Structural changes of the thylakoid membrane network induced by high light stress in plant chloroplasts

Land plants live in a challenging environment dominated by unpredictable changes. A particular problem is fluctuation in sunlight intensity that can cause irreversible damage of components of the photosynthetic apparatus in thylakoid membranes under high light conditions. Although a battery of photoprotective mechanisms minimize damage, photoinhibition of the photosystem II (PSII) complex occurs. Plants have evolved a multi-step PSII repair cycle that allows efficient recovery from photooxidative PSII damage. An important feature of the repair cycle is its subcompartmentalization to stacked grana thylakoids and unstacked thylakoid regions. Thus, understanding the crosstalk between stacked and unstacked thylakoid membranes is essential to understand the PSII repair cycle. This review summarizes recent progress in our understanding of high-light-induced structural changes of the thylakoid membrane system and correlates these changes to the efficiency of the PSII repair cycle. The role of reversible protein phosphorylation for structural alterations is discussed. It turns out that dynamic changes in thylakoid membrane architecture triggered by high light exposure are central for efficient repair of PSII.     

Grana stacking and protection of Photosystem II in thylakoid membranes of higher plant leaves under sustained high irradiance: An hypothesis

We propose yet another function for the unique appressed thylakoids of grana stacks of higher plants, namely that during prolonged high light, the non-functional, photoinhibited PS II centres accumulate as D1 protein degradation is prevented and may act as dissipative conduits to protect other functional PS II centres. The need for this photoprotective mechanism to prevent high D1 protein turnover under excess photons in higher plants, especially those grown in shade, is due to conflicting demands between efficient use of low irradiance and protection from periodic exposure to excessive irradiance.     

Knockdown of the Arabidopsis thaliana chloroplast protein disulfide isomerase 6 results in reduced levels of photoinhibition and increased D1 synthesis in high light

A chloroplast protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) was previously proposed to regulate translation of the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii chloroplast psbA mRNA, encoding the D1 protein, in response to light. Here we show that AtPDI6, one of 13 Arabidopsis thaliana PDI genes, also plays a role in the chloroplast. We found that AtPDI6 is targeted and localized to the chloroplast. Interestingly, AtPDI6 knockdown plants displayed higher resistance to photoinhibition than wild‐type plants when exposed to a tenfold increase in light intensity. The AtPDI6 knockdown plants also displayed a higher rate of D1 synthesis under a similar light intensity. The increased resistance to photoinhibition may not be rationalized by changes in antenna or non‐photochemical quenching. Thus, the increased D1 synthesis rate, which may result in a larger proportion of active D1 under light stress, may led to the decrease in photoinhibition. These results suggest that, although the D1 synthesis rates observed in wild‐type plants under high light intensities are elevated, repair can potentially occur faster. The findings implicate AtPDI6 as an attenuator of D1 synthesis, modulating photoinhibition in a light‐regulated manner.     

Further studies of the relationship between cation-induced chlorophyll fluorescence and thylakoid membrane stacking changes

Salt-induced changes in thylakoid stacking and chlorophyll fluorescence do not occur with granal membranes obtained by treatment of stacked thylakoids with digitonin. In contrast to normal untreated thylakoids, digitonin prepared granal membranes remain stacked under all ionic conditions and exhibit a constant high level of chlorophyll fluorescence. However, unstacking of these granal membranes is possible if they are pretreated with either acetic anhydride or linolenic acid.Trypsin treatment of the thylakoids inhibits the salt induced chlorophyll fluorescence and stacking changes but stacking of these treated membranes does occur when the pH is lowered, with the optimum being at about pH 4.5. This type of stacking is due to charge neutralization and does not require the presence of the 2000 dalton fragment of the polypeptide associated with the $\text{chlorophyll}\text{a}\text{chlorophyll}\text{b}$ light harvesting complex and known to be lost during treatment with trypsin (Mullet, J.E. and Arntzen, C.J. (1980) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 589, 100–117).Using the method of 9-aminoacridine fluorescence quenching it is argued that the surface charge density, on a chlorophyll basis, of unstacked thylakoid membranes is intermediate between digitonin derived granal and stromal membranes, with granal having the lowest value.The results are discussed in terms of the importance of surface negative charges in controlling salt induced chlorophyll fluorescence and thylakoid stacking changes. In particular, emphasis is placed on a model involving lateral diffusion of different types of chlorophyll protein complex within the thylakoid lipid matrix.     

Stress-induced degradation of the photosynthetic apparatus is accompanied by changes in thylakoid protein turnover and phosphorylation

Development of chlorosis and loss of PSII were compared in young spinach plants suffering under a combined magnesium and sulphur deficiency. Loss of chlorophyll could be detected already after the first week of deficiency and preceded any permanent functional inhibition of PSII as detected by changes in the chlorophyll fluorescence parameter F_v/F_m. A substantial decrease in F_v/F_m was observed only after the second week of deficiency. After 4 weeks, the plants had lost about 70% of their original chlorophyll content, but fluorescence data indicated that 80% of the existing PSII centers were still capable of initiating photosynthetic electron transport. The degradation of the photosynthetic apparatus without loss of PSII activity was due to changes in protein turnover, especially of the PSII D1 reaction center protein. Already by day 7 of deficiency, a 1.4-fold increase in D1 protein synthesis was observed measured as incorporation of ¹⁴C-leucine. Immunological determination by western-blotting did not reveal a change in D1 protein content. Thus, D1 protein was also degraded more rapidly. The increased turnover was high enough to prevent any loss or inhibition of PSII. After 3 weeks, D1 protein synthesis on a chlorophyll basis was further increased by a factor of 2. However, this was not enough to prevent a net loss of D1 protein of about 70%. Immunological determination revealed that together with the D1 protein also other polypeptides of PSII became degraded. This process prevented a large accumulation of photo-inactivated PSII centers. However, it initiated the breakdown of the other thylakoid proteins, especially of LHCII, resulting in the observed chlorosis. Together with the change in protein turnover and stability, a characteristic change in thylakoid protein phosphorylation was observed. In the deficient plants steady state phosphorylation of both LHCII and PSII proteins was increased in the dark. In the light phosphorylation of PSII proteins was stimulated and after 3 weeks of deficiency was even higher in the deficient leaves than in the control plants. In contrast, the phosphorylation level of LHCII decreased in the light and could hardly be detected after 3 weeks of deficiency. Phosphorylation of the reaction center polypeptides presumably increased their stability against proteolytic attack, whereas phosphorylated LHCII seems to be the substrate for proteolysis.     

Relationships between phosphatidylglycerol molecular species of thylakoid membrane lipids and sensitivities to chilling-induced photoinhibition in rice

In an attempt to explore the relationships between phosphatidylglycerol （PG） molecular species of thylakoid membrane lipids and sensitivities to chilling-induced photoinhibition, PG molecular species, D1 protein, electron transport activities of thylakoid membrane and the potential quantum yield （FvlFm） in rice treated under middle and low photon flux density （PFD） at 11℃ were analyzed by high performance liquid chromatography, enzyme hydrolysis, gas phase chromatography （GC） and so on. Results showed that the major molecular species of PGs in rice thylakoid membrane were 18：3/16：0, 18：3/16：1（3t）, 18：2/16：0, 18：2/16：1（3t）, 18：1/16：0, 18：1/16：1（3t）, 16：0/16：0, 16：0/16：1（3t）. There were large differences in the contents of unsaturated PG molecular species such as 18：1-3/16：0-16：1（3t） and saturated PG molecular species like 16：0/16：0-16：1（3t） among japonica cv 9516 0-9516）, japonica-indica hybrid F1 j-9516/i-SY63 （ji-95SY） and indica cv Shanyou 63 （i-SY63）. J-9516 containing higher contents of unsaturated PG molecular species was manifest in stable D1 protein contents under chill and tolerant to chill-induced photoinhibition. In contrast to j-9516, i-SY63 with lower contents of unsaturated PG molecular species, exhibited unstable D1 protein contents under chill and was sensitive to chill-induced photoinhibition, ji-95SY containing middle contents of unsaturated PG molecular species between those of j-9516 and i-SY63, exhibited mid extent of sensitivity to chill-induced photoinhibition. The losses in D1 protein also account for the inhibition in electron transport activity of thylakoid membrane and the observed decline in FvlFm. The PG molecular species that is efficient in raising chilling-resistant capacity were those containing unsaturated fatty acids, namely, unsaturated PG molecular species. These results implied that the substrate selectivity of the glycerol-3-phosphate acyltransferase in chloroplasts towards 16：0 or 18：1 displayed greatly the difference between japonica and indica rice. Itwas possible to enhance the capacity of resistance to chilling-induced photoinhibition by improving or modifying the GPAT gene.     

Two-dimensional separation of chloroplast membrane proteins by isoelectri focusing and electrophoresis in sodium dodecyl sulphate

Proteins of chloroplast subfragments enriched in Photosystem I and Photosystem II electron flow activity have been analyzed by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. In the first dimension, polyacrylamide gel isoelectric focusing (pH 5–7) was used in the presence of Triton X-100, followed at right angle by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulphate. Characteristic fingerprints were obtained for the Photosystem I and II fractions and a correlation between the major proteins separated by isoelectric focusing and the major polypeptides separated by undimensional SDS electrophoresis was established. Two dominant spots of 68 000 and 60 000 daltons appeared in the two-dimensional patterns of Photosystem I fractions $\text{p}\text{I}$ values about 5.6; two spots with molecular weights of 33 000 and 23 000 were characteristics for Photosystem II fractions $\text{p}\text{I}$ values about 5.3 and 6.3). Photosystem I fractions were furthermore characteristics by a series of spots in the 44 000–33 000 range $\text{p}\text{I}$ values from about 5.9 to 6.8). The two-dimensional system revealed that (a) several SDS-polypeptides have multiple forms differing in charge only, (b) some proteins separated by isoelectric focusing are resolved in the second dimensional into polypeptides of different size. The two-dimensional method combining Triton X-100 isoelectric focusing' and SDS electrophoresis provides a higher degree of resolution than either of the unidimensional methods thus allowing a detailed analysis of chloroplast membrane proteins.     

Drought-induced changes in chlorophyll fluorescence,photosynthetic pigments,and thylakoid membrane proteins of Vigna radiata

The effects of drought on chlorophyll fluorescence characteristics of PSII, photosynthetic pigments, thylakoid membrane protein (D1), and proline content in different varieties of mung bean plants were studied. Drought stress inhibits PSII activity and induces alterations in D1 protein. We observed a greater decline in the effective quantum yield of PSII, electron transport rate, and saturating photosynthetically active photon flux density (PPFD_sat) under drought stress in var. Anand than var. K-851 and var. RMG 268. This may possibly be due to either downregulation of photosynthesis or photoinhibition process. Withholding irrigation resulted in gradual diminution in total Chl content at Day 4 of stress. HPLC analysis revealed that the quantity of β-carotene in stressed plants was always higher reaching maxima at Day 4. Photoinactivation of PSII in var. Anand includes the loss of the D1 protein, probably from greater photosynthetic damage caused by drought stress than the other two varieties.     

Multiple strategies for a high light existence in a tropical marine macroalga

Acclimation to high light conditions on the top of coral reefs was examined in the coenocytic, filamentous green macroalga Chlorodesmis fastigiata (C. Ag.) Ducker. Despite having a pool of violaxanthin, high light does not induce formation of zeaxanthin in this macroalga. Exposure to 11 and 33% of surface irradiance resulted in parallel, reversible declines in F_v/F_mand in the number of functional PSII centers. The quantum requirement for PSII inactivation was calculated to be approx. 2×10⁷photons. Recovery of PSII activity after low photon exposures did not depend on protein synthesis, unlike at higher photon exposures, where recovery was inhibited by 50% in the presence of lincomycin. Accumulation of inactive, quenching PSII centers is proposed as a mechanism of energy dissipation; only some of these centers require protein synthesis for reactivation. In natural-sized populations, midday photoinhibition was greater in filament tips than in bases, but the number of inactive PSII centers within entire filaments did not significantly change over the course of the day. It is proposed that the higher chlorophyll concentration in the tips provides protective shading to chloroplasts in lower regions, and that cytoplasmic streaming of chloroplasts within this siphonous alga limits the cumulative exposure to high light, thereby providing another level of protection from high light stress.     

Two dimensional electrophoresis of thylakoid membrane proteins and its application to microsequencing

A procedure of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis adapted for application on membrane proteins from the thylakoids is described. It involves isoelectric focusing in the first dimension and size dependent electrophoresis in the second dimension. About 100 polypeptides are clearly separated with relatively little streaking. About 20 polypeptides are identified by immunoblotting or location in the gel. They are the polypeptides of the PS I core, the 64 kDa protein, the and subunits of CF1 ATPase, cytochrome f, Rieske iron-sulfur protein, the 23 kDa and 33 kDa polypeptides of the oxygen evolving complexes, CP29, CP24, CP27 and CP25 (last two proteins belong to LHCII). Some proteins give rise to two or more separate spots indicating a separation of different isoforms of these proteins. Among them, the LHCII polypeptides (27 kDa and 25 kDa) were each resolved into at least three spots in the pH range 4.75–5.90; the Rieske FeS protein, as published elsewhere (Yu et al. 1994), was separated into two forms having different isoelectric points (pI 5.1 and 5.4), each of them was also microsequenced; the 64 kDa protein claimed to be a LHCII-kinase was found to be multiple forms appearing in at least two isoforms with pI 6.2 (K1) and 6.0 (K2) respectively, furthermore, K1 can be resolved into two subpopulations.The lateral distribution of these proteins in the thylakoid membrane was determined by analysing the vesicles originating from different parts of the thylakoids. The data obtained from this analysis can be partially used as markers for different thylakoid domains.This procedure for sample solubilization and 2-D electrophoresis is useful for the analysis of the polypeptide composition of vesicles originating from the thylakoid membrane and for microsequences of individual polypeptides isolated from the 2-D gel.     

Characterization of processes responsible for the distinct effect of herbicides DCMU and BNT on Photosystem II photoinactivation in cells of the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7942

Light-induced modification of Photosystem II (PS II) complex was characterized in the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7942 treated with either DCMU (a phenylurea PS II inhibitor) or BNT (a phenolic PS II inhibitor). The irradiance response of photoinactivation of PS II oxygen evolution indicated a BNT-specific photoinhibition that saturated at relatively low intensity of light. This BNT-specific process was slowed down under anaerobiosis, was accompanied by the oxygen-dependent formation of a 39 kDa D1 protein adduct, and was not related to stable Q_A reduction or the ADRY effect. In the BNT-treated cells, the light-induced, oxygen-independent initial drop of PS II electron flow was not affected by formate, an anion modifying properties of the PS II non-heme iron. For DCMU-treated cells, anaerobiosis did not significantly affect PS II photoinactivation, the D1 adduct was not observed and addition of formate induced similar initial decrease of PS II electron flow as in the BNT-treated cells. Our results indicate that reactive oxygen species (most likely singlet oxygen) and modification of the PS II acceptor side are responsible for the fast BNT-induced photoinactivation of PS II. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

In vitro evidence for the involvement of activated oxygen in light-induced aggregation of thylakoid proteins

Protein aggregation in thylakoids incurred in situ during light-induced heat shock damage can be simulated in vitro by illuminating isolated thylakoids at normal temperatures. Aggregation is detectable in the in vitro model system by fluorography of [³⁵-S]-methionine-labelled thylakoids fractionated by sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and also by Coomassie staining after SDS-PAGE of unlabelled thylakoids. As in the case of light-induced heat shock damage, protein aggregation in the in vitro system is completely light dependent, and the D-1 protein of PS][is present in the protein aggregate. The model system has also provided evidence for the involvement of activated oxygen in aggregation of thylakoid proteins. Histidine, which scavenges singlet oxygen, and n -propylgallate; a non-specific scavenger of activated oxygen, both provided complete protection against light induced protein aggregation in isolated thylakoids. These compounds also strongly reduced the levels of activated oxygen by illuminated thylakoids as measured by electron spin resonance. The involvement of activated oxygen is further supported by the finding that protein aggregation in the model system proved to be oxygen dependent. The herbicide dichlorophenyldimethyl urea, which binds to the QB site of the D-1 protein of PSII and provides protection against photoinhibition and light dependent degradation of the D-1 protein, also provided partial protection against protein aggregation in the in vitro system. Protein continues to aggregate after PSII activity has reached undetectable levels suggesting that aggregation is a consequence rather than a cause of photoinhibition. The observations collectively indicate that aggregation of thylakoid proteins is attributable to activated oxygen.     

A Fourier transform infrared spectroscopic study of the effects of hydrogen peroxide and high light on protein conformations of Photosystem II

Degradation of the reaction center-binding protein D1 of Photosystem II (PS II) during photoinhibition is dependent on the action of active oxygen species and/or D1-specific proteases. Protein conformational changes may be involved in the process of D1 degradation. In the present study, we determined the effect of H₂O₂ on spinach PS II-enriched membranes and core complexes with respect to electron transport, Mn content and protein secondary structural changes as measured by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. H₂O₂ is effective in removing catalytic Mn in PS II, especially in PS II core complexes depleted of OEC18 and OEC24, impairing the donor-side. By quantitative analysis of the amide I band (1600 – 1700 cm^-1) with both aqueous and dehydrated PS II samples, we found that no significant secondary structural changes are associated with H₂O₂ treatment in the dark, even though there is some cleavage of the D1 protein by H₂O₂ treatment as determined by Western analysis with specific antibodies. In contrast, a large decrease in the -helices in the PS II core occurs, with or without H₂O₂ treatment, after 20 min strong illumination and there is more extensive degradation of the D1 protein. Our results suggest that high light enhances the cleavage of the D1 protein which is reflected in the large protein secondary structural changes in PS II detected by FTIR measurements.     

Strong-light photoinhibition treatment accelerates the changes of protein secondary structures in triton-treated photosystem I and photosystem II complexes

Changes in the protein secondary structure and electron transport activity of the Triton X-100-treated photosystem I (PSI) and photosystem II (PSII) complexes after strong illumination treatment were studied using Fourier transform-infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy and an oxygen electrode. Short periods of photoinhibitory treatment led to obvious decreases in the rates of PSI-mediated electron transport activity and PSII-mediated oxygen evolution in the native or Triton-treated PSI and PSII complexes. In the native PSI and PSII complexes, the protein secondary structures had little changes after the photoinhibitory treatment. However, in both Triton-treated PSI and PSII complexes, short photoinhibition times caused significant loss of -helical content and increase of -sheet structure, similar to the conformational changes in samples of Triton-treated PSI and PSII complexes after long periods of dark incubation. Our results demonstrate that strong-light treatment to the Triton-treated PSI and PSII complexes accelerates destruction of the transmembrane structure of proteins in the two photosynthetic membranes.     

Effect of light quality on the composition and function of thylakoid membranes in atriplex triangularis

Light quality was shown to exert well-coordinated regulatory effects on the composition and function of the thylakoid membranes as well as on the photosynthetic rates of intact leaves from Atriplex triangularis grown in continuous blue, white and red lights (50 μE · m^?2 · s^?1). The higher photosynthetic rates in plants grown in blue light, as compared to those in white and red lights, resulted from marked changes in both light-harvesting complexes and electron carriers. The concentrations of electron carriers such as atrazine binding sites, plastoquinone, cytochromes b and f and P-700 on a chlorophyll basis were markedly increased in Atriplex grown in blue light; and the apparent light-harvesting antenna unit sizes of Photosystems I and II were greatly reduced. Consequently, the electron transport capacities of Photosystems I and II were also increased as was the coupling factor CF₁ activity. Atriplex grown in red light had lower photosynthetic rates than those grown in blue or white light by incorporating changes in the composition and function of the thylakoids in a direction opposite to those caused by growth in blue light. When these regulatory effects of light quality were compared with those of light quantity [6,7], it is clear that $\text{Chl}\text{a}\text{Chl}\text{b}$ ratios, electron transport capacities of Photosystems I and II, concentrations of plastoquinone, atrazine binding sites, coupling factor CF₁ activity and the apparent antenna unit size of Photosystem II are more affected by light quantity, whereas light quality has a greater influence on the concentration of P-700, the apparent antenna unit size of Photosystem I and the overall photosynthetic rates of intact leaves.     

On the nature of the fluorescence decrease due to phosphorylation of chloroplast membrane proteins

1. Phosphorylation of chloroplast membranes by illumination in the presence of ATP results in a 15–20% increase in the rate of Photosystem I electron transfer at low light intensity. 2. Phosphorylated membranes when depleted of Mg²⁺ and resuspended in a low salt medium still show a 17% lower yield of Photosystem II fluorescence than do unphosphorylated membranes. A 31% difference is seen after restoration of the maximal yield by addition of Mg²⁺. 3. The concentration of Mg²⁺ required to induce a half-maximal increase in fluorescence is 0.9 mM for control and 1.8 mM for phosphorylated chloroplasts. Phosphorylation at 1 mM Mg²⁺ can therefore cause more than double the amount of decrease in fluorescence yield from Photosystem II compared to phosphorylation at 5 mM. 4. The above results are discussed in terms of the mechanism of the ATP-induced fluorescence changes and a suggestion is made that the apparent interaction between phosphorylation and Mg²⁺ concentration may be a physiologically important phenomenon.     

YidC family members are involved in the membrane insertion, lateral integration, folding, and assembly of membrane proteins

Members of the YidC family exist in all three domains of life, where they control the assembly of a large variety of membrane protein complexes that function as transporters, energy devices, or sensor proteins. Recent studies in bacteria have shown that YidC functions on its own as a membrane protein insertase independent of the Sec protein-conducting channel. YidC can also assist in the lateral integration and folding of membrane proteins that insert into the membrane via the Sec pathway.     

The interaction of visible and UV-B light during photodamage and repair of Photosystem II

In order to understand the mechanism of photodamage induced by solar radiation under natural conditions, we studied the interaction of visible and ultraviolet-B light in the inactivation and repair of the Photosystem II complex by using oxygen evolution and flash-induced chlorophyll fluorescence measurements. In isolated spinach thylakoids and Synechocystis 6803 cells, in which de novo protein synthesis is blocked by lincomycin, photodamage of Photosystem II by visible and UV-B light is characterized by linear semilogarithmic inactivation curves for both separate and combined illumination protocols. The extent of PS II inactivation obtained after combined illumination can be well simulated by assuming independent damaging events induced by visible and UV-B photons. In intact Synechocystis cells capable of protein repair, simultaneous illumination by visible and UV-B light impairs Photosystem II activity to a smaller extent than expected from the independent damaging events. This protective effect is pronounced at low visible light (130 μE m⁻² s⁻¹), but becomes negligible at high intensities (1300 μE m⁻² s⁻¹). Exposure of intact Synechocystis 6803 cells to direct sunlight leads to a rapid inactivation of PS II, accompanied by the accumulation of donor side inhibited centers. This phenomenon, which shows the impairment of the manganese cluster of water oxidation was not observed when the ultraviolet components of sunlight were filtered out. We conclude that visible and UV-B photons inactivate PS II via non-interacting mechanisms, which affect different target sites. In intact cells, the two spectral regions do interact, and results in synergistically enhanced protein repair capacity when UV-B radiation is accompanied by low intensity visible light, which provides protection against photodamage. However, this ameliorating effect becomes insignificant at high light intensities characteristic of direct sunlight. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Inhibitors of photosystem II and the topology of the herbicide and QB binding polypeptide in the thylakoid membrane

The folding through the thylakoid membrane of the D-1 herbicide binding polypeptide and of the homologous D-2 subunit of photosystem II is predicted from comparison of amino acid sequences and hydropathy index plots with the folding of the subunits L and M of a bacterial photosystem. As the functional amino acids involved in Q and Fe binding in the bacterial photosystem of R. viridis, as indicated by the X-ray structure, are conserved in the homologous D-1 and D-2 subunits of photosystem II, a detailed topology of the binding niche of Q_B and of herbicides on photosystem II is proposed. The model is supported by the observed amino acid changes in herbicide tolerant plants and algae. These changes are all in the binding domain on the matrix side of the D-1 polypeptide, and turn out to be of functional significance in the Q_B binding.New inhibitors of Q_B function are described. Their chemical structure, i.e. pyridones, quinolones, chromones and benzodiones, contains the features of the phenolic type herbicides. Their essential elements, -charges at particular atoms, QSAR and steric requirements for optimal inhibitory potency are discussed and compared with the classical herbicides of the urea/triazine type.