Responses of three generations of a xylem-feeding insect, Neophilaenus lineatus (Homoptera), to elevated CO2

A population of the xylem-feeding spittlebug, Neophilaenus lineatus, on blocks of natural vegetation transferred to large hemispherical chambers was studied over two generations with continuous exposure to elevated CO₂ (600 ppm). The third generation was transferred from the blocks to potted Juncus squarrosus to enable measurements of fecundity. The principal food plant throughout was Juncus squarrosus. Survival of the nymphs was reduced by more than 20% in elevated CO₂ relative to ambient (350 ppm) in both years of the main experiment. Elevated CO₂ also delayed development by one or more nymphal instars in each year. Fecundity was not significantly affected. The C/N ratio of whole Juncus leaves was increased in elevated CO₂ and the transpiration rates of the plants were reduced. These changes may have been responsible for the effect of elevated CO₂ on spittlebug performance. However, other factors such as plant architecture and microclimate may also be important.     

Response of multiple generations of cotton bollworm Helicoverpa armigera Hübner, feeding on spring wheat, to elevated CO2

Abstract:  The growth, development and consumption of three successive generations of cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa armigera (Hübner), reared on milky grains of spring wheat grown under elevated CO₂ (double-ambient vs. ambient) in open-top chambers (OTCs) were examined. Decreases in protein, total amino acid, water and nitrogen content, and increases in total non-structure carbohydrates (TNCs) and ratio of TNC : nitrogen were found in wheat milky grains grown under elevated CO₂ conditions. Changes in quality of wheat grains affected the growth, development and food utilization of H. armigera . Significantly longer larval lifespan for the third generation and lower pupal weight for all generations were observed in cotton bollworm fed on milky grains of spring wheat grown under elevated CO₂ conditions. Bollworm fecundity was significantly decreased for the second and third generations under elevated CO₂ levels. The consumption, frass per larva and relative consumption rate significantly increased in elevated CO₂ compared with ambient CO₂ conditions. However, the potential population consumption was significant reduced by elevated CO₂ in the second and third generations. The results of this study indicate that elevated CO₂ levels adversely affect grain quality, resulting in consistently increased consumption per larva for a longer period to produce less fecund bollworm through generations, suggesting that net damage of cotton bollworm on wheat will be less under elevated atmospheric CO₂ levels because increased consumption is offset by slower development and reduced fecundity.     

Effects of source-sink relations on photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO2

Abstract. While photosynthesis of C₃ plants is stimulated by an increase in the atmospheric CO₂ concentration, photosynthetic capacity is often reduced after long-term exposure to elevated CO₂. This reduction appears to be brought about by end product inhibition, resulting from an imbalance in the supply and demand of carbohydrates. A review of the literature revealed that the reduction of photosynthetic capacity in elevated CO₂ was most pronounced when the increased supply of carbohydrates was combined with small sink size. The volume of pots in which plants were grown affected the sink size by restricting root growth. While plants grown in small pots had a reduced photosynthetic capacity, plants grown in the field showed no reduction or an increase in this capacity. Pot volume also determined the effect of elevated CO₂ on the root/shoot ratio: the root/shoot ratio increased when root growth was not restricted and decreased in plants grown in small pots. The data presented in this paper suggest that plants growing in the field will maintain a high photosynthetic capacity as the atmospheric CO₂ level continues to rise.     

A mechanistic evaluation of photosynthetic acclimation at elevated CO2

Plants grown at elevated pCO₂ often fail to sustain the initial stimulation of net CO₂ uptake rate (A). This reduced, acclimated, stimulation of A often occurs concomitantly with a reduction in the maximum carboxylation velocity (V_c,max) of Rubisco. To investigate this relationship we used the Farquhar model of C₃ photosynthesis to predict the minimum V_c,max capable of supporting the acclimated stimulation in A observed at elevated pCO₂. For a wide range of species grown at elevated pCO₂ under contrasting conditions we found a strong correlation between observed and predicted values of V_c,max. This exercise mechanistically and quantitatively demonstrated that the observed acclimated stimulation of A and the simultaneous decrease in V_c,max observed at elevated pCO₂ is mechanistically consistent. With the exception of plants grown at a high elevated pCO₂ (> 90 Pa), which show evidence of an excess investment in Rubisco, the failure to maintain the initial stimulation of A is almost entirely attributable to the decrease in V_c,max and investment in Rubisco is coupled to requirements.     

Elevated CO2 and plant structure: a review

Consequences of increasing atmospheric CO₂ concentration on plant structure, an important determinant of physiological and competitive success, have not received sufficient attention in the literature. Understanding how increasing carbon input will influence plant developmental processes, and resultant form, will help bridge the gap between physiological response and ecosystem level phenomena. Growth in elevated CO₂ alters plant structure through its effects on both primary and secondary meristems of shoots and roots. Although not well established, a review of the literature suggests that cell division, cell expansion, and cell patterning may be affected, driven mainly by increased substrate (sucrose) availability and perhaps also by differential expression of genes involved in cell cycling (e.g. cyclins) or cell expansion (e.g. xyloglucan endotransglycosylase). Few studies, however, have attempted to elucidate the mechanistic basis for increased growth at the cellular level. Regardless of specific mechanisms involved, plant leaf size and anatomy are often altered by growth in elevated CO₂, but the magnitude of these changes, which often decreases as leaves mature, hinges upon plant genetic plasticity, nutrient availability, temperature, and phenology. Increased leaf growth results more often from increased cell expansion rather than increased division. Leaves of crop species exhibit greater increases in leaf thickness than do leaves of wild species. Increased mesophyll and vascular tissue cross-sectional areas, important determinates of photosynthetic rates and assimilate transport capacity, are often reported. Few studies, however, have quantified characteristics more reflective of leaf function such as spatial relationships among chlorenchyma cells (size, orientation, and surface area), intercellular spaces, and conductive tissue. Greater leaf size and/or more leaves per plant are often noted; plants grown in elevated CO₂ exhibited increased leaf area per plant in 66% of studies, compared to 28% of observations reporting no change, and 6% reported a decrease in whole plant leaf area. This resulted in an average net increase in leaf area per plant of 24%. Crop species showed the greatest average increase in whole plant leaf area (+ 37%) compared to tree species (+ 14%) and wild, nonwoody species (+ 15%). Conversely, tree species and wild, nontrees showed the greatest reduction in specific leaf area (– 14% and – 20%) compared to crop plants (– 6%). Alterations in developmental processes at the shoot apex and within the vascular cambium contributed to increased plant height, altered branching characteristics, and increased stem diameters. The ratio of internode length to node number often increased, but the length and sometimes the number of branches per node was greater, suggesting reduced apical dominance. Data concerning effects of elevated CO₂ on stem/branch anatomy, vital for understanding potential shifts in functional relationships of leaves with stems, roots with stems, and leaves with roots, are too few to make generalizations. Growth in elevated CO₂ typically leads to increased root length, diameter, and altered branching patterns. Altered branching characteristics in both shoots and roots may impact competitive relationships above and below the ground. Understanding how increased carbon assimilation affects growth processes (cell division, cell expansion, and cell patterning) will facilitate a better understanding of how plant form will change as atmospheric CO₂ increases. Knowing how basic growth processes respond to increased carbon inputs may also provide a mechanistic basis for the differential phenotypic plasticity exhibited by different plant species/functional types to elevated CO₂.     

Growth in elevated CO2 protects photosynthesis against high-temperature damage

We present evidence that plant growth at elevated atmospheric CO₂ increases the high‐temperature tolerance of photosynthesis in a wide variety of plant species under both greenhouse and field conditions. We grew plants at ambient CO₂ (~ 360 μ mol mol ^{? 1}) and elevated CO₂ (550–1000 μ mol mol ^{? 1}) in three separate growth facilities, including the Nevada Desert Free‐Air Carbon Dioxide Enrichment (FACE) facility. Excised leaves from both the ambient and elevated CO₂ treatments were exposed to temperatures ranging from 28 to 48 °C. In more than half the species examined (4 of 7, 3 of 5, and 3 of 5 species in the three facilities), leaves from elevated CO₂‐grown plants maintained PSII efficiency (F_v/F_m) to significantly higher temperatures than ambient‐grown leaves. This enhanced PSII thermotolerance was found in both woody and herbaceous species and in both monocots and dicots. Detailed experiments conducted with Cucumis sativus showed that the greater F_v/F_m in elevated versus ambient CO₂‐grown leaves following heat stress was due to both a higher F_m and a lower F_o, and that F_v/F_m differences between elevated and ambient CO₂‐grown leaves persisted for at least 20 h following heat shock. Cucumis sativus leaves from elevated CO₂‐grown plants had a critical temperature for the rapid rise in F_o that averaged 2·9 °C higher than leaves from ambient CO₂‐grown plants, and maintained a higher maximal rate of net CO₂ assimilation following heat shock. Given that photosynthesis is considered to be the physiological process most sensitive to high‐temperature damage and that rising atmospheric CO₂ content will drive temperature increases in many already stressful environments, this CO₂‐induced increase in plant high‐temperature tolerance may have a substantial impact on both the productivity and distribution of many plant species in the 21st century.     

Seed production and seed quality in a calcareous grassland in elevated CO2

In diverse plant communities the relative contribution of species to community biomass may change considerably in response to elevated CO₂. Along with species‐specific biomass responses, reproduction is likely to change as well with increasing CO₂ and might further accelerate shifts in species composition. Here, we ask if, after 5 years of CO₂ exposure, seed production and seed quality in natural nutrient‐poor calcareous grassland are affected by elevated CO₂ (650 μ L L^?1 vs 360 μ L L^?1) and how this might affect long‐term community dynamics. The effect of elevated CO₂ on the number of flowering shoots (+ 24%, P < 0.01) and seeds (+ 29%, P = 0.06) at the community level was similar to above ground biomass responses in this year, suggesting that the overall allocation to sexual reproduction remained unchanged. Compared among functional groups of species we found a 42% increase in seed number (P < 0.01) of graminoids, a 33% increase (P = 0.07) in forbs, and no significant change in legumes (? 38%, n.s.) under elevated CO₂. Large responses particularly of two graminoid species and smaller responses of many forb species summed up to the significant or marginally significant increase in seed number of graminoids and forbs, respectively. In several species the increase in seed number resulted both from an increase in flowering shoots and an increase in inflorescence size. In most species, seeds tended to be heavier (+ 12%, P < 0.01), and N‐concentration of seeds was significantly reduced in eight out of 13 species. The fraction of germinating seeds did not differ between seeds produced in ambient and elevated CO₂, but time to germination was significantly shortened in two species and prolonged in one species when seeds had been produced in elevated CO₂. Results suggest that species specific increases in seed number and changes in seed quality will exert substantial cumulative effects on community composition in the long run.     

Mineral nitrogen cycling through earthworm casts in a grazed pasture under elevated atmospheric CO2

We used the New Zealand grazed pasture free air CO₂ enrichment experiment to determine the effects of elevated CO₂ on earthworm (Aporrectodea caliginosa and Lumbricus rubellus) cast production and mineral nitrogen (N) concentration over a 5‐week period in the spring. Elevated CO₂ did not affect earthworm biomass or the amount of cast material produced. However, cast mineral N concentrations were 18% lower, resulting in 27% less mineral N being deposited on the soil surface under elevated CO₂. An analysis of the earthworms' potential diet showed that a reduction in the N content of sheep dung at elevated CO₂ was the most likely cause of the lower cast N concentrations. Earthworm casts made only a small contribution to mineral N cycling in our system; however, their quality may act as a sensitive indicator of reduced N availability under elevated CO₂ which is consistent with the hypothesised process of progressive N limitation.     

Effects of elevated CO2, nitrogen deposition, and decreased species diversity on foliar fungal plant disease

Three components of global change, elevated CO₂, nitrogen addition, and decreased plant species richness (‘diversity’), increased the percent leaf area infected by fungi (pathogen load) for much to all of the plant community in one year of a factorial grassland experiment. Decreased plant diversity had the broadest effect, increasing pathogen load across the plant community. Decreased diversity increased pathogen load primarily by allowing remaining plant species to increase in abundance, facilitating spread of foliar fungal pathogens specific to each plant species. Changes in plant species composition also strongly influenced community pathogen load, with communities that lost less disease prone plant species increasing more in pathogen load. Elevated CO₂ increased pathogen load of C₃ grasses, perhaps by decreasing water stress, increasing leaf longevity, and increasing photosynthetic rate, all of which can promote foliar fungal disease. Decreased plant diversity further magnified the increase in C₃ grass pathogen load under elevated CO₂. Nitrogen addition increased pathogen load of C₄ grasses by increasing foliar nitrogen concentration, which can enhance pathogen infection, growth, and reproduction. Because changes in foliar fungal pathogen load can strongly influence grassland ecosystem processes, our study suggests that increased pathogen load can be an important mechanism by which global change affects grassland ecosystems.     

Effects of elevated CO2 on the chrysanthemum leaf-miner, Chromatomyia syngenesiae: a greenhouse study

Although feeding behaviour of Chromatomyia syngenesiae on plants grown in elevated CO₂ (ambient + 200ppm) was unaffected, leaf-miner development was slower in elevated compared to ambient CO₂ atmospheres. Pupal weight was lower at high CO₂ and correlated with the area of leaf mined; no such correlation existed in ambient CO₂. There appears to be no compensatory feeding by the leaf-miner for the reduced food quality of plants growing in elevated CO₂. The implications of these findings are discussed.     

Growth and nitrogen uptake in an experimental community of annuals exposed to elevated atmospheric CO2

Rising levels of atmospheric CO₂ may alter patterns of plant biomass production. These changes will be dependent on the ability of plants to acquire sufficient nutrients to maintain enhanced growth. Species-specific differences in responsiveness to CO₂ may lead to changes in plant community composition and biodiversity. Differences in species-level growth responses to CO₂ may be, in a large part, driven by differences in the ability to acquire nutrients. To understand the mechanisms of how elevated CO₂ leads to changes in community-level productivity, we need to study the growth responses and patterns of nutrient acquisition for each of the species that comprise the community. In this paper, we present a study of how elevated CO₂ affects community-level and species-level patterns of nitrogen uptake and biomass production. As an experimental system we use experimental communities of 11 co-occurring annuals common to disturbed seasonal grasslands in south-western U.S.A. We established experimental communities with approximately even numbers of each species in three different atmospheric CO₂ concentrations (375, 550, and 700 ppm). We maintained these communities for 1, 1.5, and 2 months at which times we applied a ¹⁵N tracer (¹⁵NH₄¹⁵NO₃) to quantify the nitrogen uptake and then measured plant biomass, nitrogen content, and nitrogen uptake rates for the entire communities as well as for each species. Overall, community-level responses to elevated CO₂ were consistent with the majority of other studies of individual- and multispecies assemblages, where elevated CO₂ leads to enhanced biomass production early on, but this enhancement declines through time. In contrast, the responses of the individual species within the communities was highly variable, showing the full range of responses from positive to negative. Due to the large variation in size between the different species, community-level responses were generally determined by the responses of only one or a few species. Thus, while several of the smaller species showed trends of increased biomass and nitrogen uptake in elevated CO₂ at the end of the experiment, community-level patterns showed a decrease in these parameters due to the significant reduction in biomass and nitrogen content in the single largest species. The relationship between enhancement of nitrogen uptake and biomass production in elevated CO₂ was highly significant for both 550 ppm and 700 ppm CO₂. This relationship strongly suggests that the ability of plants to increase nitrogen uptake (through changes in physiology, morphology, architecture, or mycorrhizal symbionts) may be an important determinant of which species in a community will be able to respond to increased CO₂ levels with increased biomass production. The fact that the most dominant species within the community showed reduced enhancement and the smaller species showed increased enhancement suggest that through time, elevated CO₂ may lead to significant changes in community composition. At the community level, nitrogen uptake rates relative to plant nitrogen content were invariable between the three different CO₂ levels at each harvest. This was in contrast to significant reductions in total plant nitrogen uptake and nitrogen uptake relative to total plant biomass. These patterns support the hypothesis that plant nitrogen uptake is largely regulated by physiological activity, assuming that physiological activity is controlled by nitrogen content and thus protein and enzyme content.     

Leaf gas exchange and nitrogen dynamics of N2-fixing, field-grown Alnus glutinosa under elevated atmospheric CO2

Few studies have investigated the effects of elevated CO₂ on the physiology of symbiotic N₂-fixing trees. Tree species grown in low N soils at elevated CO₂ generally show a decline in photosynthetic capacity over time relative to ambient CO₂ controls. This negative adjustment may be due to a reallocation of leaf N away from the photosynthetic apparatus, allowing for more efficient use of limiting N. We investigated the effect of twice ambient CO₂ on net CO₂ assimilation (A), photosynthetic capacity, leaf dark respiration, and leaf N content of N2-fixing Alnus glutinosa (black alder) grown in field open top chambers in a low N soil for 160 d. At growth CO₂, A was always greater in elevated compared to ambient CO₂ plants. Late season A vs. internal leaf p(CO₂) response curves indicated no negative adjustment of photosynthesis in elevated CO₂ plants. Rather, elevated CO₂ plants had 16% greater maximum rate of CO₂ fixation by Rubisco. Leaf dark respiration was greater at elevated CO₂ on an area basis, but unaffected by CO₂ on a mass or N basis. In elevated CO₂ plants, leaf N content (μg N cm^?2) increased 50% between Julian Date 208 and 264. Leaf N content showed little seasonal change in ambient CO₂ plants. A single point acetylene reduction assay of detached, nodulated root segments indicated a 46% increase in specific nitrogenase activity in elevated compared to ambient CO₂ plants. Our results suggest that N₂-fixing trees will be able to maintain high A with minimal negative adjustment of photosynthetic capacity following prolonged exposure to elevated CO₂ on N-poor soils.     

Effects of elevated CO2 on development and larval food-plant preference in the butterfly Coenonympha pamphilus (Lepidoptera, Satyridae)

The objective of this study was to determine how increasing atmospheric CO₂ change plant tissue quality in four native grassland grass species (Agrostis stolonifera, Anthoxanthum odoratum, Festuca rubra, Poa pratensis) which are all larval food‐plants of Coenonympha pamphilus (Lepidoptera, Satyridae). We assessed the effect of these changes on the performance and larval food‐plant preference of C. pamphilus in a greenhouse experiment. Furthermore, we tested the interactive effects of elevated CO₂ and soil nutritional availability in F. rubra and its effect an larval development of C. pamphilus. In general, elevated CO₂ decreased leaf water concentration, nitrogen concentration and specific leaf area (SLA), while leaf starch concentration was increased in all grass species. A species‐specific reaction to elevated CO₂ was only found for foliar starch concentration. P. pratensis did not increase its starch concentration under elevated CO₂ conditions, whereas the other three species did. Fertilisation, investigated only for F. rubra, increased leaf nitrogen concentration and amplified the CO₂‐induced decrease in leaf nitrogen. Development time of C. pamphilus was on the average prolonged by two days under elevated CO₂ and the prolongation differed from 0.7 to 5.3 days among food‐plant species. Pupal fresh weight differed marginally between CO₂ treatments. Fertilisation of the larval food‐plant F. rubra shortened development time by one day and significantly increased pupal and adult fresh weights. C. pamphilus larvae showed a clear food‐plant preference among grass species at the age of 36 h or older. Additionally, a change of food‐plant preference under elevated CO₂ was found. Larvae at ambient CO₂ preferred Agrostis stolonifera and F. rubra, while under elevated CO₂Anthoxanthum odoratum and P. pratensis were preferred. The present study demonstrates that larval development of C. pamphilus is affected by food‐plant species and CO₂ induced changes in foliar chemistry. Although we found some species‐specific reactions to elevated CO₂ for foliar chemistry, no such CO₂ by species interaction was found for insect development. The change in food‐plant preference of larvae under elevated CO₂ implies potential changes in selection pressure for grass species and might therefore affect evolutionary processes.     

Host-specific aphid population responses to elevated CO2 and increased N availability

Sap-feeding insects such as aphids are the only insect herbivores that show positive responses to elevated CO₂. Recent models predict that increased nitrogen will increase aphid population size under elevated CO₂, but few experiments have tested this idea empirically. To determine whether soil nitrogen (N) availability modifies aphid responses to elevated CO₂, we tested the performance of Macrosiphum euphorbiae feeding on two host plants; a C₃ plant (Solanum dulcamara), and a C₄ plant (Amaranthus viridis). We expected aphid population size to increase on plants in elevated CO₂, with the degree of increase depending on the N availability. We found a significant CO₂× N interaction for the response of population size for M. euphorbiae feeding on S. dulcamara: aphids feeding on plants grown in ambient CO₂, low N conditions increased in response to either high N availability or elevated CO₂. No population size responses were observed for aphids infesting A. viridis. Elevated CO₂ increased plant biomass, specific leaf weight, and C : N ratios of the C₃ plant, S. dulcamara but did not affect the C₄ plant, A. viridis. Increased N fertilization significantly increased plant biomass, leaf area, and the weight : height ratio in both experiments. Elevated CO₂ decreased leaf N in S. dulcamara and had no effect on A. viridis, while higher N availability increased leaf N in A. viridis and had no effect in S. dulcamara. Aphid infestation only affected the weight : height ratio of S. dulcamara. We only observed an increase in aphid population size in response to elevated CO₂ or increased N availability for aphids feeding on S. dulcamara grown under low N conditions. There appears to be a maximum population growth rate that M. euphorbiae aphids can attain, and we suggest that this response is because of intrinsic limits on development time and fecundity.     

CO2 responsiveness of plants: a possible link to phloem loading

Of the many responses of plants to elevated CO₂, accumulation of total non-structural carbohydrates (TNC in % dry weight) in leaves is one of the most consistent. Insufficient sink activity or transport capacity may explain this obvious disparity between CO₂ assimilation and carbohydrate dissipation and structural investment. If transport capacity contributes to the problem, phloem loading may be the crucial step. It has been hypothesized that symplastic phloem loading is less efficient than apoplastic phloem loading, and hence plant species using the symplastic pathway and growing under high light and good water supply should accumulate more TNC at any given CO₂ level, but particularly under elevated CO₂. We tested this hypothesis by carrying out CO₂ enrichment experiments with 28 plant species known to belong to groups of contrasting phloem-loading type. Under current ambient CO₂ symplastic loaders were found to accumulate 36% TNC compared with only 19% in apoplastic loaders (P=0.0016). CO₂ enrichment to 600 μmol mol^?1 increased TNC in both groups by the same absolute amount, bringing the mean TNC level to 41% in symplastic loaders (compared to 25% in apoplastic loaders), which may be close to TNC saturation (coupled with chlornplast malfunction). Eight tree species, ranked as symplastic loaders by their minor vein companion cell configuration, showed TNC responses more similar to those of apoplastic herbaceous loaders. Similar results are obtained when TNC is expressed on a unit leaf area basis, since mean specific leaf areas of groups were not significantly different. We conclude that phloem loading has a surprisingly strong effect on leaf tissue composition, and thus may translate into alterations of food webs and ecosystem functioning, particularly under high CO₂.