Beta-sheet folding mechanisms from perturbation energetics

Amide backbone and sidechain mutagenesis data can be used in combination with kinetic and thermodynamic measurements to understand the energetic contributions of backbone hydrogen bonding and the hydrophobic effect to the acquisition of beta-sheet structure. For example, it has been revealed that loop 1 of the WW domain forms in the transition state, consistent with the emerging theme that reverse turn formation is rate limiting in beta-sheet folding. A distinct subset of WW domain residues principally influences thermodynamic stability by forming hydrogen bonds and hydrophobic interactions that stabilize the native state. Energetic data and sequence mining reveal that only a small subset of the molecular information contained in sequences or observed in high-resolution structures is required to generate folded functional beta-sheets, consistent with evolutionary robustness.     

Direct analysis of backbone-backbone hydrogen bond formation in protein folding transition states

Here we investigate the role of backbone-backbone hydrogen bonding interactions in stabilizing the protein folding transition states of two model protein systems, the B1 domain of protein L (ProtL) and the P22 Arc repressor. A backbone modified analogue of ProtL containing an amide-to-ester bond substitution between residues 105 and 106 was prepared by total chemical synthesis, and the thermodynamic and kinetic parameters associated with its folding reaction were evaluated. Ultimately, these parameters were used in a Phi-value analysis to determine if the native backbone-backbone hydrogen bonding interaction perturbed in this analogue (i.e. a hydrogen bond in the first beta-turn of ProtL's beta-beta-alpha-beta-beta fold) was formed in the transition state of ProtL's folding reaction. Also determined were the kinetic parameters associated with the folding reactions of two Arc repressor analogues, each containing an amide-to-ester bond substitution in the backbone of their polypeptide chains. These parameters were used together with previously established thermodynamic parameters for the folding of these analogues in Phi-value analyses to determine if the native backbone-backbone hydrogen bonding interactions perturbed in these analogues (i.e. a hydrogen bond at the end of the intersubunit beta-sheet interface and hydrogen bonds at the beginning of the second alpha-helix in Arc repressor's beta-alpha-alpha structure) were formed in the transition state of Arc repressor's folding reaction. Our results reveal that backbone-backbone hydrogen bonding interactions are formed in the beta-turn and alpha-helical transition state structures of ProtL and Arc repressor, respectively; and they were not formed in the intersubunit beta-sheet interface of Arc repressor, a region of Arc repressor's polypeptide chain previously shown to have other non-native-like conformations in Arc's protein folding transition state.     

NMR solution structure of the isolated Apo Pin1 WW domain: comparison to the x-ray crystal structures of Pin1.

The NMR solution structure of the isolated Apo Pin1 WW domain (6-39) reveals that it adopts a twisted three-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet conformation, very similar to the structure exhibited by the crystal of this domain in the context of the two domain Pin1 protein. While the B factors in the apo x-ray crystal structure indicate that loop 1 and loop 2 are conformationally well defined, the solution NMR data suggest that loop 1 is quite flexible, at least in the absence of the ligand. The NMR chemical shift and nuclear Overhauser effect pattern exhibited by the 6-39 Pin1 WW domain has proven to be diagnostic for demonstrating that single site variants of this domain adopt a normally folded structure. Knowledge of this type is critical before embarking on time-consuming kinetic and thermodynamic studies required for a detailed understanding of beta-sheet folding.     

A cross-strand Trp Trp pair stabilizes the hPin1 WW domain at the expense of function

Using the human Pin1 WW domain (hPin1 WW), we show that replacement of two nearest neighbor non-hydrogen-bonded residues on adjacent beta-strands with tryptophan (Trp) residues increases beta-sheet thermodynamic stability by 4.8 kJ mol(-1) at physiological temperature. One-dimensional NMR studies confirmed that introduction of the Trp-Trp pair does not globally perturb the structure of the triple-stranded beta-sheet, while circular dichroism studies suggest that the engineered cross-strand Trp-Trp pair adopts a side-chain conformation similar to that first reported for a designed "Trp-zipper" beta-hairpin peptide, wherein the indole side chains stack perpendicular to each other. Even though the mutated side chains in wild-type hPin1 WW are not conserved among WW domains and compose the beta-sheet surface opposite to that responsible for ligand binding, introduction of the cross-strand Trp-Trp pair effectively eliminates hPin1 WW function as assessed by the loss of binding affinity toward a natural peptide ligand. Maximizing both thermodynamic stability and the domain function of hPin1 WW by the above mentioned approach appears to be difficult, analogous to the situation with loop 1 optimization explored previously. That introduction of a non-hydrogen-bonded cross-strand Trp-Trp pair within the hPin1 WW domain eliminates function may provide a rationale for why this energetically favorable pairwise interaction has not yet been identified in WW domains or any other biologically evolved protein with known three-dimensional structure.     

Influence of hPin1 WW N-terminal domain boundaries on function, protein stability, and folding

An N-terminally truncated and cooperatively folded version (residues 6-39) of the human Pin1 WW domain (hPin1 WW hereafter) has served as an excellent model system for understanding triple-stranded beta-sheet folding energetics. Here we report that the negatively charged N-terminal sequence (Met1-Ala-Asp-Glu-Glu5) previously deleted, and which is not conserved in highly homologous WW domain family members from yeast or certain fungi, significantly increases the stability of hPin1 WW (approximately 4 kJ mol(-1) at 65 degrees C), in the context of the 1-39 sequence based on equilibrium measurements. N-terminal truncations and mutations in conjunction with a double mutant cycle analysis and a recently published high-resolution X-ray structure of the hPin1 cis/trans-isomerase suggest that the increase in stability is due to an energetically favorable ionic interaction between the negatively charged side chains in the N terminus of full-length hPin1 WW and the positively charged epsilon-ammonium group of residue Lys13 in beta-strand 1. Our data therefore suggest that the ionic interaction between Lys13 and the charged N terminus is the optimal solution for enhanced stability without compromising function, as ascertained by ligand binding studies. Kinetic laser temperature-jump relaxation studies reveal that this stabilizing interaction has not formed to a significant extent in the folding transition state at near physiological temperature, suggesting a differential contribution of the negatively charged N-terminal sequence to protein stability and folding rate. As neither the N-terminal sequence nor Lys13 are highly conserved among WW domains, our data further suggest that caution must be exercised when selecting domain boundaries for WW domains for structural, functional, or thermodynamic studies.     

The folding mechanism of a beta-sheet: the WW domain

The folding thermodynamics and kinetics of the Pin WW domain, a three-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet, have been characterized extensively. Folding and activation free energies were determined as a function of temperature for 16 mutants, which sample all strands and turns of the molecule. The mutational phi value (Phi(m)) diagram is a smooth function of sequence, indicating a prevalence of local interactions in the transition state (TS). At 37 degrees C, the diagram has a single pronounced maximum at turn 1: the rate-limiting step during folding is the formation of loop 1. In contrast, key residues for thermodynamic stability are located in the strand hydrophobic clusters, indicating that factors contributing to protein stability and folding kinetics are not correlated. The location of the TS along the entropic reaction coordinate Phi(T), obtained by temperature-tuning the kinetics, reveals that sufficiently destabilizing mutants in loop 2 or in the Leu7-Trp11-Tyr24-Pro37 hydrophobic cluster can cause a switch to a late TS. Phi(m) analysis is usually applied "perturbatively" (methyl truncation), but with Phi(T) to quantitatively assess TS shifts along a reaction coordinate, more severe mutations can be used to probe regions of the free energy surface beyond the TS.     

Structural characterisation of PinA WW domain and a comparison with other group IV WW domains, Pin1 and Ess1

The NMR solution structure of the PinA WW domain from Aspergillus nidulans is presented. The backbone of the PinA WW domain is composed of a triple-stranded anti-parallel beta-sheet and an alpha-helix similar to Ess1 and Pin1 without the alpha-helix linker. Large RMS deviations in Loop I were observed both from the NMR structures and molecular dynamics simulation suggest that the Loop I of PinA WW domain is flexible and solvent accessible, thus enabling it to bind the pS/pT-P motif. The WW domain in this structure are stabilised by a hydrophobic core. It is shown that the linker flexibility of PinA is restricted because of an alpha-helical structure in the linker region. The combination of NMR structural data and detailed Molecular Dynamics simulations enables a comprehensive structural and dynamic understanding of this protein.     

Factors involved in the stability of isolated beta-sheets: Turn sequence, beta-sheet twisting, and hydrophobic surface burial

We have recently reported on the design of a 20-residue peptide able to form a significant population of a three-stranded up-and-down antiparallel beta-sheet in aqueous solution. To improve our beta-sheet model in terms of the folded population, we have modified the sequences of the two 2-residue turns by introducing the segment DPro-Gly, a sequence shown to lead to more rigid type II' beta-turns. The analysis of several NMR parameters, NOE data, as well as Deltadelta(CalphaH), DeltadeltaC(beta), and Deltadelta(Cbeta) values, demonstrates that the new peptide forms a beta-sheet structure in aqueous solution more stable than the original one, whereas the substitution of the DPro residues by LPro leads to a random coil peptide. This agrees with previous results on beta-hairpin-forming peptides showing the essential role of the turn sequence for beta-hairpin folding. The well-defined beta-sheet motif calculated for the new designed peptide (pair-wise RMSD for backbone atoms is 0.5 +/- 0.1 A) displays a high degree of twist. This twist likely contributes to stability, as a more hydrophobic surface is buried in the twisted beta-sheet than in a flatter one. The twist observed in the up-and-down antiparallel beta-sheet motifs of most proteins is less pronounced than in our designed peptide, except for the WW domains. The additional hydrophobic surface burial provided by beta-sheet twisting relative to a "flat" beta-sheet is probably more important for structure stability in peptides and small proteins like the WW domains than in larger proteins for which there exists a significant contribution to stability arising from their extensive hydrophobic cores.     

Calorimetric dissection of thermal unfolding of OspA,a predominantly beta-sheet protein containing a single-layer beta-sheet

Outer surface protein A (OspA) from Borrelia burgdorferi is a predominantly beta-sheet protein comprised of beta-strands beta1-beta21 and a short C-terminal alpha-helix. It contains two globular domains (N and C-terminal domains) and a unique single-layer beta-sheet (central beta-sheet) that connects the two domains. OspA contains an unusually large number of charged amino acid residues. To understand the mechanism of stabilization of this unique beta-sheet protein, thorough thermodynamic investigations of OspA and its truncated mutant lacking a part of the C-terminal domain were conducted using calorimetry and circular dichroism. The stability of OspA was found to be sensitive to pH and salt concentration. The heat capacity curve clearly consisted of two components, and all the thermodynamic parameters were obtained for each step. The thermodynamic parameters associated with the two transitions are consistent with a previously proposed model, in which the first transition corresponds to the unfolding of the C-terminal domain and the last two beta-strands of the central beta-sheet, and the second transition corresponds to that of the N-terminal domain and the first beta-strand of the central beta-sheet in the second peak. The ratio of calorimetric and van't Hoff enthalpies indicates that the first peak includes another thermodynamic intermediate state. Large heat capacity changes were observed for both transitions, indicative of large changes in the exposure of hydrophobic surfaces associated with the transitions. This observation demonstrates that hydrophobic parts are buried efficiently in the native structure in spite of the low content of hydrophobic residues in OspA. By decomposing the enthalpy, entropy, and Gibbs free energy into contributions from different interactions, we found that the enthalpy changes for hydrogen bonding and polar interactions are exceptionally large, indicating that OspA maintains its stability by making full use of its unique beta-sheet and high content of polar residues. These thermodynamic analyses demonstrated that it is possible to maintain protein tertiary structure by making effective use of an unusual amino acid composition.     

Structural analysis of WW domains and design of a WW prototype

Two new NMR structures of WW domains, the mouse formin binding protein and a putative 84.5 kDa protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, show that this domain, only 35 amino acids in length, defines the smallest monomeric triple-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet protein domain that is stable in the absence of disulfide bonds, tightly bound ions or ligands. The structural roles of conserved residues have been studied using site-directed mutagenesis of both wild type domains. Crucial interactions responsible for the stability of the WW structure have been identified. Based on a network of highly conserved long range interactions across the beta-sheet structure that supports the WW fold and on a systematic analysis of conserved residues in the WW family, we have designed a folded prototype WW sequence.     

Increasing protein stability using a rational approach combining sequence homology and structural alignment: Stabilizing the WW domain

This study shows that a combination of sequence homology and structural information can be used to increase the stability of the WW domain by 2.5 kcal mol(-1) and increase the T(m) by 28 degrees C. Previous homology-based protein design efforts typically investigate positions with low sequence identity, whereas this study focuses on semi-conserved core residues and proximal residues, exploring their role(s) in mediating stabilizing interactions on the basis of structural considerations. The A20R and L30Y mutations allow increased hydrophobic interactions because of complimentary surfaces and an electrostatic interaction with a third residue adjacent to the ligand-binding hydrophobic cluster, increasing stability significantly beyond what additivity would predict for the single mutations. The D34T mutation situated in a pi-turn possibly disengages Asn31, allowing it to make up to three hydrogen bonds with the backbone in strand 1 and loop 2. The synergistic mutations A20R/L30Y in combination with the remotely located mutation D34T add together to create a hYap WW domain that is significantly more stable than any of the protein structures on which the design was based (Pin and FBP28 WW domains).     

Molecular dynamics simulations of a beta-hairpin fragment of protein G: balance between side-chain and backbone forces

How is the native structure encoded in the amino acid sequence? For the traditional backbone centric view, the dominant forces are hydrogen bonds (backbone) and phi-psi propensity. The role of hydrophobicity is non-specific. For the side-chain centric view, the dominant force of protein folding is hydrophobicity. In order to understand the balance between backbone and side-chain forces, we have studied the contributions of three components of a beta-hairpin peptide: turn, backbone hydrogen bonding and side-chain interactions, of a 16-residue fragment of protein G. The peptide folds rapidly and cooperatively to a conformation with a defined secondary structure and a packed hydrophobic cluster of aromatic side-chains. Our strategy is to observe the structural stability of the beta-hairpin under systematic perturbations of the turn region, backbone hydrogen bonds and the hydrophobic core formed by the side-chains, respectively. In our molecular dynamics simulations, the peptides are solvated. with explicit water molecules, and an all-atom force field (CFF91) is used. Starting from the original peptide (G41EWTYDDATKTFTVTE56), we carried out the following MD simulations. (1) unfolding at 350 K; (2) forcing the distance between the C(alpha) atoms of ASP47 and LYS50 to be 8 A; (3) deleting two turn residues (Ala48 and Thr49) to form a beta-sheet complex of two short peptides, GEWTYDD and KTFTVTE; (4) four hydrophobic residues (W43, Y45, F52 and T53) are replaced by a glycine residue step-by-step; and (5) most importantly, four amide hydrogen atoms (T44, D46, T53, and T55, which are crucial for backbone hydrogen bonding), are substituted by fluorine atoms. The fluorination not only makes it impossible to form attractive hydrogen bonding between the two beta-hairpin strands, but also introduces a repulsive force between the two strands due to the negative charges on the fluorine and oxygen atoms. Throughout all simulations, we observe that backbone hydrogen bonds are very sensitive to the perturbations and are easily broken. In contrast, the hydrophobic core survives most perturbations. In the decisive test of fluorination, the fluorinated peptide remains folded under our simulation conditions (5 ns, 278 K). Hydrophobic interactions keep the peptide folded, even with a repulsive force between the beta-strands. Thus, our results strongly support a side-chain centric view for protein folding.     

Effects of Turn Stability and Side-Chain Hydrophobicity on the Folding of β-Structures

Key elements of β-structure folding include hydrophobic core collapse, turn formation, and assembly of backbone hydrogen bonds. In the present folding simulations of several β-hairpins and β-sheets (peptide 1, protein G B1 domain peptide, TRPZIP2, TRPZIP4, 20mer, and 20mer^DP6D), the folding free-energy landscape as a function of several reaction coordinates corresponding to the three key elements indicates apparent dependence on turn stability and side-chain hydrophobicity, which demonstrates different folding mechanisms of similar β-structures of varied sequences. Turn stability is found to be the key factor in determining the formation order of the three structural elements in the folding of β-structures. Moreover, turn stability and side-chain hydrophobicity both affect the stability of backbone hydrogen bonds. The three-stranded β-sheets fold through a three-state transition in which the formation of one hairpin always takes precedence over the other. The different stabilities of two anti-parallel hairpins in each three-stranded β-sheet are shown to correlate well with the different levels of their hydrophobic interactions.     

Structural basis for phosphoserine-proline recognition by group IV WW domains

Pin1 contains an N-terminal WW domain and a C-terminal peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase (PPIase) domain connected by a flexible linker. To address the energetic and structural basis for WW domain recognition of phosphoserine (P.Ser)/phosphothreonine (P. Thr)- proline containing proteins, we report the energetic and structural analysis of a Pin1-phosphopeptide complex. The X-ray crystal structure of Pin1 bound to a doubly phosphorylated peptide (Tyr-P.Ser-Pro-Thr-P.Ser-Pro-Ser) representing a heptad repeat of the RNA polymerase II large subunit's C-terminal domain (CTD), reveals the residues involved in the recognition of a single P.Ser side chain, the rings of two prolines, and the backbone of the CTD peptide. The side chains of neighboring Arg and Ser residues along with a backbone amide contribute to recognition of P.Ser. The lack of widespread conservation of the Arg and Ser residues responsible for P.Ser recognition in the WW domain family suggests that only a subset of WW domains can bind P.Ser-Pro in a similar fashion to that of Pin1.     

The nucleation of monomeric parallel beta-sheet-like structures and their self-assembly in aqueous solution

The aromatic diacid residue 4,6-dibenzofuranbispropionic acid (1) was designed to nucleate a parallel beta-sheet-like structure in small peptides in aqueous solution via a hydrogen-bonded hydrophobic cluster. Even though a 14-membered ring hydrogen bond necessary for parallel beta-sheet formation is favored in simple amides composed of 1, this hydrogen bonding interaction does not appear to be sufficient to nucleate parallel beta-sheet formation in the absence of hydrophobic clustering between the dibenzofuran portion of 1 and the hydrophobic side chains of the flanking alpha-amino acids. The subsequence --hydrophobic residue-1-hydrophobic residue-- is required for folding in the context of a nucleated two-stranded parallel beta-sheet structure. In all cases where the peptidomimetics can fold into two diastereomeric parallel beta-sheet structures having different hydrogen bonding networks, these conformations appear to exchange rapidly. The majority of the parallel beta-sheet structures evaluated herein undergo linked intramolecular folding and self-assembly, affording a fibrillar beta-sheet quaternary structure. To unlink folding and assembly, asymmetric parallel beta-sheet structures incorporating N-methylated alpha-amino acid residues have been synthesized using a new solid phase approach. Residue 1 facilitates the folding of several peptides described within affording a monomeric parallel beta-sheet-like structure in aqueous solution, as ascertained by a variety of spectroscopic and biophysical methods, increasing our understanding of parallel beta-sheet structure.     

Beta-hairpin folding simulations in atomistic detail using an implicit solvent model

We have used distributed computing techniques and a supercluster of thousands of computer processors to study folding of the C-terminal beta-hairpin from protein G in atomistic detail using the GB/SA implicit solvent model at 300 K. We have simulated a total of nearly 38 micros of folding time and obtained eight complete and independent folding trajectories. Starting from an extended state, we observe relaxation to an unfolded state characterized by non-specific, temporary hydrogen bonding. This is followed by the appearance of interactions between hydrophobic residues that stabilize a bent intermediate. Final formation of the complete hydrophobic core occurs cooperatively at the same time that the final hydrogen bonding pattern appears. The folded hairpin structures we observe all contain a closely packed hydrophobic core and proper beta-sheet backbone dihedral angles, but they differ in backbone hydrogen bonding pattern. We show that this is consistent with the existing experimental data on the hairpin alone in solution. Our analysis also reveals short-lived semi-helical intermediates which define a thermodynamic trap. Our results are consistent with a three-state mechanism with a single rate-limiting step in which a varying final hydrogen bond pattern is apparent, and semi-helical off-pathway intermediates may appear early in the folding process. We include details of the ensemble dynamics methodology and a discussion of our achievements using this new computational device for studying dynamics at the atomic level.     

Solution structure of an atypical WW domain in a novel beta-clam-like dimeric form

The WW domain is known as one of the smallest protein modules with a triple-stranded beta-sheet fold. Here, we present the solution structure of the second WW domain from the mouse salvador homolog 1 protein. This WW domain forms a homodimer with a beta-clam-like motif, as evidenced by size exclusion chromatography, analytical ultracentrifugation and NMR spectroscopy. While typical WW domains are believed to function as monomeric modules that recognize proline-rich sequences, by using conserved aromatic and hydrophobic residues that are solvent-exposed on the surface of the beta-sheet, this WW domain buries these residues in the dimer interface.     

Two-rung model of a left-handed beta-helix for prions explains species barrier and strain variation in transmissible spongiform encephalopathies

In this study, a new beta-helical model is proposed that explains the species barrier and strain variation in transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. The left-handed beta-helix serves as a structural model that can explain the seeded growth characteristics of beta-sheet structure in PrP(Sc) fibrils. Molecular dynamics simulations demonstrate that the left-handed beta-helix is structurally more stable than the right-handed beta-helix, with a higher beta-sheet content during the simulation and a better distributed network of inter-strand backbone-backbone hydrogen bonds between parallel beta-strands of different rungs. Multiple sequence alignments and homology modelling of prion sequences with different rungs of left-handed beta-helices illustrate that the PrP region with the highest beta-helical propensity (residues 105-143) can fold in just two rungs of a left-handed beta-helix. Even if no other flanking sequence participates in the beta-helix, the two rungs of a beta-helix can give the growing fibril enough elevation to accommodate the rest of the PrP protein in a tight packing at the periphery of a trimeric beta-helix. The folding of beta-helices is driven by backbone-backbone hydrogen bonding and stacking of side-chains in adjacent rungs. The sequence and structure of the last rung at the fibril end with unprotected beta-sheet edges selects the sequence of a complementary rung and dictates the folding of the new rung with optimal backbone hydrogen bonding and side-chain stacking. An important side-chain stack that facilitates the beta-helical folding is between methionine residues 109 and 129, which explains their importance in the species barrier of prions. Because the PrP sequence is not evolutionarily optimised to fold in a beta-helix, and because the beta-helical fold shows very little sequence preference, alternative alignments are possible that result in a different rung able to select for an alternative complementary rung. A different top rung results in a new strain with different growth characteristics. Hence, in the present model, sequence variation and alternative alignments clarify the basis of the species barrier and strain specificity in PrP-based diseases.     

Understanding the folding and stability of a designed WW domain protein with replica exchange molecular dynamics simulations

WW domain proteins are usually regarded as simple models for understanding the folding mechanism of β-sheet. CC45 is an artificial protein that is capable of folding into the same structure as WW domain. In this article, the replica exchange molecular dynamics simulations are performed to investigate the folding mechanism of CC45. The analysis of thermal stability shows that β-hairpin 1 is more stable than β-hairpin 2 during the unfolding process. Free energy analysis shows that the unfolding of this protein substantially proceeds through solvating the smaller β-hairpin 2, followed by the unfolding of β-hairpin 1. We further propose the unfolding process of CC45 and the folding mechanism of two β-hairpins. These results are similar to the previous folding studies of formin binding protein 28 (FBP28). Compared with FBP28, it is found that CC45 has more aromatic residues in N-terminal loop, and these residues contact with C-terminal loop to form the outer hydrophobic core, which increases the stability of CC45. Knowledge about the stability and folding behaviour of CC45 may help in understanding the folding mechanisms of the β-sheet and in designing new WW domains.