Artificial modules for enhancing rate constants of a Group I intron ribozyme without a P4-P6 core element

In this paper we report newly selected artificial modules that enhance the kcat values comparable with or higher than those of the wild-type ribozyme with broad substrate specificity. The elements required for the catalysis of Group I intron ribozymes are concentrated in the P3-P7 domain of their core region, which consists of two conserved helical domains, P4-P6 and P3-P7. Previously, we reported the in vitro selection of artificial modules residing at the peripheral region of a mutant Group I ribozyme lacking P4-P6. We found that derivatives of the ribozyme containing the modules performed the reversal of the first step of the self-splicing reaction efficiently by using their affinity to the substrate RNA, although their kcat values and substrate specificity were uninfluenced and limited, respectively. The results show that it is possible to add a variety of new domains at the peripheral region that play a role comparable with that of the conserved P4-P6 domain.     

A Tyrosyl-tRNA Synthetase Suppresses Structural Defects in the Two Major Helical Domains of the Group I Intron Catalytic Core

TheNeurospora crassamitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase, the CYT-18 protein, functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active structure of the intron RNA. The group I intron catalytic core is thought to consist of two extended helical domains, one formed by coaxial stacking of P5, P4, P6, and P6a (P4-P6 domain) and the other consisting of P8, P3, P7, and P9 (P3-P9 domain). To investigate how CYT-18 stabilizes the active RNA structure, we used anEscherichia coligenetic assay based on the phage T4tdintron to systematically test the ability of CYT-18 to compensate for structural defects in three key regions of the catalytic core: J3/4 and J6/7, connecting regions that form parts of the triple-helical-scaffold structure with the P4-P6 domain, and P7, a long- range base-pairing interaction that forms the guanosine-binding site and is part of the P3-P9 domain. Our results show that CYT-18 can suppress numerous mutations that disrupt the J3/4 and J6/7 nucleotide-triple interactions, as well as mutations that disrupt base-pairing in P7. CYT-18 suppressed mutations of phylogenetically conserved nucleotide residues at all positions tested, except for the universally conserved G-residue at the guanosine-binding site. Structure mapping experiments with selected mutant introns showed that the CYT-18-suppressible J3/4 mutations primarily impaired folding of the P4-P6 domain, while the J6/7 mutations impaired folding of both the P4-P6 and P3-P9 domains to various degrees. The P7 mutations impaired the formation of both P7 and P3, thereby grossly disrupting the P3-P9 domain. The finding that the P7 mutations also impaired formation of P3 provides evidence that the formation of these two long-range pairings is interdependent in thetdintron. Considered together with previous work, the nature of mutations suppressed by CYT-18 supports a model in which CYT-18 helps assemble the P4-P6 domain and then stabilizes the two major helical domains of the catalytic core in the correct relative orientation to form the intron's active site.     

Mutagenesis and comparative sequence analysis of a base triple joining the two domains of group I ribozymes.

Tertiary interactions are important in the higher-order folding of catalytic RNAs. Recently, a base triple, joining the two major domains of the catalytic core, was determined in group I introns from the cyanobacterium Anabaena PCC7120 and the eukaryote Tetrahymena thermophila. This base triple involves the fifth base pair of P4 and the fifth base of the single-stranded region J8/7. We made base pair and single-nucleotide substitutions in the fifth base pair of P4, a G-C in the wild-type Anabaena intron, and tested them for self-splicing activity. The results suggest a hydrogen bonding model in which only the C of the base pair interacts directly with the fifth base of J8/7. Comparative sequence analysis was used to determine the different combinations of base triples that occur in approximately 450 natural group I introns identified to date. About 94% of the base triples analyzed are compatible with the proposed hydrogen bonding model. Disrupting this base triple in the Tetrahymena intron resulted in the disappearance of splicing intermediates (intron 3' exon and 5' exon), even though the first step of splicing was not affected. Restoration of the base triple by a compensatory mutation reverted the intermediates to wild-type levels. These results suggest that disruption of the base triple increases the rate of the second step of splicing or of a conformational change preceding the second step. Repositioning of the base triple to form a new set of interactions may be required for the second step of splicing.     

Role of a conserved J8/7 X P4 base-triple in the Tetrahymena ribozyme

The Tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme folds into a complex three dimensional structure for performing the self-splicing reaction. Catalysis depends on its core structure comprising two helical domains, P4-P6 and P3-P7. The two domains are joined by three sets of conserved base-triple(s) and other tertiary interactions. We found that the disruption of J8/7 X P4, one such conserved base-triple, causes the catalytic ability to deteriorate without altering the folding rate. This suggests that the base-triple stabilizes the active structure of the ribozyme but plays no significant role in RNA folding. By combining the present and previous results, it can be concluded that three sets of conserved base-triples play distinct roles in the Tetrahymena ribozyme.     

Crystal structure of a group I intron splicing intermediate

A recently reported crystal structure of an intact bacterial group I self-splicing intron in complex with both its exons provided the first molecular view into the mechanism of RNA splicing. This intron structure, which was trapped in the state prior to the exon ligation reaction, also reveals the architecture of a complex RNA fold. The majority of the intron is contained within three internally stacked, but sequence discontinuous, helical domains. Here the tertiary hydrogen bonding and stacking interactions between the domains, and the single-stranded joiner segments that bridge between them, are fully described. Features of the structure include: (1) A pseudoknot belt that circumscribes the molecule at its longitudinal midpoint; (2) two tetraloop-tetraloop receptor motifs at the peripheral edges of the structure; (3) an extensive minor groove triplex between the paired and joiner segments, P6-J6/6a and P3-J3/4, which provides the major interaction interface between the intron's two primary domains (P4-P6 and P3-P9.0); (4) a six-nucleotide J8/7 single stranded element that adopts a mu-shaped structure and twists through the active site, making critical contacts to all three helical domains; and (5) an extensive base stacking architecture that realizes 90% of all possible stacking interactions. The intron structure was validated by hydroxyl radical footprinting, where strong correlation was observed between experimental and predicted solvent accessibility. Models of the pre-first and pre-second steps of intron splicing are proposed with full-sized tRNA exons. They suggest that the tRNA undergoes substantial angular motion relative to the intron between the two steps of splicing.     

Self-assembly of a group I intron active site from its component tertiary structural domains.

The catalytic core of Group I self-splicing introns has been proposed to consist of two structural domains, P4-P6 and P3-P9. Each contains helical segments and conserved unpaired nucleotides, and the isolated P4-P6 domain has been shown to have substantial native tertiary structure. The proposed tertiary structure domains of the Tetrahymena intron were synthesized separately and shown to self-assemble into a catalytically active complex. Surprisingly, the concentration dependence of these reactions revealed that the domains interact with nanomolar apparent dissociation constants, even though there is no known base pairing between P4-P6 and P3-P9. This suggests that the domains interact through multiple tertiary contacts, the nature of which can now be explored in this system. For example, a circularly permuted version of the P4-P6 domain, which folds similarly to the native P4-P6 molecule, formed a stable but inactive complex. Interestingly, activity was demonstrated with the permuted molecule when nucleotides proposed to form a triple-strand interaction with P4 and P6 were restored as part of the P1-P3 substrate or as part of the P3-P9 RNA. Thus, beyond stabilization of the P4-P6 domain, the triple-strand region may facilitate correct orientation of the RNA domains or participate more directly in catalysis.     

Two major tertiary folding transitions of the Tetrahymena catalytic RNA.

The L-21 Tetrahymena ribozyme, an RNA molecule with sequence-specific endoribonuclease activity derived from a self-splicing group I intron, provides a model system for studying the RNA folding problem. A 160 nucleotide, independently folding domain of tertiary structure (the P4-P6 domain) comprises about half of the ribozyme. We now apply Fe(II)-EDTA cleavage to mutants of the ribozyme to explore the role of individual structural elements in tertiary folding of the RNA at equilibrium. Deletion of peripheral elements near the 3' end of the ribozyme destabilizes a region of the catalytic core (P3-P7) without altering the folding of the P4-P6 domain. Three different mutations within the P4-P6 domain that destabilize its folding also shift the folding of the P3-P7 region of the catalytic core to higher MgCl2 concentrations. We conclude that the role of the extended P4-P6 domain and of the 3'-terminal peripheral elements is at least in part to stabilize the catalytic core. The organization of RNA into independently folding domains of tertiary structure may be common in large RNAs, including ribosomal RNAs. Furthermore, the observation of domain-domain interactions in a catalytic RNA supports the feasibility of a primitive spliceosome without any proteins.     

Activity of chimeric RNAs of U6 snRNA and (-)sTRSV in the cleavage of a substrate RNA.

U6 small nuclear RNA is one of the spliceosomal RNAs essential for pre-mRNA splicing. Discovery of mRNA-type introns in the highly conserved region of the U6 snRNA genes led to the hypothesis that U6 snRNA functions as a catalytic element during pre-mRNA splicing. The highly conserved region of U6 snRNA has a structural similarity with the catalytic domain of the negative strand of the satellite RNA of tobacco ring spot virus [(-)sTRSV], suggesting that the highly conserved region of U6 snRNA forms the catalytic center. We examined whether synthetic RNAs consisting of the sequence of the highly conserved region of U6 snRNA or various chimeric RNAs between the U6 region and the catalytic RNA of (-)sTRSV could cleave a substrate RNA that can partially base-pair with them and have a GU sequence. Chimeric RNAs with 70 to 83% sequence identity with the conserved region of S. pombe U6 snRNA cleaved the substrate RNA at the 5' side of the GU sequence, which is shared by the 5' end of an intron in a pre-mRNA. We found that the highly conserved region of U6 snRNA and the catalytic domain of (-)sTRSV are strikingly similar in structure to the catalytic core region of the group I self-splicing intron in cyanobacteria. These results suggest that U6 snRNA, (-)sTRSV and the group I self-splicing intron originated from a common ancestral RNA, and support the hypothesis that U6 snRNA catalyzes pre-mRNA splicing reaction.     

The conserved U.G pair in the 5'' splice site duplex of a group I intron is required in the first but not the second step of self-splicing.

Group I self-splicing introns have a 5' splice site duplex (P1) that contains a single conserved base pair (U.G). The U is the last nucleotide of the 5' exon, and the G is part of the internal guide sequence within the intron. Using site-specific mutagenesis and analysis of the rate and accuracy of splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron, we found that both the U and the G of the U.G pair are important for the first step of self-splicing (attack of GTP at the 5' splice site). Mutation of the U to a purine activated cryptic 5' splice sites in which a U.G pair was restored; this result emphasizes the preference for a U.G at the splice site. Nevertheless, some splicing persisted at the normal site after introduction of a purine, suggesting that position within the P1 helix is another determinant of 5' splice site choice. When the U was changed to a C, the accuracy of splicing was not affected, but the Km for GTP was increased by a factor of 15 and the catalytic rate constant was decreased by a factor of 7. Substitution of U.A, U.U, G.G, or A.G for the conserved U.G decreased the rate of splicing by an even greater amount. In contrast, mutation of the conserved G enhanced the second step of splicing, as evidenced by a trans-splicing assay. Furthermore, a free 5' exon ending in A or C instead of the conserved U underwent efficient ligation. Thus, unlike the remainder of the P1 helix, which functions in both the first and second steps of self-splicing, the conserved U.G appears to be important only for the first step.     

Structural analysis of the Neurospora mitochondrial large rRNA intron and construction of a mini-intron that shows protein-dependent splicing.

The gene encoding the Neurospora mitochondrial large rRNA contains a single group I intron of 2.3 kilobases that is not self-splicing in vitro. We showed previously that the splicing of this intron in vivo and in vitro is dependent on the Neurospora cyt-18 protein, mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase. In the present work, we carried out further structural analysis of the intron and constructed mutant derivatives of it in order to identify features that are either required for splicing or prevent it from self-splicing. Previous studies showed that the intron contains a large hairpin structure near the 5' splice site. By mapping RNase III cleavage sites, we identified this hairpin structure as an extended P2 stem. We construct a mini-intron of 388 nucleotides by deleting the 426-amino acid intron open reading frame, most of the 5' intron hairpin, and all of L8. This mini-intron shows the same protein-dependent splicing as the full length intron, but is still not self-splicing. Further deletions, which remove all of P2 or all or part of P4, P6, P7, or P9, inactivate splicing, suggesting that an intact group I intron core structure is required. Strengthening the P1, P10, or P9.0 pairings did not enable the mini-intron to self-splice. Our findings indicate that the inability of the mitochondrial large rRNA intron to self-splice reflects deficiency of a structure or activity required for cleavage at the 5' splice site, either in the intron core itself or in the interaction between the core and the P1 stem.     

Designed structural-rearrangement of an active group I ribozyme

The catalytic core of the Tetrahyemena group I ribozyme consists of two functionally different domains, P4-P6 and P3-P7, that are conjugated via multiple tertiary interactions. The sequence encoding the P3-P7 domain is divided into two fragments in its primary sequence although the two domains are physically separable in the three dimensional (3D-) structure of the ribozyme: The sequence encoding the P4-P6 domain is inserted into that of the P3-P7 domain. An artificial rearrangement was designed and attempted for the primary sequence of the P3-P7 domain on the basis of a 3D-structural model and the biochemical data on the ribozyme. The domain in the primary structure was relocated to form a contiguous region while retaining the 3D-structure of the ribozyme required for self-splicing. The topologically rearranged ribozyme exhibited self-splicing activity.     

Function of tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase in splicing group I introns: an induced-fit model for binding to the P4-P6 domain based on analysis of mutations at the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices

We used an Escherichia coli genetic assay based on the phage T4 td intron to test the ability of the Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) to suppress mutations that cause structural defects around its binding site in the P4-P6 domain of the group I intron catalytic core. We analyzed all possible combinations of nucleotides at either P4 bp-1 or P6 bp-1, which together form the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices, and looked for synergistic effects in double mutants. Most mutations at either position inhibit self-splicing, but can be suppressed by CYT-18. CYT-18 can compensate efficiently for mutations that disrupt base-pairing at either P4 bp-1 or P6 bp-1, for mutations at P6 bp-1 that disrupt the base-triple interaction with J3/4-3, and for nucleotide substitutions at either position that are predicted to be suboptimal for base stacking, based on the analysis of DNA four-way junctions. However, CYT-18 has difficulty suppressing combinations of mutations at P4 bp-1 and P6 bp-1 that simultaneously disrupt base-pairing and base stacking. Thermal denaturation and Fe(II)-EDTA analysis showed that mutations at the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helices lead to grossly impaired tertiary-structure formation centered in the P4-P6 domain. CYT-18-suppressible mutants bind the protein with K(d) values up to 79-fold higher than that for the wild-type intron, but in all cases tested, the k(off) value for the complex remains within twofold of the wild-type value, suggesting that the binding site can be formed properly and that the increased K(d) value reflects primarily an increased k(on) value for the binding of CYT-18 to the misfolded intron. Our results indicate that the P4/P6 junction is a linchpin region, where even small nucleotide substitutions grossly disrupt the catalytically-active group I intron tertiary structure, and that CYT-18 binding induces the formation of the correct structure in this region, leading to folding of the group I intron catalytic core.     

The Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein C-terminal RNA-binding domain helps stabilize interdomain tertiary interactions in group I introns

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) promotes the splicing of group I introns by stabilizing the catalytically active RNA structure. To accomplish this, CYT-18 recognizes conserved structural features of group I intron RNAs using regions of the N-terminal nucleotide-binding fold, intermediate alpha-helical, and C-terminal RNA-binding domains that also function in binding tRNA(Tyr). Curiously, whereas the splicing of the N. crassa mitochondrial large subunit rRNA intron is completely dependent on CYT-18's C-terminal RNA-binding domain, all other group I introns tested thus far are spliced efficiently by a truncated protein lacking this domain. To investigate the function of the C-terminal domain, we used an Escherichia coli genetic assay to isolate mutants of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial large subunit rRNA and phage T4 td introns that can be spliced in vivo by the wild-type CYT-18 protein, but not by the C-terminally truncated protein. Mutations that result in dependence on CYT-18's C-terminal domain include those disrupting two long-range GNRA tetraloop/receptor interactions: L2-P8, which helps position the P1 helix containing the 5'-splice site, and L9-P5, which helps establish the correct relative orientation of the P4-P6 and P3-P9 domains of the group I intron catalytic core. Our results indicate that different structural mutations in group I intron RNAs can result in dependence on different regions of CYT-18 for RNA splicing.     

Analysis of the CYT-18 Protein Binding Site at the Junction of Stacked Helices in a Group I Intron RNA by Quantitative Binding Assays andin vitroSelection

TheNeurospora crassamitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (CYT-18 protein) functions in splicing group I introns by promoting the formation of the catalytically active structure of the intron RNA. Previous studies showed that CYT-18 binds with high affinity to the P4-P6 domain of the catalytic core and that there is some additional contribution to binding from the P3-P9 domain. Here, quantitative binding assays with deletion derivatives of theN. crassamitochondrial large rRNA intron showed that at least 70% of the binding energy can be accounted for by the interaction of CYT-18 with the P4-P6 domain. Within this domain, P4 and P6 are required for high affinity CYT-18 binding, while the distal elements P5 and P6a may contribute indirectly by stabilizing the correct structure of the binding site in P4 and P6. CYT-18 binds to a small RNA corresponding to the isolated P4-P6 domain, but not to a permuted version of this RNA in which P4-P6 is a continuous rather than a stacked helix. Iterativein vitroselection experiments with the isolated P4-P6 domain showed a requirement for base-pairing to maintain helices P4, P6 and P6a, but indicate that P5 is subject to fewer constraints. The most strongly conserved nucleotides in the selections were clustered around the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helix, with ten nucleotides (J3/4-2,3, P4 bp -1 and 3, and P6 bp -1 and 2) found invariant in the context of the wild-type RNA structure.In vitromutagenesis confirmed that replacement of the wild-type nucleotides at J3/4-2 and 3 or P4 bp-3 markedly decreased CYT-18 binding, reflecting either base specific contacts or indirect readout of RNA structure by the protein. Our results suggest that a major function of CYT-18 is to promote assembly of the P4-P6 domain by stabilizing the correct geometry at the junction of the P4-P6 stacked helix. The relatively large number of conserved nucleotides at the binding site suggests that the interaction of CYT-18 with group I introns is unlikely to have arisen by chance and could reflect either an evolutionary relationship between group I introns and tRNAs or interaction with a common stacked-helical structural motif that evolved separately in these RNAs.     

Synthesis of chimeric RNAs between U6 small nuclear RNA and (-)sTRSV and analysis of their cleavage activities against the substrate RNA.

U6 small nuclear RNA (U6 snRNA) is one of the spliceosomal RNAs essential for pre-mRNA splicing. Highly conserved region of U6 snRNA shows a structural similarity with the catalytic center of the negative strand of the satellite RNA of tobacco ring spot virus [(-)sTRSV], supporting the hypothesis that U6 snRNA has a catalytic role in pre-mRNA splicing. To test this hypothesis, we examined in vitro whether synthetic RNAs consisting of the sequence of the highly conserved region of U6 snRNA or various chimeric RNAs between the U6 region and the catalytic center of (-)sTRSV could cleave a substrate RNA that can partially base-pair with them and has a GU sequence between the pairing regions. Chimeric RNAs with 70 to 83% sequence identity with the conserved region of S. pombe U6 snRNA cleaved the substrate RNA at the 5' side of the GU sequence. In addition, we found that the highly conserved region of U6 snRNA is similar in structure to the catalytic core region of the group I self-splicing intron in cyanobacteria. These results support the hypothesis that U6 snRNA catalyzes the pre-mRNA splicing reaction and U6 snRNA may originate from the catalytic domain of an ancient self-splicing intron.     

Group II introns deleted for multiple substructures retain self-splicing activity.

Group II introns can be folded into highly conserved secondary structures with six major substructures or domains. Domains 1 and 5 are known to play key roles in self-splicing, while the roles of domains 2, 3, 4, and 6 are less clear. A trans assay for domain 5 function has been developed which indicates that domain 5 has a binding site on the precursor RNA that is not predicted from any secondary structure element. In this study, the self-splicing group II intron 5 gamma of the coxI gene of yeast mitochondrial DNA was deleted for various intron domains, singly and in combinations. Those mutant introns were characterized for self-splicing reactions in vitro as a means of locating the domain 5 binding site. A single deletion of domain 2, 3, 4, or 6 does not block in vitro reactions at either splice junction, though the deletion of domain 6 reduces the fidelity of 3' splice site selection somewhat. Even the triple deletion lacking domains 2, 4, and 6 retains some self-splicing activity. The deletion of domains 2, 3, 4, and 6 blocks the reaction at the 3' splice junction but not at the 5' junction. From these results, we conclude that the binding site for domain 5 is within domain 1 and that the complex of 5' exon, domain 1, and domain 5 (plus short connecting sequences) constitutes the essential catalytic core of this intron.     

Variation in sequence and RNA editing within core domains of mitochondrial group II introns among plants

The 3' regions of several group II introns within the mitochondrial genes nad1 and nad7 show unexpected sequence divergence among flowering plants, and the core domains 5 and 6 are predicted to have weaker helical structure than those in self-splicing group II introns. To assess whether RNA editing improves helical stability by the conversion of A-C mispairs to A-U pairs, we sequenced RT-PCR amplification products derived from excised intron RNAs or partially spliced precursors. Only in some cases was editing observed to strengthen the predicted helices. Moreover, the editing status within nad1 intron 1 and nad7 intron 4 was seen to differ among plant species, so that homologous intron sequences shared lower similarity at the RNA level than at the DNA level. Plant-specific variation was also seen in the length of the linker joining domains 5 and 6 of nad7 intron 3; it ranged from 4 nt in wheat to 11 nt in soybean, in contrast to the 2-4 nt length typical of classical group II introns. However, this intron is excised as a lariat structure with a domain 6 branchpoint adenosine. Our observations suggest that the core structures and sequences of these plant mitochondrial introns are subject to less stringent evolutionary constraints than conventional group II introns.     

Identification of phosphate groups important to self-splicing of the Tetrahymena rRNA intron as determined by phosphorothioate substitution.

The group I intron from the rRNA precursor of Tetrahymena undergoes self-splicing. The intron RNA catalyst contains about 400 phosphate groups. Their role in catalysis has been investigated using phosphorothioate substituted RNA. In such RNA one of the peripheral oxygens of the phosphodiesters is replaced with sulfur. Incorporation of adenosine 5' phosphorothioate in either the 5' or 3' half of the ribozyme blocked splicing whereas incorporation of uridine 5' phosphorothioate only blocked splicing if the substitution was in the 3' half of the molecule. Modification-interference assays located two major and three minor inhibitory phosphorothioate substitutions suggesting that the corresponding phosphates play a significant role in self-splicing. These are all located in the most highly conserved region of the intron.     

A peripheral element assembles the compact core structure essential for group I intron self-splicing

The presence of non-conserved peripheral elements in all naturally occurring group I introns underline their importance in ensuring the natural intron function. Recently, we reported that some peripheral elements are conserved in group I introns of IE subgroup. Using self-splicing activity as a readout, our initial screening revealed that one such conserved peripheral elements, P2.1, is mainly required to fold the catalytically active structure of the Candida ribozyme, an IE intron. Unexpectedly, the essential function of P2.1 resides in a sequence-conserved short stem of P2.1 but not in a long-range interaction associated with the loop of P2.1 that stabilizes the ribozyme structure. The P2.1 stem is indispensable in folding the compact ribozyme core, most probably by forming a triple helical interaction with two core helices, P3 and P6. Surprisingly, although the ribozyme lacking the P2.1 stem renders a loosely folded core and the loss of self-splicing activity requires two consecutive transesterifications, the mutant ribozyme efficiently catalyzes the first transesterification reaction. These results suggest that the intron self-splicing demands much more ordered structure than does one independent transesterification, highlighting that the universally present peripheral elements achieve their functional importance by enabling the highly ordered structure through diverse tertiary interactions.