In vitro assembly of 30S and 70S bacterial ribosomes from 16S RNA containing single base substitutions, insertions, and deletions around the decoding site (C1400)

An in vitro system developed for the site-specific mutagenesis of 16S RNA of Escherichia coli ribosomes [Krzyzosiak et al. (1987) Biochemistry 26, 2353-2364] was used to make 10 single base changes around C1400, a residue known to be at the decoding site. C1400 was replaced by U, A, or G, five single base deletions at and to either side of C1400 were made, and C or U was inserted next to C1400. Another mutant possessed seven additional nucleotides at the 3' end of the 16S RNA such that a stem and loop involving the anti-Shine-Dalgarno sequence could form. Each of the mutant RNAs was reconstituted with a complete mixture of 30S proteins to yield 30S ribosomes. Modified in vitro reconstitution conditions were required to obtain assembly of all of the synthetic ribosomes. Quantitative HPLC analysis of the protein content of each mutant showed that all of the proteins were present. The ability of synthetic 30S to form 70S particles under functional assay conditions was about 75% that of natural 30S and was unchanged by any of the mutations except for the deletion of G1401, which decreased the association activity under the standard conditions to 35-40% of synthetic 30S. That part of the ribosomal P site which interacts with the anticodon loop of tRNA was investigated by near-UV (greater than 300 nm) induced cross-linking of AcVal-tRNA. Cross-linking depended on both 30S subunits and the correct codon. The cross-linking yield of all mutants with a pyrimidine at position 1400 was equal to control isolated 30S, and the first-order rate constants for cross-linking of those mutants tested were like reconstituted natural 30S. The site of cross-linking for mutants with a C or U insertion between C1400 and G1401 was shifted to the inserted residue. Cross-linking to the base 5' to G1401 rather than to the residue 3' to C1399 indicates that G1401 is an important structural determinant of the P site.     

A cyanogen bromide fragment of S4 that specifically rebinds 16S RNA.

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S4 was subjected to cyanogen bromide cleavage and was found to generate a complete cleavage product capable of rebinding 16S rRNA. This fragment, consisting of residues 1-103, was found to bind with an apparent association constant of 11 microM-1. This fragment was used in place of S4 in an in vitro reconstitution experiment. Although the particles formed had a protein composition not significantly different from reconstituted 30S ribosomal subunits, their sedimentation behavior was more like that of particles reconstituted without S4. These results indicate to us that, although residues 104-203 of S4 are involved in the assembly of the 30S ribosome, they are not necessary for the binding of S4 to 16S RNA. Taken with previous results, the domain of S4 involved in specific binding of 16S RNA can be confined to residues 47-103.     

Direct localization of the tRNA--anticodon interaction site on the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunit by electron microscopy and computerized image averaging

Previous immunoelectron microscopy studies have shown that the anticodon of valyl-tRNA, photocrosslinked to the ribosomal P site at the C1400 residue of the 16 S RNA, is located in the vicinity of the cleft of the small ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli. In this study we used single-particle image-averaging techniques to demonstrate that the 30 S-bound tRNA molecule can be localized directly, without the need for specific antibody markers. In agreement with the immunoelectron microscopy results, we find that the tRNA molecule appears to be located deep in the cleft of the 30 S subunit. We believe that the use of computer image averaging to localize ligands bound to ribosomes and other macromolecular complexes will become widespread because of the superior sensitivity, precision and objectivity of this technique compared with conventional immunoelectron microscopy.     

On the role of protein S4 N-terminal residues 1 through 30 in 30S ribosome function.

30S ribosomal protein S4 contains a single cysteine residue at position 31. We have selectively cleaved the peptide bond adjacent to this residue using the reagent 2-nitro-5-thiocyanobenzoic acid. The two resultant fragments were purified. The smaller S4-fragment (1-30) was found to be incapable of interacting with 16S RNA directly. This fragment also is not incorporated into a particle reconstituted from 16S RNA and 20 purified proteins with S4 missing. In contrast, the large S4-fragment (31-203) appears to be fully functional in ribosome assembly. Replacement of S4 with this fragment in the reconstitution reaction leads to a complete 30S ribosome containing all 30S proteins. This particle has a full capacity to bind poly U but has lost all activity for poly U directed phe-tRNA binding. We therefore propose that the N-terminus of protein S4 is not critical for ribosome assembly but is essential for tRNA binding.     

Interaction of proteins S16, S17 and S20 with 16 S ribosomal RNA

We have used rapid chemical probing methods to examine the effect of assembly of ribosomal proteins S16, S17 and S20 on the reactivity of individual residues of 16 S rRNA. Protein S17 strongly protects a compact region of the RNA between positions 245 and 281, a site previously assigned to binding of S20. Protein S20 also protects many of these same positions, albeit more weakly than S17. Strong S20-dependent protections are seen elsewhere in the 5' domain, most notably at positions 108, and in the 160-200 and 330 loop regions. Enenpectedly, S20 also causes protection of several bases in the 1430-1450 region, in the 3' minor domain. In the presence of the primary binding proteins S4, S8 and S20, we observe a variety of effects that result from assembly of the secondary binding protein S16. Most strongly protected are nucleotides around positions 50, 120, 300 to 330 and 360 in the 5' domain, and positions 606 to 630 in the central domain. In addition, numerous nucleotides in the 5' and central domains exhibit enhanced reactivity in response to S16. Interestingly, the strength of the S20-dependent effects in the 1430-1450 region is attenuated in the presence of S4 + S8 + S20, and restored in the presence of S4 + S8 + S20 + S16. Finally, the previously observed rearrangement of the 300 region stem-loop that occurs during assembly is shown to be an S16-dependent event. We discuss these findings with respect to assignment of RNA binding sites for these proteins, and in regard to the co-operativity of ribosome assembly.     

Binding of tRNA alters the chemical accessibility of nucleotides within the large ribosomal RNAs of E. coli ribosomes.

Functionally active 70S ribosomes were chemically modified with dimethylsulfate (DMS) in the presence and absence of bound tRNA. The ribosomal 16S RNA and 23S RNA were extracted, separated and labeled radioactively at their 3'-ends. DMS modification sites within the last 200 nucleotides from the 3'-ends were investigated on sequencing gels, after borohydride reduction and aniline catalyzed strand scission of the isolated RNA's. tRNA binding caused enhanced reactivity at 9 nucleotide positions while three sites showed decreased reactivity in the 16S RNA. The effects of bound tRNA on the modification of 23S RNA were limited. Only one enhancement was observed in the presence of bound tRNA. mRNA binding alone showed two more sites with enhanced reactivity, however. The results are consistent with the view that the sequence 1400-1500 of the 16S RNA plays an important functional role in the translating ribosome and possibly constitutes part of the tRNA binding site.     

Structural aspects of RbfA action during small ribosomal subunit assembly

Ribosome binding factor A (RbfA) is a bacterial cold shock response protein, required for an efficient processing of the 5' end of the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) during assembly of the small (30S) ribosomal subunit. Here we present a crystal structure of Thermus thermophilus (Tth) RbfA and a three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopic (EM) map of the Tth 30S*RbfA complex. RbfA binds to the 30S subunit in a position overlapping the binding sites of the A and P site tRNAs, and RbfA's functionally important C terminus extends toward the 5' end of the 16S rRNA. In the presence of RbfA, a portion of the 16S rRNA encompassing helix 44, which is known to be directly involved in mRNA decoding and tRNA binding, is displaced. These results shed light on the role played by RbfA during maturation of the 30S subunit, and also indicate how RbfA provides cells with a translational advantage under conditions of cold shock.     

Initiation factor 3-induced structural changes in the 30 S ribosomal subunit and in complexes containing tRNA(f)(Met) and mRNA

Initiation factor 3 (IF3) acts to switch the decoding preference of the small ribosomal subunit from elongator to initiator tRNA. The effects of IF3 on the 30 S ribosomal subunit and on the 30 S.mRNA. tRNA(f)(Met) complex were determined by UV-induced RNA crosslinking. Three intramolecular crosslinks in the 16 S rRNA (of the 14 that were monitored by gel electrophoresis) are affected by IF3. These are the crosslinks between C1402 and C1501 within the decoding region, between C967xC1400 joining the end loop of a helix of 16 S rRNA domain III and the decoding region, and between U793 and G1517 joining the 790 end loop of 16 S rRNA domain II and the end loop of the terminal helix. These changes occur even in the 30 S.IF3 complex, indicating they are not mediated through tRNA(f)(Met) or mRNA. UV-induced crosslinks occur between 16 S rRNA position C1400 and tRNA(f)(Met) position U34, in tRNA(f)(Met) the nucleotide adjacent to the 5' anticodon nucleotide, and between 16 S rRNA position C1397 and the mRNA at positions +9 and +10 (where A of the initiator AUG codon is +1). The presence of IF3 reduces both of these crosslinks by twofold and fourfold, respectively. The binding site for IF3 involves the 790 region, some other parts of the 16 S rRNA domain II and the terminal stem/loop region. These are located in the front bottom part of the platform structure in the 30 S subunit, a short distance from the decoding region. The changes that occur in the decoding region, even in the absence of mRNA and tRNA, may be induced by IF3 from a short distance or could be caused by the second IF3 structural domain.     

Comparison of ribosomal entry and acceptor transfer ribonucleic acid binding sites on Escherichia coli 70S ribosomes. Fluorescence energy transfer measurements from Phe-tRNAPhe to the 3' end of 16S ribonucleic acid

Distances were measured by nonradiative energy transfer from fluorescent probes specifically located on one of three points of yeast or Escherichia coli Phe-tRNAPhe enzymatically bound to the entry site or to the acceptor site of E. coli 70S ribosomes to energy-accepting probes on the 3' end of the 16S ribonucleic acid (RNA) of the 30S subunit. The Y base in the anticodon loop of yeast tRNAPhe was replaced by proflavin. Fluorescein isothiocyanate was attached to the X base (position 47) of E. coli tRNAPhe. E. coli tRNAPhe which had been photochemically cross-linked between positions 8 and 13 followed by chemical reduction to form a fluorescent probe was also used. Labeled tRNAs were aminoacylated and enzymatically bound to the ribosome in the presence of elongation factor Tu and guanosine 5'-triphosphate (acceptor-site binding) or a nonhydrolyzable analogue (entry-site binding). Nonradiative energy transfer measurements were made of the distances between fluorophores located on the Phe-tRNA and the fluorophore at the 3' end of 16S RNA. Calculations were based on comparison of the fluorescence lifetime of the energy donor, located on the Phe-tRNA, in the absence and presence of an energy acceptor on the 3' end of the 16S RNA. Under both sets of binding conditions, the distances to the 3' end of 16S RNA were found to be the following: cross-linked tRNA, greater than 69 A; Y base of tRNA, greater than 61 A. The distance between the 3' end of 16S RNA and the X base of tRNA was found to be 81 A under acceptor-site binding conditions but greater than 86 A under entry-site binding conditions.     

Further evidence for the participation of proteins S 3, S 14 and S 19 in tRNA binding to E. coli 30 S subunits

Previous studies have shown that iodination of 30 S subunits causes inactivation for both enzymatic fMet-tRNA and non-enzymatic phe-tRNA binding activities. This inactivation was shown to be due to the modification of three to five ribosomal proteins [1]. In this report the role of these proteins in tRNA binding activity has been further studied. Purified ribosomal proteins, isolated from modified subunits, are re-assembled into otherwise unmodified 30 S ribosomes and assayed for tRNA binding capacity. The presence of modified S 3, S 14 and S 19 (S 15) in the reconstituted particle results in substantial reduction of both fMet-tRNA and phe-tRNA binding activities. This reduction in tRNA binding activity does not appear to be due to an assembly defect.     

Identification of proteins functionally altered by chemical modification of the transfer RNA and polyuridylic acid binding sites of 30 S ribosomal subunits

Previous studies have shown that Rose Bengal-sensitized photo-oxidation of 30 S ribosomal subunits causes inactivation of tRNA binding and partial loss of poly(U) binding activities (Noller et al., 1971). The present studies, reconstitution of 30 S subunits from 16 S RNA, total protein from modified subunits, and purified proteins from untreated subunits, show that proteins S2 and S3 together completely restore these activities to the reconstituted subunits. The modified proteins are capable of in vitro assembly, and give rise to particles with normal sedimentation constants, showing that restoration of activity is not simply due to correction of an assembly defect.Protein S3 restores poly(U) binding and tRNA binding to the same extent, accounting for the lowered mRNA binding activity of the modified particles as well as a corresponding fraction of the tRNA binding activity. Protein S2 restores the remaining fraction of the tRNA binding activity, but has no effect on poly (U) binding. In 50 S-stimulated tRNA binding, proteins S1 and S5 are required in addition to S2 and S3 for full activity.     

G1401: a keystone nucleotide at the decoding site of Escherichia coli 30S ribosomes.

16S ribosomal RNA contains three highly conserved single-stranded regions. Centrally located in one of these regions is the C1400 residue. Zero-length cross-linking of this residue to the anticodon of ribosome-bound tRNA showed that it was at or near the ribosomal decoding site [Ehresmann, C., Ehresmann, B., Millon, R., Ebel, J-P., Nurse, K., & Ofengand, J. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 429-437]. To assess the functional significance of sequence conservation of rRNA in the vicinity of this functionally important site, a series of site-directed mutations in this region were constructed and the effects of these mutations on the partial reactions of protein synthesis determined. Mutation of C1400 or C1402 to any other base only moderately affected a set of in vitro protein synthesis partial reactions. However, any base change from the normal G1401 residue blocked all of the tested ribosomal functions. This was also true for the deletion of G1401. Deletion of C1400 or C1402 had more complex effects. Whereas subunit association was hardly affected, 30S initiation complex formation was blocked by deletion of C1400 but much less so by deletion of C1402. Alternatively, tRNA binding to the ribosomal A site was more strongly affected by deletion of C1402 than by deletion of C1400. P site binding was inhibited by either deletion. HPLC analysis of the in vitro reconstituted mutant ribosomes showed that none of the functional effects were due to the absence or gross reduction in amount of any ribosomal protein.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The decoding region of 16S RNA; a cross-linking study of the ribosomal A, P and E sites using tRNA derivatized at position 32 in the anticodon loop.

A photo-reactive diazirine derivative was attached to the 2-thiocytidine residue at position 32 of tRNA(Arg)I from Escherichia coli. This modified tRNA was bound under suitable conditions to the A, P or E site of E.coli ribosomes. After photo-activation of the diazirine label, the sites of cross-linking to 16S rRNA were identified by our standard procedures. Each of the three tRNA binding sites showed a characteristic pattern of cross-linking. From tRNA at the A site, a major cross-link was observed to position 1378 of the 16S RNA, and a minor one to position 936. From the P site, there were major cross-links to positions 693 and to 957 and/or 966, as well as a minor cross-link to position 1338. The E site bound tRNA showed major cross-links to position 693 (identical to that from the P site) and to positions 1376/1378 (similar, but not identical, to the cross-link observed from the A site). Immunological analysis of the concomitantly cross-linked ribosomal proteins indicated that S7 was the major target of cross-linking from all three tRNA sites, with S11 as a minor product. The results are discussed in terms of the overall topography of the decoding region of the 30S ribosomal subunit.     

Covalent cross-linking of tRNAGly1 to the ribosomal P site via the dihydrouridine loop

The dihydrouracil residue at position 20 of Escherichia coli tRNAGly1 has been replaced by the photoaffinity reagent, N-(4-azido-2-nitrophenyl)glycyl hydrazide (AGH). The location of the substituent was confirmed by the susceptibility of the modified tRNA to cleavage with aniline. When N-acetylglycyl-tRNAGly1 derivatized with AGH was bound noncovalently to the P site of E. coli 70 S ribosomes, 5-6% on average was photochemically cross-linked to the ribosomal particles in a reaction requiring poly(G,U), irradiation and the presence of the AGH label in the tRNA. Approximately two-thirds of the covalently attached tRNA was associated with 16 S RNA in the 30 S subunit. This material was judged to be in the P site by the criterion of puromycin reactivity. As partial RNAase digestion of the tRNA-16 S RNA complex produced labeled fragments from both 5' and 3' segments of the rRNA, there appeared to be more than one site of cross-linking in the 30 S subunit. The small amount of N-acetylglycyl-tRNAGly1 associated with the 50 S subunit was also linked mainly to rRNA, but it was not puromycin-reactive.     

Protein S20 Binds Two 16S rRNA Sites as Assembly Is Initiated

Ribosomal protein S20 is a primary binding protein that bridges the 5′ domain and the 3′ minor domain of the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) in the 30S ribosomal subunit. Using time-dependent dimethyl sulfate modification, we have determined that as it is bound to 16S rRNA, protein S20 causes rapid protection of bases A246, A274, A279, and A282 in the stem region of helix 11 in the 5′ domain and moderately fast modifications of helix 44 bases A1433 and A1434 in the 3′ minor domain. At a later time, enhancements occur with bases A181and A190 in helix 9, bases A325 and A327 in helix 13, and base C264 at the distal end of helix 11 in the 5′ domain of 16S rRNA. The modifications that occur in the stem region of helix 11 are distant from the binding site of protein S20, as determined from the crystal structure. Simultaneous addition of protein S17 with S20 to the complex significantly alters the modifications caused by protein S20 in the stem region of helix 11 but does not alter the remaining modifications. Our results indicate that protein S20 is binding to at least two alternate 16S rRNA sites during the early assembly process.     

Interactions between 23S rRNA and tRNA in the ribosomal E site

Interactions between tRNA or its analogs and 23S rRNA in the large ribosomal subunit were analyzed by RNA footprinting and by modification-interference selection. In the E site, tRNA protected bases G2112, A2392, and C2394 of 23S rRNA. Truncated tRNA, lacking the anticodon stem-loop, protected A2392 and C2394, but not G2112, and tRNA derivatives with a shortened 3' end protected only G2112, but not A2392 or C2394. Modification interference revealed C2394 as the only accessible nucleotide in 23S rRNA whose modification interferes with binding of tRNA in the large ribosomal subunit E site. The results suggest a direct contact between A76 of tRNA A76 and C2394 of 23S rRNA. Protections at G2112 may reflect interaction of this 23S rRNA region with the tRNA central fold.     

A functional pseudoknot in 16S ribosomal RNA.

Several lines of evidence indicate that the universally conserved 530 loop of 16S ribosomal RNA plays a crucial role in translation, related to the binding of tRNA to the ribosomal A site. Based upon limited phylogenetic sequence variation, Woese and Gutell (1989) have proposed that residues 524-526 in the 530 hairpin loop are base paired with residues 505-507 in an adjoining bulge loop, suggesting that this region of 16S rRNA folds into a pseudoknot structure. Here, we demonstrate that Watson-Crick interactions between these nucleotides are essential for ribosomal function. Moreover, we find that certain mild perturbations of the structure, for example, creation of G-U wobble pairs, generate resistance to streptomycin, an antibiotic known to interfere with the decoding process. Chemical probing of mutant ribosomes from streptomycin-resistant cells shows that the mutant ribosomes have a reduced affinity for streptomycin, even though streptomycin is thought to interact with a site on the 30S subunit that is distinct from the 530 region. Data from earlier in vitro assembly studies suggest that the pseudoknot structure is stabilized by ribosomal protein S12, mutations in which have long been known to confer streptomycin resistance and dependence.     

Cross-linking of streptomycin to the 16S ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli

[3H]Dihydrostreptomycin was cross-linked to the 30S ribosomal subunit from Escherichia coli with the bifunctional reagent nitrogen mustard. The cross-linking primarily involved the 16S RNA. To localize the site of cross-linking of streptomycin to the 16S RNA, we hybridized RNA labeled with streptomycin to restriction fragments of the 16S RNA gene. Labeled RNA hybridized to DNA fragments corresponding to bases 892-917 and bases 1394-1415. These two segments of the ribosomal RNA must be juxtaposed in the ribosome, since there is a single binding site for streptomycin. This region has been implicated both in the decoding site and in the binding of initiation factor IF-3, indicating its functional importance.     

Codon-anticodon interaction at the P site is a prerequisite for tRNA interaction with the small ribosomal subunit

The arrival of high resolution crystal structures for the ribosomal subunits opens a new phase of molecular analysis and asks for corresponding analyses of ribosomal function. Here we apply the phosphorothioate technique to dissect tRNA interactions with the ribosome. We demonstrate that a tRNA bound to the P site of non-programmed 70 S ribosomes contacts predominantly the 50 S, as opposed to the 30 S subunit, indicating that codon-anticodon interaction at the P site is a prerequisite for 30 S binding. Protection patterns of tRNAs bound to isolated subunits and programmed 70 S ribosomes were compared. The results suggest the presence of a movable domain in the large ribosomal subunit that carries tRNA and reveal that only approximately 15% of a tRNA, namely residues 30 +/- 1 to 43 +/- 1, contact the 30 S subunit of programmed 70 S ribosomes, whereas the remaining 85% make contact with the 50 S subunit. Identical protection patterns of two distinct elongator tRNAs at the P site were identified as tRNA species-independent phosphate backbone contacts. The sites of protection correlate nicely with the predicted ribosomal-tRNA contacts deduced from a 5.5-A crystal structure of a programmed 70 S ribosome, thus refining which ribosomal components are critical for tRNA fixation at the P site.