Effect of Mg2+ concentration, polyamines, streptomycin, and mutations in ribosomal proteins on the accuracy of the two-step selection of aminoacyl-tRNAs in protein biosynthesis

Discrimination against the binding of noncognate aminoacyl (aa)-tRNAs by mRNA-programmed ribosomes is the outcome of two selection steps, one involving an aa-tRNA.EFTu.GTP complex, which occurs prior to and includes GTP hydrolysis, the other involving the aa-tRNA alone, which follows GTP hydrolysis. Conditions which lead to errors in protein synthesis have been found to influence the accuracy of one or both selection steps in a system measuring poly(U)-directed binding of Leu-tRNA2Leu. Streptomycin has a large effect only on the discrimination process following GTP hydrolysis, but the other pertubations of recognition studied, high [Mg2+], polyamines, the strA1 and ram1 mutations, affect both discrimination processes. The general result is consistent with the view that proofreading of aa-tRNA by ribosomes for the most part uses the same specificity determinants used in the initial selection of a ternary complex.     

The reaction of ribosomes with elongation factor Tu.GTP complexes. Aminoacyl-tRNA-independent reactions in the elongation cycle determine the accuracy of protein synthesis

The fidelity of protein synthesis depends on the rate constants for the reaction of ribosomes with ternary complexes of elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), GTP, and aminoacyl (aa)-tRNA. By measuring the rate constants for the reaction of poly(U)-programmed ribosomes with a binary complex of elongation factor (EF-Tu) and GTP we have shown that two of the key rate constants in the former reaction are determined exclusively by ribosome-EF-Tu interactions and are not affected by the aa-tRNA. These are the rate constant for GTP hydrolysis, which plays an important role in the fidelity of ternary complex selection by the ribosome, and the rate constant for EF-Tu.GDP dissociation from the ribosome, which plays an equally important role in subsequent proofreading of the aa-tRNA. We conclude that the fidelities of ternary complex selection and proofreading are fundamentally dependent on ribosome-EF-Tu interactions. These interactions determine the absolute value of the rate constants for GTP hydrolysis and EF-Tu.GDP dissociation. The ribosome then uses these rate constants as internal standards to measure, respectively, the rate constants for ternary complex and aa-tRNA dissociation from the ribosome. These rates, in turn, are highly dependent on whether the ternary complex and aa-tRNA are cognate or near-cognate to the codon being translated.     

Induced fit in initial selection and proofreading of aminoacyl-tRNA on the ribosome.

The fidelity of aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) selection by the bacterial ribosome is determined by initial selection before and proofreading after GTP hydrolysis by elongation factor Tu. Here we report the rate constants of A-site binding of a near-cognate aa-tRNA. The comparison with the data for cognate aa-tRNA reveals an additional, important contribution to aa-tRNA discrimination of conformational coupling by induced fit. It is found that two rearrangement steps that limit the chemical reactions of A-site binding, i.e. GTPase activation (preceding GTP hydrolysis) and A-site accommodation (preceding peptide bond formation), are substantially faster for cognate than for near-cognate aa-tRNA. This suggests an induced-fit mechanism of aa-tRNA discrimination on the ribosome that operates in both initial selection and proofreading. It is proposed that the cognate codon-anticodon interaction, more efficiently than the near-cognate one, induces a particular conformation of the decoding center of 16S rRNA, which in turn promotes GTPase activation and A-site accommodation of aa-tRNA, thereby accelerating the chemical steps. As kinetically favored incorporation of the correct substrate has also been suggested for DNA and RNA polymerases, the present findings indicate that induced fit may contribute to the fidelity of template-programed systems in general.     

Effect of ppGpp on the accuracy of protein biosynthesis

The maintenance of accuracy in protein biosynthesis in amino acid-starved rel+ strains of Escherichia coli has been attributed to an effect of ppGpp on the accuracy of aa-tRNA selection by the ribosome. It has been determined that concentrations of ppGpp characteristic of those found in amino acid-starved cells have no effect on the rate of reaction of poly(U)-programmed ribosomes with either the cognate (Phe) or the near-cognate (Leu2) ternary complexes. Neither the rate of GTP hydrolysis, which signals selection of the ternary complex, nor the rate of peptide formation, which signals the acceptance of the aa-tRNA after proofreading, is affected by the nucleotide. The results indicate that the effect of ppGpp in maintaining the accuracy of protein biosynthesis in cells starved for an amino acid is not due to a direct effect on the rate constants for substrate selection by the ribosome.     

Recognition of aminoacyl-tRNA: a common molecular mechanism revealed by cryo-EM

The accuracy of ribosomal translation is achieved by an initial selection and a proofreading step, mediated by EF-Tu, which forms a ternary complex with aminoacyl(aa)-tRNA. To study the binding modes of different aa-tRNAs, we compared cryo-EM maps of the kirromycin-stalled ribosome bound with ternary complexes containing Phe-tRNA^Phe, Trp-tRNA^Trp, or Leu-tRNA^LeuI. The three maps suggest a common binding manner of cognate aa-tRNAs in their specific binding with both the ribosome and EF-Tu. All three aa-tRNAs have the same ‘loaded spring' conformation with a kink and twist between the D-stem and anticodon stem. The three complexes are similarly integrated in an interaction network, extending from the anticodon loop through h44 and protein S12 to the EF-Tu-binding CCA end of aa-tRNA, proposed to signal cognate codon–anticodon interaction to the GTPase centre and tune the accuracy of aa-tRNA selection.     

Functional interaction of yeast elongation factor 3 with yeast ribosomes

Elongation factor 3 (EF-3) is a unique and essential requirement of the fungal translational apparatus. EF-3 is a monomeric protein with a molecular mass of 116,000. EF-3 is required by yeast ribosomes for in vitro translation and for in vivo growth. The protein stimulates the binding of EF-1 alpha :GTP:aa-tRNA ternary complex to the ribosomal A-site by facilitating release of deacylated-tRNA from the E-site. The reaction requires ATP hydrolysis. EF-3 contains two ATP-binding sequence motifs (NBS). NBSI is sufficient for the intrinsic ATPase function. NBSII is essential for ribosome-stimulated activity. By limited proteolysis, EF-3 was divided into two distinct functional domains. The N-terminal domain lacking the highly charged lysine blocks failed to bind ribosomes and was inactive in the ribosome-stimulated ATPase activity. The C-terminally derived lysine-rich fragment showed strong binding to yeast ribosomes. The purported S5 homology region of EF-3 at the N-terminal end has been reported to interact with 18S ribosomal RNA. We postulate that EF-3 contacts rRNA and/or protein(s) through the C-terminal end. Removal of these residues severely weakens its interaction mediated possibly through the N-terminal domain of the protein.     

Functional interactions between mutated forms of ribosomal proteins S4, S5 and S12

Here we show that ram mutations, either in ribosomal protein S4 or S5, decrease the proofreading flows for both cognate and noncognate ternary complexes bound by streptomycin-dependent (SmD) ribosomes. This effect is accompanied by a slight increase in the overall error frequency. More important, however, is the decreased proofreading of the cognate species which is almost reduced to wild-type levels. The data suggest that it may be the reduction of the proofreading of the cognate substrate that is important for suppressing streptomycin dependence. Furthermore, we show that rpsE mutants, selected from streptomycin-dependent strains, behave kinetically very similarly to the previously described rpsD mutants.     

Characterization of the elongation factors from calf brain. 3. Properties of the GTPase activity of EF-1 alpha and mode of action of kirromycin

The GTPase activity of purified EF-1 alpha from calf brain has been studied under various experimental conditions and compared with that of EF-Tu. EF-1 alpha displays a much higher GTPase turnover than EF-Tu in the absence of aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) and ribosomes (intrinsic GTPase activity); this is due to the higher exchange rate between bound GDP and free GTP. Also the intrinsic GTPase of EF-1 alpha is enhanced by increasing the concentration of monovalent cations, K+ being more effective than NH+4. Differently from EF-Tu, aa-tRNA is much more active than ribosomes in stimulating the EF-1 alpha GTPase activity. However, ribosomes strongly reinforce the aa-tRNA effect. In the absence of aa-tRNA the rate-limiting step of the GTPase turnover appears to be the hydrolysis of GTP, whereas in its presence the GDP/GTP exchange reaction becomes rate-limiting, since addition of EF-1 beta enhances turnover GTPase activity. Kirromycin moderately inhibits the intrinsic GTPase of EF-1 alpha; this effect turns into stimulation when aa-tRNA is present. Addition of ribosomes abolishes any kirromycin effect. The inability of kirromycin to affect the EF-1 alpha/guanine-nucleotide interaction in the presence of ribosomes shows that, differently from EF-Tu, the EF-1 alpha X GDP/GTP exchange reaction takes place on the ribosome.     

Thiostrepton inhibition of tRNA delivery to the ribosome

Ribosome-stimulated hydrolysis of guanosine-5'-triphosphate (GTP) by guanosine triphosphatase (GTPase) translation factors drives protein synthesis by the ribosome. Allosteric coupling of GTP hydrolysis by elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) at the ribosomal GTPase center to messenger RNA (mRNA) codon:aminoacyl-transfer RNA (aa-tRNA) anticodon recognition at the ribosomal decoding site is essential for accurate and rapid aa-tRNA selection. Here we use single-molecule methods to investigate the mechanism of action of the antibiotic thiostrepton and show that the GTPase center of the ribosome has at least two discrete functions during aa-tRNA selection: binding of EF-Tu(GTP) and stimulation of GTP hydrolysis by the factor. We separate these two functions of the GTPase center and assign each to distinct, conserved structural regions of the ribosome. The data provide a specific model for the coupling between the decoding site and the GTPase center during aa-tRNA selection as well as a general mechanistic model for ribosome-stimulated GTP hydrolysis by GTPase translation factors.     

Guanosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) as an analog of GTP in protein biosynthesis. The effects of temperature and polycations on the accuracy of initial recognition of aminoacyl-tRNA ternary complexes by ribosomes

Guanosine 5'-O-(3-thio)triphosphate (GTP gamma S) is a good analog of GTP in the reactions leading to the formation of a peptide bond in protein biosynthesis. It forms binary and ternary complexes with elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), and with EF-Tu and aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA). In addition, it stimulates aa-tRNA binding to ribosomes. Although GTP gamma S hydrolysis is more than three orders of magnitude slower than GTP hydrolysis, both reactions are dependent on the formation of a noncovalent complex (RS X TC) between mRNA-programmed ribosomes and ternary complex, and the complexes resulting from that hydrolysis are intermediates in peptide formation. The rate of dissociation of the ribosome X EF-Tu X GTP gamma S X aa-tRNA complex was determined from the rate of labeled peptide formation in the presence of an unlabeled ternary complex chase. This rate (2.2 X 10(-3) s-1) is similar to that determined previously (Thompson, R.C., and Karim, A.M. (1982) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 79, 4922-4926) from the progress of GTP gamma S hydrolysis. The effects of temperature and polycation concentration on this rate constant and that for GTP gamma S hydrolysis are reported. The rate constants measured are consistent with a kinetic rather than thermodynamic limit on the accuracy of the aa-tRNA selection in vivo.     

Ribosome interactions of aminoacyl-tRNA and elongation factor Tu in the codon-recognition complex

The mRNA codon in the ribosomal A-site is recognized by aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) in a ternary complex with elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) and GTP. Here we report the 13 A resolution three-dimensional reconstruction determined by cryo-electron microscopy of the kirromycin-stalled codon-recognition complex. The structure of the ternary complex is distorted by binding of the tRNA anticodon arm in the decoding center. The aa-tRNA interacts with 16S rRNA, helix 69 of 23S rRNA and proteins S12 and L11, while the sarcin-ricin loop of 23S rRNA contacts domain 1 of EF-Tu near the nucleotide-binding pocket. These results provide a detailed snapshot view of an important functional state of the ribosome and suggest mechanisms of decoding and GTPase activation.     

Affinity labeling at the A-site of Escherichia coli ribosomes by a non-hydrolyzable gamma-amide analog of GTP

gamma-Amides of GTP and affinity and photoaffinity derivatives of gamma-amides of GTP: gamma-anilide of GTP, gamma-(4-azido)anilide of GTP, gamma-[N-(4-azidobenzyl)-N-methyl]amide of GTP, gamma[4-N-(2-chloroethyl)-N-methylaminobenzyl]amide of GTP and gamma-[4-N-(2-oxoethyl)-N-methylaminobenzyl]amide of GTP substituted efficiently for GTP in the EF-Tu-dependent transfer of aminoacyl-tRNA to the ribosome but, in contrast to GTP, they were not hydrolyzed in this process. They represent a new class of non-hydrolyzable GTP analogs with preserved gamma-phosphodiester bond. The radioactive analog of GTP: gamma-[4-N-(2-chloroethyl)-N-methylamino[14C]benzyl]amide of GTP was used as an affinity labeling probe for the identification of components of the GTPase center formed in the EF-Tu-dependent transfer reaction of aminoacyl-tRNA to the ribosomal A-site. Within a six-component complex of poly(U)-programmed E. coli ribosomes with elongation factor Tu, Phe-tRNA(Phe) (at the A-site), tRNA(Phe) (at the P-site) and the [14C]GTP analog, mainly the ribosomal 23S RNA and to a lesser extent the ribosomal proteins L17, L21, S16, S21 and the ribosomal 16S RNA were labeled by the reagent. No significant modification of EF-Tu was detected.     

Kinetic properties of Escherichia coli ribosomes with altered forms of S12.

E. coli ribosomes with alterations in S12 leading to streptomycin resistance (SmR), dependence (SmD) and pseudodependence (SmP) were studied with the quench-flow technique. Kinetic changes at the various steps of the elongation cycle were identified. The rate of hydrolysis of GTP in the ternary complex in the ribosomal A-site is decreased drastically in SmD and moderately in SmP in relation to wild-type ribosomes. Addition of streptomycin restores much of the wild-type behaviour. The SmD, SmP and SmR ribosomes have an enhanced GTP-hydrolysis idling reaction on EF-Tu, which is correlated with how aggressive proofreaders these ribosomes are in steady-state assays. We use our in vitro findings to discuss the in vivo physiology of these mutants as well as mechanistic features of E. coli translation.     

Effect of replacing uridine 33 in yeast tRNAPhe on the reaction with ribosomes

We have determined several kinetic parameters for the reaction of poly(U)-programmed ribosomes with ternary complexes of elongation factor Tu, GTP, and yeast Phe-tRNA analogs with different bases substituted for uridine in position 33. These analogs test whether disruption of the hydrogen bonds normally formed by uridine 33 and steric crowding in the anticodon loop are detrimental to tRNA function on the ribosome. Single-turnover kinetic studies of the reaction of these ternary complexes with ribosomes show that these Phe-tRNA analogs decrease the apparent rate of GTP hydrolysis (kGTP) and the ratio of peptide formed to GTP hydrolyzed. Thus, the substitution of uridine 33 affects not only the selection of a ternary complex by the ribosome but also the selection of an aminoacyl-tRNA in the proofreading reaction. The effects become greater as first one, and then the other, H-bond is disrupted. Steric crowding in the anticodon loop is also important, but does not have as great an effect on the rate constants. An analysis of the elementary rate constants which comprise the rate constant, kGTP, demonstrates that the reduction in kGTP results from a decreased rate of ternary complex association with the ribosome (k1) and that there is little or no effect on the rate of GTP cleavage (k2). An analysis of the rate constants involved in proofreading shows that all the modified (tRNAs have increased rates of aminoacyl-tRNA rejection (k4) but that the rate of peptide bond formation (k3) is unaffected.     

Some properties and the possible role of intrinsic ATPase of rat liver 80S ribosomes in peptide bond elongation

The properties and role in peptide elongation of ATPase intrinsic to rat liver ribosomes were investigated. (i) Rat liver 80S ribosomes showed high ATPase and GTPase activities, whereas the GTPase activity of EF-1alpha and EF-2 was very low. mRNA, aminoacyl-tRNA, and elongation factors alone enhanced ribosomal ATPase activity and in combination stimulated it additively or synergistically. The results suggest that these translational components induce positive conformational changes of 80S ribosomes by binding to different regions of ribosomes. Translation inhibitors, tetracyclin and fusidic acid, inhibited ribosomal ATPase with or without elongational components. (ii) Two ATPase inhibitors, AMP-P(NH)P and vanadate, did not inhibit GTPase activities of EF-1alpha and EF-2 assayed as uncoupled GTPase, but they did inhibit poly(U)-dependent polyphe synthesis of 80S ribosomes. (iii) Effects of AMP-P(NH)P and ATP on poly(U)-dependent polyphe synthesis at various concentrations of GTP were examined. ATP enhanced the activity of polyphe synthesis even at high concentrations of GTP, suggesting a specific role of ATP. At low concentrations of GTP, the extent of inhibition by AMP-P(NH)P was very low, probably owing to the prevention of the reduction of the GTP concentration. (iv) Vanadate inhibited the translocation reaction by high KCl-washed polysomes. These findings together indicate that ribosomal ATPase participates in peptide translation by inducing positive conformational changes of mammalian ribosomes, in addition to its role of chasing tRNA from the E site.     

Codon-dependent tRNA fluctuations monitored with fluorescence polarization

During protein synthesis dictated by the codon sequence of messenger RNA, the ribosome selects aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) with high accuracy, the exact mechanism of which remains elusive. By using a single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer method coupled with fluorescence emission anisotropy, we provide evidence of random thermal motion of tRNAs within the ribosome in nanosecond timescale that we refer to as fluctuations. Our results indicate that cognate aa-tRNA fluctuates less frequently than near-cognate. This is counterintuitive because cognate aa-tRNA is expected to fluctuate more frequently to reach the ribosomal A-site faster than near-cognate. In addition, cognate aa-tRNA occupies the same position in the ribosome as near-cognate. These results argue for a mechanism which guides cognate aa-tRNA more accurately toward the A-site as compared to near-cognate. We suggest that a basis for this mechanism is the induced fit of the 30S subunit upon cognate aa-tRNA binding. Our single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer time traces also point to a mechanistic model for GTP hydrolysis on elongation factor Tu mediated by aa-tRNA.     

The influence of tRNA located at the P-site on the turnover of EF-Tu.GTP on ribosomes.

The turnover of EF-Tu.GTP on poly-U programmed ribosomes was measured both in the presence and in the absence of N-acetylated Phe-tRNA(Phe) at the P-site. The reaction was uncoupled from protein synthesis by omitting Phe-tRNA(Phe) at the A-site. In this reaction, the ribosome can be considered as an enzyme catalysing the transition of EF-Tu.GTP to EF-Tu.GTP. A constant EF-Tu.GTP concentration is maintained by regenerating GDP to GTP at the expense of phosphoenolpyruvate by pyruvate kinase. The rate constants are determined using a procedure which corrects for the reduction in specific activity of GTP due to regeneration of the nucleotide. Ribosomes with an occupied P-site are more efficient in stimulating the GTPase of EF-Tu.GTP than ribosomes with an empty P-site. The data suggest that this is mainly caused by an increased affinity of EF-Tu.GTP for ribosomes with a filled P-site rather than by an enhanced reactivity of the GTPase centre.     

The role of translocation in ribosomal accuracy. Translocation rates for cognate and noncognate aminoacyl- and peptidyl-tRNAs on Escherichia coli ribosomes

The ribosomal translocation, as measured in vitro by peptide formation on poly(U)-programmed Escherichia coli ribosomes in the presence of ternary complex, deacylated tRNA or N-acetyl-Phe-tRNA, and elongation factor G, is the rate-limiting step of protein synthesis. Elongation factor G stimulates the spontaneous translocation by a factor of about 500. N-Acetyl-Phe-Phe-tRNA(Phe E. coli) is translocated with a rate constant of 1-2 s-1 at 25 degrees C. Translocation of N-acetyl-Phe-Phe-tRNA(Phe yeast) and N-acetyl-Phe-Leu-tRNA(Leu E. coli) under identical conditions proceeds with a rate by about a factor of 2 and 10, respectively, more slowly. The translocation rate, therefore, is influenced by the nature of the tRNAs in the A-site. We can show, furthermore, that also the tRNA in the P-site, and presumably in the E-site as well, influences the rate of translocation. Reduced rates of translocation of noncognate peptidyl-tRNAs are accompanied by preferential dissociation of these tRNAs at the beginning of the translation of a mRNA.     

Incorporation of aminoacyl-tRNA into the ribosome as seen by cryo-electron microscopy

Aminoacyl-tRNAs (aa-tRNAs) are delivered to the ribosome as part of the ternary complex of aa-tRNA, elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) and GTP. Here, we present a cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) study, at a resolution of approximately 9 A, showing that during the incorporation of the aa-tRNA into the 70S ribosome of Escherichia coli, the flexibility of aa-tRNA allows the initial codon recognition and its accommodation into the ribosomal A site. In addition, a conformational change observed in the GTPase-associated center (GAC) of the ribosomal 50S subunit may provide the mechanism by which the ribosome promotes a relative movement of the aa-tRNA with respect to EF-Tu. This relative rearrangement seems to facilitate codon recognition by the incoming aa-tRNA, and to provide the codon-anticodon recognition-dependent signal for the GTPase activity of EF-Tu. From these new findings we propose a mechanism that can explain the sequence of events during the decoding of mRNA on the ribosome.     

Distinct functional classes of ram mutations in 16S rRNA

During decoding, the ribosome selects the correct (cognate) aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) from a large pool of incorrect aa-tRNAs through a two-stage mechanism. In the initial selection stage, aa-tRNA is delivered to the ribosome as part of a ternary complex with elongation factor EF-Tu and GTP. Interactions between codon and anticodon lead to activation of the GTPase domain of EF-Tu and GTP hydrolysis. Then, in the proofreading stage, aa-tRNA is released from EF-Tu and either moves fully into the A/A site (a step termed “accommodation”) or dissociates from the ribosome. Cognate codon-anticodon pairing not only stabilizes aa-tRNA at both stages of decoding but also stimulates GTP hydrolysis and accommodation, allowing the process to be both accurate and fast. In previous work, we isolated a number of ribosomal ambiguity (ram) mutations in 16S rRNA, implicating particular regions of the ribosome in the mechanism of decoding. Here, we analyze a representative subset of these mutations with respect to initial selection, proofreading, RF2-dependent termination, and overall miscoding in various contexts. We find that mutations that disrupt inter-subunit bridge B8 increase miscoding in a general way, causing defects in both initial selection and proofreading. Mutations in or near the A site behave differently, increasing miscoding in a codon-anticodon-dependent manner. These latter mutations may create spurious favorable interactions in the A site for certain near-cognate aa-tRNAs, providing an explanation for their context-dependent phenotypes in the cell.