Analysis and Comparison of Electrical Pulse Parameters for Gene Electrotransfer of Two Different Cell Lines

Knowledge of the parameters which influence the efficiency of gene electrotransfer has importance for practical implementation of electrotransfection for gene therapy as well as for better understanding of the underlying mechanism. The focus of this study was to analyze the differences in gene electrotransfer and membrane electropermeabilization between plated cells and cells in a suspension in two different cell lines (CHO and B16F1). Furthermore, we determined the viability and critical induced transmembrane voltage (ITV_c) for both cell lines. In plated cells we obtained relatively little difference in electropermeabilization and gene electrotransfection between CHO and B16F1 cells. However, significant differences between the two cell lines were observed in a suspension. CHO cells exhibited a much higher gene electrotransfection rate compared to B16F1 cells, whereas B16F1 cells reached maximum electropermeabilization at lower electric fields than CHO cells. Both in a suspension and on plated cells, CHO cells had a slightly better survival rate at higher electric fields than B16F1 cells. Calculation of ITV_c in a suspension showed that, for both electropermeabilization and gene electrotransfection, CHO cells have lower ITV_c than B16F1 cells. In all cases, ITV_c for electropermeabilization was lower than ITV_c for gene electrotransfer, which is in agreement with other studies. Our results show that there is a marked difference in the efficiency of gene electrotransfer between suspended and plated cells.     

Effect of Electric-Field Intensity on Electropermeabilization and Electrosensitmty of Various Tumor-Cell Lines In Vitro

Electropermeabilization (electroporation) is a technique widely used to introduce various membrane-impermeable molecules into cells in vitro or in vivo. In this study we determined the effect of different electric-field intensities on electropermeabilization and electrosensitivity of a variety of tumor-cell lines in vitro. For this purpose we used two assays: propidium iodide uptake for measurement of cell electropenneabilization, and the clono-genic or MTT assay for determination of electrosensitivity. Our results showed that electropermeabilization of almost all cell lines tested occurred at 600 V/cm. In contrast, a marked difference in electrosensitivity existed among these cell lines. Our results could be of great importance for pharmacological and biochemical studies in vilro, and for prediction and determination of tumor response in vivo to electropermeabilization combined with chemo-therapeutic drugs (electrochemotherapy) and gene therapy.     

Electroporating Fields Target Oxidatively Damaged Areas in the Cell Membrane

Reversible electropermeabilization (electroporation) is widely used to facilitate the introduction of genetic material and pharmaceutical agents into living cells. Although considerable knowledge has been gained from the study of real and simulated model membranes in electric fields, efforts to optimize electroporation protocols are limited by a lack of detailed understanding of the molecular basis for the electropermeabilization of the complex biomolecular assembly that forms the plasma membrane. We show here, with results from both molecular dynamics simulations and experiments with living cells, that the oxidation of membrane components enhances the susceptibility of the membrane to electropermeabilization. Manipulation of the level of oxidative stress in cell suspensions and in tissues may lead to more efficient permeabilization procedures in the laboratory and in clinical applications such as electrochemotherapy and electrotransfection-mediated gene therapy.     

Electropermeabilization of dense cell suspensions

This paper investigates the influence of cell density on cell membrane electropermeabilization. The experiments were performed on dense cell suspensions (up to 400 × 10⁶ cells/ml), which represent a simple model for studying electropermeabilization of tissues. Permeabilization was assayed with a fluorescence test using Propidium iodide to obtain the mean number of permeabilized cells (i.e. fluorescence positive) and the mean fluorescence per cell (amount of loaded dye). In our study, as the cell density increased from 10 × 10⁶ to 400 × 10⁶ cells/ml, the fraction of permeabilized cells decreased by approximately 50%. We attributed this to the changes in the local electric field, which led to a decrease in the amplitude of the induced transmembrane voltage. To obtain the same fraction of cell permeabilization in suspensions with 10 × 10⁶ and 400 × 10⁶ cells/ml, the latter suspension had to be permeabilized with higher pulse amplitude, which is in qualitative agreement with numerical computations. The electroloading of the cells also decreased with cell density. The decrease was considerably larger than expected from the differences in the permeabilized cell fractions alone. The additional decrease in fluorescence was mainly due to cell swelling after permeabilization, which reduced extracellular dye availability to the permeabilized membrane and hindered the dye diffusion into the cells. We also observed that resealing of cells appeared to be slower in dense suspensions, which can be attributed to cell swelling resulting from electropermeabilization.     

Evaluation of cell membrane electropermeabilization by means of a nonpermeant cytotoxic agent

For the evaluation of cell membrane electropermeabilization, cells are usually exposed to electric pulses in the presence of propidium iodide, a fluorescent dye activated by binding to cellular DNA. The fraction of permeabilized cells is then determined using a flow cytometer. This widely established method has several drawbacks: (i) an arbitrary choice of minimum fluorescence intensity for characterization of permeabilized cells; (ii) the inability to detect cells disintegrated because of intense electropermeabilization; and (iii) false detection of cellular ghosts devoid of fluorescence because of leakage of DNA caused by electropermeabilization. Here, we present a simple and inexpensive method that eliminates these drawbacks. The method is based on the use of a cytotoxic agent that cannot permeate through an intact plasma membrane and thus leads to selective death of the electropermeabilized cells. The amount of nonpermeabilized cells is then determined by a suitable viability test. Bleomycin at a 5-nM concentration causes no statistically significant effect on cell survival in the absence of electric pulses, yet this concentration is sufficient for lethal toxicity in electropermeabilized cells. The amount of cells surviving the exposure relative to the control gives a reliable value of the fraction of nonpermeabilized cells.     

Introduction of definite amounts of nonpermeant molecules into living cells after electropermeabilization: direct access to the cytosol

The possibility of introducing definite amounts of nonpermeant molecules into electropermeabilized living cells has been approached by quantifying the amounts of Lucifer Yellow (LY; a 457-Da highly fluorescent molecule) and Phytolacca americana (Pokeweed) antiviral protein (PAP; a 30,000-Da ribosome-inactivating protein) retained by the cells after closure of the electric-field-induced transient structures of permeation. Without the electropermeabilization, these two molecules enter the cell only in very small amounts by fluid-phase pinocytosis. Under our experimental conditions, using the NIH 3T3 cells, the intracellular LY concentration can reach a value equivalent to the extracellular concentration and can be regulated by controlling the external concentration. We describe the use of LY in a rapid and efficient test for the determination of the best electrical-shock conditions of other cell lines. After electropermeabilization, PAP is 2 X 10(5) times more cytotoxic. Its toxicity can be detected at external concentrations (10(-11) M) corresponding to less than 10 internalized molecules per electropermeabilized cell. Therefore, after electropermeabilization, the nonpermeant molecules have a direct access to the cytosol and the biological effect of nonpermeant substances can be revealed.     

In vivo cell electrofusion

In vitro electrofusion of cells brought into contact and exposed to electric pulses is an established procedure. Here we report for the first time the occurrence of fusion of cells within a tissue exposed in vivo to permeabilizing electric pulses. The dependence of electrofusion on the ratio of applied voltage to distance between the electrodes, and thus on the achievement of in vivo cell electropermeabilization (electroporation) is demonstrated in the metastasizing B16 melanoma tumor model. The kinetics of the morphological changes induced by cell electrofusion (appearance of syncytial areas or formation of giant cells) are also described, as well as the kinetics of mitosis and cell death occurrence. Finally, tissue dependence of in vivo cell electrofusion is reported and discussed, since electrofusion has been observed neither in liver nor in another tumor type. Particular microenvironmental conditions, such as the existence of reduced extracellular matrices, could be necessary for electrofusion achievement. Since biomedical applications of in vivo cell electropermeabilization are rapidly developing, we also discuss the influence of cell electrofusion on the efficacy of DNA electrotransfer for gene therapy and of antitumor electrochemotherapy, in which electrofusion could be an interesting advantage to treat metastasizing tumors.     

Use of Collagen Gel as a Three-Dimensional In Vitro Model to Study Electropermeabilization and Gene Electrotransfer

Gene electrotransfer is a promising nonviral method that enables transfer of plasmid DNA into cells with electric pulses. Although many in vitro and in vivo studies have been performed, the question of the implied gene electrotransfer mechanisms is largely open. The main obstacle toward efficient gene electrotransfer in vivo is relatively poor mobility of DNA in tissues. Since cells are mechanically coupled to their extracellular environment and act differently compared to standard in vitro conditions, we developed a three-dimensional (3-D) in vitro model of CHO cells embedded in collagen gel as an ex vivo model of tissue to study electropermeabilization and different parameters of gene electrotransfer. For this purpose, we first used propidium iodide to detect electropermeabilization of CHO cells embedded in collagen gel. Then, we analyzed the influence of different concentrations of plasmid DNA and pulse duration on gene electrotransfer efficiency. Our results revealed that even if cells in collagen gel can be efficiently electropermeabilized, gene expression is significantly lower. Gene electrotransfer efficiency in our 3-D in vitro model had similar dependence on concentration of plasmid DNA and pulse duration comparable to in vivo studies, where longer (millisecond) pulses were shown to be more optimal compared to shorter (microsecond) pulses. The presented results demonstrate that our 3-D in vitro model resembles the in vivo situation more closely than conventional 2-D cell cultures and, thus, provides an environment closer to in vivo conditions to study mechanisms of gene electrotransfer.     

High-throughput RNAi screening in vitro: from cell lines to primary cells

Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are being used to induce sequence-specific gene silencing in cultured cells to study mammalian gene function. Libraries of siRNAs targeting entire human gene classes can be used to identify genes with specific cellular functions. Here we describe high-throughput siRNA delivery methods to facilitate siRNA library screening experiments with both immortalized and primary cells. We adapted chemical reverse transfection for immortalized adherent cell lines in a 96-well format. The method is fast, robust, and exceptionally effective for many cell types. For primary cells and immortalized cells that are recalcitrant to lipofection-based methods, we developed electropermeabilization (electroporation) conditions that facilitate siRNA delivery to a broad range of cell types, including primary human T-cells, hMSC, NHA, NDHF-Neo, HUVEC, DI TNC1, RPTEC, PC12, and K562 cells. To enable high-throughput electropermeabilization of primary cells, we developed a novel 96-well electroporation device that provides highly efficient and reproducible delivery of siRNAs. The combination of high-throughput chemical reverse transfection and electroporation makes it possible to deliver libraries of siRNAs to virtually any cell type, enabling gene function analysis and discovery on a genome scale.     

Membrane disorder and phospholipid scrambling in electropermeabilized and viable cells

Membrane electropermeabilization relies on the transient permeabilization of the plasma membrane of cells submitted to electric pulses. This method is widely used in cell biology and medicine due to its efficiency to transfer molecules while limiting loss of cell viability. However, very little is known about the consequences of membrane electropermeabilization at the molecular and cellular levels. Progress in the knowledge of the involved mechanisms is a biophysical challenge. As a transient loss of membrane cohesion is associated with membrane permeabilization, our main objective was to detect and visualize at the single-cell level the incidence of phospholipid scrambling and changes in membrane order. We performed studies using fluorescence microscopy with C6-NBD-PC and FM1-43 to monitor phospholipid scrambling and membrane order of mammalian cells. Millisecond permeabilizing pulses induced membrane disorganization by increasing the translocation of phosphatidylcholines according to an ATP-independent process. The pulses induced the formation of long-lived permeant structures that were present during membrane resealing, but were not associated with phosphatidylcholine internalization. These pulses resulted in a rapid phospholipid flip/flop within less than 1 s and were exclusively restricted to the regions of the permeabilized membrane. Under such electrical conditions, phosphatidylserine externalization was not detected. Moreover, this electrically-mediated membrane disorganization was not correlated with loss of cell viability. Our results could support the existence of direct interactions between the movement of membrane zwitterionic phospholipids and the electric field.     

Control of electric field induced cell membrane permeabilization by membrane order

Cells can be made temporarily permeable if pulsed by high-intensity short-duration electric fields. The molecular mechanisms underlying this electropermeabilization are still unknown. The kinetic events may be described by four successive steps: induction, expansion, stabilization, and resealing. On one hand, cell electropermeabilization is detected only under more stringent conditions when cells have been treated by ethanol. On the other hand, lysolecithin is observed to facilitate cell electropermeabilization. More precisely, these molecules that modify membrane order, when used in concentrations compatible with cell viability, are shown to affect only the expansion and resealing steps. Electropermeabilization is inducing a transition in the membrane organization. Membrane order is modulating the energy barrier needed to evoke this membrane transition which occurs when cells are submitted to a field larger than a characteristic threshold (expansion step). Less order would increase the magnitude of this energy barrier; more order would decrease it.     

Effect of electric field induced transmembrane potential on spheroidal cells: theory and experiment

The transmembrane potential on a cell exposed to an electric field is a critical parameter for successful cell permeabilization. In this study, the effect of cell shape and orientation on the induced transmembrane potential was analyzed. The transmembrane potential was calculated on prolate and oblate spheroidal cells for various orientations with respect to the electric field direction, both numerically and analytically. Changing the orientation of the cells decreases the induced transmembrane potential from its maximum value when the longest axis of the cell is parallel to the electric field, to its minimum value when the longest axis of the cell is perpendicular to the electric field. The dependency on orientation is more pronounced for elongated cells while it is negligible for spherical cells. The part of the cell membrane where a threshold transmembrane potential is exceeded represents the area of electropermeabilization, i.e. the membrane area through which the transport of molecules is established. Therefore the surface exposed to the transmembrane potential above the threshold value was calculated. The biological relevance of these theoretical results was confirmed with experimental results of the electropermeabilization of plated Chinese hamster ovary cells, which are elongated. Theoretical and experimental results show that permeabilization is not only a function of electric field intensity and cell size but also of cell shape and orientation.     

Specific electropermeabilization of leucocytes in a blood sample and application to large volumes of cells

Electropermeabilization is obtained when the membrane potential difference reaches a critical threshold. This is performed by submitting cells to an external electric field pulse. The field modulates the endogenous potential difference in a cell-size-dependent way. Computer simulations predict that large cells would be specifically permeabilized in a mixture with smaller cells. This was examined on a mixture of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and erythrocytes. CHO cells were permeabilized to Trypan blue without any occurrence of haemolysis. A similar 'size' specificity was observed on blood samples. This agreement between prediction and experimental observation indicates that induction of electropermeabilization is mainly under the control of the size of the target cell. Its physiology plays only a minor role, if any. Treating blood with 10 square wave pulses lasting 100 microseconds of an intensity of 1.6 kV/cm induced the permeabilization of 70% of the leucocytes (polymorphs and monocytes) but did not affect erythrocytes. No washing of the sample was needed in a procedure in which cells were pulsed in the plasma. A flow electropulsing process allows the treatment of large blood volumes under conditions where cells are kept viable. These results show that electropermeabilization could be used as an effective way to obtain immunocompatible drug vehicles.     

Intracellular delivery of trehalose into mammalian cells by electropermeabilization

The disaccharide trehalose is increasingly being used as a very efficient stabilizer of cells, membranes and macromolecules during cryo- and lyoconservation. Although extracellular trehalose can reduce cryo- and lyodamage to mammalian cells, the sugar is required on both sides of the plasma membrane for maximum protection efficiency. In the present study, mouse myeloma cells were loaded with the disaccharide by means of reversible electropermeabilization in isotonic trehalose-substituted medium, which contained 290 mM trehalose as the major solute. By using the membrane-impermeable fluorescent dye propidium iodide as the reporter molecule, optimum electropulsing conditions were found, at which most permeabilized cells survived and recovered (i.e., resealed) their original membrane integrity within a few minutes after electric treatment. Microscopic examination during the resealing phase revealed that electropulsed cells shrank gradually to about 60% of their original volume. The kinetics of the dye uptake and the volumetric response of cells to electropulsing were analyzed using a theoretical model that relates the observed cell volume changes to the solute transport across the transiently permeabilized cell membrane. From the best fit of the model to the experimental data, the intracellular trehalose concentration in electropulsed cells was estimated to be about 100 mM. This loading efficiency compares favorably to other methods currently used for intracellular trehalose delivery. The results presented here point toward application of the electropermeabilization technique for loading cells with membrane-impermeable bioprotectants, with far-reaching implications for cryo- and lyopreservation of rare and valuable mammalian cells and tissues.     

In vivo targeting of inflamed areas by electroloaded neutrophils.

Due to their spontaneous accumulation in inflamed or infected areas, blood phagocytes are potent drug vectors with specific targeting. Drug like molecule loading was obtained by use of cell electropermeabilization in which the impermeability of their plasma membrane is transiently impaired. Electrical conditions were used which allow electroloading of a drug like molecule (propidium iodide) in 70% of leukocytes in a whole blood sample while preserving in vitro functional properties. Slow release of entrapped hydrophilic molecules was observed with a half lifetime longer than 4 hours at 4 degrees C and at 37 degrees C. With an in vivo assay, using a rat model of inflammation, we showed that, as for non-pulsed cells, pulsed neutrophils accumulate 10 times more in an inflamed area than they do in control areas. Phagocyte electropermeabilization is therefore a very efficient way of drug targeting. Accumulation of electropulsed neutrophils in an area of inflammation gives targeted release of the electroloaded drug.     

Studies of in vivo electropermeabilization by gamma camera measurements of (99m)Tc-DTPA

A protocol was developed to study the drug uptake from in vivo electropermeabilization at different settings of parameters influencing the uptake efficiency. Radiolabelled diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (DTPA) was used to trace the distribution and internalization of a hydrophilic drug after in vivo electropermeabilization. Skeletal muscle tissue in rat was treated with permeabilizing electric pulses before or after intravenous administration of (99m)Tc-DTPA. The drug accumulation in the treated volume was subsequently evaluated with a scintillation camera. The dependence of uptake on field strength and duration of the applied electric pulses was investigated for exponentially decaying pulses and square wave pulses. Further, the uptake dependence on time interval between injection and pulsation was studied as well as the uptake dependence on the number of pulses applied in a single electropermeabilization treatment. Dynamic gamma camera studies were performed to quantify the time scale of the drug uptake in electropermeabilized tissue.     

Signal transduction by membrane receptors in viable electropermeabilized cells: isoproterenol-stimulated cyclic AMP synthesis in C6 glioma cells

The activity of beta-adrenergic receptors at the plasma membrane level was investigated in viable, electropermeabilized C6 glioma cells. Electric field pulses were applied directly to the plated cells without any previous proteinase treatment. The affinity for isoproterenol and the density of the beta-adrenergic receptors, as judged from the number of [3H]CGP-12177 binding sites, were not affected by the electropermeabilization whereas the isoproterenol-stimulated cAMP accumulation was transiently impaired. This decrease in activity is due to an electropermeabilization-induced GTP leak. Normal activity could be obtained either by treating the cells by the electric field in a GTP-containing buffer, or by spontaneous recovery of the cells after the resealing of the plasma membrane, with a delay depending on the temperature. The activity of the receptors was not affected by the structural organization of the membrane associated to its electropermeabilization.     

Time courses of mammalian cell electropermeabilization observed by millisecond imaging of membrane property changes during the pulse

Time courses of electropermeabilization were analyzed during the electric field application using a rapid fluorescent imaging system. Exchanges of calcium ions through electropermeabilized membrane of Chinese hamster ovary cells were found to be asymmetrical. Entry of calcium ions during a millisecond pulse occurred on the anode-facing cell hemisphere. Entry through the region facing the cathode was observed only after the pulse. Leakage of intracellular calcium ions from electropermeabilized cell in low-calcium content medium was observed only from the anode-facing side. The exchanges during the pulse were mostly due to diffusion-driven processes, i.e., governed by the concentration gradient. Interaction of propidium iodide, a dye sensitive to the structural alteration of membrane, with cell membrane was asymmetrical during electropermeabilization. Localized enhancement of the dye fluorescence was observed during and after the pulsation on the cell surface. Specific staining of a limited anode-facing part of the membrane was observed as soon as the pulse was applied. The membrane fluorescence level increased during and immediately after the pulse whereas the geometry of the staining was unchanged. The membrane regions stained by propidium iodide were the same as those where calcium exchanges occurred. The fraction of the membrane on which structural alterations occurred was defined by the field strength. The density of defects was governed by the pulse duration. Electropermeabilization is a localized but asymmetrical process. The membrane defects are created unequally on the two cell sides during the pulse, implying a vectorial effect of the electric field on the membrane.     

Monitoring electropermeabilization in the plasma membrane of adherent mammalian cells.

When an electrical potential of order one volt is induced across a cell membrane for a fraction of a second, temporary breakdown of ordinary membrane functions may occur. One result of such a breakdown is that molecules normally excluded by the membrane can now enter the cells. This phenomenon, generally referred to as electropermeabilization, is known as electroporation when actual pores form in the membrane. This paper presents a unique approach to the measurement of pore formation and closure in anchored mammalian cells. The cells are cultured on small gold electrodes, and by constantly monitoring the impedance of the electrode with a low-amplitude AC signal, small changes in cell morphology, cell motion, and membrane resistance can be detected. Because the active electrode is small, the application of a few volts across the cell-covered electrode causes pore formation in the cell membrane. In addition, the heat transfer is very efficient, and the cells can be porated in their regular growth medium. By this method, the formation and resealing of pores due to applied electric fields can be followed in real time for anchorage-dependent cells.     

Ionic-strength modulation of electrically induced permeabilization and associated fusion of mammalian cells

Application of a high electric field to cells in culture has been shown to make them both permeable and fusogenic. The molecular events involved in the phenomenon are still poorly understood. In this study we investigated the effects of the ionic strength of the pulsing buffer on the electropermeabilization and electrofusion of Chinese hamster ovary cells. Increasing the ionic strength of the pulsing medium results in an increase in sieving of transient permeant structures, but decreases the fusion index. Treatment of cells with trypsin or pronase before application of the pulses abolishes the ionic modulation of both electropermeabilization and electrofusion. A similar rate of expansion of permeabilization is obtained whatever the ionic content of the pulsing buffer, and cells fuse even at high ionic strength. This observation lends support to our hypothesis that membrane proteins play a role in electrofusion.