The effect of restriction on shotgun cloning and plasmid stability in Bacillus subtilis Marburg

Summary Using the bifunctional cloning vehicle pHP13, which carries the replication functions of the cryptic Bacillus subtilis plasmid pTA1060, the effects of BsuM restriction on the efficiency of shotgun cloning of heterologous Escherichia coli DNA were studied. In a restriction-deficient but modification-proficient mutant of B. subtilis, clones were obtained at a high frequency, comparable to frequencies normally obtained in E. coli (10⁴ clones per g target DNA). Large inserts were relatively abundant (26% of the clones contained inserts in the range of 6 to 15 kb), which resulted in a high average insert length (3.6 kb). In the restriction-proficient B. subtilis strain, the class of large inserts was underrepresented. Transformation of B. subtilis with E. coli-derived individual recombinant plasmids was affected by BsuM restriction in two ways. First, the transforming activities of recombinant plasmids carrying inserts larger than 4 kb, were, in comparison with the vector pHP13, reduced to varying degrees in the restricting host. The levels of the reduction increased with insert length, resulting in a 7800-fold reduction for the largest plasmid used (pC23; insert length 16 kb). Second, more than 80% of the pC23 transformants in the restricting strain contained a deleted plasmid. In the non-restricting strain, the transforming activities of the plasmids were fairly constant as a function of insert length (in the range of 0–16 kb), and no structural instability was observed. It is concluded that for shotgun cloning in B. subtilis, the use of restriction-deficient strains is highly preferable. Evidence is presented that in addition to XhoI other sequences are involved in BsuM restriction. It is postulated that AsuII sites are additional target sites for BsuM restriction.     

Release of transforming plasmid and chromosomal DNA from two cultured soil bacteria

The release of chromosomal and plasmid DNA from Acinetobacter calcoaceticus and Bacillus subtilis cultivated in minimal medium and broth over a period of 50 h was monitored and related to growth phase, autolysis, DNase production and natural competence. The released DNAs were biologically active in natural transformation. In addition, the circular integrity of a released B. subtilis shuttle vector (pHV14) was demonstrated by artificial transformation of Escherichia coli. In cultures of both strains high molecular weight DNA accumulated, particularly during the stationary and death phase (up to 30 g ml^-1). Generally, despite the presence in culture fluids of DNase activity (and of an intracellular enzyme, catalase, indicating some cell lysis) there was high transforming activity of chromsomal and plasmid DNA even 40 h after the cultures reached the stationary phase. In cultures of B. subtilis in minimal medium a presumably active release of intact plasmids and chromsomal DNA occurred during the competence phase. The release of biologically functional DNA during essentially all growth phases of a gram-positive and a gram-negative member of soil bacteria might facilitate horizontal gene transfer by transformation in natural habitats.     

A method for the deletion of restriction sites in bacterial plasmid deoxyribonucleic acid

Summary A general method has been developed for the deletion of restriction endonuclease sites in bacterial plasmid DNA. The procedure involves partial digestion of the covalently closed circular plasmid DNA with an appropriate restriction endonuclease under conditions which allow accumulation of unit-length linear DNA molecules, controlled digestion of the exposed 5 ends with the 5-exonuclease, and in vivo recircularization of the resulting linear DNA in a bacterial host cell. The method has been used for the deletion of one of the two EcoRI sites in the plasmid pML2 (colE1-Km). Two of the resulting plasmids, pCR1 and pCR11, have a single EcoRI cleavage site, but retain genetic determinants specifying resistance to colicin E1 and kanamycin, and thus may be useful as vectors for the cloning and amplification of DNA in bacteria.     

Molecular cloning of Bacillus subtilis genes involved in DNA metabolism

Summary Different clones carrying a chromosomal DNA fragment able to transform Bacillus subtilis mutants dnaA13, dnaB19, dnaG5, recG40 and polA42 to a wild-type phenotype were isolated from a library constructed in plasmid pJH101. A recombinant clone carrying a chromosomal fragment able to transform dnaC mutants was obtained from a Charon 4A library. A restriction map of the cloned DNA fragments was constructed. The 11.3 kb cloned DNA fragment of plasmid pMP60-13 containing the wild-type sequence of dnaG5 was shown to transform a recF33 mutant as well.     

Characterization of plasmid transformation in Bacillus subtilis: kinetic properties and the effect of DNA conformation.

Summary Transformation of competent cells of Bacillus subtilis with antibiotic resistance plasmid DNA has shown that (a) competence for plasmid and chromosomal DNA develops with similar kinetics; (b) DNA linearized with a variety of restriction endonucleases does not transform; (c) CCC plasmid DNA is inactivated for transformation by a single nick; (d) T4 ligase restores transforming activity to both nicked and linearized DNA; (e) CCC relaxed DNA is fully active in transformation; (f) the DNA concentration-dependence of plasmid transformation is first order; and (g) plasmid transformation proceeds with a low efficiency, requiring the uptake of 10³ to 10⁴ DNA molecules per transformant.Based on this information, a model for the processing of chromosomal, plasmid and transfecting DNA is proposed.Abbreviations Cm Chloramphenicol - Em erythromycin - Km kanamycin - Sm streptomycin - CCC covalently closed circular - TBAB tryptose blood agar base - NCE nicking and closing enzyme In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the doctoral degree in the Department of Microbiology at the New York University School of Medicine, for S.C.     

Novel plasmid marker rescue transformation system for molecular cloning in Bacillus subtilis enabling direct selection of recombinants

Summary A versatile plasmid marker rescue transformation system was developed for homology-facilitated cloning in Bacillus subtilis. It is based on the highly efficient host-vector system 6GM15-pHPS9, which allows the direct selection of recombinants by means of -galactosidase -complementation. The system offers several advantages over previously described cloning systems: (1) the convenient direct selection of recombinants; (2) the ability to effectively transform B. subtilis competent cells with plasmid monomers, which allows the forced cloning of DNA fragments with high efficiency; (3) the availability of 6 unique target sites, which can be used for direct clone selection, SphI, NdeI, NheI, BamHI, SmaI and EcoRI; and (4) the rapid segregational loss of the helper plasmid from the transformed cells.     

Genetic Characterization of a New Thermotolerant Bacillus licheniformis Strain

A potentially new thermotolerant B. licheniformis strain (code name I89), producer of an antibiotic active against Gram-positive bacteria, was genetically characterized and compared with the type strain B. licheniformis ATCC 10716, producer of bacitracin. Studies on DNA base composition (G + C content) and DNA reassociation revealed that the two strains show around 76% homology. Nevertheless, results obtained by rRNA hybridization, with a heterologous probe coding for most of the 16S region of the rRNA operon of Bacillus subtilis, revealed differences in the number of copies for that gene and in the hybridization pattern. Additionally, a different restriction digestion pattern was obtained when DNA was digested with the enzymes NotI, SmaI and analyzed by PFGE. The I89 strain holds a 7.6-kb plasmid not present in the reference strain. The existence of various unique restriction sites and also the stability of this plasmid make it ideal for the future development of a cloning and expression vector. Received: 29 June 1999 / Accepted: 1 September 1999     

High frequency transformation of Bacillus subtilis protoplasts by plasmid DNA.

Summary A highly efficient method for transformation of Bacillus subtilis by plasmid DNA is reported. The procedure, which involves polyethylene glycolinduced DNA uptake by protoplasts and subsequent regeneration of the bacterial cell wall, yields up to 80% transformants with an efficiency of 4x10⁷ transformants per g of supercoiled DNA. Plasmids constructed by in vitro ligation or endonuclease-generated fragments of linear plasmid DNA can also transform PEG-treated protoplasts, but at a lower frequency.     

Integration and excision of a plasmid in Bacillus subtilis

Summary We have studied the behaviour in Bacillus subtilis of a plasmid (pPV21) carrying the thymidylate synthetase gene of phage 3T (thyP3). The plasmid can transform efficiently the competent cells of all the strains tested. Polyethylene glycol (PEG)-mediated protoplast transformation is efficient only for recE, recD or recF mutants. When present in recombination proficient strains, the plasmid can be integrated into the chromosome, primarily at the thyA locus. This has been shown by genetic mapping and by blot-hybridization. A second less efficient site is at (or near to) the attachment site of phage 3T. Excision of the plasmid restores the EcoRI restriction pattern of the parental DNA, although with the loss of the defective thyA endogenotic allele and the retention of the thyP exogenotic gene.     

A quantitative analysis of shotgun cloning in Bacillus subtilis protoplasts

Summary We used the Escherichia coli-Bacillus subtilis shuttle vector pHP13, which carries the replication functions of the cryptic B. subtilis plasmid pTA1060, to study the effects of BsuM restriction, plasmid size and DNA concentration on the efficiency of shotgun cloning of heterologous E. coli DNA in B. subtilis protoplasts. In a restriction-deficient strain, clones were obtained with low frequency (19% of the transformants contained a recombinant plasmid) and large inserts (>6 kb) were relatively rare (12% of the clones contained inserts in the range of 6–9 kb). The efficiency of shotgun cloning was severely reduced in restricting protoplasts: the class of large inserts (>6 kb) was under-represented in the clone bank (4% of the clones contained inserts in the range of 6–6.1 kb). Furthermore, BsuM restriction caused structural instability of some recombinant plasmids. Transformation of protoplasts with individual recombinant plasmids showed that plasmid size and transforming activity were negatively correlated. The size effect was most extreme with cut and religated plasmid DNA. The yield of clones was independent of the DNA concentration during transformation. It is therefore unlikely that clones were not detected because of simultaneous uptake of more than one plasmid. It is concluded that shotgun cloning in B. subtilis protoplasts is inferior to that in competent cells.     

Isolation of a DNA sequence related to several plasmids from Bacillus thuringiensis after a mating involving the Streptococcus faecalis plasmid pAM beta 1

Summary The transmissible plasmid pAM1, which codes for resistance to erythromycin and lincomycin, was transferred from Streptococcus faecalis to several strains of Bacillus thuringiensis by a filter-mating process. Introduction of pAM1 into the Em^r transconjugant strains of B. thuringiensis was confirmed by Southern hybridisation using the ³²P-labelled pAM1 as a probe. In the B. thuringiensis transconjugant strains, used as donors, the plasmid conserved its ability to be transferred during intraspecific mating, with a frequency of 10^-4 per recipient cell. In addition, the transconjugant clones acted as donors of the erythromycin resistance marker and permitted the transfer of cryptic plasmids present in the B. thuringiensis () strains used as donors. From a transconjugant clone of B. thuringiensis a hybrid plasmid resulting from an in vivo insertion into pAM1 of a 3 Md DNA sequence was isolated. This 3 Md DNA molecule originated from a 54 Md plasmid of a kurstaki strain and is related to several plasmids found in different serotypes of B. thuringiensis.Abbreviations cry^– acrystalliferous mutant - CCC covalently closed circular DNA - Md megadalton - EMS ethyl methanesulphonate     

Characterization of chromosome and plasmid transformation in Bacillus subtilis using gently lysed protoplasts

Competent cells of Bacillus subtilis were transformed with DNA from gently lysed protoplasts. Significant linkages among markers separated by distances of approximately 2.3% of the total chromosome were found, which have not been detected for conventional transformation. In comparison to previous reports, enhanced plasmid transformation was observed [4.0×10⁷ transformants per g DNA (one transformant per 5×10⁴ molecules added)], when competent cells were transformed with DNA from lysed protoplasts harboring pUB110.     

Physical structure and genetic expression of the sulfonamide-resistance plasmid pLS80 and its derivatives in Streptococcus pneumoniae and Bacillus subtilis

Summary The 10-kb chromosomal fragment of Streptococus pneumoniae cloned in pLS80 contains the sul-d allele of the pneumococcal gene for dihydropteroate synthase. As a single copy in the chromosome this allele confers resistance to sulfanilamide at 0.2 mg/ml; in the multicopy plasmid it confers resistance to 2.0 mg/ml. The sul-d mutation was mapped by restriction analysis to a 0.4-kb region. By the mechanism of chromosomal facilitation, in which the chromosome restores information to an entering plasmid fragment, a BamHI fragment missing the sul-d region of pLS80 established the full-sized plasmid, but with the sul-s allele of the recipient chromosome.A spontaneous deletion beginning 1.5 kb to the right of the sul-d mutation prevented gene function, possibly by removing a promoter. This region could be restored by chromosomal facilitation and be demonstrated in the plasmid by selection for sulfonamide resistance. Under selection for a vector marker, tetracycline resistance, only the deleted plasmid was detectable, apparently as a result of plasmid segregation and the advantageous growth rates of cells with smaller plasmids. When such cells were selected for sulfonamide resistance, the deleted region returned to the plasmid, presumably by equilibration between the chromosome and the plasmid pool, to give a low frequency (10^-3) of cells resistant to sulfanilamide at 2.0 mg/ml. Models for the mechanisms of chromosomal facilitation and equilibration are proposed.Several derivatives of pLS80 could be transferred to Bacillus subtilis, where they conferred resistance to sulfanil-amide at 2 mg/ml, thereby demonstrating cross-species expression of the pneumococcal gene. Transfer of the plasmids to B. subtilis gave rise to large deletions to the left of the sul-d marker, but these deletions did not interfere with the sul-d gene function. Restriction maps of pLS80 and its variously deleted derivatives are presented.     

A bifunctional plasmid carrying the recA gene of E. coli

Summary To investigate the effect of an active, plasmid-carried recA gene on the stability and/or the expression of plasmid genes in different genetic backgrounds, we have constructed a bifunctional plasmid (able to replicate in Escherichia coli and in Bacillus subtilis). Chimeric plasmids were obtained by inserting pC194 (Ehrlich 1977) into pDR1453 (Sancar and Rupp 1979). pDR1453 is a 12.9 Kbp plasmid constructed by inserting an E. coli chromosome fragment carrying the recA gene into pBR322. The expected bifunctional recombinant (pMR22/1) (15.7 Kbp) was easily obtained but surprisingly the Cm resistance was expressed only at a very low level in E. coli (as compared, for example, to pHV14, pHV15). We attribute this effect to the presence of multiple recA genes in the cell. On the contrary, Cm^r E. coli transformants bear a recombinant plasmid (pMR22/n) containing tandemly repeated copies of pC194 in equilibrium with excised free pC194. Such amplification has never been observed in a Rec^- background and is therefore mediated by the recA genes. Growth of these clones in the absence of Cm causes the loss of the extra copies, yielding a plasmid with a single copy of pC194, indistingishable from pMR22/1. Interestingly, we have observed that deletions occur at high frequency in pC194, which drastically increase Cm^r in E. coli containing plasmids with a single copy of pC194. Two types of such deletions were detected: (a) large 1050 bp deletions covering about onethird of pC194 and (b) small 120–150 bp deletions (near the MspI site) in the region containing the replicative functions of pC194 (Horinouchi and Weisblum 1982). Both types of deletion render the recombinant plasmid unable to replicate in B. subtilis. pM22/1 replicates, although with a low copy-number, and is stable in B. subtilis wild type; the recA gene of E. coli does not complement any of the rec ^- mutations of B. subtilis. A strong instability, mainly of the E. coli and pBR322 sequences, was observed in many dna and rec mutants of B. subtilis yielding smaller plasmid with a much higher copy-number.     

Physical mapping of Bacillus subtilis phage rho14 cloning vehicles: heteroduplex and restriction enzyme analyses

Summary Four deletion mutants of temperate Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage 14 have been examined utilizing restriction enzyme and DNA heteroduplex methods. This has allowed the orientation and mapping of the deletions on the 14 physical map. A continuous 15% of the genome contains functions not essential for bacteriophage viability. A 7% subsection section of this region contains phage immunity functions. The deletions were found to range in size from about 2.2–3.3 kilobases. In addition, the deletion mutants retain a single Sal I restriction site, which is currently being used as a cloning site for recombinant DNA. We have located the Sal I site to be 400 basepairs from the immunity region. Thus, the clear-and turbid-plaque deletion mutants are all capable of being utilized as molecular cloning vehicles for Bacillus subtilis.     

High-frequency transformation ofLactobacillus casei with plasmid pHY300PLK by electroporation

To optimize the conditions for transformation ofLactobacillus casei ATCC 27092 cells with plasmid pHY300PLK, a shuttle vector forEscherichia coli andBacillus subtilis, by electroporation, we investigated the effects of the electrical parameters (voltage and resistance), the concentration of plasmid DNA, the cell age and density, the electroporation buffer, and other factors. Under optimal conditions of 2.0 kV, 100 ohm, and 25F, a transformation efficiency as high as 1.4×10⁷ transformants per g of plasmid DNA was obtained, with a survival rate of about 50%.L. casei YIT 9021, one of the PL-1 phage mutants of the ATCC 27092 strain, was also transformed with the same plasmid under optimal conditions. The transformants were confirmed to harbor the same intact plasmid molecules by agarose gel electrophoretic analysis.     

Restriction and modification in Bacillus subtilis Marburg 168: target sites and effects on plasmid transformation

Summary The effects of the restriction system of Bacillus subtilis strain M on plasmid transformation were studied. Plasmid pHV1401 DNA prepared from B. subtilis transformed the restriction-proficient M strain 100 times more efficiently than the DNA prepared from Escherichia coli, while the two DNA preparations transformed restriction-deficient derivatives of that strain with similar efficiencies. This indicates that transformation with pHV1401 is sensitive to the M restriction system. pHV1401 contains three CTCGAG (XhoI sites). Successive removal of these abolished the effect of restriction. This indicates that the XhoI sites are the targets for the M restriction system.Abbreviations used Ap^r resistance to ampicillin - Cm^r resistance to chloramphenicol - R/M restriction and modification - Tc^r resistance to tetracycline     

Cloning of sporulation gene spoIVC in Bacillus subtilis

Summary Sporulation gene spoIVC of Bacillus subtilis was cloned by the prophage transformation method in temperate phage 105. The specialized transducing phage, 105spoIVC-1, restored the sporulation of the asporogenous mutant of B. subtilis strain 1S47 (spoIVC133). Transformation experiments showed that the spoIVC gene resides on a 7.3 kb HindIII restriction fragment. Subsequent analysis of the 7.3 kb HindIII fragment with restriction endonuclease EcoRI showed that the spoIVC gene resides on a 3.6 kb EcoRI fragment within the 7.3 kb fragment. The 3.6 kb fragment was recloned into the unique EcoRI site of plasmid pUB110 and deletion derivatives having a deletion within the 3.6 kb insert were constructed. The plasmid carrying the entire spoIVC gene restored the sporulation of strain HU1214 (spoIVC133, recE4) at a frequency of 10⁷ spores/ml, and reduced the sporulation of strain HU1018 (spo ⁺, recE4) to 10⁷ spores/ml.     

In vitro genetic labeling of Bacillus subtilis cryptic plasmid pHV400.

A DNA segment which encodes resistance to tetracycline, and cannot replicate autonomously, was excised by HindIII endonuclease from plasmid pT127 and joined to the cryptic Bacillus subtilis plasmid pHV400. The analysis of resulting chimerae has allowed us to identify a 1.8 × 10⁶ segment of pHV400 which carried the replication functions of the cryptic plasmid. Another DNA segment, designated pHV32, which can replicate in Escherichia coli but not in B. subtilis has also been used for genetic labeling of the replication region of pHV400. pHV32 is convenient for use in isolating cryptic replicons active in B. subtilis because (1) it can be prepared in large quantities, free from any interferring B. subtilis replicons, from an appropriate E. coli strain; (2) it carries unique sites for various restriction endonucleases; (3) the chloramphenicol resistance gene which it specifies can transform B. subtilis at a high efficiency (10⁶–10⁷ transformants/μg of DNA).     

Structure and function of the region of the replication origin of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome

Summary A BamHI restriction endonuclease fragment, B7, which is replicated first among all other fragments derived from the Bacillus subtilis chromosome, was cloned in Escherichia coli using as vector a hybrid plasmid pMS102 that can replicate both in E. coli and B. subtilis. Digestion of pMS102 with BamHI produced two fragments and the smaller one was replaced by the B7 fragment.The cloned plasmid pMS102-B7 exhibited some peculiar properties that were not observed with plasmids containing other fragments from the B. subtilis chromosome. (1) E. coli cells harboring this plasmid stuck to each other and to glass. This property was more apparent when cells were grown in poor media. (2) E. coli cells tended to lose the plasmid spontaneously when they were grown without the selective pressure favorable to the plasmid. (3) The frequency of transformation of B. subtilis by pMS102-B7 was less than 1/1,000 of that by the vector plasmid pMS102. The number of copies of pMS102-B7 present in the transformants was also markedly reduced, although the pUB110 origin of replication on the vector was intact and should be functional in B. subtilis. This inhibitory effect of the B7 fragment on plasmid replication was confirmed more directly by developing a semi in vitro replication system using protoplasts.Both in E. coli and B. subtilis the B7 fragment affected replication of its own molecule but not that of the coexisting plasmid with an identical replication system. The implication of the function of the B7 fragment in the initiation of the B. subtilis chromosome will be discussed.