Evidence of complex formation between alkaline phosphatase and a pro-apoptotic hemoprotein cytochrome c

Two proteins, alkaline phosphatase (AP) and cytochrome c (cyt c) which seem to be involved in the apoptotic cell death program were examined on their interaction. Intestinal AP affects ferricytochrome c (cyt c(FeIII)) by changing its optical properties, redox state and conformation. The effect proceeded over the course of hours with a gradual decrease in free cyt c(FeIII) as the AP concentration increased. A heme containing high molecular species was created in the first stage of interaction of the proteins in neutral, acidic (pH 2.6), alkaline (pH 8.3), low ionic strength (10 mmol/l phosphate), and high ionic strength (0.5 mol/l NaCl) media. Further complexation was favored by higher pH values and temperature. Differential scanning calorimetry revealed a decrease in enthalpy of the thermodenaturation temperature (Tm) of cyt c at 84.5 degrees C due to the AP addition. Increments of AP in the mixtures resulted in the appearance of Tm peaks at 68 degrees C and 61 degrees C. Electrophoretic analysis of the commercial samples of intestinal APs showed main fractions from 63.2 kDa to 72.9 kDa and from 172.9 up to 179.0 kDa. Changes in positions and intensities of the bands were detected upon longer incubation (24 h) with cyt c. The electrophoretic pattern of the bacterial AP was homogeneous with one fraction of 43.7 kDa showing no alteration due to the cyt c presence. Gel permeation chromatography of incubated mixtures of intestinal APs and cyt c confirmed the creation of new heme containing complexes.     

Reversible, nonionic, and pH-dependent association of cytochrome c with cardiolipin-phosphatidylcholine liposomes.

Membrane association of cytochrome c (cyt c) was monitored by the efficiency of resonance energy transfer from a pyrene-fatty acid containing phospholipid derivative (1-palmitoyl-2[6-(pyren-1-yl)]hexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (PPHPC)) to the heme of cyt c. Liposomes consisted of 85 mol% egg phosphatidylcholine (egg PC), 10 mol% cardiolipin, and 5 mol% PPHPC. Cardiolipin was necessary for the membrane binding of cyt c over the pH range studied, from 4 to 7. In accordance with the electrostatic nature of the membrane association of cyt c at neutral pH both 2 mM MgCl2 and 80 mM NaCl dissociated cyt c from the vesicles completely. At neutral pH also adenine nucleotides in millimolar concentrations were able to displace cyt c from liposomes, their efficiency decreasing in the sequence ATP > ADP > AMP. In addition, both CTP and GTP were equally effective as ATP. The detachment of cyt c from liposomes by nucleotides is likely to result from a competition between cardiolipin and the nucleotides for a common binding site in cyt c. When pH was decreased to 4 there was a small yet significant increase in the apparent affinity of cyt c to cardiolipin containing liposomes. Notably, at pH 4 the above nucleotides as well as NaCl and MgCl2 were no longer able to dissociate cyt c and, on the contrary, they slightly enhanced the quenching of pyrene fluorescence by cyt c. The above results do suggest that the membrane association of cyt c at acidic pH was non-ionic and presumably due to hydrogen bonding. The pH-dependent binding of cyt c to membranes was fully reversible. Accordingly, in the presence of sufficient concentrations of either nucleotides or salts rapid detachment and membrane association of cyt c could be induced by varying pH between neutral and acidic values, respectively.     

Temperature- and pH-dependent changes in the coordination sphere of the heme c group in the model peroxidase N alpha-acetyl microperoxidase-8.

The pH- and temperature-dependent changes in the coordination sphere of the heme c group of N alpha-acetyl microperoxidase-8 (Ac-MP-8) have been studied by examining its optical, resonance Raman, electron paramagnetic resonance, and magnetic circular dichroism spectra. An optical titration indicates that Ac-MP-8 exists in three major ionization forms over the pH 1-12 range that are linked by pK alpha values of approximately 3 and 9. The acid form that is present at pH 1.5 exists as a mixture of five- and six-coordinate high-spin species and most likely has water or buffer ions as axial ligand(s). On titration to pH 7, the His18 residue is deprotonated and becomes the proximal ligand to the iron to give a six-coordinate neutral form that has water as the sixth ligand. This form exists in a thermal high-spin intermediate-spin state equilibrium. On raising the pH to 10, an alkaline form is generated which is predominantly a five-coordinate high-spin species. It is formed by ionization of the proximal His18 residue to its imidazolate form with concomitant dissociation of the water ligand at the sixth site. At concentrations of Ac-MP-8 greater than 10 microM, some six-coordinate low-spin species are formed that are attributed to a dimer in which a His18 residue from a second molecule of Ac-MP-8 coordinates to the sixth site of another to give a bis-His complex. Raising the pH to 11.5 does not produce an appreciable amount of the six-coordinate complex with hydroxide as the sixth ligand. These studies show that Ac-MP-8 is a good water-soluble model for the peroxidases that exhibits minimal aggregation at concentrations below 10 microM in the neutral and alkaline pH regions.     

Native or nativelike species are transient intermediates in folding of alkaline iso-2 cytochrome c

Titration to high pH converts yeast iso-2 cytochrome c to an inactive but more stable alkaline form lacking a 695-nm absorbance band [Osterhout, J. J., Jr., Muthukrishnan, K., & Nall, B. T. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 6680-6684]. The kinetics of absorbance-detected refolding of the alkaline form have been measured by dilution of guanidine hydrochloride in a stopped-flow instrument. Fast-folding species (tau 2) are detected, as in refolding to the native state at neutral pH. An additional kinetic phase (tau a) is observed with an amplitude opposite in sign to the fast phase. The amplitude of this phase increases and the rate increases with increasing pH. Comparison to pH-jump measurements of the fully folded protein shows that phase tau a has the same sign, rate, and pH dependence as the alkaline isomerization reaction, suggesting that this new phase involves isomerization of native or nativelike species following fast folding. Absorbance difference spectra are taken at 5-s intervals during refolding at high pH. The spectra verify that nativelike species--with a 695-nm absorbance band--are formed transiently, before conversion of the protein to the alkaline form. Refolding in the presence of ascorbate shows that the transient, nativelike species are reducible, unlike alkaline iso-2. Thus, (1) refolding to the alkaline form of iso-2 cytochrome c proceeds through transient native or nativelike species, and (2) a folding pathway leading to native or nativelike forms is maintained at high pH, where native species are no longer the thermodynamically favored product.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Kinetic and equilibrium studies of alkaline isomerization of vertebrate cytochromes c

Equilibria and kinetics of alkaline isomerization of seven ferricytochromes c from vertebrates were studied by pH-titration and pH-jump methods in the pH region of 7-12. In the equilibrium behavior, no significant difference was detected among the cytochromes c, whereas marked differences in the kinetic behavior were observed. According to the kinetic behavior of the isomerization, the cytochromes c examined fall into three classes: Group I (horse, sheep, dog and pigeon cytochromes c), Group II (tuna and bonito cytochromes c) and Group III (rhesus monkey cytochrome c). The kinetic results are interpreted in terms of the sequential scheme: Neutral form in equilibrium with fast Transient form in equilibrium with slow Alkaline form where the neutral and alkaline forms are the species stable at neutral and alkaline pH, respectively, and the transient form is a kinetic intermediate. From comparison of the primary sequences of the seven cytochromes c and the classification of these cytochromes c, it is concluded that the amino acid substitution Phe/Tyr at the 46-th position has a major influence on the kinetic behavior. In Group II and III cytochromes c, the ionization of Tyr-46 is suggested to bring about loosening of the heme crevice and thus facilitate the ligand replacement involved in the isomerization.     

Modelling of the human papillomavirus type 16 E5 protein

Cytochrome (cyt) c forms complexes, undergoes a conformational change and becomes partly reduced at interaction with membrane anchored alkaline phosphatase (AP), a glycoprotein which is released into the body fluid in forms differing in hydrophobicity. The proportion of products formed in the mixtures depends on pH, ionic strength, temperature and the buffer composition. The reaction terminates in an equilibrium between cyt c(FeII) and other cyt c conformers. Optimal conditions for the rate of the reaction are 100 mM glycine/NaOH, pH 9.7-9.9, at which 68-74% of cyt c is found in the reduced state. The interaction affects compactness of the haem cleft as shown by changes induced in CD spectra of the Soret region and changes in optical characteristics of phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan residues. Differential scanning calorimetry of AP+cyt c mixtures revealed a creation of at least two types of complexes. A complex formed by non-coulombic binding prevails at substoichiometric AP/cyt c ratios, at higher ratios more electrostatic attraction is involved and at 1:1 molar ratio an apparent complexity of binding forces occurs. The rapid phase of the cyt c(FeII) formation depends on the presence of the hydrophobic alkylacylphosphoinositol (glycosylphosphatidylinositol) moiety, the protein part of the enzyme participates in an electrostatic and much slower phase of cyt c(FeII) creation. The results show that non-coulombic interaction may participate at interaction of cyt c with cellular proteins.     

Effect of axial coordination on the kinetics of assembly and folding of the two halves of horse heart cytochrome C

The kinetics of the assembly of two complementary fragments of oxidized horse heart cytochrome c (cyt c), namely the heme-containing fragment-(1-56) and the fragment-(57-104), have been characterized at different pH values. At neutral pH the fragment-(1-56) is hexacoordinated and has two histidines axially ligated to the heme-Fe(III) (Santucci, R., Fiorucci, L., Sinibaldi, F., Polizio, F., Desideri, A., and Ascoli, F. (2000) Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 379, 331-336), thus mimicking what occurs in the folding intermediate of cyt c. The kinetics of the formation of the complex between the two fragments are characterized at pH 7.0 by a slow rate constant that is independent of the concentration of the reactants; conversely, at a low pH the kinetics are much faster and depend on the concentration of the fragments. This behavior suggests that the rate-limiting step observed in the recombination process of the fragments at neutral pH (that leads to the final coordination of Met-80) has to be ascribed to the detachment of the "misligated" histidine. Thus, the faster recombination rate at a low pH can be related to the fact that histidine is protonated and not able to coordinate to the metal. Furthermore, the independence of the rate constant on the concentration of the reactants observed at pH 7.0 can be accounted for by the occurrence of a conformational transition, which takes place immediately after the two fragments collapse together, likely simulating what induces the detachment of the misligated histidine during cytochrome folding.     

Oxidation of the His-52 --> Leu mutant of cytochrome c peroxidase by p-nitroperoxybenzoic acid: role of the distal histidine in hydroperoxide activation

Both cytochrome c peroxidase (CcP) and a mutant cytochrome c peroxidase in which the distal histidine has been replaced by leucine, CcP(H52L), are converted to hydroxy-ligated derivatives at alkaline pH. In CcP, the hydroxy-ligated derivative is subsequently converted to a bis-imidazole species prior to protein denaturation while the initial hydroxy-ligated CcP(H52L) is converted to a second, spectroscopically distinct hydroxy-ligated species prior to denaturation. The spectra of the alkaline forms of CcP and CcP(H52L) have been determined between 310 and 700 nm. The pH dependence of the rate of reaction between CcP(H52L) and hydrogen peroxide has been extended to pH 10. The hydroxy-ligated form of CcP(H52L) reacts with hydrogen peroxide 4 times more rapidly than the pentacoordinate, high-spin form of CcP(H52L) that exists at neutral pH. The rate of the reaction between p-nitroperoxybenzoic acid and CcP(H52L) has been measured between pH 4 and pH 8. Neutral p-nitroperoxybenzoic acid reacts with CcP(H52L) 10(5) times more slowly than with CcP while the negatively charged p-nitroperoxybenzoate reacts with CcP(H52L) 10(3) times more slowly than with CcP. These data indicate that the role of the distal histidine during the initial formation of the peroxy anion/heme iron complex is not simply base catalysis.     

Effect of varying polyglutamate chain length on the structure and stability of ferricytochrome c

The effect of varying polyglutamate chain length on local and global stability of horse heart ferricytochrome c was studied using scanning calorimetry and spectroscopy methods. Spectral data indicate that polyglutamate chain lengths equal or greater than eight monomer units significantly change the apparent pK(a) for the alkaline transition of cytochrome c. The change in pK(a) is comparable to the value when cytochrome c is complexed with cytochrome bc(1). Glutamate and diglutamate do not significantly alter the temperature transition for cleavage of the Met(80)-heme iron bond of cytochrome c. At low ionic strength, polyglutamates consisting of eight or more glutamate monomers increase midpoint of the temperature transition from 57.3+/-0.2 to 66.9+/-0.2 degrees C. On the other hand, the denaturation temperature of cytochrome c decreases from 85.2+/-0.2 to 68.8+/-0.2 degrees C in the presence of polyglutamates with number of glutamate monomers n >or approximately equal 8. The rate constant for cyanide binding to the heme iron of cytochrome c of cytochrome c-polyglutamate complex also decreases by approximately 42.5% with n>or approximately equal 8. The binding constant for the binding of octaglutamate (m.w. approximately 1000) to cyt c was found to be 1.15 x 10(5) M(-1) at pH 8.0 and low ionic strength. The results indicate that the polyglutamate (n>or approximately equal 8) is able to increase the stability of the methionine sulfur-heme iron bond of cytochrome c in spite of structural differences that weaken the overall stability of the cyt c at neutral and slightly alkaline pH.     

Sedimentation and intrinsic viscosity behavior of PM2 bacteriophage DNA in alkaline solution

The sedimentation coefficient and intrinsic viscosity of nicked and closed circular PM2 bacteriophage DNA have been measured as a function of pH in the alkaline region. A gradual increase in the sidimentation coefficient, and a corresponding decrease in the intrinsic viscosity, are observed for the superhelical (closed) circle in the pH region from 10.5 to about 10.9. This has been tentatively interpreted in terms of the known dependence of sedimentation coefficient upon the number of superhelical turns. At slightly higher pH values, the curve passes through the minimum (sedimentation coefficient) and maximum (intrinsic viscosity) expected when the superhelical turns present at neutral pH are unwound by partial alkaline denaturation. Sedimentation studies of the relaxed (nicked) circular species have revealed the existence of DNA forms in the pH region from 11.27 to 11.37 which sediment considerably faster than the closed circle in the same pH region. These have been identified as partially denatured nicked circles, in which varying fractions of the duplex structure have undergone alkaline denaturation, but strand separation has not yet occurred. Varying fractions of a slower species, either undenatured or completely denatured nicked circles, are also observed in some of these experiments. A corresponding result is observed in the intrinsic viscosity vs. pH curve. When nicked circular PM2 DNA is exposed to various alkaline pH's, rapidly neutralized, and sedimented at neutral pH, the expected sharp transition from native to denatured (strand-separated) molecules is seen. However, a very narrow pH range is noted in which native and denatured forms coexist in a single experiment. The above experiments carried out upon the closed form also reveal a narrow pH range in which the bulk of the transition from native closed circles to the collapsed cyclic coil takes place, in acccord with an earlier study on a different DNA. This transition is shown never to be completely effected, however, as there is a fraction (7–8%)of the closed circles which renature to the native form, regardless of the alkaline pH employed. This same phenomenon was not observed in the case of artificially closed λb₂b₅c DNA circles. Possible explanations for some of the above results are discussed.     

Ion binding to cytochrome c studied by nuclear magnetic quadrupole relaxation.

The enhancement of the 35Cl- transverse relaxation rate on binding of chloride ions to oxidized and reduced cytochrome c has been studied under conditions of variable sodium chloride concentration, temperature, pH, sodium phosphate, iron hexacyanide, and sodium cyanide concentration. The results revealed the presence of a strong binding site(s) for chloride in both oxidized and reduced cyt c, with a higher affinity in ferrocytochrome c. Competition experiments suggest that these sites also bind iron hexacyanide and phosphate. Cyanide binding to the iron in ferricytochrome c at alkaline and neutral pH was shown to decrease the binding of chloride. The pH dependence of the 35Cl- relaxation rate has been fitted by using literature pK values for ionizable groups. No indications of Na+ binding to oxidized and reduced cytochrome c have been observed by using 23Na+ NMR. Our results suggest that chloride is bound near the exposed heme edge and that the surface structure or dynamics in this region are different in the two oxidation states.     

A model for the misfolded bis-His intermediate of cytochrome c: the 1-56 N-fragment

We have characterized the ferric and ferrous forms of the heme-containing (1-56 residues) N-fragment of horse heart cytochrome c (cyt c) at different pH values and low ionic strength by UV-visible absorption and resonance Raman (RR) scattering. The results are compared with native cyt c in the same experimental conditions as this may provide a deeper insight into the cyt c unfolding-folding process. Folding of cyt c leads to a state having the heme iron coordinated to a histidine (His18) and a methionine (Met80) as axial ligands. At neutral pH the N-fragment (which lacks Met80) shows absorption and RR spectra that are consistent with the presence of a bis-His low spin heme, like several non-native forms of the parental protein. In particular, the optical spectra are identical to those of cyt c in the presence of a high concentration of denaturants; this renders the N-fragment a suitable model to study the heme pocket microenvironment of the misfolded (His-His) intermediate formed during folding of cyt c. Acid pH affects the ligation state in both cyt c and the N-fragment. Data obtained as a function of pH allow a correlation between the structural properties in the heme pocket of the N-fragment and those of non-native forms of cyt c. The results underline that the (57-104 residues) segment under native-like conditions imparts structural stability to the protein by impeding solvent access into the heme pocket.     

Reduction of horse heart ferricytochrome c by glutathione: evidence for two different conformational forms of ferricytochrome c in neutral and slightly alkaline solutions.

The reduction of horse heart ferricytochrome c in neutral and slightly alkaline solutions follows biphasic kinetics. The obtained results are consistent with the existence of two conformational forms of ferricytochrome c, cyt c and cyt c¹. The conversion of cyt c to cyt c¹ occurs by deprotonation (pK～7), followed by a slow conformational change in the protein structure.     

Perchlorate binding to cytochrome c: a magnetic and optical study

1. The effects of perchlorate on cytochrome c have been investigated by 1H and 35Cl NMR, electron paramagnetic resonance and optical spectroscopy. 2. The pK values for the formation and disappearance of the major alkaline conformation were found to be displaced from 9.3 to 8.3 and from 10.4 to 10.9, respectively. The displacement was dependent on the ClO4(-) concentration below 0.1 M. 3. Competition experiments between perchlorate and chloride show that ClO4(-) binds both to the neutral and alkaline forms but with a higher affinity for the latter. The appearance of a new binding site in the alkaline form accounts for the markedly enhanced relaxation rate of 35ClO4(-) in this pH range. Complex formation between cyanide and the alkaline species results in the loss of this binding site, which probably is located close to or within the heme crevice. 4. The neutral form of ferricytochrome c also binds perchlorate strongly as evidence by the unique appearance of a high-spin signal dependent on pH and perchlorate concentration. This signal disappears with the same pK value as the neutral form. The effects of perchlorate on cytochrome c are due to specific binding of this ion.     

Kinetics and mechanism of the reduction of horse heart ferricytochrome c by glutathione.

A detailed investigation of the reduction of cytochrome c by glutathione has shown that the reaction proceeds through several steps. A rapid combination of the reducing agent with the cytochrome leads to the formation of a glutathione-cytochrome intermediate in which the glutathione most likely interacts with the edge of the heme moiety. The electron transfer takes place in a subsequent slower step. Since cytochrome c(III) exists in two conformational forms at neutral pH [Kujundzic, N., & Everse, J. (1978) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 82, 1211], the reduction of cytochrome c by glutathione may be represented by cyt c(III) + GS- reversible K1 cyt c(III) ... GS- reversible k1 products cyt c*(III) + GS- reversible K2 cyt c*(III) ... GS- reversible k2 products At 25 degrees C, pH 7.5, and an ionic strength of 1.0 (NaCl), k1 = 1.2 X 10(-3) S-1, k2 = 2.0 X 10(-3) S-1, k1 = 2.9 X 10(3) M-1, and K2 = 5.3 X 10(3) M-1. The reaction is catalyzed by trisulfides, and second-order rate constants of 4.55 X 10(3) and 7.14 X 10(3) M-1 S-1 were obtained for methyl trisulfide and cysteine trisulfide, respectively.     

Characterization of the reaction products of cytochrome c with glutathione by mass spectrometry

Cytochrome c and glutathione (GSH) are two important biomolecules that regulate many cellular processes. The reaction of cytochrome c with GSH involves radical oxygen species and exhibits significant complexity. In the present work, the reaction of cytochrome c with GSH in water was characterized using mass spectrometry. The results show for the first time that the reaction generates multiple products including apocytochrome c in oxidized and reduced forms, glutathionylated apocytochrome c, GSH-modified cytochrome c, and oxidized and hydroxylated species. The reaction is O(2) dependent and is rapid in water at neutral pH and 37 degrees C. The reaction involves the cleavage of thioether linkages between the heme and apocytochrome c. Evidence for the role of H(2)O(2) and other oxygen radicals in this reaction is also provided.     

Reactivity of photoreduced cytochrome aa3 complexes with molecular oxygen.

Cytochrome c oxidase (ox heart cytochrome aa3) is reduced on illumination in the presence of a photocatalyst system containing deazaflavin and EDTA. The photo-reduced enzyme reacts with oxygen at neutral pH to give a form of ferric enzyme, whereas a corresponding sample partially reduced by light in the absence of any photocatalyst reacts with oxygen to give an oxyferri species ('oxygenated' enzyme). Reduction by the photocatalyst system at an alkaline pH value (9.0) also gives rise to fully reduced oxidase (both haem groups ferrous). At these pH values the immediate product after oxygen addition is a species with a 605-606 nm absorption band, not identical with ferrous cytochrome a, but capable of oxidizing added cytochrome c. This intermediate, which is unstable at neutral pH, may be analogous to the 'compound B' obtained by Chance and co-workers [Chance, Saronio & Leigh (1975) J. Biol. Chem. 250, 9226-9237; Chance, Saronio & Leigh (1979) Biochem. J. 177, 931-941] at low temperatures.     

The kinetics of the reduction of cytochrome c by the superoxide anion radical.

1. At neutral pH ferricytochrome c is reduced by the superoxide anion radical (O2-), without loss of enzymatic activity, by a second order process in which no intermediates are observed. The yield of ferrocytochrome c (82-104%), as related to the amount of O2- produced, is slightly dependent on the concentration of sodium formate in the matrix solution. 2. The reaction (k1 equals (1.1+/-0.1) - 10(6) M-1 - s-1 at pH 7.2, I equals 4 mM and 21 degrees C) can be inhibited by superoxide dismutase and trace amounts of copper ions. The inhibition by copper ions is removed by EDTA without interference in the O2- reduction reaction. 3. The second-order rate constant for the reaction of O2- with ferricytochrome c depends on the pH of the matrix solution, decreasing rapidly at pH greater than 8. The dependence of the rate constant on the pH can be explained by assuming that only the neutral form of ferricytochrome c reacts with O2- and that the alkaline form of the hemoprotein is unreactive. From studies at pH 8.9, the rate for the transition from the alkaline to the neutral form of ferricytochrome c can be estimated to be 0.3 s-1 (at 21 degrees C and I equals 4 mM). 4. The second-order rate constant for the reaction of O2- with ferricytochrome c is also dependent on the ionic strength of the medium. From a plot of log k1 versus I1/2-(I + alphaI1/2)-1 we determined the effective charge on the ferricytochrome c molecule as +6.3 and the rate constant at I equals 0 as (3.1+/-0.1) - 10(6) M-1 - s-1 (pH 7.1, 21 degrees C). 5. The possibility that singlet oxygen is formed as a product of the reaction of O2- with ferricytochrome c can be ruled out on thermodynamic grounds.     

Characterization of the polyanion-induced molten globule-like state of cytochrome c

Cytochrome c (cyt c) undergoes a poly(vinylsulphate) (PVS)-induced transition at slightly acidic pH into a molten globule-like state that resembles the effect that negatively charged membrane surfaces have on this protein. In this work, the thermodynamic properties of the molten globule-like state of cyt c in complex with PVS are studied using differential scanning calorimetry, circular dichroism, fluorescence, and absorbance spectroscopy. The temperature-induced transition of the molten globule-like state of cyt c in the complex with PVS is characterized by a significantly lower calorimetric enthalpy than in the "typical" molten globule state of cyt c, i.e. free protein at pH 2.0 in high ionic strength. Moreover, the thermally-denatured state of cyt c in the complex at pH < 6 contains nearly 50% of the native secondary structure. The dependence of the transition temperature on the pH indicates a role for histidine residues in the destabilization of the cyt c structure in the PVS complex and in stabilization of the denatured state with the residual secondary structure. A comparison of the effects of small anions and polyanions demonstrates the importance of cooperativity among the anions in the destabilization of cyt c. Predictably, other hydrophilic flexible polyanions such as heparin, polyglutamate, and polyadenylate also have a destabilizing effect on the structure of cyt c. However, a correlation between the properties of the polyanions and their effect on the protein stability is still unclear.