Germ cell sex determination: a collaboration between soma and germline

Sex determination is regulated very differently in the soma vs. the germline, yet both processes are critical for the creation of the male and female gametes. In general, the soma plays an essential role in regulating sexual identity of the germline. However, in some species, such as Drosophila and mouse, the sex chromosome constitution of the germ cells makes an autonomous contribution to germline sexual development. Here we review how the soma and germline cooperate to determine germline sexual identity for some important model systems, the fly, the worm and the mouse, and discuss some of the implications of 'dual control' (soma plus germline) as compared to species where germline sex is dictated only by the surrounding soma.     

Germ cell sex and cell cycle

Germ cells are the only cells in the body capable of transferring an individual's genetic and epigenetic information to the next generation. However, the developmental processes that provide the foundation for male and female germ line development and later gamete production are complex and poorly understood. In mice the primordial germ cells enter the bipotential gonad at E10.5 and, in response to the testicular or ovarian micro-environment, commit to spermatogenesis or oogenesis. This paper reviews progress in understanding the molecular processes underlying the early stages of male and female germ line development.     

Germ line control of female sex determination in zebrafish

A major transition during development of the gonad is commitment from an undifferentiated “bi-potential” state to ovary or testis fate. In mammals, the oogonia of the developing ovary are known to be important for folliculogenesis. An additional role in promoting ovary fate or female sex determination has been suggested, however it remains unclear how the germ line might regulate this process. Here we show that the germ line is required for the ovary versus testis fate choice in zebrafish. When the germ line is absent, the gonad adopts testis fate. These germ line deficient testes have normal somatic structures indicating that the germ line influences fate determination of surrounding somatic tissues. In germ line deficient animals the expression of the ovary specific gene cyp19a1a fails to be maintained whereas the testis genes sox9a and amh remain expressed. Furthermore, we observed decreased levels of the ovary specific genes cyp19a1a and foxL2 in germ line deficient animals prior to morphological sex differentiation of the gonad. We propose that the germ line has a common role in female sex determination in fish and mammals. Additionally, we show that testis specification is sufficient for masculinization of the fish pointing to a direct role of hormone signaling from the gonad in directing sex differentiation of non-gonadal tissues.     

Germ plasm formation and germ cell determination

Germ cells are essential for the maintenance of a species, and in most organisms a specific germ cell lineage is established early during embryogenesis. In flies, worms and frogs a morphologically distinct germ plasm assembles in the egg and signals present in this cytoplasm are necessary for the establishment of the germ cell fate. Although the molecular nature of the germ cell signal remains unknown, genes involved in the process of germ cell determination, proliferation and survival have recently been identified.     

Germ cell cycles during sex inversion in chick embryos]

A study was made of the germ cell cycles of 11 days old embryos injected male or female hormones on the 4 th day of incubation. The cell cycles duration in genetically male 11 days embryos treated with esradiol-benzoate was close to that registered in oogonia of both treated and non-treated female embryos of the same age. The testosterone propionate injection caused an acceleration of the genetically male sex cell proliferation and a decrease of the reproduction rate of the female sex cells. It is proposed that under normal conditions female sex hormones inhibit a hypothethic factor that determines the decrease of cell proliferation during the male embryo development.     

Germ cell sex prior to meiosis in the rainbow trout

Germ cells make two major decisions when they move from an indeterminate state to their final stage of gamete production. One decision is sexual commitment for sperm or egg production, and the other is to maintain mitotic division or entry into meiosis. It is unclear whether the two decisions are made as a single event or separate events, because there has been no evidence for the presence of germ cell sex prior to meiosis. Here we report direct evidence in the fish rainbow trout that gonia have distinct sexuality. We show that dazl expression occurs in both male and female gonia but exhibits differential intracellular distribution. More strikingly, we show that boule is highly expressed in male gonia but absent in female gonia. Therefore, mitotic gonia possess sex, sperm/egg decision and mitosis/meiosis decision are two independent events, and sperm/egg decision precedes mitosis/meiosis decision in rainbow trout, making this organism a unique vertebrate model for mechanistic understanding of germ cell sex differentiation and relationship between the two decisions.     

Germ cell intercellular bridges

Stable intercellular bridges are a conserved feature of gametogenesis in multicellular animals observed more than 100 years ago, but their function was unknown. Many of the components necessary for this structure have been identified through the study of cytokinesis in Drosophila; however, mammalian intercellular bridges have distinct properties from those of insects. Mammalian germ cell intercellular bridges are composed of general cytokinesis components with additional germ cell-specific factors including TEX14. TEX14 is an inactive kinase essential for the maintenance of stable intercellular bridges in gametes of both sexes but whose loss specifically impairs male meiosis. TEX14 acts to impede the terminal steps of abscission by competing for essential component CEP55, blocking its interaction in nongerm cells with ALIX and TSG101. Additionally, TEX14-interacting protein RBM44, whose localization in stabile intercellular bridges is limited to pachytene and secondary spermatocytes, may participate in processes such as RNA transport but is nonessential to the maintenance of intercellular bridge stability.     

Plant sex determination and sex chromosomes

Sex determination systems in plants have evolved many times from hermaphroditic ancestors (including monoecious plants with separate male and female flowers on the same individual), and sex chromosome systems have arisen several times in flowering plant evolution. Consistent with theoretical models for the evolutionary transition from hermaphroditism to monoecy, multiple sex determining genes are involved, including male-sterility and female-sterility factors. The requirement that recombination should be rare between these different loci is probably the chief reason for the genetic degeneration of Y chromosomes. Theories for Y chromosome degeneration are reviewed in the light of recent results from genes on plant sex chromosomes.     

Germ cell transplantation in goats

Transplantation of spermatogonial stem cells provides a unique approach for the study of spermatogenesis and manipulation of the male germ line. This technique may also offer an alternative to the currently inefficient methods of producing transgenic domestic animals. We have recently established the technique of spermatogonial transplantation, originally developed in laboratory rodents, in pigs, and this study was aimed to extend the technique to the goat. Isolated donor testis cells were infused into the seminiferous tubules of anesthetized recipient goats through an ultrasonographically-guided catheter inserted into the rete testis. Donor cells were obtained by enzymatic digestion of freshly collected testes from immature goats (either from the recipients' contralateral testis or from unrelated donors). Prior to transplantation, testis cells were labeled with a fluorescent marker to allow identification after transplantation. Recipient testes were examined for the presence and localization of labeled donor cells at 3-week intervals up to 12 weeks after transplantation. Labeled donor cells were found in the seminiferous tubules of all testes, comprising 10-35% of the examined tubules. Histological examination of the recipient testes did not reveal evident tissue damage, except for limited fibrotic changes at the site of needle insertion. Likewise there were no detectable local or systemic signs of immunologic reactions to the transplantations. These results indicate that germ cell transplantation is technically feasible in immature male goats and that donor-derived cells are retained in the recipient testis for at least three months and through puberty. This study represents the first report of germ cell transplantation in goats.     

Bird sex determination

During the evolution, sex determination occurred early. Sex determining factors were progressively isolated from other genes in sexual chromosomes, or gonosomes. Among vertebrates, evolution took two opposite pathways : in mammals, the system of XX:XY sex determination, with Y chromosome, induces male differentiation. In contrast, in birds, the system ZZ:ZW, with the W chromosome, induces female differentiation. But comparative studies show that the two pathways are not so simple. In the chicken as in the lower vertebrates, estrogens play a central role in gonadal sex differentiation. Several genes, show to be critical for mammalian determination, are also expressed in the chicken but their expression pattern differs, indicating functional plasticity. The W-linked female determinants remains still unknown. But comparative studies of the two pathways, with conserved and divergent elements, are broadening our understanding of sex determination.     

Germ cells, gonads and sex reversal in marsupials.

The formation of the testis or ovary is a critical step in development. Alterations in gonadal development during fetal or postnatal life can lead to intersexuality or infertility. Several model systems have been particularly useful in studying gonadal differentiation, the eutherian mammal and amphibia, fish, and birds. However, marsupials provide a unique opportunity to investigate gonadal development and the interactions of genes and hormones in gonadal differentiation and germ cell development in all mammals. On the one hand the genetic mechanisms appear to be identical to those in eutherian mammals, including the testis-determining SRY gene. On the other hand, marsupials retain in part the plasticity of the amphibian gonad to hormonal manipulation. It is possible to induce female to male and also male to female gonadal sex reversal in marsupials by hormonal manipulation, and oestradiol can induce male germ cells to enter meiosis at the time the oogonia do. In addition, in marsupials the development of the scrotum and mammary glands are independent of testicular androgens and instead are controlled by a gene or genes on the X-chromosome. Thus marsupials provide a number of opportunities for manipulating the sexual differentiation of the gonads that are not possible in eutherian mammals and so provide a unique perspective for understanding the common mechanisms controlling sexual development.     

Germ cell chimerism in male marmosets

Marmosets normally produce biovular twins which are connected, via placental vascular anastomoses, as early as pre-somite stages of development. These anastomoses allow the exchange of lymphoid and hematopoietic tissue, as demonstrated by karyotype analysis in heterosexual twins. Because germ cells are also motile during development, i.e., they migrate from the yolk sac endodermal epithelium to the germinal ridges, the possibility exists that germ cells could also be exchanged between heterosexual twins. Testicular squash preparations were examined from 22 adult male marmosets of several species. During the diakinesis stage of meiotic prophase the XY chromosome pair was distinct. Spermatocytes which lacked the conspicuous end-to-end association of the XY pair were considered to have originated from germ cells with an XX sex chromosome constitution. In approximately half the animals examined, all diakinesis figures contained an end-to-end XY pair. In the remaining animals, primary spermatocytes were seen that clearly did not contain an endto-end XY pair. The largest number of such XX primary spermatocytes in any one animal was 21% (9 of 43 cells examined). The effects of germ cell chimerism on the sex ratio of offspring was also investigated.     

Germ cell transplantation in pigs.

Spermatogonial stem cells form the foundation of spermatogenesis, and their transplantation provides a unique opportunity to study spermatogenesis and may offer an alternative approach for animal transgenesis. This study was designed to extend the technique of spermatogonial transplantation to an economically important, large-animal model. Isolated immature pig testes were used to develop the intratesticular injection technique. Best results of intratubular germ cell transfer were obtained when a catheter was inserted into the rete testis under ultrasound guidance. The presence of infused dye or labeled cells was confirmed in the seminiferous tubules from 70 of 89 injected isolated testes. Infusion of 3-6 ml of dye solution or cell suspension could fill the rete and up to 50% of seminiferous tubules. The technique was subsequently applied in vivo. Donor cells included testis cells from 1- or 10-wk-old boars (from the recipients' contralateral testis or unrelated donors) and those from mice carrying a marker gene. Porcine testis cells were labeled with a fluorescent marker before transplantation. Testes were examined for the presence and localization of labeled donor cells immediately after transplantation or every week for 4 wk. Labeled porcine donor cells were found in numerous seminiferous tubules from 10 of 11 testes receiving pig cells. These results indicate that germ cell transplantation is feasible in immature pigs, and that porcine transplanted cells are retained in the recipient testis for at least 1 mo. This study represents a first step toward successful spermatogonial transplantation in a farm animal species.