The maturation state of three types of granulocyte/macrophage progenitor cells from mouse bone marrow

The progenitor cells of neutrophil granulocytes and macrophages which are able to proliferate and differentiate in vitro (CFU-c) form a heterogeneous population. By the use of specific colony stimulating activities and cell separation by equilibrium density centrifugation, three subpopulations of CFU-c can be detected. These three CFU-c are characterized by buoyant densities of 1.070, 1.075 and 1.080 g.cm^?3 and by their proliferative response to 18 h postendotoxin serum, colony stimulating factor from extracts of mouse embryos and uteri (CSF-pmue) and erythrocyte lysate, respectively. The three CFU-c are compared with respect to their differentiation potential, the maturation rate of their progeny cells and their proliferation capacity. It is shown that with increasing density of the CFU-c the maturation rate increases (sequential maturation of colonies derived from CFU-c with densities of 1.080, 1.075, 1.070 g.cm^?3) and the proliferation capacity decreases (colony size decreases in the sequence of CFU-c with densities 1.070, 1.075, 1.080 g.cm^?3). Concerning the differentiation potential it is shown that all three CFU-c detected have the capacity to form granulocytes as well as macrophages. On the basis of these results it is concluded that the CFU-c with densities of 1.070, 1.075 and 1.080 g.cm^?3 represent a maturation sequence.     

The in vitro differentiation of density sub-populations of colony-forming cells under the influence of different types of colony-stimulating factor.

The in vitro proliferation and differentiation of myeloid progenitor cells (CFU-c) in agar culture from CBA/Ca mouse bone marrow cells was studied. Density subpopulations of marrow cells were obtained by equilibrium centrifugation in continuous albumin density gradients. The formation of colonies of granulocytes and/or macrophages was studied under the influence of three types of colony-stimulating factor (CSF) from mouse lung conditioned medium CSFMLCM), post-endotoxin mouse serum (CSFES) and from human urine (CSFHu). The effect of the sulphydryl reagent mercaptoethanol on colony development was also examined. The density distribution of CFU-c was dependent on the type of CSF. Functional heterogeneity was found among CFU-c with partial discrimination between progenitor cells forming pure granulocytic colonies and those forming pure macrophage colonies. Mercaptoethanol increased colony incidence but had no apparent effect on colony morphology or the density distribution of CFU-c.     

THE IN VITRO DIFFERENTIATION OF DENSITY SUB-POPULATIONS OF COLONY-FORMING CELLS UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF DIFFERENT TYPES OF COLONY-STIMULATING FACTOR

The in vitro proliferation and differentiation of myeloid progenitor cells (CFU-c) in agar culture from CBA/Ca mouse bone marrow cells was studied. Density sub-populations of marrow cells were obtained by equilibrium centrifugation in continuous albumin density gradients. The formation of colonies of granulocytes and/or macrophages was studied under the influence of three types of colony-stimulating factor (CSF) from mouse lung conditioned medium CSF_MLCM), post-endotoxin mouse serum (CSF_ES) and from human urine (CSF_Hu). The effect of the sulphydryl reagent mercaptoethanol on colony development was also examined. The density distribution of CFU-c was dependent on the type of CSF. Functional heterogeneity was found among CFU-c with partial discrimination between progenitor cells forming pure granulocytic colonies and those forming pure macro-phage colonies. Mercaptoethanol increased colony incidence but had no apparent effect on colony morphology or the density distribution of CFU-c.     

Effects of human leukocyte conditioned medium on mouse haemopoietic progenitor cells.

Medium conditioned by human peripheral blood leukocytes (HLCM) was studied for its in vitro effects on haemopoietic progenitor cells (CFU-s and CFU-c) present in mouse bone marrow. HLCM has poor colony stimulating activity in semi-solid cultures of mouse bone marrow cells, but invariably increases the number of colonies obtained in the presence of plateau levels of semi-purified colony stimulating factor (CSF). In liquid cultures, HLCM appears to contain a potent initiator of DNA synthesis in CFU-s, an activity which coincides with an increased CFU-s maintenance and causes a three- to four-fold increase in CFU-c number. It is apparent from this study that HLCM, in addition to stimulating colony formation in cultures of human bone marrow cells, has a profound in vitro effect on primitive haemopoietic progenitor cells of the mouse, which cannot be attributed to CSF.     

EFFECTS OF HUMAN LEUKOCYTE CONDITIONED MEDIUM ON MOUSE HAEMOPOIETIC PROGENITOR CELLS

Medium conditioned by human peripheral blood leukocytes (HLCM) was studied for its in vitro effects on haemopoietic progenitor cells (CFU-s and CFU-c) present in mouse bone marrow. HLCM has poor colony stimulating activity in semi-solid cultures of mouse bone marrow cells. but invariably increases the number of colonies obtained in the presence of plateau levels of semi-purified colony stimulating factor (CSF). In liquid cultures, HLCM appears to contain a potent initiator of DNA synthesis in CFU-s. an activity which coincides with an increased CFU-s maintenance and causes a three- to four-fold increase in CFU-c number. It is apparent from this study that HLCM, in addition to stimulating colony formation in cultures of human bone marrow cells, has a profound in vitro effect on primitive haemopoietic progenitor cells of the mouse, which cannot be attributed to CSF.     

BUOYANT DENSITY ANALYSIS OF MYELOID COLONY-FORMING CELLS IN GERMFREE AND CONVENTIONAL MICE

Granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming cells (CFUc), in the bone marrow of germfree and conventional CBA mice, were compared quantitatively and qualitatively. Cells were separated on the basis of their buoyant density by equilibrium centrifugation in continuous albumin density gradients. CFUc in the density subpopulations were detected by culture in agar containing three different types of colony stimulating factor (CSF). The sources of the CSF were post-endotoxin mouse serum (CSF_ES), mouse lung conditioned medium (CSF_MLCM) and human urine (CSF_HU). Mice were removed from the germfree environment and the buoyant density status of their CFUc was examined 1, 4 and 8 weeks later. No difference was found between germfree and conventional mice in the number of nucleated cells per femur or in their modal density. Neither was the number of CFUc per femur different. The cell cycle status of CFUc, as determined by the thymidine suicide technique was not significantly different. Functional heterogeneity was found among the density subpopulations for both groups of mice. This depended on the type of CSF. The density distribution of CFUc was significantly different in germfree mice. There were proportionately more low density CFUc. The mean modal density of CFUc under CSF_ES stimulation was less by 0.0045 g/cm³ in germfree mice. The removal of mice from the germfree environment resulted in a shift of the distribution to higher densities. The trend was towards the conventional situation. The significance of the buoyant density status of CFUc is discussed.     

Survival and repopulation of irradiated 'pre-CFU-c' in mice

Supernatants of murine bone-marrow cultures contain a colony-promoting factor (CPF) which increases the number of granulocyte and macrophage colonies in semi-solid agar cultures in the presence of colony-stimulating factor (CSF). Incubation of bone-marrow cells with CPF results in an increase in the number of granulocyte/macrophage progenitor cells (CFU-c) and the CPF-responsive cells may be younger than the CFU-c. We have investigated the radiosensitivity and the pattern of the recovery after irradiation of CPF-responsive cells. We found that the radiosensitivity of CPF-responsive cells was significantly lower than those of CFU-c, burst-forming units-erythroid (BFU-e) and pluripotent stem cells in vivo (CFU-s) and in vitro (CFU-mix). The CPF-responsive cells remained subnormal even at 28 days after irradiation of the mice, a time when the CFU-s and CFU-c had recovered completely. Therefore the CPF-responsive cells may constitute a separate compartment, namely 'pre-CFU-c', in the maturation sequence of granulopoiesis, and this maturation of the 'pre-CFU-c' to CFU-c seems to be highly stimulated after irradiation to counterbalance the influx from CFU-s.     

Survival and Repopulation of Irradiated 'Pre-Cfu-C' In Mice

ABSTRACT Supernatants of murine bone-marrow cultures contain a colony-promoting factor (CPF) which increases the number of granulocyte and macrophage colonies in semi-solid agar cultures in the presence of colony-stimulating factor (CSF). Incubation of bone-marrow cells with CPF results in an increase in the number of granulocyte/macrophage progenitor cells (CFU-c) and the CPF-responsive cells may be younger than the CFU-c. We have investigated the radiosensitivity and the pattern of the recovery after irradiation of CPF-responsive cells. We found that the radiosensitivity of CPF-responsive cells was significantly lower than those of CFU-c. burst-forming units-erythroid (BFU-e) and pluripotent stem cells in vivo (CFU-s) and in vitro (CFU-mix). the CPF-responsive cells remained subnormal even at 28 days after irradiation of the mice, a time when the CFU-s and CFU-c had recovered completely. Therefore the CPF-responsive cells may constitute a separate compartment, namely ‘pre-CFU-c’, in the maturation sequence of granulopoiesis, and this maturation of the ‘pre-CFU-c’ to CFU-c seems to be highly stimulated after irradiation to counterbalance the influx from CFU-s.     

Retinoic acid enhances colony-stimulating factor-induced clonal growth of normal human myeloid progenitor cells in vitro

We studied the effect of vitamin A and its analogues (retinoids) on the clonal growth in vitro of normal human myeloid progenitor cells. Normal human bone marrow cells were cultured in soft gel in the presence of a source of colony-stimulating factor (CSF), and various retinoids, and the number of granulocyte-macrophage colonies (CFU-GM) were scored. The addition of 3 × 10^?8 to 3 × 10^?6 M retinoic acid to culture plates containing CSF markedly increased the number of myeloid colonies as compared with culture plates containing CSF alone. Maximal stimulation occurred at a concentration of 3 × 10^?7 M retinoic acid which increased the mean number of colonies by 213 ± 8 % (±S.E.) over plates containing CSF alone. Retinal or retinyl acetate was less potent than retinoic acid, and retinol (vitamin A) had no effect on colony growth. Retinoic acid had no direct CSF activity nor did it stimulate CSF production by the cultured bone marrow cells. Our studies show for the first time that retinoids can stimulate granulopoiesis in vitro and we suggest that this stimulation may be mediated by increased responsiveness of the granulocyte-macrophage progenitors to the action of CSF.     

Buoyant density analysis of myeloid colony-forming cells in germfree and conventional mice.

Granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming cells (CFUc), in the bone marrow of germfree and conventioal CBA mice, were compared quantitatively and qualitatively. Cells were separated on the basis of their buoyant density by equilibrium centrifugation in continuous albumin density gradients. CFUc in the density subpopulations were detected by culture in agar containing three different types of colony stimulating factor (CSF). The sources of the CSF were post-endotoxin mouse serum (CSFES), mouse lung conditioned medium (CSFMLCM) and human urine (CSFHU). Mice were removed from the germfree environment and the buoyant density status of their CFUc was examined 1, 4 and 8 weeks later. No difference was found between germfree and conventional mice in the number of nucleated cells per femur or in their modal density. Neither was the number of CFUc per femur different. The cell cycle status of CFUc, as determined by the thymidine suicide technique was not significantly different. Functional heterogeneity was found among the density subpopulations for both groups of mice. This depended on the type of CSF. The density distribution of CFUc was significantly different in germfree mice. There were proportionately more low density CFUc. The mean modal density of CFUc under CSFES stimulation was less by 0.0045 g/cm3 in germfree mice. The removal of mice from the germfree environment resulted in a shift of the distribution to higher densities. The trend was towards the conventional situation. The significance of the buoyant density status of CFUc is discussed.     

Antibody-mediated suppression of bone marrow colony formation in vitro.

Antisera to mouse brain reacts with hematopoietic stem cells in the mouse bone marrow. We have examined the effect of anti-mouse brain serum (AMBS) on the development of in vitro colonies from mouse bone marrow cells. The addition of 5% AMBS to the cultures markedly decreased the numbers of colonies formed to an average of 10% of the number obtained with normal rabbit serum. AMBS suppressed formation induced by colony stimulating factors (CSF) derived from three different sources; serum from endotoxin treated mice, mouse L-cell conditioned media, and human peripheral mononuclear cell conditioned media. The suppressive activity was quantitatively recovered in the IgG fraction of AMBS. Divalent F(ab')2 fragments were as effective as the intact IgG in decreasing colony formation. Fab fragments were not suppressive. These results suggest that colony formation is induced via a dynamic interaction between CSF and the progenitor cell membrane, and that antibody directed at cell membrane antigen(s) interferes with the generation of the induction signal.     

QUANTITATIVE IN VITRO STUDIES ON STIMULATION OF MURINE HAEMOPOIETIC CELLS BY COLONY STIMULATING FACTOR

A new standardization method for Colony Stimulating Factor (CSF) is described and criteria are introduced which enables stimulating activity to be assessed independent of absolute colony numbers. With this method CSF preparations from different sources are compared and evidence is presented that suggests an identical mechanism of action for these substances. Data are presented on the increase in colony numbers that is induced by the addition of erythrocyte lysates to the cultures. The relationship between colony forming cells that are stimulated by CSF alone and cells stimulated by the combined action of CSF and erythrocyte lysate is discussed.     

Isolation of colony stimulating factor from human milk

Human milk contains colony stimulating factor (CSF), a polypeptide growth factor, which stimulates in in vitro bone marrow culture proliferation and differentiation of colony forming granulocytic macrophage progenitor cells (CFU-GM) to form colonies. This activity was not found in either bovine milk or colostrum when assayed in human or mouse bone marrow cells. The human milk CSF activity is destroyed by treatment with proteases. However, neither 6M urea, 4M guanidine hydrochloride, 5 mM dithiothreitol, nor exposure to pH 2 will inactivate the milk derived CSF. Gel filtration and isoelectric focusing indicate that human milk CSF differs biochemically from the other CSFs isolated from various sources and has a molecular weight between 250,000 and 240,000 and an isoelectric point between 4.4 and 4.9.     

Colony-forming units in diffusion chambers (CFU-d) and colony-forming units in agar culture (CFU-c) obtained from normal human bone marrow: a possible parent-progeny relationship.

An series of experiments was performed to elucidate the relationship between cells that form granulocytic colonies in fibrin clot diffusion chambers implanted into the peritoneum (i.p.) of irradiated mice (CFU-d) and day 7 and day 14 CFU-U which give rise to colonies after 7 and 14 days in agar cultures in vitro, respectively. Normal human bone marrow cells were cultured in suspension in vitro or in diffusion chambers implanted into irradiated or non-irradiated mice. During these culture conditions there was an initial decrease in the number of CFU-c per culture. This was followed by an increase between day 2 and day 7 of culture. No similar increase of neutrophilic CFU-d was observed. When CFU-d, day 14 and day 7 CFU-c in normal marrow were separated by velocity sedimentation and cultured in suspension culture or in diffusion chambers for 7 days, the maximum increase of day 7 and day 14 CFU-c was observed in slowly sedimenting cell fractions which contained the majority of CFU-d. After 3 days in suspension culture, the maximum increase of day 14 CFU-c was found in fractions which also gave rise to maximum numbers of CFU-c after 7 days. However, day 7 CFU-c were found in fractions which initially contained the majority of day 14 CFU-c. No increase in CFU-d was found in fractions initially containing peak numbers of CFU-c. Between 53 and 71% of CFU-c harvested from diffusion chambers in irradiated mice or from suspension cultures were sensitive to pulse incubation with tritiated thymidine, suggesting that the cells were proliferating during these culture conditions. In diffusion chambers implanted into non-irradiated mice, however, CFU-c were found to be relatively resistant to this treatment (3-11% sensitive to tritiated thymidine). Thus marked increases in CFU-c were also observed during experimental conditions, where no significant DNA synthesis was detected. A reproducible time sequence of increase in CFU-c populations in culture was observed. Day 14 CFU-c and cells that gave rise to clusters on day 7 in agar increased between day 2 and day 4, whereas day 7 CFU-c increased between day 4 and day 7. The results suggested that CFU-d gave rise to CFU-c in culture and that day 14 CFU-c were precursors of day 7 CFU-c.     

The nature of 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA)-stimulated hemopoiesis, colony stimulating factor (CSF) requirement for colony formation, and the effect of TPA on [125I]CSF-1 binding to macrophages

The tumor-promoting phorbol diester, 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) was found to act both independently of and synergistically with the mononuclear phagocyte specific colony stimulating factor (CSF-1) to stimulate the formation of macrophage colonies in cultures of mouse bone marrow cells. In contrast, TPA did not synergize with other CSF subclasses that stimulate the formation of eosinophil, eosinophil-neutrophil, neutrophil, neutrophil-macrophage, and macrophage colonies, nor with either of the two factors required for megakaryocyte colony formation, megakaryocyte CSF, and megakaryocyte colony potentiator. In serum-free mouse bone marrow cell cultures TPA retained the ability to independently stimulate macrophage colony formation. However, TPA-stimulated colony formation was suboptimal and delayed in serum-free cultures that could support optimal colony formation in the presence of CSF-1. In addition, TPA did not directly compete with [125I]CSF-1 at 4 degrees C for its specific, high-affinity receptor on mouse peritoneal exudate macrophages. However, a 2-hour preincubation of the cells with TPA at 37 degrees caused almost complete loss of the receptor. Thus, TPA is able to mimic CSF-1 in its effects on CSF-1 responsive cells in some aspects (the spectrum of target cells, the morphology of resulting colonies, and the ability to down-regulate the CSF-1 receptor) but it is not able to mimic CSF-1 in other ways (TPA alone cannot stimulate the full CSF-1 response, TPA does not stimulate the most primitive CSF-1 responsive cells, and TPA does not bind to the CSF-1 receptor).     

Serum of lipopolysacharide-treated mice contains two types of colony-stimulating factor,separable by affinity chromatography

Serum from mice traated with bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) was fractionated by Con A-Sepharose affinity chromatography, and assayed in vitro for colony-stimulating factor (CSF) using mouse bone marrow cells. The CSF failing to bind to concanavalin A-Sepharose (pool A) had similar biological properties to the unfractionated serum, i.e., it stimulated the formation of about equal numbers of granulocytic, mixed granulocyte-macrophage and macrophage colonies. The fraction eluted from the Con A-Sepharose column with α-methyl-D-glucopyranoside (pool B) had a steeper dose-response curve than either the unfractionated serum or the pool A CSF and most of the colonies were composed of macrophages. A mixture of the pool A and pool B CSFs stimulated colonies in a similar way as unfractionated serum and pool A. The apparent molecular weights of the two types of CSF were determined by two different gel-filtration procedures. Sephacryl S-200 gel-filtration suggested an apparent molecular weight of 85,000 for pool A CSF and 180,000 for pool B CSF. Gel-filtration on Sepharose CL-6B in the presence of guanidine hydrochloride (6M) yielded an apparent molecular weight of approximately 23,000 for pool A CSF and 33,000 for pool B CSF. The colony-forming cells (CFC) responding to pool B CSF were found to have a relatively high sedimentation velocity (peak sedimentation velocity 5.6–6.2 mm/hr) compared to the CFC responding to mouse-lung conditioned medium (MLCM) whose peak sedimentation velocity was between 4.0–4.5 mm/hour. The CFC responding to pool A CSF had an intermediate sedimentation velocity (peak 4.6–5.2 mm/hour). A time-course analysis of the morphology of clones or colonies in cultures stimulated with either MLCM or pool B CSF showed that the proporation of different colony types depends significantly on the incubation period and suggested that pool B CSF induced an early commitment of CFC towards macrophage differentiation.     

Studies on colony formation in vitro by mouse bone marrow cells. II. Action of colony stimulating factor

An analysis was made of some of the processes involved in the stimulation by colony stimulating factor (CSF) of cluster and colony formation by mouse bone marrow cells in agar cultures in vitro. Colony formation was shown to be related to the concentration and not the total amount of CSF. The concentration of CSF determined the rate of new cluster initiation in cultures and the rate of growth of individual clusters. Colony growth depleted the medium of CSF suggesting that colony cells may utilise CSF during proliferation. Bone marrow cells incubated in agar in the absence of CSF rapidly died or lost their capacity to proliferate and form clusters or colonies. CSF appears (a) to be necessary for survival of cluster-and colony-forming cells or for survival of their proliferative potential, (b) to shorten the lag period before individual cells commence proliferation and (c) to increase the growth rate of individual clusters and colonies.     

Separation by velocity sedimentation of human haemopoietic precursors forming colonies in vivo and in vitro cultures

Cells which give rise to granulocyte-macrophage colonies under the influence of peripheral blood white cells (CFU-c (WBC] and Mo T cell conditioned medium (CFU-c (Mo] sedimented at a faster rate than the cells which form mixed erythroid-granulocytic colonies in methylcellulose in vitro (CFU-mix) and granulocytic (CFU-dg) and megakaryocytic (CFU-dm) colonies in diffusion chambers in mice. Despite identical peak sedimentation rate for the two CFU-c populations, sedimentation profiles suggest that they are heterogeneous with respect to size. A proportion of CFU-c (Mo) may be identical with CFU-dg and CFU-mix. Sedimentation profiles for cells which give rise to mixed colonies in vitro (CFU-mix) and to granulocytic colonies in diffusion chambers in cyclophosphamide pretreated mice (CFU-dg (CY] and in Mo conditioned medium treated mice (CFU-dg (Mo] were similar. On the average CFU-dm sedimented somewhat slower than CFU-dg. These and other observations suggesting a close relationship between CFU-dg and multipotential haemopoietic precursors are discussed.     

Effects of okadaic acid on mouse hemopoietic cells

Effects of okadaic acid, a potent non-12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate(TPA)-type tumor promoter, on mouse hemopoietic cells were investigated. Okadaic acid stimulated mouse bone marrow cells to form granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming unit (CFU-GM) colonies without added colony stimulating factors(CSFs). At the concentration of 1.82 x 10(-8) M, colony formation of 77 +/- 14 colonies/1 x 10(5) bone marrow cells was observed. Observations on the effects of other cells on the CSF induction suggested that okadaic acid primarily stimulated the functions of macrophages, and the CSF production from macrophages might be attributed to the CFU-GM colony formation. On the other hand, the erythroid colony-forming unit(CFU-E) colony formation stimulated by     

The effect of DLE fractions on GM-progenitors of haematopoietic stem cells in vitro

Dialysable leucocyte extract (DLE) prepared from buffy coats of human blood, potentiates the effect of Colony-stimulating factor (CSF) on the growth of granulocyte-macrophage colony forming cell (GM-CFC) colonies in vitro. This relative increase of the number of colonies is apparent when diluted CSF (present in lung conditioning medium) as a control, and DLE, in a wide range of concentrations are added to the culture of mouse bone marrow cells. Fractionation of DLE on Amicon membranes revealed that the activity resides in molecules of 0-5kD. Molecules 5-10kD have no potentiating effect. DLE and its fractions (0-5kD, 0-1kD), except fractions 0-500 D and 5-10kD, when added undiluted i.e. at the initial concentration, exerted a suppressive effect: colonies are not formed despite the presence of CSF. In a pilot experiment, it was shown that DLE is able to stimulate colony-forming activity of earlier progenitors of erythroid cells (BFUe), under the influence of erythropoietin.