Metabolic depression and sodium-potassium ATPase in the aestivating frog, Neobatrachus kunapalari

In aestivation the metabolic rate of the Australian desert frog Neobatrachus kunapalari was 50–67% lower than in the non-aestivating state. The rate of O₂ consumption of isolated muscle, skin and brain was measured in both metabolic states. The average rate of O₂ consumption of muscle was 30% lower and brain 50% lower in aestivating frogs, while the rate of O₂ consumption of skin was the same. The reduction in muscle could account for a large proportion of whole animal metabolic depression. To look for evidence of a reduction in energy demand in the tissues we measured the ouabain-sensitive fraction of tissue rate of O₂ consumption, which is considered to be the proportion of metabolism used for transmembrane Na⁺/K⁺ pumping. Ouabain inhibited the in vitro rate of O₂ consumption of skin by a average of 20% and of brain by an average of 30%. However, in muscle, ouabain stimulated in vitro O₂ consumption. Despite the 50% reduction in the in vitro rate of O₂ consumption of brain during aestivation, neither the ouabain-sensitive nor ouabain-insensitive fractions were found be statistically different, possibly because of the large individual variation in the degree of ouabain inhibition. A reduction in the level of ion pumping during aestivation was therefore not demonstrated in any tissue. Measurement of the level of the enzyme Na⁺K⁺-ATPase in skeletal muscle, ventricle, kidney and brain showed that there was no change in the amount of this enzyme in the aestivating frogs. Measurement of the levels of adenylates in muscle and liver showed that the adenylate energy charge was maintained in aestivation, but that there was a reduction in ATP in liver and a reduction in the level of total adenylates in both tissues, which could be an adaptation of the tissues to a lower energy turnover. Accepted: 22 July 1996     

Tissue-specific changes in protein synthesis associated with seasonal metabolic depression and recovery in the north temperate labrid, Tautogolabrus adspersus

The tissue-specific changes in protein synthesis were tracked in relation to the seasonal metabolic depression in cunner (Tautogolabrus adsperus). In vivo protein synthesis rate and total RNA content were determined in liver, white muscle, brain, heart, and gill during periods of normal activity before metabolic depression, entrance into and during winter dormancy, and during the recovery period. The decrease in water temperature from 8 degrees C to 4 degrees C was accompanied by a 55% depression of protein synthesis in liver, brain, and heart and a 66% depression in gill. Protein synthesis in white muscle fell below detectable levels at this temperature. The depression of protein synthesis is an active process (Q(10) = 6-21 between 8 degrees C and 4 degrees C) that occurs in advance of the behavioral and physiological depression at the whole animal level. Protein synthesis was maintained at these depressed levels in white muscle, brain, heart, and gill until water temperature returned to 4 degrees C in the spring. Liver underwent a hyperactivation in the synthesis of proteins at 0 degrees C, which may be linked to antifreeze production. During the recovery period, a hyperactivation of protein synthesis occurred in white muscle, which is suggestive of compensatory growth, as well as in heart and liver, which is considered to be linked to increased activity and feeding. Seasonal changes in total RNA content demonstrate the depression of protein synthesis with decreasing temperature to be closely associated with translational capacity, but the stimulation of protein synthesis during recovery appears to be associated with increased translational efficiency.     

Metabolic depression and Na+/K+ gradients in the aestivating Australian goldfields frog,Neobatrachus wilsmorei

During aestivation the metabolic rate of the Australian goldfields frog Neobatrachus wilsmorei was reduced by 80% from its standard metabolic rate. The in vitro rate of oxygen consumption of isolated muscle and skin from aestivating frogs was up to 50% lower than that of the non-aestivating frogs. This in vitro rate of oxygen consumption was maintained for 6–12 h, indicating an intrinsic metabolic depression of tissues during aestivation. Frogs became dehydrated during aestivation. Muscle, skin and liver also became dehydrated during aestivation, but brain and kidney did not. Na⁺ and K⁺ contents and extracellular space measurement for muscle indicated that ion gradients were maintained across the muscle cell membrane during aestivation. Increases in plasma concentrations of Na⁺ and K⁺ were matched with similar increases in muscle intracellular ion concentrations. Extracellular space measurements were unsuccessful in the other tissues, but K⁺ content in all tissues (per dry weight) was maintained during aestivation, and the concentration of plasma K⁺ did not increase above that which can be accounted for by dehydration, indicating that K⁺ gradients were maintained.Abbreviations bm body mass - DPM disintegrations per minute - dw dry weight - MR metabolic rate - vO₂ rate of oxygen consumption - ww wet weight     

Metabolic depression during aestivation in Cyclorana alboguttata

The green striped burrowing frog, Cyclorana alboguttata, spends, on average, nine to ten months of every year in aestivation. Recently, C. alboguttata has been the focus of much investigation regarding the physiological processes involved in aestivation, yet our understanding of this frog's capacity to metabolically depress remains limited. This study aimed to extend our current knowledge of metabolic depression during aestivation in C. alboguttata. C. alboguttata reduced whole animal metabolism by 82% within 5 weeks of aestivation. The effects of aestivation on mass specific in vitro tissue metabolic rate (VO₂) varied among individual organs, with muscle and liver slices showing significant reductions in metabolism; kidney VO₂ was elevated and there was no change in the VO₂ of small intestine tissue slices. Organ size was also affected by aestivation, with significant reductions in the mass of all tissues, except the gastrocnemius. These reductions in organ size, combined with changes in mass specific VO₂ of tissue slices, resulted in further energy savings to aestivating animals. This study shows that C. alboguttata is capable of selectively down- or up-regulating individual tissues, using both changes in metabolic rate and morphology. This strategy allows maximal energy savings during aestivation without compromising organ functionality and survival at arousal.     

Metabolic depression during aestivation does not involve remodelling of membrane fatty acids in two Australian frogs

Changes in membrane lipid composition (membrane remodelling) have been associated with metabolic depression in some aestivating snails but has not been studied in aestivating frogs. This study examined the membrane phospholipid composition of two Australian aestivating frog species Cyclorana alboguttata and Cyclorana australis. The results showed no major membrane remodelling of tissue in either frog species, or in mitochondria of C. alboguttata due to aestivation. Mitochondrial membrane remodelling was not investigated in C. australis. Where investigated in C. alboguttata, total protein and phospholipid content, and citrate synthase (CS) and cytochrome c oxidase (CCO) activities in tissues and mitochondria mostly did not change with aestivation in liver. In skeletal muscle, however, CS and CCO activities, mitochondrial and tissue phospholipids, and mitochondrial protein decreased with aestivation. These decreases in muscle indicate that skeletal muscle mitochondrial content may decrease during aestivation. Na⁺K⁺ATPase activity of both frog species showed no effect of aestivation. In C. alboguttata different fat diets had a major effect on both tissue and mitochondrial phospholipid composition indicating an ability to remodel membrane composition that is not utilised in aestivation. Therefore, changes in lipid composition associated with some aestivating snails do not occur during aestivation in these Australian frogs.     

Protein synthesis is defended in the mitochondrial fraction of gill but not heart in cunner (Tautogolabrus adspersus) exposed to acute hypoxia and hypothermia

The cunner, Tautogolabrus adspersus, is a north-temperate teleost which relies upon metabolic depression to survive the extreme low water temperatures of its habitat during the winter. Previous study has demonstrated a decrease in protein synthesis accompanies the metabolic depression observed at the whole animal level during seasonal low temperature exposure. As such, the objective of the current study was to determine: (i) if the response of decreased protein synthesis is conserved across environmental stressors and (ii) if the response of metabolic depression is conserved across levels of cellular organization. This was accomplished through the measurement of in vivo protein synthesis rates in the whole tissue, cytosolic and mitochondrial protein pools (reflective of nuclear encoded proteins imported into mitochondria) of heart and gill in cunner exposed to either acute low temperature (8–4°C) or acute hypoxia (10% O₂ saturation). In both heart and gill, rates of protein synthesis in the whole tissue and cytosolic protein pools were substantially depressed by 80% in response to acute hypothermia. In hypoxic heart, protein synthesis was significantly decreased by 50–60% in the whole tissue, cytosolic and mitochondrial pools; however, in gill there was no significant difference in rates of protein synthesis in any cellular fraction between normoxic and hypoxic groups. Most strikingly the rate of new protein accumulation in the mitochondrial fraction of gill did not change in response to either a decrease in temperature or hypoxia. The defense of protein synthesis in the gill is most likely associated with the importance of maintaining ionic regulation and the oxidative capacity in this front line organ for gas and ion exchange.     

Enzyme activity in the aestivating Green-striped burrowing frog (Cyclorana alboguttata)

Green-striped burrowing frogs (Cyclorana alboguttata) can depress their resting metabolism by more than 80% during aestivation. Previous studies have shown that this species is able to withstand long periods of immobilisation during aestivation while apparently maintaining whole muscle mass and contractile performance. The aim of this study was to determine the effect of prolonged aestivation on the levels of metabolic enzymes (CCO, LDH and CS) in functionally distinct skeletal muscles (cruralis, gastrocnemius, sartorius, iliofibularis and rectus abdominus) and liver of C. alboguttata. CS activity was significantly reduced in all tissues except for the cruralis, gastrocnemius and the liver. LDH activity was significantly reduced in the sartorius and rectus abdominus, but remained at control (active) levels in the other tissues. CCO activity was significantly reduced in the gastrocnemius and rectus abdominus, and unchanged in the remaining tissues. Muscle protein was significantly reduced in the sartorius and iliofibularis during aestivation, and unchanged in the remaining muscles. The results suggest that the energy pathways involved in the production and consumption of ATP are remodelled during prolonged aestivation but selective. Remodelling and subsequent down-regulation of metabolic activity seem to target the smaller non-jumping muscles, while the jumping muscles retain enzyme activities at control levels during aestivation. These results suggest a mechanism by which aestivating C. alboguttata are able to maintain metabolic depression while ensuring that the functional capacity of critical muscles is not compromised upon emergence from aestivation.     

In vivo downregulation of protein synthesis in the snail Helix apersa during estivation

Protein synthesis is downregulated during metabolic depression in a number of systems where the metabolic depression is effected by obvious extrinsic cues. The metabolic depression of the estivating land snail Helix apersa occurs in the absence of any obvious physiological stress and has an intrinsic component independent of temperature, pH, O(2) status, or osmolality. We show that this metabolic depression is accompanied by a downregulation of protein synthesis in vivo. The rate of protein synthesis decreases in two major tissues during estivation: to 23% and 53% of the awake rate in hepatopancreas and foot muscle, respectively. We show from calculations of the theoretical contribution of protein synthesis to total O(2) consumption that the depression of protein synthesis must be a significant, obligate, in vivo component of metabolic depression in H. aspersa.     

Lipid, ketone body and oxidative metabolism in the African lungfish, Protopterus dolloi following 60 days of fasting and aestivation

The potential importance of lipids and ketone bodies as fuels in the African lungfish, Protopterus dolloi, and the role of oxidative metabolism, were examined under control, fasted and aestivated conditions. In aestivating but not fasting lungfish, the activities of citrate synthase (CS) and cytochrome c oxidase (CCO) (enzymes of oxidative metabolism) showed tissue-specific changes. Significant reductions in CS activity occurred in the kidney, heart, gill and muscle, and in CCO in the liver and kidney tissues. Aestivation, but not fasting, also had a tissue-specific effect on mitochondrial state 3 respiration rates (using succinate as a substrate), with a >50% reduction in the liver, yet no change within muscle mitochondria. There is no indication that enzymes involved in lipid catabolism are up-regulated during periods of fasting or aestivation; however, both 3-hydroxyacyl CoA dehydrogenase (HOAD) and carnitine palmitoyl CoA transferase (CPT) activities were sustained in the liver despite the approximately 42% reduction in CCO activity, potentially indicating lipid metabolism is of importance during aestivation. Lungfish are able to utilize both the d- and l-stereoisomers of the ketone body beta-hydroxybutyrate (beta-HB); however, beta-HB does not appear to be an important fuel source during aestivation or fasting as no changes were observed in beta-HB tissue levels. This study demonstrates that an important aspect of metabolic depression during aestivation in lungfish is the tissue-specific down regulation of enzymes of aerobic metabolism while maintaining the activities of enzymes in pathways that supply substrates for aerobic metabolism.     

Time course of the effect of catabolic doses of corticosterone on protein turnover in rat skeletal muscle and liver.

The time course of the response of protein synthesis in muscle and liver to catabolic doses of corticosterone (10 mg/day per 100 g body wt.) was studied in vivo in growing rats over a 12-day period. The rate of protein synthesis in muscle and liver and the rate of actomyosin synthesis in muscle were measured by the phenylalanine-flooding technique, and 3-methylhistidine (N tau-methylhistidine) synthesis was measured by injection of labelled histidine. 3-Methylhistidine concentrations in tissue free pools and urinary excretion were also measured to compare directly with the rate of muscle protein degradation determined as the difference between synthesis and growth each day during the treatment. The overall rate of protein synthesis in muscle fell gradually over the first 4 days, reaching a rate after 5 days that was 36% of the initial rate, and this lower rate was then maintained for the following week. This decrease in the overall rate was accompanied with changes in the relative rate of synthesis in muscle proteins, since during the first 4 days there was a disproportionate decrease in the rate of actomyosin synthesis, and specifically 3-methylhistidine synthesis. In the latter case the synthesis rate was decreased to only 4% of its initial rate after 4 days. These changes in protein synthesis in muscle were accompanied by a transient increase in the rate of protein degradation, which was more than doubled on days 2 and 3 of treatment but which returned to the original rate on day 5, and a similar pattern of response was indicated by urinary 3-methylhistidine excretion, which also exhibited a transient increase. Thus in this case 3-methylhistidine excretion and measured rates of protein degradation in muscle do correlate. The transient effects of the glucocorticoids on degradation compared with the sustained effect on synthesis suggest that these two responses are achieved by different mechanisms. The hepatic size and protein mass were increased by the treatment, and protein synthesis was well maintained until after 12 days, when the rate was suppressed. Although the fractional synthesis rate was transiently increased for 24 h, it is argued that the enlarged liver most likely reflects a decrease in protein degradation resulting from the increased amino acid supply to the liver. This would result from the cessation of muscle growth while dietary supply was maintained.     

The interplay of increased urea synthesis and reduced ammonia production in the African lungfish Protopterus aethiopicus during 46 days of aestivation in a mucus cocoon

This study was undertaken to test the hypothesis that the rate of urea synthesis in Protopterus aethiopicus was up-regulated to detoxify ammonia during the initial phase of aestivation in air (day 1-day 12), and that a profound suppression of ammonia production occurred at a later phase of aestivation (day 35-day 46) which eliminated the need to sustain the increased rate of urea synthesis. Fasting apparently led to a greater rate of nitrogenous waste excretion in P. aethiopicus in water, which is an indication of increases in production of endogenous ammonia and urea probably as a result of increased proteolysis and amino acid catabolism for energy production. However, 46 days of fasting had no significant effects on the ammonia or urea contents in the muscle, liver, plasma and brain. In contrast, there were significant decreases in the muscle ammonia content in fish after 12, 34 or 46 days of aestivation in air when compared with fish fasting in water. Ammonia was apparently detoxified to urea because urea contents in the muscle, liver, plasma and brain of P. aethiopicus aestivated for 12, 34 or 46 days were significantly greater than the corresponding fasting control; the greatest increases in urea contents occurred during the initial 12 days. There were also significant increases in activities of some of the hepatic ornithine-urea cycle enzymes from fish aestivated for 12 or 46 days. Therefore, contrary to a previous report on P. aethiopicus, our results demonstrated an increase in the estimated rate of urea synthesis (2.8-fold greater than the day 0 fish) in this lungfish during the initial 12 days of aestivation. However, the estimated rate of urea synthesis decreased significantly during the next 34 days. Between day 35 and day 46 (12 days), urea synthesis apparently decreased to 42% of the day 0 control value, and this is the first report of such a phenomenon in African lungfish undergoing aestivation. On the other hand, the estimated rate of ammonia production in P. aethiopicus increased slightly (14.7%) during the initial 12 days of aestivation as compared with that in the day 0 fish. By contrast, the estimated rate of ammonia production decreased by 84% during the final 12 days of aestivation (day 35-day 46) compared with the day 0 value. Therefore, it can be concluded that P. aethiopicus depended mainly on increased urea synthesis to ameliorate ammonia toxicity during the initial phase of aestivation, but during prolonged aestivation, it suppressed ammonia production profoundly, eliminating the need to increase urea synthesis which is energy-intensive.     

Protein synthesis in the liver of Bufo marinus: cost and contribution to oxygen consumption

While many estimates of the contribution of protein synthesis to metabolic rate exist for a variety of animals, most rely on theoretical costs of protein synthesis. The limitations of this approach are that theoretical costs depend upon variable estimates of ATP cost per peptide bond. In addition, they do not take into account the fact that there are protein-specific pre- and post-translational costs. By inhibiting, protein synthesis with cycloheximide and measuring the resultant decrease in oxygen consumption, we have measured the actual cost of protein synthesis and its contribution to metabolic rate in an in vitro system of tissue slices from Bufo marinus. Such measurements exist for endotherms, but there are few such measurements for ectotherms, and none have been done previously for amphibians. The cost of protein synthesis in liver slices from B. marinus was 7.32+/-1.19 mmol O2 x g(protein)(-1) (x +/- SE, n = 48) and protein synthesis accounted for 12% of the total metabolic rate of this tissue. This cost is comparable to values measured for other ectotherms although the contribution of protein synthesis to metabolic rate is at the lower end of the range of estimates for other ectotherms.     

Early development of protein metabolic perturbations in the liver and skeletal muscle of tumour-bearing rats. A model system for cancer cachexia.

In rats into which a fast-growing ascites hepatoma (Yoshida AH-130) had been transplanted, tumour growth elicited a marked loss of body weight until the animal's death in about 2 weeks. Overall tissue protein metabolism was simultaneously studied in vivo in the gastrocnemius muscle and liver after labelling with [14C]bicarbonate. Early and progressive atrophy developed in the gastrocnemius muscle, the underlying metabolic imbalance being expressed by an elevation in the apparent protein-degradation rate, with no changes in the apparent synthesis rate. A transient hyperplastic response preceded waste in the liver, both states being associated with alterations in protein-degradation rate: an initial decrease during liver growth, then an acceleration as liver regressed. Protein-synthesis rates, virtually unchanged during liver growth, were elevated in the subsequent phase, although not sufficient to balance the enhanced breakdown. Thus, in the tumour host tissues examined, altered states of protein turnover appeared to result mostly from changes in rates of protein breakdown. In sharp contrast with the negative protein balance in the host, the ascites hepatoma cells had the ability to grow or at least, in advanced stages, to maintain a stationary state.     

Protein metabolism in the mouse during pregnancy and lactation.

Protein synthesis was measured in vivo in the whole body and in a number of individual tissues in mice at various stages of pregnancy and lactation. The absolute rate of protein synthesis in the whole body increased from 640 mg/day in virgin mice to 1590 mg/day by day 18 of pregnancy, and to 2100 mg/day by day 15 of lactation. Large proportions of these increments were contributed by the rapidly growing foetuses and placentae in the pregnant animals and by protein synthesis in the mammary glands during lactation. In addition, a substantial stimulation of growth and protein synthesis was also observed in the liver and the gastrointestinal tract. Gastrocnemius muscle showed no changes in protein metabolism, indicating that in the well-fed mouse this tissue is not required to play a role as a protein reserve during pregnancy and lactation.     

Protein turnover and growth in the whole body, liver and kidney of the rat from the foetus to senility.

Changes in the growth and protein turnover (measured in vivo) of the rat liver, kidney and whole body were studied between 16 days of life in utero and 105 weeks post partum. Tissue and whole-body growth were related to changes in both cellular hyperplasia (i.e. changes in DNA) and hypertrophy (protein/DNA values) and to the protein composition within the enlarging tissue mass. The suitability of using a single large dose of phenylalanine for measuring the rates of protein synthesis during both pre- and post-natal life was established. The declining growth rates in the whole animal and the two visceral tissues were then explained by developmental changes in the fractional rates of protein synthesis and breakdown, turnover rates being age-for-age higher in the liver than in the kidney, which in turn were higher than those measured in the whole animal. The declining fractional rates of synthesis in both tissues and the whole body with increasing age were related to changes in the tissues' ribosomal capacity and activity. The fall in the hepatic rate between 18 and 20 days of foetal life (from 134 to 98% per day) corresponded to a decrease in both the ribosomal capacity and the rate of synthesis per ribosome. No significant changes in any of these parameters were, however, found in the liver between weaning (3 weeks) and senility (105 weeks). In contrast, the fractional synthetic (and degradative) rates progressively declined in the kidney (from 95 to 24% per day) and whole body (from 70 to 11% per day) throughout both pre- and post-natal life, mainly as a consequence of a progressive decline in the ribosomal capacity, but with some fall in the ribosomal activity also during foetal life. The age-related contributions of these visceral tissues to the total amount of protein synthesized per day by the whole animal were determined. The renal contribution remained fairly constant at 1.6-2.9%, whereas the hepatic contribution declined from 56 to 11%, with increasing age. Approximate-steady-state conditions were reached at, and between, 44 and 105 weeks post partum, the half-life values of mixed whole-body, kidney and liver proteins being 6.4, 3.0 and 1.5 days, respectively, at 105 weeks.     

Alterations of mitochondrial protein metabolism in liver, brown adipose tissue and skeletal muscle. During cold-acclimation.

Incorporation of L-[U-14C] leucine into liver, brown adipose tissue and skeletal muscle mitochondrial proteins was determined in vivo and in vitro during cold-acclimation. Major alterations in mitochondrial protein metabolism were observed in brown adipose tissue and skeletal muscle but not in liver. Immediate cold-exposure is accompanied by an inhibition of the in vivo incorporation of L-[U-14C] leucine into mitochondrial proteins of all tissues. However, during cold-acclimation the incorporation of leucine increases markedly in brown adipose tissue, continues to decrease in skeletal muscle, nut does not change appreciably in the liver. Because increased incorporation of L-[U-14C]-leucine into brown adipose tissue mitochondrial proteins was observed both in vivo and in vitro, it can be concluded that the mitochondrial protein-synthesizing system of this tissue is directly affected by the acclimation process. The observed changes in mitochondrial protein metabolism of brown adipose tissue and skeletal muscle might be responsible for the development of several morphological and biochemical alterations that characterize the establishment in these tissues of the cold-acclimated state.     

Estimation of growth potential by measurement of tissue protein synthetic rates in feeding and fasting rainbow trout, Salmo gairdnerii Richardson

Protein synthesis in liver, gill and muscle tissue was measured in vivo by constant infusion of ¹⁴C-tyrosine in fed and fasted freshwater rainbow trout, Salmo gairdnerii , at 12° C. Synthesis rates (percentage of tissue protein synthesized per day) were 15-17% in liver, 4–5% in gill and 0.38% in muscle of fed fish. Liver and gill synthesis rate showed no significant change in fish that had been without food for 15 days, whereas muscle protein synthesis fell to 0.09%. The greater susceptability of muscle protein synthesis to fasting, possibly results from the greater proportion of synthesis retained as growth in this tissue. Growth rates indicate little change in protein turnover in the muscle but increased protein degradation with fasting. The difference between fed and fasted synthesis rates in muscle may be used as a measurement of potential growth rate for a particular species.     

Increased urea synthesis and/or suppressed ammonia production in the African lungfish, Protopterus annectens, during aestivation in air or mud

The objective of this study was to elucidate how the African lungfish, Protopterus annectens, ameliorated ammonia toxicity during 12 or 46 days of aestivation in air or in mud. Twelve days of aestivation in air led to significant increases in contents of urea, but not ammonia, in tissues of P. annectens. The estimated rate of urea synthesis increased 2.7-fold despite the lack of changes in the activities of hepatic ornithine–urea cycle enzymes, but there was only a minor change in the estimated rate of ammonia production. After 46 days of aestivation in air, the ammonia content in the liver decreased significantly and contents of urea in all tissues studied increased significantly, indicating that the fish shifted to a combination of increased urea synthesis (1.4-fold of the day 0 value) and decreased ammonia production (56% of the day 0 value) to defend against ammonia toxicity. By contrast, 12 days of aestivation in mud produced only minor increases in tissue urea contents, with ammonia contents remained unchanged. This was apparently achieved through decreases in urea synthesis and ammonia production (40 and 15%, respectively, of the corresponding day 0 value). Surprisingly, 46 days of aestivation in mud resulted in no changes in tissue urea contents, indicating that profound suppressions of urea synthesis and ammonia production (2.6 and 1.2%, respectively, of the corresponding day 0 value) had occurred. This is the first report on such a phenomenon, and the reduction in ammonia production was so profound that it could be the greatest reduction known among animals. Since fish aestivated in mud had relatively low blood pO₂ and muscle ATP content, they could have been exposed to hypoxia, which induced reductions in metabolic rate and ammonia production. Consequently, fish aestivating in mud had a lower dependency on increased urea synthesis to detoxify ammonia, which is energy intensive, than fish aestivating in air.