleen cells which mediated both NK and NC cell activity with (a) normal spleen cells in which NC activity was neutralized by anti-TNF Abs (NK+,NC-), (b) NK-depleted or NK-deficient spleen cells (NK-,NC+), and (c) NK-deficient or -depleted spleen cells with NC activity neutralized by anti-TNF Abs (NK-,NC-). Results of these studies indicate that lysis of the original MCA 102 tumor cells was relatively low and was mediated by NC cells. UV irradiation significantly increased MCA 102 tumor cell sensitivity to lysis by both NK and NC cells. Analysis of the mechanisms involved in UV-induced NK sensitivity revealed that UV irradiation increased tumor cell susceptibility to lytic NK-derived granules. NC sensitivity of MCA 102UV tumor cells was associated with their increase in sensitivity to TNF and selection of MCA 102UV cells for resistance to rTNF resulted in a decrease in their susceptibility to NC cells. To determine how fast UV-induced sensitivity to NCMC and rTNF can be established, 51Cr-labeled MCA 102 cells were irradiated in vitro with 38-304 J/m2 of UVC light and their sensitivity to lysis by spleen cells and rTNF was tested immediately in an 18-hr cytotoxicity assay. UV treatment with the same doses was repeated 12 days later. The data obtained showed that tumor cell sensitivity to NCMC and TNF appeared shortly after UV irradiation, was stable, and was further substantially augmented by the second round of UV treatment. Thus, in vitro UV irradiation of tumor cells could be an effective modulator of tumor cell sensitivity to TNF-dependent and TNF-independent cell-mediated cytotoxicity.     

Mechanism of cytolytic T lymphocyte killing of a low class I-expressing tumor

Many tumors have been shown to express minimal levels of class I MHC Ag, which makes them more resistant to recognition and lysis by cytolytic T lymphocytes. Line 1, a BALB/c spontaneous lung carcinoma, normally expresses very low levels of class I Ag, but expression can be increased 50-fold by treatment with agents such as DMSO or IFN-gamma. Because class I Ag serve as restricting elements for cytolytic T cell recognition of tumor Ag, we wished to determine if cytotoxic T lymphocytes could play a role in the immune response to this type of class I low, but inducible, tumor. After immunization in vivo and restimulation of splenic cells in vitro we were able to generate T cell clones that lysed line 1 cells induced to express high levels of class I, but did not lyse uninduced, low class I expressing line 1 cells in short term (6-h) 51Cr release assays. Paradoxically, incubation of the T cells with uninduced class I low line 1 cells for a few days resulted in complete destruction of the tumor cells. We demonstrate that the T cells, stimulated by the tumor cells, produce IFN-gamma, which in turn induces class I expression on the line 1 cells making them susceptible to lysis by the T cell clone. This suggests that a positive feedback reaction can occur in generating a response to this and perhaps other inducible tumor cell lines.     

Biochemical and molecular characterization of the glucocorticoid receptor of lymphosarcoma P1798 variants

Three phenotypically distinct isolates from lymphosarcoma P1798 have been compared with respect to properties of the glucocorticoid receptor. Wild type P1798 cells express functional receptors and glucocorticoid treatment of such cells causes cytolysis in vivo. Wild type cells do not undergo cytolysis in culture. Rather, such cells exhibit reversible inhibition of proliferation in the presence of dexamethasone. Two variant populations were selected from this background. One was selected for the ability to form tumors in mice receiving pharmacological doses of glucocorticoids. Cells from such tumors are resistant to the cytolytic effects of glucocorticoids in vivo, but are sensitive to the antiproliferative effects of the hormone in culture. Variants were also selected based upon their ability to proliferate in the presence of dexamethasone in culture. These variants were resistant to glucocorticoid-mediated cytolysis in vivo. Wild type P1798 cells express approximately 20,000 high affinity dexamethasone-binding sites per cell. Dexamethasone-mesylate labeling and immunoblotting experiments indicate that hormone binding is due to a polypeptide of Mr 90-100 K. This polypeptide is encoded in an mRNA species that resolved as a single entity of approximately 7000 nucleotides. Variants selected for resistance to cytolysis in vivo are indistinguishable in any of these respects from wild type cells. The receptors are fully functional, as evidenced by their ability to precipitate growth arrest of dexamethasone-treated cultures. Variants selected for resistance in culture harbor a receptor mutation. They express fewer than 500 dexamethasone-binding sites per cell. Such variants contain neither detectable dexamethasone-mesylate-binding protein nor any protein that is recognized by a receptor antibody.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Natural immunity to grafts of FLD-3 erythroleukemia cells by irradiated mice

Mice were irradiated and infused with BALB/c Friend virus-induced FLD-3 erythroleukemia cells. Growth of the cells was estimated by measuring splenic incorporation of 5-iodo-2'-deoxyuridine-125I 5 days after cell transfer. BALB/cJ and C3H mice were 'poor responders' in that FLD-3 cells grew well in their spleens, while mice of other strains were 'good responders', resisting the growth of FLD-3 cells. No H-2 or Fv genetic locus was associated with resistance. Athymic nude mice and mice depleted of marrow tissue by 89Sr or estradiol resisted FLD-3 cells, indicating that the effectors were thymus- and marrow-independent. Silica, carrageenan and Propionibacterium acnes organisms all altered resistance, suggesting a function of macrophages. Neither interferon nor anti-interferon serum treatment altered resistance. Anti-asialo GM1 serum inhibited resistance to FLD-3 cells in vivo and inhibited natural cytotoxic (NC) activity against FLD-3 cells in vitro. NC (FLD-3) activity was greatly decreased in spleens 3 days after irradiation, in contrast with NK (YAC-1) and NC(WEHI-164.1) activities. Moreover, a 3-day delay in infusion of FLD-3 cells 'synergized' with silica in weakening genetic resistance in vivo. Thus, natural immunity to FLD-3 cells in vivo differs from that of genetic resistance to normal bone marrow cell allografts, and the lysis of FLD-3 cells in vitro seems to be mediated by cells which do not easily fit into the definition of natural killer (NK) or natural cytotoxic (NC) cells.