Changes in chromatin structure at the replication fork. DNase I and trypsin-micrococcal nuclease effects on approximately 300- and 150-base pair nascent DNAs

DNase I, trypsin, and micrococcal nuclease are used to further probe the structure of nascent deoxyribonucleoprotein (DNP) fractions which appear after in vivo 20-s pulse labeling of sea urchin embryos with [3H]thymidine. We present evidence that the large nascent DNP which protects the approximately 300-base pair large nascent DNA consists of at least one nucleosome core. This is based on fractionation in denaturing polyacrylamide gels of DNA extracted from large nascent DNP fractions of a micrococcal nuclease + DNase I digest of nuclei. The data also suggest the existence of a DNase I-hypersensitive site(s) within the large nascent DNP; this is consistent with the hypothesis that the latter consists of closely packed dinucleosome cores. Histone H1 and non-histone proteins do not account for the previously reported unusual hyperresistance of the large nascent DNA against micrococcal nuclease. The protection offered this approximately 300-base pair nascent DNA was not eliminated by an 0.2-microgram/ml trypsin pretreatment which removes the above proteins from the chromatin. However, 5-10 micrograms/ml of trypsin, which remove a portion of the NH2 termini of the four core histones of nucleosomes, eliminate the hyperresistance of the large nascent DNA to subsequent micrococcal nuclease digestion, while nascent and bulk monomer DNAs remain unaffected. This indicates histone-histone and/or histone-DNA interactions within the large nascent DNP which differ from those of nascent and bulk mononucleosome cores.     

Reduced repeat length of nascent nucleosomal DNA is generated by replicating chromatin in vivo

Micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclei from sea urchin embryos revealed transient changes in chromatin structure which resulted in a reduction in the repeat length of nascent chromatin DNA as compared with bulk DNA. This was considered to be entirely the consequence of in vivo events at the replication fork (Cell 14, 259, 1978). However, a micrococcal nuclease-generated sliding of nucleosome cores relative to nascent DNA, which might account for the smaller DNA fragments, was not excluded. In vivo [3H]thymidine pulse-labeled nuclei were fixed with a formaldehyde prior to micrococcal nuclease digestion. This linked chromatin proteins to DNA and thus prevented any in vitro sliding of histone cores. All the nascent DNAs exhibiting shorter repeat lengths after micrococcal nuclease digestion, were resolved at identical mobilities in polyacrylamide gels of DNA from fixed and unfixed nuclei. We conclude that these differences in repeat lengths between nascent and bulk DNA was generated in vivo by changes in chromatin structure during replication, rather than by micrococcal nuclease-induced sliding of histone cores in vitro.     

A site of discontinuity in the interaction between DNA and histones in nucleosomes of sea urchin embryo chromatin.

Digestion of chromatin DNA in nuclei of sea urchin embryos with pancreatic nuclease and with micrococcal nuclease give additional details concerning the interaction between DNA and histones. A specific site of hydrolysis appears to be located on the nucleosome in such a position as to split the DNA unit length in two equivalent fragments of about 60–70 base pairs in length. The complete digestion of chromatin DNA appears to depend on the low stability of the nucleosome containing the split DNA fragments.     

Nascent DNA in nucleosome like structures from chromatin

We have used chromatin sensitivity to cleavage by micrococcal nuclease as a probe for differences between chromatin containing nascent DNA and that containing bulk DNA. Micrococcal nuclease digested the nascent DNA in chromatin of swimming blastulae of sea urchins more rapidly to acid-soluble nucleotides than the DNA of bulk chromatin. A part of the nascent DNA occurred in micrococcal nuclease-resistant structures which were either different from, or temporary modifications of, the bulk nucleosomes. This was inferred from the size differences between bulk and nascent DNA fragments in 10% polyacrylamide gels after micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclei from a mixture of ¹⁴C-thymidine long- and ³H-thymidine pulse-labeled embryos. Bulk monomer and dimer DNA fragments contained about 170 and 410 base pairs (bp), respectively, when 18% of the bulk DNA had been rendered acid-soluble. At this level of digestion, “nascent monomer DNA” fragments of about 150 bp as well as 305 bp “large nascent DNA fragments” were observed. Increasing levels of digestion indicated that the large nascent DNA fragment was derived from a chromatin structure which was more resistant to micrococcal nuclease cleavage than bulk dimer chromatin subunits. Peaks of ³H-thymidine-labeled DNA fragments from embryos which had been pulse-labeled and then chased or labeled for several minutes overlapped those of ¹⁴C-thymidine long-labeled monomer, dimer and trimer fragments. This indicated that the chromatin organization at or near the replication fork which had temporarily changed during replication had returned to the organization of its nonreplicating state.     

Deoxyribonuclease II as a probe for chromatin structure. I. Location of cleavage sites

DNAase II has been shown to cleave condensed mouse liver chromatin at 100-bp² intervals while chromatin in the extended form is cleaved at 200-bp intervals (Altenburger et al., 1976). Evidence is presented here that DNA digestion patterns of a half-nucleosomal periodicity are also obtained upon DNAase II digestion of chicken erythrocyte nuclei and yeast nuclei, both of which differ in their repeat lengths (210 and 165 bp) from mouse liver chromatin. In the digestion of mouse liver nuclei a shift from the 100-bp to the 200-bp cleavage mode takes place when the concentration of monovalent cations present during digestion is decreased below 1 mM. When soluble chromatin prepared by micrococcal nuclease is digested with DNAase II the same type of shift occurs, albeit at higher ionic strength.In order to map the positions of the DNAase II cleavage sites on the DNA relative to the positions of the nucleosome cores, the susceptibility of DNAase II-derived DNA termini to exonuclease III was investigated. In addition, oligonucleosome fractions from HaeIII and micrococcal nuclease digests were end-labelled with polynucleotide kinase and digested with DNAase II under conditions leading to 100 and 200-bp digestion patterns. Analysis of the chain lengths of the resulting radioactively labelled fragments together with the results of the exonuclease assay allow the following conclusions. In the 200-bp digestion mode, DNAase II cleaves exclusively in the internucleosomal linker region. Also in the 100-bp mode cleavage occurs initially in the linker region. Subsequently, DNAase II cleaves at intranucleosomal locations, which are not, however, in the centre of the nucleosome but instead around positions 20 and 125 of the DNA associated with the nucleosome core. At late stages of digestion intranucleosomal cuts predominate and linkers that are still intact are largely resistant to DNAase II due to interactions between adjacent nucleosomes. These findings offer an explanation for the sensitivity of DNAase II to the higher-order structure of chromatin.     

Different repeat lengths in rat satellite I DNA containing chromatin and bulk chromatin.

The nucleosome repeat structure of a rat liver chromatin component containing the satellite I DNA (repeat length 370 bp) was investigated. Digestion experiments with micrococcal nuclease, DNAase II, and the Ca2+/Mg2+-dependent endogenous nuclease of rat liver nuclei revealed a repeat unit of 185 nucleotide pairs which is shorter by approximately 10 bp than the repeat unit of the bulk chromatin of this cell type. The difference seems not to be related to the histone composition which was found to be similar in the two types of chromatin.     

A lysine-rich protein functions as an H1 histone in Dictyostelium discoideum chromatin.

Mononucleosomes released from Dictyostelium discoideum chromatin by micrococcal nuclease contained two distinctive DNA sizes (166-180 and 146 bp). Two dimensional gel electrophoresis suggested a lysine-rich protein protected the larger mononucleosomes from nuclease digestion. This was confirmed by stripping the protein from chromatin with Dowex resin. Subsequently, only the 146 bp mononucleosome was produced by nuclease digestion. Reconstitution of the stripped chromatin with the purified lysine-rich protein resulted in the reappearance of the larger mononucleosomes. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis showed the protein was associated with mononucleosomes. Hence, the protein functions as an H1 histone in bringing the two DNA strands together at their exit point from the nucleosome. Trypsin digestion of the lysine-rich protein in nuclei resulted in a limiting peptide of approx. 10 kilodaltons. Trypsin concentrations which degraded the protein to peptides of 12-14 kilodaltons and partially degraded the core histones did not change the DNA digestion patterns obtained with micrococcal nuclease. Thus, the trypsin-resistant domain of the lysine-rich protein is able to maintain chromatosome structure.     

Nucleosome structure in Aspergillus nidulans

The structure of chromatin from Aspergillus nidulans was studied using micrococcal nuclease and DNAase I. Limited digestion with micrococcal nuclease revealed a nucleosomal repeat of 154 base pairs for Aspergillus and 198 base pairs for rat liver. With more extensive digestion, both types of chromatin gave a similar quasi-limit product with a prominent fragment at 140 base pairs. The similarity of the two limit digests suggests that the structure of the 140 base pair nucleosome core is conserved. This implies that the difference in nucleosome repeat lengths between Aspergillus and rat liver is caused by a difference in the length of the DNA between two nucleosome cores. Digestion of Aspergillus chromatin with DNAase I produced a pattern of single-stranded fragments at intervals of 10 bases which was similar to that produced from rat liver chromatin.     

Histone deacetylation is required for the maturation of newly replicated chromatin

The effects of inhibiting histone deacetylation on the maturation of newly replicated chromatin have been examined. HeLa cells were labeled with [3H]thymidine in the presence or absence of sodium butyrate; control experiments demonstrated that butyrate did not significantly inhibit DNA replication for at least 70 min. Like normal nascent chromatin, chromatin labeled for brief periods (0.5-1 min) in the presence of butyrate was more sensitive to digestion with DNase I and micrococcal nuclease than control bulk chromatin. However, chromatin replicated in butyrate did not mature as in normal replication, but instead retained approximately 50% of its heightened sensitivity to DNase I. Incubation of mature chromatin in butyrate for 1 h did not induce DNase I sensitivity: therefore, the presence of sodium butyrate was required during replication to preserve the increased digestibility of nascent chromatin DNA. In contrast, sodium butyrate did not inhibit or retard the maturation of newly replicated chromatin when assayed by micrococcal nuclease digestion, as determined by the following criteria: 1) digestion to acid solubility, 2) rate of conversion to mononucleosomes, 3) repeat length, and 4) presence of non-nucleosomal DNA. Consistent with the properties of chromatin replicated in butyrate, micrococcal nuclease also did not preferentially attack the internucleosomal linkers of chromatin regions acetylated in vivo. The observation of a novel chromatin replication intermediate, which is highly sensitive to DNase I but possesses normal resistance to micrococcal nuclease, suggests that nucleosome assembly and histone deacetylation are not obligatorily coordinated. Thus, while deacetylation is required for chromatin maturation, histone acetylation apparently affects chromatin organization at a level distinct from that of core particle or linker, possibly by altering higher order structure.     

Linker DNA destabilizes condensed chromatin.

The contribution of the linker region to maintenance of condensed chromatin was examined in two model systems, namely sea urchin sperm nuclei and chicken red blood cell nuclei. Linkerless nuclei, prepared by extensive digestion with micrococcal nuclease, were compared with Native nuclei using several assays, including microscopic appearance, nuclear turbidity, salt stability, and trypsin resistance. Chromatin in the Linkerless nuclei was highly condensed, resembling pyknotic chromatin in apoptotic cells. Linkerless nuclei were more stable in low ionic strength buffers and more resistant to trypsin than Native nuclei. Analysis of histones from the trypsinized nuclei by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis showed that specific histone H1, H2B, and H3 tail regions stabilized linker DNA in condensed nuclei. Thermal denaturation of soluble chromatin preparations from differentially trypsinized sperm nuclei demonstrated that the N-terminal regions of histones Sp H1, Sp H2B, and H3 bind tightly to linker DNA, causing it to denature at a high temperature. We conclude that linker DNA exerts a disruptive force on condensed chromatin structure which is counteracted by binding of specific histone tail regions to the linker DNA. The inherent instability of the linker region may be significant in all eukaryotic chromatins and may promote gene activation in living cells.     

Structure of eukaryotic chromatin. Evaluation of periodicity using endogenous and exogenous nucleases.

DNA isolated from (a) liver chromatin digested in situ with endogenous Ca2+, Mg2+-dependent endonuclease, (b) prostate chromatin digested in situ with micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic DNAase I, and (c) isolated liver chromatin digested with micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic DNAase I has been analyzed electrophoretically on polyacrylamide gels. The electrophoretic patterns of DNA prepared from chromatin digested in situ with either endogenous endonuclease (liver nuclei) or micrococcal nuclease (prostate nuclei) are virtually identical. Each pattern consists of a series of discrete bands representing multiples of the smallest fragment of DNA 200 +/- 20 base pairs in length. The smallest DNA fragment (monomer) accumulates during prolonged digestion of chromatin in situ until it accounts for nearly all of the DNA on the gel; approx. 20% of the DNA of chromatin is rendered acid soluble during this period. Digestion of liver chromatin in situ in the presence of micrococcal nuclease results initially in the reduction of the size of the monomer from 200 to 170 base pairs of DNA and subsequently results in its conversion to as many as eight smaller fragments. The electrophoretic pattern obtained with DNA prepared from micrococcal nuclease digests of isolated liver chromatin is similar, but not identical, to that obtained with liver chromatin in situ. These preparations are more heterogeneous and contain DNA fragments smaller than 200 base pairs in length. These results suggest that not all of the chromatin isolated from liver nuclei retains its native structure. In contrast to endogenous endonuclease and micrococcal nuclease digests of chromatin, pancreatic DNAase I digests of isolated chromatin and of chromatin in situ consist of an extremely heterogeneous population of DNA fragments which migrates as a continuum on gels. A similar electrophoretic pattern is obtained with purified DNA digested by micrococcal nuclease. The presence of spermine (0.15 mM) and spermidine (0.5 mM) in preparative and incubation buffers decreases the rate of digestion of chromatin by endogenous endonuclease in situ approx. 10-fold, without affecting the size of the resulting DNA fragments. The rates of production of the smallest DNA fragments, monomer, dimer, and trimer, are nearly identical when high molecular weight DNA is present in excess, indicating that all of the chromatin multimers are equally susceptible to endogenous endonuclease. These observations points out the effects of various experimental conditions on the digestion of chromatin by nucleases.     

The chromatin structure of specific genes: I. Evidence for higher order domains of defined DNA sequence.

When the chromatin of Drosophila is examined by digestion with DNAase I or micrococcal nuclease, no general structural organization above the level of the nucleosome is revealed by the cleavage pattern. In contrast, the DNAase I cleavage pattern of specific regions of the Drosophila chromosome shows discrete bands with sizes ranging from a few kilobase pairs (kb) to more than 20 kb. Visualization of such higher order bands was achieved by the use of the Southern blotting technique. The DNAase I-cleaved fragments were transferred onto a nitrocellulose sheet after size fractionation by gel electrophoresis. Hybridization was then carried out with radioactively labeled cloned fragments of DNA from D. melanogaster. For the five different chromosomal regions examined, each gives a unique pattern of higher order bands on the autoradiogram; the patterns are different for different regions. Restriction enzyme cleavage of the fragments generated indicates that the preferential DNAase I cleavage sites in chromatin are position-specific. The chromosomal regions bounded by preferential DNAase I cleavage sites are referred to as supranucleosomal or higher order domains for purposes of discussion and analysis. The micrococcal nuclease cleavage pattern of chromatin at specific loci was also examined. In the one case studied in detail, this nuclease also cleaves at position-specific sites.     

Variation in chromatin structure in two cell types from the same tissue: a short DNA repeat length in cerebral cortex neurons

We have used micrococcal nuclease as a probe of the repeating structure of chromatin in four nuclear populations from three tissues of the rabbit. Neuronal nuclei isolated from the cerebral cortex contain about 160 base pairs of DNA in the chromatin repeat unit, as compared with about 200 base pairs for nonastrocytic glial cell nuclei from the same tissue, neuronal nuclei from the cerebellum and liver nuclei. All four types of nuclei show the same features of nucleosomal organization as other eucaryotic nuclei so far studied: nucleosomes liberated by digestion with micrococcal nuclease give a “core particle” containing 140 base pairs as a metastable intermediate on further digestion and a series of single-strand DNA fragments which are mutiples of 10 bases after digestion with DNAase I. Nuclei from cerebral cortex neurons, which have a short repeat, are distinct from the others in being larger, in having a higher proportion of euchromatin (dispersed chromatin) as judged by microscopy and in being more active in RNA synthesis in vitro.     

Polyamine depletion is associated with altered chromatin structure in HeLa cells.

HeLa cells depleted of polyamines by treatment with alpha-difluoromethylornithine (DFMO), methylglyoxal bis(guanylhydrazone) (MGBG) or a combination of the two, were examined for sensitivity to micrococcal nuclease, DNAase I and DNAase II. The degrees of chromatin accessibility to DNAase I and II appeared enhanced somewhat in all three treatment groups, and the released digestion products differed from those in non-depleted cells. DNA released from MGBG- and DFMO/MGBG-treated cells by DNAase II digestion was enriched 4-7-fold for Mg2+-soluble species relative to controls. DNA released by micrococcal nuclease digestion from all three treatment groups was characterized as consisting of higher-order nucleosomal structure than was DNA released from untreated cells. At least some of the altered chromatin properties were abolished by a brief treatment of cells with polyamines, notably spermine. These studies provide the first demonstration in vivo of altered chromatin structure in cells treated with inhibitors of polyamine biosynthesis.     

Nucleosome cores reconstituted from poly (dA-dT) and the octamer of histones.

In this paper we describe a detailed investigation of the reconstitution of nucleosome cores from poly (dA-dT) and the octamer of histones. We also attempted the reconstitution from the copolymers poly dA.poly dT, poly dG.poly dC and poly (dG-dC). The repeat of the reconstituted chromatin fibre is discussed. The micrococcal nuclease released poly (dA-dT) core particle is found to contain a considerably narrower DNA size distribution that of the native random DNA nucleosome core (12). In addition we have succeeded in obtaining small crystals of the poly (dA-dT) nucleosome core. The DNAase I digestion pattern of the poly (dA-dT) containing nucleosome core is presented. The periodicity of DNAase I cutting sites is found to be about 10.5 bases and is similar to that of the native nucleosome core (12, 13).     

The distribution of benzo(a)pyrene DNA adducts in mammalian chromatin.

This paper describes the distribution of DNA-lesions generated by the potent carcinogen benzo(a)pyrene (BP) or its ultimate metabolic derivative 7 alpha, 8 8 beta, di-hydroxy-9 beta, 10 beta-epoxy-7,8,9,10-tetrahydrobenzo(a)pyrene (BPDE) within mammalian chromatin using the enzymic probe micrococcal nuclease. We have shown that the progress of the nuclease on naked DNA is unaffected by the presence of the hydrocarbon lesion at moderate extents of digestion. Digestion of nuclei isolated from murine erythroleukaemic cells immediately following BPDE treatment, and analysis of micrococcal nuclease resistant DNA by TCA precipitation, hydroxyapatite chromatography and gel electrophoresis demonstrates a non-random distribution of lesions. Approximately three times more binding occurs on the linker DNA regions between nucleosome cores than on the nucleosome core DNA itself. A similar result was obtained with BPDE treated primary mouse embryo cells; however nuclei isolated from these cells after prolonged treatment with BP (to allow metabolic activation) showed no such preferential binding. Post-treatment incubation of BPDE-treated cells shows that this difference can be accounted for by the loss of preferential localisation with time.     

Nucleosomal structure of sea urchin and starfish sperm chromatin. Histone H2B is possibly involved in determining the length of linker DNA.

Comparison has been made between sea urchin and starfish sperm chromatin. The only protein by which chromatins from these sources differ significantly is histone H2B. Sea urchin sperm H2B is known to contain an elongated N-terminal region enriched in Arg. Analysis of the micrococcal nuclease digests of sea urchin and starfish nuclei in one- and two-dimensional electrophoresis has shown that sperm chromatin of both animals consists of repeated units similar in general features to those of rat thymus or liver. However, DNA repeat length in chromatin of sea urchin sperm (237 bp) is higher than that of starfish sperm (224 bp), while the core DNA length does not differ and is the same as in the chromatin of rat liver or thymus. A suggestion has been made that the N-terminal region of histone H2B is associated with the linker DNA and is responsible for the increased length of sea urchin linker DNA.     

Organization of 5S genes in chromatin of Xenopus laevis.

The chromatin organization of the genes coding for 5S RNA in Xenopus laevis has been investigated with restriction endonucleases and micrococcal nuclease. Digestion of nuclei from liver, kidney, blood and kidney cells maintained in culture with micrococcal nuclease reveals that these Xenopus cells and tissues have shorter nucleosome repeat lengths than the corresponding cells and tissues from other higher organisms. 5S genes are organized in nucleosomes with repeat lengths similar to those of the bulk chromatin in liver (178 bp) and cultured cells (165 bp); however, 5S gene chromatin in blood cells has a shorter nucleosome repeat (176 bp) than the bulk of the genome in these cells (184 bp). From an analysis of the 5S DNA fragments produced by extensive restriction endonuclease cleavage of chromatin in situ, no special arrangement of the nucleosomes with respect to the sequence of 5S DNA can be detected. The relative abundance of 5S gene multimers follows a Kuhn distribution, with about 57% of all HindIII sites cleaved. This suggests that HindIII sites can be cleaved both in the nucleosome core and linker regions.     

The structural organization of mouse chromatin as a function of age.

Chromatin is organized into a repeating structure (nucleosome) made up of proteins and DNA. Micrococcal nuclease and DNAase I have been used to probe this structure in nuclear populations from three tissues (liver, brain, and heart) of the inbred mouse strain C57BL at different ages. For those parameters examined, for each tissue, chromatin contained essentially the same features of nucleosomal organization, regardless of the age of the mouse. Thus, the rate and extent of nuclease digestion and the size of the DNA repeat unit and nucleosome core are not significantly different as a function of age. However, the accessibility of internucleosomal DNA to micrococcal nuclease, as determined by measuring the DNA size distribution after nuclease cutting, may be partially limited in chromatin of brain (but not liver or heart) of older animals. These results indicate that there are no gross, age-related changes in the conformational state or organization of chromatin in these tissues. The results do not exclude smaller alterations in chromatin that might occur with age, which the current methodology might not be sensitive enough to detect.