The Pim kinase pathway contributes to survival signaling in primed CD8+ T cells upon CD27 costimulation

Stimulation of the costimulatory receptor CD27 by its ligand CD70 has proved important for the generation of primary and memory CD8(+) T cell responses in various models of antigenic challenge. CD27/CD70-mediated costimulation promotes the survival of primed T cells and thereby increases the size of effector and memory populations. In this paper, we reveal molecular mechanisms underlying the prosurvival effect of CD27. CD27 signaling upregulated expression of the antiapoptotic Bcl-2 family member Bcl-x(L). However, genetic reconstitution of Cd27(-/-) CD8(+) T cells with Bcl-x(L) alone or in combination with the related protein Mcl-1 did not compensate for CD27 deficiency in the response to influenza virus infection. This suggested that CD27 supports generation of the CD8(+) effector T cell pool not only by counteracting apoptosis via Bcl-2 family members. Genome-wide mRNA expression profiling indicated that CD27 directs expression of the Pim1 gene. Pim-1 is a serine/threonine kinase that sustains survival of rapidly proliferating cells by antiapoptotic and prometabolic effects that are independent of the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) pathway. In TCR-primed CD8(+) T cells, CD27 could increment Pim-1 protein expression and promote cell survival throughout clonal expansion independent of the mTOR and IL-2R pathways. In addition, introduction of the Pim1 gene in Cd27(-/-) CD8(+) T cells partially corrected their defect in clonal expansion and formation of an effector pool. We conclude that CD27 may contribute to the survival of primed CD8(+) T cells by the upregulation of antiapoptotic Bcl-2 family members but also calls the Pim-1 kinase survival pathway into action.     

Differential CD40/CD40L expression results in counteracting antitumor immune responses

Establishment of host-protective memory T cells against tumors is the objective of an antitumor immunoprophylactic strategy such as reinforcing T cell costimulation via CD40-CD40L interaction. Previous CD40-targeted strategies assumed that T cell costimulation is an all-or-none phenomenon. It was unknown whether different levels of CD40L expression induce quantitatively and qualitatively different effector T cell responses. Using mice expressing different levels of CD40L, we demonstrated that the greater the T cell CD40L expression the less tumor growth occurred; the antitumor T cell response was host-protective. Lower levels of CD40L expression on T cells induced IL-10-mediated suppression of tumor-regressing effector CD8(+) T cells and higher productions of IL-4 and IL-10. Using mice expressing different levels of CD40 or by administering different doses of anti-CD40 Ab, similar observations were recorded implying that the induction of protumor or antitumor T cell responses was a function of the extent of CD40 cross-linking. IL-10 neutralization during priming with tumor Ags resulted in a stronger tumor-regressing effector T cell response. Using IL-10(-/-) DC for priming of mice expressing different levels of CD40L and subsequent transfer of the T cells from the primed mice to nu/nu mice, we demonstrated the protumor role of IL-10 in the induction of tumor-promoting T cells. Our results demonstrate that a dose-dependent cross-linking of a costimulatory molecule dictates the functional phenotype of the elicited effector T cell response. The T cell costimulation is a continuum of a function that induces not only graded T cell responses but also two counteracting responses at two extremes.     

Lack of ICAM-1 on APCs during T cell priming leads to poor generation of central memory cells

ICAM-1/LFA-1 interactions are known to enhance T cell/APC interactions and to promote T cell activation and cytokine secretion. We have analyzed the consequences of ICAM-1-mediated signaling on the generation of memory T cell subsets. We report that lack of ICAM-1 on APCs, but not on T cells, leads to poor T cell activation and proliferation in vitro and in vivo, and that the defect can be compensated by Ag dose, exogenous IL-2, additional costimulation, and by increasing responder T cell density on APCs. ICAM-1-null mice do not respond to immunization with OVA peptide, but immunization with OVA or with Salmonella typhimurium leads to good T cell proliferation 7-10 days later, and clearance of a challenge infection is equivalent to that of wild-type mice. However, when followed over time, recall proliferation and antibacterial immunity decay rapidly in ICAM-1-null mice, while recall cytokine responses are unaffected. The decline in immunity is not related to poor survival of T cells activated on ICAM-1-null APCs, or to poor generation of effectors in ICAM-1-null mice. Phenotypic analysis of T cells stimulated on ICAM-1-null APCs reveals preferential generation of CD44(high) CD62L(low) effector memory cells (T(EM)) over CD44(high) CD62L(high) central memory cells (T(CM)). Further, while the proportion of naive:memory T cells is similar in unmanipulated wild-type and ICAM-1-null mice, there is an accumulation of T(EM) cells, and a high T(EM):T(CM) ratio in aging ICAM-1-null mice. Together, the data indicate that signaling through LFA-1 during T cell activation may be involved in commitment to a proliferation-competent memory pool.     

Cutting edge: Bcl-3 up-regulation by signal 3 cytokine (IL-12) prolongs survival of antigen-activated CD8 T cells

Clonal expansion of T cells requires cell division and survival during the proliferative phase of the response. Naive murine CD8 T cells responding to Ag and costimulation undergo an abortive response characterized by impaired clonal expansion, failure to develop effector functions, and long-term tolerance. A third signal provided by IL-12 is required for full expansion, activation, and establishment of memory. The enhanced survival, and thus clonal expansion, supported by IL-12 is not due to increased Bcl-2 or Bcl-x(L) expression; both are maximally activated by signals 1 and 2. In contrast, Bcl-3, recently shown to enhance survival when ectopically expressed in T cells, is increased only when IL-12 is present. Furthermore, examination of Bcl-3-deficient CD8 T cells demonstrates that the increased survival caused by IL-12 depends upon Bcl-3. The time courses of expression suggest that Bcl-2 and Bcl-x(L) promote survival early in the response, whereas Bcl-3 acts later in the response.     

OX40 and Bcl-xL promote the persistence of CD8 T cells to recall tumor-associated antigen

The molecular signals that allow primed CD8 T cells to persist and be effective are particularly important during cancer growth. With response to tumor-expressed Ag following adoptive T cell transfer, we show that CD8 effector cells deficient in OX40, a TNFR family member, could not mediate short-term tumor suppression. OX40 was required at two critical stages. The first was during CD8 priming in vitro, in which APC-transmitted OX40 signals endowed the ability to survive when adoptively transferred in vivo before tumor Ag encounter. The second was during the in vivo recall response of primed CD8 T cells, the stage in which OX40 contributed to the further survival and accumulation of T cells at the tumor site. The lack of OX40 costimulation was associated with reduced levels of Bcl-x(L), and retroviral expression of Bcl-x(L) in tumor-reactive CD8 T cells conferred greatly enhanced tumor protection following adoptive transfer. These data demonstrate that OX40 and Bcl-x(L) can control survival of primed CD8 T cells and provide new insights into both regulation of CD8 immunity and control of tumors.     

Enhanced levels of costimulation lead to reduced effector/memory CD8+ T cell functionality

The role of different levels of costimulation in conjunction with signal 1 in the activation of memory CD8+ T cells remains elusive. In this study, we demonstrate, in a mouse model with the influenza nucleoprotein epitope NP68, that mouse early memory (effector/memory) CD8+ T cells that were generated with high levels of costimulation have reduced CTL functionality compared with those that were generated with low levels of costimulation. This reduction is associated with increased phosphorylation of the negative regulatory site 292 on Zap70 and a decrease in granzyme B levels. Furthermore, we show that enhanced costimulation reduces proliferation and cytokine production of effector/memory CD8+ T cells in response to intermediate and weak TCR stimulation, in contrast to previously described positive effects of costimulation on naive CD8+ T cells. This effect is associated with the expression of ICAM-1 on APCs. Together, our results indicate that enhanced costimulation can lead to reduced functionality in effector/memory CD8+ T cells. This compromised effector function of effector/memory CD8+ T cells in response to high levels of costimulation can have important implications for designing immunotherapeutic strategies to enhance immune responses.     

Role of CD4 T cell help and costimulation in CD8 T cell responses during Listeria monocytogenes infection

CD4 T cells are known to assist the CD8 T cell response by activating APC via CD40-CD40 ligand (L) interactions. However, recent data have shown that bacterial products can directly activate APC through Toll-like receptors, resulting in up-regulation of costimulatory molecules necessary for the efficient priming of naive T cells. It remains unclear what role CD4 T cell help and various costimulation pathways play in the development of CD8 T cell responses during bacterial infection. In this study, we examined these questions using an intracellular bacterium, Listeria monocytogenes, as a model of infection. In CD4 T cell-depleted, CD4(-/-), and MHC class II(-/-) mice, L. monocytogenes infection induced CD8 T cell activation and primed epitope-specific CD8 T cells to levels commensurate with those in normal C57BL/6 mice. Furthermore, these epitope-specific CD8 T cells established long-term memory in CD4(-/-) mice that was capable of mounting a protective recall response. In vitro analysis showed that L. monocytogenes directly stimulated the activation and maturation of murine dendritic cells. The CD8 T cell response to L. monocytogenes was normal in CD40L(-/-) mice but defective in CD28(-/-) and CD137L(-/-) mice. These data show that in situations where infectious agents or immunogens can directly activate APC, CD8 T cell responses are less dependent on CD4 T cell help via the CD40-CD40L pathway but involve costimulation through CD137-CD137L and B7-CD28 interactions.     

Primary T cell expansion and differentiation in vivo requires antigen presentation by B cells

B cells are well documented as APC; however, their role in supporting and programming the T cell response in vivo is still unclear. Studies using B cell-deficient mice have given rise to contradictory results. We have used mixed BM chimeric mice to define the contribution that B cells make as APC. When the B cell compartment is deficient in MHC class II, while other APC are largely normal, T cell clonal expansion is significantly reduced and the differentiation of T cells into cytokine-secreting effector cells is impaired (in particular, Th2 cells). The development of the memory T cell populations is also decreased. Although MHC class II-mediated presentation by B cells was crucial for an optimal T cell response, neither a B cell-specific lack of CD40 (influencing costimulation) nor lymphotoxin alpha (influencing lymphoid tissue architecture) had any effect on the T cell response. We conclude that in vivo B cells provide extra and essential Ag presentation capacity over and above that provided by dendritic cells, optimizing expansion and allowing the generation of memory and effector T cells.     

CD27low CD4 T lymphocytes that accumulate in the mouse lungs during mycobacterial infection differentiate from CD27high precursors in situ, produce IFN-gamma, and protect the host against tuberculosis infection

The generation of effector, IFN-gamma producing T lymphocytes and their accumulation at sites of infection are critical for host protection against various infectious diseases. The activation and differentiation of naive T lymphocytes into effector memory cells starts in lymphoid tissues, but it is not clear whether the Ag-experienced cells that leave lymph nodes (LN) are mature or if they undergo further changes in the periphery. We have previously shown that CD44(high)CD62L(low) effector CD4 T lymphocytes generated during the course of mycobacterial infection can be segregated into two subsets on the basis of CD27 receptor expression. Only the CD27(low) subset exhibited a high capacity for IFN-gamma secretion, indicating that low CD27 expression is characteristic of fully differentiated effector CD4 T lymphocytes. We demonstrate now that CD27(low) IFN-gamma-producing CD4 T lymphocytes accumulate in the lungs but are rare in LNs. Several factors contribute to their preferential accumulation. First, CD27(low) CD4 T lymphocytes present in the LN are highly susceptible to apoptosis. Second, circulating CD27(low) CD4 T cells do not enter the LN but efficiently migrate to the lungs. Third, CD27(high) effector CD4 T cells that enter the lungs down-regulate CD27 expression in situ. In genetically heterogeneous mice that exhibit varying susceptibility to tuberculosis, the accumulation of mature CD27(low) CD4 T cells in the lungs correlates with the degree of protection against infection. Thus, we propose that terminal maturation of effector CD4 T lymphocytes in the periphery provides the host with efficient local defense and avoids potentially harmful actions of inflammatory cytokines in lymphoid organs.     

Differential requirements for OX40 signals on generation of effector and central memory CD4+ T cells

Memory T cells can be divided into effector memory (T(EM)) and central memory (T(CM)) subsets based on their effector function and homing characteristics. Although previous studies have demonstrated that TCR and cytokine signals mediate the generation of the two memory subsets of CD8(+) T cells, the mechanisms for generation of the CD4(+) T(EM) and T(CM) cell subsets are unknown. We found that OX40-deficient mice showed a marked reduction in the number of CD4(+) T(EM) cells, whereas the number of CD4(+) T(CM) cells was normal. Adoptive transfer experiments using Ag-specific CD4(+) T cells revealed that OX40 signals during the priming phase were indispensable for the optimal generation of the CD4(+) T(EM), but not the CD4(+) T(CM) population. In a different transfer experiment with in vitro established CD4(+)CD44(high)CD62L(low) (T(EM) precursor) and CD4(+)CD44(high)CD62L(high) (T(CM) precursor) subpopulations, OX40-KO T(EM) precursor cells could not survive in the recipient mice, whereas wild-type T(EM) precursor cells differentiated into both T(EM) and T(CM) cells. In contrast, T(CM) precursor cells mainly produced T(CM) cells regardless of OX40 signals, implying the dispensability of OX40 for generation of T(CM) cells. Nevertheless, survival of OX40-KO T(EM) cells was partially rescued in lymphopenic mice. During in vitro recall responses, the OX40-KO T(EM) cells that were generated in lymphopenic recipient mice showed impaired cytokine production, suggesting an essential role for OX40 not only on generation but also on effector function of CD4(+) T(EM) cells. Collectively, the present results indicate differential requirements for OX40 signals on generation of CD4(+) T(EM) and T(CM) cells.     

Role of CD28-B7 interactions in generation and maintenance of CD8 T cell memory.

Although the role of CD28-B7 interaction in the activation of naive T cells is well established, its importance in the generation and maintenance of T cell memory is not well understood. In this study, we examined the requirement for CD28-B7 interactions in primary T cell activation and immune memory. Ag-specific CD8 T cell responses were compared between wild-type (+/+) and CD28-deficient (CD28(-/-)) mice following an acute infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV). During the primary response, there was a substantial activation and expansion of LCMV-specific CD8 T cells in both +/+ and CD28(-/-) mice. However, the magnitude of the primary CD8 T cell response to both dominant and subdominant LCMV CTL epitopes was approximately 2- to 3-fold lower in CD28(-/-) mice compared with +/+ mice; the lack of CD28-mediated costimulation did not lead to preferential suppression of CD8 T cell responses to the weaker subdominant epitopes. As seen in CD28(-/-) mice, blockade of B7-mediated costimulation by CTLA4-Ig treatment of +/+ mice also resulted in a 2-fold reduction in the anti-LCMV CD8 T cell responses. Loss of CD28/B7 interactions did not significantly affect the generation and maintenance of CD8 T cell memory; the magnitude of CD8 T cell memory was approximately 2-fold lower in CD28(-/-) mice as compared with +/+ mice. Further, in CD28(-/-) mice, LCMV-specific memory CD8 T cells showed normal homeostatic proliferation in vivo and also conferred protective immunity. Therefore, CD28 signaling is not necessary for the proliferative renewal and maintenance of memory CD8 T cells.     

Phenotype and homing of CD4 tumor-specific T cells is modulated by tumor bulk

Technical difficulties in tracking endogenous CD4 T lymphocytes have limited the characterization of tumor-specific CD4 T cell responses. Using fluorescent MHC class II/peptide multimers, we defined the fate of endogenous Leishmania receptor for activated C kinase (LACK)-specific CD4 T cells in mice bearing LACK-expressing TS/A tumors. LACK-specific CD44(high)CD62L(low) CD4 T cells accumulated in the draining lymph nodes and had characteristics of effector cells, secreting IL-2 and IFN-gamma upon Ag restimulation. Increased frequencies of CD44(high)CD62L(low) LACK-experienced cells were also detected in the spleen, lung, liver, and tumor itself, but not in nondraining lymph nodes, where the cells maintained a naive phenotype. The absence of systemic redistribution of LACK-specific memory T cells correlated with the presence of tumor. Indeed, LACK-specific CD4 T cells with central memory features (IL-2(+)IFN-gamma(-)CD44(high)CD62L(high) cells) accumulated in all peripheral lymph nodes of mice immunized with LACK-pulsed dendritic cells and after tumor resection. Together, our data demonstrate that although tumor-specific CD4 effector T cells producing IFN-gamma are continuously generated in the presence of tumor, central memory CD4 T cells accumulate only after tumor resection. Thus, the continuous stimulation of tumor-specific CD4 T cells in tumor-bearing mice appears to hinder the systemic accumulation of central memory CD4 T lymphocytes.     

Control of memory CD4 T cell recall by the CD28/B7 costimulatory pathway

The CD28/B7 costimulatory pathway is generally considered dispensable for memory T cell responses, largely based on in vitro studies demonstrating memory T cell activation in the absence of CD28 engagement by B7 ligands. However, the susceptibility of memory CD4 T cells, including central (CD62L(high)) and effector memory (T(EM); CD62L(low)) subsets, to inhibition of CD28-derived costimulation has not been closely examined. In this study, we demonstrate that inhibition of CD28/B7 costimulation with the B7-binding fusion molecule CTLA4Ig has profound and specific effects on secondary responses mediated by memory CD4 T cells generated by priming with Ag or infection with influenza virus. In vitro, CTLA4Ig substantially inhibits IL-2, but not IFN-gamma production from heterogeneous memory CD4 T cells specific for influenza hemagglutinin or OVA in response to peptide challenge. Moreover, IL-2 production from polyclonal influenza-specific memory CD4 T cells in response to virus challenge was completely abrogated by CTLA4Ig with IFN-gamma production partially inhibited. When administered in vivo, CTLA4Ig significantly blocks Ag-driven memory CD4 T cell proliferation and expansion, without affecting early recall and activation. Importantly, CTLA4Ig treatment in vivo induced a striking shift in the phenotype of the responding population from predominantly T(EM) in control-treated mice to predominantly central memory T cells in CTLA4Ig-treated mice, suggesting biased effects of CTLA4Ig on T(EM) responses. Our results identify a novel role for CD28/B7 as a regulator of memory T cell responses, and have important clinical implications for using CTLA4Ig to abrogate the pathologic consequences of T(EM) cells in autoimmunity and chronic disease.     

Manipulating the rate of memory CD8+ T cell generation after acute infection

Infection with Listeria monocytogenes elicits expansion in numbers of Ag-specific CD8+ T cells, which then undergo programmed contraction. The remaining cells undergo further phenotypic and functional changes with time, eventually attaining the qualities of memory CD8+ T cells. In this study, we show that L. monocytogenes-specific CD8+ T cell populations primed in antibiotic-pretreated mice undergo brief effector phase, but rapidly develop phenotypic (CD127(high), CD43(low)) and functional (granzyme B(low), IL-2-producing) characteristics of memory CD8+ T cells. These early memory CD8+ T cells were capable of substantial secondary expansion in response to booster challenge at day 7 postinfection, resulting in significantly elevated numbers of secondary effector and memory CD8+ T cells and enhanced protective immunity compared with control-infected mice. Although early expansion in numbers is similar after L. monocytogenes infection of antibiotic-pretreated and control mice, the absence of sustained proliferation coupled with decreased killer cell lectin-like receptor G-1 up-regulation on responding CD8+ T cells may explain the rapid effector to memory CD8+ T cell transition. In addition, antibiotic treatment 2 days post-L. monocytogenes challenge accelerated the generation of CD8+ T cells with memory phenotype and function, and this accelerated memory generation was reversed in the presence of CpG-induced inflammation. Together, these data show that the rate at which Ag-specific CD8+ T cell populations acquire memory characteristics after infection is not fixed, but rather can be manipulated by limiting inflammation that will in turn modulate the timing and extent to which CD8+ T cells proliferate and up-regulate killer cell lectin-like receptor G-1 expression.     

Mouse vascular endothelium activates CD8+ T lymphocytes in a B7-dependent fashion

Despite several studies examining the contribution of allorecognition pathways to acute and chronic rejection of vascularized murine allografts, little data describing activation of alloreactive T cells by mouse vascular endothelium exist. We have used primary cultures of resting or IFN-gamma-activated C57BL/6 (H-2(b)) vascular endothelial cells as stimulators and CD8(+) T lymphocytes isolated from CBA/J (H-2(k)) mice as responders. Resting endothelium expressed low levels of MHC class I, which was markedly up-regulated after activation with IFN-gamma. It also expressed moderate levels of CD80 at a resting state and after activation. Both resting and activated endothelium were able to induce proliferation of unprimed CD8(+) T lymphocytes, with proliferation noted at earlier time points after coculture with activated endothelium. Activated endothelium was also able to induce proliferation of CD44(low) naive CD8(+) T lymphocytes. Activated CD8(+) T lymphocytes had the ability to produce IFN-gamma and IL-2, acquired an effector phenotype, and showed up-regulation of the antiapoptotic protein Bcl-x(L). Treatment with CTLA4-Ig led to marked reduction of T cell proliferation and a decrease in expression of Bcl-x(L). Moreover, we demonstrate that nonhemopoietic cells such as vascular endothelium induce proliferation of CD8(+) T lymphocytes in a B7-dependent fashion in vivo. These results suggest that vascular endothelium can act as an APC for CD8(+) direct allorecognition and may, therefore, play an important role in regulating immune processes of allograft rejection.     

SVR angiosarcomas can be rejected by CD4 costimulation dependent and CD8 costimulation independent pathways

PURPOSE: We wished to determine whether virally- induced endothelial tumors are rejected by CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes, and whether there are differences in requirements for costimulation in the rejection of these tumors by lymphocyte subsets. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: We have developed a model of endothelial tumorigenesis through the sequential introduction of SV40 large T antigen and oncogenic H-ras into endothelial cells. These cells (SVR cells) form highly aggressive angiosarcomas in immunocompromised mice, but do not grow in syngeneic C57BL/6 mice. Using both acute blockade with systemic administration of antibodies and mice genetically deficient in the costimulatory molecules CD28, CD40, and CD40L, we have delineated the requirements of costimulation required to reject this virally-induced endothelial tumor. RESULTS: Control of SVR angiosarcoma is mediated through T lymphocytes, and both CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes are capable of controlling SVR angiosarcoma growth in vivo. Mice genetically deficient in CD28, CD40, and CD40L were able to reject SVR tumors, but depletion of these mice of CD8, but not CD4 cells led to rapid tumor growth. This data suggests that CD4 mediated rejection has a greater dependence of costimulation than CD8 mediated rejection. Surprisingly, acute depletion of costimulatory molecules in immunocompetent C57BL/6 mice led to rapid tumor growth. CONCLUSIONS: Significant differences exist in the immune status of mice acutely depleted of costimulatory molecules versus genetically deficient mice. Our results suggest that acute depletion is more immunosuppressive than genetic depletion. Humans who undergo costimulatory blockade may require periodic surveillance for virally-induced tumors.     

Choice of resident costimulatory molecule can influence cell fate in human naïve CD4+ T cell differentiation

With antigen stimulation, naïve CD4+ T cells differentiate to several effector or memory cell populations, and cytokines contribute to differentiation outcome. Several proteins on these cells receive costimulatory signals, but a systematic comparison of their differential effects on naïve T cell differentiation has not been conducted. Two costimulatory proteins, CD28 and ICAM-1, resident on human naïve CD4+ T cells were compared for participation in differentiation. Under controlled conditions, and with no added cytokines, costimulation through either CD3+CD28 or CD3+CAM-1 induced differentiation to T effector and T memory cells. In contrast, costimulation through CD3+ICAM-1 induced differentiation to Treg cells whereas costimulation through CD3+CD28 did not.     

4-1BB and OX40 dual costimulation synergistically stimulate primary specific CD8 T cells for robust effector function

CD40, 4-1BB, and OX40 are costimulatory molecules belonging to the TNF/nerve growth factor superfamily of receptors. We examined whether simultaneous costimulation affected the responses of T cells using several different in vivo tracking models in mice. We show that enforced dual costimulation through 4-1BB and OX40, but not through CD40, induced profound specific CD8 T cell clonal expansion. In contrast, the response of specific CD4 T cells to dual costimulation was additive rather than synergistic. The synergistic response of the specific CD8 T cells persevered for several weeks, and the expanded effector cells resided throughout lymphoid and nonlymphoid tissue. Dual costimulation through 4-1BB and OX40 did not increase BrdU incorporation nor an increase in the number of rounds of T cell division in comparison to single costimulators, but rather enhanced accumulation in a cell-intrinsic manner. Mechanistically speaking, we show that CD8 T cell clonal expansion and effector function did not require T help, but accumulation in (non)lymphoid tissue was predominantly CD4 T cell dependent. To determine whether this approach would be useful in a physiological setting, we demonstrated that dual costimulation mediated rejection of an established murine sarcoma. Importantly, effector function directed toward established tumors was CD8 T cell dependent while being entirely CD4 T cell independent, and the timing of enforced dual costimulation was exquisitely regulated. Collectively, these data suggest that simultaneous dual costimulation through 4-1BB and OX40 induces a massive burst of CD8 T cell effector function sufficient to therapeutically treat established tumors even under immunocompromising conditions.