Assembly of an exceptionally stable RNA tertiary interface in a group I ribozyme

Group I intron RNAs contain a core of highly conserved helices flanked by peripheral domains that stabilize the core structure. In the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme, the P4, P5, and P6 helices of the core pack tightly against a three-helix subdomain called P5abc. Chemical footprinting and the crystal structure of the Tetrahymena intron P4-P6 domain revealed that tertiary interactions between these two parts of the domain create an extensive solvent-inaccessible interface. We have examined the formation and stability of this tertiary interface by providing the P5abc segment in trans to a Tetrahymena ribozyme construct that lacks P5abc (EDeltaP5abc). Equilibrium gel shift experiments show that the affinity of the P5abc and EDeltaP5abc RNAs is exceptionally strong, with a Kd of approximately 100 pM at 10 mM MgCl2 (at 37 degrees C). Chemical and enzymatic footprinting shows that the RNAs are substantially folded prior to assembly of the complex. Solvent accessibility mapping reveals that, in the absence of P5abc, the intron RNA maintains a nativelike fold but its active-site helices are not tightly packed. Upon binding of P5abc, the catalytic core becomes more tightly packed through indirect effects of the tertiary interface formation. This two-component system facilitates quantitative examination of individual tertiary contacts that stabilize the folded intron.     

A peripheral element assembles the compact core structure essential for group I intron self-splicing

The presence of non-conserved peripheral elements in all naturally occurring group I introns underline their importance in ensuring the natural intron function. Recently, we reported that some peripheral elements are conserved in group I introns of IE subgroup. Using self-splicing activity as a readout, our initial screening revealed that one such conserved peripheral elements, P2.1, is mainly required to fold the catalytically active structure of the Candida ribozyme, an IE intron. Unexpectedly, the essential function of P2.1 resides in a sequence-conserved short stem of P2.1 but not in a long-range interaction associated with the loop of P2.1 that stabilizes the ribozyme structure. The P2.1 stem is indispensable in folding the compact ribozyme core, most probably by forming a triple helical interaction with two core helices, P3 and P6. Surprisingly, although the ribozyme lacking the P2.1 stem renders a loosely folded core and the loss of self-splicing activity requires two consecutive transesterifications, the mutant ribozyme efficiently catalyzes the first transesterification reaction. These results suggest that the intron self-splicing demands much more ordered structure than does one independent transesterification, highlighting that the universally present peripheral elements achieve their functional importance by enabling the highly ordered structure through diverse tertiary interactions.     

Protein Roles in Group I Intron RNA Folding: The Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetase CYT-18 Stabilizes the Native State Relative to a Long-Lived Misfolded Structure without Compromising Folding Kinetics

The Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein is a mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase that also promotes self-splicing of group I intron RNAs by stabilizing the functional structure in the conserved core. CYT-18 binds the core along the same surface as a common peripheral element, P5abc, suggesting that CYT-18 can replace P5abc functionally. In addition to stabilizing structure generally, P5abc stabilizes the native conformation of the Tetrahymena group I intron relative to a globally similar misfolded conformation that has only local differences within the core and is populated significantly at equilibrium by a ribozyme variant lacking P5abc (E^ΔP5abc). Here, we show that CYT-18 specifically promotes formation of the native group I intron core from this misfolded conformation. Catalytic activity assays demonstrate that CYT-18 shifts the equilibrium of E^ΔP5abc toward the native state by at least 35-fold, and binding assays suggest an even larger effect. Thus, similar to P5abc, CYT-18 preferentially recognizes the native core, despite the global similarity of the misfolded core and despite forming crudely similar complexes, as revealed by dimethyl sulfate footprinting. Interestingly, the effects of CYT-18 and P5abc on folding kinetics differ. Whereas P5abc inhibits refolding of the misfolded conformation by forming peripheral contacts that must break during refolding, CYT-18 does not display analogous inhibition, most likely because it relies to a greater extent on direct interactions with the core. Although CYT-18 does not encounter this RNA in vivo, our results suggest that it stabilizes its cognate group I introns relative to analogous misfolded intermediates. By specifically recognizing native structural features, CYT-18 may also interact with earlier folding intermediates to avoid RNA misfolding or to trap native contacts as they form. More generally, our results highlight the ability of a protein cofactor to stabilize a functional RNA structure specifically without incurring associated costs in RNA folding kinetics.     

New pathways in folding of the Tetrahymena group I RNA enzyme.

Previous studies have shown that the earliest detectable step in folding of the Tetrahymena ribozyme is tertiary structure formation of the peripheral element P5abc. This, along with other results, has suggested that P5abc may serve as a scaffold upon which additional tertiary structure is built. Herein we use the onset of oligonucleotide cleavage activity as a readout for native state formation and investigate the effect of P5abc on the rate of folding to the native structure. Despite the early folding of P5abc, its removal to give the E delta P5abc variant decreases the rate of attainment of an active structure less than fivefold (20-100 mM Mg2+, 15-50 degrees C). Furthermore, P5abc added in trans is able to bind the folded E delta P5abc ribozyme and promote oligonucleotide cleavage at least tenfold more rapidly than folding of the wild-type ribozyme, indicating that E delta P5abc does not have to first unfold before productively binding P5abc to form the true native state. This suggests that a state with the overall tertiary structure formed but with P5abc unfolded represents a viable on-pathway intermediate for the wild-type ribozyme. These results provide strong evidence for the existence of two pathways to the native state: in one pathway P5abc forms tertiary structure first, and in another it forms late. The pathway in which P5abc forms first is favored because P5abc can fold quickly and because its tertiary structure is stable in the absence of additional structured elements, not because P5abc formation is required for subsequent folding steps. In the course of these experiments, we also found that most of the ribozyme population does not reach the native state directly under standard conditions in vitro, but instead forms an inactive structure that is stable for hours. Finally, the fraction that does fold to the native state folds with a single rate constant of 1 min-1, suggesting that there are no significantly populated "fast-track" pathways that reach the native state directly by avoiding slow folding steps.     

Deletion of the P5abc peripheral element accelerates early and late folding steps of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme

The P5abc peripheral element stabilizes the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme and enhances its catalytic activity. Despite its beneficial effects on the native structure, prior studies have shown that early formation of P5abc structure during folding can slow later folding steps. Here we use a P5abc deletion variant E(deltaP5abc) to systematically probe the role of P5abc throughout tertiary folding. Time-resolved hydroxyl radical footprinting shows that E(deltaP5abc) forms its earliest stable tertiary structure on the millisecond time scale, approximately 5-fold faster than the wild-type ribozyme, and stable structure spreads throughout E(deltaP5abc) in seconds. Nevertheless, activity measurements show that the earliest detectable formation of native E(deltaP5abc) ribozyme is much slower (approximately 0.6 min(-1)), in a manner similar to that of the wild type. Also similar, only a small fraction of E(deltaP5abc) attains the native state on this time scale under standard conditions at 25 degrees C, whereas the remainder misfolds; footprinting experiments show that the misfolded conformer shares structural features with the long-lived misfolded conformer of the wild-type ribozyme. Thus, P5abc does not have a large overall effect on the rate-limiting step(s) along this pathway. However, once misfolded, E(deltaP5abc) refolds to the native state 80-fold faster than the wild-type ribozyme and is less accelerated by urea, indicating that P5abc stabilizes the misfolded structure relative to the less-ordered transition state for refolding. Together, the results suggest that, under these conditions, even the earliest tertiary folding intermediates of the wild-type ribozyme represent misfolded species and that P5abc is principally a liability during the tertiary folding process.     

Structure-function analysis from the outside in: long-range tertiary contacts in RNA exhibit distinct catalytic roles

The conserved catalytic core of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme is encircled by peripheral elements. We have conducted a detailed structure-function study of the five long-range tertiary contacts that fasten these distal elements together. Mutational ablation of each of the tertiary contacts destabilizes the folded ribozyme, indicating a role of the peripheral elements in overall stability. Once folded, three of the five tertiary contact mutants exhibit defects in overall catalysis that range from 20- to 100-fold. These and the subsequent results indicate that the structural ring of peripheral elements does not act as a unitary element; rather, individual connections have distinct roles as further revealed by kinetic and thermodynamic dissection of the individual reaction steps. Ablation of P14 or the metal ion core/metal ion core receptor (MC/MCR) destabilizes docking of the substrate-containing P1 helix into tertiary interactions with the ribozyme's conserved core. In contrast, ablation of the L9/P5 contact weakens binding of the guanosine nucleophile by slowing its association, without affecting P1 docking. The P13 and tetraloop/tetraloop receptor (TL/TLR) mutations had little functional effect and small, local structural changes, as revealed by hydroxyl radical footprinting, whereas the P14, MC/MCR, and L9/P5 mutants show structural changes distal from the mutation site. These changes extended into regions of the catalytic core involved in docking or guanosine binding. Thus, distinct allosteric pathways couple the long-range tertiary contacts to functional sites within the conserved core. This modular functional specialization may represent a fundamental strategy in RNA structure-function interrelationships.     

P5abc of the Tetrahymena ribozyme consists of three functionally independent elements.

P5abc domain of Tetrahymena LSU intron functions as an activator that is not essential for but enhances the activity of the ribozyme either when present in cis or when added in trans. This domain contains three regions (A-rich bulge, L5b, and L5c) that have been demonstrated to interact with the rest of the intron. Although these regions are presumably important for efficient activation, the role of each element is not understood in the mechanism of activation. We employed circularly permuted introns and examined the roles of each element. The results show that each of the three elements can activate the intron independently. We also found that a correlation between the activation by P5abc and the physical affinity of P5abc to the intron exists.     

Recognition elements for 5' exon substrate binding to the Candida albicans group I intron

A group I intron precursor and ribozyme were cloned from the large subunit rRNA of the human pathogen Candida albicans. Both the precursor and ribozyme are functional as determined from in vitro assays. Comparisons of dissociation constants for oligonucleotide binding to the ribozyme and to a hexanucleotide mimic of its internal guide sequence lead to a model for recognition of the 5' exon substrate by this intron. In particular, tertiary contacts with the P1 helix that help align the splice site include three 2'-hydroxyl groups, a G.U pair that occurs at the intron's splice junction, and a G.A pair. The free energy contribution that each interaction contributes to tertiary binding is determined. When the G.A pair is replaced with a G-C pair, tertiary interactions to 5' exon mimic 2'-hydroxyl groups are significantly weakened. When the G.A pair is replaced with a G.U pair, tertiary interactions are retained and binding is 10-fold tighter. These results expand our knowledge of substrate recognition by group I introns, and also provide a basis for rational design of oligonucleotide-based therapeutics for targeting group I introns by binding enhancement by tertiary interactions and suicide inhibition strategies.     

Crystal structure of a phage Twort group I ribozyme-product complex

Group I introns are catalytic RNAs capable of orchestrating two sequential phosphotransesterification reactions that result in self-splicing. To understand how the group I intron active site facilitates catalysis, we have solved the structure of an active ribozyme derived from the orf142-I2 intron from phage Twort bound to a four-nucleotide product RNA at a resolution of 3.6 A. In addition to the three conserved domains characteristic of all group I introns, the Twort ribozyme has peripheral insertions characteristic of phage introns. These elements form a ring that completely envelops the active site, where a snug pocket for guanosine is formed by a series of stacked base triples. The structure of the active site reveals three potential binding sites for catalytic metals, and invokes a role for the 2' hydroxyl of the guanosine substrate in organization of the active site for catalysis.     

Contributions of individual nucleotides to tertiary binding of substrate by a Pneumocystis carinii group I intron

Pneumocystis carinii is a mammalian pathogen that infects and kills immunocompromised hosts such as cancer and AIDS patients. The LSU rRNA precursor of P. carinii contains a conserved group I intron that is an attractive drug target because humans do not contain group I introns. The oligonucleotide r(AUGACU), whose sequence mimics the 3'-end of the 5'-exon, binds to a ribozyme derived from the intron with a K(d) of 5.2 nM, which is 61000-fold tighter than expected from base-pairing alone [Testa, S. M., Haidaris, G. C., Gigliotti, F., and Turner, D. H. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 9379-9385]. Thus, oligonucleotide binding is enhanced by tertiary interactions. To localize interactions that give rise to this tertiary stability, binding to the ribozyme has been measured as a function of oligonucleotide length and sequence. The results indicate that 4.3 kcal/mol of tertiary stability is due to a G.U pair that forms at the intron's splice junction. Eliminating nucleotides at the 5'-end of r(AUGACU) does not affect intron binding more than expected from differences in base-pairing until r((___)ACU), which binds much more tightly than expected. Adding a C at the 5'- or 3'-end that can potentially form a C-G pair with the target has little effect on binding affinity. Truncated oligonucleotides were tested for their ability to inhibit intron self-splicing via a suicide inhibition mechanism. The tetramer, r((__)GACU), retains similar binding affinity and reactivity as the hexamer, r(AUGACU). Thus oligonucleotides as short as tetramers might serve as therapeutics that can use a suicide inhibition mechanism to inhibit self-splicing. Results with a phosphoramidate tetramer and thiophosphoramidate hexamer indicate that oligonucleotides with backbones stable to nuclease digestion retain favorable binding and reactivity properties.     

The P5 activator of a group IC ribozyme can replace the P7.1/7.2 activator of a group IA ribozyme

The P5 or P7 extensions in the group I intron ribozyme serve as "modular activator units" by stabilizing the conserved core of the ribozyme. The P5 extension of a group IC1 intron was introduced to a barely active group IA2 intron lacking its original P7 extension. The inserted P5 extension significantly activated the chimeric construct. Because the CYT-18 protein factor is also known to activate mutant group IA2 and IC1 introns lacking their P7 and P5 extensions, respectively, the RNA and protein activator units function in an analogous manner.     

Minimal catalytic domain of a group I self-splicing intron RNA

The self-splicing intron ribozymes have been regarded as primitive forms of the splicing machinery for eukaryotic pre-mRNAs. The splicing activity of group I self-splicing introns is dependent on an absolutely conserved and exceptionally densely packed core region composed of two helical domains, P3-P7 and P4-P6, that are connected rigidly via base triples. Here we show that a mutant group I intron ribozyme lacking both the P4-P6 domain and the base triples can perform the phosphoester transfer reactions required for splicing at both the 5' and 3' splice sites, demonstrating that the elements required for splicing are concentrated in the stacked helical P3-P7 domain. This finding establishes that the conserved core of the intron consists of two physically and functionally separable components, and we present a model showing the architecture of a prototype of this class of intron and the course of its molecular evolution.     

Distinct sites of phosphorothioate substitution interfere with folding and splicing of the Anabaena group I intron

Although the active site of group I introns is phylogenetically conserved, subclasses of introns have evolved different mechanisms of stabilizing the catalytic core. Large introns contain weakly conserved 'peripheral' domains that buttress the core through predicted interhelical contacts, while smaller introns use loop-helix interactions for stability. In all cases, specific and non-specific magnesium ion binding accompanies folding into the active structure. Whether similar RNA-RNA and RNA-magnesium ion contacts play related functional roles in different introns is not clear, particularly since it can be difficult to distinguish interactions directly involved in catalysis from those important for RNA folding. Using phosphorothioate interference with RNA activity and structure in the small (249 nt) group I intron from Anabaena, we used two independent assays to detect backbone phosphates important for catalysis and those involved in intron folding. Comparison of the interference sites identified in each assay shows that positions affecting catalysis cluster primarily in the conserved core of the intron, consistent with conservation of functionally important phosphates, many of which are magnesium ion binding sites, in diverse group I introns, including those from Azoarcus and Tetrahymena. However, unique sites of folding interference located outside the catalytic core imply that different group I introns, even within the same subclass, use distinct sets of tertiary interactions to stabilize the structure of the catalytic core.     

Atomic level architecture of group I introns revealed

Twenty-two years after their discovery as ribozymes, the self-splicing group I introns are finally disclosing their architecture at the atomic level. The crystal structures of three group I introns solved at moderately high resolution (3.1-3.8A) reveal a remarkably conserved catalytic core bound to the metal ions required for activity. The structure of the core is stabilized by an intron-specific set of long-range interactions that involves peripheral elements. Group I intron structures thus provide much awaited and extremely valuable snapshots of how these ribozymes coordinate substrate binding and catalysis.     

Probing the role of a secondary structure element at the 5'- and 3'-splice sites in group I intron self-splicing: the tetrahymena L-16 ScaI ribozyme reveals a new role of the G.U pair in self-splicing

Several ribozyme constructs have been used to dissect aspects of the group I self-splicing reaction. The Tetrahymena L-21 ScaI ribozyme, the best studied of these intron analogues, catalyzes a reaction analogous to the first step of self-splicing, in which a 5'-splice site analogue (S) and guanosine (G) are converted into a 5'-exon analogue (P) and GA. This ribozyme preserves the active site but lacks a short 5'-terminal segment (called the IGS extension herein) that forms dynamic helices, called the P1 extension and P10 helix. The P1 extension forms at the 5'-splice site in the first step of self-splicing, and P10 forms at the 3'-splice site in the second step of self-splicing. To dissect the contributions from the IGS extension and the helices it forms, we have investigated the effects of each of these elements at each reaction step. These experiments were performed with the L-16 ScaI ribozyme, which retains the IGS extension, and with 5'- and 3'-splice site analogues that differ in their ability to form the helices. The presence of the IGS extension strengthens binding of P by 40-fold, even when no new base pairs are formed. This large effect was especially surprising, as binding of S is essentially unaffected for S analogues that do not form additional base pairs with the IGS extension. Analysis of a U.U pair immediately 3' to the cleavage site suggests that a previously identified deleterious effect from a dangling U residue on the L-21 ScaI ribozyme arises from a fortuitous active site interaction and has implications for RNA tertiary structure specificity. Comparisons of the affinities of 5'-splice site analogues that form only a subset of base pairs reveal that inclusion of the conserved G.U base pair at the cleavage site of group I introns destabilizes the P1 extension >100-fold relative to the stability of a helix with all Watson-Crick base pairs. Previous structural data with model duplexes and the recent intron structures suggest that this effect can be attributed to partial unstacking of the P1 extension at the G.U step. These results suggest a previously unrecognized role of the G.U wobble pair in self-splicing: breaking cooperativity in base pair formation between P1 and the P1 extensions. This effect may facilitate replacement of the P1 extension with P10 after the first chemical step of self-splicing and release of the ligated exons after the second step of self-splicing.     

CRS1, a chloroplast group II intron splicing factor, promotes intron folding through specific interactions with two intron domains

Group II introns are ribozymes that catalyze a splicing reaction with the same chemical steps as spliceosome-mediated splicing. Many group II introns have lost the capacity to self-splice while acquiring compensatory interactions with host-derived protein cofactors. Degenerate group II introns are particularly abundant in the organellar genomes of plants, where their requirement for nuclear-encoded splicing factors provides a means for the integration of nuclear and organellar functions. We present a biochemical analysis of the interactions between a nuclear-encoded group II splicing factor and its chloroplast intron target. The maize (Zea mays) protein Chloroplast RNA Splicing 1 (CRS1) is required specifically for the splicing of the group II intron in the chloroplast atpF gene and belongs to a plant-specific protein family defined by a recently recognized RNA binding domain, the CRM domain. We show that CRS1's specificity for the atpF intron in vivo can be explained by CRS1's intrinsic RNA binding properties. CRS1 binds in vitro with high affinity and specificity to atpF intron RNA and does so through the recognition of elements in intron domains I and IV. These binding sites are not conserved in other group II introns, accounting for CRS1's intron specificity. In the absence of CRS1, the atpF intron has little uniform tertiary structure even at elevated [Mg2+]. CRS1 binding reorganizes the RNA, such that intron elements expected to be at the catalytic core become less accessible to solvent. We conclude that CRS1 promotes the folding of its group II intron target through tight and specific interactions with two peripheral intron segments.     

Fast folding of a ribozyme by stabilizing core interactions: evidence for multiple folding pathways in RNA

Folding of the Tetrahymena ribozyme under physiological conditions in vitro is limited by slow conversion of long-lived intermediates to the active structure. These intermediates arise because the most stable domain of the ribozyme folds 10-50 times more rapidly than the core region containing helix P3. Native gel electrophoresis and time-resolved X-ray-dependent hydroxyl radical cleavage revealed that mutations that weaken peripheral interactions between domains accelerated folding fivefold, while a point mutation that stabilizes P3 enabled 80 % of the mutant RNA to reach the native conformation within 30 seconds at 22 degrees C. The P3 mutation increased the folding rate of the catalytic core as much as 50-fold, so that both domains of the ribozyme were formed at approximately the same rate. The results show that the ribozyme folds rapidly without significantly populating metastable intermediates when native interactions in the ribozyme core are stabilized relative to peripheral structural elements.     

Modular engineering of a Group I intron ribozyme

All Group I intron ribozymes contain a conserved core region consisting of two helical domains, P4–P6 and P3–P7. Recent studies have demonstrated that the elements required for catalysis are concentrated in the P3–P7 domain. We carried out in vitro selection experiments by using three newly constructed libraries on a variant of the T4 td Group I ribozyme containing only a P3–P7 domain in its core. Selected variants with new peripheral elements at L7.1, L8 or L9 after nine cycles efficiently catalyzed the reversal reaction of the first step of self-splicing. The variants from this selection contained a short sequence complementary to the substrate RNA without exception. The most active variant, which was 3-fold more active than the parental wild-type ribozyme, was developed from the second selection by employing a clone from the first selection. The results show that the P3–P7 domain can stand as an independent catalytic module to which a variety of new domains for enhancing the activity of the ribozyme can be added.     

Structural requirement for Mg2+ binding in the group I intron core

Divalent metal ions are required for splicing of group I introns, but their role in maintaining the structure of the active site is still under investigation. Ribonuclease and hydroxyl radical footprinting of a small group I intron from Azoarcus pre-tRNA(Ile) showed that tertiary interactions between helical domains are stable in a variety of cations. Only Mg(2+), however, induced a conformational change in the intron core that correlates with self-splicing activity. Three metal ion binding sites in the catalytic core were identified by Tb(III)-dependent cleavage. Two of these are near bound substrates in a three-dimensional model of the ribozyme. A third metal ion site is near an A minor motif in P3. In the pre-tRNA, Tb(3+) cleavage was redirected to the 5' and 3' splice sites, consistent with metal-dependent activation of splice site phosphodiesters. The results show that many counterions induce global folding, but organization of the group I active site is specifically linked to Mg(2+) binding at a few sites.     

Domains 2 and 3 interact to form critical elements of the group II intron active site

Group II introns are self-splicing RNA molecules that also behave as mobile genetic elements. The secondary structure of group II intron RNAs is typically described as a series of six domains that project from a central wheel. Most structural and mechanistic analyses of the intron have focused on domains 1 and 5, which contain the residues essential for catalysis, and on domain 6, which contains the branch-point adenosine. Domains 2 and 3 (D2, D3) have been shown to make important contributions to intronic activity; however, information about their function is quite limited. To elucidate the role of D2 and D3 in group II ribozyme catalysis, we built a series of multi-piece ribozyme constructs based on the ai5gamma group II intron. These constructs are designed to shed light on the roles of D2 and D3 in some of the major reactions catalyzed by the intron: 5'-exon cleavage, branching, and substrate hydrolysis. Reactions with these constructs demonstrate that D3 stimulates the chemical rate constant of group II intron reactions, and that it behaves as a form of catalytic effector. However, D3 is unable to associate independently with the ribozyme core. Docking of D3 is mediated by a short duplex that is found at the base of D2. In addition to recruiting D3 into the core, the D2 stem directs the folding of the adjacent j(2/3) linker, which is among the most conserved elements in the group II intron active site. In turn, the D2 stem contributes to 5'-splice site docking and ribozyme conformational change. Nucleotide analog interference mapping suggests an interaction between the D2 stem and D3 that builds on the known theta-theta' interaction and extends it into D3. These results establish that D3 and the base of D2 are key elements of the group II intron core and they suggest a hierarchy for active-site assembly.