Development and Evaluation of PCR Assays for the Detection of Paenibacillus larvae in Honey Samples: Comparison with Isolation and Biochemical Characterization

PCR assays were developed for the direct detection of Paenibacillus larvae in honey samples and compared with isolation and biochemical characterization procedures. Different primer pairs, designed from the 16S rRNA and the metalloproteinase precursor gene regions, and different DNA extraction methods were tested and compared. The sensitivity of the reactions was evaluated by serial dilutions of DNA extracts obtained from P. larvae cultures. The specificity of the primers was assessed by analyzing related Paenibacillus and Bacillus strains isolated from honey. The PCR assays also amplified these related bacteria, but at lower sensitivity. In the next step, the PCR assays were applied to contaminated honey and other bee products originating from 15 countries. Lysozyme treatment followed by proteinase K digestion was determined to be the best DNA extraction method for P. larvae spores. The most sensitive primer pair detected P. larvae in 18 of 23 contaminated honey samples, as well as in pollen, wax, and brood. Honey specimens containing saprophyte bacilli and paenibacilli, but not P. larvae, were PCR negative. Although the isolation and biochemical identification method (BioLog) showed higher sensitivity and specificity, PCR proved to be a valuable technique for large-scale screening of honey samples for American foulbrood, especially considering its rapidity and moderate costs.     

Development of multiplex PCR for fast detection of Paenibacillus Larvae in putrid masses and in isolated bacterial colonies

The present study was performed to develop a fast and sensitive multiplex polymerase chain reaction protocol for routine diagnostics of American foulbrood. A new approach for detection of Paenibacillus larvae in putrid masses was described. Forty five samples of putrid masses obtained from bee combs suspicious for American foulbrood, a reference strain Paenibacillus larvae (NBIMCC 8478), clinical isolates and 4 strains of closely related bacterial species were included in experiments. Bacterial colonies?? DNA was isolated by heat and centrifugation method (standard procedure) and with prepGem commercial kit. DNA from putrid masses was isolated by standard and modified procedure. Three pairs of primers specific for 16S rRNA and one pair specific for 35 kDa metalloproteinase genes of Paenibacillus larvae were tested as single pair and in different combinations as multiplex PCR. The sensitivity of the multiplex PCR protocol for putrid masses, developed in study was 100%, versus 45.2% for the standard protocol. The developed multiplex PCR protocol could be successfully used for rapid and specific detection of Paenibacillus larvae in both putrid masses and isolated bacterial colonies.     

Low-Molecular-Weight Metabolites Secreted by Paenibacillus larvae as Potential Virulence Factors of American Foulbrood

The spore-forming bacterium Paenibacillus larvae causes a severe and highly infective bee disease, American foulbrood (AFB). Despite the large economic losses induced by AFB, the virulence factors produced by P. larvae are as yet unknown. To identify such virulence factors, we experimentally infected young, susceptible larvae of the honeybee, Apis mellifera carnica, with different P. larvae isolates. Honeybee larvae were reared in vitro in 24-well plates in the laboratory after isolation from the brood comb. We identified genotype-specific differences in the etiopathology of AFB between the tested isolates of P. larvae, which were revealed by differences in the median lethal times. Furthermore, we confirmed that extracts of P. larvae cultures contain low-molecular-weight compounds, which are toxic to honeybee larvae. Our data indicate that P. larvae secretes metabolites into the medium with a potent honeybee toxic activity pointing to a novel pathogenic factor(s) of P. larvae. Genome mining of P. larvae subsp. larvae BRL-230010 led to the identification of several biosynthesis gene clusters putatively involved in natural product biosynthesis, highlighting the potential of P. larvae to produce such compounds.     

Differentiation of Paenibacillus larvae subsp. larvae, the Cause of American Foulbrood of Honeybees, by Using PCR and Restriction Fragment Analysis of Genes Encoding 16S rRNA

A rapid procedure for the identification of Paenibacillus larvae subsp. larvae, the causal agent of American foulbrood (AFB) disease of honeybees (Apis mellifera L.), based on PCR and restriction fragment analysis of the 16S rRNA genes (rDNA) is described. Eighty-six bacterial strains belonging to 39 species of the genera Paenibacillus, Bacillus, Brevibacillus, and Virgibacillus were characterized. Amplified rDNA was digested with seven restriction endonucleases. The combined data from restriction analysis enabled us to distinguish 35 profiles. Cluster analysis revealed that P. larvae subsp. larvae and Paenibacillus larvae subsp. pulvifaciens formed a group with about 90% similarity; however, the P. larvae subsp. larvae restriction fragment length polymorphism pattern produced by endonuclease HaeIII was found to be unique and distinguishable among other closely related bacteria. This pattern was associated with DNA extracted directly from honeybee brood samples showing positive AFB clinical signs that yielded the restriction profile characteristic of P. larvae subsp. larvae, while no amplification product was obtained from healthy larvae. The method described here is particularly useful because of the short time required to carry it out and because it allows the differentiation of P. larvae subsp. larvae-infected larvae from all other species found in apiarian sources.     

Short communication: Ascorbyl/ascorbate ratio as a marker of oxidative stress in larvae (Apis mellifera) exposed to Paenibacillus larvae

Paenibacillus larvae, the causal agent of American foulbrood disease (AFB), affects Apis mellifera larvae and can induce oxidative stress by overproduction of radical oxygen species (ROS). This study aimed to assess the oxidative stress levels in larvae exposed to three different strains of P. larvae through their diet by examining the ascorbyl radical (A) to ascorbate anion (AH¯) ratio. The results revealed that larvae inoculated with P. larvae exhibited a lower value of this index compared to uninoculated ones. Interestingly, the level of A remained constant, while the concentration of AH¯ increased. Said increase correlated with the virulence of the specific P. larvae strain used in the inoculation. These findings suggest a potential link between AH¯ molecules and a defense response in A. mellifera larvae against infection, consistent with their resistance to P. larvae (LD₅₀).     

Ultrastructure of American foulbrood disease pathogenesis in larvae of the worker honey bee,Apis mellifera

Using electron microscopy, the pathogenesis of American foulbrood disease was followed from ingestion of Bacillus larvae spores by young, susceptible honey bee larvae to death of the host and sporulation of the pathogen. Interaction between the host peritrophic membrane and B. larvae vegetatives is described. Phagocytosis was demonstrated to be a mechanism of entry of pathogen into host midgut cells. No evidence of enzymatic digestion of peritrophic membrane or host-cell microvilli was found during the initial interaction of pathogen and host midgut cell, although eventual lysis of host gut cells may have been the result of enzymatic activity. Following entry of bacteria into the hemocoel, host death resulted from systemic bacteremia.     

Molecular Typing of Paenibacillus larvae Strains Isolated from Bulgarian Apiaries Based on Repetitive Element Polymerase Chain Reaction (Rep-PCR)

The aim of the present study was to perform molecular typing of Paenibacillus larvae (P. larvae) isolates from Bulgarian apiaries with repetitive element polymerase chain reaction (rep-PCR) using BOX A1R, MBO REP1, and ERIC primers. A total of 96 isolates collected from brood combs with clinical symptoms of American foulbrood originating from apiaries located in different geographical regions of Bulgaria, a reference strain P. larvae NBIMCC 8478 and 30 commercial honey samples with Bulgarian origin were included in the study. Rep-PCR fingerprinting analysis revealed two genotypes ab and AB of P. larvae isolates from brood combs and honey samples. A combination of genotypes ab/AB was detected in one apiary and honey sample. The prevailing genotype ab was found in 78.1 % of brood combs isolates as well as in the reference strain whereas genotype AB was determined in 21.9 % of isolates. The examination of honey samples confirmed the preponderance of ab genotype which was demonstrated in 20 of 30 samples analyzed. In conclusion, the genetic epidemiology of P. larvae revealed two genotypes—ab and AB for Bulgarian strains. Developed protocols for molecular typing of P. larvae are reliable and may be used to trace the source of infection.     

Bacteria in the gut of Japanese honeybee, Apis cerana japonica, and their antagonistic effect against Paenibacillus larvae, the causal agent of American foulbrood

We assessed the complexity of bacterial communities occurring in the digestive tract of the Japanese honeybee, Apis cerana japonica, using histological and 16S rRNA gene sequence analyzes. Both Gram-positive and -negative bacteria were observed, and the number of gut bacteria was higher in old larvae compared with young larvae. A total of 35 clones were obtained by a culture-dependent method, and 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis revealed that the bacterial population in the gut of Japanese honeybee was diverse, including the phyla firmicutes, actinobacteria, and alpha-, beta-, and gammaproteobacteria. Further investigation by in vitro inhibition assays was carried out to determine the ability of an isolate to inhibit Paenibacillus larvae, the causal agent of American foulbrood. Out of 35 isolates, seven showed strong inhibitory activity against P. larvae. Most of the antagonistic bacteria belonged to Bacillus species, suggesting that the bacterial isolates obtained in this study appear to be potential candidates for the biological control of P. larvae.     

Synergistic effect of surfactin from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bacillus subtilis</Emphasis> C4 and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Achyrocline satureioides</Emphasis> extracts on the viability of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Paenibacillus larvae</Emphasis>

The aim of this work was to determine the in vitro effect of the mixture between the lipopeptide surfactin, synthesized by Bacillus subtilis C4 (strain isolated from honey) and the most active vegetal extract from Achyrocline satureioides, a traditional medicinal plant, on local strains of Paenibacillus larvae, the agent of American Foulbrood in honeybees. Five P. larvae strains isolated in Córdoba, Argentina, were phenotypically characterized. These and 12 other P. larvae strains from different regions of Argentina were analysed. The antimicrobial activities of the essential oil, hexane (HE) and benzene extracts from A. satureioides were assessed against P. larvae and the HE showed the highest anti-P. larvae activity. A combination of the biosurfactant surfactin, produced by B. subtilis C4, and the HE of A. satureioides revealed a synergistic action on P. larvae. The effective surfactin concentration in the mixture decreased from 32 to 1 μg ml⁻¹ and the HE concentration from 32 to 4 μg ml⁻¹, values similar or equal to minimal inhibitory concentrations observed for oxytetracycline. The fractional inhibitory concentration index confirmed synergism in 4 strains and partial synergism in one strain. The combination of surfactin synthesized by B. subtilis C4 and the HE from A. satureioides could be a natural alternative to help beekeepers to combat the American foulbrood agent P. larvae.     

Complementary Methodologies To Identify Specific Agrobacterium Strains

Serological techniques and restriction enzyme cleavage patterns of total DNA were used to differentiate strains of Agrobacterium spp. Forty-five wild-type and plasmid-cured Agrobacterium strains were tested by immunodiffusion and immunofluorescence against polyclonal antisera to a crude ribosome preparation from Agrobacterium strains K84, U11, B6, A323, NT1, and C58. In immunodiffusion gels, these antisera reacted only with water-phenol extracts of the homologous strain, producing a single, strain-specific precipitin line. In contrast, when the same antisera were used in immunofluorescence staining, cross-reactions occurred with a limited number of heterologous Agrobacterium strains. However, the cross-reacting heterologous cells fluoresced generally less brightly than the homologous cells. When the EcoRI-digested DNA profiles from the same Agrobacterium strains were compared, 34 distinct cleavage patterns were observed. The DNA profiles were the same for all strains sharing a common chromosomal background and correlated with the strain-specific serological reaction. The presence or absence of plasmid DNA did not alter the strain-specific serological reaction or the DNA cleavage patterns. Both the serological reaction and the restriction enzyme digestion of total DNA were complementary to each other. These methods were used successfully to identify A. radiobacter K84 strains which were recovered 6 months after being inoculated to young trees in the field.     

A PCR Detection Method for Rapid Identification of Paenibacillus larvae

American foulbrood is a disease of larval honeybees (Apis mellifera) caused by the bacterium Paenibacillus larvae. Over the years attempts have been made to develop a selective medium for the detection of P. larvae spores from honey samples. The most successful of these is a semiselective medium containing nalidixic acid and pipermedic acid. Although this medium allows the growth of P. larvae and prevents the growth of most other bacterial species, the false-positive colonies that grow on it prevent the rapid confirmation of the presence of P. larvae. Here we describe a PCR detection method which can be used on the colonies that grow on this semiselective medium and thereby allows the rapid confirmation of the presence of P. larvae. The PCR primers were designed on the basis of the 16S rRNA gene of P. larvae and selectively amplify a 973-bp amplicon. The PCR amplicon was confirmed as originating from P. larvae by sequencing in both directions. Detection was specific for P. larvae, and the primers did not hybridize with DNA from closely related bacterial species.     

Chemical composition and antimicrobial activity of Citrus essences on honeybee bacterial pathogen <Emphasis Type="Italic">Paenibacillus larvae</Emphasis>, the causal agent of American foulbrood

Antimicrobial properties and chemical composition of four citrus fruit essential oils to control Paenibacillus larvae, the causal agent of American foulbrood disease (AFB) were determined. This honeybee larvae disease occurs throughout the world and is found in many beekeeping areas of Argentina. Citrus fruit essential oils tested were those from grapefruit (Citrus paradisi), sweet orange (Citrus sinensis), mandarin (Citrus nobilis) and lemon (Citrus limon). The components of the essential oils were identified by SPME-GC/MS analysis. The antimicrobial activity of the oils against P. larvae were determined by the broth microdilution method. Two way ANOVA tests for minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) data and minimal bactericide concentrations (MBCs) data, indicated significant differences between the strains and the oils tested. The antimicrobial assays showed that the oil of C. paradisi inhibited the bacterial strains at the lowest concentrations tested, MICs and MBCs averages of 385.0 mg/l and 770.0 mg/l, respectively. This property could be attributed to the kind and percentage of the volatile components of the oil, like limonene (69.9%) and myrcene (9.6%). The use of essential oils or their specific volatile components individually against pests related to food provision may represent an alternative scope for the control of this serious disease because it does not leave toxic chemical residues in honey nor in its by products.     

Biocidal properties of maltose reduced silver nanoparticles against American foulbrood diseases pathogens

Bee disease caused by spore-forming Paenibacillus larvae and Paenibacillus alvei is a serious problem for honey production. Thus, there is an ongoing effort to find an effective agent that shows broad biocidal activity with minimal environmental hazard. In this study, the biocidal effect of maltose reduced silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) is evaluated against American foulbrood and European foulbrood pathogens. The results demonstrate that the maltose reduced AgNPs are excellent short and long-term biocides against P. larvae isolates. The long-term effect suggests that the Ag⁺ ions are released from the AgNPs with increasing time in a controlled manner.     

Paenibacillus larvae-Directed Bacteriophage HB10c2 and Its Application in American Foulbrood-Affected Honey Bee Larvae

Paenibacillus larvae is the causative agent of American foulbrood (AFB), the most serious honey bee brood bacterial disease. We isolated and characterized P. larvae-directed bacteriophages and developed criteria for safe phage therapy. Whole-genome analysis of a highly lytic virus of the family Siphoviridae (HB10c2) provided a detailed safety profile and uncovered its lysogenic nature and a putative beta-lactamase-like protein. To rate its antagonistic activity against the pathogens targeted and to specify potentially harmful effects on the bee population and the environment, P. larvae genotypes ERIC I to IV, representatives of the bee gut microbiota, and a broad panel of members of the order Bacillales were analyzed for phage HB10c2-induced lysis. Breeding assays with infected bee larvae revealed that the in vitro phage activity observed was not predictive of the real-life scenario and therapeutic efficacy. On the basis of the disclosed P. larvae-bacteriophage coevolution, we discuss the future prospects of AFB phage therapy.     

Detection of Paenibacillus larvae subspecies larvae spores in naturally infected bee larvae and artificially contaminated honey by PCR

American foulbrood (AFB), a severe bacterial disease of honeybee brood, has recently been found in Uruguayan apiaries. Detection of the causative agent, Paenibacillus larvae subspecies larvae, is a very important concern in order to prevent disease dissemination and decrease of honey production. Since spores are the infective forms of this pathogen, in the present work we report the use of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to detect P. l. subsp. larvae spores from in vitro cultures, larvae with clinical symptoms and experimentally contaminated honey. The set of primers was designed based on the published P. l. subsp. larvae 16S rRNA gene. Using this approach we could amplify the pathogen DNA and obtain a great sensitivity and a notable specificity. Detection limit for spore suspension was a 10^–2 dilution of template DNA obtained from 32 spores, as determined by plate count. For artificially contaminated honey, we could detect the PCR product at a 10^–3 dilution of template DNA obtained from 170 spores. In addition, when PCR conditions were set to improve specificity, we were able to amplify P. l. subsp. larvae DNA selectively and no cross-reactions were observed with a variety of related bacterial species, including P. l. subsp. pulvifaciens. Since spore detection is very important to confirm the presence of the disease, this method provides a reliable diagnosis of AFB from infected larvae and contaminated honey in a few hours.     

L-Tenuazonic Acid,a New Inhibitor of Paenibacillus Larvae

A search for bioactive compounds, inhibitors of Paenibacillus larvae, the causal agent of American foulbrood, a honeybees' disease, was carried on. Extracts of two fungal strains, Alternaria brassicicola and Alternaria raphani, isolated from pollen collected from beehives, exhibited a specific inhibitory activity against this bacterium. From these extracts and by means of chromatographic steps and bioassay-guided fractionation, three tetramic acids were isolated. The compounds were identified by spectroscopic methods and the absolute stereochemistry was chemically determined. L-Tenuazonic acid was shown to be responsible for the antibiotic activity. This compound showed a MIC of 32 μg/ml, comparable with that of oxytetracycline, an antibiotic currently used for the prevention of American foulbrood. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

噬菌体疗法及其在美洲幼虫腐臭病中的研究进展

美洲幼虫腐臭病是西方蜜蜂中最严重的细菌病之一,给养蜂业带来了严重的损失。幼虫芽胞杆菌是幼蜂感染美洲幼虫腐臭病的病原菌。由于抗生素产生的耐药性越来越严重,并且抗生素的使用会破坏宿主肠道菌群,使蜂群处于高危的环境中,因此迫切需要抗生素治疗的替代技术,而噬菌体在预防和控制细菌耐药性方面已显示出显著的优势。主要综述了噬菌体疗法、安全性及其在蜜蜂美洲幼虫腐臭病中的研究现状,介绍了噬菌体疗法在各类细菌病中的研究与应用,对今后噬菌体治疗蜜蜂细菌病研究方向进行了展望。     

The biological role of the enigmatic C3larvinAB toxin of the honey bee pathogenic bacterium Paenibacillus larvae

Paenibacillus larvae is the causative agent of the notifiable epizootic American foulbrood, a fatal bacterial disease of honey bee larvae. The species P. larvae has been classified into four differentially virulent and prevalent genotypes (ERIC I-IV), which also differ in their virulence factor equipment. Recently, a novel P. larvae toxin, the C3-like C3larvin, has been described. Genome analysis now revealed that the C3larvin gene is actually a part of a toxin locus encompassing two genes encoding a binary AB toxin with the A subunit being C3larvin (C3larvinA) and a putative B subunit (C3larvinB) encoded by the second gene. Sequence and structural analyses demonstrated that C3larvinB is a homologue of the Bacillus anthracis protective antigen (PA), the B subunit of anthrax toxin. The C3larvinAB toxin locus was interrupted by point mutations in all analysed P. larvae ERIC I and ERIC II strains. Only one P. larvae ERIC III/IV strain harboured an uninterrupted toxin locus comprising full-length genes for C3larvinA and B. Exposure bioassays did not substantiate a role as virulence factor for C3larvinAB in P. larvae ERIC I/II. However, the PA homologue C3larvinB had an influence on the virulence of the unique P. larvae strain expressing the functional C3larvinAB locus.     

DNA extraction and PCR detection of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Paenibacillus larvae</Emphasis> spores from naturally contaminated honey and bees using spore-decoating and freeze-thawing techniques

Summary Paenibacillus larvae causes American foulbrood (AFB), a severe disease that affects the brood of honey bee Apis mellifera. AFB is worldwide distributed and causes great economic losses to beekeepers, but in many cases early diagnosis could help in its prevention and control. The aim of the present work was to design a reliable protocol for DNA extraction of P. larvae spores from naturally contaminated honey and adult bees. A novel method that includes a step of spore-decoating followed by an enzymatic spore disruption and DNA purification was developed. Also a freeze-thaw cycle protocol was tested and the results were compared. The DNA extracted was used as template for specific bacterial detection by amplification of a 16S rDNA fragment. Both methods allowed the direct detection by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of P. larvae spores present in naturally contaminated material. The spore-decoating strategy was the most successful method for DNA extraction from spores, allowing specific and remarkably sensitive PCR detection of spores in all honey and bees tested samples. On the other hand freeze-thawing was only effective for detection of spores recovered from bees, and extensive damage to DNA affected detection by PCR. This work provides new strategies for spore DNA extraction and detection by PCR with high sensitivity, and brings an alternative tool for P. larvae detection in natural samples.