Intergeneric hybridization between<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Erucastrum cardaminoides</Emphasis> and two diploid crop<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Brassica</Emphasis> species

Two intergeneric hybrids involving wild species Erucastrum cardaminoides (2n=18, E^cd E^cd) and two crop brassica species, Brassica rapa (2n=20, AA) and B. nigra (2n=16, BB), were synthesized through in vitro sequential ovary culture. Morphological, molecular and cytological studies were conducted to establish their hybridity. Both hybrids, though morphologically distinct, were intermediate phenotypically between their respective parents. Cytological analysis of the E. cardaminoides × B. rapa hybrid (2n=19), revealed the occurrence of 17 I+1 II at diakinesis/metaphase in the majority (28%) of the pollen mother cells (PMCs), whereas in E. cardaminoides × B. nigra hybrid (2n=17), 13 I+2 II was the predominant (32%) meiotic configuration. A maximum of 5 II was recorded in both hybrids, indicating homoeologous pairing in the respective combined genomes. Chromosome doubling by colchicine application gave rise to two new amphiploids (AA E^cdE^cd and BB E^cdE^cd) having normal chromosome pairing and pollen fertility. The occasional occurrence of one quadrivalent in the amphiploids confirmed partial homoeology between the E^c and A/B genomes. The E. cardaminoides ×B. nigra hybrid and amphiploid appeared to be tolerant to alternaria blight under field conditions.Communicated by H.F. Linskens     

Shoot δ15N and δ13C values of non-host Brassica rapa change when exposed to ±Glomus etunicatum inoculum and three levels of phosphorus and nitrogen

Glasshouse experiments were conducted to study the response of non-host Brassica rapa and host Sorghum bicolor to inoculation with the arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus (AMF) Glomus etunicatum when given different levels of N (0.9 mmol kg^-1 sand, 2.7 mmol kg^-1 sand, 8.1 mmol kg^-1 sand) and P (3.6 µmol kg^-1 sand, 10.7 µmol kg^-1 sand, 32.0 µmol kg^-1 sand) fertiliser. On both plant species, the presence of G. etunicatum inoculum (+AMF) was associated with significant changes of shoot '¹⁵N values, with +AMF plants having larger average '¹⁵N values than uninoculated plants (-AMF). These values are the largest average differences in shoot '¹⁵N yet recorded for AMF and nutrient effects. B. rapa shoot '¹⁵N average differences ranged from 1.67‰ to 2.70‰, while for S. bicolor they range between 2.07‰ and 4.40‰. For shoot '¹³C only the non-host B. rapa responded to -AMF and added N. Although the harvested dry weight biomass (-35.2% B. rapa; +39.8% S. bicolor) of both plant species responded to AMF inoculation, no direct relationship was observed between isotopic discrimination and growth inhibition for the non-host B. rapa. In this paper we discuss some implications regarding AMF inocula on the basis of our findings and current literature.     

Interactions between extrafloral nectaries, aphids and ants: are there competition effects between plant and homopteran sugar sources?

Broad bean (Vicia faba), an annual plant bearing extrafloral nectaries (EFN) at the base of the upper leaves, is regularly infested by two aphid species, Aphis fabae and Acyrthosiphon pisum. EFN and A. fabae are commonly attended by the ant, Lasius niger, while Ac. pisum usually remains uninfested. Sugar concentration and sugar composition of extrafloral nectar did not change significantly after aphid infestation. The sugar concentration was significantly higher in EFN (c. 271 µg µl^-1) than in the honeydew of A. fabae (37.5 µg µl^-1). The presence of small A. fabae colonies had no significant effect on ant attendance of EFN, which remained at the same level as that on plants without A. fabae. Obviously, there was no significant competitive effect between the two sugar sources. We suggest that the high sugar concentration in the extrafloral nectar may outweigh the higher quality (due to the presence of melezitose) and quantity of aphid honeydew. Ants and the presence of EFN influenced aphid colony growth. While A. fabae colonies generally grew better in the presence of ants, Ac. pisum colonies declined on plants with EFN or A. fabae colonies. We conclude that EFN may provide some degree of protection for V. faba against those sucking herbivores that are not able to attract ants.     

Production of fertile intergeneric somatic hybrids between Brassica napus and Sinapis arvensis for the enrichment of the rapeseed gene pool

Somatic hybrids between Brassica napus (oilseed rape) and its wild relative Sinapis arvensis (Xinjiang wild mustard) from northwestern China were produced by fusing mesophyll protoplasts. Fifty-four plants were identified as symmetric hybrids and four as asymmetric hybrids by random amplified polymorphic DNA analysis and nuclear DNA content. The morphology of investigated 58 hybrid plants resembled characters from both parental species. Highly fertile hybrids were recovered where the fertility was associated with the choice of B. napus genotype. Enhanced disease resistance to Leptosphaeria maculans was found in S. arvensis and in the hybrid offspring. This plant material has great potentials not only for use as a bridge for the introduction of a number of valuable traits from the wild species to Brassica crops but also for breeding new varieties with improved blackleg resistance.     

Diversity of Olea genotypes and the origin of cultivated olives

Tandem repeats belonging to three DNA sequence families (OeTaq80, OeTaq178, and OeGEM86) were isolated from the nuclear DNA of Olea europaea cv. Carolea and dot-hybridized to the genomic DNA of 14 hypothetically different Olea species, 78 olive cultivars, and 14 wild olives. The copy number per unreplicated haploid genome of OeTaq80- and OeTaq178-related sequences was in the 10⁷-10⁶ range and that of OeGEM86-related sequences was in the 10⁵ range in cultivars, wild olives and some Olea species. A large variation in the frequency of repeats belonging to each sequence family was observed within each group of plants. Positive correlations existed in each genome between the frequencies of repeats belonging to each family, and their overall frequency was positively correlated to the genome size. Duncan grouping showed that the frequency variation of tandem repeats within each group of plants was not continuous. Two main groups and several subgroups of genotypes could be separated within both the olive cultivars and the wild olives. Discrete areas in the Mediterranean Basin could be delimited by the geographic distribution of cultivated olives with different genotypes and the wild plants were associated with the cultivars in these areas according to genotypic similarity. The Olea species could be divided into four genotypic groups. Three of these, comprising accessions from Asia and North Africa, showed similarity with the genotypes of cultivars and wild olives. These results suggest a polyphyletic origin of cultivated olives from different wild Olea forms distributed throughout the Mediterranean Basin.     

14C transfer between the spring ephemeral Erythronium americanum and sugar maple saplings via arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi in natural stands

We investigated in the field the carbon (C) transfer between sugar maple (Acer saccharum) saplings and the spring ephemeral Erythronium americanum via the mycelium of arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi. Sugar maple saplings and E. americanum plants were planted together in pots placed in the ground of a maple forest in 1999. Ectomycorrhizal yellow birches (Betula alleghaniensis) were added as control plants. In spring 2000, during leaf expansion of sugar maple saplings, the leaves of E. americanum were labelled with ¹⁴CO₂. Seven days after labelling, radioactivity was detected in leaves, stem and roots of sugar maples. Specific radioactivity in sugar maples was 13-fold higher than in yellow birches revealing the occurrence of a direct transfer of ¹⁴C between the AM plants. The quantity of ¹⁴C transferred to sugar maple saplings was negatively correlated with the percentage of ¹⁴C allocated to the storage organ of E. americanum. A second labelling was performed in autumn 2000 on sugar maple leaves during annual growth of E. americanum roots. Radioactivity was detected in 7 of 22 E. americanum root systems and absent in yellow birches. These results suggest that AM fungi connecting different understorey species can act as reciprocal C transfer bridges between plant species in relation with the phenology of the plants involved.     

Leaf δ<Superscript>13</Superscript>C variability with elevation,slope aspect,and precipitation in the southwest United States

Leaves from several desert and woodland species, including gymnosperms and angiosperms with both C₃ and C₄ physiology, were analyzed to detect trends in '¹³C_leaf with elevation and slope aspect along two transects in southeastern Utah and south-central New Mexico, USA. The main difference between the two transects is the steeper elevational gradient for mean annual and summer precipitation in the southern transect. For any given species, we found that isotopic differences between individual plants growing at the same site commonly equal differences measured for plants along the entire altitudinal gradient. In C₃ plants, '¹³C_leaf values become slightly enriched at the lowest elevations, the opposite of trends identified in more humid regions. Apparently, increasing water-use efficiency with drought stress offsets the influence of other biotic and abiotic factors that operate to decrease isotopic discrimination with elevation. For some species shared by the two transects (e.g., Pinus edulis and Cercocarpus montanus), '¹³C_leaf values are dramatically depleted at sites that receive more than 550 mm mean annual precipitation, roughly the boundary (pedalfer-pedocal) at which soils commonly fill to field capacity in summer and carbonates are leached. We hypothesize that, in summer-wet areas, this may represent the boundary at which drought stress overtakes other factors in determining the sign of '¹³C_leaf with elevation. The opposition of isotopic trends with elevation in arid versus humid regions cautions against standard correction for elevation in comparative studies of '¹³C_leaf.     

Water availability and carbon isotope discrimination in conifers

The stable C isotope composition ('¹³C) of leaf and wood tissue has been used as an index of water availability at both the species and landscape level. However, the generality of this relationship across species has received little attention. We compiled literature data for a range of conifers and examined relationships among landscape and environmental variables (altitude, precipitation, evaporation) and '¹³C. A significant component of the variation in '¹³C was related to altitude (discrimination decreased with altitude in stemwood, 2.53‰ km^-1 altitude, r²=0.49, and in foliage, 1.91‰ km^-1, r²=0.42), as has been noted previously. The decrease in discrimination with altitude was such that the gradient in CO₂ partial pressure into the leaf (P_a-P_i) and altitude were generally unrelated. The ratio of precipitation to evaporation (P/E) explained significant variation in P_a-P_i of stemwood (r²=0.45) and foliage (r²=0.27), but only at low (<0.8) P/E. At greater P/E there was little or no relationship, and other influences on '¹³C probably dominated the effect of water availability. We also examined the relationship between plant drought stress (O) and '¹³C within annual rings of stemwood from Pinus radiata and Pinus pinaster in south-western Australia. Differential thinning and fertiliser application produced large differences in the availability of water, nutrients and light to individual trees. At a density of 750 stems ha^-1, O and '¹³C were less (more negative) than at 250 stems ha^-1 indicating greater drought stress and less efficient water use, contrary to what was expected in light of the general relationship between discrimination and P/E. The greater '¹³C of trees from heavily thinned plots may well be related to an increased interception of radiation by individual trees and greater concentrations of nutrients in foliage - attributes that increase rates of photosynthesis, reduce P_i and increase '¹³C. '¹³C was thus modified to a greater extent by interception of radiation and by nutrient concentrations than by water availability and the '¹³C-O relationship varied between thinning treatments. Within treatments, the relationship between '¹³C and O was strong (0.38<r²<0.58). We conclude that '¹³C may well be a useful indicator of water availability or drought stress, but only in seasonally dry climates (P/E<1) and where variation in other environmental factors can be accounted for.     

Relations between efficiency of water transport and duration of leaf growth in some deciduous and evergreen trees

Shoot and leaf growth rate as well as shoot hydraulic conductance per unit leaf area (K_SL) were measured on three evergreen (Viburnum tinus L., Prunus laurocerasus L., Laurus nobilis L.) and three deciduous (Corylus avellana L., Juglans regia L., Castanea sativa L.) trees growing under the same environmental conditions. The times required to complete shoot growth (27 days for P. laurocerasus to 51 days for V. tinus) and leaf expansion (24 days for C. sativa to 42 days for C. avellana) were very different among the studied species. These species also differed in K_SL that ranged between 1.5 and 3.5 e-4 kg s^-1 m^-2 MPa^-1 in C. avellana and C. sativa, respectively, with intermediate values recorded in the other species. A strong, negative and statistically significant correlation was found to exist between K_SL and the time required for complete leaf expansion. This suggests that duration of leaf growth is shortened by the high hydraulic efficiency of the shoot. In contrast, no statistically significant relationship was found to exist between K_SL and shoot growth rate. Whether a high leaf growth rate can be interpreted as advantageous to plants or it is only an epiphenomenon of the high efficiency in the vertical water transport is discussed.     

Production and cytogenetics of intergeneric hybrids between Brassica napus and Orychophragmus violaceus

The intergeneric hybrid between Brassica napus and Orychophragmus violaceus was obtained by means of embryo culture technique with the latter as the pollen parent. The hybrid was morphologically intermediate between its parents, but could produce a lot of seeds when selfed. Somatic separation of the genomes from the two parental species was observed during the mitotic divisions of some of the hybrid cells. Thus, the hybrid became the mixoploid in nature, consisting of haploid and diploid cells of B. napus, and a nuclear — cytoplasmic hybrid, with the cytoplasm of B. napus and the nuclei of O. violaceus, and the hybrid cells. Pollen mother cells with 19, 12 and 6 bivalents, respectively, were produced by the hybrid. From the selfed progeny of the hybrid, mainly two kinds of plants, B. napus and the hybrid, were found. The hybrid plants of the selfed progeny again produced two kinds of plants, B. napus and the hybrid.     

Genetic analysis of hybrid seed formation ability of Brassica rapa in intergeneric crossings with Raphanus sativus

A hybridization barrier leads to the inability of seed formation after intergeneric crossings between Brassica rapa and Raphanus sativus. Most B. rapa lines cannot set intergeneric hybrid seeds because of embryo breakdown, but a B. rapa line obtained from turnip cultivar ‘Shogoin-kabu’ is able to produce a large number of hybrid seeds as a maternal parent by crossings with R. sativus. In ‘Shogoin-kabu’ crossed with R. sativus, developments of embryos and endosperms were slower than those in intraspecific crossings, but some of them grew to mature seeds without embryo breakdown. Intergeneric hybrid seeds were obtained in a ‘Shogoin-kabu’ line at a rate of 0.13 per pollinated flower, while no hybrid seeds were obtained in a line developed from Chinese cabbage cultivar ‘Chiifu’. F₁ hybrid plants between the lines of ‘Shogoin-kabu’ and ‘Chiifu’ set a larger number of hybrid seeds per flower, 0.68, than both the parental lines. Quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for hybrid seed formation were analyzed after intergeneric crossings using two different F₂ populations derived from the F₁ hybrids, and three QTLs with significant logarithm of odds scores were detected. Among them, two QTLs, i.e., one in linkage group A10 and the other in linkage group A01, were detected in both the F₂ populations. These two QTLs had contrary effects on the number of hybrid seeds. Epistatic interaction between these two QTLs was revealed. Possible candidate genes controlling hybrid seed formation ability in QTL regions were inferred using the published B. rapa genome sequences.     

Development and characterization of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica juncea – fruticulosa</Emphasis> introgression lines exhibiting resistance to mustard aphid (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Lipaphis erysimi</Emphasis> Kalt)

Background

Mustard aphid is a major pest of Brassica oilseeds. No source for aphid resistance is presently available in Brassica juncea . A wild crucifer, Brassica fruticulosa is known to be resistant to mustard aphid. An artificially synthesized amphiploid, AD-4 (B. fruticulosa × B. rapa var. brown sarson) was developed for use as a bridge species to transfer fruticulosa resistance to B. juncea. Using the selfed backcross we could select a large number of lines with resistance to mustard aphid. This paper reports cytogenetic stability of introgression lines, molecular evidence for alien introgression and their reaction to mustard aphid infestation.

Results

Majority of introgression lines had expected euploid chromosome number(2n= 36), showed normal meiosis and high pollen grain fertility. Well-distributed and transferable simple-sequence repeats (SSR) markers for all the 18 B. juncea chromosomes helped to characterize introgression events. Average proportions of recipient and donor genome in the substitution lines were 49.72 and 35.06%, respectively. Minimum alien parent genome presence (27.29%) was observed in the introgression line, Ad3K-280 . Introgressed genotypes also varied for their resistance responses to mustard aphid infestations under artificial release conditions for two continuous seasons. Some of the test genotypes showed consistent resistant reaction.

Conclusions

B.juncea-fruticulosa introgression set may prove to be a very powerful breeding tool for aphid resistance related QTL/gene discovery and fine mapping of the desired genes/QTLs to facilitate marker assisted transfer of identified gene(s) for mustard aphid resistance in the background of commercial mustard genotypes.

     

Microsite characteristics of Muhlenbergia richardsonis (Trin.) Rydb., an alpine C4 grass from the White Mountains, California

C₄ plants are uncommon in cold environments and do not generally occur in the alpine tundra. In the White Mountains of California, however, the C₄ grass Muhlenbergia richardsonis is common in the alpine zone at 3,300-3,800 m, with the highest population observed at 3,960 m (13,000 feet) above sea level. This is the highest reported C₄ species in North America and is near the world altitude limit for C₄ plants (4,000-4,500 m). Above 3,800 m, M. richardsonis is largely restricted to southern slope aspects, with greatest frequency on southeast-facing slopes. In open tundra, M. richardsonis formed prostrate mats with a mean height of 2.5 cm. Neighboring C₃ grasses were two to three times taller. Because of its short stature, leaf temperature of M. richardsonis was greatly influenced by the boundary layer of the ground, rising over 20°C above air temperature in full sun and still air and over 10°C above air temperature in full sun and wind velocity of 1-4 m s^-1. Thus, although air temperatures did not exceed 15°C, midday leaf temperatures of M. richardsonis were routinely between 25°C and 35°C, a range favorable to C₄ photosynthesis. At night, leaf temperature of M. richardsonis was often 5-12°C below air temperature, resulting in regular exposure to subzero temperatures and frosting of the leaves. No visible injury was associated with exposure to freezing night temperatures. The presence of M. richardsonis in the alpine zone demonstrates that C₄ plants can tolerate extreme cold during the growing season. The localization to microsites where leaf temperatures can exceed 25°C during the day, however, indicates that even when cold tolerant, C₄ plants still require periods of high leaf temperature to remain competitive with C₃ species. In this regard, the prostrate growth form of M. richardsonis compensates for the alpine climate by allowing sufficient heating of the leaf canopy during the day.     

Gene transfer between canola (Brassica napus L. and B. campestris L.) and related weed species

Brassica species are particularly receptive to gene transformation techniques. There now exists canola genotypes with transgenic herbicide resistance for glyphosate, imidazolinone, sulfonylurea and glufosinate herbicides. The main concern of introducing such herbicide resistance into commercial agriculture is the introgression of the engineered gene to related weed species. The potential of gene transfer between canola (Brassica napus and B. campestris) and related weed species was determined by hand pollination under controlled greenhouse conditions. Canola was used as both male and female parent in crosses to the related weed species collected in the Inland Northwest region of the United States. Weed species used included: field mustard (B. rapa), wild mustard (S. arvensis) and black mustard (B. nigra). Biological and cytological aspects necessary for successful hybrid seed production were investigated including: pollen germination on the stigma; pollen tube growth down the style; attraction of pollen tubes to the ovule; ovule fertilisation; embryo and endosperm developmental stages. Pollen germination was observed in all 25 hybrid combinations. Pollen tubes were found in the ovary of over 80% of combinations. About 30% of the hybrid combinations developed to the heart stage of embryo development or further. In an additional study involving transgenic glufosinate herbicide resistant B. napus and field mustard it was found that hybrids occurred with relatively high frequency, hybrids exhibited glufosinate herbicide resistance and a small proportion of hybrids produced self fertile seeds. These fertile plants were found to backcross to either canola or weed parent.     

Origins of the amphiploid species <Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica napus</Emphasis>L. investigated by chloroplast and nuclear molecular markers

Background  

The amphiploid species Brassica napus (oilseed rape, Canola) is a globally important oil crop yielding food, biofuels and industrial compounds such as lubricants and surfactants. Identification of the likely ancestors of each of the two genomes (designated A and C) found in B. napus would facilitate incorporation of novel alleles from the wider Brassica genepool in oilseed rape crop genetic improvement programmes. Knowledge of the closest extant relatives of the genotypes involved in the initial formation of B. napus would also allow further investigation of the genetic factors required for the formation of a stable amphiploid and permit the more efficient creation of fully fertile re-synthesised B. napus. We have used a combination of chloroplast and nuclear genetic markers to investigate the closest extant relatives of the original maternal progenitors of B. napus. This was based on a comprehensive sampling of the relevant genepools, including 83 accessions of A genome B. rapa L. (both wild and cultivated types), 94 accessions of B. napus and 181 accessions of C genome wild and cultivated B. oleracea L. and related species.     

13C content of ecosystem respiration is linked to precipitation and vapor pressure deficit

Variation in the carbon isotopic composition of ecosystem respiration ('¹³C_R) was studied for 3 years along a precipitation gradient in western Oregon, USA, using the Keeling plot approach. Study sites included six coniferous forests, dominated by Picea sitchensis, Tsuga heterophylla, Pseudotsuga menziesii, Pinus ponderosa, and Juniperus occidentalis, and ranged in location from the Pacific coast to the eastern side of the Cascade Mountains (a 250-km transect). Mean annual precipitation across these sites ranged from 227 to 2,760 mm. Overall '¹³C_R varied from -23.1 to -33.1‰, and within a single forest, it varied in magnitude by 3.5-8.5‰. Mean annual '¹³C_R differed significantly in the forests and was strongly correlated with mean annual precipitation. The carbon isotope ratio of carbon stocks (leaves, fine roots, litter, and soil organic matter) varied similarly with mean precipitation (more positive at the drier sites). There was a strong link between '¹³C_R and the vapor saturation deficit of air (vpd) 5-10 days earlier, both across and within sites. This relationship is consistent with stomatal regulation of gas exchange and associated changes in photosynthetic carbon isotope discrimination. Recent freeze events caused significant deviation from the '¹³C_R versus vpd relationship, resulting in higher than expected '¹³C_R values.     

Meiotic behaviour of Un,D and R genomes in the amphiploid Aegilops ventricosa -Secale cereale and the parental species

Summary Meiotic pairing frequencies of the Un and D genomes of Ae. ventricosa and the R of S. cereale could be easily established at metaphase I in Aegilops ventricosa — Secale cereale amphiploid plants as well as in its parental species by using the C-banding technique procedure. The results show a high diminution of chromosome pairing for all genomes in the amphiploid with respect to its parental species probably due to C-heterochromatin content and/or genotypic or cryptic interactions between the three genomes.     

Salt, nutrient uptake and transport, and ABA of Populus euphratica; a hybrid in response to increasing soil NaCl

The uptake and transport of salt ions (Na⁺, Cl^-), macronutrients (K⁺, Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺) and abscisic acid (ABA) response to increasing soil salinity were examined in 2-year-old seedlings of Populus euphratica and a hybrid, P. talassica Kom 2 (P. euphratica + Salix alba L.). Leaf burn symptoms appeared in the hybrid after 8 days of exposure to salinity when soil NaCl concentration increased to 206 mM, whereas P. euphratica exhibited leaf damage after day 21 when soil NaCl exceeded 354 mM. Leaf necrosis was the result of excess salt accumulation since the injury followed an abrupt increase of endogenous salt levels. Compared with the hybrid, P. euphratica exhibited a greater capacity to exclude salt ions from leaves under increasing salinity, especially Cl^-. Salt treatment altered nutrient balance of the hybrid, leaf K⁺, Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ concentrations significantly declined and the same trends were observed in roots with the exception of K⁺. Although K⁺ levels decreased in salinised P. euphratica, increasing salinity did not affect the levels of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ in leaves, but did increase the uptake of these nutrients when salt stress was initiated. NaCl-induced increase of ABA concentration in xylem sap [ABA] was observed in the two tested genotypes, however xylem [ABA] increased more rapidly in P. euphratica and a fivefold increase of xylem [ABA] was recorded after the first day of exposure to salt stress. Therefore, we conclude that the increase of Ca²⁺ uptake may be associated with the rise of ABA, and thus contributes to membrane integrity maintenance, which enables P. euphratica to regulate uptake and transport of salt ions under high levels of external salinity in the longer term.     

Insects as vectors of plant pathogens: mutualistic and antagonistic interactions

Interactions between plants and their herbivores and pathogens are mostly analysed separately, thereby neglecting mutualistic or antagonistic interactions between these antagonists and possible joint effects on the host. We studied interactions between the weed Cirsium arvense, the rust fungus Puccinia punctiformis and three herbivorous insects, the aphids Aphis fabae ssp. cirsiiacanthoidis and Uroleucon cirsii, and the beetle Cassida rubiginosa. All three insect species mechanically transported spore material and significantly increased rates of P. punctiformis infection in healthy thistles. The interaction between C. rubiginosa and the fungus was antagonistic. Although C. rubiginosa transferred spores, biomass of adults was significantly reduced, development of adults tended to be prolonged and mortality increased when feeding on plants infected with P. punctiformis. In contrast, the relationship between the aphid U. cirsii and P. punctiformis was mutualistic: U. cirsii profited by fungal infection and formed significantly larger colonies on fungus-infected plants. Although the differences in insect performance suggest that aphids may be better vectors than the beetle, infection rates were similar. This is the first study to demonstrate that the relationship between herbivores, which increase the dispersal of a pathogen, and the pathogen itself can be mutualistic or antagonistic, depending on the species.