Expression of the barley dehydrin multigene family and the development of freezing tolerance

Dehydrins (DHNs; LEA D11) are one of the typical families of plant proteins that accumulate in response to dehydration, low temperature, osmotic stress or treatment with abscisic acid (ABA), or during seed maturation. We previously found that three genes encoding low-molecular-weight DHNs (Dhn1, Dhn2 and Dhn9) map within a 15-cM region of barley chromosome 5H that overlaps a QTL for winterhardiness, while other Dhn genes encoding low- and high-molecular-weight DHNs are located on chromosomes 3H, 4H and 6H. Here we examine the expression of specific Dhn genes under conditions associated with expression of the winterhardiness phenotype. Plants grown at 4 degrees C or in the field in Riverside, California developed similar, modest levels of freezing tolerance, coinciding with little low-MW Dhn gene activity. Dicktoo (the more tolerant cultivar) and Morex (the less tolerant) grown in Saskatoon, Canada expressed higher levels of expression of genes for low-MW DHNs than did the same cultivars in Riverside, with expression being higher in Dicktoo than Morex. Dehydration or freeze-thaw also evoked expression of genes for low MW DHNs, suggesting that the dehydration component of freeze-thaw in the field induces low expression of genes encoding low-MW DHNs. These observations are consistent with the hypothesis that the major chilling-induced DHNs help to prime plant cells for acclimation to more intense cold, which then involves adaptation to dehydration during freeze-thaw cycling. A role for chromosome 5H-encoded DHNs in acclimation to more intense cold seems possible, even though it is not the basis of the major heritable variation in winterhardiness within the Dicktoo x Morex population.     

Barley Cbf3 gene identification,expression pattern,and map location

Although cold and drought adaptation in cereals and other plants involve the induction of a large number of genes, inheritance studies in Triticeae (wheat [Triticum aestivum], barley [Hordeum vulgare], and rye [Secale cereale]) have revealed only a few major loci for frost or drought tolerance that are consistent across multiple genetic backgrounds and environments. One might imagine that these loci could encode highly conserved regulatory factors that have global effects on gene expression; therefore, genes encoding central regulators identified in other plants might be orthologs of these Triticeae stress tolerance genes. The CBF/DREB1 regulators, identified originally in Arabidopsis as key components of cold and drought regulation, merit this consideration. We constructed barley cDNA libraries, screened these libraries and a barley bacterial artificial chromosome library using rice (Oryza sativa) and barley Cbf probes, found orthologs of Arabidopsis CBF/DREB1 genes, and examined the expression and genetic map location of the barley Cbf3 gene, HvCbf3. HvCbf3 was induced by a chilling treatment. HvCbf3 is located on barley chromosome 5H between markers WG364b and saflp58 on the barley cv Dicktoo x barley cv Morex genetic linkage map. This position is some 40 to 50 cM proximal to the winter hardiness quantitative trait locus that includes the Vrn-1H gene, but may coincide with the wheat 5A Rcg1 locus, which governs the threshold temperature at which cor genes are induced. From this, it remains possible that HvCbf3 is the basis of a minor quantitative trait locus in some genetic backgrounds, though that possibility remains to be thoroughly explored.     

Map locations of barley Dhn genes determined by gene-specific PCR

We previously identified 11 unique barley Dhn genes and found, using wheat-barley addition lines, that these genes are dispersed on four chromosomes 3H, 4H, 5H, 6H. In the present work, more precise positions of barley Dhn genes were determined using gene-specific PCR and 100 doubled haploid lines developed from a cross of Dicktoo and Morex barley. Dhn10 is located on 3H between saflp106 and ABG4. Dhn6 is at the previously determined position on 4H between SOLPRO and BCD265a. Dhn1 and Dhn2 are at the previously determined position on 5H between mR and saflp172. The Dhn locus previously called Dhn4a on barley 5H or Dhn2.2 on T. monococcum 5A is in fact Dhn9 and maps to a revised position between BCD265b and saflp218. Dhn3, Dhn4, Dhn7 and Dhn5 each map to the same position on chromosome 6H, suggesting that the previously reported separation of Dhn3, Dhn4 and Dhn5 may reflect limitations in the accuracy of Southern blot data. In addition to clarifying the map positions of these important stress-related genes, these results illustrate the advantage of gene-specific probes for the mapping of individual genes in a multi-gene family. Received: 11 August 1999 / Accepted: 16 December 1999     

A newly identified barley gene, Dhn12, encoding a YSK2 DHN, is located on chromosome 6H and has embryo-specific expression

Dehydrins are water-soluble lipid-associating proteins that accumulate during low-temperature or water-deficit conditions, and are thought to play a role in freezing- and drought-tolerance in plants. Dhn genes exist as multi-gene families in plants. Previously, we screened lambda genomic libraries of two barley cultivars in an effort to isolate all of the barley Dhn genes. We identified 11 unique Dhn genes and estimated a total of 13 Dhn genes in the barley genome. To extend the collection, we used an alternative source of clones, a 1.5×Morex barley BAC library. In this library, we found nine Dhn genes that we described previously and one new Dhn gene, Dhn12. The Dhn12 gene encodes an acidic YSK₂ dehydrin. The Dhn12 gene is located on chromosome 6H, and shows a different expression pattern from all other Dhn genes identified previously. RT-PCR results show that Dhn12 expression is embryo-specific. Dhn12 is not expressed in seedling shoots under any of the conditions tested, including non-stressed as well as dehydrated, or cold-, ABA- or NaCl-treated seedlings. Received: 6 June 1999 / Accepted: 3 November 1999     

Genetic analysis of the accumulation of COR14 proteins in wild (Hordeum spontaneum) and cultivated (Hordeum vulgare) barley

The cold-regulated (COR14) protein of 14 kDa is a polypeptide accumulated under low-temperature conditions in the chloroplasts of barley leaves. In H. vulgare the COR14 antibody cross-reacts with two proteins, with a slightly different relative molecular weight around the marker of 14.4 kDa, referred to as COR14a and COR14b (high and low relative molecular weight, respectively). In a collection of H. spontaneum genotypes a clear polymorphism was found for the corresponding COR proteins. While some accessions showed the same COR pattern as cultivated barley, in 38 out of 61 accessions examined the COR14 antibody cross-reacted with an additional coldregulated protein with a relative molecular weight of about 24 kDa (COR24). The accumulation of COR24 was often associated with the absence of COR14b; the relationship between the COR14b/COR24 polymorphism and the adaptation of H. spontaneum to different environments is discussed. By studying COR14 accumulation in cultivated barley we have found that the threshold induction-temperature of COR14a is associated with the loci controlling winter hardiness. This association was demonstrated by using either a set of 30 cultivars of different origin, or two sets of frost-tolerant and frost-sensitive F1 doubled-haploid lines derived from the cross Dicktoo (winter type) x Morex (spring type). These results suggest that the threshold induction-temperature of COR14a can be a potential biochemical marker for the identification of superior frostresistant barley genotypes.     

Nucleotide sequence and molecular analysis of the low temperature induced cereal gene, BLT4

Summary The nucleotide sequence and derived amino acid sequence of a cDNA clone (BLT4) for a low temperature induced barley gene were determined. This gene, together with a small family of related genes, was shown to reside on chromosome 3. The BLT4 clone has homology with genes in wheat and oats. Its expression was studied in oats and in barley doubled haploid lines segregating for spring/winter habit and for frost hardiness. These analyses show that elevated steady state levels of BLT4 mRNA are produced in shoot meristematic tissue after 3 days low positive temperature treatment. The low temperature response was found in all barley doubled haploid lines and was therefore not associated specifically with either the spring/winter habit or frost hardiness. Elevated levels of BLT4 mRNA were also seen in drought-stressed barley and it is likely that this is a gene encoding a low molecular weight protein that is responsive to dehydrative stresses, such as cold and drought.The EMBL accession number for BLT4 is X56547 H. vulgare cDNA     

Adaptive microclimatic evolution of the dehydrin 6 gene in wild barley at ��Evolution Canyon��, Israel

Dehydrins are one of the major stress-induced gene families, and the expression of dehydrin 6 (Dhn6) is strictly related to drought in barley. In order to investigate how the evolution of the Dhn6 gene is associated with adaptation to environmental changes, we examined 48 genotypes of wild barley, Hordeum spontaneum, from "Evolution Canyon" at Mount Carmel, Israel. The Dhn6 sequences of the 48 genotypes were identified, and a recent insertion of 342?bp at 5'UTR was found in the sequences of 11 genotypes. Both nucleotide and haplotype diversity of single nucleotide polymorphism in Dhn6 coding regions were higher on the AS ("African" slope or dry slope) than on the ES ("European" slope or humid slope), and the applied Tajima D and Fu-Li test rejected neutrality of SNP diversity. Expression analysis indicated that the 342?bp insertion at 5'UTR was associated with the earlier up-regulation of Dhn6 after dehydration. The genetic divergence of amino acids sequences indicated significant positive selection of Dhn6 among the wild barley populations. The diversity of Dhn6 in microclimatic divergence slopes suggested that Dhn6 has been subjected to natural selection and adaptively associated with drought resistance of wild barley at "Evolution Canyon".     

Expression analysis of dehydrin multigene family across tolerant and susceptible barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) genotypes in response to terminal drought stress

Dehydrins are one of the characteristic families of plant proteins that usually accumulate in response to drought. In the present study, gene expressions of dehydrin multigene family (13 genes) were examined in flag leaves of tolerant (Yousef) and susceptible (Moroco) barley varieties under terminal drought to characterize the involvement of dehydrins in the adaptive processes. The stomatal conductance, RWC, and Chl a, b contents had more reduction in Moroco than the Yousef which has more elevated osmotic adjustment. Drought stress increased significantly MDA and electrolyte leakage levels, but greater in Moroco, indicating a poor protection of cell and cytoplasmic membrane in this variety. Yousef variety had no reduction in grain yield under drought condition. Five genes (Dhn1, Dhn3, Dhn5, Dhn7 and Dhn9) were exclusively induced in Yousef under drought stress. In the stress condition, relative gene expression of Dhn3, Dhn9 had the direct correlations (P < 0.05) with Chl a, b contents, osmotic adjustment, stomatal conductance, plant biomass and grain yield, and the negative correlations (P < 0.05) with MDA and electrolyte leakage levels. The results supported the impending functional roles of dehydrin K_n and particularly Y_nSK_n types in dehydration tolerance of barley during the reproductive stage.     

Haplotype variability and identification of new functional alleles at the Rdg2a leaf stripe resistance gene locus

The barley Rdg2a locus confers resistance to the leaf stripe pathogen Pyrenophora graminea and, in the barley genotype Thibaut, it is composed of a gene family with three highly similar paralogs. Only one member of the gene family (called as Rdg2a) encoding for a CC-NB-LRR protein is able to confer resistance to the leaf stripe isolate Dg2. To study the genome evolution and diversity at the Rdg2a locus, sequences spanning the Rdg2a gene were compared in two barley cultivars, Thibaut and Morex, respectively, resistant and susceptible to leaf stripe. An overall high level of sequence conservation interrupted by several rearrangements that included three main deletions was observed in the Morex contig. The main deletion of 13,692 bp was most likely derived from unequal crossing over between Rdg2a paralogs leading to the generation of a chimeric Morex rdg2a gene which was not associated to detectable level of resistance toward leaf stripe. PCR-based analyses of genic and intergenic regions at the Rdg2a locus in 29 H. vulgare lines and one H. vulgare ssp. spontaneum accession indicated large haplotype variability in the cultivated barley gene pool suggesting rapid and recent divergence at this locus. Barley genotypes showing the same haplotype as Thibaut at the Rdg2a locus were selected for a Rdg2a allele mining through allele re-sequencing and two lines with polymorphic nucleotides leading to amino acid changes in the CC-NB and LRR encoding domains, respectively, were identified. Analysis of nucleotide diversity of the Rdg2a alleles revealed that the polymorphic sites were subjected to positive selection. Moreover, strong positively selected sites were located in the LRR encoding domain suggesting that both positive selection and divergence at homologous loci are possibly representing the molecular mechanism for the generation of high diversity at the Rdg2a locus in the barley gene pool.     

Cryoprotective activity of a cold-induced dehydrin purified from barley

Dehydrins are a family of proteins associated with cell dehydration. Drought, salinity, and high and low temperature may cause water loss from cells. Cold‐induced dehydrins have been reported in several species. P‐80 is a cold‐induced 80 kDa dehydrin in barley. This protein has the same apparent molecular mass as Dhn5, previously described for barley cv Himalaya. P‐80 was localized in the vicinity of vascular cylinders and in the epidermis of leaves and stems. Both tissues have been reported to be sites of early ice nucleation during controlled freezing. The present authors have proposed that this protein cryoprotects macromolecules and frost‐sensitive structures. In the present study, P‐80 and Dhn5 were purified with the purposes of demonstrating their cryoprotective activity in vitro, and comparing both proteins. More than 95% purity was obtained combining heat treatment, cationic exchange chromatography, preparative denaturant electrophoresis and band electroelution. Western blots showed that P‐80 was the major cold‐induced dehydrin in the cultivars examined in the present study. There was a major band of mRNA that showed expression kinetics consistent with P‐80 accumulation. The RT‐PCR picked one major band when using Dhn5‐specific primers in four cold‐acclimated barley cultivars. Both proteins have a similar amino acid composition, with differences in Arg, Asn + Asp, Glu + Gln, His, and Lys. The analysis of proteolytic fragments of Dhn5 and P‐80 by reverse phase chromatography showed a similar pattern. Furthermore, both proteins were able to cryoprotect lactate dehydrogenase (LDH, EC 1.1.1.27) against freeze/thaw inactivation, showing a similar shape dependence on concentration and almost the same protein dosage that renders 50% of cryoprotection (PD₅₀). Thus, P‐80 and Dhn‐5 share more similarities than expected for two different proteins. Their identities, though, remain to be firmly established. Further research is necessary to establish if the observed in vitro cryoprotective activity of these dehydrins is important for cryoprotection in vivo. The association of cryoprotective activity with K repeats of dehydrins is discussed.     

Increased dehydrin promoter activity caused by HvSPY is independent of the ABA response pathway

A barley SPINDLY protein, HvSPY, is a negative regulator of gibberellin (GA) action. It is also found to be a positive regulator of the promoter of a barley dehydrin (Dhn) gene which is abscisic acid (ABA) upregulated. To investigate whether HvSPY acts through the ABA signaling pathway to upregulate the Dhn promoter, functional characterization was carried out by co-bombardment experiments. These experiments used Dhn promoter-GUS reporter constructs and an effector construct to overexpress HvSPY protein in barley aleurone. ABA dose-response experiments with and without HvSPY overexpression showed that the induction by HvSPY occurred in addition to the ABA effect. Gibberellic acid (GA3) did not reduce the induction by ABA, but it had a small, although significant, effect on the ability of HvSPY to upregulate. The induction of promoter activity of Dhn by HvSPY required the intact protein, and a small deletion in the tetratricopeptide repeat (TPR) region reduced this ability significantly. When a promoter region containing an element for ABA responsiveness was mutagenized or deleted, the mutant promoters lost ABA responsiveness but remained responsive to HvSPY. In addition, HvSPY did not increase promoter activities of other ABA-upregulated genes. Taken together, these results indicate that HvSPY and ABA both regulate promoter activity of Dhn, and that HvSPY acts independently of the ABA signaling pathway.     

Molecular dissection of a dormancy QTL region near the chromosome 7 (5H) L telomere in barley

Moderate seed dormancy is desirable in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.). It is difficult for breeders to manipulate seed dormancy in practical breeding programs because of complex inheritance and large environmental effects. Quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping opens a way for breeders to manipulate quantitative trait genes. A seed dormancy QTL, SD2, was mapped previously in an 8-cM interval near the chromosome 7 (5H) L telomere from a cross of 'Steptoe' (dormant)/'Morex' (non-dormant) by the North American Barley Genome Project using an interval mapping method and a relatively low-resolution genetic map. SD2 has a moderate dormancy effect, which makes it a promising candidate gene for moderate seed dormancy in barley cultivar development. The fine mapping of SD2 is required for efficient manipulation of SD2 in breeding and would facilitate the study of dormancy in barley. Ten different Morex isolines were generated, including regenerated Morex, of which nine lines had duplicates. The isolines together with Steptoe and Morex were grown in growth room and field environments for 2 years (2000 and 2001). In the growth room, relatively low growing temperatures (25 degrees C day/15 degrees C night) were employed to promote seed dormancy development. Seed germination percentage, determined at different post-harvest after-ripening periods, was used to measure seed dormancy. Fine mapping using the substitution mapping method based on differences among isolines resolved the SD2 QTL into an 0.8-cM interval between molecular markers MWG851D and MWG851B near the chromosome 7 (5H) L telomere. Relatively low temperatures (< or =25 degrees C) during seed development promoted the expression of the SD2 dormancy QTL. The chromosome region above the MWG851D-MWG851B interval might play a role in reducing barley seed dormancy during after-ripening.     

Molecular mapping of a gene responsible for Al-activated secretion of citrate in barley

Aluminium (Al) toxicity is an important limitation to barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) on acid soil. Al-resistant cultivars of barley detoxify Al externally by secreting citrate from the roots. To link the genetics and physiology of Al resistance in barley, genes controlling Al resistance and Al-activated secretion of citrate were mapped. An analysis of Al-induced root growth inhibition from 100 F2 seedlings derived from an Al-resistant cultivar (Murasakimochi) and an Al-sensitive cultivar (Morex) showed that a gene associated with Al resistance is localized on chromosome 4H, tightly linked to microsatellite marker Bmag353. Quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis from 59 F4 seedlings derived from an F3 plant heterozygous at the region of Al resistance on chromosome 4H showed that a gene responsible for the Al-activated secretion of citrate was also tightly linked to microsatellite marker Bmag353. This QTL explained more than 50% of the phenotypic variation in citrate secretion in this population. These results indicate that the gene controlling Al resistance on barley chromosome 4H is identical to that for Al-activated secretion of citrate and that the secretion of citrate is one of the mechanisms of Al resistance in barley. The identification of the microsatellite marker associated with both Al resistance and citrate secretion provides a valuable tool for marker-assisted selection of Al-resistant lines.     

Genetic variation in pea (Pisum) dehydrins: sequence elements responsible for length differences between dehydrin alleles and between dehydrin loci in Pisum sativum L.

 The electrophoretic patterns of dehydrins extracted from mature seeds of a range of pea (Pisum) species revealed extensive variation in dehydrin polypeptide mobility. Variation was also observed among lines of P. sativum. Crosses between lines with different dehydrin electrophoretic patterns produced F₁ seeds with additive patterns, and segregation in the F₂ generation was consistent with a 1 : 2 : 1 ratio, indicating allelic variation at each of two dehydrin loci (Dhn2, Dhn3). Genetic linkage was observed between Dhn2 and Dhn3, and the segregation ratios indicated preferential transmission of one allele at the Dhn3 locus. Dehydrin cDNA clones were characterised that encoded the allelic variants at Dhn2 and Dhn3. Their deduced amino-acid sequences were very similar to each other as well as to the product of the Dhn1 locus reported previously. Comparisons were made between the sequences of allelic variants at a single locus, and between the products of different loci. Differences in the electrophoretic mobilities between allelic variants at Dhn2 and Dhn3 were associated with differences in polypeptide length resulting principally from tandem duplications of 21 (Dhn2) or 24 (Dhn3) amino-acid residues. These duplications accounted for much of the difference in length between dehydrins encoded by the different loci. The conserved core of one of the duplicated regions varied in copy number, and small insertions/deletions of amino acids near this core also contributed to length variation both between allelic forms and between loci. Dehydrins possess characteristic highly conserved amino-acid sequence motifs, yet vary considerably in length. Mechanisms involving sequence duplication appear to be responsible for generating the length differences observed between allelic variants as well as between the products of different loci. Received: 12 June 1997 / Accepted: 29 October 1997     

Low-temperature acclimation of barley cultivars used as parents in mapping populations: response to photoperiod,vernalization and phenological development

Six barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) accessions, previously used as parents of mapping populations, were evaluated for characters potentially affecting the location of low-temperature (LT) tolerance QTLs. Three were of winter growth habit (Kompolti Korai, Nure, and Strider), one was facultative (Dicktoo) and two were spring (Morex and Tremois). Final leaf number (FLN) and LT₅₀ were determined at weekly intervals from 0 to 98 days of LT acclimation/vernalization under both long day (LD) and short day (SD) photoperiods. The point of vegetative/reproductive transition was determined from measurements of double ridge (DR) formation and FLN. With the exception of Nure, SD delayed development by increasing leaf production. Dicktoo was extremely SD sensitive lengthening its vegetative phase by more than 63 days relative to the LD photoperiod. SD had the opposite effect on Nure, causing an accelerating of flowering exhibiting the characteristic of ‘short day vernalization’. All accessions except Dicktoo and Kompolti Korai acclimated rapidly in the first 7 days of LT exposure, approaching their maximum LT tolerance in 14–21 days. Dicktoo and Kompolti Korai continued to slowly acclimate until reproductive transition. The results emphasize two important points: (1) the location of QTLs for LT tolerance, and as a consequence the identification of putative candidate genes, will be a function of the genotypes sampled, the experimental conditions used, and the quality of the phenotypic data and (2) the barley LT tolerance pathway reaches an early impediment relative to closely related more hardy members of the Triticeae such as wheat and rye.     

Adaptive microclimatic structural and expressional dehydrin 1 evolution in wild barley, Hordeum spontaneum, at 'Evolution Canyon', Mount Carmel, Israel

'Evolution Canyon' (ECI) at Lower Nahal Oren, Mount Carmel, Israel, is an optimal natural microscale model for unravelling evolution in action highlighting the twin evolutionary processes of adaptation and speciation. A major model organism in ECI is wild barley, Hordeum spontaneum , the progenitor of cultivated barley, which displays dramatic interslope adaptive and speciational divergence on the 'African' dry slope (AS) and the 'European' humid slope (ES), separated on average by 200 m. Here we examined interslope single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) sequences and the expression diversity of the drought resistant dehydrin 1 gene ( Dhn1 ) between the opposite slopes. We analysed 47 plants (genotypes), 4–10 individuals in each of seven stations (populations) in an area of 7000 m², for Dhn1 sequence diversity located in the 5' upstream flanking region of the gene. We found significant levels of Dhn1 genic diversity represented by 29 haplotypes, derived from 45 SNPs in a total of 708 bp sites. Most of the haplotypes, 25 out of 29 (= 86.2%), were represented by one genotype; hence, unique to one population. Only a single haplotype was common to both slopes. Genetic divergence of sequence and haplotype diversity was generally and significantly different among the populations and slopes. Nucleotide diversity was higher on the AS, whereas haplotype diversity was higher on the ES. Interslope divergence was significantly higher than intraslope divergence. The applied Tajima D rejected neutrality of the SNP diversity. The Dhn1 expression under dehydration indicated interslope divergent expression between AS and ES genotypes, reinforcing Dhn1 associated with drought resistance of wild barley at 'Evolution Canyon'. These results are inexplicable by mutation, gene flow, or chance effects, and support adaptive natural microclimatic selection as the major evolutionary divergent driving force.     

Effects of photo and thermo cycles on flowering time in barley: a genetical phenomics approach

The effects of synchronous photo (16 h daylength) and thermo (2 degrees C daily fluctuation) cycles on flowering time were compared with constant light and temperature treatments using two barley mapping populations derived from the facultative cultivar 'Dicktoo'. The 'Dicktoo'x'Morex' (spring) population (DM) segregates for functional differences in alleles of candidate genes for VRN-H1, VRN-H3, PPD-H1, and PPD-H2. The first two loci are associated with the vernalization response and the latter two with photoperiod sensitivity. The 'Dicktoo'x'Kompolti korai' (winter) population (DK) has a known functional polymorphism only at VRN-H2, a locus associated with vernalization sensitivity. Flowering time in both populations was accelerated when there was no fluctuating factor in the environment and was delayed to the greatest extent with the application of synchronous photo and thermo cycles. Alleles at VRN-H1, VRN-H2, PPD-H1, and PPD-H2--and their interactions--were found to be significant determinants of the increase/decrease in days to flower. Under synchronous photo and thermo cycles, plants with the Dicktoo (recessive) VRN-H1 allele flowered significantly later than those with the Kompolti korai (recessive) or Morex (dominant) VRN-H1 alleles. The Dicktoo VRN-H1 allele, together with the late-flowering allele at PPD-H1 and PPD-H2, led to the greatest delay. The application of synchronous photo and thermo cycles changed the epistatic interaction between VRN-H2 and VRN-H1: plants with Dicktoo type VRN-H1 flowered late, regardless of the allele phase at VRN-H2. Our results are novel in demonstrating the large effects of minor variations in environmental signals on flowering time: for example, a 2 degrees C thermo cycle caused a delay in flowering time of 70 d as compared to a constant temperature.