Deep undercooling of tissue water and winter hardiness limitations in timberline flora

Deep undercooled tissue water, which froze near −40 C, was found in winter collected stem and leaf tissue of the dominant timberline tree species of the Colorado Rocky Mountains, Engelmann spruce (Picea engelmannii (Parry) Engelm.) and subalpine fir (Abies lasiocarpa (Hook.) Nutt.), and in numerous other woody species in and below the subalpine vegetation zone. Previous work on numerous woody plants indicates that deep undercooling in xylem makes probable a −40 C winter hardiness limit in stem tissue. Visual injury determinations and electrolyte loss measurements on stem tissue revealed injury near −40 C associated with the freezing of the deep undercooled stem tissue water. These results suggest that the winter hardiness limit of this woody flora is near −40 C. The relevance of deep undercooling in relation to timberline, the upper elevational limit of the subalpine forest, is discussed.     

Freezing tolerance in Draba chionophila,a ‘miniature’ caulescent rosette species

Summary Freezing tolerance as a cold resistance mechanism is described for the first time in a plant growing in the tropical range of the Andean high mountains. Draba chionophila, the plant in which freezing tolerance was found, is the vascular plant which reaches the highest altitudes in the Venezuelan Andes (approximately 4700m). Night cycles of air and leaf temperature were studied in the field to determine the temperature at which leaf freezing began. In the laboratory, thermal analysis and freezing injury determinations were also carried out. From both field and laboratory experiments, it was determined that freezing of the leaf tissue, as well as root and pith tissue, initiated at a temperature of approximately-5.0°C, while freezing injury occurred at approximately-12.0°C for the pith, and below-14.0°C for roots and leaves. This difference in temperature suggests that the plant still survives freezing in the-5.0 to-14.0°C range. Daily cycles of leaf osmotic potential and soluble carbohydrate concentration were also determined in an attempt to explain some of the changes occurring in this species during the nighttime temperature period. A comparison between Andean and African high mountain plants from the point of view of cold resistance mechanisms is made.     

Induction of Frost Hardiness in Stem Cortical Tissues of Cornus stolonifera Michx. by Water Stress: I. Unfrozen Water in Cortical Tissues and Water Status in Plants and Soil

Water supply and day length were varied in cold hardiness studies of red osier dogwood plants (Cornus stolonifera Michx.). The frost killing temperature, the content and freezing of stem cortical tissue water along with soil moisture content and tension were evaluated. Seven days of water stress in long and short day photoperiod regimes caused a rapid decrease in soil moisture content and plant water potential. During the same period, the frost hardiness increased from −3 to −11 C. Further water stress treatment had little effect. Control plants in short days showed only a gradual decrease in plant water potential and only gradually increased in frost hardiness while control plants in long days were unchanged. Freezing studies using nuclear magnetic resonance showed that increased hardiness in water-stressed plants resulted from both an increased tolerance of freezing and an increased avoidance of freezing, the latter resulting from higher solute concentration in the tissue solutions. The short day controls also showed similar changes; however, the changes were smaller over the 21 days of the study.     

Bark cells and xylem cells in Japanese white birch twigs initiate deacclimation at different temperatures

Appropriate timing of cold deacclimation is an important component of winter survival of perennial plants, such as trees, in temperate and boreal zones. Recently, concerns about predicted global climate change disturbing deacclimation timing have been increasing. The relationship between ambient temperatures and the manner by which cells' freezing resistance changes is essential for forecasting the timing of deacclimation. In this study, Japanese white birch twigs that underwent deacclimation treatment at a constant temperature of −2, 0, 4, 10, or 20 °C were separated into bark in which cells adapted to subfreezing temperatures by extracellular freezing and xylem in which cells adapted to subfreezing temperatures by deep supercooling, and the freezing resistance of cells in each tissue type was investigated by measuring percentage electrolyte leakage. Birch cells deacclimated in a different manner according to tissue type. Within 7 days under deacclimation treatment, xylem cells decreased their freezing resistance significantly at a high subfreezing temperature (−2 °C). In contrast, bark cells required a temperature of 10 or 20 °C for a detectable decrease in freezing resistance to occur within the same period. At a temperature lower than 0 °C, bark cells did not decrease their freezing resistance, even after 28 days of treatment. The difference in freezing behavior of cells might involve the difference in how deacclimation occurred in bark and xylem cells.     

Plant Freezing and Damage

Imaging methods are giving new insights into plant freezingand the consequent damage that affects survival and distributionof both wild and crop plants. Ice can enter plants through stomataand hydathodes. Intrinsic nucleation of freezing can also occur.The initial growth of ice through the plant can be as rapidas 40 mm s^-1, although barriers can limit this growth. Onlya small fraction of plant water is changed to ice in this firstfreezing event. Nevertheless, this first rapid growth of iceis of key importance because it can initiate further, potentiallylethal, freezing at any site that it reaches. Some organs andtissues avoid freezing by supercooling. However, supercooledparts of buds can dehydrate progressively, indicating that avoidanceof freezing-induced dehydration by deep supercooling is onlypartial. Extracellular ice forms in freezing-intolerant as wellas freezing-tolerant species and causes cellular dehydration.The single most important cause of freezing-damage is when thisdehydration exceeds what cells can tolerate. In freezing-adaptedspecies, lethal freezing-induced dehydration causes damage tocell membranes. In specific cases, other factors may also causedamage, examples being cell death when limits to deep supercoolingare exceeded, and death of shoots when freezing-induced embolismsin xylem vessels persist. Extracellular masses of ice can damagethe structure of organs but this may be tolerated, as in extra-organfreezing of buds. Experiments to genetically engineer expressionof fish antifreeze proteins have not improved freezing toleranceof sensitive species. A better strategy may be to confer toleranceof cellular dehydration.Copyright 2001 Annals of Botany Company Freezing, dehydration, infrared video thermography, low temperature scanning electron microscopy, NMR micro-imaging     

Propagation and characterisation of the freezing tolerance of a novel South African ornamental (Cineraria saxifraga)

Successful propagation of Cineraria saxifraga was achieved using apical softwood cuttings and micropropagation protocols. Plants propagated using micropropagation had a multiplication rate eight times that of the original population after 4 wk. Apical cuttings were subjected to a standard conductive freezing test to establish the freezing tolerance of the species. Results showed that cold‐acclimated plants had a 43% increased survival compared to non‐acclimated plants. Using plants established from tissue culture, two further freezing tests were conducted to establish the effects of surface water and container size on the frost resistance of this species. Surface water significantly decreased survival score compared to dry plants. Plants grown in small containers had a significant decrease in plant survival score compared to those grown in large containers.     

Freezing avoidance by supercooling in Olea europaea cultivars: the role of apoplastic water,solute content and cell wall rigidity

Plants can avoid freezing damage by preventing extracellular ice formation below the equilibrium freezing temperature (supercooling). We used Olea europaea cultivars to assess which traits contribute to avoid ice nucleation at sub‐zero temperatures. Seasonal leaf water relations, non‐structural carbohydrates, nitrogen and tissue damage and ice nucleation temperatures in different plant parts were determined in five cultivars growing in the Patagonian cold desert. Ice seeding in roots occurred at higher temperatures than in stems and leaves. Leaves of cold acclimated cultivars supercooled down to ?13 °C, substantially lower than the minimum air temperatures observed in the study site. During winter, leaf ice nucleation and leaf freezing damage (LT₅₀) occurred at similar temperatures, typical of plant tissues that supercool. Higher leaf density and cell wall rigidity were observed during winter, consistent with a substantial acclimation to sub‐zero temperatures. Larger supercooling capacity and lower LT₅₀ were observed in cold‐acclimated cultivars with higher osmotically active solute content, higher tissue elastic adjustments and lower apoplastic water. Irreversible leaf damage was only observed in laboratory experiments at very low temperatures, but not in the field. A comparative analysis of closely related plants avoids phylogenetic independence bias in a comparative study of adaptations to survive low temperatures.     

Does plant height determine the freezing resistance in the páramo plants?

Neotropical ecosystems between treeline and snowline, called páramos, stretch along Andean ranges from Costa Rica to northern Peru. The páramo climate is characterized by regular night frosts occurring throughout the year. Páramo plants use two strategies to deal with freezing temperatures. They either avoid ice formation in the tissues or tolerate extracellular ice formation. We tested the microclimate hypothesis, which suggests that the freezing resistance of the páramo plants is determined by plant height, that is, that taller plants experience a milder microclimate and avoid freezing, whereas smaller plants are exposed to the more extreme thermal conditions near the ground and tolerate them. We measured the temperature at which ice formed inside the plants (the ‘exotherm’), and compared it with the temperature at which 50% damage to the tissue occurred (Lt50); a significant difference between the exotherm and Lt50 would indicate freezing tolerance whereas the absence of a difference would indicate avoidance by supercooling. We analysed the freezing resistance of 38 common Ecuadorian páramo species. We found no correlation between plant height and freezing resistance mechanism or injury temperature and reject the microclimate hypothesis. Tolerant plants reach higher altitudes than avoidant plants, but their altitudinal ranges largely overlap and the Lt50 does not differ between them. These results suggest that there is no qualitative difference between the two strategies to survive the páramo frosts. Shrub leaves were injured at significantly lower temperatures than other life forms, such as herbs, which may reflect leaf anatomical differences among the plants.     

Phenotypic plasticity in Phragmites australis as a functional response to water depth

We have performed investigations to see if the emergent macrophyte Phragmites australis (Cav.) Trin. ex Steud. exhibits phenotypic plasticity as a response to water depth and if such responses in biomass allocation pattern and morphology are functional responses, improving the performance of the plant. In greenhouse experiments plants were grown in deep or shallow water to evaluate plastic responses. Allometric methods were used to handle effects caused by size differences between treatments. To evaluate if phenotypic responses to water depth are functional, the relative growth rate (RGR) of plants acclimatised to shallow or deep water, respectively, were compared in deep water, and the growth of plants in fluctuating and constant water level were compared.When grown in deep (70 or 75 cm), compared to shallow (20 or 5 cm) water, plants allocated proportionally less to below-ground weight, made proportionally fewer but taller stems, and had rhizomes that were situated more superficially in the substrate. Plants acclimatised to shallow water had lower RGR than plants acclimatised to deep water, when they were grown in deep water, and plants in constant water depth (40 cm) grew faster than plants in fluctuating water depth (15/65 cm). In an additional field study, the rhizomes were situated superficially in the sediment in deep, compared to shallow water.We have shown that P. australis acclimatises to deep water with phenotypic plasticity through allocating more resources to stem weight, and also by producing fewer but taller stems, which will act to maintain a positive carbon balance and an effective gas exchange between aerial and below-ground parts. Furthermore, the decreased proportional allocation to below-ground parts probably results in decreased nutrient absorption, decreased anchorage in the sediment and decreased carbohydrate reserves. Thus, in deep water, plants have an increased risk of becoming uprooted and experience decreased growth and dispersal rates.     

Attempts to diminish the injurious consequences of low winter temperatures by means of vitamins and growth substances

Plants of two varieties of winter wheat—Besostoya 1 and Etoile de Choisie— were raised in the field. The same number of selected plants from each variety were frozen once in a refrigerator at a temperature of ?15°C for 24 hrs. After freezing, the plants were gradually thawed and returned to the field. Early in the spring, test and control plants were treated with one of following diluted solutions: vitamin B₁, vitamin B₆, indolyl-3-acetic acid and adenine (the four solutions at a concentration of 0·01% and 5% urea solution in water) by immersion for 15 hrs. at a temperature of 18–20°C. The plants were measured in the spring and in the summer, the yield being determined after ripening. It was found that all substances used helped to diminish the deleterious consequences of overwintering and to raise the yield of the plants. Vitamin B₆ exerted the strongest influence. Vitamin B₆ treated plants produced higher or slightly lower yields than those of the non-frozen control. Plants treated with vitamin B₁ gave yields close to, but in most cases lower than those of the non-frozen control. The yields of plants treated with solutions of the remaining substances were appreciably lower than those of the non-frozen controls. Plants of the more winter-hardy variety Besostoya 1 recovered relatively more easily under the effect of the substances used than the plants of the less winter-hardy variety Etoile de Choise.     

Deep Undercooling in Woody Taxa Growing North of the -40 degrees C Isotherm

The freezing of deep undercooled water in cold-hardened 3-year-old stems of 16 woody taxa was studied in mid-January by differential thermal analysis. The initiation temperature and the size of the low temperature exotherm (LTE) were compared for nonthawed, thawed, and freeze-killed stems. In general, the initiation temperature of the LTE for nonthawed stems occurred at a lower temperature than for thawed stems and freeze-killed stems. In some cases, no LTE was detected in nonthawed stems although a LTE was detected after thawing. The size of the LTE increased after thawing the stem and also after the stem was freeze killed. The LTE observed in one species disappeared upon exposure to continuous low sub-zero temperatures. Results suggest that undercooling which subsequently results in the LTE in woody stems is due to the cell wall and the plasma membrane. During periods of prolonged freezing, cellular water migrates from the cells which undercool to extracellular ice. This results in a concentration of cell solutes which lowers the homogeneous nucleation temperature of the cell sap. The cold hardiness of nonthawed and thawed stems was compared by a controlled freeze test. In general, thawing had little effect on the survival temperature whereas it had a marked effect on the initiation of the LTE.     

模拟喀斯特不同土壤生境下黑麦草对水分胁迫的生长和光合生理响应

以多年生草本黑麦草为对象,模拟喀斯特生境土壤特征设置浅而宽(Shallow and wide, SW:30×30×5 cm³)和深而窄(Deep and narrow, DN:10×10×45 cm³)两种土壤容器,以正常降水量为对照供水(W100%),设减水50%(W50%)和减水70%(W30%)共3种水分处理进行盆栽实验,探究了两种不同土壤生境中土壤水分变化对黑麦草生长及光合生理的影响,以进一步理解喀斯特地区植物的适应对策。结果显示:(1)SW生境对水分变化敏感,随供水减少土壤含水量显著下降。轻度减水下植物叶面积增大,光合速率提高,地上部分生长得到促进,但水分严重减少对其生长和光合生理有抑制作用,但地上质量分数和水分利用效率却显著升高;(2)DN生境保水能力较好,随供水减少土壤水分含量下降较为平缓。叶片相对含水量、气孔导度和比叶面积在各水分处理之间差异不显著,但严重减水条件下总生物量、地上质量分数和水分利用效率均有回升。研究表明:浅而宽生境中植物倾向于通过提高地上部分的生长,保持较高的光合速率,并向地上部分分配较多生物量来应对水分胁迫;...     

Interrelations between Environmental Factors and Freezing Resistance of Cabbage Leaves

Rapid wilting of cabbage leaves (Brassica capitata L.), induced by excision of the shoot, induced as rapid and high a degree of freezing resistance as a similar period of hardening at low temperature. Maximum hardening in the leaf was generally associated with the maximum growth rate. On the other hand, exposure of the excised shoot to low temperature while immersed in aerated water failed to harden the plants. In the absence of light, abrupt wilting at room or low temperature induced little or no hardening. With the available equipment, which required the absence of light, freezing temperatures induced little or no hardening above that obtained by nonfreezing low temperature. In fact, the plant frozen at moderate temperatures showed a gradual but steady decrease in freezing resistance. Since these experiments were performed with plants grown in pots, and since they eventually became pot-bound, the results may not apply equally to field-grown plants.     

Selective freezing of target biological tissues after injection of solutions with specific thermal properties

Cryosurgery is a minimally invasive surgical technique that employs the destructive effect of freezing to eradicate undesirable tissues. This paper proposes a flexible method to control the size and shape of the iceball by injecting solutions with specific thermal properties into the target tissues, to enhance freezing damage to the diseased tissues while preserving the normal tissues from injury. The cryosurgical procedure was performed using a minimally invasive cryoprobe cooled by liquid nitrogen (LN2) to obtain deep regional freezing. Several needle thermocouples were applied simultaneously to record the transient temperature to detect the freezing effect on the tissues. Simulation experiments on biological tissue (fresh pork) were performed in vitro and four different liquids were injected into the test materials; these were distilled water, an aqueous suspension of aluminum nanoparticles in water, ethanol, and a 10% solution of the cryoprotective agent dimethyl sulfoxide (Me2SO). The experimental results demonstrate that the localized injection of an appropriate solution could enhance the tumor-killing effect without altering the freezing conditions. The study also suggests the potential value of combining cryosurgery with other therapeutic methods, such as electrical, chemical, and thermal treatments, to develop new clinical modalities in the near future.     

Drought increases freezing tolerance of both leaves and xylem of Larrea tridentata

Drought and freezing are both known to limit desert plant distributions, but the interaction of these stressors is poorly understood. Drought may increase freezing tolerance in leaves while decreasing it in the xylem, potentially creating a mismatch between water supply and demand. To test this hypothesis, we subjected Larrea tridentata juveniles grown in a greenhouse under well‐watered or drought conditions to minimum temperatures ranging from ?8 to ?24 °C. We measured survival, leaf retention, gas exchange, cell death, freezing point depression and leaf‐specific xylem hydraulic conductance (k_l). Drought‐exposed plants exhibited smaller decreases in gas exchange after exposure to ?8 °C compared to well‐watered plants. Drought also conferred a significant positive effect on leaf, xylem and whole‐plant function following exposure to ?15 °C; drought‐exposed plants exhibited less cell death, greater leaf retention, higher k_l and higher rates of gas exchange than well‐watered plants. Both drought‐exposed and well‐watered plants experienced 100% mortality following exposure to ?24 °C. By documenting the combined effects of drought and freezing stress, our data provide insight into the mechanisms determining plant survival and performance following freezing and the potential for shifts in L. tridentata abundance and range in the face of changing temperature and precipitation regimes.     

Drought increases the freezing resistance of high-elevation plants of the Central Chilean Andes

Freezing temperatures and summer droughts shape plant life in Mediterranean high-elevation habitats. Thus, the impacts of climate change on plant survival for these species could be quite different to those from mesic mountains. We exposed 12 alpine species to experimental irrigation and warming in the Central Chilean Andes to assess whether irrigation decreases freezing resistance, irrigation influences freezing resistance when plants are exposed to warming, and to assess the relative importance of irrigation and temperature in controlling plant freezing resistance. Freezing resistance was determined as the freezing temperature that produced 50 % photoinactivation [lethal temperature (LT₅₀)] and the freezing point (FP). In seven out of 12 high-Andean species, LT₅₀ of drought-exposed plants was on average 3.5 K lower than that of irrigated plants. In contrast, most species did not show differences in FP. Warming changed the effect of irrigation on LT₅₀. Depending on species, warming was found to have (1) no effect, (2) to increase, or (3) to decrease the irrigation effect on LT₅₀. However, the effect size of irrigation on LT₅₀ was greater than that of warming for almost all species. The effect of irrigation on FP was slightly changed by warming and was sometimes in disagreement with LT₅₀ responses. Our data show that drought increases the freezing resistance of high-Andean plant species as a general plant response. Although freezing resistance increases depended on species-specific traits, our results show that warmer and moister growing seasons due to climate change will seriously threaten plant survival and persistence of these and other alpine species in dry mountains.     

Cold hardiness and deep supercooling in xylem of shagbark hickory

Differential thermal analysis, differential scanning calorimetry, pulsed nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and low temperature microscopy are utilized to investigate low temperature freezing points or exotherms which occur near −40 C in the xylem of cold-acclimated shagbark hickory (Carya ovata L.). Experiments using these methods demonstrate that the low temperature exotherm results from the freezing of cellular water in a manner predicted for supercooled dilute aqueous solutions. Heat release on freezing, nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation times, and freezing and thawing curves for hickory twigs all point to a supercooled fraction in the xylem at subfreezing temperatures. Calorimetric and low temperature microscopic analyses indicate that freezing occurs intracellularly in the xylem ray parenchyma. The supercooled fraction is found to be extremely stable, even at temperatures only slightly above the homogeneous nucleation temperature for water (−38 C). Xylem water is also observed to be resistant to dehydration when exposed to 80% relative humidity at 20 C. D₂O exchange experiments find that only a weak kinetic barrier to water transport exists in the xylem rays of shagbark hickory.     

Introgression mapping of genes for winter hardiness and frost tolerance transferred from Festuca arundinacea into Lolium multiflorum

Genes for winter hardiness and frost tolerance were introgressed from Festuca arundinacea into winter-sensitive Lolium multiflorum. Two partly fertile, pentaploid (2n = 5x = 35) F(1) hybrids F. arundinacea (2n = 6x = 42) x L. multiflorum (2n = 4x = 28) were generated and backcrossed twice onto L. multiflorum (2x). The backcross 1 (BC(1)) and backcross 2 (BC(2)) plants were preselected for high vigor and good fertility, and subsequently, a total of 83 BC(2) plants were selected for winter hardiness after 2 Polish winters and by simulated freezing tests. Genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) was performed on 6 winter-hardy plants selected after the first winter and shown to be significantly (P < 0.05) more frost tolerant than the L. multiflorum control. Among the analyzed BC(2) winter survivors, only diploid (2n = 2x = 14) plants were found. Five plants carried 13 intact L. multiflorum chromosomes and 1 L. multiflorum chromosome with a single introgressed F. arundinacea terminal chromosome segment. The sixth BC(2) winter survivor appeared to be Lolium without any Festuca introgression capable of detection by GISH. A combined GISH and fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis with rDNA probes of the most winter-hardy (after 2 winters) and frost-tolerant BC(2) plant revealed the location of an F. arundinacea introgression on the nonsatellite arm of L. multiflorum chromosome 2, the same chromosome location reported previously as a site for frost tolerance genes in the diploid and winter-hardy species Festuca pratensis.     

The Use of Microwaves to Monitor the Freezing and Thawing of Water in Plants

Harbinson, J. and Woodward, F. I. 1987. The use of microwavesto monitor the freezing and thawing of water in plants.—J.exp. Bot. 38: 1325–1335. The use of radiation with a frequency of 10·687 GHz tomeasure the freezing and thawing of water in plants is discussed.Results showing the freezing and thawing of plant material arepresented. In its simplest form the technique offers a methodfor investigating the freezing and thawing of water in plants. Key words: Freezing, microwaves     

Interactions among Flooding, Freezing, and Ice Encasement in Winter Wheat

Exposure of winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) to various combinations of flooding and freezing stresses induces much greater damage than the individual stresses. Cold-hardened plants flooded for 1 week or exposed to −6°C for 1 week show 100% survival, while survival of plants exposed to both stresses simultaneously is reduced by 20 to 30%, and cold hardiness decreases by several degrees. The level of nonstructural carbohydrates increases in crown tissue during cold acclimation, but decreases when the plants are exposed to flooding or to −6°C for 1 week. The respiratory capacity of crown tissue segments declines when the plants are stressed. Uptake of ⁸⁶Rb by the roots of intact seedlings declines after exposure to either freezing or flooding, whereas passive efflux of amino acids is observed after freezing but not following flooding. This study has shown that detectable stress-induced metabolic changes occur in winter wheat before the applied stress is severe enough to reduce survival.