Active and passive mechanisms of helicases

In this work, we discuss the active or passive character of helicases. In the past years, several studies have used the theoretical framework proposed by Betterton and Julicher [Betterton, M.D. and Julicher, F. (2005) Opening of nucleic-acid double strands by helicases: active versus passive opening. Phys. Rev. E, 71, 11904–11911.] to analyse the unwinding data and assess the mechanism of the helicase under study (active versus passive). However, this procedure has given rise to apparently contradictory interpretations: helicases exhibiting similar behaviour have been classified as both active and passive enzymes [Johnson, D.S., Bai, L. Smith, B.Y., Patel, S.S. and Wang, M.D. (2007) Single-molecule studies reveal dynamics of DNA unwinding by the ring-shaped T7 helicase. Cell, 129, 1299–1309; Lionnet, T., Spiering, M.M., Benkovic, S.J., Bensimon, D. and Croquette, V. (2007) Real-time observation of bacteriophage T4 gp41 helicase reveals an unwinding mechanism Proc. Natl Acid. Sci., 104, 19790–19795]. In this work, we show that when the helicase under study has not been previously well characterized (namely, if its step size and rate of slippage are unknown) a multi-parameter fit to the afore-mentioned model can indeed lead to contradictory interpretations. We thus propose to differentiate between active and passive helicases on the basis of the comparison between their observed translocation velocity on single-stranded nucleic acid and their unwinding rate of double-stranded nucleic acid (with various GC content and under different tensions). A threshold separating active from passive behaviour is proposed following an analysis of the reported activities of different helicases. We study and contrast the mechanism of two helicases that exemplify these two behaviours: active for the RecQ helicase and passive for the gp41 helicase.     

Single-molecule studies reveal dynamics of DNA unwinding by the ring-shaped T7 helicase

Helicases are molecular motors that separate DNA strands for efficient replication of genomes. We probed the kinetics of individual ring-shaped T7 helicase molecules as they unwound double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) or translocated on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). A distinctive DNA sequence dependence was observed in the unwinding rate that correlated with the local DNA unzipping energy landscape. The unwinding rate increased approximately 10-fold (approaching the ssDNA translocation rate) when a destabilizing force on the DNA fork junction was increased from 5 to 11 pN. These observations reveal a fundamental difference between the mechanisms of ring-shaped and nonring-shaped helicases. The observed force-velocity and sequence dependence are not consistent with a simple passive unwinding model. However, an active unwinding model fully supports the data even though the helicase on its own does not unwind at its optimal rate. This work offers insights into possible ways helicase activity is enhanced by associated proteins.     

Unwinding of unnatural substrates by a DNA helicase

Helicases separate double-stranded DNA into single-stranded DNA intermediates that are required during replication and recombination. These enzymes are believed to transduce free energy available from ATPase activity to unwind the duplex and translocate along the nucleic acid lattice. The nature of enzyme-substrate interactions between helicases and duplex DNA substrates has not been well-defined. Most helicases require a single-stranded DNA overhang adjacent to duplex DNA in order to initiate unwinding. The strand containing the overhang is referred to as the loading strand whereas the complementary strand is referred to as the displaced strand. We have investigated the interactions between a DNA helicase and the DNA substrate by replacing the displaced strand with a nucleic acid mimic, peptide nucleic acid (PNA). PNA is capable of forming duplex structures with DNA according to Watson-Crick base pairing rules, but contains a N-(2-aminoethyl)glycine backbone in place of the deoxyribose phosphates. The PNA-DNA hybrids had higher melting temperatures than their DNA-DNA counterparts. Dda helicase, from bacteriophage T4, was able to unwind the DNA-PNA substrates at similar rates as DNA-DNA substrates. The results indicate that the rate-limiting step for unwinding is relatively insensitive to the chemical nature of the displaced strand and the thermal stability of oligonucleotide substrates.     

Mechanistic and biological aspects of helicase action on damaged DNA

Helicases catalytically unwind structured nucleic acids in a nucleoside-triphosphate-dependent and directionally specific manner, and are essential for virtually all aspects of nucleic acid metabolism. ATPase-driven helicases which translocate along nucleic acids play a role in damage recognition or unwinding of a DNA tract containing the lesion. Although classical biochemical experiments provided evidence that bulky covalent adducts inhibit DNA unwinding catalyzed by certain DNA helicases in a strand-specific manner (i.e., block to DNA unwinding restricted to adduct residence in the strand the helicase translocates), recent studies suggest more complex arrangements that may depend on the helicase under study, its assembly in a protein complex, and the type of structural DNA perturbation. Moreover, base and sugar phosphate backbone modifications exert effects on DNA helicases that suggest specialized tracking mechanisms. As a component of the replication stress response, the single-stranded DNA binding protein Replication Protein A (RPA) may serve to enable eukaryotic DNA helicases to overcome certain base lesions. Helicases play important roles in DNA damage signaling which also involve their partnership with RPA. In this review, we will discuss our current understanding of mechanistic and biological aspects of helicase action on damaged DNA.     

Coupling translocation with nucleic acid unwinding by NS3 helicase

We present a semiquantitative model for translocation and unwinding activities of monomeric nonstructural protein 3 (NS3) helicase. The model is based on structural, biochemical, and single-molecule measurements. The model predicts that the NS3 helicase actively unwinds duplex by reducing more than 50% the free energy that stabilizes base pairing/stacking. The unwinding activity slows the movement of the helicase in a sequence-dependent manner, lowering the average unwinding efficiency to less than 1 bp per ATP cycle. When bound with ATP, the NS3 helicase can display significant translocational diffusion. This increases displacement fluctuations of the helicase, decreases the average unwinding efficiency, and enhances the sequence dependence. Also, interactions between the helicase and the duplex stabilize the helicase at the junction, facilitating the helicase's unwinding activity while preventing it from dissociating. In the presence of translocational diffusion during active unwinding, the dissociation rate of the helicase also exhibits sequence dependence. Based on unwinding velocity fluctuations measured from single-molecule experiments, we estimate the diffusion rate to be on the order of 10 s^− 1 . The generic features of coupling single-stranded nucleic acid translocation with duplex unwinding presented in this work may apply generally to a class of helicases.     

Helicase Processivity and Not the Unwinding Velocity Exhibits Universal Increase with Force

Helicases, involved in a number of cellular functions, are motors that translocate along single-stranded nucleic acid and couple the motion to unwinding double-strands of a duplex nucleic acid. The junction between double- and single-strands creates a barrier to the movement of the helicase, which can be manipulated in vitro by applying mechanical forces directly on the nucleic acid strands. Single-molecule experiments have demonstrated that the unwinding velocities of some helicases increase dramatically with increase in the external force, while others show little response. In contrast, the unwinding processivity always increases when the force increases. The differing responses of the unwinding velocity and processivity to force have lacked explanation. By generalizing a previous model of processive unwinding by helicases, we provide a unified framework for understanding the dependence of velocity and processivity on force and the nucleic acid sequence. We predict that the sensitivity of unwinding processivity to external force is a universal feature that should be observed in all helicases. Our prediction is illustrated using T7 and NS3 helicases as case studies. Interestingly, the increase in unwinding processivity with force depends on whether the helicase forces basepair opening by direct interaction or if such a disruption occurs spontaneously due to thermal fluctuations. Based on the theoretical results, we propose that proteins like single-strand binding proteins associated with helicases in the replisome may have coevolved with helicases to increase the unwinding processivity even if the velocity remains unaffected.     

Helicase from hepatitis C virus,energetics of DNA binding

The ability of a helicase to bind single-stranded nucleic acid is critical for nucleic acid unwinding. The helicase from the hepatitis C virus, NS3 protein, binds to the 3'-DNA or the RNA strand during unwinding. As a step to understand the mechanism of unwinding, DNA binding properties of the helicase domain of NS3 (NS3h) were investigated by fluorimetric binding equilibrium titrations. The global analysis of the binding data by a combinatorial approach was done using MATLAB. NS3h interactions with single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) are 300-1000-fold tighter relative to duplex DNA. The NS3h protein binds to ssDNA less than 15 nt in length with a stoichiometry of one protein per DNA. The minimal ssDNA binding site of NS3h helicase was determined to be 8 nucleotides with the microscopic K(d) of 2-4 nm or an observed free energy of -50 kJ/mol. These NS3h-DNA interactions are highly sensitive to salt, and the K(d) increases 4 times when the NaCl concentration is doubled. Multiple HCV helicase proteins bind to ssDNA >15 nucleotides in length, with an apparent occluded site of 8-11 nucleotides. The DNA binding data indicate that the interactions of multiple NS3h protein molecules with long ssDNA are both noncooperative and sequence-independent. We discuss the DNA binding properties of HCV helicase in relation to other superfamily 1 and 2 helicases. These studies provide the basis to investigate the DNA binding interactions with the unwinding substrate and their modulation by the ATPase activity of HCV helicase.     

Coupling of DNA unwinding to nucleotide hydrolysis in a ring-shaped helicase

The ring-shaped T7 helicase uses the energy of dTTP hydrolysis to perform the mechanical work of translocation and base pair (bp) separation. We have shown that the unwinding rate of T7 helicase decreases with increasing DNA stability. Here, we show that the dTTPase rate also decreases with increasing DNA stability, which indicates close linkage between chemical transition steps and translocation steps of unwinding. We find that the force-producing step during unwinding is not associated with dTTP binding, but dTTP hydrolysis or P(i) release. We determine that T7 helicase extracts approximately 3.7 kcal/mol energy from dTTPase to carry out the work of strand separation. Using this energy, T7 helicase unwinds approximately 4 bp of AT-rich DNA or 1-2 bp of GC-rich DNA. T7 helicase therefore adjusts both its speed and coupling ratio (bp/dTTP) to match the work of DNA unwinding. We discuss the mechanistic implications of the variable bp/dTTP that indicates T7 helicase either undergoes backward movements/futile hydrolysis or unwinds DNA with a variable bp-step size; 'long and fast' steps on AT-rich and 'short and slow' steps on GC-rich DNA.     

Structure-Based Mutagenesis Study of Hepatitis C Virus NS3 Helicase

The NS3 protein of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is a bifunctional protein containing a serine protease in the N-terminal one-third, which is stimulated upon binding of the NS4A cofactor, and an RNA helicase in the C-terminal two-thirds. In this study, a C-terminal hexahistidine-tagged helicase domain of the HCV NS3 protein was expressed in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity by conventional chromatography. The purified HCV helicase domain has a basal ATPase activity, a polynucleotide-stimulated ATPase activity, and a nucleic acid unwinding activity and binds efficiently to single-stranded polynucleotide. Detailed characterization of the purified HCV helicase domain with regard to all four activities is presented. Recently, we published an X-ray crystallographic structure of a binary complex of the HCV helicase with a (dU)(8) oligonucleotide, in which several conserved residues of the HCV helicase were shown to be involved in interactions between the HCV helicase and oligonucleotide. Here, site-directed mutagenesis was used to elucidate the roles of these residues in helicase function. Four individual mutations, Thr to Ala at position 269, Thr to Ala at position 411, Trp to Leu at position 501, and Trp to Ala at position 501, produced a severe reduction of RNA binding and completely abolished unwinding activity and stimulation of ATPase activity by poly(U), although the basal ATPase activity (activity in the absence of polynucleotide) of these mutants remained intact. Alanine substitution at Ser-231 or Ser-370 resulted in enzymes that were indistinguishable from wild-type HCV helicase with regard to all four activities. A mutant bearing Phe at Trp-501 showed wild-type levels of basal ATPase, unwinding activity, and single-stranded RNA binding activity. Interestingly, ATPase activity of this mutant became less responsive to stimulation by poly(U) but not to stimulation by other polynucleotides, such as poly(C). Given the conservation of some of these residues in other DNA and RNA helicases, their role in the mechanism of unwinding of double-stranded nucleic acid is discussed.     

DNA mechanics as a tool to probe helicase and translocase activity

Helicases and translocases are proteins that use the energy derived from ATP hydrolysis to move along or pump nucleic acid substrates. Single molecule manipulation has proved to be a powerful tool to investigate the mechanochemistry of these motors. Here we first describe the basic mechanical properties of DNA unraveled by single molecule manipulation techniques. Then we demonstrate how the knowledge of these properties has been used to design single molecule assays to address the enzymatic mechanisms of different translocases. We report on four single molecule manipulation systems addressing the mechanism of different helicases using specifically designed DNA substrates: UvrD enzyme activity detection on a stretched nicked DNA molecule, HCV NS3 helicase unwinding of a RNA hairpin under tension, the observation of RecBCD helicase/nuclease forward and backward motion, and T7 gp4 helicase mediated opening of a synthetic DNA replication fork. We then discuss experiments on two dsDNA translocases: the RuvAB motor studied on its natural substrate, the Holliday junction, and the chromosome-segregation motor FtsK, showing its unusual coupling to DNA supercoiling.     

Mechanisms of a ring shaped helicase

Bacteriophage T7 helicase (T7 gene 4 helicase-primase) is a prototypical member of the ring-shaped family of helicases, whose structure and biochemical mechanisms have been studied in detail. T7 helicase assembles into a homohexameric ring that binds single-stranded DNA in its central channel. Using RecA-type nucleotide binding and sensing motifs, T7 helicase binds and hydrolyzes several NTPs, among which dTTP supports optimal protein assembly, DNA binding and unwinding activities. During translocation along single stranded DNA, the subunits of the ring go through dTTP hydrolysis cycles one at a time, and this probably occurs also during DNA unwinding. Interestingly, the unwinding speed of T7 helicase is an order of magnitude slower than its translocation rate along single stranded DNA. The slow unwinding rate is greatly stimulated when DNA synthesis by T7 DNA polymerase is coupled to DNA unwinding. Using the T7 helicase as an example, we highlight critical findings and discuss possible mechanisms of helicase action.     

A helicase assay based on the displacement of fluorescent, nucleic acid-binding ligands.

We have developed a new helicase assay that overcomes many limitations of other assays used to measure this activity. This continuous, kinetic assay is based on the displacement of fluorescent dyes from dsDNA upon DNA unwinding. These ligands exhibit significant fluorescence enhancement when bound to duplex nucleic acids and serve as the reporter molecules of DNA unwinding. We evaluated the potential of several dyes [acridine orange, ethidium bromide, ethidium homodimer, bis-benzimide (DAPI), Hoechst 33258 and thiazole orange] to function as suitable reporter molecules and demonstrate that the latter three dyes can be used to monitor the helicase activity of Escherichia coli RecBCD enzyme. Both the binding stoichiometry of RecBCD enzyme for the ends of duplex DNA and the apparent rate of unwinding are not significantly perturbed by two of these dyes. The effects of temperature and salt concentration on the rate of unwinding were also examined. We propose that this dye displacement assay can be readily adapted for use with other DNA helicases, with RNA helicases, and with other enzymes that act on nucleic acids.     

Yeast Pif1 Helicase Exhibits a One-base-pair Stepping Mechanism for Unwinding Duplex DNA

Kinetic analysis of the DNA unwinding and translocation activities of helicases is necessary for characterization of the biochemical mechanism(s) for this class of enzymes. Saccharomyces cerevisiae Pif1 helicase was characterized using presteady state kinetics to determine rates of DNA unwinding, displacement of streptavidin from biotinylated DNA, translocation on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA), and ATP hydrolysis activities. Unwinding of substrates containing varying duplex lengths was fit globally to a model for stepwise unwinding and resulted in an unwinding rate of ∼75 bp/s and a kinetic step size of 1 base pair. Pif1 is capable of displacing streptavidin from biotinylated oligonucleotides with a linear increase in the rates as the length of the oligonucleotides increased. The rate of translocation on ssDNA was determined by measuring dissociation from varying lengths of ssDNA and is essentially the same as the rate of unwinding of dsDNA, making Pif1 an active helicase. The ATPase activity of Pif1 on ssDNA was determined using fluorescently labeled phosphate-binding protein to measure the rate of phosphate release. The quantity of phosphate released corresponds to a chemical efficiency of 0.84 ATP/nucleotides translocated. Hence, when all of the kinetic data are considered, Pif1 appears to move along DNA in single nucleotide or base pair steps, powered by hydrolysis of 1 molecule of ATP.     

T7 DNA helicase: a molecular motor that processively and unidirectionally translocates along single-stranded DNA

DNA helicases are molecular motors that use the energy from NTP hydrolysis to drive the process of duplex DNA strand separation. Here, we measure the translocation and energy coupling efficiency of a replicative DNA helicase from bacteriophage T7 that is a member of a class of helicases that assembles into ring-shaped hexamers. Presteady state kinetics of DNA-stimulated dTTP hydrolysis activity of T7 helicase were measured using a real time assay as a function of ssDNA length, which provided evidence for unidirectional translocation of T7 helicase along ssDNA. Global fitting of the kinetic data provided an average translocation rate of 132 bases per second per hexamer at 18 degrees C. While translocating along ssDNA, T7 helicase hydrolyzes dTTP at a rate of 49 dTTP per second per hexamer, which indicates that the energy from hydrolysis of one dTTP drives unidirectional movement of T7 helicase along two to three bases of ssDNA. One of the features that distinguishes this ring helicase is its processivity, which was determined to be 0.99996, which indicated that T7 helicase travels on an average about 75kb of ssDNA before dissociating. We propose that the ability of T7 helicase to translocate unidirectionally along ssDNA in an efficient manner plays a crucial role in DNA unwinding.     

The functional interaction of the hepatitis C virus helicase molecules is responsible for unwinding processivity

Although helicases participate in virtually every cellular process involving nucleic acids, the details of their mechanism including the role of interaction between the subunits remains unclear. Here we study the unwinding kinetics of the helicase from hepatitis C virus using DNA substrates with a range of tail and duplex lengths. The binding of the helicase to the substrates was characterized by electron microscopy and fluorimetric titrations. Depending on the length of the ssDNA tail, one or more helicase molecules can be loaded on the DNA. Unwinding was measured under single-turnover conditions, and the results show that a monomer is active on short duplexes yet multiple molecules are needed to unwind long duplexes. Thus, increasing the ssDNA tail length increases the unwinding efficiency. The unwinding kinetics was modeled as a stepwise process performed by single or multiple helicase molecules. The model programmed in MATLAB was used for global fitting of the kinetics, yielding values for the rate of unwinding, processivity, cooperativity, step size, and occlusion site. The results indicate that a single hepatitis C virus helicase molecule unwinds DNA with a low processivity. The multiple helicase molecules present on the DNA substrate show functional cooperativity and unwind with greater efficiency, although they bind and release the substrate non-cooperatively, and the ATPase cycle of the helicase molecules is not coordinated. The functional interaction model explains the efficient unwinding by multiple helicases and is generally applicable.     

Crystal structure of the hexameric replicative helicase RepA of plasmid RSF1010

Unwinding of double-stranded DNA into single-stranded intermediates required for various fundamental life processes is catalyzed by helicases, a family of mono-, di- or hexameric motor proteins fueled by nucleoside triphosphate hydrolysis. The three-dimensional crystal structure of the hexameric helicase RepA encoded by plasmid RSF1010 has been determined by X-ray diffraction at 2.4 A resolution. The hexamer shows an annular structure with 6-fold rotational symmetry and a approximately 17 A wide central hole, suggesting that single-stranded DNA may be threaded during unwinding. Homologs of all five conserved sequence motifs of the DnaB-like helicase family are found in RepA, and the topography of the monomer resembles RecA and the helicase domain of the bacteriophage T7 gp4 protein. In a modeled complex, ATP molecules are located at the subunit interfaces and clearly define adenine-binding and ATPase catalytic sites formed by amino acid residues located on adjacent monomers; most remarkable is the "arginine finger" Arg207 contributing to the active site in the adjacent monomer. This arrangement of active-site residues suggests cooperativity between monomers in ATP hydrolysis and helicase activity of RepA. The mechanism of DNA unwinding remains elusive, as RepA is 6-fold symmetric, contrasting the recently published asymmetric structure of the bacteriophage T7 gp4 helicase domain.     

Processivity of nucleic acid unwinding and translocation by helicases

Helicases are a class of enzymes that use the chemical energy of NTP hydrolysis to drive mechanical processes such as translocation and nucleic acid (NA) strand separation. Besides the NA unwinding speed, another important factor for the helicase activity is the NA unwinding processivity. Here, we study the NA unwinding processivity with an analytical model that captures the phenomenology of the NA unwinding process. First, we study the processivity of the non‐hexameric helicase that can unwind NA efficiently in the form of a monomer and the processivity of the hexameric helicase that can unwind DNA effectively, providing quantitative explanations of the available single‐molecule experimental data. Then, we study the processivity of the non‐hexameric helicases, in particular UvrD, in the form of a dimer and compare with that in the form of a monomer. The available single‐molecule and some biochemical data showing that while UvrD monomer is a highly processive single‐stranded DNA translocase it is inactive in DNA unwinding, whereas other biochemical data showing that UvrD is active in both single‐stranded DNA translocation and DNA unwinding in the form of a monomer can be explained quantitatively and consistently. In addition, the recent single‐molecule data are also explained quantitatively showing that constraining the 2B subdomain in closed conformation by intramolecular cross‐linking can convert Rep monomer with a very poor DNA unwinding activity into a superhelicase that can unwind more than thousands of DNA base pairs processively, even against a large opposing force. Proteins 2016; 84:1590–1605. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Structurally conserved amino Acid w501 is required for RNA helicase activity but is not essential for DNA helicase activity of hepatitis C virus NS3 protein

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) is a positive-strand RNA virus that encodes a helicase required for viral replication. Although HCV does not replicate through a DNA intermediate, HCV helicase unwinds both RNA and DNA duplexes. An X-ray crystal structure of the HCV helicase complexed with (dU)(8) has been solved, and the substrate-amino acids interactions within the catalytic pocket were shown. Among these, residues W501 and V432 were reported to have base stacking interactions and to be important for the unwinding function of HCV helicase. It has been hypothesized that specific interactions between the enzyme and substrate in the catalytic pocket are responsible for the substrate specificity phenotype. We therefore mutagenized W501 and V432 to investigate their role in substrate specificity in HCV helicase. Replacement of W501, but not V432, with nonaromatic residues resulted in complete loss of RNA unwinding activity, whereas DNA unwinding activity was largely unaffected. The loss of unwinding activity was fully restored in the W501F mutant, indicating that the aromatic ring is crucial for RNA helicase function. Analysis of ATPase and nucleic acid binding activities in the W501 mutant enzymes revealed that these activities are not directly responsible for the substrate specificity phenotype. Molecular modeling of the enzyme-substrate interaction at W501 revealed a putative pi-facial hydrogen bond between the 2'-OH of ribose and the aromatic tryptophan ring. This evidence correlates with biochemical results suggesting that the pi-facial bond may play an important role in the RNA unwinding activity of the HCV NS3 protein.     

UvrD helicase unwinds DNA one base pair at a time by a two-part power stroke

Helicases use the energy derived from nucleoside triphosphate hydrolysis to unwind double helices in essentially every metabolic pathway involving nucleic acids. Earlier crystal structures have suggested that DNA helicases translocate along a single-stranded DNA in an inchworm fashion. We report here a series of crystal structures of the UvrD helicase complexed with DNA and ATP hydrolysis intermediates. These structures reveal that ATP binding alone leads to unwinding of 1 base pair by directional rotation and translation of the DNA duplex, and ADP and Pi release leads to translocation of the developing single strand. Thus DNA unwinding is achieved by a two-part power stroke in a combined wrench-and-inchworm mechanism. The rotational angle and translational distance of DNA define the unwinding step to be 1 base pair per ATP hydrolyzed. Finally, a gateway for ssDNA translocation and an alternative strand-displacement mode may explain the varying step sizes reported previously.