Evolutionary and experimental change in egg volume, heterochrony of larval body and juvenile rudiment, and evolutionary reversibility in pluteus form

SUMMARY Heterochronic developmental plasticity of the juvenile rudiment and larval body of sea urchin larvae occurs in response to supply of food. Evolutionary increase in egg size can also be associated with earlier development of the juvenile rudiment. We examined effects of egg volume of feeding larvae on this heterochrony and other changes in larval form. (1) Evolutionary and experimental enlargements of egg volume did not accelerate formation of the rudiment relative to the larval body. Development of the larval body and juvenile rudiment was compared for the echinoids Strongylocentrotus purpuratus (with an egg of 78–82 μm) and Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis (with an egg of 150–160 μm diameter). Development of both larval body and rudiment were accelerated in S. droebachiensis relative to S. purpuratus but with greater acceleration of the larval body, so that the rudiment of S. droebachiensi s was initiated at a later larval stage even though at an earlier age. Also, experimentally doubling the egg volume of S. purpuratus did not accelerate development of the juvenile rudiment relative to the larval body. (2) Both species exhibited similar plasticity in timing of rudiment development in response to food supplies. (3) Doubling egg volume of S. purpuratus produced a larval form more similar to that of S. droebachiensis . This result mirrors previous experiments in which larvae from half embryos of S. droebachiensis were more similar to larvae of S. purpuratus . Many of the effects of egg volume on larval form are similar against either species' genetic background and are thus evolutionarily reversible effects on larval form.     

Development of the nervous system in the brittle star Amphipholis kochii

There are several studies of neural development in various echinoderms, but few on ophiuroids, which develop indirectly via the production of pluteus larvae, as do echinoids. To determine the extent of similarity of neuroanatomy and neural development in the ophiuroids with other echinoderm larvae, we investigated the development of the nervous system in the brittle star Amphipholis kochii (Echinodermata: Ophiuroidea) by immunohistochemistry. Immunoreactive cells first appeared bilaterally in the animal pole at the late gastrula stage, and there was little migration of the neural precursors during A. kochii ontogeny, as is also the case in echinoids and holothuroids. On the other hand, neural specification in the presumptive ciliary band near the base of the arms does occur in ophiuroid larvae and is a feature they share with echinoids and ophiuroids. The ophiopluteus larval nervous system is similar to that of auricularia larvae on the whole, including the lack of a fine network of neurites in the epidermis and the presence of neural connections across the oral epidermis. Ophioplutei possess a pair of bilateral apical organs that differ from those of echinoid echinoplutei in terms of relative position. They also possess coiled cilia, which may possess a sensory function, but in the same location as the serotonergic apical ganglia. These coiled cilia are thought to be a derived structure in pluteus-like larvae. Our results suggest that the neural specification in the animal plate in ophiuroids, holothuroids, and echinoids is a plesiomorphic feature of the Ambulacraria, whereas neural specification at the base of the larval arms may be a more derived state restricted to pluteus-like larvae.     

Echinoderms from Marino Ballena National Park, Pacific, Costa Rica

A total of 25 species of echinoderms (four asteroids, six ophiuroids, five echinoids and ten holothurians) were recorded at Marino Ballena National Park, using 25 m2 quadrants, parallel to the coast, at seven sites. The ophiuroids were the most abundant group with 581 individuals and the asteroids the less abundant (48 individuals). Echinoderms densities were low, with the exception of the ophiuroids. Diversity, density and the number of groups were higher where sedimentation was lower. We suggest that sedimentation is having a negative effect on the diversity of echinoderms and on the development of the coral reefs in this park.     

Electron microscopic study of the cortical reaction of an ophiuroid echinoderm.

The egg coats of an ophiuroid echinoderm (Ophiopholis aculeata) are described by electron microscopy before and after fertilization. The unfertilized egg is closely invested by a vitelline coat about 40 A thick, and the peripheral cytoplasm is crowded with cortical granules five or six deep. During the cortical reaction, which rapidly follows insemination, exocytosis of cortical granules takes place. Some of the cortical granule material is evidently added to the vitelline coat to form a composite structure, the fertilization envelope, which is made up of a 400 A thick middle layer separating inner and outer dense layers, each about 50 A thick. The elevation of the fertilization envelope from the egg surface creates a perivitelline space in which the hyaline layer soon forms. The hyaline layer is about 2 micron thick, finely granular, and apparently derived from cortical granule material. The extracellular layers of the early developmental stages of ophiuroids and echinoids are quite similar in comparison to those of asteroids; this finding helps support Hyman's argument that the ophiuroids are more closely related to the echinoids than to the asteroids.     

Resolving phylogenetic signal from noise when divergence is rapid: a new look at the old problem of echinoderm class relationships

Resolving evolutionary relationships in groups that underwent fast radiation in deep time is a problem for molecular phylogeny, as the scant phylogenetic signal that characterises short internal branches is generally swamped by more recent substitutions. We implement an approach, that maps how the support for rival phylogenies changes when analysing subsets of sites with either faster and more heterogeneous rates or slower and more homogeneous rates, to address a long-standing problem in deuterostome phylogeny - the interrelationships of the eleutherozoan echinoderm classes. We show that miRNA genes are phylogenetically uninformative as to the relationships of asteroids, echinoids and ophiuroids, consistent with a rapid radiation of these groups as suggested by their fossil record. Using three nuclear rRNAs and seven nuclear housekeeping genes, we map the support for the three possible phylogenetic arrangements of asteroids, ophiuroids and echinoids when moving between subsets of the data with very similar or very different rates of evolution. Only one of the three possible topologies (asteroids (ophiuroids + echinoids)) strengthens when the most rate-homogeneous subset of data are analysed. The other two possible pairings become stronger in a less reliable data subset, which includes the fastest and thus homoplasy-rich data in our alignment. Thus, while superficial analysis of our concatenated alignment identifies asteroids and ophiuroids as sister taxa, more thorough analyses suggest that ophiuroids may be more closely related to echinoids. Divergence of these echinoderm groups, using a relaxed molecular clock, is estimated to have occurred within ∼5 million years. Our results illustrate that the analytic approach of phylogenetic signal dissection can be a powerful tool to investigate rapid radiations in deep geologic time.     

Comparative Morphology of Echinoderm Sperm and Possible Phylogenetic Implications

The sperm morphology of at least 7 crinoids, 11 ophiuroids,23 asteroids, 23 holothuroids, and 37 echinoids is known. Forall the known crinoids, ophiuroids, and asteroids, the spermare spherical, while those of echinoids are conical. Holothuroidsperm are basically spherical, with two exceptions: cylindricalin Cucumaria lubrica and tabloid in Cucumaria pseudocurata.The possible implications of sperm morphology in the mode offertilization and in echinoderm phylogeny are discussed.     

Peptidergic and serotonergic immunoreactivity in the metamorphosing ophiopluteus of Ophiactis resiliens (Echinodermata, Ophiuroidea)

Abstract. Antibodies against the echinoderm-specific neuropeptide S1 and against 5HT were used to examine the fate of the larval nervous system during metamorphosis in the ophiuroid Ophiactis resiliens . In contrast to most echinoderms, the onset of peptidergic and serotonergic expression was delayed to the advanced ophiopluteus stage, in particular for 5HT. In advanced ophioplutei, peptidergic immunoreactivity was located in simple fibres associated with the ciliated bands, a stomach nerve ring, and cells along the antero-lateral arms. 5HT immunoreactivity was concentrated in 2 oral ganglia in the adoral projections, located at the posterior rim of the mouth. Clusters of 5HT-positive cells were also found along the antero-lateral arms. The ophiopluteus lacked a serotonergic (or peptidergic) anterior ganglion. In echinoids, holothuroids, and crinoids, anterior ganglia are thought to have a sensory role in settlement and metamorphosis. Given that ophioplutei metamorphose in the plankton and that larval structures degenerate before settlement, the absence of apical ganglia correlates with the lack of a functional role for larval structures in substrate selection and settlement. Although most of the larval nervous system degenerated during metamorphosis, the adoral projections and associated oral ganglia appeared to be incorporated into the juvenile mouth, suggesting a potential role for larval neurons in contributing to oral neuronal structures in the adult. S1-positive neurons and fibres in the rudiment developed de novo and in parallel with development of the epineural canal. This structure gives rise to the primordia of the adult circumoral nerve ring and radial nerves, indicating that differentiation of the adult nervous system begins in the early stages of metamorphosis.     

LiCl inhibits the establishment of left-right asymmetry in larvae of the direct-developing echinoid Peronella japonica

The effect of LiCl on the establishment of left-right (LR) asymmetry in larvae of the direct-developing echinoid Peronella japonica was investigated with special attention to the location of the amniotic opening and ciliary band pattern. The larvae of echinoids are LR symmetric, but shortly before metamorphosis the larval LR symmetry is lost as a result of the formation of an amniotic cavity (vestibule), part of the adult rudiment, on the left side of the body. P. japonica has been considered to be the only exception among the echinoids, because the amniotic cavity forms at the midline of the larval body. In the present study we discovered the following two different LR asymmetric traits in larvae of P. japonica: the opening of the amniotic cavity initially forms at the midline of the larval body but shifts to the left dorsal side, and a looped ciliary band that initially forms with LR symmetry becomes LR asymmetric as a result of the formation of a bulge on left dorsal side. The establishment of LR asymmetry in both the location of the amniotic opening and the change in the shape of the ciliary band was influenced by exposing embryos to LiCl. Quantitative analysis of the shift in amniotic opening showed that exposure of embryos to LiCl causes repression of leftward shifting of the amniotic opening in earlier stage larvae, and leftward or rightward shifting in later stage larvae. These findings suggest that LiCl is an effective means of impairing the establishment of LR asymmetry in sea urchin embryos.     

Ontogeny of the holothurian larval nervous system: evolution of larval forms

Echinoderm larvae share numerous features of neuroanatomy. However, there are substantial differences in specific aspects of neural structure and ontogeny between the dipleurula-like larvae of asteroids and the pluteus larvae of echinoids. To help identify apomorphic features, we have examined the ontogeny of the dipleurula-like auricularia larva of the sea cucumber, Holothuria atra. Neural precursors arise in the apical ectoderm of gastrulae and appear to originate in bilateral clusters of cells. The cells differentiate without extensive migration, and they align with the developing ciliary bands and begin neurogenesis. Neurites project along the ciliary bands and do not appear to extend beneath either the oral or aboral epidermis. Apical serotonergic cells are associated with the preoral loops of the ciliary bands and do not form a substantial commissure. Paired, tripartite connectives form on either side of the larval mouth that connect the pre-oral, post-oral, and lateral ciliary bands. Holothurian larvae share with hemichordates and bipinnariae a similar organization of the apical organ, suggesting that the more highly structured apical organ of the pluteus is a derived feature. However, the auricularia larva shares with the pluteus larva of echinoids several features of neural ontogeny. Both have a bilateral origin of neural precursors in ectoderm adjacent to presumptive ciliary bands, and the presumptive neurons move only a few cell diameters before undergoing neurogenesis. The development of the holothurian nervous systems suggests that the extensive migration of neural precursors in asteroids is a derived feature. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

On the sites of secondary podia formation in a juvenile echinoid: growth of the body types in echinoderms

The growth of the adult echinoderm body is addressed here in the echinoid Holopneustes purpurescens in a study of the early development of the secondary podia along the five radial canals of the adult rudiment. At a stage when the first four secondary podia have formed along each radius oral to the primary podium, two podia are on one side of the radius and two are on the other side, all at a different distance from the primary podium. The pattern of the connexions of these secondary podia to the radial canals changes in successive radii in a manner similar to Lovén’s law for skeletal plates and matches the reported sequence in the times at which the first ambulacral skeletal plates form in the adult echinoid rudiment. A similar pattern is described for the reported origins of the secondary podia in apodid holothurians. A common plan for the growth of the body types is described for echinoids, asteroids, holothurians and concentricycloids. The five metameric series of secondary podia formed in echinoderms have a coelomic developmental origin like the single metameric series of somites formed in the axial structures of chordates.     

Larval growth and perimetamorphosis in the echinoid <Emphasis Type="Italic">Echinocardium cordatum</Emphasis> (Echinodermata): the spatangoid way to become a sea urchin

The prejuvenile development of Echinocardium cordatum (Echinoidea) was investigated by means of scanning electron, confocal and light microscopes, aiming to illustrate the early life history of a spatangoid representative and to compare it with the other major echinoid groups. During the larval development of E. cordatum, two periods follow one another. The first one takes 12 days; it ends with the formation of a complete echinopluteus with twelve elongated larval arms. The second lasts from 3 to 12 days; it is entirely devoted to the building of the echinid rudiment and ends with the acquisition of larval competence. No appendage other than arms develops at the larva’s outer surface. Competent larvae are demersal. They settle onto the substratum and test it for suitability using the five rudiment podia that protrude through the vestibule opening. Metamorphosis is a rapid event that lasts less than an hour. The rudiment does not everse and its spines and podia actively tear up the larval epidermis which is progressively covered by the growing vestibular epidermis. The resulting postlarva is short-lived and morphologically similar to both the late rudiment and the early juvenile, which, however, is exotrophic. Late rudiments in E. cordatum show basic spatangoid features being bilaterally symmetric and having clavulae and sphaeridia. More importantly, they already have the convex shape and the appendage cover of early juveniles. Metamorphosis in E. cordatum appears to be less complex, i.e. no rudiment is everted, and more complete, since, in contrast to “regular” echinoids, no transitory appendages are seen. Metamorphosis/development of E. cordatum, thus, is closer to that of clypeasteroids, since the rudiment of the latter already bears juvenile definitive appendages, when everted during metamorphsis.     

Potential for paired vestibules in plutei (Echinodermata, Echinoidea)

Abstract. Echinoids are generally thought to develop only a single ectodermal invagination (V1), which expands into a vestibule and contributes to the formation of the juvenile rudiment on the left side of the larval body. However, in 2 echinoid species, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus and Dendraster excentricus, a second invagination (V2) was observed to form on the right side of the larval body exactly opposite V1. Formation of the invaginations was followed and characterized using light microscopy and antibodies directed against the S2amide echinoderm neuropeptide as a morphological tag. V2 consistently formed later than V1, and appeared capable of contributing to the formation of a second rudiment when it received the appropriate mesodermal influence from contact with a hydrocoel. Otherwise, in both species, V2 formed a skeletal element that has not been previously described in this location. Because of the location, shape, and timing of its formation, V2, like V1, appears to have the innate ability of the larval ectoderm to contribute to juvenile rudiment formation.     

Vestigial ophiopluteal structures in the lecithotrophic larvae of Ophionereis schayeri (Ophiuroidea)

Evolution of echinoderm development from a feeding to a non-feeding mode can be examined by studying non-feeding larvae with structures that appear to be vestiges derived from a feeding ancestral state. The lecithotrophic larvae of the Australian brittle star Ophionereis schayeri possess such features, and the early development of this species was documented by light and scanning electron microscopy. The embryos undergo irregular cleavage, resulting in the formation of different sized blastomeres, with subsequent development through a wrinkled blastula stage. The lecithotrophic larva of O. schayeri possesses several vestigial ophiopluteal structures, including a continuous ciliated band, a larval gut, and a larval skeleton. The ciliated band is a reduced expression of the continuous ciliated band typical of ophioplutei. The larval gut is a transiently complete system, but an esophageal plug and rapid closure of the blastopore renders it nonfunctional. The larval skeleton, though reduced, consists of four rods corresponding to the body, posterolateral, anterolateral, and postoral rods characteristic of an ophiopluteus. Due to a heterochrony in larval skeletogenesis, the postoral rods develop early and simultaneously with the other rods. Compared with the larvae of other lecithotrophic ophiuroids, the larva of O. schayeri is one of the most reduced ophiopluteal forms reported to date.     

Toxicity of shallow-water Antarctic echinoderms

Summary The toxicity of 23 species of shallow-water antarctic echinoderms from McMurdo Sound was investigated using Gambusia affinis (Vertebrata: Pisces) as a test organism. Ichthyotoxicity assays were conducted on the body wall tissues of thirteen species of asteroids and three species of holothuroids, the tests of three species of echinoids and the arms of three species of ophiuroids and one species of crinoid. Patterns of toxicity were class-specific, with varying degrees of toxicity occurring exclusively among the Asteroidea and Holothuroidea. Seven of the thirteen species of asteroids were mildly to highly toxic (54%), while one of the three holothuroids was mildly and one highly toxic. Toxicity was not related to the level of calcification of the body wall and energy level in asteroids. The only armored asteroid, Notasterias armata, was non-toxic. The occurrence of toxins in the body tissues of antarctic echinoderms is similar in pattern and frequency with that of temperate and tropical species.     

Sea urchins, sea stars and brittle stars from Terra Nova Bay (Ross Sea, Antarctica)

Although echinoderms constitute some of the most conspicuous taxa of the Antarctic benthic communities, the echinoderm fauna of Terra Nova has not been described yet. The present study provides the first species list of echinoids, ophiuroids and asteroids from Terra Nova Bay (30–500 m depth) and describes the depth distribution of these species. Preliminary observations of the summer reproductive condition of some of the species are also included.     

Developmental plasticity in Macrophiothrix brittlestars: are morphologically convergent larvae also convergently plastic?

The pluteus larval forms of sea urchins (echinoids) and brittlestars (ophiuroids) use an internal skeleton to project arms that bear a long ciliated band used in swimming and feeding. The length of this ciliated band influences rates of maximum food clearance for larvae of both echinoderm classes and affects rates of growth and development in the plankton. Phylogenetic and morphological evidence, however, tend to support the view that the pluteus morphologies of the two classes are independently derived. Studies with echinoplutei have shown that investment in skeletal growth and ciliated band length changes in response to food conditions, with poorly fed larvae investing more in growth of the larval skeleton and arms either absolutely or in relation to other larval or developing postlarval structures. We present evidence for similar plasticity of skeletal growth in ophioplutei. We examined four species in the brittlestar genus Macrophiothrix that spanned a 3.8-fold range in egg size. Sibling larvae in 14 male-female crosses were reared with high (H) or low (L) food rations, and measurements were recorded for five skeletal arm rods and three non-arm body dimensions. The expression of adaptive plasticity (significantly longer arms in L versus H cultures on a given day) was apparent for most crosses in M. koehleri, the species with the smallest egg size. In the single cross for M. longipeda, larvae from L cultures had longer arms for their body length or stomach width than did larvae from H cultures. In these cases, plasticity was similar in timing, persistence, and magnitude to previously published results from echinoplutei. If internal skeletons are independently derived in the two classes, then plasticity in the expression of this homoplastic trait may itself be homoplastic.     

Evolution of pelagic direct development in the starfish Pteraster tesselatus (Asteroidea: Velatida)

Despite a diversity of larval forms, remarkably conservative features of asteroid development define a larval body plan that occurs throughout the class. However, recent work on the starfish Pteraster tesselatus has documented a highly derived pattern of development. Several features, including radial symmetry, parallel embryonic and adult axes of symmetry, absence of a preoral lobe, and formation of coeloms in the adult orientation from seven separate enterocoels, have not been reported in asteroids before. The complete absence of the larval body plan features that are found in other asteroids, indicates that P. tesselatus develops directly from the embryo to the juvenile and has a pelagic, nonfeeding (lecithotrophic), but nonlarval mode of development. I postulate that direct development evolved over an extended period in a lineage of brooding, deep-sea velatid (probably pterastcrid) ancestors of P. tesselatus. Selection for increased developmental efficiency (loss of nonfunctional larval features) in the brooded offspring, could explain the lack of larval settlement structures, the nonlarval arrangement of coeloms, the lack of a preoral lobe, the transverse orientation of the juvenile disc, and the lack of bilateral symmetry. The pattern of coclomogenesis could have been derived from that of other velatids (e.g. solasterids) by relatively simple changes in timing and orientation of entcroeoel formation. Rotation and posterior translation of the coelomic fate map of the archenteron prior to enlerocoel formation would produce the coelomic compartments in the adult orientation that characterizes direct development in P. tesselatus. These unusual developmental features lead to a radically different interpretation for the evolution of the pelagic ‘larva’ of P. tesselatus: (1) evolution of benthie brooding, (2) extreme simplification of development involving the loss of all larval features from the life cycle, and (3) subsequent re-evolution of pelagic development. In the case of P. tesselatus, where all larval structures were lost, there do not seem to be functional constraints preventing the re-evolution of pelagic development. Analysis of pelagic and benthie larvae, in other asteroids, suggests that major ecological transitions in life histories need not be associated with substantia] changes in morphology. The loss of pelagic development should have occurred repeatedly and should be readily reversible. These findings have interesting implications for the loss and evolution of pelagic dispersal in the life histories of marine benthie invertebrates.