Increased Ethylene Production during Clinostat Experiments May Cause Leaf Epinasty

Ethylene production from tomato (Lycopersicum esculentum L. cv. Rutgers) plants based on a clinostat doubled during the first 2 hours of rotation. Carbon dioxide blocked the appearance of leaf epinasty normally associated with plants rotated on a clinostat. These results support the idea that epinasty of clinostated plants was due to increased ethylene production and not to the cancellation of the gravitational pull on auxin transport in the petiole.     

Ethylene as a Cause of Transient Petiole Epinasty in Helianthus annuus during Clinostat Experiments

Petiole curvature and elongation growth in Helianthus annuus L. have been recorded for plants rotating with their stems parallel to the horizontal axis of a clinostat at 8 revolutions per hour over 72 hours. When rotation was continuous, dorso-convex curvature (epinasty) developed in the first 12 hours and was followed by recovery (straightening) in the next 36 hours. Thereafter the petioles remained straight. These changes in shape are due to brief consecutive increases in the elongation growth of the upper and lower halves of the petiole. Plants exposed to 10 μl per liter ethylene after 200 hours on the clinostat, developed similar petiole epinasty, followed by straightening when the exposure to ethylene ceased. Interrupting rotation of the plant for 1 hour in 4, did not change the petiole response, whereas the alternation of 4 hour stationary and rotation periods, delayed the straightening process. The axillary angle between the stem and petiole increased from about 40° to 63° during either continuous rotation or rotation with 1 or 4 hour stationary periods. When detached leaves were inverted, the rate of ethylene release approximately doubled after 4 hours and continued to increase thereafter. The results indicate that the development of transient petiole epinasty on the clinostat, is due to ethylene production caused primarily by the disorientation of the plant, rather than to the rotation process.     

Gravity can induce epinastic bending of isolated leaves

Abstract Isolated leaves of Plectranthus fruticosus were grown in cubic plastic cuvettes, and were supplied via their cut petioles with nutrient solution and indole-3-acetic acid (10^?6m ). Holes bored in the cuvette walls allowed the petioles to be oriented at approximately 60°, 90° or 120° to the vertical. Growth of the leaves initially oriented at angles of 60° and 90°, which simulated the situation in the intact plant, did not result in epinastic bending of the petiole. Inversion of the leaves (adaxial surface of the petiole downwards) and orientation of the adaxial/abaxial surfaces of the horizontal petiole parallel to the gravity vector, however, yielded strong epinastic bending of the petioles. In the latter case, this bending was not in the direction of the gravity vector (evidence for point (iii), below). Furthermore, epinastic bending occurred, when the isolated leaves were rotated on a clinostat (petioles parallel to the rotation axis or inclined to the rotation axis at an angle of 30°; 3 r.p.m.). Since a possible influence of the shoot was excluded, it is concluded that (i) perception and response are restricted to the leaf, (ii) gravity alone is sufficient to induce epinasty, (iii) a gravitropic component of the response can probably be excluded. The clinostat induced epinasty may not have been caused by nullifying the effect of gravity but due to continuous gravistimulation of the leaf.     

Gravitropism in Higher Plant Shoots: I. A ROLE FOR ETHYLENE

It has long been known that applied ethylene can redirect the gravitropic response, but only occasionally has it been suggested that ethylene normally plays a role in gravitropism. Two inhibitors of ethylene synthesis [Co²⁺ and aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG)] and two inhibitors of ethylene action (Ag⁺ and CO₂) were shown to delay the gravitropic response of cocklebur (Xanthium strumarium L.), tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.), and castor bean (Ricinus communis L.) stems. Gentle shaking on a mechanical shaker does not inhibit the gravitropic response, but vigorous hand shaking for 120 seconds delays the response somewhat. AVG and Ag⁺ further delay the response of mechanically stimulated plants. AVG delays the response of defoliated and of decapitated plants. Plants laid on their side and restricted so that they cannot bend upward store both bending energy and gravitropic stimulus; they bend immediately when released from restriction (stored energy) and continue to bend for some hours after (stored stimulus). AVG retards the storage of bending energy but not of stimulus. In gravitropism, graviperception may first stimulate ethylene evolution, which may then influence bending directly, or responses involving ethylene could be more indirect.     

Choice of rotation rate for the horizontal clinostat

A series of nine rates of rotation of the clinostat were tested to determine optimal and acceptable conditions for simulating weightlessness in plants. Young seedlings of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) developed roots and coleoptiles of equal lengths and with the same orientation angles over a range of rotation rates from 0.25 to 480 minutes per revolution. Rates from 0.25 to 3 minutes per revolution provided for maximal epinastic curvatures of leaves and branches of Coleus blumei Benth. except for a reduced mean curvature of branches at 0.25 minute per revolution, due probably to physical disturbances in their growth. Smaller epinastic curvatures developed in both leaves and branches rotated at 15 minutes per revolution or more slowly. Indoleacetic acid-2-¹⁴C was used for measurements of extractable radioactivity in determining the reason for smaller curvatures of Coleus branches and tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) leaves at the rotation rate of 60 minutes per revolution than at 1 minute per revolution. The cause was determined to be movement of some auxin from the upper into the lower side of a plagiotropic leaf or branch under the transient influence of gravity during rotation on the slower clinostat. A rotation period of 1 to 3 minutes was found to be acceptable for most plants.     

Growth and epinasty of marigold plants maintained from emergence on horizontal clinostats

Dry weight, leaf number, and leaf size of marigold plants (Tagetes patula) grown from emergence for 18 days on horizontal clinostats rotating at 15 revolutions per hour (rph), were similar to those of plants grown for the same period on vertically oriented clinostats rotating at 15 rph. The horizontally grown plants exhibited some epinasty which disappeared when plants were placed upright for 24 hours. Vertically grown plants when placed on horizontal clinostats for 24 hours exhibited more epinasty than plants grown from emergence on horizontal clinostats.

Data are provided to demonstrate that leaves undergo movement (bending) during each rotation cycle that leads to the development of a leaf curvature that is oriented away from the direction of rotation. The results of this study suggest that epinasty of plants placed on horizontal clinostats could be due to uncontrolled movement of plants during rotation rather than controlled by gravity nullification. The usefulness of horizontal clinostats for gravity nullification or simulating weightlessness on plants is questioned.

     

The Role of Gravity in Apical Dominance : Effects of Clinostating on Shoot Inversion-Induced Ethylene Production, Shoot Elongation, and Lateral Bud Growth

Shoot inversion-induced release of apical dominance in Pharbitis nil is inhibited by rotating the plant at 0.42 revolutions per minute in a vertical plane perpendicular to the axis of rotation of a horizontal clinostat. Clinostating prevented lateral bud outgrowth, apparently by negating the restriction of the shoot elongation via reduction of ethylene production in the inverted shoot. Radial stem expansion was also decreased. Data from experiments with intact tissue and isolated segments indicated that shoot-inversion stimulates ethylene production by increasing the activity of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid synthase. The results support the hypothesis that shoot inversion-induced release of apical dominance in Pharbitis nil is due to gravity stress and is mediated by ethylene-induced retardation of the elongation of the inverted shoot.     

Brassinosteroid-induced epinasty in tomato plants

The effects of root treatments of brassinosteroid (BR) on the growth and development of hydroponically grown tomato plants (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill cv Heinz 1350) were evaluated. There was a dramatic increase in petiole bending when the plants were treated with 0.5 to 1.0 micromolar BR. The leaf angle of the treated plants was almost three times that of untreated controls. BR-induced epinasty appeared to be due to stimulation of ethylene production. Excised petioles from BR-treated plants produced more than twice as much ethylene as did untreated controls. As ethylene production increased, the degree of petiole bending also increased, and inhibition of ethylene production by AOA or CoCl₂ also inhibited epinasty. BR-treated plants had increased levels of the ethylene precursor 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) in the leaf tissue. ACC appeared to accumulate primarily in the petioles with the greatest amount of ACC accumulating in the youngest petioles. Time course evaluations revealed that BR treatment stimulated ACC production. As ACC accumulated, ethylene increased, resulting in epinasty. Little or no ACC was found in the xylem sap, indicating that there was a signal transported from the roots which stimulated ACC synthesis in the leaf tissue.     

Failure of Ethylene to Change the Distribution of Indoleacetic Acid in the Petiole of Coleus blumei X frederici during Epinasty

The effect of ethylene on the distribution of applied indoleacetic acid in the petiole of Coleus blumei Benth. X C. frederici G. Taylor has been investigated during the development of epinastic curvature. Using intact plants, ¹⁴C-IAA was applied to the distal region of the leaf lamina and the accumulation of label in the abaxial and adaxial halves of 5 mm petiole sections was determined after 1.5, 3, and 6 hours. Over this period the label was transported out of the lamina into the petiole at a rate of at least 66 mm hr⁻¹. Of the total amount of label in the petiole sections, 24 to 30% was located in the adaxial half and this distribution was not altered significantly by exposing plants to an atmosphere containing 50 μl/l ethylene. Thus when epinastic curvature is induced by ethylene there is no associated increase in the IAA content of the expanding adaxial half. The role of endogenous IAA in petiole epinasty was studied by restricting its movement with DPX 1840 (3,3a-dihydro-2-[p-methoxyphenyl]-8H-pyrozolo{5,1-a}isoindol-8-one). The leaf petioles still showed an initial epinastic response to ethylene. It is concluded that ethylene-induced epinasty is not dependent upon either any change in the transport of IAA or its redistribution within the petiole.     

Regulation of epinasty induced by 2,4‐dichlorophenoxyacetic acid in pea and Arabidopsis plants

The herbicide 2,4‐dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4‐D) causes uncontrolled cell division and malformed growth in plants, giving rise to leaf epinasty and stem curvature. In this study, mechanisms involved in the regulation of leaf epinasty induced by 2,4‐D were studied using different chemicals involved in reactive oxygen species (ROS) accumulation (diphenyleniodonium, butylated hydroxyanisole, EDTA, allopurinol), calcium channels (LaCl₃), protein phosphorylation (cantharidin, wortmannin) and ethylene emission/perception (aminoethoxyvinyl glycine, AgNO₃). The effect of these compounds on the epinasty induced by 2,4‐D was analysed in shoots and leaf strips from pea plants. For further insight into the effect of 2,4‐D, studies were also made in Arabidopsis mutants deficient in ROS production (rbohD, rbohF, xdh), ethylene (ein 3‐1, ctr 1‐1, etr 1‐1), abscisic acid (aba 3.1), and jasmonic acid (coi 1.1, jar 1.1, opr 3) pathways. The results suggest that ROS production, mainly ·OH, is essential in the development of epinasty triggered by 2,4‐D. Epinasty was also found to be regulated by Ca²⁺, protein phosphorylation and ethylene, although all these factors act downstream of ROS production. The use of Arabidopsis mutants appears to indicate that abscisic and jasmonic acid are not involved in regulating epinasty, although they could be involved in other symptoms induced by 2,4‐D.     

Epinasty promoted by salinity or ethylene is an indicator of salt-sensitivity in tomatoes

Abstract Six genotypes of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) that differ in their salt-tolerance, were exposed to 200 mol m^?3 NaCl for 4 weeks. Seedlings exhibited a marked decline in shoot dry weight accumulation and increased petiolar epinasty after exposure to salinity stress. Ranking accessions on the basis of their relative growth reduction in response to salinity, provided good agreement with the level of epinasty promoted during the salinity treatment. In the absence of salt-stress, leaf epinasty promoted by exogenous ethylene treatment was found to be a positive indicator of the genotypes incipient salt-sensitivity. Endogenous ethylene levels in untreated plants were negatively correlated with ethephon-induced epinasty. Genotypes with normally high endogenous C₂H₄ levels were less responsive to ethephon treatment and also exhibited greater salt-tolerance than genotypes with low endogenous C₂H₄ levels. These observations are consistent with the suggestion that a main feature of adaptation in the genotypes examined may involve modulation of their cellular sensitivity to C₂H₄. The results indicate that leaf epinasty, whether salt- or ethylene-induced, is a sensitive indicator of salt-sensitivity. Ethylene-induced epinasty may, therefore, provide a simple basis upon which to identify and select salt-tolerant plants.     

Inhibition of ethylene synthesis in tomato plants subjected to anaerobic root stress

Enhanced ethylene production and leaf epinasty are characteristic responses of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) to waterlogging. It has been proposed (Bradford, Yang 1980 Plant Physiol 65: 322-326) that this results from the synthesis of the immediate precursor of ethylene, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), in the waterlogged roots, its export in the transpiration stream to the shoot, and its rapid conversion to ethylene. Inhibitors of the ethylene biosynthetic pathway are available for further testing of this ACC transport hypothesis: aminooxyacetic acid (AOA) or aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) block the synthesis of ACC, whereas CO²⁺ prevents its conversion to ethylene. AOA and AVG, supplied in the nutrient solution, were found to inhibit the synthesis and export of ACC from anaerobic roots, whereas Co²⁺ had no effect, as predicted from their respective sites of action. Transport of the inhibitors to the shoot was demonstrated by their ability to block wound ethylene synthesis in excised petioles. All three inhibitors reduced petiolar ethylene production and epinasty in anaerobically stressed tomato plants. With AOA and AVG, this was due to the prevention of ACC import from the roots as well as inhibition of ACC synthesis in the petioles. With Co²⁺, conversion of both root- and petiole-synthesized ACC to ethylene was blocked. Collectively, these data support the hypothesis that the export of ACC from low O₂ roots to the shoot is an important factor in the ethylene physiology of waterlogged tomato plants.     

WHITE PINE SHOOTS: ROLES OF GRAVITY AND EPINASTY IN MOVEMENTS AND COMPRESSION WOOD LOCATION

Pinus strobus L. trees were grown on a clinostat. Although elongating shoots moved in almost the reverse of the normal pattern, they reached a normal original angle. Compression wood (CW) formed only on the upper side of branches opposite where CW had previously formed. Neither treatments to remove epinasty (girdling branches, removing leaders and branches), nor treatments to bend branches out of position changed CW distribution. On trees grown off the clinostat, branches bending upwards after removal of the terminal formed CW on the upper side before reaching vertical. Main stems could form CW on the upper side after having been tipped to induce CW formation on the under side. It is suggested that epinasty is not involved in either early shoot movements or in compression wood location and that when gravity stimulates CW formation on the under side of a shoot it preconditions the upper side for CW formation, thus establishing an equilibrium position for the shoot.     

Prevention of salt-induced epinasty by α-aminooxyacetic acid and cobalt

Ethylene production in leaf petiole and laminae tissues was stimulated in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv. UCT5) plants exposed to salinity-stress. At the highest salinity level (250 mM NaCl), rates of ethylene production more than doubled over those observed in non-stressed plants. Correspondingly, petiolar epinasty increased with increasing levels of stress impositions. Both responses were suppressed when either 1 mM -aminooxyacetic acid (AOA), or 100 M Co²⁺ was simultaneously applied. Co²⁺, but not AOA, had a pronounced effect on ethylene production resulting from the application of a saturating dose (2 mM) of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), the immediate precursor of ethylene. This result suggests that ethylene production is dependent upon the activity of ethylene forming enzyme (EFE). The magnitude of ethylene stimulation in leaf petioles was related to the salinity level imposed and to the induction of petiole epinasty. In the absence of stress impositions, epinastic responsiveness to ethylene or its precursor, ACC, might provide a simple, indirect criteria to adjudge salt-sensitivity among plants.Research supported by AID contract II, NEB-1070-A-00-2074-00.     

Effects of root anaerobiosis on ethylene production, epinasty, and growth of tomato plants

Experiments were performed to determine the source(s) of ethylene-causing epinasty in flooded tomato plants (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.). Simultaneous measurements were made of ethylene synthesized by the roots and shoots of tomato plants exposed to either aerobic or anaerobic atmospheres in the root zone. When the root zone was made anaerobic by a flowing stream of N₂ gas, petiole epinasty and accelerated ethylene synthesis by the shoots were observed. In soil-grown plants, ethylene synthesis by the root-soil complex increased under anaerobic conditions; but when grown in inert media under the same conditions, ethylene synthesis by roots remained constant or declined during the period of rapid epinastic growth by the petioles. Other characteristic symptoms of flooding, e.g. reduced growth and chlorosis, were also observed in plants with anaerobic roots. Pretreatment of plants with AgNO₃, an inhibitor of ethylene action, completely prevented epinasty, demonstrating that ethylene is the agent responsible for waterlogging symptoms. These results indicate that deprivation of O₂ to the roots is the primary effect of soil flooding, and that this is sufficient to cause increased ethylene synthesis in the shoot. The basis of the observed root-shoot communication is unknown, but root-synthesized hormones or specific ethylene-promoting factors may be involved.     

Stomatal behavior and water relations of waterlogged tomato plants

The effects of waterlogging the soil on leaf water potential, leaf epidermal conductance, transpiration, root conductance to water flow, and petiole epinasty have been examined in the tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.). Stomatal conductance and transpiration are reduced by 30% to 40% after approximately 24 hours of soil flooding. This is not due to a transient water deficit, as leaf water potential is unchanged, even though root conductance is decreased by the stress. The stomatal response apparently prevents any reduction in leaf water potential. Experiments with varied time of flooding, root excision, and stem girdling provide indirect evidence for an influence of roots in maintaining stomatal opening potential. This root-effect cannot be entirely accounted for by alterations in source-sink relationships. Although 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid, the immediate precursor of ethylene, is transported from the roots to the shoots of waterlogged tomato plants, it has no direct effect on stomatal conductance. Ethylene-induced petiole epinasty develops coincident with partial stomatal closure in waterlogged plants. Leaf epinasty may have beneficial effects on plant water balance by reducing light interception.     

Regulation of soybean nodulation independent of ethylene signaling

Leguminous plants regulate the number of Bradyrhizobium- or Rhizobium-infected sites that develop into nitrogen-fixing root nodules. Ethylene has been implicated in the regulation of nodule formation in some species, but this role has remained in question for soybean (Glycine max). The present study used soybean mutants with decreased responsiveness to ethylene, soybean mutants with defective regulation of nodule number, and Ag⁺ inhibition of ethylene perception to examine the role of ethylene in the regulation of nodule number. Nodule numbers on ethylene-insensitive mutants and plants treated with Ag⁺ were similar to those on wild-type plants and untreated plants, respectively. Hypernodulating mutants displayed wild-type ethylene sensitivity. Suppression of nodule numbers by high nitrate was also similar between ethylene-insensitive plants, wild-type plants, and plants treated with Ag⁺. Ethylene insensitivity of the roots of etr1-1 mutants was confirmed using assays for sensitivity to 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid and for ethylene-stimulated root-hair formation. Additional phenotypes of etr1-1 roots were also characterized. Ethylene-dependent pathways regulate the number of nodules that form on species such as pea and Medicago truncatula, but our data indicate that ethylene is less significant in regulating the number of nodules that form on soybean.     

The effects of the herbicide quinclorac on shoot growth in tomato is alleviated by inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis and by the presence of an antisense construct to the 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase gene in transgenic plants

Reduction of shoot growth, leaf epinasty and chlorosis in young tomato plants (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv. Hellfrucht/Frühstamm) treated hydroponically with 10^-7 M of the herbicide quinclorac were partially compensated when the plants were simultaneously sprayed with salicyclic acid or the oxime ether derivative PACME. Since salicyclic acid and PACME are known inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis, it is suggested that this pathway is implicated in quinclorac action. Further support for this hypothesis was obtained in experiments with transgenic tomato plants containing an antisense gene to 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase in ethylene biosynthesis. When quinclorac was applied via the root antisense plants showed reduced phenotypical alterations compared to those of wild-type plants.     

Whole Plant and Leaf Steady State Gas Exchange during Ethylene Exposure in Xanthium strumarium L

The effects of ethylene evolved from ethephon on leaf and whole plant photosynthesis in Xanthium strumarium L. were examined. Ethylene-induced epinasty reduced light interception by the leaves of ethephon treated plants by up to 60%. Gas exchange values of individual, attached leaves under identical assay conditions were not inhibited even after 36 hours of ethylene exposure, although treated leaves required a longer induction period to achieve steady state photosynthesis. The speed of translocation of recently fixed ¹¹C-assimilate movement was not seriously impaired following ethephon treatment; however, a greater proportion of the assimilate was partitioned downward toward the roots. Within 24 hours of ethephon treatment, the whole plant net carbon exchange rate expressed on a per plant basis or a leaf area basis had dropped by 35%. The apparent inhibition of net carbon exchange rate was reversed by physically repositioning the leaves with respect to the light source. Ethylene exposure also inhibited expansion of young leaves which was partially reversed when the leaves were repositioned. The data indicated that ethylene indirectly affected net C gain and plant growth through modification of light interception and altered sink demand without directly inhibiting leaf photosynthesis.     

Ethylene as a regulator of senescence in tobacco leaf discs

The regulatory role of ethylene in leaf senescence was studied with excised tobacco leaf discs which were allowed to senesce in darkness. Exogenous ethylene, applied during the first 24 hours of senescence, enhanced chlorophyll loss without accelerating the climacteric-like pattern of rise in both ethylene and CO₂, which occurred in the advanced stage of leaf senescence. Rates of both ethylene and CO₂ evolution increased in the ethylene-treated leaf discs, especially during the first 3 days of senescence. The rhizobitoxine analog, aminoethoxy vinyl glycine, markedly inhibited ethylene production and reduced respiration and chlorophyll loss. Pretreatment of leaf discs with Ag⁺ or enrichment of the atmosphere with 5 to 10% CO₂ reduced chlorophyll loss, reduced rate of respiration, and delayed the climacteric-like rise in both ethylene and respiration. Ag⁺ was much more effective than CO₂ in retarding leaf senescence. Despite their senescence-retarding effect, Ag⁺ and CO₂, which are known to block ethylene action, stimulated ethylene production by the leaf discs during the first 3 days of the senescing period; Ag⁺ was more effective than CO₂. The results suggest that although ethylene production decreases prior to the climacteric-like rise during the later stages of senescence, endogenous ethylene plays a considerable role throughout the senescence process, presumably by interacting with other hormones participating in leaf senescence.