Sequence-dependent DNA structure: dinucleotide conformational maps

We have used a computational model to calculate the potential energy surface for dinucleotide steps in double helical DNA as a function of the two principal degrees of freedom, slide and shift. By using a virtual bond to model the constraints imposed by the sugar-phosphate backbone, twist, roll, tilt and rise can be simultaneously optimised for any given values of slide and shift. Thus we have been able to construct complete conformational maps for all step types. For some steps, the maps agree well with experimental data from X-ray crystal structures, but other steps appear to be strongly perturbed by the effects of context (conformational coupling with the neighbouring steps). The optimised values of twist and roll show sequence-dependent variations consistent with the crystal structure data. The conformational maps allow us to construct adiabatic paths, and hence calculate the flexibility of each step with respect to slide and shift. Again the results agree well with the available experimental assignments of flexibility: YR steps, CA/TG and CG, are the most flexible and RR steps, such as AA, the least flexible.     

Chiral phosphorothioate analogues of B-DNA. The crystal structure of Rp-d[Gp(S)CpGp(S)CpGp(S)C]

The compound Rp-d[Gp(S)CpGp(S)CpGp(S)C], an analogue of the deoxyoligomer d(G-C)3, crystallizes in space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) with a = 34.90 A, b = 39.15 A and c = 20.64 A. The structure, which is not isomorphous with any previously determined deoxyoligonucleotide, was refined to an R factor of 14.5% at a resolution of 2.17 A, with 72 solvent molecules located. The two strands of the asymmetric unit form a right-handed double helix, which is a new example of a B-DNA conformation and brings to light an important and overlooked component of flexibility of the double helix. This flexibility is manifest in the alternation of the backbone conformation between two states, defined by the adjacent torsion angles epsilon and zeta, trans . gauche-(BI) and gauche-. trans (BII). BI is characteristic of classical of B-DNA and has an average C(1') to C(1') separation of 4.5 A. The corresponding separation for BII is 5.3 A. Each state is associated with a distinct phosphate orientation where the plane of the PO2 (or POS) group is alternately near horizontal or vertical with respect to the helix axis. The BI and BII conformations are out of phase on the two strands. As a consequence, on one strand purine-pyrimidine stacking is better than pyrimidine-purine, while the converse holds for the other strand. At each base-pair step, good and bad stacking alternate across the helix axis. The pattern of alternation is regular in the context of a fundamental dinucleotide repeat. Re-examination of the B-DNA dodecamer d(C-G-C-G-A-A-T-T-C-G-C-G) shows that the C-G-C-G regions contain the BI and BII conformations, and the associated dual phosphate orientation and asymmetric base stacking. Different mechanisms are used in the two structures to avoid clashes between guanine residues on opposite strands, a combination of lateral slide, tilt and helical twist in the present structure, and base roll, tilt and longitudinal slide (Calladine rules) in the dodecamer. The flexibility of the phosphate orientations demonstrated in this structure is important, since it offers a structural basis for protein-nucleic acid recognition.     

Flexibility of the B-DNA backbone: effects of local and neighbouring sequences on pyrimidine-purine steps.

The structurally correlated dihedral angles epsilon and zeta are known for their large variability within the B-DNA backbone. We have used molecular modelling to study both energetic and mechanical features of these variations which can produce BI/BII transitions. Calculations were carried out on DNA oligomers containing either YpR or RpY dinucleotides steps within various sequence environments. The results indicate that CpA and CpG steps favour the BI/BII transition more than TpA or any RpY step. The stacking energy and its intra- and inter-strand components explain these effects. Analysis of neighbouring base pairs reveals that BI/BII transitions of CpG and CpA are easiest within (Y)n(R)n sequences. These can also induce a large vibrational amplitude for TpA steps within the BI conformation.     

Stacking interactions in RNA and DNA: Roll‐slide energy hyperspace for ten unique dinucleotide steps

Understanding dinucleotide sequence directed structures of nuleic acids and their variability from experimental observation remained ineffective due to unavailability of statistically meaningful data. We have attempted to understand this from energy scan along twist, roll, and slide degrees of freedom which are mostly dependent on dinucleotide sequence using ab initio density functional theory. We have carried out stacking energy analysis in these dinucleotide parameter phase space for all ten unique dinucleotide steps in DNA and RNA using DFT‐D by ωB97X‐D/6‐31G(2d,2p), which appears to satisfactorily explain conformational preferences for AU/AU step in our recent study. We show that values of roll, slide, and twist of most of the dinucleotide sequences in crystal structures fall in the low energy region. The minimum energy regions with large twist values are associated with the roll and slide values of B‐DNA, whereas, smaller twist values correspond to higher stability to RNA and A‐DNA like conformations. Incorporation of solvent effect by CPCM method could explain the preference shown by some sequences to occur in B‐DNA or A‐DNA conformations. Conformational preference of BII sub‐state in B‐DNA is preferentially displayed mainly by pyrimidine–purine steps and partly by purine–purine steps. The purine–pyrimidine steps show largest effect of 5‐methyl group of thymine in stacking energy and the introduction of solvent reduces this effect significantly. These predicted structures and variabilities can explain the effect of sequence on DNA and RNA functionality. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 103: 134–147, 2015.     

DNA fine structure and dynamics in crystals and in solution: the impact of BI/BII backbone conformations

Sugar-phosphate backbone conformations are an important structural element for a complete understanding of specific recognition in nucleic acid-protein interactions. They can be involved both in early stages of target discrimination and in structural adaptation upon binding. In the first part of this study, we have analyzed high-resolution structures of double-stranded B-DNA either isolated or bound to proteins, and explored the impact of both the standard BI and the unusual BII phosphate backbone conformations on neighboring sugar puckers and on selected helical parameters. Correlations are found to be similar for free and bound DNA, and in both categories, the possible facing backbone conformations (BI.BI, BI.BII, and BII.BII) define well-characterized substates in the B-DNA conformational space. Notably, BII.BII steps are characterized by specific, and sequence-independent, structural effects involving reduced standard deviations for almost all conformational parameters. In the second part of this work, we analyze four 10 ns molecular dynamics simulations in explicit solvent on the DNA targets of NF-kappaB and bovine papillomavirus E2 proteins, highlighting the multiplicity of backbone dynamical behavior. These results show sequence effects on the percentages of BI and BII conformers, the preferential state of facing backbones, the occurrence of coupled transitions. The backbone states can consequently be seen as a mechanism for transmitting information from the bases to the phosphate groups and thus for modulating the overall structural properties of the target DNA.     

M.TaqI facilitates the base flipping via an unusual DNA backbone conformation

MD simulations have been carried out to understand the dynamical behavior of the DNA substrate of the Thermus aquaticus DNA methyltransferase (M.TaqI) in the methylation process at N6 of adenine. As starting structures, an x-ray structure of M.TaqI in complex with DNA and cofactor analogue (PDB code: 1G 38) and free decamer d(GTTCGATGTC)(2) were taken. The x-ray structure shows two consecutive BII substates that are not observed in the free decamer. These consecutive BII substates are also observed during our simulation. Additionally, their facing backbones adopt the same conformations. These double facing BII substates are stable during the last 9 ns of the trajectories and result in a stretched DNA structure. On the other hand, protein-DNA contacts on 5' and 3' phosphodiester groups of the partner thymine of flipped adenine have changed. The sugar and phosphate parts of thymine have moved further into the empty space left by the flipping base without the influence of protein. Furthermore, readily high populated BII substates at the GpA step of palindromic tetrad TCGA rather than CpG step are observed in the free decamer. On the contrary, the BI substate at the GpA step is observed on the flipped adenine strand. A restrained MD simulation, reproducing the BI/BII pattern in the complex, demonstrated the influence of the unusual backbone conformation on the dynamical behavior of the target base. This finding along with the increased nearby interstrand phosphate distance is supportive to the N6-methylation mechanism.     

Sequence-dependent DNA structure: tetranucleotide conformational maps

A database of X-ray crystal structures of double helical DNA oligomers has been used to analyse the role of the sugar-phosphate backbone in coupling the conformational properties of neighbouring dinucleotide steps. The base step parameters which are most strongly coupled to the backbone degrees of freedom are slide and shift, and these are the two dinucleotide step parameters which show strong correlations along a sequence: the value of slide follows the values in the neighbouring steps, whereas shift tends to alternate. This conformational coupling is mediated by the shared furanose rings at the step junctions: a change in the value of slide causes a change in the mean value of the same strand 3' and 5'-chi torsion angle, and a change in the mean value of the 3' and 5' sugar pseudo-rotation phase angle, P; a change in the value of shift causes a difference between the same strand 3' and 5'-chi in A-DNA and a difference between the 3' and 5'-P in B-DNA. We have used a database of tetranucleotide X-ray crystal structures to parameterise a simple model for the coupling of slide and shift. Using this junction model together with our dinucleotide step potential energy maps described previously, we can in principle calculate the structure of any DNA oligomer. The parameterisation indicates that the rotational step parameters are accurate to within 5 degrees, and the translational step parameters are accurate to within 0.5 A. The model has been used to study the potential energy surfaces of all possible tetranucleotide sequences, and the calculations agree well with the experimental data from X-ray crystal structures. Some dinucleotide steps are context independent (AA/TT, AT and TA), because the conformational properties of all possible neighbouring steps are compatible. When the conformational properties of the neighbours are not compatible, the behaviour of a step cannot be understood at the dinucleotide level. Thus the conformations of CG, GC and GG/CC are all strongly context dependent. The remaining mixed sequence steps show weakly context-dependent behaviour. The approach allows the calculation of the relative stability and flexibility of tetranucleotide sequences, and the results indicate why TATA is used as an origin of replication. Clear predictions are made about sequences which have not yet been characterised crystallographically. In particular, poly(CCA).poly(TGG) is predicted to have an unusual structure which lies between the C and D-DNA polymorphs.     

Sequence Effects On The Propeller Twist Of Base Pairs In DNA Helices

Abstract

Molecular mechanics calculations are performed on all the ten base pair steps (duplex dimers) and also a number of trimer and tetramer duplexes comprising them, in an attempt to systematically examine the possible base sequence effects on the magnitudes of propeller twists of base pairs at a given step. The analysis reveals that though propeller twist is a base pair property, it behaves very much like other base step parameters such as slide, roll, twist etc., Hence, it may be necessary to monitor the nature and variation of magnitudes of pt at a step. Calculations performed on 45 out of the 136 unique tetramer combinations involving all the ten unique base steps show that the difference in magnitudes of propeller twists of the base pairs of a given step has been found to be either steep or moderate depending on base pairs that flank the base step. These observations compare very well with the available experimental data. Tetramer sequences, wherein abase pair of a base step repeats in the same direction, exhibit a relatively steep difference in propeller twist at the step. Tetramers other than these exhibit moderate difference in propeller twist Such sequences are broadly classified as type-I and type-II respectively. Practically all the tetrads considered in the study, excepting those with GT step and a few involving CG and GC steps, conform to the above classification.     

Unexpected BII conformer substate population in unoriented hydrated films of the d(CGCGAATTCGCG)2 dodecamer and of native B-DNA from salmon testes.

Conformational substates of B-DNA had been observed so far in synthetic oligonucleotides but not in naturally occurring highly polymeric B-DNA. Our low-temperature experiments show that native B-DNA from salmon testes and the d(CGCGAATTCGCG)2 dodecamer have the same BI and BII substates. Nonequilibrium distribution of conformer population was generated by quenching hydrated unoriented films to 200 K, and isothermal structural relaxation toward equilibrium by interconversion of substates was followed by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. BI interconverts into BII on isothermal relaxation at 200 K, whereas on slow cooling from ambient temperature, BII interconverts into BI. Our estimation of the dodecamer's BI-to-BII conformer substate population by curve resolution of the symmetrical stretching vibration of the ionic phosphate is 2.4 +/- 0.5 to 1 at 200 K, and it is 1.3 +/- 0.5 to 1 between 270 and 290 K. Pronounced spectral changes upon BI-to-BII interconversion are consistent with base destacking coupled with migration of water from ionic phosphate toward the phosphodiester and sugar moieties. Nonspecific interaction of proteins with the DNA backbone could become specific by induced-fit-type interactions with either BI or BII backbone conformations. This suggests that the BI-to-BII substate interconversion could be a major contributor to the protein recognition process.     

Sequence dependence of DNA conformational flexibility

By using conformational free energy calculations, we have studied the sequence dependence of flexibility and its anisotropy along various conformational variables of DNA base pairs. The results show the AT base step to be very flexible along the twist coordinate. On the other hand, homonucleotide steps, GG(CC) and AA(TT), are among the most rigid sequences. For the roll motion that would correspond to a bend, the TA step is most flexible, while the GG(CC) step is least flexible. The flexibility of roll is quite anisotropic; the ratio of fluctuations toward the major and minor grooves is the largest for the GC step and the smallest for the AA(TT) and CG steps. Propeller twisting of base pairs is quite flexible, especially of A.T base pairs; propeller twist can reach 19 degrees by thermal fluctuation. We discuss the effect of electrostatic parameters, comparison with available experimental results, and biological relevance of these results.     

Intrinsic bending and deformability at the T-A step of CCTTTAAAGG: a comparative analysis of T-A and A-T steps within A-tracts

Introduction of a T-A or pyrimidine-purine step into a straight and rigid A-tract can cause a positive roll deformation that kinks the DNA helix at that step. In CCTTTAAAGG, the central T-A step has an 8.6 degrees bend toward the major groove. We report the structural analysis of CCTTTAAAGG and a comparison with 25 other representative crystal structures from the NDB containing at least four consecutive A or T bases. On average, more local bending occurs at the disruptive T-A step (8.21 degrees ) than at an A-T step (5.71 degrees ). In addition, A-tracts containing an A-T step are more bent than are pure A-tracts, and hence A-A and A-T steps are not equivalent. All T-A steps examined exhibit positive roll, bending towards the major groove, while A-T steps display negative roll and bend slightly towards the minor groove. This illustrates how inherent negative and positive roll are, respectively, at A-T and T-A steps within A-tracts. T-A steps are more deformable, showing larger and more variable deformations of minor groove width, rise, cup, twist, and buckle. Standard deviations of twist, rise, and cup for T-A steps are 6.66 degrees, 0.55 A, and 15.90 degrees, versus 2.28 degrees, 0.21 A, and 2.99 degrees for A-T steps. Packing constraints determine which local values of these helical parameters an individual T-A step will adopt. For instance, with CCTTTAAAGG and three isomorphous structures, CGATTAATCG, CGATATATCG, and CGATCGATCG, crystal packing forces lead to a series of correlated changes: widened minor groove, large slide, low twist, and large rise. The difference in helical parameters between A-T steps lying within A-tracts, versus A-T steps within alternating AT sequences, demonstrates the importance of neighboring steps on the conformation of a given dinucleotide step.     

The relationship between mutation rates for the (C-G)-->(T-A) transition and features of T-G mispair structures in different neighbor environments, determined by free energy molecular mechanics.

The results of this theoretical study combining sequence analysis and minimization with integral equation liquid structural methods indicate that the local sequence context of a T-G wobble mismatch influences the local conformation of the helix, and that conformational alterations are correlated with mutational activity. Studies on the mismatch in four different 5' and 3' neighbor contexts indicate that the nature of the 5' base to the thymine of the mispair is probably the single most critical factor in determining the structural features that facilitate or discourage mutations. When cytosine is the 5' neighbor, the helix adopts a mostly BII conformation, whereas a 5' guanine preserves the canonical BI. Structures that vary little from the BI structure on the incorporation of the mismatch have sequences that correspond to lower rates of transition, whereas those with mostly BII conformations, have sequences with high mutation rates. Subtle variations in stacking patterns around the mismatch precipitate a structural Domino-effect, with a variety of changes in conformation. The helix opens at the mismatch with increased roll angle and propeller twist, causing the thymine to migrate into the major groove and the guanine into the minor groove, exposing the heteroatomic groups to the solvent in the major and minor grooves, respectively, and allowing for some unusual hydrogen bonds. These alterations show a tentative correlation with mutation rates, implying that stacking and structure around the mismatch are important features in the discrimination by proofreading activities of canonical W-C and wobble mismatch base pairs during replication-repair. Variations in the C1'-C1' distances, high propeller twists, changes in the electrostatic complementarity leading to unusual hydrogen bonding patterns probably all correlate with detectability.     

Sequence-dependent DNA structure: a database of octamer structural parameters

We have constructed the potential energy surfaces for all unique tetramers, hexamers and octamers in double helical DNA, as a function of the two principal degrees of freedom, slide and shift at the central step. From these potential energy maps, we have calculated a database of structural and flexibility properties for each of these sequences. These properties include: the values of each of the six step parameters (twist roll, tilt, rise, slide and shift), for each step of the sequence; flexibility measures for both decrease and increase in each property value from the minimum energy conformation for the central step; and the deviation from the path of a hypothetical straight octamer. In an analysis of structural change as a function of sequence length, we observe that almost all DNA tends to B-DNA and becomes less flexible. A more detailed analysis of octamer properties has allowed us to determine the structural preferences of particular sequence elements. GGC and GCC sequences tend to confer bistability, low stability and a predisposition to A-form DNA, whereas AA steps strongly prefer B-DNA and inhibit A-structures. There is no correlation between flexibility and intrinsic curvature, but bent DNA is less stable than straight. The most difficult deformation is undertwisting. The TA step stands out as the most flexible sequence element with respect to decreasing twist and increasing roll. However, as with the structural properties, this behavior is highly context-dependent and some TA steps are very straight.     

Interdependence of conformational variables in double-helical DNA.

DNA exhibits conformational polymorphism, with the details depending on the sequence and its environment. To understand the mechanisms of conformational polymorphism and these transitions, we examine the interrelationships among the various conformational variables of DNA. In particular, we examine the stress-strain relation among conformational variables, describing base-pair morphology and their effects on the backbone conformation. For the calculation of base pairs, we use the method previously developed to calculate averages over conformational variables of DNA. Here we apply this method to calculate the Boltzmann averages of conformational variables for fixed values of one particular conformational variable, which reflects the strain in the structure responding to a particular driving stress. This averaging over all but one driving variable smooths the usual rough energy surface to permit observation of the effects of one conformational variable at a time. The stress-strain analyses of conformational variables of base pair slide, twist, and roll, which exhibit characteristic changes during the conformational transition of DNA, have shown that the conformational changes of base pairs are strongly correlated with one another. Furthermore, the stress-strain relations are not symmetrical with respect to these variables, i.e., the response of one coordinate to another is different from the reverse direction. We also examine the effect of conformational changes in base-pair variables on the sugar-backbone conformation by using the minimization method we developed. The conformational changes of base pairs affect the sugar pucker and other dihedral angles of the backbone of DNA, but each variable affects the sugar-backbone differently. In particular, twist is found to have the most influence in affecting the sugar pucker and backbone conformation. These calculated conformational changes in base pairs and backbone segments are consistent with experimental observations and serve to validate the calculation method.     

The DNA structure responds differently to physiological concentrations of K(+) or Na(+)

The influence of monovalent cations on DNA conformation and readout is an open question. This NMR study of DNA with either Na(+) or K(+) at physiological concentrations shows that the nature of the cation affects the (31)P chemical shifts (deltaP) and the sequential distances H2'(i)-H6/8(i+1), H2"(i)-H6/8(i+1), and H6/8(i)-H6/8(i+1). The deltaP and distance variations ascertain that the nature of the cation affects the DNA overall structure, i.e. both the conformational equilibria between the backbone BI (epsilon-zeta <0 degrees ) and BII (epsilon-zeta >0 degrees ) states and the helical parameters, via their strong mechanical coupling. These results reveal that Na(+) and K(+) interactions with DNA are different and sequence-dependent. These ions modulate the overall intrinsic properties of DNA, and possibly its packaging and readout.     

Sequence effects on the propeller twist of base pairs in DNA helices.

Molecular mechanics calculations are performed on all the ten base pair steps (duplex dimers) and also a number of trimer and tetramer duplexes comprising them, in an attempt to systematically examine the possible base sequence effects on the magnitudes of propeller twists of base pairs at a given step. The analysis reveals that though propeller twist is a base pair property, it behaves very much like other base step parameters such as slide, roll, twist etc., Hence, it may be necessary to monitor the nature and variation of magnitudes of pt at a step. Calculations performed on 45 out of the 136 unique tetramer combinations involving all the ten unique base steps show that the difference in magnitudes of propeller twists of the base pairs of a given step has been found to be either steep or moderate depending on base pairs that flank the base step. These observations compare very well with the available experimental data. Tetramer sequences, wherein a base pair of a base step repeats in the same direction, exhibit a relatively steep difference in propeller twist at the step. Tetramers other than these exhibit moderate difference in propeller twist. Such sequences are broadly classified as type-I and type-II respectively. Practically all the tetrads considered in the study, excepting those with GT step and a few involving CG and GC steps, conform to the above classification.     

The intrinsic mechanics of B-DNA in solution characterized by NMR

Experimental characterization of the structural couplings in free B-DNA in solution has been elusive, because of subtle effects that are challenging to tackle. Here, the exploitation of the NMR measurements collected on four dodecamers containing a substantial set of dinucleotide sequences provides new, consistent correlations revealing the DNA intrinsic mechanics. The difference between two successive residual dipolar couplings (ΔRDCs) involving C6/8-H6/8, C3′-H3′ and C4′-H4′ vectors are correlated to the ³¹P chemical shifts (δP), which reflect the populations of the BI and BII backbone states. The δPs are also correlated to the internucleotide distances (D_inter) involving H6/8, H2′ and H2″ protons. Calculations of NMR quantities on high resolution X-ray structures and controlled models of DNA enable to interpret these couplings: the studied ΔRDCs depend mostly on roll, while D_inter are mainly sensitive to twist or slide. Overall, these relations demonstrate how δP measurements inform on key inter base parameters, in addition to probe the BI↔BII backbone equilibrium, and shed new light into coordinated motions of phosphate groups and bases in free B-DNA in solution. Inspection of the 5′ and 3′ ends of the dodecamers also supplies new information on the fraying events, otherwise neglected.     

Conformational variation of the central CG site in d(ATGACGTCAT)2 and d(GAAAACGTTTTC)2. An NMR, molecular modelling and 3D-homology investigation.

The determination of the solution structure of two self-complementary oligomers d(ATGACGTCAT)2 (CG10) and d(GAAAACGTTTTC)2 (CG12), both containing the 5'-pur-ACGT-pyr-3' sequence, is reported. The impact of the base context on the conformation of the central CpG site has been examined by a combined approach of: (a) 2D 1H-NMR and 31P-NMR; (b) molecular mechanics under experimental constraints; (c) back-calculations of NOESY spectra and iterative refinements of distances; and (d) 3D-homology search of the central tetrad ACGT within the complete oligonucleotides. A full NMR study of each fragment is achieved by means of standard 2D experiments: NOESY, 2D homonuclear Hartmann-Hahn spectroscopy, double-quantum-filtered COSY and heteronuclear 1H-31P correlation. Sugar phase angle, epsilon-zeta difference angle and NOE-derived distances are input as experimental constraints to generate molecular models by energy minimization with the help of jumna. The morass program is used to iteratively refine the structures obtained. The similarity of the two ACGTs within the whole oligonucleotides is investigated. Both the decamer and the dodecamer adopt a B-like DNA conformation. However, the helical parameters within this conformational type are significantly different in CG12 and CG10. The central CpG step conformation is not locked by its nearest environment (5'A and 3'T) as seen from the structural analysis of ACGT in the two molecules. In CG12, despite the presence of runs of A-T pairs, CpG presents a high twist of 43 degrees and a sugar phase at the guanine of about 180 degrees, previously observed in other ACGT-containing-oligomers. Conversely, ACGT in CG10 exhibits strong inclinations, positive rolls, a flat profile of sugar phase, twist and glycosidic angles, as a result of the nucleotide sequence extending beyond the tetrad. The structural specificity of CG10 and its flexibility (as reflected by its energy) are tentatively related to the process of recognition of the cyclic AMP response element by its cognate protein.