Effects of water activity and aqueous solvent ordering on thermal stability of lysozyme, α-chymotrypsinogen A, and alcohol dehydrogenase

Effects of water activity (a_W) and solvent ordering were separately analyzed on the thermal unfolding of lysozyme and α-chymotrypsinogen A, and also on the thermal deactivation of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (YADH) in aqueous solutions with various additives. With the coexistence of additives, water activity was the determinant of the extent of the change in the thermal stability of proteins while solvent ordering was the determinant of the direction of the change. The parameter α, determined from the activity coefficient of water, representing the deviation of a_W from that of the ideal solution, was useful as a quantitative index of the solvent ordering showing good correlations with the unfolding temperature and enthalpy of lysozyme and α-chymotrypsinogen A and also with the thermal deactivation rate constant of YADH at a constant a_W. Solvent ordering seemed to affect the thermal stability of proteins mainly through its effect on the intramolecular hydrophobic interaction among amino acid residues in a protein molecule but the contribution of the electrostatic interaction including hydrogen bonding through the change in permittivity of solution was also suggested.     

Influence of water activity and aqueous solvent ordering on enzyme kinetics of alcohol dehydrogenase, lysozyme, and beta-galactosidase

Effects of the water activity (a(w)) and the solvent ordering, as determined by the activity coefficient of water, were investigated on the enzyme kinetics of alcohol dehydrogenase, lysozyme, and beta-galactosidase in various aqueous solutions. The water activity and the solvent ordering were adjusted by addition of electrolytes (NaCl, KCl, CsCl, etc.) or nonelectrolytes (sugars, alcohols, urea, etc.) at various concentrations. Although the enzyme kinetics were strongly dependent on a(w), a(w) was not a complete determinant of the enzyme behavior in aqueous solutions. Enzyme kinetics were also dependent on the solvent ordering. At a fixed a(w), all the enzyme kinetic parameters tested had a good correlation with the solvent ordering parameter as represented by the parameter alpha, an index of the deviation of the water state from the ideal solution, determined from the activity coefficient of water in solutions. Solvent ordering was expected to affect the enzyme kinetics through its effect on the hydrophobic interaction between the enzyme and the substrate and also on the thermal fluctuation.     

Hydration state change of proteins upon unfolding in sugar solutions

Change in hydration number of proteins upon unfolding, Deltan, was obtained from the analysis of thermal unfolding behavior of proteins in various sugar solutions with water activity, a(W), varied. By applying the reciprocal form of Wyman-Tanford equation, Deltan was determined to be 133.9, 124.1, and 139.2 per protein molecule for ribonuclease A at pH=5.5, 4.2, and 2.8, respectively, 201.4 for lysozyme at pH=5.5, and 100.1 for alpha-chymotripnogen A at pH=2.0. Among the sugars tested, reducing sugars gave the lower apparent Deltan as compared with nonreducing sugars probably because of the direct interaction of reducing terminal with amino group of proteins at a high temperature. From the knowledge of Deltan, a new thermodynamic model for protein stability was proposed with explicit consideration for hydration state change of protein upon unfolding. From this model, the contribution of a(W) was proven to be always positive for stabilization of proteins and its effect is not negligible depending on Deltan and a(W).     

Interaction of 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol with proteins: calorimetric, densimetric and surface tension approach

The thermal denaturation of hen egg-white lysozyme was studied in the presence of 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) at various pH values using micro differential scanning calorimetry. Quantitative thermodynamic parameters accompanying the thermal transitions were evaluated. It is observed that thermal unfolding of lysozyme in the presence of TFE upto a concentration of 4.0 mol dm(-3) follows a two-state denaturation mechanism as indicated by the equality of van't Hoff and calorimetric enthalpies. The finer details of interaction were studied by measuring the partial molar volume of some constituent amino acids and glycine peptides from water to aqueous TFE at 298.15 K. The physico-chemical properties of aqueous TFE: apparent molar heat capacities, apparent molar volumes and surface tension were measured to understand the intrinsic properties of the cosolvent as well. From the correlation among the thermal unfolding data on lysozyme in aqueous TFE, calculated preferential interaction parameters, physico chemical properties of aqueous TFE and partial molar volumes of transfer, it is concluded that both solvent mediated effect and direct interaction constitute the mechanism of TFE-protein interactions.     

Thermodynamic, kinetic, and operational stabilities of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase in sugar and compatible osmolyte solutions

Thermodynamic, kinetic, and operational stabilities of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (YADH) were measured and compared in aqueous solutions containing various sugars (sucrose, glucose, and ribose) and compatible osmolytes (betaine and sarcosine). In the measurement of operational stability, native YADH was entrapped and physically immobilized in an ultrafiltration hollow fiber tube to retain the native characteristics of the enzyme. All the additives tested increased thermodynamic stability and kinetic stability of YADH. The order of the magnitude of stabilization effect among additives was different between thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities. Compared to the thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities, the effects of additives were much different in operational stability. Sucrose, glucose, and betaine stabilized YADH substantially while ribose and sarcosine destabilized the enzyme. These results show that the thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities do not necessarily guarantee the operational stability of YADH. The coexistence of stabilizing solute was proved effective to increase the productivity of the bioreactor with immobilized YADH.     

Thermodynamic,kinetic, and operational stabilities of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase in sugar and compatible osmolyte solutions

Thermodynamic, kinetic, and operational stabilities of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (YADH) were measured and compared in aqueous solutions containing various sugars (sucrose, glucose, and ribose) and compatible osmolytes (betaine and sarcosine). In the measurement of operational stability, native YADH was entrapped and physically immobilized in an ultrafiltration hollow fiber tube to retain the native characteristics of the enzyme. All the additives tested increased thermodynamic stability and kinetic stability of YADH. The order of the magnitude of stabilization effect among additives was different between thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities. Compared to the thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities, the effects of additives were much different in operational stability. Sucrose, glucose, and betaine stabilized YADH substantially while ribose and sarcosine destabilized the enzyme. These results show that the thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities do not necessarily guarantee the operational stability of YADH. The coexistence of stabilizing solute was proved effective to increase the productivity of the bioreactor with immobilized YADH.     

Determination of the volumetric properties of proteins and other solutes using pressure perturbation calorimetry

Pressure perturbation calorimetry is a new technique that measures the heat change in a solution that results when the pressure above the solution is changed. When used in a differential calorimeter containing a dilute solution of solute in the sample cell and the corresponding buffer in the reference cell, the measured differential heat can be used to calculate the thermal coefficient of expansion of the partial volume of the solute, alpha. For proteins in dilute aqueous solution, alpha is dominated by a temperature-dependent contribution arising from the interaction of protein groups with water at the protein-solvent interface. This arises due to the effect of the protein groups on the hydrogen-bonded structure of water, and thereby clearly differentiates between structure-making hydrophobic groups and structure-breaking hydrophilic groups. This solvation contribution to alpha can be accentuated in solvents having more structure (deuterium oxide) than water and attenuated in solvents having less structure (2.8 M guanidinium sulfate). Six different proteins (chymotrypsinogen, pepsinogen, lysozyme, bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor, ribonuclease A, and T4 lysozyme) were examined carefully by this technique, allowing estimates of various volumetric parameters including the volume change resulting from thermal unfolding of each protein. For ribonuclease A, results obtained in both water and deuterium oxide led to an estimate of the accessible surface area of the native protein of approximately 45% relative to the fully reduced unfolded protein. Also, it was also found that ligand binding to ribonuclease A led to changes in alpha, suggesting a burial of some surface area in the ligand-protein complex.     

Thermal stability and enzymatic activity of a smaller lysozyme from silk moth (Bombyx mori)

Bombyx mori lysozyme is 10 amino acids shorter than hen egg-white lysozyme, which is a typical c-type lysozyme. It was expressed by using the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris. The thermal stability and the enzymatic activity of the Bombyx mori lysozyme were estimated and compared with those of human and hen egg-white lysozymes. The denaturation temperature was 17-26°C lower than those of human and hen egg-white lysozymes. Further, the enthalpy change and the heat capacity change for unfolding were smaller than those of human lysozyme. It was also confirmed that the stability against guanidine hydrochloride was lower than those of the other two lysozymes. The enzymatic activity toward a simple synthetic substrate was measured and compared with those of human and hen egg-white lysozymes. The B-F binding mode was obviously dominant, although the A-E binding mode was preferred in human and hen egg-white lysozymes.     

Solution thermodynamic approach to analyze protein stability in aqueous solutions

Protein thermal stability was analyzed by a solution thermodynamic approach. The small energetic differences in hydrogen-bonds (HB) among amino acid resdues and water molecules were proved to be amplified by the large number of HB involved to bring about the equilibrium shift from folding to unfolding of proteins. In aqueous solutions, water activity (A_w) plays a key role in protein stability. Therefore, A_w was precisely determined for various solutions and its relationship with solution structure was discussed. Wyman-Tanford analysis based on A_w showed linear regressions, without exception, between protein unfolding-ratio and A_w for lysozyme, ribonuclease A, and α-chymotrypsinogen A in various solutions with sugars, osmolytes, alcohols, and protein denaturant. From this linear regression, the free energy difference, ΔΔG, for a protein in a solution and in pure water, was easily obtained. Protein stability in a solution was proved to be determined by a balance between hydration and solute-binding effects to the protein and also by solution structure, which indirectly affects the hydrophobic interaction in a protein molecule. Temperature dependence of HB on protein stability suggested its interrelationship with hydrophobic interaction.     

Determination of partial unfolding enthalpy for lysozyme upon interaction with dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide using an extended solvation model

The interactions of dodecyltrimethylammonium bromides (DTABs) with hen egg lysozyme have been investigated at pH = 7.0 and 27 degrees C in phosphate buffer by isothermal titration calorimetry. DTAB interacts endothermically and activate lysozyme. The endothermicity of the lysozyme-DTAB interaction is in marked contrast to the exothermic interactions between sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) and lysozyme which have been attributed to specific binding between the anionic sulphate head groups and cationic amino acid residues. The enthalpies of interaction between the cationic surfactant (DTAB) and lysozyme are dominated by the endothermic unfolding of the native structure followed by an exothermic solvation of the lysozyme-DTAB complex by the addition of extra DTAB. A new direct calorimetric method to follow protein denaturation, and the effect of surfactants on the stability of proteins was introduced. The extended solvation model was used to reproduce the enthalpies of lysozyme-DTAB interaction over the whole range of DTAB concentrations. The solvation parameters recovered from the new equation, attributed to the structural change of lysozyme and its biological activity. At low concentrations of DTAB, the binding is mainly electrostatic, with some simultaneous interaction of the hydrophobic tail with nearby hydrophobic patches on the lysozyme. These initial interactions presumably cause some protein unfolding and expose additional hydrophobic sites. The DTAB-induced denaturation enthalpy of lysozyme is 86.46 +/- 0.02 kJ mol(-1).     

trans-Cyclohexanediamines Prevent Thermal Inactivation of Protein: Role of Hydrophobic and Electrostatic Interactions

Although solution additives prevent protein misfolding, the mechanism remains elusive. In this paper, we compare the preventive effects of trans-1,2-cyclohexanediamine (1,2-CHDA) and trans-1,4-cyclohexanediamine (1,4-CHDA) on the heat-induced inactivation of ribonuclease A (RNase A) and lysozyme. These additives are more effective in preventing thermal inactivation of the proteins than guanidine (Gdn) and arginine (Arg). The results suggest two possibilities: (i) decrease in the hydrophobic interaction between unfolded protein molecules is indispensable for preventing protein association, and (ii) the electrostatic interaction between additives interacting with the hydrophobic residues of protein molecules plays an important role in preventing thermal inactivation of proteins.     

Thermodynamic analysis of protein unfolding in aqueous solutions as a multisite reaction of protein with water and solute molecules

Thermal unfolding of ribonuclease A, lysozyme, and chymotrypsinogen A was analyzed as a multisite reaction of a protein molecule with water and solute molecules. The protein unfolding process in various solutions of sugars and denaturants was described well by the van't Hoff equation. The reciprocal form of the Wyman-Tanford equation, which describes the unfolded-to-folded protein ratio as a function of water activity, was successfully applied to obtain a good linear relationship. From this analysis, the role of water activity on protein stability was clearly explained and the contributions of hydration and solute binding to protein molecule were separately discussed in protein unfolding. General solution for the free energy of protein stability was obtained as a simple function of solute concentration.     

Application of the local-bulk partitioning and competitive binding models to interpret preferential interactions of glycine betaine and urea with protein surface

Two thermodynamic models have been developed to interpret the preferential accumulation or exclusion of solutes in the vicinity of biopolymer surface and the effects of these solutes on protein processes. The local-bulk partitioning model treats solute (and water) as partitioning between the region at/or near the protein surface (the local domain) and the bulk solution. The solvent exchange model analyzes a 1:1 competition between water and solute molecules for independent surface sites. Here we apply each of these models to interpret thermodynamic data for the interactions of urea and the osmoprotectant glycine betaine (N,N,N-trimethylglycine; GB) with the surface exposed in unfolding the marginally stable lacI HTH DNA binding domain. The partition coefficient K(P) quantifying accumulation of urea at this protein surface (K(P) approximately equal 1.1) is only weakly dependent on urea concentration up to 6 M urea. However, K(P) quantifying exclusion of GB from the vicinity of this protein surface increases from 0.83 (extrapolated to 0 M GB) to 1.0 (indicating that local and bulk GB concentrations are equal) at 4 M GB (activity > 40 M). We interpret the significant concentration dependence of K(P) for GB, predicted to be general for excluded, nonideal solutes such as GB, as a modest (8%) attenuation of the GB concentration dependence of solute nonideality in the local domain relative to that in the bulk solution. Above 4 M, K(P) for the interaction of GB with the surface exposed in protein unfolding is predicted to exceed unity, which explains the maximum in thermal stability observed for RNase and lysozyme at 4 M GB (Santoro, M. M., Liu, Y. F., Khan, S. M. A., Hou, L. X., and Bolen, D. W. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 5278-5283). Both thermodynamic models provide good two-parameter fits to GB and urea data for lacI HTH unfolding over a wide concentration range. The solute partitioning model allows for a full spectrum of attenuation effects in the local domain, encompasses the cases treated by the competitive binding model, and provides a somewhat better two-parameter fit of effects of high GB concentration on lacI HTH stability. Parameters of this fit should be applicable to isothermal and thermal unfolding data for all proteins with similar compositions of surface exposed in unfolding.     

Liposomal encapsulation of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase with cofactor for stabilization of the enzyme structure and activity

Yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (YADH) with its cofactor nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) could be stably encapsulated in liposomes composed of POPC (1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3- phosphocholine). The YADH- and NAD+-containing liposomes (YADH-NADL) were 100 nm in mean diameter. The liposomal YADH and NAD+ concentrations were 2.3 mg/mL and 3.9 mM, respectively. A synergistic effect of the liposomal encapsulation and the presence of NAD+ was examined on the thermal stability of YADH at 45 and 50 degrees C. The enzyme stability of the YADH-NADL was compared to the stabilities of the liposomal YADH (YADHL) containing 3.3 mg/mL YADH without NAD+ as well as the free YADH with and without NAD+. Free YADH was increasingly deactivated during its incubation at 45 degrees C for 2 h with decrease of the enzyme concentration from 3.3 to 0.01 mg/mL because of the dissociation of tetrameric YADH into its subunits. At that temperature, the coexistence of free NAD+ at 3.9 mM improved the stability of free YADH at 2.3 mg/mL through forming their thermostable complex, although the stabilization effect of NAD+ was lowered at 50 degrees C. The turbidity measurements for the above free YADH solution with and without NAD+ revealed that the change in the enzyme tertiary structure was much more pronounced at 50 degrees C than at 45 degrees C even in the presence of NAD+. This suggests that YADH was readily deactivated in free solution due to a decrease in the inherent affinity of YADH with NAD+. On the other hand, both liposomal enzyme systems, YADH-NADL and YADHL, showed stabilities at both 45 and 50 degrees C much higher than those of the above free enzyme systems, YADH/NAD+ and YADH. These results imply that the liposome membranes stabilized the enzyme tertiary and thus quaternary structures. Furthermore, the enzyme activity of the YADH-NADL showed a stability higher than that of the YADHL with a more remarkable effect of NAD+ at 50 degrees C than at 45 degrees C. This was considered to be because even at 50 degrees C the stabilization effect of lipid membranes on the tertiary and quaternary structures of the liposomal YADH allowed the enzyme to form its thermostable complex with NAD+ in liposomes.     

Effect of Zinc Ions on Conformational Stability of Yeast Alcohol Dehydrogenase

Yeast alcohol dehydrogenase preparations were prepared with the conformational zinc ion removed (Apo-I YADH) and with both the conformational and catalytic zinc ions removed (Apo-II YADH). The unfolding of Apo-I YADH and Apo-II YADH during denaturation in urea solutions was then followed by fluorescence emission, circular dichroism, and second-derivative optical spectroscopies. Compared with the native enzyme, Apo-I YADH incurred some slight unfolding, and its stability against urea was markedly decreased, while Apo-II YADH incurred marked unfolding but contained residual ordered structure even at high urea concentrations. The results show that native YADH is more conformationally stable against urea denaturation than Apo-I YADH, indicating that the conformational Zn²⁺ plays an important role in stabilizing the conformation of the YADH molecule. However, unfolding of the region around the conformational zinc ion is shown not to be the rate limited step in the unfolding of the molecule by the fact that the unfolding and inactivation rate constants of native and Apo-I YADH are the same. It is suggested that the catalytic zinc ion is more important in maintaining the structure of YADH. YADH lost its cooperative unfolding ability after the zinc ions were removed. The shape of the transition curves of Apo-I YADH suggests the existence of an unfolding intermediate. For both native and Apo-I YADH, inactivation occurs at much lower urea concentrations than that needed to produce significant conformational changes of the enzyme molecule. At urea concentration above 4 M, the inactivation rate constants are much higher than those of the fast phase of the reaction of unfolding. These results support the suggestion of flexibility at the active site of the enzyme (C. L. Tsou (1986) Trends Biochem. Sci., 11, 427-429; (1993) Science, 262, 308-381).     

The stabilization of proteins by osmolytes.

The preferential interactions of lysozyme with solvent components and the effects of solvent additives on its stability were examined for several neutral osmolytes: L-proline, L-serine, gamma-aminobutyric acid, sarcosine, taurine, alpha-alanine, beta-alanine, glycine, betaine, and trimethylamine N-oxide. It was shown that all these substances stabilize the protein structure against thermal denaturation and (except for trimethylamine N-oxide for which interaction measurements could not be made) are strongly excluded from the protein domain, rendering unlikely their direct binding to proteins. On the other hand, valine, not known as an osmolyte, had no stabilizing effect, although it induced a large protein-preferential hydration. A possible explanation is given for the use of these substances as osmotic-pressure-regulating agents in organisms living under high osmotic pressure.     

Interchain disulfide bonds promote protein cross-linking during protein folding

We provide evidence that in vitro protein cross-linking can be accomplished in three concerted steps: (i) a change in protein conformation; (ii) formation of interchain disulfide bonds; and (iii) formation of interchain isopeptide cross-links. Oxidative refolding and thermal unfolding of ribonuclease A, lysozyme, and protein disulfide isomerase led to the formation of cross-linked dimers/oligomers as revealed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Chemical modification of free amino groups in these proteins or unfolding at pH < 7.0 resulted in a loss of interchain isopeptide cross-linking without affecting interchain disulfide bond cross-linking. Furthermore, preformed interchain disulfide bonds were pivotal for promoting subsequent interchain isopeptide cross-links; no dimers/oligomers were detected when the refolding and unfolding solution contained the reducing agent dithiothreitol. Similarly, the Cys326Ser point mutation in protein disulfide isomerase abrogated its ability to cross-link into homodimers. Heterogeneous proteins become cross-linked following the formation of heteromolecular interchain disulfide bonds during thermal unfolding of a mixture of of ribonuclease A and lysozyme. The absence of glutathione and glutathione disulfide during the unfolding process attenuated both the interchain disulfide bond cross-links and interchain isopeptide cross-links. No dimers/oligomers were detected when the thermal unfolding temperature was lower than the midpoint of thermal denaturation temperature.     

Thermal and chemical stability of solid-state enzymes

The thermal deactivation of solid-state acid-phosphatase has been studied, in the presence and in the absence of organic solvents. The experimental results have been modelled in terms of a single-step, non-linear, irreversible kinetic model. Enzyme stability was strongly affected by deactivation temperature and initial water content of the enzyme preparation. In contrast, no direct influence of solvent hydrophobicity was detected. The results were compared with those obtained in aqueous solution.     

Increased thermal stability of proteins in the presence of sugars and polyols.

Sugars and polyols stablize proteins against heat denaturation. Scanning calorimetry was used to obtain a quantitative estimate of the degree of stabilization. Solutions of ovalbumin, lysozyme, conalbumin, and alpha-chymotrypsinogen were heated at a constant rate, and the temperature of the maximum rate of denaturation was estimated (Tm). Addition of a sugar or polyol raised Tm. The magnitude of the stabilizing effect (delta Tm) depended on both the nature of the protein and the nature of the sugar or polyol, ranging from 18.5 degrees C for lysozyme at pH 3 in the presence of 50% (w/w) sorbitol to 0 degrees C for conalbumin at pH 7 in 50% glycerol solution. It is argued that this stablization is due to the effects of sugars and polyols on hydrophobic interactions. The strength of the hydrophobic interaction was measured in model systems in sucrose and glycerol solutions. Sucrose and glycerol strengthened the pairwise hydrophobic interaction between hydrophobic groups; however, they reduced the tendency for complete transfer of hydrophobic groups from an aqueous to a nonpolar environment. The extent of stabliziation by different sugars and polyols is explained by their different influences on the structure of water. The difference between the partial molar volume of the sugar or polyol and its van der Waals volume was used as a rough quantitative measure of the structure-making or structure-breaking effect. There was a linear relationship between this quantity and delta Tm.     

Chemical modification of tryptophan residues and stability changes in proteins

The role of tryptophan residues in the stability of proteins was studied by ozone oxidation, which causes a small change in the tryptophan side chain. Trp 187 of the constant fragment of a type lambda immunoglobulin light chain, Trp 59 of ribonuclease T1, and Trp 62 of hen egg white lysozyme were oxidized specifically by ozone to N'-formylkynurenine or kynurenine. Judging from their circular dichroic and fluorescence spectra, these modified proteins were found to be the same as those of the respective intact proteins. However, even the slight modification of a single tryptophan residue produced a large decrease in the stability of these proteins to guanidine hydrochloride and heat. The smaller the extent of exposure of the tryptophan residue, the greater the effect of the modification on the stability. The formal kinetic mechanism of unfolding and refolding by guanidine hydrochloride of the CL fragment was not altered by tryptophan oxidation, but the rate constants for unfolding and refolding changed. The thermal unfolding transitions were analyzed to obtain the thermodynamic parameters. The enthalpy and entropy changes for the modified proteins were larger than the respective values for the intact proteins.