The evolution of parental care in freshwater leeches

Summary The life-history strategies of a selection of the most common European freshwater leeches (Euhirudinea) are described. On the basis of this information and results from the literature, the probable phylogenetic development of parental care in the Euhirudinea is reconstructed. The jawless worm leeches (Erpobdellidae) secrete a protective cocoon, cement it to the substrate and sometimes ventilate it before they leave the egg capsules. This behaviour represents the most ancient state in leech evolution. Members of the jawed Hirudinidae deposit desiccation-resistant cocoons on land. All known Glossiphoniidae (leeches equipped with a proboscis) have evolved the habit of brooding the eggs and young. These unique parental care patterns within one family of extant freshwater leeches can be arranged schematically in a series of increasing complexity which may reflect the evolution of brooding behaviour. Glossiphoniid leeches of the genus Helobdella, which have a world-wide distribution, display the most highly developed parental care system: they not only protect but also feed the young they carry. This results in the young being much larger when they leave the parent and, presumably, in higher subsequent survival. Isolated cocoons of all aquatic leeches are rapidly destroyed by predators, primarily water snails. In erpobdellids (but not glossiphoniids, which protect the cocoons) a large portion of the cocoons are lost due to predatory attacks. We conclude that the major selective pressure driving the evolution of parental care in leeches may have been predation on eggs and juvenile stages. Dedicated to Professor Dr. G. Osche on the occasion of his 75th birthday     

Comparing fecundity in parthenogenetic versus sexual populations of the freshwater snail Campeloma limum: is there a two‐fold cost of sex?

Abstract. The predominance of sexuality in eukaryotes remains an evolutionary paradox, given the "two-fold cost of sex" also known as the "cost of males." [Correction added after online publication 29 January 2009: in the preceding sentence, extraneous words were deleted.] As it requires two sexual parents to reproduce and only one parthenogenetic parent, parthenogens should have twice the reproductive rate compared with their sexual counterparts and their genes should spread twice as fast, if all else is equal. Yet, parthenogenesis is relatively rare and considered an evolutionary dead-end, while sexuality is the dominant form of reproduction in multicellular eukaryotes. Many studies have explored short-term benefits of sex that could outweigh its two-fold cost, but few have compared fecundity between closely related sexuals and parthenogens to first verify that "all else is equal" reproductively. We compared six fecundity measures between sexual and parthenogenetic populations of the freshwater snail, Campeloma limum , during a brooding cycle (1 year) across two drainages. Drainages were analyzed separately because of a significant drainage effect. In the Savannah drainage, fecundity was not significantly different between sexuals and parthenogens, even though parthenogens had significantly more empty egg capsules per brood. In the Ogeechee drainage, parthenogens had significantly more egg capsules with multiple embryos and more hatched embryos than sexuals. Taken over 1 year, embryo size was not significantly different between parthenogens and sexuals in either drainage. Given these results and the close proximity of sexual and parthenogenetic populations, it is perplexing why parthenogenetic populations have not completely replaced sexual populations in C. limum.     

Brooding in Corbicula madagascariensis (Bivalvia, Corbiculidae) and the repeated evolution of viviparity in corbiculids

The limnic bivalve genus Corbicula Megerle von Mühlfeld, 1811 is a hyper-invasive neozoon in North and South America as well as in Europe, where currently some taxa are rapidly extending their range. In addition to its extraordinarily invasive potential, the 'Asiatic clam' is remarkable for its recently discovered wide spectrum of reproductive strategies comprising oviparity, ovoviviparity and euviviparity. It renders Corbicula an ideal model for studying evolutionary transformations of reproductive features, in particular with respect to intrabranchial incubation (brooding) of embryos and shelled larvae in freshwater lineages. Based on rare material from Madagascar we here present evidence for prolonged incubation interpreted as being indicative of euviviparous reproduction in C. madagascariensis Smith, 1882. This mode is not only novel for corbiculids from the Ethiopian biogeographical region, but suggests — in combination with a mtDNA phylogeny — a more complicated pattern of the evolution of reproductive modes in corbiculids than previously assumed. We find an independent origin of viviparity and even euviviparity in the South American Neocorbicula Fischer, 1887 and the Afro-Asian Corbicula , representing a remarkable example of parallel evolution in New and Old World corbiculids.     

Insights in the ecology and evolutionary history of the Miscellaneous Crenarchaeotic Group lineage

Members of the archaeal Miscellaneous Crenarchaeotic Group (MCG) are among the most successful microorganisms on the planet. During its evolutionary diversification, this very diverse group has managed to cross the saline–freshwater boundary, one of the most important evolutionary barriers structuring microbial communities. However, the current understanding on the ecological significance of MCG in freshwater habitats is scarce and the evolutionary relationships between freshwater and saline MCG remains poorly known. Here, we carried out molecular phylogenies using publicly available 16S rRNA gene sequences from various geographic locations to investigate the distribution of MCG in freshwater and saline sediments and to evaluate the implications of saline–freshwater transitions during the diversification events. Our approach provided a robust ecological framework in which MCG archaea appeared as a core generalist group in the sediment realm. However, the analysis of the complex intragroup phylogeny of the 21 subgroups currently forming the MCG lineage revealed that distinct evolutionary MCG subgroups have arisen in marine and freshwater sediments suggesting the occurrence of adaptive evolution specific to each habitat. The ancestral state reconstruction analysis indicated that this segregation was mainly due to the occurrence of a few saline–freshwater transition events during the MCG diversification. In addition, a network analysis showed that both saline and freshwater MCG recurrently co-occur with archaea of the class Thermoplasmata in sediment ecosystems, suggesting a potentially relevant trophic connection between the two clades.     

Diet-morphology correlations in the radiation of South American geophagine cichlids (Perciformes: Cichlidae: Cichlinae)

Genera within the South American cichlid tribe Geophagini display specialized feeding and reproductive strategies, with some taxa specialized for both substrate-sifting and mouth brooding. Several lineages within the clade also possess an epibranchial lobe (EBL), a unique pharyngeal structure that has been proposed to have a function in feeding and/or mouth brooding. A recently published genus-level phylogeny of Neotropical cichlids was used as the evolutionary framework for investigating the evolution of morphological features presumably correlated with diet and mouth brooding in the tribe Geophagini. We tested for possible associations between the geophagine epibranchial lobe and benthic feeding and mouth brooding. We also addressed whether the EBL may be associated with unique patterns of diversification in certain geophagine clades. Tests of binary character correlations revealed the EBL was significantly associated with mouth brooding. We also tested for a relationship between diet and morphology. We analyzed stomach contents and morphometric variation among 21 species, with data for two additional species obtained from the literature. Principal Components Analysis revealed axes of morphological variation significantly correlated with piscivory and benthivory, and both morphology and diet were significantly associated with phylogeny. These results suggest that the EBL could be an adaptation for either feeding or mouth brooding. The EBL, however, was not associated with species richness or accelerated rates of phyletic diversification.     

The evolution of viviparity in holocene islands: ecological adaptation versus phylogenetic descent along the transition from aquatic to terrestrial environments

Species that contain populations with different reproductive modes offer excellent opportunities to study the transition between such strategies. Salamandra salamandra (Linnaeus, 1758) is one of two species within the Salamandra – Lyciasalamandra clade which displays two reproductive modes simultaneously. Along the S. salamandra distribution, the common reproductive mode is ovoviviparity although the species also has viviparous populations in the northern Iberian Peninsula. The occurrence of viviparity has recently been reported in two small offshore island populations on the Atlantic coast (NW Iberia), which originated after the last glacial period (8000–9000 years ago). In this paper, we analysed ovoviviparous, hybrid and viviparous populations (inland and mainland) from 17 localities across the northern Iberian Peninsula using two mitochondrial markers (Cyt b and COI , c . 1100 bp). Phylogenetic and phylogeographic analyses highly support that viviparity arose as an evolutionary novelty in the S. salamandra island populations and that viviparous populations are therefore not monophyletic. The recent insularity of Atlantic island populations leads us to conclude that the transition from ovoviviparity to viviparity can happen in a very short-time span. Additionally, to determine the likely source of this evolutionary transition, we discuss how ecological pressures could have an effect on the maintenance of the ovoviviparous reproductive mode. Hence, taking into account the results of this study, we propose the consideration of the island populations as an evolutionary unit for conservation purposes.     

Habitat and phylogeny influence salinity discrimination in crocodilians: implications for osmoregulatory physiology and historical biogeography

Crocodylids are better adapted than alligatorids, through a suite of morphological specializations, for life in hyperosmotic environments. The presence of such specializations even in freshwater crocodylids has been interpreted as evidence for a marine phase in crocodylid evolution, consistent with the trans-osceanic migration hypothesis of crocodilian biogeography. The ability to discriminate fresh water from hyperosmotic sea water, and to avoid drinking the latter, is known to be an important osmoregulatory mechanism for estuarine crocodylids. This study was undertaken to determine whether the ability to discriminate between hyper- and hypo-osmotic salinities is determined by habitat, as it is in other normally freshwater reptiles, or whether, like morphological adaptations associated with estuarine life, it has a phylogenetic basis. Two species of freshwater alligatorid were found to drink fresh water and hyperosmotic sea water indiscriminately, while an estuarine population of a normally freshwater alligatorid species drank only fresh water. This indicated that salinity discrimination is determined at least in part by habitat. However, all three crocodylid species tested drank fresh water but not hyperosmotic sea water, suggesting that, in crocodilians, the ability to distinguish between fresh water and sea water is influenced by phylogeny as well as by habitat. The implications of this result are discussed in the context of two alternate hypotheses for the historical biogeography of the Crocodilia.     

Hermaphroditism in molluscs

The functional significance of hermaphroditism is, as yet, not well understood. This study attempts to examine the relevance of some theories on this topic to reality, by reviewing the literature on hermaphroditism among molluscs. The study reveals that about 40% of the 5600 mollusc genera are either simultaneous or sequential hermaphrodites. Hermaphroditism occurs in 100% of the Solenogastres, 99% of the Opisthobranchia, 100% of the Pulmonata, 3% of the Prosobranchia and 9% of the Bivalvia. Sequential hermaphroditism, whatever its theoretical advantages over gonochorism, is not common among molluscs. Simultaneous hermaphroditism is common among the Euthyneura. Over 80% of the hermaphroditic genera belong to the Euthyneura (about 2000 recent genera), and over 99% of the Euthyneura are hermaphrodites. The almost ubiquitous occurrence of hermaphroditism throughout the Euthyneurans, coupled with this group's very widespread dispersal in marine, terrestrial and freshwater habitats (and corresponding exposure to a very wide range of predators, competitors or parasites); and also its wide range of population densities, suggests that in this group hermaphroditism is not an adaptive response to selective forces of the environment and it may well be a phylogenetic constraint. A few stylommatophorans have broken this constraint by possessing genitalia in which the male system is absent (aphally) or extremely reduced (hemiphally). They reproduce by self-fertilization. In theory this is advantageous in that these species save the cost of developing two sets of reproductive apparatus. In reality there is no record of aphally occurring throughout an entire species, as one may expect if this saving of cost were so overwhelmingly advantageous. There is also no record of stylommatophoran individuals developing only the male system, as one may expect if there was any evolutionary trend from hermaphroditism towards gonochorism. Simultaneous hermaphroditism offers a (theoretical) option to selling. Selfing by self-fertilization is widespread among freshwater basommatophorans, amphibious stylommatophorans and freshwater bivalves. Selfing by parthenogenesis is widespread among freshwater prosobranchs. Altogether, of 48 genera which self, 60% are dwellers of freshwater. Certain freshwater habitats may perhaps be less stable than most marine or terrestrial ones are. Beyond the Euthyneura, hermaphroditism is common among parasitic, deep sea and Cnidaria-eating molluscs. Perhaps these three associations should be slightly rearranged and combined into a single generalization: that hermaphroditism (beyond the Euthyneura) is widespread among molluscs that live in a close and permanent intimacy with live marine invertebrates, whether as parasites, commensals or predators. Gonochorism but with dwarf males is common among the Eulimoidea, which are parasites, and Galeommatoidea, which are commensals. This situation of gonochorism, in which there is a very close association between members of the two sexes, is functionally a hermaphroditic type. Animals that can manipulate the physiology and endocrinology of their hosts may also have the tendency and ability to manipulate the size of their own males. It may well be that the female not only determines the size of the male but also his sex, in which case dwarf males should be considered as a case of environmental sex determination. The theoretical possibility that hermaphroditism may evolve in brooding animals was examined in gastropods. Among the (predominantly gonochoric) prosobranchs brooding is recorded in 85 genera (4%), only two of which are hermaphrodites. Among the (predominantly hermaphrodite) heterobranchs it is recorded in only 95 odd genera (4%). When all gastropod genera are considered together, the frequency of hermaphroditism among the brooders is only very slightly and insignificantly higher than in the non-brooders. When only the prosobranchs are considered, the frequency of hermaphroditism among the brooders is actually lower than among non-brooders. The theory that hermaphroditism evolves in brooding animals thus appears not to be relevant to the vast majority of gastropods. Brooding is widespread among freshwater prosobranchs (48% of the brooding genera). In this habitat, brooding may perhaps be an adaptation to protect the developing embryo against osmotic stresses.     

Smaller amphipod mothers show stronger trade-offs between offspring size and number

Trade-offs between embryo mass and number were studied in 10 populations of the freshwater amphipod Gammarus minus . Trade-offs were stronger in populations with small brooding females than in those with larger brooding females. Relationships between embryo mass and maternal body mass were also stronger in populations dominated by small versus large brooding females. These patterns are likely the result of morphological constraints, at least in part. Embryo size is more affected by brood size and maternal size in small mothers, probably because of offspring-packaging constraints associated with small brood pouches. Energy constraints appear to be less important. These results suggest that body size may not only affect the magnitude of individual life-history traits, as is well known, but also the covariance between traits.     

Novel reproductive modes in freshwater clams: brooding and larval morphology in Southeast Asian taxa of Corbicula (Mollusca, Bivalvia, Corbiculidae)

While the majority of marine bivalves are oviparous, the two freshwater families among the order Veneroida, i.e. Corbiculidae and Sphaeriidae, comprise species with ovoviviparous and viviparous reproduction. Within the Corbiculidae, the genus Corbicula, which is well‐known for its invasive and, thus, ecologically important representatives, is characterized by (i) a wide range of limnic habitats, inhabiting both brackish water and freshwater environments, and (ii) contrasting modes of reproduction, including ‘planktonic’ development via a free‐swimming larva vs. intrabranchial incubation (brooding) of shelled juveniles. The present investigation of five species of Corbicula from the Indonesian islands Sumatra and Sulawesi, which were hitherto not studied anatomically, adds to the diversity in reproductive patterns in this genus. As a unique feature among Corbicula we here report on two newly observed modes of brooding in species endemic to Sulawesi, (i) tetragenous brooding (i.e. in both demibranchs) in Corbicula possoensis Sarasin & Sarasin, 1898 from Lake Poso, and (ii) prolonged incubation in the maternal gills, with juvenile shells reaching up to 1.3 mm in length and with a well‐developed hinge in C. linduensis Bollinger, 1914 from the Lindu River system. In contrast, a third method is seen in the following taxa that incubate their young in their inner demibranchs only until the stage of juveniles with straight‐hinged shells (D‐shaped): C. matannensis Sarasin & Sarasin, 1898 from Lake Matano and Lake Mahalona, C. loehensis Kruimel, 1913 from Lake Masapi (all on Sulawesi) and C. moltkiana Prime, 1878 from Lakes Maninjau and Singkarak (on Sumatra). Details of the anatomical and histological features of ctenidia are described for each type of brooding, and some trends in the evolution of reproductive strategies within the Corbiculidae are discussed, comparing them with those known from other limnic molluscs.     

OVIPARITY, EGG RETENTION AND OVOVIVIPARITY IN PULMONATES

Oviparity, egg retention and ovoviviparity are known to occurin pulmonates, but the few reports of true viviparity are unconfirmed.Oviparity is defined as the release of eggs as soon as theyare fully formed; they usually contain a single celled, fertilizedovum. Egg retention involves holding eggs for variable periodof time; ovoviviparity involves release of live young. The numerousvariations on the theme of egg retention or ovoviviparity areshown diagrammatically in an attempt to clarify the literature.These latter modes of reproduction are one method of avoidingegg desiccation in some snails, or are a method of carryingan extra rood during winter hibernation. Physiological adaptationsaccompanying ovoviviparity are not understood (Received 28 April 1978; revised 27 March 1979;     

Multi‐stage disruption of freshwater mussel reproduction by high suspended solids in short‐ and long‐term brooders

相似文献   

A likelihood method for detecting trait-dependent shifts in the rate of molecular evolution

Rate heterogeneity within groups of organisms is known to exist even when closely related taxa are examined. A wide variety of phylogenetic and dating methods have been developed that aim either to test for the existence of rate variation or to correct for its bias. However, none of the existing methods track the evolution of features that account for observed rate heterogeneity. Here, we present a likelihood model that assumes that rate variation is caused, in part, by species' intrinsic characteristics, such as a particular life-history trait, morphological feature, or habitat association. The model combines models of sequence and character state evolution such that rates of sequence change depend on the character state of a lineage at each point in time. We test, using simulations, the power and accuracy of the model to determine whether rates of molecular evolution depend on a particular character state and demonstrate its utility using an empirical example with halophilic and freshwater daphniids.     

Transitions between marine and freshwater environments provide new clues about the origins of multicellular plants and algae

Marine–freshwater and freshwater–marine transitions have been key events in the evolution of life, and most major groups of organisms have independently undergone such events at least once in their history. Here, we first compile an inventory of bidirectional freshwater and marine transitions in multicellular photosynthetic eukaryotes. While green and red algae have mastered multiple transitions in both directions, brown algae have colonized freshwater on a maximum of six known occasions, and angiosperms have made the transition to marine environments only two or three times. Next, we review the early evolutionary events leading to the colonization of current habitats. It is commonly assumed that the conquest of land proceeded in a sequence from marine to freshwater habitats. However, recent evidence suggests that early photosynthetic eukaryotes may have arisen in subaerial or freshwater environments and only later colonized marine environments as hypersaline oceans were diluted to the contemporary level. Although this hypothesis remains speculative, it is important to keep these alternative scenarios in mind when interpreting the current habitat distribution of plants and algae. Finally, we discuss the roles of structural and functional adaptations of the cell wall, reactive oxygen species scavengers, osmoregulation, and reproduction. These are central for acclimatization to freshwater or to marine environments. We observe that successful transitions appear to have occurred more frequently in morphologically simple forms and conclude that, in addition to physiological studies of euryhaline species, comparative studies of closely related species fully adapted to one or the other environment are necessary to better understand the adaptive processes.     

Life‐history strategy,with ctenidial and pallial larval brooding,of the troglodytic ‘living fossil’ Congeria kusceri (Bivalvia: Dreissenidae) from the subterranean Dinaric Alpine karst of Croatia

Among freshwater bivalves, the brooding of embryos and larvae within the maternal ctenidia is well known. Exceptions to this generalization are the non‐brooding freshwater and estuarine species of Dreissena and Mytilopsis, respectively. It was reported that the freshwater troglodytic cousin, Congeria kusceri Bole, 1962, of these dreissenids does not brood either. It is herein demonstrated that C. kusceri undergoes one reproductive cycle each year. Sexes are separate, with an early male and later female bias. A small percentage (2.14%) of individuals is hermaphroditic. The gonads mature over summer from May to November. Spawning commences in September, when females release mature oocytes into their ctenidia and inhale sperm from mature males. Here the oocytes are fertilized, and develop within interfilamentary marsupia. Ctenidial tissues glandularize, and may provide a source of maternal nutrition for the embryos. At the late prodissoconch‐1 or prodissoconch‐2 stage (PR2, ~220 μm), larvae are released into the infrabranchial chamber via a birth channel along the outer edge of the ventral marginal food groove of both inner demibranchs. Here, they are brooded further in mantle pouches located beneath the inhalant siphon. Subsequently, after the PR2 stage (nepioconch/dissoconch), they are released from the inhalant siphon and assume an independent life as crawling juveniles. Such juveniles may be found amongst clusters of adults. Not only is C. kusceri unique amongst the Dreissenidae in possessing the capacity to brood internally fertilized ova, but it is also exceptional amongst the Bivalvia in possessing the described methods of brooding and birth. Explanations for both lie in its troglodytic lifestyle, decadal length longevity and habitat: that of byssal attachment to the hard surfaces of underground freshwater rivers, caves, pits, and sinkholes in the Tethyan arc of the Dinaric karst. Internal fertilization of a few large yolky eggs, lecithotrophic larvae, ctenidial brooding, and secondary pallial parental care represent relatively recent, Late Miocene, evolutionary adaptations from a Tethyan lentic ancestor.     

THE EVOLUTION AND COMPARATIVE PHYSIOLOGY OF TERRESTRIAL AND FRESHWATER NEMERTEANS

(1) Parallel evolution from separate marine ancestors has given rise to two groups of genera of terrestrial nemerteans, representative of at least two different family stocks. They have colonized land by the direct route, moving up the shore on widely separated oceanic islands. The relationships between the known terrestrial and semi-terrestrial nemerteans, comprising seven genera and 15 species, are defined and their geographic distribution is discussed.
(2) In fresh water, three heteronemertean and nine hoplonemertean species are known. The hoplonemerteans arise from two different families representing two different evolutionary routes to fresh water, one by way of estuaries and the other via land. The distribution of freshwater nemerteans and the characters common to all species are discussed.
(3) Very little is known about the comparative physiology of land and freshwater nemerteans. However, information about the physiology of marine forms is combined with morphological differences from them found in terrestrial and freshwater species to suggest profitable lines of future research.
(4) Water relations pose a major problem for both terrestrial and freshwater nemerteans. The role of the cerebral organs, the blood and the excretory system in the osmotic physiology of some littoral nemerteans is beginning to be understood. These systems in land and freshwater forms have clearly distinctive features which need to be thoroughly investigated.
(5) Suggestions are given for valuable lines of investigation of the mucous glands, digestive physiology and general behaviour of terrestrial and freshwater nemerteans.     

Recreated Ancestral Opsin Associated with Marine to Freshwater Croaker Invasion Reveals Kinetic and Spectral Adaptation

Rhodopsin, the light-sensitive visual pigment expressed in rod photoreceptors, is specialized for vision in dim-light environments. Aquatic environments are particularly challenging for vision due to the spectrally dependent attenuation of light, which can differ greatly in marine and freshwater systems. Among fish lineages that have successfully colonized freshwater habitats from ancestrally marine environments, croakers are known as highly visual benthic predators. In this study, we isolate rhodopsins from a diversity of freshwater and marine croakers and find that strong positive selection in rhodopsin is associated with a marine to freshwater transition in South American croakers. In order to determine if this is accompanied by significant shifts in visual abilities, we resurrected ancestral rhodopsin sequences and tested the experimental properties of ancestral pigments bracketing this transition using in vitro spectroscopic assays. We found the ancestral freshwater croaker rhodopsin is redshifted relative to its marine ancestor, with mutations that recapitulate ancestral amino acid changes along this transitional branch resulting in faster kinetics that are likely to be associated with more rapid dark adaptation. This could be advantageous in freshwater due to the redshifted spectrum and relatively narrow interface and frequent transitions between bright and dim-light environments. This study is the first to experimentally demonstrate that positively selected substitutions in ancestral visual pigments alter protein function to freshwater visual environments following a transition from an ancestrally marine state and provides insight into the molecular mechanisms underlying some of the physiological changes associated with this major habitat transition.     

Messinian salinity crisis and the origin of freshwater lifestyle in western Mediterranean gobies

The present paper reports on a molecular study based on 12S rRNA and 16S rRNA mitochondrial genes partly sequenced in 13 species of western Mediterranean gobies, three of which are strictly freshwater-dwelling. A total of 867 bp were aligned and used for the phylogenetic reconstruction. Two major lineages were identified, one clustering the sand gobies in a monophyletic clade. Relationships among taxa based on sequence analysis only partly match those based on morphological criteria, suggesting that the latter are somehow insufficient to correctly establish phylogenetic relationships within this family. The results provide evidence for a multiple independent evolution of the freshwater lifestyle in Knipowitschia and Padogobius lineages. On the basis of the present results, it is uncertain whether the freshwater preference within the genus Padogobius originated twice independently in P. nigricans and P. martensii or only once in their common ancestor. Estimation of the ages of the two major lineages of this group of fish with a molecular clock (in combination with the construction of a linearized tree) suggests that they are much older (at least 40 Myr) than previously thought. Thus, there should be no correlation between their diversification and the Miocene-Pliocene geological events, including the so-called Messinian salinity crisis, which occurred about 10 MYA and is believed to have played a role in their evolution. Alternatively, these gobies would have an evolutionary rate at least fourfold faster than those of other vertebrates.     

Ecological constraint and the evolution of sexual dichromatism in darters

It is not known how environmental pressures and sexual selection interact to influence the evolution of extravagant male traits. Sexual and natural selection are often viewed as antagonistic forces shaping the evolution of visual signals, where conspicuousness is favored by sexual selection and crypsis is favored by natural selection. Although typically investigated independently, the interaction between natural and sexual selection remains poorly understood. Here, we investigate whether sexual dichromatism evolves stochastically, independent from, or in concert with habitat use in darters, a species‐rich lineage of North American freshwater fish. We find the evolution of sexual dichromatism is coupled to habitat use in darter species. Comparative analyses reveal that mid‐water darter lineages exhibit a narrow distribution of dichromatism trait space surrounding a low optimum, suggesting a constraint imposed on the evolution of dichromatism, potentially through predator‐mediated selection. Alternatively, the transition to benthic habitats coincides with greater variability in the levels of dichromatism that surround a higher optimum, likely due to relaxation of the predator‐mediated selection and heterogeneous microhabitat dependent selection regimes. These results suggest a complex interaction of sexual selection with potentially two mechanisms of natural selection, predation and sensory drive, that influence the evolution of diverse male nuptial coloration in darters.