Conservation and variation in enamel protein distribution during vertebrate tooth development

Vertebrate enamel formation is a unique synthesis of the function of highly specialized enamel proteins and their effect on the growth and organization of apatite crystals. Among tetrapods, the physical structure of enamel is highly conserved, while there is a greater variety of enameloid tooth coverings in fish. In the present study, we postulated that in enamel microstructures of similar organization, the principle components of the enamel protein matrix would have to be highly conserved. In order to identify the enamel proteins that might be most highly conserved and thus potentially most essential to the process of mammalian enamel formation, we used immunoscreening with enamel protein antibodies as a means to assay for degrees of homology to mammalian enamel proteins. Enamel preparations from mouse, gecko, frog, lungfish, and shark were screened with mammalian enamel protein antibodies, including amelogenin, enamelin, tuftelin, MMP20, and EMSP1. Our results demonstrated that amelogenin was the most highly conserved enamel protein associated with the enamel organ, enamelin featured a distinct presence in shark enameloid but was also present in the enamel organ of other species, while the other enamel proteins, tuftelin, MMP20, and EMSP1, were detected in both in the enamel organ and in other tissues of all species investigated. We thus conclude that the investigated enamel proteins, amelogenin, enamelin, tuftelin, MMP20, and EMSP1, were highly conserved in a variety of vertebrate species. We speculate that there might be a unique correlation between amelogenin-rich tetrapod and lungfish enamel with long and parallel crystals and enamelin-rich basal vertebrate enameloid with diverse patterns of crystal organization.     

Cell-free translation of messenger RNAs of embryonic tooth organs: Synthesis of the major extracellular matrix proteins

In order to understand the regulation of embryonic mammalian enamel and dentine extracellular matrix protein synthesis, the biological activity of embryonic rabbit molar tooth organ messenger RNAs has been examined. Total RNA was extracted from 26-day embryonic tooth organs and fractionated by chromatography on oligo(dT)-cellulose. Replicate samples were fractionated on sucrose density gradients and the poly(A)-containing distribution determined using a poly(U) ${}^3$H assay. The poly(A)-containing fractions stimulated ${}^3$H-proline incorporation 10-fold in wheat germ cell-free extracts. Analysis of the labelled reaction products on sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gels revealed seven major peaks, one co-migrating with procollagen alpha chains (circa 145,000 daltons) and the others migrating slightly faster than the various extracellular matrix proteins which characterize amelogenesis and dentinogenesis. Purified collagenase digestion of the cell-free reaction products eliminated the 145,000 dalton procollagen-like polypeptide. This is the first demonstration of the isolation of embryonic tooth organ messenger RNAs and provides an experimental approach by which to study the regulation of extracellular matrix formation during tooth morphogenesis. We predict that the non-collagenous proteins synthesized $\text{in vitro}$ represent enamel proteins, alkaline phosphatase, dentine phosphoproteins and proteins associated with proteoglycans.     

Selachian tooth development: II. Immunolocalization of amelogenin polypeptides in epithelium during secretory amelogenesis in Squalus acanthias

We have determined the distribution of amelogenin polypeptides in an order of elasmobranchs using indirect immunofluorescence with rabbit polyclonal antibodies prepared to purified murine amelogenins. We find that amelogenins are definitely present within the inner enamel epithelium prior to the production of the extracellular matrix component termed "enameloid" (row II developing tooth organs). During subsequent stages of selachian tooth development (row III tooth organs), immunofluorescence staining data indicated localization of amelogenin antigens within epithelium as well as the enameloid extracellular matrix. The results from these immunohistochemical studies suggest that the 16-20 kdalton amelogenins, which are characteristic of murine inner enamel epithelial cells undergoing terminal biochemical differentiation into secretory ameloblasts, may also be regarded as molecular markers for amelogenesis in developing teeth in the spiny dogfish, Squalus acanthias.     

Biosynthesis and characterization of rabbit tooth enamel extracellular-matrix proteins.

Tooth enamel biomineralization is mediated by enamel proteins synthesized by ameloblast cells. Two classes of proteins have been described: enamelins and amelogenins. In lower vertebrates the absence of amelogenins is believed to give rise to aprismatic enamel; however, rabbit teeth, which apparently do not synthesize amelogenins, form prismatic enamel. The present study was designed to characterize the enamel proteins present in rabbit tooth organs and to gain an insight into the process of biomineralization. Rabbit enamel extracellular-matrix proteins were isolated and characterized during sequential stages of rabbit tooth organogenesis. The biosynthesis of enamel proteins was analysed by metabolic 'pulse-chase' experiments as well as mRNA-translation studies in cell-free systems. Our results indicated that rabbit enamel extracellular matrix contains 'amelogenin-like' proteins. However, these proteins are not synthesized as typical amelogenins, as in other mammalian species, thus suggesting that they are the processing products of higher-molecular-mass precursors. An N-terminal amino acid sequence of 29 residues, considered characteristic of mammalian amelogenins, was present in the rabbit 'amelogenin-like' proteins. By using anti-peptide antibodies to this region, similar epitopes were detected in all nascent enamel proteins, including enamelins. These studies suggest that the N-terminal sequence might be characteristic of all enamel proteins, not only amelogenins.     

Immunochemical and immunohistochemical study of the 27- and 29-kDa calcium-binding proteins and related proteins in the porcine tooth germ

 Our previous report identified 27- and 29-kDa calcium-binding proteins in porcine immature dental enamel. In this study we revealed that the N-terminal amino acid sequences of the two proteins were identical: LLANPXGXIPNLARGPAGRSRGPPG. The sequence matches a portion of the amino acid sequence of the porcine sheath protein, sheathlin. Porcine tooth germs were investigated immunochemically and immunohistochemically using specific antibodies raised against synthetic peptide that included residues 13–25 of this sequence. The affinity-purified antibodies reacted with several proteins extracted from newly formed immature enamel in immunochemical analyses, especially protein bands migrating at 62, 35–45, 29, and 27 kDa in SDS-polyacrylamide gels. The largest protein detected was a weak band near 70 kDa. In immunochemical analyses of proteins extracted from the inner (old) immature enamel, the antibody reacted faintly with the 27- and 29-kDa proteins. In immunohistochemical preparations, the Golgi apparatus and secretory granules of the secretory ameloblast, and the surface layer of immature enamel showed immunoreactivity. The immunoreactivity of immature enamel just beneath the secretory face of the Tomes’ process was intense. No immunoreactivity was found in the Golgi apparatus of the maturation ameloblast. These results suggest that the 70-kDa protein, whose degradation might be very fast, is the parent protein of the 27- and 29-kDa proteins. Accepted: 20 January 1997     

Amelogenesis in vitro: a model for studies of epithelial postsecretory processing during tissue-specific extracellular matrix biomineralization

The extracellular matrix (ECM) of developing mammalian enamel comprises a complex of unusual epithelial-derived proteins, which appear to function in concert to initiate and propagate tissue-specific biomineralization. Following enamel protein synthesis by ameloblast cells within the enamel organ, the subsequent steps of posttranslational modification, secretion, postsecretory processing and eventual removal of these proteins from forming enamel are largely unknown. To address this issue we have designed studies to investigate the hypothesis that enamel proteins are removed from enamel and translocated into the vasculature as relatively high-molecular-weight components. We examined enamel proteins recovered from serumless medium during prolonged organ culture of mouse capstage mandibular first molars. By 21 days in vitro the tooth crown formed and dentine and enamel biomineralization were apparent. At 31 days, explants retained metabolic activity and the enamel matrix showed extensive transformation. Immunologically identified enamel proteins of 26-18 k Da were produced by cultured tooth organs, translocated from tooth explants to the culture medium, recovered from the medium and then compared to control enamel protein from in vivo preparations. Comparable postsecretory processing of the 26-k Da amelogenin protein was observed in vitro and in vivo. We speculate that the pathway reported in the present studies is comparable to the processing of the enamel protein polypeptides of the maturing enamel which occurs in vivo. The in vitro organ culture model described in this report provides an approach with which to investigate the molecular events associated with epithelial-derived postsecretory processing of ECM molecules associated with tissue-specific biomineralization.     

Enamel protein biosynthesis and secretion in mouse incisor secretory ameloblasts as revealed by high-resolution immunocytochemistry

Mouse secretory ameloblasts express a number of enamel proteins, which have been divided into amelogenin and enamelin subfamilies. We have used polyclonal antibodies to murine amelogenins to reveal enamel proteins in mouse ameloblasts using the protein A-gold immunocytochemical technique. Specific immunolabeling was detected over the extracellular enamel matrix and over the rough endoplasmic reticulum, the saccules of the Golgi apparatus, and the secretory granules of the ameloblasts. In addition, some lysosome-like granules were also labeled. Only background labeling was obtained over mitochondria, nuclei, cytosol, adjacent odontoblasts, and dentin. Quantitation of the intensity of labeling showed the presence of an increasing gradient along the secretory pathway, which may correspond to the concentration or the maturation of these proteins as they are processed by the cell. These findings indicate that the ameloblast displays an intracellular distribution of its secretory products similar to that of other merocrine secreting cells. The presence of enamel proteins in lysosomes suggests that crinophagy and/or resorption occurs in these cells.     

High yield expression of biologically active recombinant full length human tuftelin protein in baculovirus-infected insect cells

Tuftelin is an acidic protein expressed at very early stages of mouse odontogenesis. It was suggested to play a role during epithelial–mesenchymal interactions, and later, when enamel formation commences, to be involved in enamel mineralization. Tuftelin was also detected in several normal soft tissues of different origins and some of their corresponding cancerous tissues. Tuftelin is expressed in low quantities, and undergoes degradation in the enamel extracellular matrix. To investigate the structure and function of tuftelin, the full length recombinant human tuftelin protein was produced. The full length human tuftelin cDNA was cloned using Gateway^TM recombination into the Bac-to-Bac^TM system compatible transfer vector pDest10. This vector adds a hexahistidine tag to the N-terminus of the expressed protein, enabling one-step affinity purification on nickel column. The recombinant human tuftelin protein was transposed into the bacmid and expressed in Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf9) insect cells. The yield of the purified, his-tagged recombinant full length human Tuftelin (rHTuft⁺) was 5–8 mg/L culture. rHTuft⁺ was characterized by SDS–PAGE, Western blot, ESI-TOF spectrometry, restriction mapping and MS/MS sequencing. The availability of the purified, full length recombinant human tuftelin protein opened up the possibility to investigate novel functions of tuftelin. Application of rHTuft⁺ agarose beads onto embryonic mouse mandibular explants caused changes in the surrounding epithelial cells, including morphology, orientation and spatial organization. Further studies using DiI labeling, revealed that rHTuft⁺, placed on the tooth germ region, brought about recruitment of adjacent embryonic mesenchymal cells. These findings support the hypothesis that tuftelin plays an important role during embryogenesis.     

Ameloblast differentiation in the human developing tooth: Effects of extracellular matrices

Tooth enamel is formed by epithelially-derived cells called ameloblasts, while the pulp dentin complex is formed by the dental mesenchyme. These tissues differentiate with reciprocal signaling interactions to form a mature tooth. In this study we have characterized ameloblast differentiation in human developing incisors, and have further investigated the role of extracellular matrix proteins on ameloblast differentiation. Histological and immunohistochemical analyses showed that in the human tooth, the basement membrane separating the early developing dental epithelium and mesenchyme was lost shortly before dentin deposition was initiated, prior to enamel matrix secretion. Presecretary ameloblasts elongated as they came into contact with the dentin matrix, and then shortened to become secretory ameloblasts. In situ hybridization showed that the presecretory stage of odontoblasts started to express type I collagen mRNA, and also briefly expressed amelogenin mRNA. This was followed by upregulation of amelogenin mRNA expression in secretory ameloblasts. In vitro, amelogenin expression was upregulated in ameloblast lineage cells cultured in Matrigel, and was further up-regulated when these cells/Matrigel were co-cultured with dental pulp cells. Co-culture also up-regulated type I collagen expression by the dental pulp cells. Type I collagen coated culture dishes promoted a more elongated ameloblast lineage cell morphology and enhanced cell adhesion via integrin α2β1. Taken together, these results suggest that the basement membrane proteins and signals from underlying mesenchymal cells coordinate to initiate differentiation of preameloblasts and regulate type I collagen expression by odontoblasts. Type I collagen in the dentin matrix then anchors the presecretary ameloblasts as they further differentiate to secretory cells. These studies show the critical roles of the extracellular matrix proteins in ameloblast differentiation.     

Light and electron microscopical immunohistochemical localization of large proteoglycans in human tooth germs at the bell stage

Summary The immunohistochemical localization of large hyaluronate-binding proteoglycans has been studied in human tooth germs at the bell stage using a monoclonal antibody, 5D5, which is derived from bovine sclera and specifically recognizes the core protein of large proteoglycans, such as versican, neurocan and brevican, but not that of aggrecan. In the early bell stage before predentine secretion, when the enamel organs consisted of the inner and outer enamel epithelia, stratum intermedium and stellate reticulum, the enamel organs were not stained by 5D5, but the dental papillae and follicles stained strongly. Concomitant with the secretion of predentine, dentine and subsequent enamel matrix, strong 5D5 immunostaining distributed over the entire cell surfaces of secretory ameloblasts was observed. The forming enamel matrix showed strong staining. While most of the inner and outer enamel epithelia and stratum intermedium lacked staining, the cervical loop region and stellate reticulum showed weak staining. Although the forming dentine and odontoblasts appeared to lack 5D5 affinity, the predentine, dental papilla and dental follicle demonstrated moderate to strong reactivity. At the ultrastructural level, specific immunoreaction by immunogold particle deposition was clearly detected over the basal lamina of presecretory ameloblasts, secretion granules of secretory ameloblasts and the forming enamel matrix. These results indicate that a marked increase in the large proteoglycan associated with secretory ameloblasts may correlate with cell differentiation and enamel matrix biosynthesis. This revised version was published online in November 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Immunocytochemical and immunochemical study of enamelins, using antibodies against porcine 89-kDa enamelin and its N-terminal synthetic peptide, in porcine tooth germs

Enamelins comprise an important family of the enamel matrix proteins. Porcine tooth germs were investigated immunochemically and immunocytochemically using two antibodies: a polyclonal antibody raised against the porcine 89-kDa enamelin (89 E) and an affinity purified anti-peptide antibody against the porcine enamelin amino-terminus (EN). Immunochemical analysis of layers of immature enamel from the matrix formation stage detected immunopositive protein bands ranging from 10 kDa to 155 kDa in the outer layer enamel sample irrespective of the antibodies used. In contrast, the middle and inner enamel layer mainly contained lower molecular weight enamelins. In immunocytochemical analyses of the differentiation stage, 89 E stained enamel matrix islands around mineralized collagen fibrils of dentin, while EN stained both enamel matrix islands and stippled material. At the matrix formation stage, both antibodies intensely stained enamel prisms located in the outer layer. In the inner layer, 89 E moderately stained enamel matrix homogeneously, while EN primarily stained the prism sheath. The intense immunoreaction over the surface layer of enamel matrix at the matrix formation stage, following staining with 89 E and EN, disappeared by the end of the transition stage and the early maturation stage, respectively. The Golgi apparatus and secretory granules in the ameloblasts from the late differentiation stage to the transition stage were immunostained by both antibodies. These results suggest that expression of enamelin continues from late differentiation to the transition stage and the cleavage of N-terminal region of enamelin occurs soon after secretion. Some enamelin degradation products, which apparently have no affinity for hydroxyapatite crystals, concentrate in the prism sheaths during enamel maturation.     

mRNA polyadenylate-binding protein: gene isolation and sequencing and identification of a ribonucleoprotein consensus sequence.

We identified and produced antibodies to the major proteins that interact with poly(A)+ RNAs in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The major proteins which were cross-linked by UV light to poly(A)+ RNA in intact yeast cells had apparent molecular weights of 72,000, 60,000, and 50,000. The poly(A) segment of the RNA was selectively cross-linked to the 72,000-molecular-weight protein (72K protein). Mice immunized with purified UV-cross-linked RNA-protein (RNP) complexes produced antibodies to the three major RNP proteins. A yeast genomic DNA library constructed in the lambda gt11 expression vector was screened with the anti-RNP serum, and recombinant bacteriophage clones were isolated. One recombinant phage, lambda YPA72.1, bearing a 2.5-kilobase insert, produced a large beta-galactosidase-RNP fusion protein. Affinity-selected antibodies from the anti-RNP serum on this fusion protein recognized a single 72K protein which was cross-linked to the poly(A) segment of RNA in the intact cell. Furthermore, the fusion protein of lambda YPA72.1 had specific poly(A)-binding activity. Therefore, lambda YPA72.1 encodes the 72K poly(A)-binding protein. Immunofluorescence microscopy showed that this protein was localized in the cytoplasm. Hybrid-selected mRNA translated in vitro produced the 72K poly(A)-binding protein, and mRNA blot analysis detected a single 2.1-kilobase mRNA. DNA blot analysis suggested a single gene for the poly(A)-binding protein. DNA sequence analysis of genomic clones spanning the entire gene revealed a long open reading frame encoding a 64,272-molecular-weight protein with several distinct domains and repeating structural elements. A sequence of 11 to 13 amino acids is repeated three times in this protein. Strikingly, this repeated sequence (RNP consensus sequence) is highly homologous to a sequence that is repeated twice in a major mammalian heterogeneous nuclear RNP protein, A1. The conservation of the repetitive RNP consensus sequence suggests an important function and a common evolutionary origin for messenger RNP and heterogeneous nuclear RNP proteins.     

Immunofluorescent localization of amelogenins in developing bovine teeth.

Antiserum was prepared to the proteins (amelogenins) isolated from fetal bovine enamel matrix. This antiserum was used to localize the amelogenins in the developing bovine molar by immunofluorescent microscopy. Amelogenins could be identified in the preameloblasts before enamel matrix deposition had begun as well as in the secretory ameloblasts. The closely adherent layer of stratum intermedium cells also contained some immunoreactive material, suggesting that they may contribute protein to the enamel matrix. The newly deposited enamel matrix consisted of brightly fluorescent particles. Mature enamel matrix did not contain the immunoreactive protein except in a thin layer along the dentino-enamel junction and adjacent to the ameloblasts. No other portion of the tooth bud or other tissues reacted with the specific antiserum.     

The epithelial genotype controls the pattern of extracellular enamel prism formation

Abstract. Enamel formation in the developing tooth organ is the product of epithelial-mesenchymal interactions which result in the differentiation of ameloblasts, the secretion of enamel proteins, and the production of a highly organized extracellular matrix. The three-dimensional organization of enamel prisms is species-specific: irregular polygonshaped in rabbit and rectangular-shaped in mouse. We designed experiments to test the hypothesis that three-dimensional organization of enamel prism formation is genetically determined by epithelium; the prediction being that speciesspecific enamel prism pattern formation is expressed independent of mesenchymal instructions. Our strategy employs scanning electron microscopy to examine enamel prism patterns formed during rabbit and mouse tooth morphogenesis in situ and in vitro, and to then determine the specific tissue type required for regulating these patterns using heterotypic tissue recombinations. Morphometric analyses demonstrated that cap stage tooth organs cultured on the chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) formed enamel prisms equivalent to prism patterns observed for in situ controls. Heterotypic tissue recombinations, using cap stage molar organs, formed rabbit-like prisms with rabbit epithelium/mouse mesenchyme, and mouse-like prisms with mouse epithelium/rabbit mesenchyme. These results indicate that dental papilla mesenchyme has no apparent influence on enamel prism pattern formation. Enamel prism pattern appears to be genetically regulated by the inner enamel epithelium.     

Ultrastructural study of tracer permeability through the cat and ferret enamel organ

The access of exogenous materials to the developing enamel surface has been intensively studied in rodents, but not in other mammalian species. This ultrastructural study investigates the permeability of injected horseradish peroxidase (HRP) and lanthanum tracers in cat and ferret tooth buds. In cat enamel organs fixed by immersion, lanthanum did not escape the capillaries overlying secretory stage tooth buds, but it did permeate up to the distal junctions of ruffle-ended (RA) and the proximal junctions of smooth-ended (SA) ameloblasts. Perfusion fixation with lanthanum compromised junctional integrity of cat ameloblasts at all stages of development. Similarly, HRP rarely escaped the capillaries associated with cat secretory stage enamel organs. However, unlike lanthanum, HRP was mostly confined to the vasculature of maturation stage enamel organs in immersion fixed cats at all time intervals examined. In ferrets, HRP penetrated up to, but not beyond, the distal junctional complexes of secretory ameloblasts. In maturation stage enamel organs, HRP coated the papillary and RA cells, but did not penetrate the RA distal cell junctions. HRP did permeate the extracellular spaces of SA to reach the underlying enamel surface. Ameloblasts in transitional phases of SA and RA endocytosed HRP at the distal cell surface. This data leads to several conclusions. First, HRP localization in the ferret paralleled that observed in rodents. Second, the results of cat enamel organs substantiate previous studies showing perfusion fixation can increase vascular and intercellular permeability to lanthanum. However, in cats fixed by immersion, both lanthanum and HRP were restricted to capillaries associated with the secretory stage enamel organ, and only lanthanum escaped maturation stage capillaries. It is suggested that variations in the fenestrations and distribution of capillaries associated with the cat enamel organ may differentially retain some materials and permit other materials to escape with relative ease.