Reduction of the amyloidogenicity of a protein by specific binding of ligands to the native conformation

It is known that human muscle acylphosphatase (AcP) is able, under appropriate conditions in vitro, to aggregate and form amyloid fibrils of the type associated with human diseases. A number of compounds were tested for their ability to bind specifically to the native conformation of AcP under conditions favoring denaturation and subsequent aggregation and fibril formation. Compounds displaying different binding affinities for AcP were selected and their ability to inhibit protein fibrillization in vitro was evaluated. We found that compounds displaying a relatively high affinity for AcP are able to significantly delay protein fibrillization, mimicking the effect of stabilizing mutations; in addition, the effectiveness of such outcome correlates positively to both ligand concentration and affinity to the native state of AcP. By contrast, the inhibitory effect of ligands on AcP aggregation disappears in a mutant protein in which such binding affinity is lost. These results indicate that the stabilization of the native conformation of amyloidogenic proteins by specific ligand binding can be a strategy of general interest to inhibit amyloid formation in vivo.     

Nature and significance of the interactions between amyloid fibrils and biological polyelectrolytes

Charged polyelectrolytes such as glycosaminoglycans and nucleic acids have frequently been found associated with the proteinaceous deposits in the tissues of patients with amyloid diseases. We have investigated the nature and generality of this phenomenon by studying the ability of different polyanions, including DNA, ATP, heparin, and heparan sulfate, to promote the aggregation of amyloidogenic proteins and to bind to the resulting aggregates. Preformed amyloid fibrils of human muscle acylphosphatase and human lysozyme, proteins with a net positive charge at physiological pH values, were found to bind tightly to the negatively charged DNA or ATP. The effects of the polyelectrolytes on the kinetics of aggregation were studied for acylphosphatase, and the presence of ATP, DNA, or heparin was found to increase its aggregation rate dramatically, with a degree dependent on the net charge and size of the polyanion. Magnesium or calcium ions were found to attenuate, and ultimately to suppress, these interactions, suggesting that they are electrostatic in nature. Moreover, heparin was found to stabilize the aggregated state of acylphosphatase through compensation of electrostatic repulsion. Noteworthy, differences in affinity between native and aggregated acylphosphatase with heparin suggest that amyloid fibrils can themselves behave as polyelectrolytes, interacting very strongly with other polyelectrolytes bearing the opposite charge. Within an in vivo context, the strengthening of the electrostatic interactions with other biological polyelectrolytes, as a consequence of protein misfolding and aggregation, could therefore result in depletion of essential molecular components and contribute to the known cytotoxicity of amyloid fibrils and their precursors.     

Amyloid formation from HypF-N under conditions in which the protein is initially in its native state

Aggregation of the N-terminal domain of the Escherichia coli HypF (HypF-N) was investigated in mild denaturing conditions, generated by addition of 6-12% (v/v) trifluoroethanol (TFE). Atomic force microscopy indicates that under these conditions HypF-N converts into the same type of protofibrillar aggregates previously shown to be highly toxic to cultured cells. These convert subsequently, after some weeks, into well-defined fibrillar structures. The rate of protofibril formation, monitored by thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence, depends strongly on the concentration of TFE. Prior to aggregation the protein has far-UV circular dichroism (CD) and intrinsic fluorescence spectra identical with those observed for the native protein in the absence of co-solvent; the quenching of the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence by acrylamide and the ANS binding properties are also identical in the two cases. These findings indicate that HypF-N is capable of forming amyloid protofibrils and fibrils under conditions in which the protein is initially in a predominantly native-like conformation. The rate constants for folding and unfolding of HypF-N, determined in 10% TFE using the stopped-flow technique, indicate that a partially folded state is in rapid equilibrium with the native state and populated to ca 1%. A kinetic analysis reveals that aggregation results from molecules accessing such a partially folded state. The approach described here shows that it is possible to probe the mechanism of aggregation of a specific protein under conditions in which the protein is initially native and hence relevant to a physiological environment. In addition, the results indicate that toxic protofibrils can be formed from globular proteins under conditions that are only marginally destabilising and in which the large majority of molecules have the native fold. This conclusion emphasises the importance for cells to constantly combat the propensity for even the most stable of these proteins to aggregate.     

Mutational analysis of the aggregation-prone and disaggregation-prone regions of acylphosphatase

We have performed an extensive mutational analysis of aggregation and disaggregation of amyloid-like protofibrils of human muscle acylphosphatase. Our findings indicate that the regions that promote aggregation in 25% (v/v) 2,2,2 trifluoroethanol (TFE) are different from those that promote disaggregation under milder conditions (5% TFE). Significant changes in the rate of disaggregation of protofibrils in 5% TFE result not only from mutations situated in the regions of the sequence that play a key role in the mechanism of aggregation in 25% TFE, but also from mutations located in other regions. In order to rationalise these results, we have used a modified version of the Zyggregator aggregation propensity prediction algorithm to take into account structural rearrangements of the protofibrils that may be induced by changes in solution conditions. Our results suggest that a wider range of residues contributes to the stability of the aggregates in addition to those that play an important kinetic role in the aggregation process. The mutational approach described here is capable of providing residue-specific information on the structure and dynamics of amyloid protofibrils under conditions close to physiological and should be widely applicable to other systems.     

Reversal of protein aggregation provides evidence for multiple aggregated States

Observations that prefibrillar aggregates from different amyloidogenic proteins can be solubilised under some conditions have raised questions as to the generality of this phenomenon and the nature of the factors that influence it. By studying aggregates formed from human muscle acylphosphatase (AcP) under mild denaturing conditions, and by using a battery of techniques, we demonstrate that disaggregation is possible under conditions close to physiological where the protein is stable in its native state. In the presence of 25% (v/v) trifluoroethanol (TFE) AcP undergoes partial unfolding and globular aggregates (60-200 nm in diameter) that can assemble further into clusters (400-800 nm in diameter) develop progressively. Yet larger superstructures (>5 microm) are formed when the concentration of the globular aggregates exceeds a critical concentration. After diluting the sample to give a solution containing 5% TFE, the fraction of partially unfolded monomeric protein refolds very rapidly, with a rate constant of approximately 1s(-1). The 60-200 nm globular aggregates disaggregate with an apparent rate constant of approximately 2.5 x 10(-3)s(-1) while the 400-800 nm clusters disassembly more slowly with a rate constant of approximately 3.1 x 10(-4)s(-1). The larger (>5 microm) superstructures are not disrupted under the conditions used here. These results suggest that amyloid formation occurs in discrete steps whose reversibility is increasingly difficult, and dependent on the size of the aggregates, and that disaggregation experiments can provide a powerful method of detecting different types of species within the complex process of aggregation. In addition, our work suggests that destabilization of amyloid aggregates resulting in the conversion of misfolded proteins back to their native states could be an important factor in both the onset and treatment of diseases associated with protein aggregation.     

Non-fibrillar components of amyloid deposits mediate the self-association and tangling of amyloid fibrils

Amyloid deposits are proteinaceous extra-cellular aggregates associated with a diverse range of disease states. These deposits are composed predominantly of amyloid fibrils, the unbranched, beta-sheet rich structures that result from the misfolding and subsequent aggregation of many proteins. In addition, amyloid deposits contain a number of non-fibrillar components that interact with amyloid fibrils and are incorporated into the deposits in their native folded state. The influence of a number of the non-fibrillar components in amyloid-related diseases is well established; however, the mechanisms underlying these effects are poorly understood. Here we describe the effect of two of the most important non-fibrillar components, serum amyloid P component and apolipoprotein E, upon the solution behavior of amyloid fibrils in an in vitro model system. Using analytical ultracentrifugation, electron microscopy, and rheological measurements, we demonstrate that these non-fibrillar components cause soluble fibrils to condense into localized fibrillar aggregates with a greatly enhanced local density of fibril entanglements. These results suggest a possible mechanism for the observed role of non-fibrillar components as mediators of amyloid deposition and deposit stability.     

Protein particulates: another generic form of protein aggregation?

Protein aggregation is a problem with a multitude of consequences, ranging from affecting protein expression to its implication in many diseases. Of recent interest is the specific form of aggregation leading to the formation of amyloid fibrils, structures associated with diseases such as Alzheimer's disease. The ability to form amyloid fibrils is now regarded as a property generic to all polypeptide chains. Here we show that around the isoelectric point a different generic form of aggregation can also occur by studying seven widely different, nonrelated proteins that are also all known to form amyloid fibrils. Under these conditions gels consisting of relatively monodisperse spherical particulates are formed. Although these gels have been described before for beta-lactoglobulin, our results suggest that the formation of particulates in the regime where charge on the molecules is minimal is a common property of all proteins. Because the proteins used here also form amyloid fibrils, we further propose that protein misfolding into clearly defined aggregates is a generic process whose outcome depends solely on the general properties of the state the protein is in when aggregation occurs, rather than the specific amino acid sequence. Thus under conditions of high net charge, amyloid fibrils form, whereas under conditions of low net charge, particulates form. This observation furthermore suggests that the rules of soft matter physics apply to these systems.     

Prediction of the absolute aggregation rates of amyloidogenic polypeptide chains

Protein aggregation is associated with a variety of pathological conditions, including Alzheimer's and Creutzfeldt-Jakob diseases and type II diabetes. Such degenerative disorders result from the conversion of the normal soluble state of specific proteins into aggregated states that can ultimately form the characteristic amyloid fibrils found in diseased tissue. Under appropriate conditions it appears that many, perhaps all, proteins can be converted in vitro into amyloid fibrils. The aggregation propensities of different polypeptide chains have, however, been observed to vary substantially. Here, we describe an approach that uses the knowledge of the amino acid sequence and of the experimental conditions to reproduce, with a correlation coefficient of 0.92 and over five orders of magnitude, the in vitro aggregation rates of a wide range of unstructured peptides and proteins. These results indicate that the formation of protein aggregates can be rationalised to a considerable extent in terms of simple physico-chemical parameters that describe the properties of polypeptide chains and their environment.     

Effects of randomizing the Sup35NM prion domain sequence on formation of amyloid fibrils in vitro

The mechanism by which proteins aggregate and form amyloid fibrils is still elusive. In order to preclude interference by cellular factors and to clarify the role of the primary sequence of Sup35p prion domain in formation of amyloid fibrils, we generated five Sup35NM variants by randomizing amino acid sequences in PrDs without altering the amino acid composition and analyzed the in vitro process of amyloid fibril formation. The results showed that each of the five Sup35NM variants polymerized into amyloid fibrils in vitro under native conditions. Furthermore, the Sup35NM variants showed differences in their aggregation time courses. These findings indicate that specific amino acid sequence features in PrD can modify the rate of conversion of Sup35p into amyloid fibrils in vitro.     

Dissolution of beta2-microglobulin amyloid fibrils by dimethylsulfoxide

Increasing numbers of proteins have been found to aggregate into insoluble fibers, collectively referred to as amyloid fibrils. To address the conformational stability of amyloid fibrils, we studied the effects of dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE), and 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoro-2-propanol (HFIP) on beta(2)-microglobulin amyloid fibrils by circular dichroism, thioflavin T fluorescence, light scattering, and electron microscopy. When measured by circular dichroism and thioflavin T fluorescence, HFIP, and TFE dissolved the fibrils, producing predominantly helical conformations. However, these alcohols did not dissolve the amyloid fibrils completely as monitored by light scattering and electron microscopy. On the other hand, DMSO completely dissolved the amyloid fibrils although a high concentration [i.e., 80% (v/v)] was required. These results are consistent with the important role of hydrogen bonds in stabilizing amyloid fibrils.     

Folding and Fibrillogenesis: Clues from β2-Microglobulin

Renal failure impairs the clearance of β₂-microglobulin from the serum, with the result that this protein accumulates in joints under the form of amyloid fibrils. While the molecular mechanism leading to deposition of amyloid in vivo is not totally understood, some organic compounds, such as trifluoroethanol (TFE), are commonly used to promote the elongation of amyloid fibrils in vitro. This article gives some insights into the structural properties and the conformational states of β₂-microglobulin in the presence of TFE, using both the wild-type protein and the mutant Trp60Gly. The structure of the native state of the protein is rather insensitive to the presence of the alcohol, but the stability of this state is lowered in comparison to some other conformational states. In particular, a native-like folding intermediate is observed in the presence of moderate concentrations of TFE. Instead, at higher concentrations of the alcohol, the population of a disordered native-unlike state is dominant and correlates with the ability to elongate fibrils.     

Amyloidogenic potential of alpha-chymotrypsin in different conformational states

Amyloid fibril formation is widely believed to be a generic property of polypeptide chains. In the present study, alpha-chymotrypsin, a well-known serine protease has been driven toward these structures by the use of two different conditions involving (I) high temperature, pH 2.5, and (II) low concentration of trifluoroethanol (TFE), pH 2.5. A variety of experimental methods, including fluorescence emission, dynamic quenching, steady-state fluorescence anisotropy, far-UV circular dichroism, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and dynamic light scattering were employed to characterize the conformational states of alpha-chymotrypsin that precede formation of amyloid fibrils. The structure formed under Condition I was an unfolded monomer, whereas an alpha-helical rich oligomer was induced in Condition II. Both the amyloid aggregation-prone species manifested a higher solvent exposure of hydrophobic and aromatic residues compared with the native state. Upon incubation of the protein in these conditions for 48 h, amyloid-like fibrils were formed with diameters of about 10-12 nm. In contrast, at neutral pH and low concentration of TFE, a significant degree of amorphous aggregation was observed, suggesting that charge neutralization of acidic residues in the amyloid core region has a positive influence on amyloid fibril formation. In summary, results presented in this communication suggest that amyloid fibrils of alpha-chymotrypsin may be obtained from a variety of structurally distinct conformational ensembles highlighting the critical importance of protein evolution mechanisms related to prevention of protein misfolding.     

Amyloid fibril formation in the context of full-length protein: effects of proline mutations on the amyloid fibril formation of beta2-microglobulin

Beta2-microglobulin (beta2-m), a typical immunoglobulin domain made of seven beta-strands, is a major component of amyloid fibrils formed in dialysis-related amyloidosis. To understand the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation in the context of full-length protein, we prepared various mutants in which proline (Pro) was introduced to each of the seven beta-strands of beta2-m. The mutations affected the amyloidogenic potential of beta2-m to various degrees. In particular, the L23P, H51P, and V82P mutations significantly retarded fibril extension at pH 2.5. Among these, only L23P is included in the known "minimal" peptide sequence, which can form amyloid fibrils when isolated as a short peptide. This indicates that the residues in regions other than the minimal sequence, such as H51P and V82P, determine the amyloidogenic potential in the full-length protein. To further clarify the mutational effects, we measured their stability against guanidine hydrochloride of the native state at pH 8.0 and the amyloid fibrils at pH 2.5. The amyloidogenicity of mutants showed a significant correlation with the stability of the amyloid fibrils, and little correlation was observed with that of the native state. It has been proposed that the stability of the native state and the unfolding rate to the amyloidogenic precursor as well as the conformational preference of the denatured state determine the amyloidogenicity of the proteins. The present results reveal that, in addition, stability of the amyloid fibrils is a key factor determining the amyloidogenic potential of the proteins.     

Transition of transferrin from native to fibrillar state: An implication for amyloid-linked diseases

Human transferrin (hTF), an α/β protein, transforms from its native soluble form to proto-fibrils and amyloid fibrils at 20% TFE after prolonged incubation. This type of amyloid fibrils is observed in a number of pathological disorders. Existence of dry molten-globule state, at 5% TFE, was characterized by native-like secondary structure, Trp fluorescence and negligible ANS binding, indicating its dry interior. At 15% TFE, decrease in Trp and increase in ANS fluorescence was observed with native-like secondary structure, indicating exposure to water molecule and hence, this was referred to as Wet MG state. AFM revealed protofibrils as smaller in size howbeit amyloid fibrils were long and stiffer in morphology. Amyloid fibrils were found to possess cross-linked β-sheet, lack of tertiary contacts, as revealed by CD and ATR-FTIR, enhanced Thioflavin T fluorescence and shift in Congo red absorbance. These results showed that formation of amyloid fibrils becomes favorable when protein is destabilized in suitable conditions and non-covalent interactions, particularly intermolecular hydrogen bonding becomes prominent. Protofibrils were genotoxic in nature albeit amyloid fibrils lack this effect.     

Amyloid fibrils formed by the programmed cell death regulator Bcl-xL

The accumulation of amyloid fibers due to protein misfolding is associated with numerous human diseases. For example, the formation of amyloid deposits in neurodegenerative pathologies is correlated with abnormal apoptosis. We report here the in vitro formation of various types of aggregates by Bcl-xL, a protein of the Bcl-2 family involved in the regulation of apoptosis. Bcl-xL forms aggregates in three states, micelles, native-like fibrils, and amyloid fibers, and their biophysical characterization has been performed in detail. Bcl-xL remains in its native state within micelles and native-like fibrils, and our results suggest that native-like fibrils are formed by the association of micelles. Formation of amyloid structures, that is, nonnative intermolecular β-sheets, is favored by the proximity of proteins within fibrils at the expense of the Bcl-xL native structure. Finally, we provide evidence of a direct relationship between the amyloid character of the fibers and the tertiary-structure stability of the native Bcl-xL. The potential causality between the accumulation of Bcl-xL into amyloid deposits and abnormal apoptosis during neurodegenerative diseases is discussed.     

The regions of the sequence most exposed to the solvent within the amyloidogenic state of a protein initiate the aggregation process

Formation of misfolded aggregates is an essential part of what proteins can do. The process of protein aggregation is central to many human diseases and any aggregating event needs to be prevented within a cell and in protein design. In order to aggregate, a protein needs to unfold its native state, at least partially. The conformational state that is prone to aggregate is difficult to study, due to its aggregating potential and heterogeneous nature. Here, we use a systematic approach of limited proteolysis, in combination with electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry, to investigate the regions that are most flexible and solvent-exposed within the native, ligand-bound and amyloidogenic states of muscle acylphosphatase (AcP), a protein previously shown to form amyloid fibrils in the presence of trifluoroethanol. Seven proteases with different degrees of specificity have been used for this purpose. Following exposure to the aggregating conditions, a number of sites along the sequence of AcP become susceptible to proteolytic digestion. The pattern of proteolytic cleavages obtained under these conditions is considerably different from that of the native and ligand-bound conformations and includes a portion within the N-terminal tail of the protein (residues 6-7), the region of the sequence 18-23 and the position 94 near the C terminus. There is a significant overlap between the regions of the sequence found to be solvent-exposed from the present study and those previously identified to be critical in the rate-determining steps of aggregation from protein engineering approaches. This indicates that a considerable degree of solvent exposure is a feature of the portions of a protein that initiate the process of aggregation.     

Protein engineering as a strategy to avoid formation of amyloid fibrils

The activation domain of human procarboxypeptidase A2 (ADA2h) aggregates following thermal or chemical denaturation at acidic pH. The aggregated material contains well-defined ordered structures with all the characteristics of the fibrils associated with amyloidotic diseases. Variants of ADA2h containing a series of mutations designed to increase the local stability of each of the two helical regions of the protein have been found to have a substantially reduced propensity to form fibrils. This arises from a reduced tendency of the denatured species to aggregate rather than from a change in the overall stability of the native state. The reduction in aggregation propensity may result from an increase in the stability of local relative to longer range interactions within the polypeptide chain. These findings show that the intrinsic ability of a protein to form amyloid can be altered substantially by protein engineering methods without perturbing significantly its overall stability or activity. This suggests new strategies for combating diseases associated with the formation of aggregated proteins and for the design of novel protein or peptide therapeutics.     

Reduced global cooperativity is a common feature underlying the amyloidogenicity of pathogenic lysozyme mutations

One of the 20 or so human amyloid diseases is associated with the deposition in vital organs of full-length mutational variants of the antibacterial protein lysozyme. Here, we report experimental data that permit a detailed comparison to be made of the behaviour of two of these amyloidogenic variants, I56T and D67H, under identical conditions. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange experiments monitored by NMR and mass spectrometry reveal that, despite their different locations and the different effects of the two mutations on the structure of the native state of lysozyme, both mutations cause a cooperative destabilisation of a remarkably similar segment of the structure, comprising in both cases the beta-domain and the adjacent C-helix. As a result, both variant proteins populate transiently a closely similar, partially unstructured intermediate in which the beta-domain and the adjacent C-helix are substantially and simultaneously unfolded, whereas the three remaining alpha-helices that form the core of the alpha-domain still have their native-like structure. We show, in addition, that the binding of a camel antibody fragment, cAb-HuL6, which was raised against wild-type lysozyme, restores to both variant proteins the stability and cooperativity characteristic of the wild-type protein; as a consequence, it inhibits the formation of amyloid fibrils by both variants. These results indicate that the reduction in global cooperativity, and the associated ability to populate transiently a specific, partly unfolded intermediate state under physiologically relevant conditions, is a common feature underlying the behaviour of these two pathogenic mutations. The formation of intermolecular interactions between lysozyme molecules that are in this partially unfolded state is therefore likely to be the fundamental trigger of the aggregation process that ultimately leads to the formation and deposition in tissue of amyloid fibrils.     

Exploring the mechanism of formation of native-like and precursor amyloid oligomers for the native acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus

Over 40 human diseases are associated with the formation of well-defined proteinaceous fibrillar aggregates. Since the oligomers precursors to the fibrils are increasingly recognized to be the causative agents of such diseases, it is important to elucidate the mechanism of formation of these early species. The acylphosphatase from Sulfolobus solfataricus is an ideal system as it was found to form, under conditions in which it is initially native, two types of prefibrillar aggregates: (1) initial enzymatically active aggregates and (2) oligomers with characteristics reminiscent of amyloid protofibrils, with the latter originating from the structural reorganization of the initial assemblies. By studying a number of protein variants with a variety of biophysical techniques, we have identified the regions of the sequence and the driving forces that promote the first aggregation phase and show that the second phase consists in a cooperative conversion involving the entire globular fold.     

Conformational stability of amyloid fibrils of beta2-microglobulin probed by guanidine-hydrochloride-induced unfolding

Although the stability of globular proteins has been studied extensively, that of amyloid fibrils is scarcely characterized. Beta2-microglobulin (beta2-m) is a major component of the amyloid fibrils observed in patients with dialysis-related amyloidosis. We studied the effects of guanidine hydrochloride on the amyloid fibrils of beta2-m, revealing a cooperative unfolding transition similar to that of the native state. The stability of amyloid fibrils increased on the addition of ammonium sulfate, consistent with a role of hydrophobic interactions. The results indicate that the analysis of unfolding transition is useful to obtain insight into the structural stability of amyloid fibrils.