Neutron small angle scattering of matched proteoliposomes with incorporated F0F1 ATPase complex from Rhodospirillum rubrum FR1. An approach to the structure of membrane proteins in their natural environment

Purified F0F1 ATPase from Rhodospirillum rubrum FR1 has been incorporated into lipid vesicles from the partially deuterated phospholipid dimyristoylglycerophosphocholine (DMPC-D54). These proteoliposomes were able to carry out energy transducing reactions. The incorporation of the membrane protein was controlled by freeze fracture electron microscopy. A method for structural research of the membrane protein in its natural environment has been developed by means of neutron small angle scattering. Using the contrast variation technique, the lipid part of the proteoliposomes was matched by adding an appropriate amount of D2O to the solvent. Thus the neutron scattering profile of F0F1 ATPase incorporated into vesicles was separated from the neutron scattering of the liposome. F0F1 ATPase incorporated in a lipid bilayer, as well as the free enzyme, yields a radius of gyration of Rg = 6.0 +/- 0.1 nm which leads to an overall diameter of 15.5 nm. This result suggests that the monomeric form of F0F1 ATPase is incorporated in DMPC-D54 membranes at 20 degrees C.     

The model membrane system. Egg lecithin + myelin protein (N-2). Effect of solvent density variation on the X-ray scattering.

The electron density contrast method has been applied to the membrane system egg lecithin + myelin protein (N-2). The case treated here is for a low protein concentration. As theory predicts, the scattering from the different regions of the membrane (protein, hydrocarbon, and polar head group regions) are modulated differently by changing the contrast. It is then possible to separate out the electron pair correlation functions for the different regions, and from these to determine the membrane election density distribution for an external electron density p0 = 0.     

Liquid diffraction analysis of the model membrane system. Egg lecithin + myelin protein (N-2).

The scattering from the model membrane system, egg lecithin + myelin protein (N-2), has been analyzed by liquid diffraction methods. It is found that by manipulating the protein-lipid ratio, the scattering domains of the protein and lipid can be identified. The multilayer contribution can also be identified by its position and concentration behavior in both the intensity pattern and its Fourier transform. When the multilayer and protein components are subtracted, the phospholipid scattering and an interaction term are left: these two can be resolved by a reasonable assessment of their relative magnitude in the boundary region where they overlap. The interaction term can then be used to determine the most probably position of the protein in the membrane. The deconvoluted protein and lipid transforms can then be combined in the proper way to obtain the electron density profiles. The resolution of the interaction term is not yet complete, but a method for accomplishing this is discussed.     

Surfactin-triggered small vesicle formation of negatively charged membranes: a novel membrane-lysis mechanism

The molecular mode of action of the lipopeptide SF with zwitterionic and negatively charged model membranes has been investigated with solid-state NMR, light scattering, and electron microscopy. It has been found that this acidic lipopeptide (negatively charged) induces a strong destabilization of negatively charged micrometer-scale liposomes, leading to the formation of small unilamellar vesicles of a few 10s of nanometers. This transformation is detected for very low doses of SF (Ri = 200) and is complete for Ri = 50. The phenomenon has been observed for several membrane mixtures containing phosphatidylglycerol or phosphatidylserine. The vesicularization is not observed when the lipid negative charges are neutralized and a cholesterol-like effect is then evidenced, i.e., increase of gel membrane dynamics and decrease of fluid membrane microfluidity. The mechanism for small vesicle formation thus appears to be linked to severe changes in membrane curvature and could be described by a two-step action: 1), peptide insertion into membranes because of favorable van der Waals forces between the rather rigid cyclic and lipophilic part of SF and lipid chains and 2), electrostatic repulsion between like charges borne by lipid headgroups and the negatively charged SF amino acids. This might provide the basis for a novel mode of action of negatively charged lipopeptides.     

X-ray scattering with momentum transfer in the plane of membrane. Application to gramicidin organization.

We demonstrate a technique for measuring x-ray (or neutron) scattering with the momentum transfer confined in the plane of membrane, for the purpose of studying lateral organization of proteins and peptides in membrane. Unlike freeze-fracture electron microscopy or atomic force microscopy which requires the membrane to be frozen or fixed, in-plane x-ray scattering can be performed with the membrane maintained in the liquid crystalline state. As an example, the controversial question of whether gramicidin forms aggregates in membrane was investigated. We used dilauroylphosphatidylcholine (DLPC) bilayers containing gramicidin in the molar ratio of 10:1. Very clear scattering curves reflecting gramicidin channel-channel correlation were obtained, even for the sample containing no heavy atoms. Thallium ions bound to gramicidin channels merely increase the magnitude of the scattering curve. Analysis of the data shows that the channels were randomly distributed in the membrane, similar to a computer simulation of freely moving disks in a plane. We suggest that oriented proteins may provide substantial x-ray contrast against the lipid background without requiring heavy-atom labeling. This should open up many possible new experiments.     

Monopolar-bipolar lipid interactions in model membrane systems

1H-NMR, dynamic light scattering and negative staining electron microscopy have been used to study the formation and physico-chemical properties of aqueous dispersions of mixtures of monopolar lipids extracted from Sulfolobus solfataricus. This microorganism is a thermophilic archaeobacterium growing optimally at about 85 degrees C and pH 3. The two hydrolytic fractions of the membrane complex lipids that have been studied are: the symmetric lipid glycerol dialkyl glycerol tetraether (GDGT) and the asymmetric lipid glycerol dialkyl nonitol tetraether (GDNT). Electron micrographs of pure and mixed GDNT and GDGT dispersions show the formation of complex structures. Only above a critical monopolar/bipolar lipid ratio, typical of the bipolar lipid, could closed structures be formed and good agreement was obtained in sizing with NMR, electron microscopy and dynamic light scattering. NMR spectra have been carried out at several temperatures from 25 degrees to 85 degrees C, to obtain information on the temperature-dependent structural, dynamic and permeability properties of the co-dispersed vesicles. The results are discussed in terms of the steric constraints and the chemico-physical interactions occurring among the different parts of the molecules and compared with previous studies performed with different physical techniques.     

Phase transitions in monoglyceride bilayers. A light scattering study.

Thermotropic phase transitions in single planar bilayers of glycerol mono-oleate have been investigated using quasi-elastic light scattering from thermally excited membrane fluctuations. In certain cases both spectroscopic and intensity information were derived from the observations. For solvent-free bilayers transitional changes were observed in several membrane parameters: in tension, viscosity and thickness, in a combination of lipid orientational order parameter and dielectric anisotropy, and in the lateral compression modulus. These changes, particularly those in membrane thickness and in the anisotropy/order combination, were clearly indicative of a chain-melting transition in the lipid molecules. The chain-melting transition temperature was identified as 16.6 +/- 0.03 degrees C (delta T 1/2 = 1.5 degrees C). The other changes tended to cluster around 12.5 and 16.6 degrees C, suggesting that a two-stage transition was involved. Analysis of pretransitional fluctuations in membrane viscosity, based on a Landau approach, suggested that at the transition the membrane was close to a critical point (T = 12.7 degrees C). Less information was accessible for membranes containing n-decane within their structure. In this case, the change in membrane tension was much smaller than in the solvent-free case and the transition was considerably broadened. These effects accord with an increase in 'interactive volume' within the bilayer due to solvent inclusion.     

Binding of polylysine to charged bilayer membranes: molecular organization of a lipid.peptide complex.

The interaction between a positively charged peptide (poly-L-lysine) and model membranes containing charged lipids has been investigated. Conformational changes of the polypeptide as well as changes in the membrane lipid distribution were observed upon lipid-protein agglutination: 1. The strong binding of polylysine is shown directly by the use of spinlabelled polypeptide. Upon binding to phosphatidic acid a shift in the hyperfine coupling constant from 16.5 to 14.6 Oe is observed. The spectrum of the lipid-bound peptide is superimposed on the spectrum of polylysine in solution. Half of the lysine groups are bound to the charged membranes. A change in the conformation of polylysine from a random coil to a partially ordered configuration is suggested. 2. Spin labelling of the lipid component gives evidence concerning the molecular organization of a lipid mixture containing charged phosphatitid acid. Addition of polylysine induces the formation of crystalline patches of bound phosphatidic acid. 3. Excimer forming pyrene decanoic acid has been employed. Addition of positively charged polylysine (pH 9.0) to phosphatidic acid membranes increases the transition temperature of the lipid from Tt = 50 to Tt = 62 degrees C. Thus, a lipid segregation of lipid into regions of phosphatidic acid bound to the peptide which differ in their microviscosity from the surrounding membrane is induced. One lysine group binds one phosphatidic acid molecule, but only half of the phosphatidic acid is bound. 4. Direct evidence for charge induced domain formation in lipid mixtures containing phosphatidic acid is given by electron microscopy. Addition of polylysine leads to a change in the surface curvature of the bound charged lipid. The domain size is estimated from the electron micrographs. The number of domains present is dependent on both the ratio of charged to uncharged lipids as well as on the amount of polylysine added to the vesicles. The size of the domains is not dependent on membrane composition. However, the size seems to increase in a stepwise manner that is correlated with a multiple of the area covered by one polylysine molecule.     

A liquid diffraction analysis of sarcoplasmic reticulum. I. Compositional variation.

Intensities of x-ray scattering from a series of fragmented rabbit muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) samples have been measured over the range x = 0.05 to s = 0.25. By varying the relative concentrations of lipid and protein (chiefly the Mg++-dependent, Ca++- stimulated ATPase) in the membranes of this series, and by employing methods of analysis appropriate to the scattering from binary liquid mixtures, we have identified the separable contributions of protein and lipid, and the protein-lipid interaction contributions to the total scattering profiles. The shape of the protein term is consistent with scattering from a cylindrical ATPase particle 142 A in length and 35 A in diameter. These data imply that the dominant ATPase species is monomeric. The protein-lipid interaction term has been analyzed by a novel treatment based on a determination of the pair correlation function between the electrons of the protein molecule with the electrons of the lipid bilayer in terms of the asymmetry of the transbilayer disposition of the protein. Applied to our results, the analysis indicates a fully asymmetric disposition of ATPase, in which one end of the molecule is contiguous with either the lumenal or cytoplasmic surface of the bilayer.     

Electron paramagnetic study of electron transport in photosynthetic systems. X. Effect of magnesium ions on the structural state of thylakoid membranes and the kinetics of electron transport between the two photosystems in bean chloroplasts

The effect of Mg2+-ions on the physical state of thylakoid membrane and kinetics of electron transport between two photosystems were studied. The rate of electron transport from photosystem 2 to P700+ and the activity of photosystem 2 were obtained from the kinetics of P700 redox transients induced by flashes of white light (t1/2 = 7 musec or 0.75 msec) fired simultaneously with the background continuous far-red light (707 nm). The spin-labeled stearic acids (I1.14 and I12.3) were used as indicators of Mg2+-induced structural changes. Addition of MgCl2 stimulates incorporation of spin-labels into the lipid region of the thylakoid membrane. It was found that Mg2+-ions modify the ESR spectrum of I12.3. The results evidence that the screening of charged groups on the thylakoid membrane surface induces structural changes in the lipid region of the membrane. We have concluded that these structural changes result in reorientation of lipid molecules in the thylakoid membrane. There is a correlation between Mg2+-induced structural changes and electron transport in chloroplasts. Addition of Mg2+-ions stimulates the photochemical activity of photosystem 2 by increasing the amount of active reaction centres and modifies the rate constant of electron transport from photosystem 2 to P700+. It has been demonstrated that ion regulation of electron transport in more effective in the oxidising side than in the reducing side of plastoquinone shuttle.     

Lipid enrichment of thylakoid membranes. I. Using soybean phospholipids

(1) Using asolectin (mixed soybean phospholipids) liposomes, extra lipid, with or without additional plastoquinone, has been introduced into isolated thylakoid membranes of pea chloroplasts. (2) Evidence for this lipid enrichment was obtained from freeze-fracture which indicated that a decrease in the numbers of EF and PF particles per unit area of membrane occurred with increasing lipid incorporation. The decrease was not due to loss of integral membrane polypeptides as judged by assay of cytochrome present or SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of lipid-enriched membrane fractions. Moreover, the enrichment procedure did not lead to extraction of low molecular weight lipophilic membrane components or of thylakoid membrane lipids. (3) The introduction of phospholipids into the membrane affected steady-state electron transport. Inhibition of electron transport was observed when either water (Photosystem (PS) II + PS I) or duroquinol (PS I) was used as electron donor with methyl viologen as electron acceptor, and the degree of inhibition increased with higher enrichment levels. Introduction of exogenous plastoquinone with the additional lipid had little effect on whole-chain electron transport, but caused an increase in the 2,5-dibromo-3-methyl-6-isopropyl-p-benzoquinone (DBMIB)-sensitive rate of PS I electron transport. The inhibition was also detected by flash-induced oxidation-reduction changes of cytochrome f.     

Conformation of liquid N-alkanes.

The conformations of liquid n-alkanes have been studied using neutron scattering techniques to better understand the conformational forces present in membrane lipid interiors. We have studied hydrocarbon chains having lengths comparable to those found for esterified membrane lipid fatty acids, and find that the steric constraints of packing in the liquid state do not change the conformational distributions of hydrocarbon chains from those imposed by the intrachain forces present in the gas phase. It follows that the central region of membranes containing lipids in the disordered state should contain hydrocarbon chain conformations determined primarily by intrachain forces.     

Architecture of bacterial lipid A in solution. A neutron small-angle scattering study

The phase structure of isolated bacterial lipid A, the lipid anchor of the lipopolysaccharides of the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria, has been investigated by neutron small-angle scattering. The shape of the scattering curves obtained at different H2O/2H2O ratios revealed a lamellar organisation of the lipid A at neutral pH both above and below its main phase temperature (approximately 40-45 degrees C). Analysis of the scattering curves and interpretation of the corresponding thickness distance distribution functions of the lamellar aggregates led to a model in which the lipid A molecules form a bilayer of about 5 nm in thickness. This value for the thickness of the bilayer, as well as the neutron-scattering density profile across the bilayer, can be explained by a molecular model which shows interdigitation of the fatty acid chains of the lipid A.     

Neutron scattering studies of photosynthetic membranes in aqueous dispersion

A method for structural analysis of biological membranes using neutron scattering from suspensions is described and applied to photosynthetic membranes from bacteria. The variation of scattering density across the membrane is analysed using small-angle scattering and contrast variation with H₂O/²H₂O mixtures. Effects due to membrane curvature and scattering density variation in the plane of the membrane are evaluated. Thickness parameters (D) are obtained from the small-angle scattering data, which are the one-dimensional analogues of radii of gyration. The formalism of contrast variation is used to describe the change of intensity and thickness parameter with H₂O/²H₂O mixture. The results are expressed in terms of a thickness parameter at infinite contrast, which is directly related to the physical thickness of the membrane, and a measure of the variation of the scattering density across the membrane, produced, for example, by the higher scattering densities of the polar surfaces relative to a hydrocarbon interior of the membrane. Asymmetry in the membrane scattering density is also evaluated.The results for photosynthetic membranes demonstrate a lipid hydrocarbon core in the membrane. About two-thirds of the protein is closely associated with the lipid layer, and no substantial amounts of protein project more than short distances from the lipid layer. There is a contribution to the variation in scattering density across the membrane that cannot be attributed to lipid, and may involve scattering density heterogeneity within the protein, giving a high proportion of hydrophobic protein segments at the interior of the membrane that have lower scattering densities than the hydrophilic segments at the surfaces of the membrane. The membrane scattering density is not markedly asymmetric. Several alternative structures previously proposed for photosynthetic membranes are incompatible with these results.     

Conformation of peptides in lipid membranes studied by x-ray grazing incidence scattering

Although the antimicrobial, fungal peptide alamethicin has been extensively studied, the conformation of the peptide and the interaction with lipid bilayers as well as the mechanism of channel gating are still not completely clear. As opposed to studies of the crystalline state, the polypeptide structures in the environment of fluid bilayers are difficult to probe. We have investigated the conformation of alamethicin in highly aligned stacks of model lipid membranes by synchrotron-based x-ray scattering. The (wide-angle) scattering distribution has been measured by reciprocal space mappings. A pronounced scattering signal is observed in samples of high molar peptide/lipid ratio which is distinctly different from the scattering distribution of an ideal helix in the transmembrane state. Beyond simple models of ideal helices, the data is analyzed in terms of models based on atomic coordinates from the Brookhaven Protein Data Bank, as well as from published molecular dynamics simulations. The results can be explained by assuming a wide distribution of helix tilt angles with respect to the membrane normal and a partial insertion of the N-terminus into the membrane.     

A 9 A two-dimensional projected structure of cholera toxin B-subunit-GM1 complexes determined by electron crystallography.

Highly ordered two-dimensional crystals of cholera toxin B-subunit pentamers have been grown by specific interaction with planar lipid films containing monosialoganglioside GM1. Electron diffractograms of frozen-hydrated crystals show diffraction peaks extending to beyond 4 A, while electron images diffract to 8 A. A two-dimensional projected structure of cholera toxin B-subunit-GM1 complex has been calculated at 9 A resolution by combining electron diffraction and image data. Crystals present an approximate pgg projection symmetry, with unit cell dimensions a = 119(+/- 1) A, b = 123(+/- 1) A, gamma = 90 degrees. Each pentameric assembly presents two concentric rings of electron scattering density, separated by an area of lower density. The outer and inner rings are centered at 25 A and and 11 A from the pentamer centre, respectively. The apparent projected density of the outer ring is larger than that of the inner ring. We propose that the outer and inner density rings correspond respectively to the peripheral beta-sheet arrangement and the central alpha-helix barrel, recently identified in the crystal structure of the heat-labile enterotoxin from Escherichia coli.     

Shaping membrane interfaces in lipid vesicles mimicking the cytoplasmic leaflet of myelin through variation of cholesterol and myelin basic protein contents

Myelin basic protein (MBP) is an intrinsically disordered protein and in the central nervous system (CNS) mainly responsible for connecting the cytoplasmic surfaces of the multilamellar, compact myelin. Increased posttranslational modification of MBP is linked to both, the natural development (from adolescent to adult brains) of myelin, and features of multiple sclerosis. Here, we study how a combination of this intrinsically disordered myelin protein with varying the natural cholesterol content may alter the characteristics of myelin-like membranes and interactions between these membranes. Large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) with a composition mimicking the cytoplasmic leaflet of myelin were chosen as the model system, in which different parameters contributing to the interactions between the lipid membrane and MBP were investigated. While we use cryo-transmission electron microscopy (TEM) for imaging, dynamic light scattering (DLS) and electrophoretic measurements through continuously-monitored phase-analysis light scattering (cmPALS) were used for a more global overview of particle size and charge, and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy was utilized for local behavior of lipids in the vesicles' membranes in aqueous solution. The cholesterol content was varied from 060 % in these LUVs and measurements were performed in the presence and absence of MBP. We find that the composition of the lipid layers is relevant to the interaction with MBP. Not only the size, the shape and the aggregation behavior of the vesicles depend on the cholesterol content, but also within each membrane, cholesterol's freedom of movement, its environmental polarity and its distribution were found to depend on the content using the EPR-active spin-labeled cholesterol (CSOSL). In addition, DLS and EPR measurements probing the transition temperatures of the lipid phases allow a correlation of specific behavior with the human body temperature of 37 °C. Overall, our results aid in understanding the importance of the native cholesterol content in the healthy myelin membrane, which serves as the basis for stable and optimum protein-bilayer interactions. Although studied in this specific myelin-like system, from a more general and materials science-oriented point of view, we could establish how membrane and vesicle properties depend on cholesterol and/or MBP content, which might be useful generally when specific membrane and vesicle characteristics are sought for.     

Cooperativity of the phase transition in single- and multibilayer lipid vesicles.

The effect of membrane morphology on the cooperativity of the ordered-fluid, lipid phase transition has been investigated by comparing the transition widths in extended, multibilayer dispersons of dimyristoyl phosphatidyl-choline, and also of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine, with those in the small, single-bilayer vesicles obtained by sonication. The electron spin resonance spectra of three different spin-labelled probes, 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperdine-N-oxyl, phosphatidylcholine and stearic acid, and also 90 degrees light scattering and optical turbidity measurements were used as indicators of the phase transition. In all cases the transition was broader in the single-bilayer vesicles than in the multibilayer dispersions, corresponding to a decreased cooperativity on going to the small vesicles. Comparison of the light scattering properties of centrifuged and uncentrifuged, sonicated vesicles suggests that these are particularly sensitive to the presence of intermediate-size particles, and thus the spin label measurements are likely to give a more reliable measure of the degree of cooperativity of the small, single-bilayer vesicles. Application of the Zimm and Bragg theory ((1959) J. Chem. Phys. 31, 526-535) of cooperative transitions to the two-dimensional bilayer system shows that the size of the cooperative unit, 1/square root sigma, is a measure of the mean number of molecules per perimeter molecule, in a given region of ordered or fluid lipid at the centre of the transition. From this result it is found that it is the vesicle size which limits the cooperativity of the transition in the small, single-bilayer vesicles. The implications for the effect of membrane structure and morphology on the cooperativity of phase transitions in biological membranes, and for the possibility of achieving lateral communication in the plane of the membrane, are discussed.     

The peculiar thermo-structural behavior of the anionic lipid DMPG

Aqueous dispersions of the anionic phospholipid dimyristoyl phosphatidylglycerol (DMPG), around 100 mM ionic strength, are known to exhibit a thermal behavior similar to that of the largely studied lipid dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC), which undergoes a gel to liquid crystalline phase transition at 23 degrees C, well characterized by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and other methods. However, at low ionic strength, DMPG has been shown to present a large gel-fluid transition region, ranging from 18 to 35 degrees C. This intermediate phase is optically transparent and characterized by a continuous change in membrane packing. Structural properties of the DMPG gel-fluid transition region will be discussed, based on results obtained by several techniques: electron spin resonance (ESR) of spin labels at the membrane surface and intercalated at different depths in the bilayer; light scattering; DSC; small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS); and fluorescence spectroscopy of probes in the bilayer.     

The location of redox centers in biological membranes determined by resonance x-ray diffraction. I. Observation of the resonance effect

We have developed resonance X-ray diffraction methods to locate for the first time intrinsic metal atoms associated with redox centers within biological membrane systems. The study of membranes containing dilute concentrations of resonant scatterers has been made possible by the development of synchrotron radiation sources of X-rays. The technique permits altering the scattering power of a particular atom relative to others by varying the incident X-ray energy. Thus, this method may be used to locate a metal atom within a complex integral protein without chemical modification of the membrane. We present resonance diffraction data taken with synchroton radiation for two different membrane systems: cytochrome oxidase incorporated into lipid vesicles and a photosynthetic reaction center-cytochrome c complex also reincorporated into lipid vesicles.