Continuous insect cell (Sf-9) culture with aeration through sparging

The continuous growth of Spodoptera frugiperda Sf-9 cells in a 250-ml blown-glass jacketed spinner flask under a direct air sparging environment was investigated. Even at 220 ml working volume (about 90% of total volume), this spinner flask provided good mixing and oxygenation as demonstrated by a higher cell density compared with fermentor cultures. This eliminates a common limitation of the traditional spinner flask, namely much lower cell density at high working volume. Furthermore, this spinner flask has been run with Sf-9 cell culture at five different dilution rates and two different air sparging rates at steady state, demonstrating its utility in research applications where cell size, metabolic activity and environmental conditions can be constantly maintained. In addition to demonstrating the utility of the reactor, three novel points are made in this report. First, cell density in continuous cultures is increased significantly due to a high agitation rate and, especially, air sparging rate, which is seldom used in animal cell or insect cell culture. Second, there is no apparent difference in the specific death rate at two different sparging rates (0.0093 vvm and 0.0125 vvm). Finally, we have maintained Sf-9 cells for more than 4 months in a continuous culture using a serum-free medium without loss of recombinant protein expression in infected cells.     

Carboxymethyl cellulose protects algal cells against hydrodynamic stress

The harmful effect of direct air sparging on Phaeodactylum tricornutum microalgal cultures was investigated in bubble columns and airlift photobioreactors with various superficial air velocities and two types of spargers which generated different sizes of bubbles. Small bubbles bursting at the surface of the culture were apparently the main cause of cell damage in batch cultures in laboratory-scale bubble columns. Other mechanisms of cell damage also were a contributing factor to the observed cell loss in outdoor pilot-scale bubble columns. Supplementation of the microalgal culture medium with carboxymethyl cellulose at concentrations of 0.02% and greater is shown to protect the algal cells against aeration-induced hydrodynamic stress.     

Sparging and agitation-induced injury of cultured animals cells: Do cell-to-bubble interactions in the bulk liquid injure cells?

It has been established that the forces resulting from bubbles rupturing at the free air (gas)/liquid surface injure animal cells in agitated and/or sparged bioreactors. Although it has been suggested that bubble coalescence and breakup within agitated and sparged bioreactors (i.e., away from the free liquid surface) can be a source of cell injury as well, the evidence has been indirect. We have carried out experiments to examine this issue. The free air/liquid surface in a sparged and agitated bioractor was eliminated by completely filling the 2-L reactor and allowing sparged bubbles to escape through an outlet tube. Two identical bioreactors were run in parallel to make comparisons between cultures that were oxygenated via direct air sparging and the control culture in which silicone tubing was used for bubble-free oxygenation. Thus, cell damage from cell-to-bubble interactions due to processes (bubble coalescence and breakup) occurring in the bulk liquid could be isolated by eliminating damage due to bubbles rupturing at the free air/liquid surface of the bioreactor. We found that Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells grown in medium that does not contain shear-protecting additives can be agitated at rates up to 600 rpm without being damaged extensively by cell-to bubble interactions in the bulk of the bioreactor. We verified this using both batch and high-density perfusion cultures. We tested two impeller designs (pitched blade and Rushton) and found them not to affect cell damage under similar operational conditions. Sparger location (above vs. below the impeller) had no effect on cell damage at higher agitation rates but may affect the injury process at lower agitation intensities (here, below 250 rpm). In the absence of a headspace, we found less cell damage at higher agitation intensities (400 and 600 rpm), and we suggest that this nonintuitive finding derives from the important effect of bubble size and foam stability on the cell damage process. (c) 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Large-scale propagation of a replication-defective adenovirus vector in stirred-tank bioreactor PER.C6 cell culture under sparging conditions

Large-scale propagation of replication-defective adenovirus vectors has not been well studied to date. One of the challenges for efficient propagation at large scale is to overcome the sensitivity of virus infected cells to gas sparging required for oxygenation and CO(2) removal. In our initial experiments, it was observed that productivity of an adenovirus vector was significantly reduced under sparging conditions as compared to nonsparged, i.e., surface-aerated controls in serum-free cultures. Investigations led to the identification of a buffer containing surfactant (Polysorbate-80, PS-80) that was included in the virus seed stock formulation and introduced through virus infection into the culture at a very low concentration as the cause of the reduced virus productivity. This finding was not obvious and trivial, as neither uninfected sparged nor infected nonsparged PER.C6 trade mark cells in serum-free cultures were affected by the buffer at such a low PS-80 concentration of 0.00025% (v/v), which is a common component of serum-free cell culture media. These results strongly suggest that virus-infected cells behave very differently from uninfected cells under sparging conditions. To mitigate the deleterious effects of sparging, the virus seed stock was prepared in the absence of the buffer containing PS-80. At the same time, the concentration of Pluronic-F68 (PF-68) in the serum-free medium was increased to 1 g/L, at which cell growth and metabolism were unaffected, even though this measure alone did not result in virus productivity improvement. Only by implementing the two measures together was virus productivity loss completely eliminated under sparging conditions. After demonstration of the process robustness in 2-L bioreactors, this adenovirus propagation process was successfully scaled up to 250 L in a 300-L bioreactor under the worst-case sparging conditions projected for 10,000-L scale.     

Cell-microcarrier adhesion to gas-liquid interfaces and foam

The interaction of microcarriers, both with and without cells attached, with gas bubbles was studied. These studies consisted of qualitative microscopic observations of microcarriers with bubbles, quantitative measurements of microcarrier entrapment in foam, and quantitative measurements of the effect of bubble rupture at gas-medium interfaces. Ten different "protective additives" were evaluated for their ability to change the dynamic surface tension of the culture media and to prevent microcarrier adhesion to air bubbles during gas sparging and to prevent entrapment in the foam layer. These studies indicate that microcarriers, with and without cells, readily attach to gas-medium interfaces; yet unlike suspended cells, cells attached to microcarriers are not damaged by bubble ruptures at gas-medium interfaces. Only one surfactant was found to substantially prevent microcarrier entrapment in the foam layer; however, this surfactant was toxic to cells. No correlation was observed between surface tension and the prevention of microcarrier adhesion to gas-liquid interfaces. It is suggested that cell damage as a result of sparging in microcarrier cultures is the result of cells, attached to microcarriers, attaching to rising bubbles and then detaching from the microcarrier as this combination rises through the medium. It is further suggested that the hydrodynamic drag force of the rising microcarrier is sufficiently high to remove the bubble-attached cell from the microcarrier.     

Oxygenation of intensive cell-culture system

The abilities of various methods of oxygenation to meet the demands of high-cell-density culture were investigated using a spin filter perfusion system in a bench-top bioreactor. Oxygen demand at high cell density could not be met by sparging with air inside a spin filter (oxygen transfer values in this condition were comparable with those for surface aeration). Sparging with air outside a spin filter gave adequate oxygen transfer for the support of cell concentrations above 10⁷ ml^–1 in fully aerobic conditions but the addition of antifoam to control foaming caused blockage of the spinfilter mesh. Bubble-free aeration through immersed silicone tubing with pure oxygen gave similar oxygen transfer rates to that of sparging with air but without the problems of bubble damage and fouling of the spin filter. A supra-optimal level of dissolved oxygen (478% air saturation) inhibited cell growth. However, cells could recover from this stress and reach high density after reduction of the dissolved oxygen level to 50% air saturation.     

Enhancing oxygen transfer in surface-aerated bioreactors by stable foams.

To enhance oxygen transfer in surface-aeration bioreactors, stabilized foams were generated to increase the gas-liquid interfacial area by slowly introducing coarse bubbles into media containing fetal bovine serum. The bubble sparging rates were so low (i.e., 20 and 50 mL/h) that the contribution to oxygen transfer from these bubbles was due to foaming instead of bubbling. Furthermore, no physical cell damage caused by bubble sparging was observed. Oxygen transfer coefficients, kLa, in the bioreactors were measured in cell-free media. Without the foam-stabilizing agent (i.e., serum), no appreciable change in kLa was observed due to the bubble sparging. On the other hand, with serum, kLa increased with increasing serum content and bubble sparging rate and corresponded well with the degree of foaming. With 10% fetal bovine serum and a bubble sparging rate of 50 mL/h, kLa increased approximately 90% compared with no foaming. The enhancing effect of foam on oxygen transfer in surface aeration bioreactors has been further demonstrated with hybridoma cultures simultaneously grown in three identical bioreactors with and without stabilized foams.     

Thermodynamic approach to explain cell adhesion to air-medium interfaces

Cell damage has been observed in suspension cell cultures with air sparging, especially in the absence of any protective additives. This damage is associated with cells adhering to bubbles, and it has been shown that if this adhesion is prevented, cell damage is prevented. This article presents a thermodynamic approach for predicting cell adhesion at the air-medium interface. With this relationship it can be shown that cell-gas adhesion can be prevented by lowering the surface tension of the liquid growth medium through the addition of surface-active protective additives. The thermodynamic relationship describes the change in free energy as a function of the interfacial tensions between the (i) gas and liquid phases, (ii) gas and cell phases, and (iii) liquid and cell phases. Experimental data, along with theoretical and empirical equations, are used to quantify the changes in free energy that predict the process of cell-gas adhesion. The thermodynamic model is nonspecific in nature and, consequently, results are equally valid for all types of cells. (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

NS0 cell damage by high gas velocity sparging in protein-free and cholesterol-free cultures

Recent developments in high cell density and high productivity fed-batch animal cell cultures have placed a high demand on oxygenation and carbon dioxide removal in bioreactors. The high oxygen demand is often met by increasing agitation and sparging rates of air/O2 in the bioreactors. However, as we demonstrate in this study, an increase of gas sparging can result in cell damage at the sparger site due to high gas entrance velocities. Previous studies have showed that gas bubble breakup at the culture surface was primarily responsible for cell damage in sparged bioreactors. Such cell damage can be reduced by use of surfactants such as Pluronic F-68 in the culture. In our results, where NS0 cells were grown in a protein-free and cholesterol-free medium containing 0.5 g/L Pluronic F-68, high gas entrance velocity at the sparger site was observed as the second mechanism for cell damage. Experiments were performed in scaled-down spinners to model the effect of hydrodynamic force resulting from high gas velocities on antibody-producing NS0 cells. Cell growth and cell death were described by first-order kinetics. Cell death rate constant increased significantly from 0.04 to 0.18 day(-1) with increasing gas entrance velocity from 2.3 to 82.9 m/s at the sparger site. The critical gas entrance velocity for the NS0 cell line studied was found to be approximately 30 m/s; velocities greater than 30 m/s caused cell damage which resulted in reduced viability and consequently reduced antibody production. Observations from a second cholesterol-independent NS0 cell line confirmed the occurrence of cell damage due to high gas velocities. Increasing the concentration of Pluronic F-68 from 0.5 to 2 g/L had no additional protective effect on cell damage associated with high gas velocity at the sparger. The results of gas velocity analysis for cell damage have been applied in two case studies of large-scale antibody manufacturing. The first is a troubleshooting study for antibody production carried out in a 600 L bioreactor, and the second is the development of a gas sparger design for a large bioreactor scale (e.g., 10,000 L) for antibody manufacturing.     

Quantitative investigations of cell-bubble interactions using a foam fractionation technique

Previous work by the authors and others has shown that suspended animal cell damage in bioreactors is caused by cell-bubble interactions, regardless whether the bubbles are from bubble entrainment or direct gas sparging. As approach to measure the adsorptivity of animal cells to bubbles, a modified batch foam fractionation technique has been developed in this work and proven to be applicable. By using this technique, the number of cells adsorbed per unit bubble surface area and the adsorption coefficients have been measured to quantify hybridoma cell-bubble interactions, and the prevetive effects of serum and Pluronic F68 on these interactions. It was demonstrated quantitatively that the hybridoma cells adhere to bubbles spontaneously and significant numbers exist in the foam, and that both the serum and Pluronic F68 provide strong prevention to these cell-bubble interactions. The results obtained provide criteria for bioreactor operation and medium formulation to prevent cell-bubble interactions and cell damage in the culture processes.Abbreviations NBCS new born calf serum - SFM serum-free medium     

Impact of aeration strategy on CHO cell performance during antibody production

Stirred tank bioreactors using suspension adapted mammalian cells are typically used for the production of complex therapeutic proteins. The hydrodynamic conditions experienced by cells within this environment have been shown to directly impact growth, productivity, and product quality and therefore an improved understanding of the cellular response is critical. Here we investigate the sub‐lethal effects of different aeration strategies on Chinese hamster ovary cells during monoclonal antibody production. Two gas delivery systems were employed to study the presence and absence of the air–liquid interface: bubbled direct gas sparging and a non‐bubbled diffusive silicone membrane system. Additionally, the effect of higher gas flow rate in the sparged bioreactor was examined. Both aeration systems were run using chemically defined media with and without the shear protectant Pluronic F‐68 (PF‐68). Cells were unable to grow with direct gas sparging without PF‐68; however, when a silicone membrane aeration system was implemented growth was comparable to the sparged bioreactor with PF‐68, indicating the necessity of shear protectants in the presence of bubbles. The cultures exposed to increased hydrodynamic stress were shown by flow cytometry to have decreased F‐actin intensity within the cytoskeleton and enter apoptosis earlier. This indicates that these conditions elicit a sub‐lethal physiological change in cells that would not be detected by the at‐line assays which are normally implemented during cell culture. These physiological changes only result in a difference in continuous centrifugation performance under high flow rate conditions. Product quality was more strongly affected by culture age than the hydrodynamic conditions tested. © 2012 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2013.     

Evaluation of the killing volume of gas bubbles in sparged animal cell culture bioreactors

The detrimental effect of direct gas sparging on insect cells was investigated in bubble columns with various gas flow rates and bubble sizes. The first-order cell death rate was shown to be directly proportional to the gas flow rate and inversely proportional to the bubble size. The specific killing volume of a bubble, killing volume per unit volume of bubble, was found to have a linear correlation with the specific interfacial area of a bubble. Based on these experimental results and the analysis of a bursting bubble at the liquid surface, it was concluded that the killing volume of a bubble is in the liquid layer surrounding the bubble before its rupture, and most important, in the liquid layer beneath the bubble cavity. Cell damage in the bubble film cap was relatively insignificant compared to that in the liquid layer underneath the bubble cavity, except for very large bubbles (i.e., bubble diameter over 5 mm).     

Effects of stirring and sparging on cultured hybridoma cells

The response of hybridoma cells to fluid shear caused by stirring and sparging has been investigated in a 2-L turbine-agitated bioreactor. Viable cell count, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) release, and antibody secretion were measured over the course of batch culture experiments under varied conditions of stirring and gas sparging. The effectiveness of Pluronic F68 as a protective agent in sparged cultures was also studied. Growth was found to be unaffected by stirring of the culture under surface aerated conditions, but gas sparging had a significant detrimental effect on growth and antibody production. The effect of sparging was reduced when cultures were supplemented with Pluronic at a level of 0.4% (w/v). Experimental data were analyzed through formulation of models for LDH release and antibody production. Rates of cell lysis could be estimated by correlating extracellular LDH levels through the model for LDH release. The lysis rate estimated for sparged conditions was sufficiently large to approximately account for the observed decrease in the specific growth rate of the culture. The presence of Pluronic apparently interfered with the LDH release mechanism, so precise estimation of lysis rates under these conditions was not possible. Sparging was found not to have a detrimental effect on antibody production in cultures without Pluronic added. Specific antibody production rates in cultures supplemented with Pluronic were about 25% higher than in sparged cultures without Pluronic added.     

Microscopic visualization of insect cell-bubble interactions. I: Rising bubbles, air-medium interface, and the foam layer.

Through the use of microscopic, high-speed video technology, the interactions of two suspended insect cell lines, Trichoplusia ni (TN-368) and Spodoptera frugiperda (SF-9), with air and oxygen bubbles were studied. Events such as cell-bubble attachment, cell-bubble collision, cell transport into the foam layer, and trapping of cells in the foam layer are presented and discussed. Based on these observations and those in a companion paper (Chalmers, J. J.; Bavarian, F. Biotechnol. Prog. 1991, following paper in this issue) and the experimental and theoretical work of other researchers, several mechanisms of cell damage as a result of sparging are presented.     

Design of a bubble-swawm bioreactor for animal cell culture

A stationary bubble-swarm has been used to aerate a mammalian cell culture bioreactor with an extremely low gas flow rate. Prolonging the residence time of the gas bubbles within the medium improved the efficiency of the gas transfer into the liquid phase and suppressed foam formation. An appropriate field of speed gradients prevented the bubbles from rising to the surface. This aeration method achieves an almost 90% transfer of oxygen supplied by the bubbles. Consequently, it is able to supply cells with oxygen even at high cell densities, while sparging with a gas flow of only 0.22·10^–3–1.45·10^–3 vvm (30–200 ml/h).The reactor design, the oxygen transfer rates and the high efficiency of the system are presented. Two repeated batch cultures of a rat-mouse hybridoma cell line are compared with a surface-aerated spinner culture. The used cell culture medium was serum-free, either with or without BSA and did not contain surfactants or other cell protecting agents. One batch is discussed in detail for oxygen supply, amino acid consumption and specific antibody production.     

Understanding factors that limit the productivity of suspension-based perfusion cultures operated at high medium renewal rates

One of the key parameters in perfusion culture is the rate of medium replacement (D). Intensifying D results in enhanced provision of nutrients, which can lead to an increase in the viable cell density (X(v)). The daily MAb production of hybridoma cells can thus be increased proportionally without modifying the bioreactor scale, provided that both viable cell yield per perfusion rate (Y(Xv/D)) and specific MAb productivity (q(MAb)) remain constant at higher D. To identify factors prone to limit productivity in perfusion, a detailed kinetic analysis was carried out on a series of cultures operated within a D range of 0.48/4.34 vvd (volumes of medium/reactor volume/day) in two different suspension-based systems. In the Celligen/vortex-flow filter system, significant reductions in Y(Xv/D) and q(MAb) resulting from the use of gas sparging were observed at D > 1.57 vvd (X(v) > 15 x 10(6) cells/mL). Through glucose supplementation, we have shown that the decrease in Y(Xv/D) encountered in presence of sparging was not resulting from increased cellular destruction or reduced cell growth, but rather from glucose limitation. Thus, increases in hydrodynamic shear stress imparted to the culture via intensification of gas sparging resulted in a gradual increase in specific glucose consumption (q(glc)) and lactate production rates (q(lac)), while no variations were observed in glutamine-consumption rates. As a result, while glutamine was the sole limiting-nutrient under non-sparging conditions, both glutamine and glucose became limiting under sparging conditions. Although a reduction in q(MAb) was observed at high-sparging rates, inhibition of MAb synthesis did not result from direct impact of bubbles, but was rather associated with elevated lactate levels (25-30 mM), resulting from shear stress-induced increases in q(lac), q(glc), and Y(lac/glc). Deleterious effects of sparging on Y(Xv/D) and q(MAb) encountered in the Celligen/vortex-flow filter system were eliminated in the sparging-free low-shear environment of the Chemap-HRI/ultrasonic filter system, allowing for the maintenance of up to 37 x 10(6) viable cells/mL. A strategy aimed at reducing requirements for sparging in large-scale perfusion cultures by way of a reduction in the oxygen demand using cellular engineering is discussed.     

Bubble bed reactor: A reactor design to minimize the damage of bubble aeration on animal cells

A new bubble aeration system was designed to minimize cell killing and cellular damage due to sparging. The residence time of the bubbles in the developed bubble bed reactor was prolonged dramatically by floating them in a countercurrent produced by an impeller. The performance of the new reactor bubble aeration system, implemented in a laboratory reactor, was tested in dynamic aeration experiments with an without cells. An efficiency up to 95% in oxygen transfer could be achieved, which enables a much lower gas flow rate compared with conventional bubble aeration reactors. The low gas flow rate is important to keep cell damage by bubbles as low as possible. A laser light sheet technique used to find the optimal flow pattern in the reactor. The specific power dissipation of the impeller is a good measure to predict cell damage in a turbulent flow. Typical values for the power dissipation measured in the bubble bed reactor were in the range of 0.002 to 0.013 W/kg, which is far below the critical limit for animal cells. The growth of a hybridoma cell line was studied in cell cultivation experiments. A protein-free medium without supplements such as serum or Pluronic F68 was used to exclude any effect of cell-protecting factors, No difference in the specific growth rate and the yield of the antibodies was observed in cell grown in the bubble free surface aeration in the spinner flask. In contrast to the spinner flask, however, the bubble bed reactor design could be scaled up. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Physical modeling of animal cell damage by hydrodynamic forces in suspension cultures

Physical damage of animal cells in suspension culture, due to stirring and sparging, is coupled with complex metabolic responses. Nylon microcapsules, therefore, were used as a physical model to study the mechanisms of damage in a stirred bioreactor and in a bubble column. Microcapsule breaskage folowed first-order kinetices in all experiments Entrainment of bubbles into the liquid phase in the stirred bioreactor gave more microcapsule breakage. In the bubble column, the bubble bursting zone at gas-liquid interface was primarilu responsible for microcapsule breakage. The forces on the microcapsules were equivalent to an external pressure of approximately 4 x 10(4) N . m(-2), based on the critical microcapsule diameter for survival of 190 mum. A stable foam layer, however, was found to be effective in protecting microcapsules from damage. The microcapsule transport to the gas-liquid interface and entrainment into the foam phase was consistent with flotation by air bubbles. This result implies that additives and operation of bioreactors should be selected to minimize flotation of cells. (c) 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

动物细胞培养用生物反应器设计原理

动物细胞培养用生物反应器设计和放大的关键问题是细胞破损与供氧和混合的矛盾,在分析细胞破损机理基础上,提出了动物细胞培养生物反应器的设计原理——设计模型和有关设计条件,从而清楚地确立了细胞死亡速度与培养基组成、反应器设计和操作参数间的定量关系,以及反应器设计应遵循的保证细胞生长和满足传质要求的条件。还对强化传质和抑制细胞破损这一矛盾作了简要分析和讨论。