Evaluation of a modular strategy for the construction of novel polydactyl zinc finger DNA-binding proteins

In previous studies, we have developed a technology for the rapid construction of novel DNA-binding proteins with the potential to recognize any unique site in a given genome. This technology relies on the modular assembly of modified zinc finger DNA-binding domains, each of which recognizes a three bp subsite of DNA. A complete set of 64 domains would provide comprehensive recognition of any desired DNA sequence, and new proteins could be assembled by any laboratory in a matter of hours. However, a critical parameter for this approach is the extent to which each domain functions as an independent, modular unit, without influence or dependence on its neighboring domains. We therefore examined the detailed binding behavior of several modularly assembled polydactyl zinc finger proteins. We first demonstrated that 80 modularly assembled 3-finger proteins can recognize their DNA target with very high specificity using a multitarget ELISA-based specificity assay. A more detailed analysis of DNA binding specificity for eight 3-finger proteins and two 6-finger proteins was performed using a target site selection assay. Results showed that the specificity of these proteins was as good or better than that of zinc finger proteins constructed using methods that allow for interdependency. In some cases, near perfect specificity was achieved. Complications due to target site overlap were found to be restricted to only one particular amino acid interaction (involving an aspartate in position 2 of the alpha-helix) that occurs in a minority of cases. As this is the first report of target site selection for designed, well characterized 6-finger proteins, unique insights are discussed concerning the relationship of protein length and specificity. These results have important implications for the design of proteins that can recognize extended DNA sequences, as well as provide insights into the general rules of recognition for naturally occurring zinc finger proteins.     

Effects of DNA binding of the zinc finger and linkers for domain fusion on the catalytic activity of sequence-specific chimeric recombinases determined by a facile fluorescent system

Artificial zinc finger proteins (ZFPs) consist of Cys(2)-His(2)-type modules composed of ～30 amino acids with a ββα structure that coordinates a zinc ion. ZFPs that recognize specific DNA target sequences can substitute for the binding domains of enzymes that act on DNA to create designer enzymes with programmable sequence specificity. The most studied of these engineered enzymes are zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs). ZFNs have been widely used to model organisms and are currently in human clinical trials with an aim of therapeutic gene editing. Difficulties with ZFNs arise from unpredictable mutations caused by nonhomologous end joining and off-target DNA cleavage and mutagenesis. A more recent strategy that aims to address the shortcomings of ZFNs involves zinc finger recombinases (ZFRs). A thorough understanding of ZFRs and methods for their modification promises powerful new tools for gene manipulation in model organisms as well as in gene therapy. In an effort to design efficient and specific ZFRs, the effects of the DNA binding affinity of the zinc finger domains and the linker sequence between ZFPs and recombinase catalytic domains have been assessed. A plasmid system containing ZFR target sites was constructed for evaluation of catalytic activities of ZFRs with variable linker lengths and numbers of zinc finger modules. Recombination efficiencies were evaluated by restriction enzyme analysis of isolated plasmids after reaction in Escherichia coli and changes in EGFP fluorescence in mammalian cells. The results provide information relevant to the design of ZFRs that will be useful for sequence-specific genome modification.     

Beyond the "recognition code": structures of two Cys2His2 zinc finger/TATA box complexes

BACKGROUND: Several methods have been developed for creating Cys2His2 zinc finger proteins that recognize novel DNA sequences, and these proteins may have important applications in biological research and gene therapy. In spite of this progress with design/selection methodology, fundamental questions remain about the principles that govern DNA recognition. One hypothesis suggests that recognition can be described by a simple set of rules--essentially a "recognition code"--but careful assessment of this proposal has been difficult because there have been few structural studies of selected zinc finger proteins. RESULTS: We report the high-resolution cocrystal structures of two zinc finger proteins that had been selected (as variants of Zif268) to recognize a eukaryotic TATA box sequence. The overall docking arrangement of the fingers within the major groove of the DNA is similar to that observed in the Zif268 complex. Nevertheless, comparison of Zif268 and the selected variants reveal significant differences in the pattern of side chain-base interactions. The new structures also reveal side chain-side chain interactions (both within and between fingers) that are important in stabilizing the protein-DNA interface and appear to play substantial roles in recognition. CONCLUSIONS: These new structures highlight the surprising complexity of zinc finger-DNA interactions. The diversity of interactions observed at the protein-DNA interface, which is especially striking for proteins that were all derived from Zif268, challenges fundamental concepts about zinc finger-DNA recognition and underscores the difficulty in developing any meaningful recognition code.     

Determination of the base recognition positions of zinc fingers from sequence analysis.

The CC/HH zinc finger is a small independently folded DNA recognition motif found in many eukaryotic proteins, which ligates zinc through two cysteine and two histidine ligands. A database of 1340 zinc fingers from 221 proteins has been constructed and a program for analysis of aligned sequences written. This paper describes sequence analysis aimed at determining the amino acid positions that recognize the DNA bases, by comparing two types of sequence variation. Using the idea that long runs of adjacent zinc fingers have arisen from internal gene duplication, the conservation of each position of the finger within the runs was calculated. The conservation of each position of the finger between homologous proteins from different species was also noted. A correlation of the two types of conservation showed clusters of related amino acids. One cluster of three positions was found to be especially variable within long runs, but highly conserved between corresponding fingers of homologous proteins; these positions are predicted to be the base contact positions. They match the amino acid positions that contact the bases in the co-crystal structure determined by Pavletich and Pabo [Science, 240, 809-817 (1991)]. An adjacent cluster of four positions on the plot may also be associated with DNA binding. This analysis shows that the base recognition positions can be identified even in the absence of a known structure for a zinc finger. These results are applicable to zinc fingers where the structure of the complex is unknown, in particular suggesting that the individual finger--DNA interaction seen in the Zif268--DNA structure has been conserved in many zinc finger--DNA interactions.     

Structural and functional analysis of the PDZ domains of human HtrA1 and HtrA3

High-temperature requirement A (HtrA) and its homologs contain a serine protease domain followed by one or two PDZ domains. Bacterial HtrA proteins and the mitochondrial protein HtrA2/Omi maintain cell function by acting as both molecular chaperones and proteases to manage misfolded proteins. The biological roles of the mammalian family members HtrA1 and HtrA3 are less clear. We report a detailed structural and functional analysis of the PDZ domains of human HtrA1 and HtrA3 using peptide libraries and affinity assays to define specificity, structural studies to view the molecular details of ligand recognition, and alanine scanning mutagenesis to investigate the energetic contributions of individual residues to ligand binding. In common with HtrA2/Omi, we show that the PDZ domains of HtrA1 and HtrA3 recognize hydrophobic polypeptides, and while C-terminal sequences are preferred, internal sequences are also recognized. However, the details of the interactions differ, as different domains rely on interactions with different residues within the ligand to achieve high affinity binding. The results suggest that mammalian HtrA PDZ domains interact with a broad range of hydrophobic binding partners. This promiscuous specificity resembles that of bacterial HtrA family members and suggests a similar function for recognizing misfolded polypeptides with exposed hydrophobic sequences. Our results support a common activation mechanism for the HtrA family, whereby hydrophobic peptides bind to the PDZ domain and induce conformational changes that activate the protease. Such a mechanism is well suited to proteases evolved for the recognition and degradation of misfolded proteins.     

Structure-function analysis of the THAP zinc finger of THAP1, a large C2CH DNA-binding module linked to Rb/E2F pathways

THAP1, the founding member of a previously uncharacterized large family of cellular proteins (THAP proteins), is a sequence-specific DNA-binding factor that has recently been shown to regulate cell proliferation through modulation of pRb/E2F cell cycle target genes. THAP1 shares its DNA-binding THAP zinc finger domain with Drosophila P element transposase, zebrafish E2F6, and several nematode proteins interacting genetically with the retinoblastoma protein pRb. In this study, we report the three-dimensional structure and structure-function relationships of the THAP zinc finger of human THAP1. Deletion mutagenesis and multidimensional NMR spectroscopy revealed that the THAP domain of THAP1 is an atypical zinc finger of approximately 80 residues, distinguished by the presence between the C2CH zinc coordinating residues of a short antiparallel beta-sheet interspersed by a long loop-helix-loop insertion. Alanine scanning mutagenesis of this loop-helix-loop motif resulted in the identification of a number of critical residues for DNA recognition. NMR chemical shift perturbation analysis was used to further characterize the residues involved in DNA binding. The combination of the mutagenesis and NMR data allowed the mapping of the DNA binding interface of the THAP zinc finger to a highly positively charged area harboring multiple lysine and arginine residues. Together, these data represent the first structure-function analysis of a functional THAP domain, with demonstrated sequence-specific DNA binding activity. They also provide a structural framework for understanding DNA recognition by this atypical zinc finger, which defines a novel family of cellular factors linked to cell proliferation and pRb/E2F cell cycle pathways in humans, fish, and nematodes.     

Finger-positional change in three zinc finger protein Sp1: influence of terminal finger in DNA recognition

The connection of functional modules is effective for the design of DNA binding molecules with the desired sequence specificity. C(2)H(2)-type zinc finger proteins have a tandemly repeated array structure consisting of independent finger modules and are expected to recognize any DNA sequences by permutation, multi-connection, and the substitution of various sets of zinc fingers. To investigate the effects of the replacement of the terminal finger on the DNA recognition by other fingers, we have constructed the three zinc finger peptides with finger substitution at the N- or C-terminus, Sp1(zf223), Sp1(zf323), and Sp1(zf321). From the results of gel mobility shift assays, each mutant peptide binds preferentially to the target sequence that is predicted if the fingers act in a modular fashion. The methylation interference analyses demonstrate that in the cases of the N-terminal finger substitution mutants, Sp1(zf223) and Sp1(zf323), the N-terminal finger recognizes bases to different extents from that of the wild-type peptide, Sp1(zf123). Of special interest is the fact that the N-terminal finger of the C-terminal finger substitution mutant, Sp1(zf321), shows a distinct base recognition from those of Sp1(zf123) and Sp1(zf323). DNase I footprinting analyses indicate that the C-terminal finger (active finger) induces a conformational change in the DNA in the region for the binding of the N-terminal finger (passive finger). The present results strongly suggest that the extent of base recognition of the N-terminal finger is dominated by the binding of the C-terminal finger. This information provides an important clue for the creation of a zinc finger peptide with the desired specificity, which is applicable to the design of novel drugs and biological tools.     

Towards therapeutic applications of engineered zinc finger proteins

It has long been the goal of molecular biologists to design DNA-binding proteins for the specific control of gene expression. The zinc finger design is ideally suited for such purposes, discriminating between closely related sequences both in vitro and in vivo. Whereas other DNA-binding proteins generally make use of the 2-fold symmetry of the double helix, zinc fingers do not and so can be linked linearly in tandem to recognize DNA sequences of different lengths, with high fidelity. This modular design offers a large number of combinatorial possibilities for the specific recognition of DNA. By fusing zinc finger peptides to repression or activation domains, genes can be selectively targeted and switched off and on. Several recent applications of such engineered zinc finger proteins (ZFPs) are described, including the activation of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) in a human cell line and an animal model. Clinical trials have recently begun on using VEGF-activating ZFPs to treat human peripheral arterial disease, by stimulating vascular growth. Also in progress are pre-clinical studies using ZFPs to target the defective genes in two monogenic disorders, SCID and SCA. The aim is to replace them in each case by a correct copy from an extrachromosomal DNA donor by means of homologous recombination. Promising results are reported.     

The reaction mechanism of FokI excludes the possibility of targeting zinc finger nucleases to unique DNA sites

The FokI endonuclease is a monomeric protein with discrete DNA-recognition and catalytic domains. The latter has only one active site so, to cut both strands, the catalytic domains from two monomers associate to form a dimer. The dimer involving a monomer at the recognition site and another from free solution is less stable than that from two proteins tethered to the same DNA. FokI thus cleaves DNA with two sites better than one-site DNA. The two sites can be immediately adjacent, but they can alternatively be many hundreds of base pairs apart, in either inverted or repeated orientations. The catalytic domain of FokI is often a component of zinc finger nucleases. Typically, the zinc finger domains of two such nucleases are designed to recognize two neighbouring DNA sequences, with the objective of cutting the DNA exclusively between the target sequences. However, this strategy fails to take account of the fact that the catalytic domains of FokI can dimerize across distant sites or even at a solitary site. Additional copies of either target sequence elsewhere in the chromosome must elicit off-target cleavages.     

Sequence-specific cleavage of the RNA strand in DNA–RNA hybrids by the fusion of ribonuclease H with a zinc finger

Ribonucleases (RNases) are valuable tools applied in the analysis of RNA sequence, structure and function. Their substrate specificity is limited to recognition of single bases or distinct secondary structures in the substrate. Currently, there are no RNases available for purely sequence-dependent fragmentation of RNA. Here, we report the development of a new enzyme that cleaves the RNA strand in DNA–RNA hybrids 5 nt from a nonanucleotide recognition sequence. The enzyme was constructed by fusing two functionally independent domains, a RNase HI, that hydrolyzes RNA in DNA–RNA hybrids in processive and sequence-independent manner, and a zinc finger that recognizes a sequence in DNA–RNA hybrids. The optimization of the fusion enzyme’s specificity was guided by a structural model of the protein-substrate complex and involved a number of steps, including site-directed mutagenesis of the RNase moiety and optimization of the interdomain linker length. Methods for engineering zinc finger domains with new sequence specificities are readily available, making it feasible to acquire a library of RNases that recognize and cleave a variety of sequences, much like the commercially available assortment of restriction enzymes. Potentially, zinc finger-RNase HI fusions may, in addition to in vitro applications, be used in vivo for targeted RNA degradation.     

Importance of a flanking AT-rich region in target site recognition by the GC box-binding zinc finger protein MIG1.

MIG1 is a zinc finger protein that mediates glucose repression in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. MIG1 is related to the mammalian Krox/Egr, Wilms' tumor, and Sp1 finger proteins. It has two fingers and binds to a GCGGGG motif that resembles the GC boxes recognized by these mammalian proteins. We have performed a complete saturation mutagenesis of a natural MIG1 site in order to elucidate its binding specificity. We found that only three mutations within the GC box retain the ability to bind MIG1: G1 to C, C2 to T, and G5 to A. This result is consistent with current models for zinc finger-DNA binding, which assume that the sequence specificity is determined by base triplet recognition within the GC box. Surprisingly, we found that an AT-rich region 5' to the GC box also is important for MIG1 binding. This AT box is present in all natural MIG1 sites, and it is protected by MIG1 in DNase I footprints. However, the AT box differs from the GC box in that no single base within it is essential for binding. Instead, the AT-rich nature of this sequence seems to be crucial. The fact that AT-rich sequences are known to increase DNA flexibility prompted us to test whether MIG1 bends DNA. We found that binding of MIG1 is associated with bending within the AT box. We conclude that DNA binding by a simple zinc finger protein such as MIG1 can involve both recognition of the GC box and flanking sequence preferences that may reflect local DNA bendability.