Programmed appearance of translatable flagellar tubulin mRNA during cell differentiation in Naegleria.

The programmed de novo synthesis of flagellar tubulin during the hour-long differentiation of Naegleria gruberi from amoebae to flagellates is our paradigm for the study of gene expression during cell differentiation. This paper reports the efficient translation of flagellar tubulin mRNA in the wheat germ cell-free system directed by total or polyadenylated RNA extracted from differentiating cells. The tubulin in the in vitro product has a subunit molecular weight of 55,000, separates into alpha and beta subunits under suitable conditions of polyacrylamide gel electrophoreis and co-polymerizes with calf brain tubulin. At least half of the tubulin synthesized in vitro is precipitated by antibodies specific to flagellar tubulin, and the immunoprecipitated tubulin subunits yield peptide maps similar to those of outer doublet tublin. Flagellar tubulin is the predominant protein synthesized in the cell-free system, and amounts to about 5% of the polypeptides whose synthesis is directed by total RNA from differentiating cells. In contrast, little or no flagellar tubulin is synthesized when the cell-free system is directed by RNA extracted from amoebae prior to differentiation. Translation assays show that at least 92% of the flagellar tubulin mRNA appears during differentiation. The time course of appearance of this mRNA was measured by quantitative immunoprecipitation of the cell-free products. Under conditions where cells from flagella 60 min after initiation of differentiation, translatable flagellar tubulin mRNA was first detected at 20 min, reached a maximum at about 60 min and then declined. An excellent correlation was observed between the amount of translatable flagellar tubulin mRNA and the previously measured rates of flagellar tubulin synthesis in vivo. These results indicate that synthesis of flagellar tubulin is a direct reflection of the abundance of its mRNA, and provide the molecular techniques for dissection of the factors that regulate the rapid appearance of this structural protein during differentiation.     

mRNAs for alpha- and beta-tubulin and flagellar calmodulin are among those coordinately regulated when Naegleria gruberi amebae differentiate into flagellates

Three of four mRNAs that are specific to the differentiation of Naegleria gruberi amebae into flagellates (Mar, J., J. H. Lee, D. Shea, and C. J. Walsh, 1986, J. Cell Biol., 102:353-361) have been identified as coding for flagellar proteins. The products of these mRNAs, which are coordinately regulated during the differentiation, were identified by in vitro translation of hybrid-selected RNA followed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and antibody binding. Six cross-hybridizing clones complementary to a 1.7-kb RNA (class II) all selected mRNA that was translated into two alpha-tubulins. The principal in vitro product, alpha-1, comigrated with a cytoplasmic alpha-tubulin, while the minor product with a more acidic pI, alpha-2, comigrated with flagellar alpha-tubulin. While Naegleria flagellar alpha-tubulin was found to be acetylated based on its reaction with a monoclonal antibody specific to this form, we suggest that alpha-2 is not likely to arise due to acetylation in vitro but probably represents the product of a second alpha-tubulin gene. The class III clone, also complementary to a 1.7-kb RNA, selected beta-tubulin mRNA. In the course of this work it was found, using monoclonal antibodies to the alpha- and beta-subunits of tubulin, that Naegleria alpha-tubulin migrated faster than beta-tubulin on SDS-PAGE. The class IV clone, which hybridizes with a 0.5-kb RNA, selected an mRNA that was translated into a heat stable calcium-binding protein, flagellar calmodulin.     

Induction of microtubule protein synthesis in Chlamydomonas reinhardi during flagellar regeneration

Flagellar regeneration in gametes of Chlamydomonas reinhardi is initiated within 15–20 min after flagellar amputation and proceeds at a rapid but decelerating rate until by 90 min flagellar outgrowth is 80–85% complete. Sufficient flagellar protein reserves exist in the cytoplasm to allow regeneration of flagella $\text{1}\text{3}\text{–}\text{1}\text{2}$ normal length. Nevertheless, in vivo labeling with ¹⁴C-amino acids shows that microtubule protein and other flagellar proteins are synthesized de novo during flagellar regeneration. To determine whether tubulin is synthesized continuously by gametic cells or whether its synthesis is induced as a consequence of deflagellation, we have isolated polyribosomes from deflagellated and control cells, and analyzed the proteins produced by these polyribosomes during in vitro translation. Two proteins of 53,000 and 56,000 molecular weight which co-migrate with flagellar and chick brain tubulin on SDS-polyacrylamide gels and which selectively co-assemble with chick brain tubulin during in vitro microtubule assembly are synthesized by polyribosomes (or polyadenylated mRNA) from deflagellated cells. No microtubule proteins can be detected in the translation products synthesized by polyribosomes (or mRNA) from control cells, clearly indicating that deflagellation results in the induction of tubulin synthesis.Kinetics of tubulin synthesis demonstrate that induction takes place immediately after deflagellation; polyribosomes bearing tubulin mRNA can be detected in the cytoplasm in as little as 15 min after removal of flagella. Maximal rates of tubulin synthesis occur between 45 and 90 min after deflagellation when approximately 14% of the protein being synthesized by the cell is tubulin. This estimate of tubulin synthesis based on in vitro translation data agrees well with in vivo measurements of flagellar tubulin synthesis. While high levels of tubulin production extend well beyond the period of rapid flagellar assembly, synthesis begins to decline after 90 min, and by 180 min after deflagellation only low levels of tubulin mRNA are detectable in polyribosomes.     

Developmental changes in messenger RNAs and protein synthesis in Dictyostelium discoideum

The pattern of proteins synthesized at different stages of differentiation of the slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum was studied by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Of the approximately 400 proteins detected during growth and/or development, synthesis of most continued throughout differentiation. Approximately 100 proteins show changes in their relative rates of synthesis. During the transition from growth to interphase, the major change observed is reduction in the relative rate of synthesis of about 8 proteins. Few further changes are noticeable until the stage of late cell aggregation, when production of about 40 new proteins begins and synthesis of about 10 is reduced considerably. Thereafter, there are few changes in the pattern of protein synthesis. Major changes in the relative rates of synthesis of a number of proteins are found during culmination, but few culmination-specific proteins are observed. In an attempt to understand the molecular basis for these changes, mRNA was isolated from different stages of differentiation and translated in an improved wheat germ cell-free system; the products were resolved on two-dimensional gels. The ratio of total translatable mRNA to total cellular RNA is constant throughout growth and differentiation. Messenger RNAs for many, but not all, developmentally regulated proteins can be identified by translation in cell-free systems. Actin is the major protein synthesized by vegetative cells and by early differentiating cells. The threefold increase in the relative rate of synthesis of actin during the first 2 hr of differentiation and the decrease which occurs thereafter can be accounted for by parallel changes in the amount of translatable actin mRNA. Most of the changes in the pattern of protein synthesis which occur during the late aggregation and culmination stages can also be accounted for by parallel increases or decreases in the amounts of translatable mRNAs encoding these proteins. It is concluded that mRNAs do not appear in a translatable form before synthesis of the homologous protein begins, and that regulation of protein synthesis during development is primarily at the levels of production or destruction of mRNA.     

Tubulin mRNA instability and stabilization by protein synthesis inhibitors are reproducible in nontranslating extracts from Chlamydomonas

In Chlamydomonas rein-hardtii, flagellar amputation stimulates an induction in the synthesis of flagellar proteins which allows the cells to rapidly regenerate their flagella. The induction involves the coordinate accumulation and rapid degradation of a large number mRNAs, including those encoding the tubulins. The post-induction degradation of induced tubulin mRNAs has been shown to differ from the consti-tutive turnover pathway in two ways: (1) the rate of degradation is accelerated, and (2) degradation is prevented by inhibition of protein synthesis. In this report, it is shown that the post-induction degradation of all deflagellation-induced mRNAs examined is prevented by cycloheximide (CX), suggesting they all may be degraded via the same pathway. A cell-free decay system has been developed to investigate the degradation pathway. At least two characteristics of tubulir mRNA degradation are reproducible in these extracts: (1) endogenous α-tubulin mRNA is less stable than constitutive mRNAs in the same extract and (2) α-tubulin mRNA in extracts prepared from CX-treated cells (CX ex-tracts) is significantly more stable than it is in extracts from untreated cells (control extracts). This indicates that the mechanism by which CX blocks rapid degradation of tubulin mRNA in vivo is not simply by preventing its translation and suggests the involvement of an altered trans-factor. The difference in tubulin mRNA stability in the two extracts is maintained when the extracts are prepared under conditions that dissociate ribosomes from mRNPs, indicating intact polysome structure is not necessary. Tubulin mRNA-containing polysomes isolated from control and CX extracts are equally stable when assayed alone. However, the poly-somes from control extracts are more sensitive to exogenous RNAse treatment than are those from CX extracts, indicating a structural difference. There are no detectable differences in soluble factors that influence tubulin mRNA degradation rate between control and CX extracts; addition of excess soluble factors to either control or CX extracts does not alter the tubulin mRNA degradation in the extract, nor does a simple one-to-one combination of the two extracts result in stabilization or destabilization of the whole population of tubulin mRNAs in the mixture. The deflagellation-induced mRNAs, as a group, are shown to be particularly susceptible to a nuclease activity in extracts, inhibitable by vanadyl ribonucleoside complexes, which does not appear to attack constitutive mRNAs. It is proposed that a structural difference in the tubulin mRNPs produced in the presence and absence of CX underlies their differences in stabilities, and that a common nuclease targets the induced flagellar protein mRNAs. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The normal program of gene expression during spore germination in Dictyostelium discoideum is deranged in a germination-defective mutant

During spore germination in the cellular slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum, spores swell and then release single amoebae in a highly synchronous manner. A mutant, named HE 1, is unable to complete the sequence. It swells normally but amoebae are not released from the swollen spore. The mutant was used to investigate whether this defect in spore germination affected the orderly progression of appearance and disappearance of mRNAs developmentally regulated during germination. Three previously characterized cDNA clones representing D. discoideum sequences that are modulated during spore germination, and are not present in growing cells, were used as probes. In the wild type, the levels of the respective mRNAs reach a peak early during spore germination (1-1.5 hr) but fall at later times, indicating that their synthesis has stopped and they are rapidly degraded. However, in the mutant, after reaching their maximum levels during germination (also at 1-1.5 hr), the mRNA levels remain high. This is apparently at least partly due to the increased stability of these mRNAs in the mutant compared to the wild type. It is concluded that the time of the onset of synthesis of the mRNAs and the time when their maximum levels is reached are normal in HE 1. However, the later events, the level of mRNA attained, and the subsequent disappearance of these mRNAs are abnormal.     

Rapid changes in tubulin RNA synthesis and stability induced by deflagellation in Chlamydomonas

Detachment of the flagella of Chlamydomonas induces a rapid accumulation of mRNAs for tubulin and other flagellar proteins. Measurement of the rate of alpha and beta tubulin RNA synthesis during flagellar regeneration shows that deflagellation elicits a rapid, 4-7- fold burst in tubulin RNA synthesis. The synthesis rate peaks within 10- 15 min, then declines back to the predeflagellation rate. Redeflagellation of cells at times before the first flagellar regeneration is completed (and when cells have already accumulated elevated levels of tubulin RNA) induces another burst in tubulin RNA synthesis which is identical to the first in magnitude and duration. This finding indicates that the induction signal may act to simply reprogram the tubulin genes for a transient burst of maximal synthesis. Evidence is presented that the stability of the tubulin RNAs changes during regeneration. Stability changes include both an apparent stabilization during regeneration and accelerated decay following regeneration.     

In vitro regulation of granulosa cell differentiation. Involvement of cytoskeletal protein expression

The link between the biochemical and morphological differentiation of granulosa cells was studied by investigating the organization and the expression of cytoskeletal proteins which determine cell shape and contacts. In cells treated with follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), in a serum- and growth factor-free medium, or with other compounds which elevate cellular cAMP levels, the synthesis of the adherens junction proteins, vinculin, alpha-actinin, and actin was reduced significantly when compared to unstimulated cells (7-fold for vinculin, 5-fold for alpha-actinin, and 3-fold for actin). The in vitro translatability of the mRNAs coding for these proteins and the level of actin mRNA determined by RNA blot hybridization were generally reduced in differentiating cells. The synthesis and the organization of vimentin and tubulin was unaffected during this process, whereas the organization of actin and vinculin was dramatically affected, with FSH-treated cells displaying a diffuse pattern of actin and vinculin, with very little vinculin in adhesion plaques. Gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist and the phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate which are known to antagonize the cAMP-mediated biochemical differentiation of granulosa cells by reducing cAMP levels or by activating protein kinase C and phospholipid turnover, blocked to a large extent the FSH-induced effect on the adherens junction proteins. Epidermal growth factor, which blocked the FSH-induced cAMP increase, but not the FSH-induced progesterone production, failed to block the synthesis of vinculin, alpha-actinin, and actin. Cytochalasin B could induce steroidogenesis and similar changes in the synthesis of these cytoskeletal proteins, whereas fibronectin, which causes cell spreading, blocked in part the FSH-induced effect on the expression of cytoskeletal proteins. The modulation of cytoskeletal proteins may therefore be an essential feature of programmed differentiation events leading to the final phenotype of granulosa cells.     

Temperature-shock induction of multiple flagella induces additional synthesis of flagellum specific mRNAs and tubulin

Four mRNAs (alpha- and beta-tubulin, flagellar calmodulin and Class-I), specifically expressed when Naegleria amebae differentiate into flagellates, were followed at 5-10 min intervals during the temperature-shock induction of multiple flagella in order to better understand how basal body and flagellum number are regulated. Surprisingly, tubulin synthesis continued during the 37 min temperature shock. An initial rapid decline in alpha- and beta-tubulin and flagellar calmodulin mRNAs was followed by a rapid re-accumulation of mRNAs before the temperature was lowered. mRNA levels continued to increase until they exceeded control levels by 4-21%. Temperature shock delayed flagella formation 37 min, produced twice as much tubulin protein synthesis and three fold more flagella. Labeling with an antibody against Naegleria centrin suggested that basal body formation was also delayed 30-40 min. An extended temperature shock demonstrated that lowering the temperature was not required for return of mRNAs to near control levels suggesting that induction of multiple flagella and the formation of flagella per se are affected in different ways. We suggest that temperature-shock induction of multiple flagella reflects increased mRNA accumulation combined with interference with the regulation of the recently reported microtubule-nucleating complex needed for basal body formation.     

Increased levels of mRNAs for tubulin and other flagellar proteins after amputation or shortening of Chlamydomonas Flagella

A dramatic stimulation of synthesis of flagellar proteins occurs in Chlamydomonas following flagellar removal or experimentally induced resorption of the flagella into the cell. In this report we show that this stimulation involves an increase in the levels of mRNAs for tubulin and many other flagellar proteins. Total RNA and poly(A) RNA were isolated from cells after deflagellation or flagellar resorption, and were then translated in the reticulocyte lysate system. Two-dimensional gel analysis of the translation products demonstrates that the RNA-directed in vitro synthesis of α and β tubulins, and a number of other flagellar proteins, increases after deflagellation or flagellar resorption. Surprisingly, the α-tubulin synthesized in vitro does not co-migrate on two-dimensional gels with mature flagellar α-tubulin. Moreover, in vivo labeling experiments show that the major α-tubulin synthesized in the cell after deflagellation co-migrates with the major α-tubulin made in vitro, not with the major α-tubulin present in the flagella. These results suggest that flagellar α-tubulin is synthesized as a precursor, and undergoes post-translational modification before assembly into the flagella. In addition, we report that the synthesis of tubulin and other flagellar proteins can be specifically inhibited, as well as stimulated. Treatment of cells with IBMX, which induces flagellar resorption, causes a marked decrease in the levels of translatable mRNAs for tubulin and other flagellar proteins, without affecting levels of mRNAs for nonflagellar proteins.     

Accelerated poly(A) loss and mRNA stabilization are independent effects of protein synthesis inhibition on alpha-tubulin mRNA in Chlamydomonas.

In Chlamydomonas, the usual rapid degradation of tubulin mRNAs induced by flagellar amputation is prevented by inhibition of protein synthesis with cycloheximide. Evidence is presented that the ability of cycloheximide to stabilize alpha-tubulin mRNA depends on the time of addition. Addition of cycloheximide to cells before induction strongly stabilizes the induced mRNAs, while addition after their synthesis stabilizes them only transiently. Moreover, cycloheximide inhibition does not stabilize the same alpha-tubulin mRNA species in uninduced cells. These results suggest that cycloheximide is not acting to stabilize the induced alpha-tubulin mRNAs simply by preventing ribosome translocation. The stabilized state of tubulin mRNA was found to correlate with its occurrence on smaller polysomes but larger EDTA-released mRNP particles than the unstable state. A second effect of cycloheximide on the metabolism of induced tubulin mRNAs is to accelerate complete poly(A) removal. This effect of cycloheximide inhibition, unlike stabilization, occurs whenever cycloheximide is added to cells, and appears unrelated to stabilization. The effect is shown to be mRNA-specific; poly(A)-shortening on the rbcS2 mRNA is not altered in the presence of cycloheximide, nor do completely deadenylated molecules accumulate. Experiments in which cells were released from cycloheximide inhibition suggest that deadenylated alpha-tubulin mRNAs may be less stable than their polyadenylated counterparts during active translation.     

Effect of viral infection on host protein synthesis and mRNA association with the cytoplasmic cytoskeletal structure

We studied the association of several eucaryotic viral and cellular mRNAs with cytoskeletal fractions derived from normal and virus-infected cells. We found that all mRNAs appear to associate with the cytoskeletal structure during protein synthesis, irrespective of their 5' and 3' terminal structures: e.g., poliovirus that lacks a 5' cap structure or reovirus and histone mRNAs that lack a 3' poly A tail associated with the cytoskeletal framework to the same extent as capped, polyadenylated actin mRNA. Cellular (actin) and viral (vesicular stomatitis virus and reovirus) mRNAs were released from the cytoskeletal framework and their translation was inhibited when cells were infected with poliovirus. In contrast, actin mRNA was not released from the cytoskeleton during vesicular stomatitis virus infection although actin synthesis was inhibited. In addition, several other conditions under which protein synthesis is inhibited did not result in the release of mRNAs from the cytoskeletal framework. We conclude that the association of mRNA with the cytoskeletal framework is required but is not sufficient for protein synthesis in eucaryotes. Furthermore, the shut-off of host protein synthesis during poliovirus infection and not vesicular stomatitis virus infection occurs by a unique mechanism that leads to the release of host mRNAs from the cytoskeleton.     

Coordinate accumulation of contractile protein mRNAs during myoblast differentiation.

The synthesis of contractile protein mRNAs has been studied during the differentiation of quail skeletal muscle myoblasts in culture. Eight contractile protein mRNAs were identified by translation of total cellular RNA isolated from differentiated myofibers in wheat germ and reticulocyte lysates. Products of the translation systems were fractionated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, and incorporation of [³⁵S]methionine into individual contractile proteins was quantitated by computerized densitometry of autoradiograms. These translation assay systems were used to quantitate levels of contractile protein mRNAs in cultures of myoblasts undergoing highly synchronous differentiation. Our results show that dividing myoblasts contain very little, if any, translatable contractile protein mRNA. The mRNAs coding for myosin heavy chain, the musclespecific actin, three myosin light chains, two tropomyosin subunits, and one troponin subunit begin to coordinately accumulate at fusion, when contractile protein synthesis is activated. Their levels increase 50- to 200-fold during the next 30 hr, paralleling increases in the rates of contractile protein synthesis. These results indicate that the contractile protein mRNAs accumulate coordinately during myoblast differentiation and that contractile protein synthesis is regulated by changes in the levels of these mRNAs.     

Spatial organization of the synthesis of cytoskeletal proteins

The cytoskeleton of most cells is complex and spatially diverse. The mRNAs for some cytoskeletal proteins are localized, suggesting that synthesis of these proteins may occur at sites appropriate for function or assembly. mRNA concentrations were first observed for several oocyte and embryonic mRNAs. Some insight has been gained into the mechanisms that help to position these mRNAs. More surprising to some, many cytoskeletal mRNAs are also localized. Among them are mRNAs for actin, tubulin, intermediate filaments, and a variety of associated proteins. Different mRNAs in the same cell can be located in different places; the same mRNA can be located in different places; the same mRNA can be located differently at different times of development. For example, we observed vimentin mRNA in developing chicken muscle cultures by fluorescent in situ hybridization. We found that vimentin mRNA takes on a variety of positions during myogenesis, ending up located with its cognate protein at costameres. This last pattern is significant because it is too finely structured to have a function in the soluble phase and probably reflects contranslational assembly of this particular protein. Analogies can be made between oocyte or embryonic positions (animal/vegetal poles, oocyte cortex, and interior) and somatic cell positions (anterior/posterior and cell cortex/cell center). These analogies may point to conserved mechanisms for moving and retaining mRNA. Localization of cytoskeletal synthesis, through the mRNA or by other means, may prove as important for assembling and maintaining differentiated cytoskeletal structures and somatic cells as mRNA location is for organizing the embryo. Mechanisms that permit mRNA localization are likely to be conserved.