Helix switching of a key active-site residue in the cytochrome cbb3 oxidases

In the respiratory chains of mitochondria and many aerobic prokaryotes, heme-copper oxidases are the terminal enzymes that couple the reduction of molecular oxygen to proton pumping, contributing to the protonmotive force. The cbb(3) oxidases belong to the superfamily of enzymes that includes all of the heme-copper oxidases. Sequence analysis indicates that the cbb(3) oxidases are missing an active-site tyrosine residue that is absolutely conserved in all other known heme-copper oxidases. In the other heme-copper oxidases, this tyrosine is known to be subject to an unusual post-translational modification and to play a critical role in the catalytic mechanism. The absence of this tyrosine in the cbb(3) oxidases raises the possibility that the cbb(3) oxidases utilize a different catalytic mechanism from that of the other members of the superfamily. Using homology modeling, quantum chemistry, and molecular dynamics, a model of the structure of subunit I of a cbb(3) oxidase (Vibrio cholerae) was constructed. The model predicts that a tyrosine residue structurally analogous to the active-site tyrosine in other oxidases is present in the cbb(3) oxidases but that the tyrosine originates from a different transmembrane helix within the protein. The predicted active-site tyrosine is conserved in the sequences of all of the known cbb(3) oxidases. Mutagenesis of the tyrosine to phenylalanine in the V. cholerae oxidase resulted in a fully assembled enzyme with nativelike structure but lacking catalytic activity. These findings strongly suggest that all of the heme-copper oxidases utilize the same catalytic mechanism and provide an unusual example in which a critical active-site residue originates from different places within the primary sequence for different members of the same superfamily.     

Comparative genomics and site-directed mutagenesis support the existence of only one input channel for protons in the C-family (cbb3 oxidase) of heme-copper oxygen reductases

Oxygen reductase members of the heme-copper superfamily are terminal respiratory oxidases in mitochondria and many aerobic bacteria and archaea, coupling the reduction of molecular oxygen to water to the translocation of protons across the plasma membrane. The protons required for catalysis and pumping in the oxygen reductases are derived from the cytoplasmic side of the membrane, transferred via proton-conducting channels comprised of hydrogen bond chains containing internal water molecules along with polar amino acid side chains. Recent analyses identified eight oxygen reductase families in the superfamily: the A-, B-, C-, D-, E-, F-, G-, and H-families of oxygen reductases. Two proton input channels, the K-channel and the D-channel, are well established in the A-family of oxygen reductases (exemplified by the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidases and by the respiratory oxidases from Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Paracoccus denitrificans). Each of these channels can be identified by the pattern of conserved polar amino acid residues within the protein. The C-family (cbb3 oxidases) is the second most abundant oxygen reductase family after the A-family, making up more than 20% of the sequences of the heme-copper superfamily. In this work, sequence analyses and structural modeling have been used to identify likely proton channels in the C-family. The pattern of conserved polar residues supports the presence of only one proton input channel, which is spatially analogous to the K-channel in the A-family. There is no pattern of conserved residues that could form a D-channel analogue or an alternative proton channel. The functional importance of the residues proposed to be part of the K-channel was tested by site-directed mutagenesis using the cbb3 oxidases from R. sphaeroides and Vibrio cholerae. Several of the residues proposed to be part of the putative K-channel had significantly reduced catalytic activity upon mutation: T219V, Y227F/Y228F, N293D, and Y321F. The data strongly suggest that in the C-family only one channel functions for the delivery of both catalytic and pumped protons. In addition, it is also proposed that a pair of acidic residues, which are totally conserved among the C-family, may be part of a proton-conducting exit channel for pumped protons. The residues homologous to these acidic amino acids are highly conserved in the cNOR family of nitric oxide reductases and have previously been implicated as part of a proton-conducting channel delivering protons from the periplasmic side of the membrane to the enzyme active site in the cNOR family. It is possible that the C-family contains a homologous proton-conducting channel that delivers pumped protons in the opposite direction, from the active site to the periplasm.     

Proton transfer in ba(3) cytochrome c oxidase from Thermus thermophilus

The respiratory heme-copper oxidases catalyze reduction of O(2) to H(2)O, linking this process to transmembrane proton pumping. These oxidases have been classified according to the architecture, location and number of proton pathways. Most structural and functional studies to date have been performed on the A-class oxidases, which includes those that are found in the inner mitochondrial membrane and bacteria such as Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Paracoccus denitrificans (aa(3)-type oxidases in these bacteria). These oxidases pump protons with a stoichiometry of one proton per electron transferred to the catalytic site. The bacterial A-class oxidases use two proton pathways (denoted by letters D and K, respectively), for the transfer of protons to the catalytic site, and protons that are pumped across the membrane. The B-type oxidases such as, for example, the ba(3) oxidase from Thermus thermophilus, pump protons with a lower stoichiometry of 0.5 H(+)/electron and use only one proton pathway for the transfer of all protons. This pathway overlaps in space with the K pathway in the A class oxidases without showing any sequence homology though. Here, we review the functional properties of the A- and the B-class ba(3) oxidases with a focus on mechanisms of proton transfer and pumping.     

Functional proton transfer pathways in the heme–copper oxidase superfamily

Heme–copper oxidases (HCuOs) terminate the respiratory chain in mitochondria and most bacteria. They are transmembrane proteins that catalyse the reduction of oxygen and use the liberated free energy to maintain a proton-motive force across the membrane. The HCuO superfamily has been divided into the oxygen-reducing A-, B- and C-type oxidases as well as the bacterial NO reductases (NOR), catalysing the reduction of NO in the denitrification process. Proton transfer to the catalytic site in the mitochondrial-like A family occurs through two well-defined pathways termed the D- and K-pathways. The B, C, and NOR families differ in the pathways as well as the mechanisms for proton transfer to the active site and across the membrane. Recent structural and functional investigations, focussing on proton transfer in the B, C and NOR families will be discussed in this review. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Respiratory Oxidases.     

Functional proton transfer pathways in the heme-copper oxidase superfamily

Heme-copper oxidases (HCuOs) terminate the respiratory chain in mitochondria and most bacteria. They are transmembrane proteins that catalyse the reduction of oxygen and use the liberated free energy to maintain a proton-motive force across the membrane. The HCuO superfamily has been divided into the oxygen-reducing A-, B- and C-type oxidases as well as the bacterial NO reductases (NOR), catalysing the reduction of NO in the denitrification process. Proton transfer to the catalytic site in the mitochondrial-like A family occurs through two well-defined pathways termed the D- and K-pathways. The B, C, and NOR families differ in the pathways as well as the mechanisms for proton transfer to the active site and across the membrane. Recent structural and functional investigations, focussing on proton transfer in the B, C and NOR families will be discussed in this review.     

Could the tyrosine-histidine ligand to Cu<Subscript>B</Subscript> in cytochrome<Emphasis Type="Italic"> c</Emphasis> oxidase be coordinatively labile? Implications from a quantum chemical model study of histidine substitutional lability and the effects of the covalent tyrosine-histidine cross-link

Density functional theory calculations have been used to evaluate the effects of inter-ring interactions within a covalently linked histidine-tyrosine cofactor such as that which is a ligand to the Cu(B) centre in cytochrome c oxidases and to investigate the energetics of histidine substitution at the Cu(B) centre. Small, but significant, perturbations of the redox potentials and/or p K(a) values of the histidine imidazole, the tyrosine phenol and the copper ion are found. The Cu(B)-N(cofactor) bond is estimated to be weaker than the Cu(B)-N(histidine coligand) bonds in the Cu(B)(I) state and in the Cu(B) (II) state when the cofactor is oxidized, by approximately 13 kJ/mol and approximately 23 kJ/mol, respectively. The calculations reveal that displacement of a histidine ligand from the Cu(B) centre, as is suggested in proposals of "histidine cycle" mechanisms for proton pumping in cytochrome c oxidases, is only energetically feasible if accompanied by protonation of the histidine imidazole and coupled to an endothermic process. It is proposed that the histidine-tyrosine cofactor ought to be considered as the substitutionally labile ligand to Cu(B) as the covalent crosslink would ensure displacement of the cofactor from Cu(B)-driven helix deformation. It is estimated that this process could store up to approximately 70 kJ/mol, which, based upon thermodynamic considerations, is sufficient for the pumping of two protons in the later steps (reductive phase) of the catalytic cycle. Ramifications of this proposition for the mechanism of proton pumping in cytochrome c oxidases are discussed.     

Mutagenesis of tyrosine residues within helix VII in subunit I of the cytochrome <Emphasis Type="Italic">cbb</Emphasis><Subscript>3</Subscript> oxidase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rhodobacter capsulatus</Emphasis>

The cbb ₃-type oxidases are members of the heme-copper oxidase superfamily, distant by sequence comparisons, but sharing common functional characteristics. The cbb ₃ oxidases are missing an active-site tyrosine residue that is absolutely conserved in all A and B-type heme-copper oxidases. This tyrosine is known to play a critical role in the catalytic mechanisms of A and B-type oxidases. The absence of this tyrosine in the cbb ₃ oxidases raises the possibility that the cbb ₃ oxidases utilize a different catalytic mechanism from that of the other members of the superfamily, or have this conserved residue in different helices. Recently sequence comparisons indicate that, a tyrosine residues that might be analogous to the active-site tyrosine in other oxidases are present in the cbb ₃ oxidases but these tyrosines originates from a different transmembrane helix within the protein. In this research, three conserved tyrosine residues, Y294, Y308 and Y318, in helix VII were substituted for phenylalanine. Y318F mutant in the Rhodobacter capsulatus oxidase resulted in a fully assembled enzyme with nativelike structure and activity, but Y294F mutant is not assembled and have a catalytic activity. On the other hand, Y308F mutant is fully assembled enzyme with nativelike structure, but lacking catalytic activity. This result indicates that Y308 should be crucial in catalytic activity of the cbb ₃ oxidase of R. capsulatus. These findings support the assumption that all of the heme-copper oxidases utilize the same catalytic mechanism and provide a residue originates from different places within the primary sequence for different members of the same superfamily.     

Proton transfer in ba3 cytochrome c oxidase from Thermus thermophilus

The respiratory heme-copper oxidases catalyze reduction of O₂ to H₂O, linking this process to transmembrane proton pumping. These oxidases have been classified according to the architecture, location and number of proton pathways. Most structural and functional studies to date have been performed on the A-class oxidases, which includes those that are found in the inner mitochondrial membrane and bacteria such as Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Paracoccus denitrificans (aa₃-type oxidases in these bacteria). These oxidases pump protons with a stoichiometry of one proton per electron transferred to the catalytic site. The bacterial A-class oxidases use two proton pathways (denoted by letters D and K, respectively), for the transfer of protons to the catalytic site, and protons that are pumped across the membrane. The B-type oxidases such as, for example, the ba₃ oxidase from Thermus thermophilus, pump protons with a lower stoichiometry of 0.5 H⁺/electron and use only one proton pathway for the transfer of all protons. This pathway overlaps in space with the K pathway in the A class oxidases without showing any sequence homology though. Here, we review the functional properties of the A- and the B-class ba₃ oxidases with a focus on mechanisms of proton transfer and pumping. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Respiratory Oxidases.     

Transmembrane proton translocation by cytochrome c oxidase

Respiratory heme-copper oxidases are integral membrane proteins that catalyze the reduction of molecular oxygen to water using electrons donated by either quinol (quinol oxidases) or cytochrome c (cytochrome c oxidases, CcOs). Even though the X-ray crystal structures of several heme-copper oxidases and results from functional studies have provided significant insights into the mechanisms of O2 -reduction and, electron and proton transfer, the design of the proton-pumping machinery is not known. Here, we summarize the current knowledge on the identity of the structural elements involved in proton transfer in CcO. Furthermore, we discuss the order and timing of electron-transfer reactions in CcO during O2 reduction and how these reactions might be energetically coupled to proton pumping across the membrane.     

Specific inhibition of proton pumping by the T315V mutation in the K channel of cytochrome ba3 from Thermus thermophilus

Cytochrome ba₃ from Thermus thermophilus belongs to the B family of heme-copper oxidases and pumps protons across the membrane with an as yet unknown mechanism. The K channel of the A family heme-copper oxidases provides delivery of a substrate proton from the internal water phase to the binuclear heme-copper center (BNC) during the reductive phase of the catalytic cycle, while the D channel is responsible for transferring both substrate and pumped protons. By contrast, in the B family oxidases there is no D-channel and the structural equivalent of the K channel seems to be responsible for the transfer of both categories of protons. Here we have studied the effect of the T315V substitution in the K channel on the kinetics of membrane potential generation coupled to the oxidative half-reaction of the catalytic cycle of cytochrome ba₃. The results suggest that the mutated enzyme does not pump protons during the reaction of the fully reduced form with molecular oxygen in a single turnover. Specific inhibition of proton pumping in the T315V mutant appears to be a consequence of inability to provide rapid (τ ~ 100 μs) reprotonation of the internal transient proton donor(s) of the K channel. In contrast to the A family, the K channel of the B-type oxidases is necessary for the electrogenic transfer of both pumped and substrate protons during the oxidative half-reaction of the catalytic cycle.     

Proton translocation by cytochrome c oxidase can take place without the conserved glutamic acid in subunit I

A glutamic acid residue in subunit I of the heme-copper oxidases is highly conserved and has been directly implicated in the O(2) reduction and proton-pumping mechanisms of these respiratory enzymes. Its mutation to residues other than aspartic acid dramatically inhibits activity, and proton translocation is lost. However, this glutamic acid is replaced by a nonacidic residue in some structurally distant members of the heme-copper oxidases, which have a tyrosine residue in the vicinity. Here, using cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans, we show that replacement of the glutamic acid and a conserved glycine nearby lowers the catalytic activity to <0.1% of the wild-type value. But if, in addition, a phenylalanine that lies close in the structure is changed to tyrosine, the activity rises more than 100-fold and proton translocation is restored. Molecular dynamics simulations suggest that the tyrosine can support a transient array of water molecules that may be essential for proton transfer in the heme-copper oxidases. Surprisingly, the glutamic acid is thus not indispensable, which puts important constraints on the catalytic mechanism of these enzymes.     

The causes of reduced proton-pumping efficiency in type B and C respiratory heme-copper oxidases,and in some mutated variants of type A

The heme-copper oxidases may be divided into three categories, A, B, and C, which include cytochrome c and quinol-oxidising enzymes. All three types are known to be proton pumps and are found in prokaryotes, whereas eukaryotes only contain A-type cytochrome c oxidase in their inner mitochondrial membrane. However, the bacterial B- and C-type enzymes have often been reported to pump protons with an H⁺/e^- ratio of only one half of the unit stoichiometry in the A-type enzyme. We will show here that these observations are likely to be the result of difficulties with the measuring technique together with a higher sensitivity of the B- and C-type enzymes to the protonmotive force that opposes pumping. We find that under optimal conditions the H⁺/e^- ratio is close to unity in all the three heme-copper oxidase subfamilies. A higher tendency for proton leak in the B- and C-type enzymes may result from less efficient gating of a proton pump mechanism that we suggest evolved before the so-called D-channel of proton transfer. There is also a discrepancy between results using whole bacterial cells vs. phospholipid vesicles inlaid with oxidase with respect to the observed proton pumping after modification of the D-channel residue asparagine-139 (Rhodobacter sphaeroides numbering) to aspartate in A-type cytochrome c oxidase. This discrepancy might also be explained by a higher sensitivity of proton pumping to protonmotive force in the mutated variant. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: 18th European Bioenergetic Conference.     

The KC Channel in the cbb3-Type Respiratory Oxygen Reductase from Rhodobacter capsulatus Is Required for Both Chemical and Pumped Protons

The heme-copper superfamily of proton-pumping respiratory oxygen reductases are classified into three families (A, B, and C families) based on structural and phylogenetic analyses. Most studies have focused on the A family, which includes the eukaryotic mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase as well as many bacterial homologues. Members of the C family, also called the cbb₃-type oxygen reductases, are found only in prokaryotes and are of particular interest because of their presence in a number of human pathogens. All of the heme-copper oxygen reductases require proton-conducting channels to convey chemical protons to the active site for water formation and to convey pumped protons across the membrane. Previous work indicated that there is only one proton-conducting input channel (the K^C channel) present in the cbb₃-type oxygen reductases, which, if correct, must be utilized by both chemical protons and pumped protons. In this work, the effects of mutations in the K^C channel of the cbb₃-type oxygen reductase from Rhodobacter capsulatus were investigated by expressing the mutants in a strain lacking other respiratory oxygen reductases. Proton pumping was evaluated by using intact cells, and catalytic oxygen reductase activity was measured in isolated membranes. Two mutations, N346M and Y374F, severely reduced catalytic activity, presumably by blocking the chemical protons required at the active site. One mutation, T272A, resulted in a substantially lower proton-pumping stoichiometry but did not inhibit oxygen reductase activity. These are the first experimental data in support of the postulate that pumped protons are taken up from the bacterial cytoplasm through the K^C channel.     

Transmembrane proton translocation by cytochrome c oxidase

Respiratory heme-copper oxidases are integral membrane proteins that catalyze the reduction of molecular oxygen to water using electrons donated by either quinol (quinol oxidases) or cytochrome c (cytochrome c oxidases, CcOs). Even though the X-ray crystal structures of several heme-copper oxidases and results from functional studies have provided significant insights into the mechanisms of O₂-reduction and, electron and proton transfer, the design of the proton-pumping machinery is not known. Here, we summarize the current knowledge on the identity of the structural elements involved in proton transfer in CcO. Furthermore, we discuss the order and timing of electron-transfer reactions in CcO during O₂ reduction and how these reactions might be energetically coupled to proton pumping across the membrane.     

A structural and functional perspective on the evolution of the heme–copper oxidases

The heme–copper oxidases (HCOs) catalyze the reduction of O₂ to water, and couple the free energy to proton pumping across the membrane. HCOs are divided into three sub-classes, A, B and C, whose order of emergence in evolution has been controversial. Here we have analyzed recent structural and functional data on HCOs and their homologues, the nitric oxide reductases (NORs). We suggest that the C-type oxidases are ancient enzymes that emerged from the NORs. In contrast, the A-type oxidases are the most advanced from both structural and functional viewpoints, which we interpret as evidence for having evolved later.     

Gene cluster of Rhodothermus marinus high-potential iron-sulfur Protein: oxygen oxidoreductase, a caa(3)-type oxidase belonging to the superfamily of heme-copper oxidases

The respiratory chain of the thermohalophilic bacterium Rhodothermus marinus contains an oxygen reductase, which uses HiPIP (high potential iron-sulfur protein) as an electron donor. The structural genes encoding the four subunits of this HiPIP:oxygen oxidoreductase were cloned and sequenced. The genes for subunits II, I, III, and IV (named rcoxA to rcoxD) are found in this order and seemed to be organized in an operon of at least five genes with a terminator structure a few nucleotides downstream of rcoxD. Examination of the amino acid sequence of the Rcox subunits shows that the subunits of the R. marinus enzyme have homology to the corresponding subunits of oxidases belonging to the superfamily of heme-copper oxidases. RcoxB has the conserved histidines involved in binding the binuclear center and the low-spin heme. All of the residues proposed to be involved in proton transfer channels are conserved, with the exception of the key glutamate residue of the D-channel (E(278), Paracoccus denitrificans numbering). Analysis of the homology-derived structural model of subunit I shows that the phenol group of a tyrosine (Y) residue and the hydroxyl group of the following serine (S) may functionally substitute the glutamate carboxyl in proton transfer. RcoxA has an additional sequence for heme C binding, after the Cu(A) domain, that is characteristic of caa(3) oxidases belonging to the superfamily. Homology modeling of the structure of this cytochrome domain of subunit II shows no marked electrostatic character, especially around the heme edge region, suggesting that the interaction with a redox partner is not of an electrostatic nature. This observation is analyzed in relation to the electron donor for this caa(3) oxidase, the HiPIP. In conclusion, it is shown that an oxidase, which uses an iron-sulfur protein as an electron donor, is structurally related to the caa(3) class of heme-copper cytochrome c oxidases. The data are discussed in the framework of the evolution of oxidases within the superfamily of heme-copper oxidases.     

Active site structure of the aa3 quinol oxidase of Acidianus ambivalens

The membrane bound aa(3)-type quinol:oxygen oxidoreductase from the hyperthermophilic archaeon, Acidianus ambivalens, which thrives at a pH of 2.5 and a temperature of 80 degrees C, has several unique structural and functional features as compared to the other members of the heme-copper oxygen reductase superfamily, but shares the common redox-coupled, proton-pumping function. To better understand the properties of the heme a(3)-Cu(B) catalytic site, a resonance Raman spectroscopic study of the enzyme under a variety of conditions and in the presence of various ligands was carried out. Assignments of several heme vibrational modes as well as iron-ligand stretching modes are made to serve as a basis for comparing the structure of the enzyme to that of other oxygen reductases. The CO-bound oxidase has conformations that are similar to those of other oxygen reductases. However, the addition of CO to the resting enzyme does not generate a mixed valence species as in the bovine aa(3) enzyme. The cyanide complex of the oxidized enzyme of A. ambivalens does not display the high stability of its bovine counterpart, and a redox titration demonstrates that there is an extensive heme-heme interaction reflected in the midpoint potentials of the cyanide adduct. The A. ambivalens oxygen reductase is very stable under acidic conditions, but it undergoes an earlier alkaline transition than the bovine enzyme. The A. ambivalens enzyme exhibits a redox-linked reversible conformational transition in the heme a(3)-Cu(B) center. The pH dependence and H/D exchange demonstrate that the conformational transition is associated with proton movements involving a group or groups with a pK(a) of approximately 3.8. The observed reversibility and involvement of protons in the redox-coupled conformational transition support the proton translocation model presented earlier. The implications of such conformational changes are discussed in relation to general redox-coupled proton pumping mechanisms in the heme-copper oxygen reductases.     

Heme-copper oxidases with modified D- and K-pathways are yet efficient proton pumps

The cytochrome aa(3)-type quinol oxidase from the archaeon Acidianus ambivalens and the ba(3)-type cytochrome c oxidase from Thermus thermophilus are divergent members of the heme-copper oxidase superfamily of enzymes. In particular they lack most of the key residues involved in the proposed proton transfer pathways. The pumping capability of the A. ambivalens enzyme was investigated and found to occur with the same efficiency as the canonical enzymes. This is the first demonstration of pumping of 1 H(+)/electron in a heme-copper oxidase that lacks most residues of the K- and D-channels. Also, the structure of the ba(3) oxidase from T. thermophilus was simulated by mutating Phe274 to threonine and Glu278 to isoleucine in the D-pathway of the Paracoccus denitrificans cytochrome c oxidase. This modification resulted in full efficiency of proton translocation albeit with a substantially lowered turnover. Together, these findings show that multiple structural solutions for efficient proton conduction arose during evolution of the respiratory oxidases, and that very few residues remain invariant among these enzymes to function in a common proton-pumping mechanism.     

Dynamic water networks in cytochrome cbb3 oxidase

Heme-copper oxidases (HCOs) are terminal electron acceptors in aerobic respiration. They catalyze the reduction of molecular oxygen to water with concurrent pumping of protons across the mitochondrial and bacterial membranes. Protons required for oxygen reduction chemistry and pumping are transferred through proton uptake channels. Recently, the crystal structure of the first C-type member of the HCO superfamily was resolved [Buschmann et al. Science 329 (2010) 327–330], but crystallographic water molecules could not be identified. Here we have used molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, continuum electrostatic approaches, and quantum chemical cluster calculations to identify proton transfer pathways in cytochrome cbb₃. In MD simulations we observe formation of stable water chains that connect the highly conserved Glu323 residue on the proximal side of heme b₃ both with the N- and the P-sides of the membrane. We propose that such pathways could be utilized for redox-coupled proton pumping in the C-type oxidases. Electrostatics and quantum chemical calculations suggest an increased proton affinity of Glu323 upon reduction of high-spin heme b₃. Protonation of Glu323 provides a mechanism to tune the redox potential of heme b₃ with possible implications for proton pumping.