Genetic characterisation of dough rheological properties in a wheat doubled haploid population: additive genetic effects and epistatic interactions

Doubled haploid lines (n=160) from a cross between wheat cultivars Cranbrook (high dough extensibility) and Halberd (low dough extensibility) were grown at three Australian locations. The parents differ at all high- and low-molecular-weight glutenin loci. Dough rheological parameters were measured using small-scale testing procedures, and quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping procedures were carried out using an existing well-saturated genetic linkage map for this cross. Genetic parameters were estimated using three software packages: QTLCartographer, Epistat and Genstat. Results indicated that environmental factors are a major determinant of dough extensibility across the three trial sites, whereas genotypic factors are the major determinants of dough strength. Composite interval mapping analysis across the 21 linkage groups revealed that as expected, the main additive QTLs for dough rheological properties are located at the high- and low-molecular-weight glutenin loci. A new QTL on chromosome 5A for M-extensibility (a mixograph-estimated measure of extensibility) was detected. Analysis of epistatic interactions revealed that there were significant conditional epistatic interactions related with the additive effects of glutenin loci on dough rheological properties. Therefore, the additive genetic effects of glutenins on dough rheological properties are conditional upon the genetic background of the wheat line. The molecular basis of the interactions with the glutenin loci may be via proteins that modify or alter the gluten protein matrix or variations in the expression level of the glutenin genes. Reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatography analysis of the molar number of individual glutenin subunits across the population showed that certain conditional epistases resulted in increased expression of the affected glutenin. The epistatic interactions detected in this study provide a possible explanation of the variable genetic effects of some glutenins on quality attributes in different genetic backgrounds and provide essential information for the accurate prediction of glutenin related variance in marker-assisted wheat breeding.     

Linkage studies of the Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome: polymorphisms at TIMP and the X chromosome centromere are informative markers for genetic prediction

Summary Eleven families segregating for the X-linked recessive immune deficiency disorder, Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS), were studied by linkage analysis with an alpha satellite DNA probe, pBamX-7, which detects polymorphism at the X chromosome centromere, locus DXZ1, as well as three other polymorphic markers defining loci on the proximal short arm of the X chromosome. Linkage has been established between WAS and DXZ1 ( ()=7.08 at =0.03) and WAS and the TIMP gene locus ( ()=5.09 at =0.0). We have also confirmed close linkage between DXZ1 and two marker loci, DXS14 and DXS7, previously shown to be linked to the WAS locus. The probe pBamX-7 detected allelic variation in all females tested, reflecting the high frequency of polymorphism at the centromere. One WAS carrier revealed a recombination between WAS and both marker loci DXZ1 and DXS14, indicating that WAS does not map between these loci. In conjunction with previous data from genetic mapping studies of WAS, these results confirm the pericentromerix Xp localization of WAS and demonstrate the usefulness of alpha satelite DNA probes as tools for genetic prediction in WAS as well as other pericentric X-linked diseases.     

Allelic variation at α-Amylase loci in hexaploid wheat

Summary A study of -amylase isozyme patterns from gibberellin-induced endosperms from more than 200 wheat genotypes has revealed allelic variation at five of the six -Amy-1 and -Amy-2 structural loci. These differences will find application as genetic markers and in varietal identification. The -Amy-B1 locus on chromosome 6B was most variable and displayed eight distinct allelic forms. The nature of the allelic phenotypes, observations of segregating populations and the number of in vivo translation products of mRNAs from the -Amy-1 and -Amy-2 loci indicated that the individual loci are multigenic, each consisting of tightly linked subunits which produce several different isoforms.     

Effect of gliadins and HMW and LMW subunits of glutenin on dough properties in the F6 recombinant inbred lines from a bread wheat cross

The storage proteins of 64 F₂-derived F₆ recombinant inbred lines (RILs) from the bread wheat cross Prinqual/Marengo were analyzed. Parents differed at four loci: Gli-B1 (coding for gliadins), Glu-B1 (coding for HMW glutenin subunits), Glu-A3/Gli-A1 (coding for LMW glutenin subunits/gliadins) and Glu-D3 (coding for LMW glutenin subunits). The effect of allelic variation at these loci on tenacity, extensibility and dough strength as measured by the Chopin alveograph was determined. Allelic differences at the Glu-B1 locus had a significant effect on only tenacity. None of the allelic differences at either the Glu-A3/Gli-A1 or Glu-D3 loci had a significant effect on quality criteria. Allelic variation at the Gli-B1 locus significantly affected all of the dough properties. Epistatic effects between some of the loci considered contributed significantly to the variation in dough quality. Additive and epistatic effects each accounted for 15% of the variation in tenacity. Epistasis accounted for 15% of the variation in extensibility, whereas additive effects accounted for 4%. Epistasis accounted for 14% of the variation in dough strength, and additivity for 9%. The relative importance of epistatic effects suggest that they should be included in predictive models when breeding for breadmaking quality.     

Effect of assortative mating on genetic change due to selection

Summary Two mathematical models (A and B) were used to study joint effects of selection and assortative mating on genetic change. Computer simulation was used to verify and extend the results. In each model, the genotype was additive with equal effects at each of N loci and the environmental distribution was N(0, ²). In Model A, each locus had two alleles; in Model B, allelic effects at each locus followed a normal distribution. Using Model A, genetic change with assortative or random mating of selected parents was evaluated for combinations of number of loci (N = 1, 2, 3), heritability in base population (H^[0] = 0.2, 0.5, 0.8), allelic frequency in base population (p = 0.1, 0.5), and proportion selected ( = 0.20, 0.85). Using Model B, genetic change with or without assortative mating was calculated for combinations of N (1, 2, 3, 5, 10, 100, H^[0] (0.2, 0.5, 0.8) and (0.20, 0.85). Response to selection under both mating systems in a finite population was estimated using Model A from 200 replications of a computer simulation; this was done for all combinations of N (1,2, 3, 5, 10) and (0.20, 0.85), with H^[0] = 0.5 and p = 0.1. Results obtained with both models indicate that the effect of assortative mating on genetic change increases with H^[0] and , and decreases with p. With Model A, the relationship between N and the effect of assortative mating on genetic change was not clear; with Model B, however, the advantage of assortative over random mating increased with N, as expected. Simulation results were in agreement with theory of Model A. This study indicates that selection with assortative mating can have a sizable (10 to 20%) long-term advantage over selection with random mating of parents when H^[0] is high, p is low and is large.     

Quantitative variability in wheat following irradiation,EMS, and hybridization

Summary The effects of gamma irradiation and EMS seed treatment on the genetic properties of pure line and hybrid wheat populations were measured. Two hundred lines were derived from each mutagenic treatment of each genetic source and, together with their control materials, were assayed for heading date, plant height, spike length, and kernel weight in a replicated field experiment.Both mutagens induced significant genetic variability for the four traits in either Giza 150 or Sonora 64, two pure cultivars, but neither was effective in increasing the genetic variation in their hybrid background. The relative magnitude of induced variation compared with that from hybridization depended on the particular mutagen and attribute and averaged less than 50% of that from hybridization. Heritabilities and expected genetic gains were not much lower in mutagenic populations than in hybrid populations. The relative distributions of the variance components among families and within families, and the estimates of the genetic correlations in the various populations, indicated that induced mutations were somewhat similar in nature to the variation released from hybridization. The induced variation was not accompanied by any shift in the population mean and, in most cases, variation was equally distributed around the population mean.     

Genic variation in the deer mouse,Peromyscus maniculatus,in a small geographic area

Genic variation was examined with starch and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis at 14 loci in 12 populations of Peromyscus maniculatus nubiterrae from a small part of the Appalachians in eastern Tennessee and western North Carolina. Polymorphism was observed at eight loci with no significant correlations between frequency of common genotypes or alleles and altitude. Average individual heterozygosity (\-H) values were low for P. maniculatus whether using only slow evolving loci (mean = 3.0%) or both slow and fast evolving loci (mean = 4.9%). No significant correlation was present between altitude and \-H. Interlocality variation of \-H was as great in this study as previously reported for P. maniculatus over larger geographic areas. Rogers' coefficients of genetic similarity of paired combinations of populations based on slow evolving loci (range of 0.941 to 0.997) or based on slow and fast evolving loci (range of 0.858 to 0.974) showed all populations to be highly similar. Ranges of similarity values observed in the present study were as great as those previously reported for P. maniculatus over a larger geographic area.     

Analysis of QTLs for yield, yield components, and malting quality in a BC3-DH population of spring barley

Advanced backcross (AB)-quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis has been successfully applied for detecting and transferring QTLs from unadapted germplasm into elite breeding lines in various plant species. Here, we describe the application of a modified AB breeding scheme to spring barley. A BC₃-doubled haploid (DH) population consisting of 181 lines derived from the German spring barley cultivar Brenda (Hordeum vulgare subsp. vulgare) as the recurrent parent and the wild species line HS213 (H. vulgare subsp. spontaneum) as the donor line was evaluated for yield and its components as well as malting quality traits. A set of 60 microsatellite markers was used to genotype the population, and phenotypic data were collected at two locations in Germany in continuous years. Altogether, 25 significant QTLs were detected by single-marker regression analysis and interval mapping. Most positive QTLs originated from the recurrent parent Brenda. A QTL, Qhd2.1, on chromosome 2HS from Brenda explained 18.3% and 20.7% of the phenotypic variation for yield and heading date, respectively. Due to the small percentage of donor-parent genome of 6.25%, the BC₃-DH lines could be directly used for the extraction of near-isogenic lines (NILs) for Qhd2.1. Consequently, it was possible to determine the precise location of the locus hd2.1 within a region of 6.5 cM, using an F₂ population consisting of 234 individuals developed from a cross between an NIL containing a defined donor segment at this locus and Brenda. The location of this QTL was consistent with the presence of a major photoperiod response gene, Ppd-H1, previously reported in this region, which is associated with pleiotropic effects on yield components. In summary, the analysis of a BC₃-DH population in barley provides a compromise between the analysis of QTLs by means of an AB scheme and the generation of defined substitution lines. Several lines carrying defined different donor segments for only one single chromosome or trait in the genetic background of Brenda could be selected for further genetic studies.     

Mapping the genome of rapeseed (Brassica napus L.). I. Construction of an RFLP linkage map and localization of QTLs for seed glucosinolate content

A linkage map of the rapeseed genome comprising 204 RFLP markers, 2 RAPD markers, and 1 phenotypic marker was constructed using a F₁ derived doubled haploid population obtained from a cross between the winter rapeseed varieties Mansholt's Hamburger Raps and Samourai. The mapped markers were distributed on 19 linkage groups covering 1441 cM. About 43% of these markers proved to be of dominant nature; 36% of the mapped marker loci were duplicated, and conserved linkage arrangements indicated duplicated regions in the rapeseed genome. Deviation from Mendelian segregation ratios was observed for 27.8% of the markers. Most of these markers were clustered in 7 large blocks on 7 linkage groups, indicating an equal number of effective factors responsible for the skewed segregations. Using cDNA probes for the genes of acyl-carrier-protein (ACP) and -ketoacyl-ACP-synthase I (KASI) we were able to map three and two loci, respectively, for these genes. The linkage map was used to localize QTLs for seed glucosinolate content by interval mapping. Four QTLs could be mapped on four linkage groups, giving a minimum number of factors involved in the genetic control of this trait. The estimated effects of the mapped QTLs explain about 74% of the difference between both parental lines and about 61.7 % of the phenotypic variance observed in the doubled haploid mapping population.     

Interval mapping of quantitative trait loci for reproductive,morphological, and seed traits of soybean (Glycine max L.)

Quantitative trait loci (QTL) were mapped in segregating progeny from a cross between two soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) cultivars: Minsoy (PI 27.890) and Noir 1 (PI 290.136). The 15 traits analyzed included reproductive, morphological, and seed traits, seed yield and carbon isotope discrimination ratios (¹³C/¹²C). Genetic variation was detected for all of the traits, and transgressive segregation was a common phenomenon. One hundred and thirty-two linked genetic markers and 24 additional unlinked markers were used to locate QTL by interval mapping and one-way analysis of variance, respectively. Quantitative trait loci controlling 11 of the 15 traits studied were localized to intervals in 6 linkage groups. Quantitative trait loci for developmental and morphological traits (R1, R5, R8, plant height, canopy height, leaf area, etc.) tended to be clustered in three intervals, two of which were also associated with seed yield. Quantitative trait loci for seed oil were separated from all the other QTL. Major QTL for maturity and plant height were linked to RFLP markers R79 (31% variation) and G173 (53% variation). Quantitative trait loci associated with unlinked markers included possible loci for seed protein and weight. Linkage between QTL is discussed in relation to the heritability and genetic correlation of the traits.     

Number of alleles at the incompatibility loci in Secale cereale L.

Summary Two experiments were performed to estimate the number of alleles at the two incompatibility loci of rye in the variety Halo. In one experiment I₁ progenies from enforced selfing under controlled conditions were isolated. In the other experiment a genotype, homozygous at both incompatibility loci, was used as pollinator for a sample of the Halo population, which was regarded as an equilibrium population. Genotypes, which are homozygous at both incompatibility loci, can be found after selfing. The estimate for the number of alleles was 6 to 7 at one locus and 12 to 13 at the other locus.     

Fine mapping of a malting-quality QTL complex near the chromosome 4H S telomere in barley

Malting quality has long been an active objective in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) breeding programs. However, it is difficult for breeders to manipulate malting-quality traits because of inheritance complexity and difficulty in evaluation of these quantitative traits. Quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping provides breeders a promising basis with which to manipulate quantitative trait genes. A malting-quality QTL complex, QTL2, was mapped previously to a 30-cM interval in the short-arm telomere region of barley chromosome 4H in a Steptoe/Morex doubled haploid population by the North American Barley Genome Project, using an interval mapping method with a relatively low-resolution genetic map. The QTL2 complex has moderate effects on several malting-quality traits, including malt extract percentage (ME), -amylase activity (AA), diastatic power (DP), malt -glucan content (BG), and seed dormancy, which makes it a promising candidate gene source in malting barley-cultivar development. Fine mapping QTL2 is desirable for precisely studying barley malting-quality trait inheritance and for efficiently manipulating QTL2 in breeding. A reciprocal-substitution mapping method was employed to fine map QTL2. Molecular marker-assisted backcrossing was used to facilitate the generation of isolines. Fourteen different types of Steptoe isolines, including regenerated Steptoe and 13 different types of Morex isolines, including regenerated Morex, were made within a 41.5-cM interval between MWG634 and BCD265B on chromosome 4H. Duplicates were identified for 12 Steptoe and 12 Morex isoline types. The isolines together with Steptoe and Morex were grown variously at three locations in 2 years for a total of five field environments. Four malting-quality traits were measured: ME, DP, AA, and BG. Few significant differences were found between duplicate isolines for these traits. A total of 15 putative QTLs were mapped; three for ME, four for DP, six for AA, and two for BG. Background genotype seemed to make a difference in expression/detection of QTLs. Of the 15 QTLs identified, ten were from the Morex and only five from the Steptoe background. By combining the results from different years, field environments, and genetic backgrounds and taking into account overlapping QTL segments, six QTLs can be conservatively estimated: two each for ME and AA and one each for DP and BG with chromosome segments ranging from 0.7 cM to 27.9 cM. A segment of 15.8 cM from the telomere (MWG634–CDO669) includes all or a portion of all QTLs identified. Further study and marker-assisted breeding should focus on this 15.8-cM chromosome region.     

Identification and mapping of cleistogamy genes in barley

Cleistogamy is a closed type of flowering with ensured self-pollination and an important trait to study evolutionary development in flower organs, reproduction systems, gene flow, and disease control. Still, very limited information is available about the genetic control and regulatory mechanism of this trait in barley. In this work, from the eight crosses between cleistogamous and chasmogamous accessions, five crosses generated chasmogamous F₁ plants and their F₂ plants segregated as 3 chasmogamous:1 cleistogamous, whereas three crosses generated cleistogamous F₁ plants, and their F₂ plants segregated as 1 chasmogamous:3 cleistogamous. Although a single gene was responsible for the control of cleistogamy in these two groups of crosses, the direction of dominance was opposite, suggesting two genes, cly1 and Cly2, for the genetic control of cleistogamy in barley. Epistatic type of gene interaction between the two loci was detected. In the analysis of 99 recombinant inbred lines of Azumamugi × Kanto Nakate Gold and doubled haploid lines of Harrington × Mikamo Golden, where in both crosses F₁ was chasmogamous, the cly1 locus has been mapped on chromosome 2HL. Using the analysis of the F₂ population of Misato Golden and Satsuki Nijo where F₁ was cleistogamous, the Cly2 locus was mapped in the same region of chromosome 2HL. Because the cly1 and Cly2 loci were mapped in the same region in these three different mapping populations, it was concluded that the expression of cleistogamy is under the control of two tightly linked genes or different alleles of the same gene.     

Genetic analysis of morphological variation in Brassica oleracea using molecular markers

A cross between the open-pollinated Brassica oleracea cabbage cultivar Wisconsin Golden Acre and the hybrid broccoli cultivar Packman was used with molecular markers to investigate the genetic control of morphological variation. Twenty-two traits derived from leaf, stem, and flowering measurements were analyzed in 90 F₂ individuals that were also classified for genotype by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) markers. Seventy-two RFLP loci, which covered the mapped genome at an average of 10 map-unit intervals on all nine linkage groups, were tested individually for associations to phenotypic measurements by single factor ANOVA, and markers with significant associations (P<0.05) were used to develop multilocus models. These data were utilized to describe the location, parental contribution of alleles, magnitude of effect, and the gene action of trait loci. Single marker loci that were significantly associated (P<0.05) with trait measurements accounted for 6.7–42.7% of the phenotypic variation. Multilocus models described as much as 60.1% of the phenotypic variation for a given trait. In some cases, different related traits had common marker-locus associations with similar gene action and genotypic class ranking. The numbers, action, and linkages, of genes controlling traits estimated with marker loci in this population corresponded to estimates based on classical genetic methods from other studies using similar, or similarly-wide, crosses. There was no evidence that genome duplication accounted for a significant portion of multiple genes controlling trait loci over the entire genome, but possible duplications of trait loci were identified for two regions with linked, duplicated marker loci.     

Abiotrophic gene action inHomo sapiens: Potential mechanisms and significance for the pathobiology of aging

A subset of genetic loci ofHomo sapiens are reviewed that: 1) have the potential for allelic variation (either mutation or polymorphism) such that degenerative and/or proliferative phenotypic aberrations may be of relatively late onset (abiotrophic); 2) have phenotypic features which overlap, to some extent, with those of important age-related disorders of man (many of which are systematically tabulated in this review); 3) have had significant characterization at the biochemical genetic level. The ascertainment bias of physicians to discover strong phenotypic effects (non-leaky mutations) obscures the fact that, for many such instances, there exist numerous other alleles of lesser effects, including those whose gene actions probably escape the force of natural selection.The patterns of normal aging inHomo sapiens are quite variable and, hence, difficult to define. It seems likely that the wild-type alleles of a number of loci will also be found to have antagonistic pleiotropic effects that contribute to the syndromology of senescence in our species.     

Selection at the α-Gpdh locus in experimental populations of Drosophila melanogaster

Three sets of experiments have been conducted in order to evaluate the role of natural selection at the -Gpdh locus in Drosophila melanogaster. (1) The evolution of the F-allele frequency has been followed for many generations in 13 experimental populations having different genetic backgrounds. (2) Egg-to-adult viability has been measured in synthetic populations derived from one locality (Brouilly) and the results have been compared with those of a previous experiment involving a different local population (Tostes). (3) The effects of sodium octanoate on egg-to-adult viability have been measured on the genotypes FF, FS, SF, and SS. The results demonstrate that selection operates on a small block of genes which includes the -Gpdh locus.ERA 406 CNRS: Analyse et mécanismes de maintien du polymorphisme.     

Use of recombinant substitution lines in the construction of RFLP-based genetic maps of chromosomes 6A and 6B of tetraploid wheat (Triticum turgidum L.)

RFLP-based genetic maps of chromosomes 6A and 6B of Triticum turgidum have been constructed using data obtained by the study of Triticum turgidum var durum cv Langdon-T. t. var dicoccoides recombinant substitution lines (RSLs) supplemented with data obtained from F₃ families derived from Langdon dicoccoides 6A and 6B disomic substitution lines. The average RFLP frequencies detected for the two chromosomes in a test of 45 DNA clones with six restriction enzymes were 56% and 53%, respectively, and a subset of 32 clones gave frequencies of 75% and 72%, respectively. Seventeen loci were mapped in 6A and 18 in 6B. With the possible exception of 5 loci in the centromeric region of 6A, all of the mapped 6A and 6B loci are located in the same arm as are homologous loci in hexaploid wheat, and the linear order of the loci is the same in the two chromosomes, except possibly close to the centromere. Major differences in genetic distances exist between homologous loci located in the proximal regions of the 6AL and 6BL linkage groups, however, the distances being much larger in the former than in the latter. The 6B maps that were constructed using data from both the RSL and the F₂ populations and using data from the RSL population alone closely resemble one another, indicating that the 6B RSL population, composed of 85 lines, can be reliably used for genetic mapping. Additional studies must be conducted before the utility of the 6A RSL population, composed of 66 lines, can be adequately assessed.     

Analysis of allozymic and quantitative variation produced by artificial selection in Drosophila melanogaster

In order to study a possible connection between allozymic and quantitative variation in D. melanogaster, three selection experiments were carried out, using founder strains of known genetic and chromosomal composition.The Adh and Gpdh-1 enzyme loci have been used as genetic markers and the maximum wing length has been the quantitative trait chosen. Two selected lines (high and low) were maintained and also one without selection (drift), to estimate the effect of random fluctuation on gene frequency variation. The allozymic variation was analysed by means of a polynomial regression, and a normal linear model allowed to make pairwise comparisons.The allelic combination ((F), A(-)) was favoured in the low lines of the selection experiments; the selection acted in favour of homozygotes, with a correlated loss of genetic homoeostasis. The similar behaviour of the drift and the control lines shows that random fluctuations in the gene frequencies in selected lines are negligible.     

Linkage mapping of ‘25-kDa globulin’ genes on homoeologous group-1 chromosomes of bread and durum wheat

Acid polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis (A-PAGE) of ethanol-soluble proteins from the endosperm of bread and durum wheats reveals some bands encoded by genes on the homoeologous group-1 chromosomes with higher mobility than the -gliadins. The isolation of these proteins showed that they were the previously described 25-kDa globulins encoded by genes at the Glo-A1, Glo-B1, and Glo-D1 loci. The variability found among a collection of 51 bread and 81 durum wheats was very low: two allelic variants at Glo-A1 and no variants at Glo-B1 in each of the two species, and two allelic variants at Glo-D1 in bread wheat. Inheritance studies of 25-kDa globulin genes on group-1 chromosomes of bread and durum wheat were carried out on the F₂ progeny from four crosses, two in bread wheat and two in durum wheat. The linkage mapping of the 1A 25-kDa globulin genes of bread wheat was done based on four prolamin loci: Glu-A1, Glu-A3, Gli-A1 and Gli -A3. The percentages of recombination and the distances found allowed a re-evaluation of the linkage map of endosperm protein loci on this chromosome. The Glo-A1 locus was found to be located at the distal end of the short arm of 1A chromosome, at a distance of 5.23±1.99 cM from Gli-A1, 6.85±2.22 cM from Glu-A3, 22.64±3.62 cM from Gli-A1, and at a recombination percentage of 49.30±4.40 from Glu-A1. A similar distance between Gli-A1 and Glo-A1 (4.82±1.75 and 6.66±2.26 cM) was found in durum wheat. The distance between Gli-D1 and Glo-D1 on chromosome 1D was 2.86±1.39 cM.     

What's in a Cause?: The Pragmatic Dimensions of Genetic Explanations

The paper argues for a pragmatic account of genetic explanation. This is to say that when a disease or other trait is termed genetic, the reasons for singling out genes as causes over other, also necessary, genetic and nongenetic conditions are not wholly theoretical but include pragmatic dimensions. Whether the explanation is the presence of a trait in an individual or differences in a trait among individuals, genetic explanations are context-dependent in three ways: they are relative to a causal background of genetic and nongenetic factors; they are relative to a population; and they are relative to the present state of knowledge. Criteria like causal priority, nonstandardness, and causal efficacy that purport to distinguish objectively between genetic causes and nongenetic conditions either incorporate pragmatic elements or fail for other reasons. When the pragmatic dimensions of genetic explanations are recognized, we come to understand the current phenomenon of geneticization to be a reflection of increased technological capacities to manipulate genes in the laboratory, and potentially the clinic, rather than theoretical progress in understanding how diseases and other traits arise. This calls into question the value of the search for theoretical definitions of designations like genetic disease or genetic susceptibility as directives for action.