Warming and hypoxia reduce the performance and survival of northern bay scallops (Argopecten irradians irradians) amid a fishery collapse

Warming temperatures and diminishing dissolved oxygen (DO) concentrations are among the most pervasive drivers of global coastal change. While regions of the Northwest Atlantic Ocean are experiencing greater than average warming, the combined effects of thermal and hypoxic stress on marine life in this region are poorly understood. Populations of the northern bay scallop, Argopecten irradians irradians across the northeast United States have experienced severe declines in recent decades. This study used a combination of high-resolution (~1 km) satellite-based temperature records, long-term temperature and DO records, field and laboratory experiments, and high-frequency measures of scallop cardiac activity in an ecosystem setting to quantify decadal summer warming and assess the vulnerability of northern bay scallops to thermal and hypoxic stress across their geographic distribution. From 2003 to 2020, significant summer warming (up to ~0.2°C year⁻¹) occurred across most of the bay scallop range. At a New York field site in 2020, all individuals perished during an 8-day estuarine heatwave that coincided with severe diel-cycling hypoxia. Yet at a Massachusetts site with comparable DO levels but lower daily mean temperatures, mortality was not observed. A 96-h laboratory experiment recreating observed daily temperatures of 25 or 29°C, and normoxia or hypoxia (22.2% air saturation), revealed a 120-fold increased likelihood of mortality in the 29°C-hypoxic treatment compared with control conditions, with scallop clearance rates also reduced by 97%. Cardiac activity measurements during a field deployment indicated that low DO and elevated daily temperatures modulate oxygen consumption rates and likely impact aerobic scope. Collectively, these findings suggest that concomitant thermal and hypoxic stress can have detrimental effects on scallop physiology and survival and potentially disrupt entire fisheries. Recovery of hypoxic systems may benefit vulnerable fisheries under continued warming.     

Acquisition of thermotolerance in bay scallops, Argopecten irradians irradians, via differential induction of heat shock proteins

Many cells and organisms are rendered transiently resistant to lethal heat shock by short exposure to sublethal temperatures. This induced thermotolerance is thought to be related to increased amounts of heat shock proteins (HSPs) which, as molecular chaperones, protect cells from stress-induced damage. As part of a study on bivalve stress and thermotolerance, work was undertaken to examine the effects of sublethal heat shock on stress tolerance of juveniles of the northern bay scallop, Argopecten irradians irradians, in association with changes in the levels of cytoplasmic HSP70 and 40. Juvenile bay scallops heat-shocked at a sublethal temperature of 32 °C survived an otherwise lethal heat treatment at 35 °C for at least 7 days. As determined by ELISA, acquisition of induced thermotolerance closely paralleled HSP70 accumulation, whereas HSP40 accrual appeared less closely associated with thermotolerance. Quantification of scallop HSPs following lethal heat treatment, with or without conditioning, suggested a causal role for HSP70 in stress tolerance, with HSP40 contributing to a lesser, but significant extent. Overall, this study demonstrated that sublethal heat shock promotes survival of A. irradians irradians juveniles upon thermal stress and the results support the hypothesis that HSPs have a role in this induced thermotolerance. Exploitation of the induced thermotolerance response shows promise as a means to improve survival of bay scallops in commercial culture.     

Spatio-temporal patterns in the mortality of bay scallop recruits in North Carolina: investigation of a life history anomaly

By timing reproduction to occur when predatory mortality on progeny is minimal, organisms may maximize recruitment to adult populations. Accordingly, an hypothesis to explain the greater importance of fall than spring spawning to North Carolina populations of bay scallops (Argopecten irradians) is that predatory mortality of bay scallop recruits is lower in fall and winter than spring and summer. To test this hypothesis, we measured predatory mortality of scallop recruits monthly. To infer the identities of predators that are most important in determining patterns of mortality of bay scallop recruits in spring and in fall, predatory mortality of bay scallop recruits was compared between the edge and interior of sheltered and exposed seagrass patches during the day and at night in May and November. Consideration of predatory mortality throughout the year indicated that mortality of scallop recruits over late spring and summer approaches 100% but is negligible over late fall and winter. In May, predatory mortality of scallop recruits was similar during day and night but greater at exposed than sheltered sites. In November, predatory mortality was greater during night than day and slightly greater at sheltered than exposed sites. In neither month did position within patch influence mortality, and at all times and places, missing and crushed scallops contributed a higher proportion than drilled scallops to the total dead. These spatio-temporal patterns of mortality of scallop recruits suggest that mud crabs, Dyspanopeus sayi, which are more abundant in exposed than sheltered seagrass beds during spring and can feed by day and night, are a likely major contributor to spatio-temporal pattern in mortality of scallop recruits in North Carolina. Blue crabs, Callinectes sapidus, which are many times more abundant in summer than winter, may also contribute to observed seasonal patterns in mortality. The dramatically lower rates of predation on bay scallops over the winter months appear to provide fall settlers with a temporal window of opportunity to recruit to the adult population. Although spring spawning contributes little to adult populations in most years because of high rates of predatory mortality during summer, we hypothesize that spring spawning persists because infrequent devastating perturbations, such as hurricanes and red tides, can result in complete failure of fall recruitment.     

Development of Expressed Sequence Tags from the Bay Scallop, Argopecten irradians irradians

The bay scallop, Argopecten irradians irradians, introduced from North America, has become one of the most important aquaculture species in China. Inan effort to identify scallop genes involved in host defense, a high-quality cDNA library was constructed from whole body tissues of the bay scallop. A total of 5828 successful sequencing reactions yielded 4995 expressed sequence tags (ESTs) longer than 100 bp. Cluster and assembly analyses of the ESTs identified 637 contigs (consisting of 2853 sequences) and 2142 singletons, totaling 2779 unique sequences. Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) analysis showed that the majority (73%) of the unique sequences had no significant homology (E-value ≤ 0.005) to sequences in GenBank. Among the 748 sequences with significant GenBank matches, 160 (21.4%) were for genes related to metabolism, 131 (17.5%) for cell/organism defense, 124 (16.6%) for gene/protein expression, 83 (11.1%) for cell structure/motility, 70 (9.4%) for cell signaling/communication, 17 (2.3%) for cell division, and 163 (21.8%) matched to genes of unknown functions. The list of host-defense genes included many genes with known and important roles in innate defense such as lectins, defensins, proteases, protease inhibitors, heat shock proteins, antioxidants, and Toll-like receptors. The study provides a significant number of ESTs for gene discovery and candidate genes for studying host defense in scallops and other molluscs.     

Heat shock protein responses in thermally stressed bay scallops, Argopecten irradians, and sea scallops, Placopecten magellanicus

The effects of thermal stress on the induction of heat shock proteins (HSPs) were examined in northern bay scallops, Argopecten irradians irradians, a relatively heat tolerant estuarine species, and sea scallops, Placopecten magellanicus, a species residing in cooler, deeper water. Polyclonal antibodies used in this work for analysis of inducible HSP70 and HSP40 only recognized proteins of 72 and 40 kDa respectively from the mantles of both scallop species. Additionally, HSP quantification using the antibody to HSP70 was equally effective by either immunoprobing of western blots or ELISA, demonstrating that either approach could be successfully employed for analysis of thermal response in scallops. Sea scallop HSP70 and HSP40 did not change when animals were heat-shocked for 3 h by raising the temperature from 10 °C to 20 °C; however, a 24 h treatment of the same magnitude elicited a significant response. Conversely, bay scallops displayed rapid and prolonged HSP70 and HSP40 responses during the recovery period following a 3 h heat shock from 20 °C to 30 °C. Temperature reduction from 20 °C to 3 °C for 3 h also caused significant HSP70 and HSP40 increases in bay scallops; this represents the first time cold shock was shown to induce HSP synthesis in bivalve mollusks. The onset of the HSP40 response was more rapid than for HSP70, occurring at the end of the cold shock itself prior to transfer to a recovery temperature. Both proteins responded maximally during recovery at control temperature. HSP responses of sea and bay scallops to thermal stress may be related to their habitat in the natural environment and they suggest a differential capacity for adaptation to temperature change. This is an important consideration in assessing the response of these scallops to different culture conditions.     

Genomic Characterization of Interspecific Hybrids between the Scallops Argopecten purpuratus and A. irradians irradians

The Peruvian scallop (Argopecten purpuratus) has been introduced to China and has successfully been hybridized with the bay scallop (A. irradians irradians). The F1 hybrids of these two scallops exhibited a large increase in production traits and some other interesting new characteristics. To understand the genetic basis of this heterosis, nuclear gene and partial mtDNA sequences, and genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) were employed to analyze the genomic organization of the hybrids. Amplification of the ribosomal DNA internal transcribed spacer (ITS) showed that the parental ITS sequences were present in all the hybrid individuals, illustrating that the hybrid offspring inherited nuclear DNA from both parents. Sequence analyses of the ITS region further confirmed that the hybrids harbored alleles from their parents; some recombinant variants were also detected, which revealed some alterations in the nuclear genetic material of the hybrids. The analysis of mitochondrial 16S rDNA showed that the hybrids possessed sequences that were identical to the 16S rDNA of the female parents, proving a matrilineal inheritance of mitochondrial genes in scallops. In addition, GISH clearly discriminated between the parental chromosomes and indicated a combination of haploid genomes of duplex parents in the hybrids. The genetic analyses in our study illustrated that the F1 hybrids inherited nuclear material from both parents and cytoplasmic genetic material maternally, and some variations occurred in the genome, which might contribute to a further understanding of crossbreeding and heterosis in scallop species.     

Development of an Argopecten-Specific 18S rRNA Targeted Genetic Probe

Comparison of 18S ribosomal RNA gene sequences between diverse bivalve species, including eight scallop species, allowed the design of an 18S rRNA targeted oligonucleotide probe (BS-1364) that was specific for scallops belonging to the genus Argopecten (bay and calico scallops). The high sequence similarity of the 18S rRNA gene between Argopecten irradians and Argopecten gibbus (98.8%) prevented the design of an A. irradians species-specific probe. Hybridization studies using amplified 18S rDNA from a diverse collection of bivalve species demonstrated that the specificity of the digoxygenin-labeled probe was consistent with the predicted specificity indicated by sequence comparison. Hybridization studies using laboratory-spawned bay scallop veligers indicated that a single veliger could be detected by probe hybridization in a blot format, and that probe hybridization signal was proportional (r ²= .99) to the abundance of veligers. Methods for rRNA extraction and blotting were developed that allowed bay scallop veligers to be specifically and quantitatively identified in natural plankton samples. Preliminary studies conducted in Tampa Bay, Florida, suggest that introduced scallops can successfully spawn and produce veligers under in situ conditions. The Argopecten-specific probe and methods developed in this study provide the means to study the production and fate of bay scallop larvae in nature and provide evidence that scallops introduced into Tampa Bay have the potential for successful reproduction and enhancement of scallop stocks. Received January 25, 1999; accepted May 7, 1999.     

Growth and reproduction of the bay scallop, Argopecten irradians (Lamarck) at its southern distributional limit

Growth and reproduction in a Florida population of bay scallop, Argopecten irradians (Lamarck), existing at the southern limit of its distribution, was monitored over a 3-yr period. Somatic growth accompanied increasing water temperature between May and August, when maximum mantle, digestive gland, and adductor muscle weights and indexes were observed. From July through September, reproductive development was correlated with a decline in adductor muscle weight and index. Maximum gonad weight, gonad index, and oocyte diameter were found in late September and early October. Spawning commenced at this time in conjunction with decreasing water temperature.In comparison to more northern populations, the reproductive cycle of the Florida bay scallop occurs later in the year and is characterized by a higher gametogenic initiation temperature, a decreased maximum gonad index and decreased oocyte diameter, and a shift in reproductive energy resources from digestive gland (available food) to adductor muscle (pre-stored reserves). Increased metabolic rate associated with higher temperature and coupled with decreased food supply results in the Florida bay scallop having less energy available for reproduction, ultimately limiting its southern distribution.     

A Consensus Microsatellite-Based Linkage Map for the Hermaphroditic Bay Scallop (Argopecten irradians) and Its Application in Size-Related QTL Analysis

Bay scallop (Argopecten irradians) is one of the most economically important aquaculture species in China. In this study, we constructed a consensus microsatellite-based genetic linkage map with a mapping panel containing two hybrid backcross-like families involving two subspecies of bay scallop, A. i. irradians and A. i. concentricus. One hundred sixty-one microsatellite and one phenotypic (shell color) markers were mapped to 16 linkage groups (LGs), which corresponds to the haploid chromosome number of bay scallop. The sex-specific map was 779.2 cM and 781.6 cM long in female and male, respectively, whereas the sex-averaged map spanned 849.3 cM. The average resolution of integrated map was 5.9 cM/locus and the estimated coverage was 81.3%. The proportion of distorted markers occurred more in the hybrid parents, suggesting that the segregation distortion was possibly resulted from heterospecific interaction between genomes of two subspecies of bay scallop. The overall female-to-male recombination rate was 1.13∶1 across all linked markers in common to both parents, and considerable differences in recombination also existed among different parents in both families. Four size-related traits, including shell length (SL), shell height (SH), shell width (SW) and total weight (TW) were measured for quantitative trait loci (QTL) analysis. Three significant and six suggestive QTL were detected on five LGs. Among the three significant QTL, two (qSW-10 and qTW-10, controlling SW and TW, respectively) were mapped on the same region near marker AiAD121 on LG10 and explained 20.5% and 27.7% of the phenotypic variance, while the third (qSH-7, controlling SH) was located on LG7 and accounted for 15.8% of the phenotypic variance. Six suggestive QTL were detected on four different LGs. The linkage map and size-related QTL obtained in this study may facilitate marker-assisted selection (MAS) in bay scallop.     

The effect of photoperiod on the reproductive development of the northern bay scallop, Argopecten irradians irradians

One-year-old bay scallops, Argopecten irradians irradians (58 ± 2 mm, 22 ± 1 g live weight) were exposed to four replicated photoperiod treatments (24D, 8L:16D, 16L:8D, and 24L where D = dark hours, L = light hours) in order to measure the effect on gonad weight and maturation during the conditioning process. Results indicated that day-lengths of more than 8 h are necessary to promote gonad maturation in bay scallops. After 6 wk, the mean gonad weight for scallops in the 16-h and 24-h light regimes was similar at 0.6 ± 0.1 g dry weight compared to a mean of 0.2 ± 0.1 g dry weight for those in the 8-h and 0-h light regimes. Histological assessment indicated significantly more follicular tissue development in both the male and female portion of the gonad in the two longer photoperiod treatments. Overall, gamete maturity was highest for the scallops in the 16-h light regime; the incidence of mature eggs was 50% compared to 35% in the 24-h light regime, 20% in the 8-h light regime and 10% in the 0-h light regime. Assessment of feeding rates indicated no significant difference in algal cell consumption among treatments. Total dry tissue weight doubled over the 6-wk conditioning trial with no significant differences among treatments. One-year-old bay scallops appear to be non-responsive to conditions suitable for gonad maturation (i.e. appropriate temperature and food levels) unless they receive more than 8 h of light exposure. This finding has important implications for northern hatcheries which typically condition broodstock indoors during the early spring.     

Development and Linkage Analysis of 104 New Microsatellite Markers for Bay Scallop (Argopecten irradians)

For genetic analysis and linkage mapping of bay scallop (Argopecten irradians), a set of 120 novel simple sequence repeat markers were developed from microsatellite-enriched libraries and expressed sequence tags. An inter-subspecies hybrid bay scallop family (CC5) of 46 progeny was analyzed as the reference population to confirm polymorphism and test the segregation patterns of these loci. A total of 104 microsatellite markers were polymorphic in the reference family, among which 36 in female, 28 in male, and 40 in both parents, respectively. Linkage analysis allowed mapping these markers to 15 linkage groups, which is close to the haploid chromosome number of bay scallop (n = 16). Analysis of the 40 markers segregating in both parents showed a higher recombination rate in the female parent, with the average of female-to-male recombination ratio of 1.09:1 between linked pairs of markers. When null alleles were considered, there were 17 loci showing segregation distortion at the 5% significance level using the chi-square test. The microsatellite markers developed in this study provide a useful resource for future linkage mapping and quantitative loci analysis in A. irradians.     

The role of hydrodynamics in recruitment,growth, and survival of Argopecten irradians (L.) and Anomia simplex (D'Orbigny) within eelgrass meadows

Larvae of the bay scallop Argopecten irradians (L.) and the common jingle Anomia simplex (D'Orbigny) use byssal threads to settle onto blades of eelgrass Zostera marina (L.) and other elevated substrata. A 2-yr study of the role of hydrodynamics in recruitment of these bivalves into eelgrass meadows, and in their subsequent growth and survival as juveniles, was conducted in Northwest Harbor, New York. Sea-water flux through the meadow varied significantly among sites and depended on the numerical density of eelgrass shoots. Recruitment of both bivalves varied significantly among sites in a similar manner, indicating that hydrodynamics in eelgrass meadows strongly affects bivalve recruitment. Results from experimental deployments of two types of substrata indicate that hydrodynamics in eelgrass meadows exerts a stronger influence on bivalve recruitment than does either interblade abrasion or possible differences among sites in the nature of the blade substratum. In one of the two study years, hydrodynamics in eelgrass meadows influenced growth and survival of Argopecten following settlement. Abundances and growth of Anomia following settlement appeared unaffected by hydrodynamics. Several lines of evidence suggest that predation is less important than hydrodynamics in determining abundances of recruits and early juvenile stages of these bivalves.     

Egg size and larval survival of Mercenaria mercenaria (L.) and Argopecten irradians (Lamarck)

Eggs of the hard clam, Mercenaria mercenaria (L.), and the bay scallop, Argopecten irradians (Lamarck), were graded to three size categories, split into replicates and these were replicate-sampled. A chi-square analysis compared the proportion of larvae (48-h survival) to the proportions of eggs in each initial replicate experiment. Statistically significant differences attributed to egg size were found for both species. Large eggs survived better than small eggs, while those of intermediate size showed no difference between expected and observed survival.     

Different responses to selection in two stocks of the bay scallop, Argopecten irradians irradians Lamarck (1819)

Two different stocks (A and B) of the bay scallop Argopecten irradians irradians (Lamarck, 1819) were used to test mass selection on growth. Stock A was a descending stock from the initial introduction from U.S.A. in 1982, which had been cultured in China for about 20 years. Stock B was the third generation from a recent introduction from U.S.A. in 1999. Truncation selection was conducted by selecting the largest 11% scallops in shell length from Stock A and the largest 12.7% scallops from Stock B as parents for the respective selected groups. Before the removal of parents for truncation selection, equal numbers of scallops were randomly chosen from Stock A and B to serve as parents for the control groups. Offspring from the four groups were reared under the same hatchery, nursery, and grow-out conditions. Values of response to selection and realized heritability at larvae, spat and grow-out stages for Stock B were all significantly (P<0.001) higher than its counterpart for Stock A. For Stock A, no significant response to selection was observed (P>0.05) at any stage, and the realized heritability for shell length was 0.015±0.024 for larvae, 0.040±0.027 for spat, and 0.080±0.009 for grow-out, respectively. For Stock B, however, significant (P<0.05) response to selection was observed, and the realized heritability for shell length was 0.511±0.010 for larvae, 0.341±0.022 for spat, and 0.338±0.015 for grow-out. On average, responses to selection at the three stages for Stock B was 30×, 7.1×, and 3× higher than its counterpart for Stock A, respectively. Accordingly, realized heritability at above stages for Stock B was 33×, 7.5×, and 3.2× higher than its counterpart for Stock A, respectively. Differences in response to selection and realized heritability between the two stocks are presumably due to differences in genetic variability. As the 20th generation from the initial introduction consisted of only 26 scallops, Stock A is known to be highly inbred, while inbreeding in Stock B is negligible.     

Ecological consequences of ontogenetic shifts in predator diet: Seasonal constraint of a behaviorally mediated indirect interaction

Predators play an important role in structuring assemblages through direct and cascading indirect effects. While there has been recent interest in how the strength and direction of trophic cascades vary spatially, seasonal variability in trophic links is seldom considered. In North Carolina, recruitment-failure of bay scallops typically occurs following the spring but not the fall spawning despite the presence in each of these seasons of predatory blue crabs. One explanation for this pattern is that in the fall, seasonally abundant predators of blue crabs reduce the foraging efficiency of crabs on scallops and thus the overall magnitude of top-down effects. Quantification of bay scallop consumption by blue crabs in closed mesocosms with or without pinfish supported the hypothesis that seasonally abundant adult pinfish indirectly increase survivorship of bay scallop recruits in fall by reducing predation by blue crabs. Despite voracious consumption of bay scallops during both the day and night in mesocosms to which only small blue crabs were added, blue crabs in mesocosms with visually-foraging adult pinfish consumed bay scallops only by night. Juvenile pinfish that dominate estuarine populations in spring did not impede consumption of bay scallops by blue crabs. In mesocosms from which animals could not emigrate, the addition of neither adult nor juvenile pinfish increased the mortality of blue crabs, indicating a behaviorally mediated interaction. Blue crabs restricted by adult pinfish to nocturnal feeding did not compensate for lost feeding time by increasing their night-time consumption of bay scallops. These results strongly suggest that greater survivorship of bay scallops in fall than spring is due to adult pinfish, potential predators of small blue crabs, restricting blue crab foraging to hours of dark. In spring, when pinfish are small and incapable of consuming blue crabs, blue crabs consume bay scallops by day and by night. Such seasonal variation in the number of trophic links in a system may have important evolutionary implications. By timing reproduction to occur in fall when the pinfish-crab-scallop cascade is in operation, bay scallops maximize recruitment.     

An immune responsive multidomain galectin from bay scallop Argopectens irradians

Galectins are a family of β-galactoside-binding lectins which play crucial roles in innate immunity of vertebrates and invertebrates. In the present study, the cDNA of a galectin with multiple carbohydrate-recognition domains (CRDs) was cloned from bay scallop Argopectens irradians (designated AiGal1) by expressed sequence tag (EST) and rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RACE) techniques. The full-length cDNA of AiGal1 was of 2235 nucleotides, encoding a polypeptide of 549 amino acids. SMART program analysis revealed that AiGal1 contained four galectin CRDs, and all the CRDs contained the two consensus motifs essential for ligand-binding. Quantitative real-time PCR was employed to investigate the tissue distribution of AiGal1 mRNA and temporal expression in haemocytes of scallops challenged with Vibrio anguillarum, Micrococcus luteus and Pichia pastoris. The AiGal1 mRNA could be detected in all tested tissues with the highest expression level in hepatopancreas. After challenged by V. anguillarum and M. luteus, the expression level of AiGal1 mRNA was both up-regulated and reached the maximum level at 9 h (1.52 fold, P < 0.05) and 18 h (2.89 fold, P < 0.01) post challenge, respectively. However, there was no significant difference in the mRNA expression of AiGal1 in haemocytes after P. pastoris challenge (P > 0.05). These results collectively indicated that AiGal1 was a new member of the galectin family and involved in the immune responses against bacterial infection.