Ovule morphogenesis in Ranunculaceae and its systematic significance

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Ranunculaceae has a prominent phylogenetic position in Ranunculales which appears at the base of eudicots. The aims of the present paper are to reveal the features of ovule morphogenesis in different taxa and gain a better understanding of the systematics of Ranunculaceae. METHODS: Flowers of 17 species from three subfamilies, nine tribes and 16 genera of Ranunculaceae, at successive developmental stages, were collected in the wild and studied with a scanning electron microscope. KEY RESULTS: The integuments in the unitegmic ovules in Helleborus, Ranunculus and Oxygraphis, as well as the inner integuments in the bitegmic genera, initiate annularly and eventually become cup-shaped. However, the integuments in the unitegmic ovules in Anemone and Clematis, as well as the outer integuments in the bitegmic genera, arise semi-annularly and eventually become hood-shaped. Different kinds of appendages appear on the ovules during development. In Coptis of subfamily Coptidoideae, a wrap-shaped appendage arises outside the ovule and envelopes the ovule entirely. In the genera of subfamily Thalictroideae and tribe Anemoneae of subfamily Ranunculoideae, appendages appear on the placenta, the funicle or both. In tribe Helleboreae of subfamily Ranunculoideae, an alary appendage is initiated where the integument and the funicle join and becomes hood-shaped. CONCLUSIONS: Ovule morphogenesis characteristics are significant in classification at the levels of subfamilies and tribes. The initiation patterns of the integuments and the development of appendages show diversity in Ranunculaceae. The present observations suggest that the bitegmic, hood-shaped outer integument and endostomic micropyle are primitive while the unitegmic, cupular-shaped outer integument and bistomic micropyle are derivative.     

Ovule morphogenesis and structure in Menispermaceae,focusing on the development of the single fertile ovule and its systematic significance

Menispermaceae is one of the core groups of Ranunculales. The single fertile ovule in each ovary in Menispermaceae varies greatly in integument number, micropyle formation, and integument lobe. However, data regarding ovule morphogenesis in the family are very limited. In this study, we document ovule development of selected species in the Menispermaceae using scanning electron microscopy and light microscopy. Ovule development in Menispermaceae shows the following characteristics. Two ovules are initiated in a young carpel, one of them degenerates gradually and the other develops into a fertile ovule in subsequent stages. Bitegmic in Sinomenium Diels. and Cocculus DC. and unitegmic in Stephania Lour. The formation of unitegmy is probably due to integumentary shifting. The annularly initiated inner integument is of dermal origin and has 2–3 cell layers in the family, but the semi-annularly initiated outer integument is of both dermal and subdermal origin. Both inner and outer integument are cup-shaped at maturity. The cup-shaped outer integument is formed due to the outer integument's extension to the concave (adaxial) side of the funiculus. The obturator is well developed and consists of 2–3 cell layers in Cocculus or 9–11 cell layers in Stephania. Ovule development of Menispermaceae suggests some common characteristics between Cocculus and Sinomenium, and derived unitegmy supports molecular data that indicate Stephania is one of the late-diverging lineages in the family. Integument lobations are present. The sterile ovule shows variations in the degeneration process. These results will provide evidence for exploring the evolution of ovules in Ranunculales.     

Expression of ovule and integument‐associated genes in reduced ovules of Santalales

SUMMARY Santalales comprise mainly parasitic plants including mistletoes and sandalwoods. Bitegmic ovules similar to those found in most other angiosperms are seen in many members of the order, but other members exhibit evolutionary reductions to the unitegmic and ategmic conditions. In some mistletoes, extreme reduction has resulted in the absence of emergent ovules such that embryo sacs appear to remain embedded in placental tissues. Three santalalean representatives (Comandra, Santalum, and Phoradendron), displaying unitegmic, and ategmic ovules, were studied. Observed ovule morphologies were consistent with published reports, including Phoradendron serotinum, which we interpret as having reduced ategmic ovules, consistent with earlier reports on this species. For further understanding of the nature of the ovule reductions we isolated orthologs of the Arabidopsis genes AINTEGUMENTA (ANT) and BELL1 (BEL1), which are associated with ovule development in this species. We observed ovular expression of ANT and BEL1 in patterns largely resembling those seen in the integumented ovules of Arabidopsis. These genes were found to be expressed in the integument of unitegmic ovules and in the surface layers of ategmic ovules, and in some cases, expression of BEL1 was also observed in the surrounding carpel tissue. We hypothesize that ategmic ovules derive from a fusion of the integuments with the nucellus or that the nucellus has taken on some of the characteristics confined to integuments in ancestral species.     

Morphological and ontogenetic studies on southern African podocarps. Initiation of the seed scale complex and early development of integument, nucellus and epimatium

STOFFBERG, E., 1991. Morphological and ontogenetic studies on southern African podocarps. Initiation of the seed scale complex and early development of integument, nucellus and epimatium. The primordium of the seed scale complex (ssc) (ovule with epimatium) is initiated in the axil of the first or second cone bracts (prophylls) as a dome shaped structure consisting of a group of uniform, meristematic cells. A distinct protodermal layer develops. The nucellus is a dome on the ventral side of the ssc primordium. In the species of section Podocarpus the integument is initiated as a circular ridge around the nucellus, while in P.falcatus two protrusions on the anterior and posterior sides of the nucellus are the first indications of integumentary differentiation. The integument of all species studied is of subdermal origin. The epimatium (sensu stricto) is initiated after the integument, is of subdermal origin and forms a hood around the developing ovule. Considering research results, together with related literature, it is concluded that the integument of gymnosperms may be homologous with the outer integument of a bitegmic angiospermous ovule, that the position of integumentary initiation may be specific for certain taxa and that there seems to be no constant sequence of emergence of ovular envelopes in gymnosperms.     

Interactions among Genes Regulating Ovule Development in Arabidopsis Thaliana

The INNER NO OUTER (INO) and AINTEGUMENTA (ANT) genes are essential for ovule integument development in Arabidopsis thaliana. Ovules of ino mutants initiate two integument primordia, but the outer integument primordium forms on the opposite side of the ovule from the normal location and undergoes no further development. The inner integument appears to develop normally, resulting in erect, unitegmic ovules that resemble those of gymnosperms. ino plants are partially fertile and produce seeds with altered surface topography, demonstrating a lineage dependence in development of the testa. ant mutations affect initiation of both integuments. The strongest of five new ant alleles we have isolated produces ovules that lack integuments and fail to complete megasporogenesis. ant mutations also affect flower development, resulting in narrow petals and the absence of one or both lateral stamens. Characterization of double mutants between ant, ino and other mutations affecting ovule development has enabled the construction of a model for genetic control of ovule development. This model proposes parallel independent regulatory pathways for a number of aspects of this process, a dependence on the presence of an inner integument for development of the embryo sac, and the existence of additional genes regulating ovule development.     

Integument initiation and testa development in some Cruciferae

This study has shown for the first time that the middle layer (or layers) of the outer integument is (are) of subdermal derivation in at least some taxa of the Cruciferae. The outer integument is initiated in the Cruciferae in three different ways, viz. subdermally (Brassica, Sinapis) , partly subdermally and partly dermally (Lunaria) , or completely dermally (Capsella). These differences in initiation are reflected in the structure of the mature testa. The inner integument is completely of dermal derivation and originally two cell-layers thick, but may become more than two-layered during the ovule and seed maturation by periclinal divisions of the inner cell layer. The consequences of the ontogeny of the integuments for the terminology and interpretation of the mature testa is discussed.     

Anatomy and ontogeny of Pterodon emarginatus (Fabaceae: Faboideae) seed.

The aim of this study was to describe the anatomy and ontogeny of Pterodon emarginatus seed using the usual techniques. The ovules are campilotropous, crassinucelate, and bitegmic. The following processes occur during integument development: anticlinal divisions and phenolic compound accumulations in the exotesta, whose cells become palisade; predominantly periclinal divisions and cell expansion in the mesotesta, where the rapheal bundle differentiates; differentiation of the hourglass-cell layer adjacent to the palisade; fusion of outer and inner integuments, which remain individualized structures only at the micropylar end; and intense pectin impregnation in the mesotesta thicker walls with lignification restricted to the xylem. At the hilar pole, the Faboideae seed characteristic structure develops, with double palisade layer, subhilar parenchyma, and tracheid bar. The younger nucellus shows thicker pectic cell walls and is consumed during seed formation. The endosperm is nuclear and, after cellularization, shows peripheral cells with dense lipid content; the seeds are albuminous. The axial embryo shows fleshy cotyledons, which accumulate lipid and protein reserves; starch is rare. Although the seed structure is characteristic of the Fabaceae, the inner integument coalesces into the outer integument without being reabsorbed.     

Development of ovule,fruit and seed of Xyris (Xyridaceae,Poales) and taxonomic considerations

The development of the ovule, fruit and seed of Xyris spp. was studied to assess the embryological characteristics of potential taxonomic usefulness. All of the studied species have (1) orthotropous, bitegmic and tenuinucellate ovules, with a micropyle formed by both the endostoma and exostoma; (2) a cuticle in the ovules and seeds between the nucellus/endosperm and the inner integument and between the inner and outer integuments; (3) helobial, starchy endosperm; (4) a reduced, campanulate and undifferentiated embryo; (5) a seed coat formed by a tanniferous endotegmen, endotesta with thick‐walled cells and exotesta with thin‐walled cells; and (6) a micropylar operculum formed from inner and outer integuments. The pericarp is composed of a mesocarp with cells containing starch grains and an endocarp and exocarp formed by cells with U‐shaped thickened walls. The studied species differ in the embryo sac development, which can be of the Polygonum or Allium type, and in the pericarp, which can have larger cells in either endocarp or exocarp. The Allium‐type embryo sac development was observed only in Xyris spp. within Xyridaceae. Xyris also differs from the other genera of Xyridaceae by the presence of orthotropous ovules and a seed coat formed by endotegmen, endotesta and exotesta, in agreement with the division of the family into Xyridoideae and Abolbodoideae. © 2015 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2015, 177 , 619–628.     

Embryology of theaceae — Anther and ovule development ofAdinandra,Cleyera andEurya

Anther and ovule development of the theaceous Ternstroemioideae is reported for the first time on the basis of eight specles of three generaAdinandra, Cleyera andEurya. Anthers of these three genera are similar and can be characterized by the following traits: tapetum of glandular type, anther dehiscing latrorse-introrse, both connective and anther epidermis heavily tanniniferous, and connective and even anther wall layers having abundant druses. Their ovules are also very similar in being bitegmic and tenuinucellate, and in having a micropyle formed by the inner integument only, three cell-layered integuments, a raphe bundle terminating at chalaza, usually amphitropous or less often campylotropous ovule, embryo sac formation of Polygonum type, ephemeral antipodal cells, and tanniniferous ovule epidermis. Such ovules are readily distinguishable from those of Camellioideae and all other families. It is suggested that the three genera studied are closely related, and that the degree of embryological specialization is highest inAdinandra and lowest inEurya. On the basis of the significant embryological discrepacies, the Ternstroemioideae seem to have diverged rather distantly from the other core-subfamily Camellioideae of the Theaceae.     

Development of the ovule and seed in Costus cuspidatus (N.E.Br.) Maas (Zingiberaceae), with special reference to the formation of the operculum

The ovule primordium of Costus is trizonate and both its integuments are dermally initiated. With other evidence, this strongly suggests that most, if not all, monocotyledons have dermally initiated integuments, indicating a derived status. The mature seed coat of Costus is completely formed by the outer integument and its principal mechanical layer is the endotesta.
The seed of Costus has an aril, an operculum and a micropylar collar. These structures, characteristic of zingiberalean seeds, are each initiated in a different, specific cell layer of the exostome. The aril is completely dermally initiated. The parenchymatic part of the operculum and the micropylar collar are of dual origin, namely dermal at me integumentary region and subdermal at the raphe.     

Embryology of Siparunaceae (Laurales): characteristics and character evolution

Embryological characters of Siparunaceae, which are poorly understood, were studied on the basis of two constituent genera, an African Glossocalyx and a South American Siparuna, to better understand their evolution within Laurales. These two genera have many embryological characteristics in common with the other lauralean families. Noticeably, they share the multi-celled ovule archesporium (uncertain in Glossocalyx) as a synapomorphy with all the other lauralean families except Lauraceae, the anthers dehisced by valves as a synspomorphy with all the other lauralean families except Calycanthaceae and Monimiaceae, and the bisporangiate anther as a synapomorphy with Gomortegaceae and Atherospermataceae. Siparunaceae are, however, distinct from all other laularean families in having unitegmic ovules that were derived from bitegmic ovules, probably due to an elimination of the outer integument. Likewise, the lack of the testa (i.e., developed outer integument), the "endotegmic" seed coat, and the perichalazal seed at maturity are also characteristics of Siparunaceae. Within the family, Siparuna differs from Glossocalyx in having plural tetrads of megaspores and plural, starchy-rich, one-nucleate, tubular embryo sacs (autapomorphies). On the other hand, Glossocalyx is characterized by having bilaterally flattened seeds (autapomorphy). Although functional aspects of those autapomorphies are uncertain, both Glossocalyx and Siparuna show evolution in different embryological characters.     

Gametophytes,embryogeny and pericarp ofMicrostylis wallichii lindl. (Orchidaceae)

The anther wall is 4-layered thick. Its development is of the Monocotyledonous type. Simultaneous cytokinesis results in decussate, isobilateral, linear and tetrahedral tetrads. At anthesis, the microspores are 2-celled. The mature ovules are anatropous, bitegmic and tenuinucellate. Both the integuments are dermal in origin and 2-layered. The inner integument alone forms the micropyle. Development of the female gametophyte is of the Monosporic type. Double fertilization occurs but the primary endosperm nucleus degenerates without any division. Development of embryo corresponds to the variation of the Onagrad type. The mature embryo lacks differentiation. The seeds are minute and non-endospermic. The seed coat is formed entirely by the outer layer of outer integument. There are three sterile and three fertile valves in the ovary. In the prefertilization stages valves consist of parenchymatous cells. After fertilization, the sterile valves become sclerenchymatous whereas the fertile valves remain parenchymatous.     

FURTHER CYTOLOGICAL STUDIES OF A PERIODIC ACID-SCHIFF'S SUBSTANCE IN THE OVULES OF PASPALUM ORBICULARE AND P. LONGIFOLIUM

A periodic acid-Schiff's substance present in the micropylar end of the ovules of Paspalum orbiculare and P. longifolium was further studied by light and electron microscopy of glutaraldehyde-osmium-fixed and freeze-substituted, osmium-fixed tissues. The PAS substance is water soluble and is found in intercellular spaces between the nucellus and inner integument, the inner and outer integuments, the outer integument and ovary wall, and in the micropyle. Structurally the substance consists of fibrils embedded in a dense, amorphous matrix and may be associated with membranous structures in special layers between the plasmalemma and the cell wall in nucellar and integumentary cells. Part of the water soluble substance is believed to be secreted from the nucellar and integumentary cells. A large amount of this substance may be formed as a result of the dissolution of about one third of the distal micopylar portion of the outer integument prior to anthesis. Many of the electron-dense fibrils seem to be fibrillar intercellular substances and others appear to originate from the cell walls, including the cuticle. Both the matrix and the fibrils may be chemically heterogeneous and together form a mucilagenous substance which may facilitate the final growth of pollen tubes in these two species.     

Studies in the embryology of the diandrous orchidCypripedium cordigerum (Cypripedieae,Orchidaceae)

The anther wall layers ofCypripedium cordigerum are six to eight. The glandular tapetum is 2- or 3-layered and its cells are uninucleate. Simultaneous cytokinesis results in decussate, isobilateral and tetrahedral pollen tetrads. Ripe pollen grains are 2-celled. The mature ovules are anatropous, bitegmic and tenuinucellate. Both the integuments are dermal in origin and 2-layered. The inner integument alone forms the micropyle. The female gametophyte is 6-nucleate and bisporic. The reduction of nuclei is due to the strike phenomenon. Double fertilization occurs. The primary endosperm nucleus divides to form two free endosperm nuclei. The mature embryo is undifferentiated. The cells ca, m and n contribute to the embryo. The suspensor is single-celled. The seed coat is formed entirely by the outer layer of the outer integument. There are three sterile and three fertile valves in the ovary. In the prefertilization stages these valves consist of parenchymatous cells with starch and raphides. After fertilization, the sterile valves develop sclerotic cells whereas the fertile valves remain parenchymatous. The pericarp structure and embryological features support the retention of tribeCypripedieae within theOrchidaceae.     

Ovule and gametophyte development in Nicotiana glauca Graham (Solanaceae)

Abstract

The development of ovule and megagametophyte is examined in Nicotiana glauca, using light microscopy. The ovules proved unitegmic, tenuinucellate and endothelial as in all the Solanaceae so far studied. The ovule primordia are of the three-zonate type. The integument, which is of dermal origin, is at first two-layered but later produces additional intermediate cells whose origin is not constant. The nucellus, whose initial curvature bears no relation to the origin of the integument, has, like other Solanaceae, a one or two-celled archesporium from which a single meiocyte develops. The gametophyte is confirmed to be bisporic in origin and its development follows the Allium type. Furthermore, the hypostase, which is rare in the family, is observed below the antipodal cells.     

Comparative structure of ovules and seeds inRafflesiaceae

The genera of theRafflesiaceae show a marked diversity in the structure of their ovules and seeds. Evolutionary trends are recognizable in ovule orientation and number of integuments. A change from anatropous ovules inApodantheae andMitrastemoideae towards incomplete anatropy inRafflesieae and orthotropy inCytineae occurs, next to a change from bitegmic ovules inApodantheae towards unitegmy with rudimentary outer integuments inRafflesieae andCytineae and full unitegmy inMitrastemoideae.—The differences in ovule structure are clearly reflected in the seeds. The seeds are essentially exotegmic, have very small embryos and an oily endosperm.—Seed structure strongly confirms the existing subfamilial classification and supports additional arguments for the generic status ofApodanthes. It does not support a separate status of the genusBerlinianche. InRafflesiaceae, seed micromorphology is only of limited use at the species level. As far as known seed dispersal is endo- or exozoochorous in all genera.     

Embryological studies inGlaucidium palmatum Sieb. et Zucc. with a discussion on the taxonomy of the genus

Embryological features ofGlaucidium palmatum are as follows: the ovule is anatropous and bitegmic; the archesporium is hypodermal and multicelled, consisting of about 10 to 15 cells; all the archesporial, cells develop directly into megaspore mother cells, only three or four of which, however, generally complete meiotic divisions; before and during meiosis, dermal cells of the nucellar apical part undergo successive periclinal divisions forming a thick nucellar cap of as many as 20 cell-layers; embryo sac formation is of the Polygonum type; multiple embryo sacs occur frequently; antipodal cells are small in size and ephemeral or persistent; the inner integument is 3 to 5 cell-layers thick, and the outer integument 7 to 13 cell-layers thick; the outer integument is vascularized; a micropyle is formed by the inner integument alone; the endosperm is of the Nuclear type; embryogeny is of a type similar to the Onagrad type. In light of evidence from embryology and other sources it seems that there is ample reason for recognizing the family Glaucidiaceae which is distinct from the Ranunculaceae and its related families. Several common embryological features suggest an affinity between the Glaucidiaceae and the Paeoniaceae.     

Ovules and seeds in Acalyphoideae (Euphorbiaceae): structure and systematic implications

Acalyphoideae, the largest subfamily of Euphorbiaceae, are investigated with respect to ovule and seed structure on the basis of 172 species of 80 genera in all 20 tribes of Acalyphoideae sensu Webster. All species of Acalyphoideae examined have bitegmic ovules with a non-vascularized inner integument. However, noticeable differences exist among and sometimes within the genera in the thickness of the inner and outer integument, the presence or absence of vascular bundles in the outer integument, whether ovules are pachychalazal or not, the presence or absence of an aril, seed coat structure (in terms of the best-developed mechanical cell-layer), and the shape of cells constituting the exotegmen. For the latter two characters, two different types of seed coat (i.e., "exotegmic" and "exotestal") and three different types of exotegmic cell (i.e., palisadal, tracheoidal and ribbon-like) were distinguished. Comparisons showed that three tribes Clutieae, Chaetocarpeae and Pereae are distinct from the other Acalyphoideae as well as from the other Euphorbiaceae in having an exotestal seed coat with a tracheoidal exotegmen. The tribe Dicoelieae is also distinct from the other Acalyphoideae in having an exotegmic seed that is composed of ribbon-like cells of exotegmen (i.e., cells both longitudinally and radially elongated, sclerotic and pitted). The tribe Galearieae, which should be treated as a distinct family Pandaceae, is also distinct from the other Acalyphoideae in having an exotegmic seed with a tracheoidal exotegmen (i.e., cells longitudinally elongated, sclerotic and pitted). The remaining genera of Acalyphoideae always have an exotegmic seed with a palisadal exotegmen (i.e., cells radially elongated, sclerotic and pitted). The shared palisadal exotegmen supports the close affinity of Acalyphoideae (excluding five tribes) with Crotonoideae and Euphorbioideae. Within the remaining genera of Acalyphoideae, a significant diversity is found in ovule and seed morphology with respect to the thickness of the inner and outer integument, the size of chalaza, vascularization of an outer integument and an aril.     

Anatomy of ovary and ovule in dandelions (Taraxacum, Asteraceae)

The genus Taraxacum Wigg. (Asteraceae) forms a polyploid complex within which there are strong links between the ploidy level and the mode of reproduction. Diploids are obligate sexual, whereas polyploids are usually apomictic. The paper reports on a comparative study of the ovary and especially the ovule anatomy in the diploid dandelion T. linearisquameum and the triploid T. gentile. Observations with light and electron microscopy revealed no essential differences in the anatomy of both the ovary and ovule in the examined species. Dandelion ovules are anatropous, unitegmic and tenuinucellate. In both sexual and apomictic species, a zonal differentiation of the integument is characteristic of the ovule. In the integumentary layers situated next to the endothelium, the cell walls are extremely thick and PAS positive. Data obtained from TEM indicate that these special walls have an open spongy structure and their cytoplasm shows evidence of gradual degeneration. Increased deposition of wall material in the integumentary cells surrounding the endothelium takes place especially around the chalazal pole of the embryo sac as well as around the central cell. In contrast, the integumentary cells surrounding the micropylar region have thin walls and exhibit a high metabolic activity. The role of the thick-walled integumentary layers in the dandelion ovule is discussed. We also consider whether this may be a feature of taxonomic importance.     

Ovule,fruit and seed development in Abolboda (Xyridaceae,Poales): implications for taxonomy and phylogeny

Xyridaceae belongs to the xyrid clade of Poales, but the phylogenetic position of the xyrid families is only weakly supported. Xyridaceae is divided into two subfamilies and five genera, the relationships of which remain unclear. The development of the ovule, fruit and seed of Abolboda spp. was studied to identify characteristics of taxonomic and phylogenetic value. All of the studied species share anatropous, tenuinucellate and bitegmic ovules with a micropyle formed by the inner and outer integuments, megagametophyte development of the Polygonum type, seeds with a tanniferous hypostase, a helobial and starchy endosperm and an undifferentiated embryo, seed coat derived from both integuments with a tanniferous tegmen and a micropylar operculum, and fruits with a parenchymatous endocarp and mesocarp and a sclerenchymatous exocarp. Most of the ovule and seed characteristics described for Abolboda are also present in Xyris and may represent a pattern for the family. Abolboda is distinguished by the ovule type, endosperm formation and the number of layers in the seed coat, in agreement with its classification in Abolbodoideae. The following characteristics link Xyridaceae to Eriocaulaceae and Mayacaceae, supporting the xyrid clade: tenuinucellate, bitegmic ovules; seeds with a tanniferous hypostase, a starchy endosperm and an undifferentiated embryo; and a seed coat with a tanniferous tegmen. A micropylar operculum in the seeds of Abolboda is described for the first time here and may represent a synapomorphy for the xyrids. © 2014 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2014, 175 , 144–154.