Transposon-mediated single-copy gene delivery leads to increased transgene expression stability in barley

Instability of transgene expression in plants is often associated with complex multicopy patterns of transgene integration at the same locus, as well as position effects due to random integration. Based on maize transposable elements Activator (Ac) and Dissociation (Ds), we developed a method to generate large numbers of transgenic barley (Hordeum vulgare var Golden Promise) plants, each carrying a single transgene copy at different locations. Plants expressing Ac transposase (AcTPase) were crossed with plants containing one or more copies of bar, a selectable herbicide (Basta) resistance gene, located between inverted-repeat Ds ends (Ds-bar). F(1) plants were self-pollinated and the F(2) generation was analyzed to identify plants segregating for transposed Ds-bar elements. Of Ds-bar transpositions, 25% were in unlinked sites that segregated from vector sequences, other Ds-bar copies, and the AcTPase gene, resulting in numerous single-copy Ds-bar plants carrying the transgene at different locations. Transgene expression in F(2) plants with transposed Ds-bar was 100% stable, whereas only 23% of F(2) plants carrying Ds-bar at the original site expressed the transgene product stably. In F(3) and F(4) populations, transgene expression in 81.5% of plants from progeny of F(2) plants with single-copy, transposed Ds-bar remained completely stable. Analysis of the integration site in single-copy plants showed that transposed Ds-bar inserted into single- or low-copy regions of the genome, whereas silenced Ds-bar elements at their original location were inserted into redundant or highly repetitive genomic regions. Methylation of the non-transposed transgene and its promoter, as well as a higher condensation of the chromatin around the original integration site, was associated with plants exhibiting transgene silencing.     

Comparative high resolution map of the six-rowed spike locus 1 (vrs1) in several populations of barley, Hordeum vulgare L

Multiple alleles at the vrs1 locus control the development and fertility of the lateral spikelets of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.), which is a key character in the study of yield, utilization and domestication. In this study, six linkage maps of the vrs1 locus were constructed, using different mapping populations developed from nine different barley cultivars (H. vulgare subsp. vulgare) or mutant and wild barley (H. vulgare subsp. spontaneum). A total of 8387 chromosomes (gametes) were sampled for analysis based on a hypothesis that orders of marker loci were the same over the different parental lines. The results showed that four markers and the vrs1 locus in all cases were arranged in the same order, which was in a good agreement with the hypothesis. This makes the linkage maps suitable for the positional cloning of the alleles at the vrs1 locus.     

Features of recombination of nuclear genome in back crossed offspring of barley-wheat hybrids Hordeum vulgare L. (2n=14) x Triticum aestivum L. (2n+42) with the use of SSR-analysis

The backcross progenies of the barley-wheat hybrids Hordeum vulgare L. (2n = 14) x Triticum aestivum L. (2n = 42) and two alloplasmic lines derived from them were studied using microsatellite markers of barley and wheat. The F1 hybrids and first backcross plants BC1 contained the genetic material of both cultivated barley and the cultivars of common wheat involved in developing of these hybrid genotypes. The genomes of BC3, BC4, and alloplasmic lines contained no microsatellite markers of the cultivated barley, whereas chromosomes of each homeologous group of common wheat were identified. In chromosomes of backcross progenies BC3, BC4, and alloplasmic lines yielded by backcrosses of hybrids and various common wheat cultivars, microsatellite markers of the parental wheat cultivars were shown to undergo recombination.     

Genetic transformation of barley: limiting factors

This review summarizes main difficulties involved in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) transformation. The most commonly used procedures for genetic transformation in barley are Agrobacterium tumefaciens and particle bombardment mediated methods. While different barley cultivars are used for genetic engineering with varying sensitivity, recent improvements in regeneration and transformation techniques are described and summarized. Furthermore, some of the transformation complicating factors, in particular somaclonal variation and transgene insertion sites, are discussed in more detail.     

Endosperm-specific expression of green fluorescent protein driven by the hordein promoter is stably inherited in transgenic barley (Hordeum vulgare) plants

The expression of green fluorescent protein (GFP) and its inheritance were studied in transgenic barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) plants transformed with a synthetic green fluorescent protein gene [sgfp(S65T)] driven by either a rice actin promoter or a barley endosperm-specific d-hordein promoter. The gene encoding phosphinothricin acetyltransferase (bar), driven by the maize ubiquitin promoter and intron, was used as a selectable marker to identify transgenic tissues. Strong GFP expression driven by the rice actin promoter was observed in callus cells and in a variety of tissues of T0 plants transformed with the sgfp(S65T)-containing construct. GFP expression, driven by the rice actin promoter, was observed in 14 out of 17 independent regenerable transgenic callus lines; however, expression was gradually lost in T0 and later generation progeny of diploid lines. Stable GFP expression was observed in T2 progeny from only 6 out of the 14 (43%) independent GFP-expressing callus lines. Four of the 8 lines not expressing GFP in T2 progeny, lost GFP expression during T0 plant regeneration from calli; one lost GFP expression in the transition from the T0 to T1 generations and three lines were sterile. Similarly, expression of bar driven by the maize ubiquitin promoter was lost in T1 progeny; only 21 out of 26 (81%) independent lines were Basta-resistant. In contrast to actin-driven expression, GFP expression driven by the d-hordein promoter exhibited endosperm-specificity. All seven lines transformed with d-hordein-driven GFP (100%) expressed GFP in the T1 and T2 generations, regardless of ploidy levels, and expression segregated in a Mendelian fashion. We conclude that the sgfp(S65T) gene was successfully transformed into barley and that GFP expression driven by the d-hordein promoter was more stable in its inheritance pattern in T1 and T2 progeny than that driven by the rice actin promoter or the bar gene driven by the maize ubiquitin promoter.     

Genetic transformation of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) via infection of androgenetic pollen cultures with Agrobacterium tumefaciens

A novel genetic transformation method for barley (Hordeum vulgare L.), based on infection of androgenetic pollen cultures with Agrobacterium tumefaciens, is presented. Winter-type barley cv. 'Igri' was amenable to stable integration of transgenes mediated by A. tumefaciens strain LBA4404 harbouring a vector system that confers hypervirulence, or by the non-hypervirulent strain GV3101 with a standard binary vector. The efficacy of gene transfer was substantially influenced by pollen pre-culture time, choice of Agrobacterium strain and vector system, Agrobacterium population density, medium pH and the concentrations of acetosyringone, CaCl(2) and glutamine. After co-culture, rapid removal of viable agrobacteria was crucial for subsequent development of the pollen culture. To this end, the growth of agrobacteria was suppressed by the concerted effects of appropriate antibiotics, low pH, reduced level of glutamine and high concentrations of CaCl(2) and acetosyringone. Following infection with LBA4404 and GV3101, about 31% and 69%, respectively, of the primary transgenic (T(0)) plants carried a single copy of the sequence integrated. The use of hypervirulent A. tumefaciens and hygromycin resistance as a selectable marker resulted in 3.7 T(0) plants per donor spike. About 60% of the primary transgenic plants set seed, indicating spontaneous genome doubling. An analysis of 20 T(1) populations revealed that four progenies did not segregate for reporter gene expression. This indicates that the approach pursued enables the generation of instantly homozygous primary transgenic plants. The method established will be a valuable tool in functional genomics as well as for the biotechnological improvement of barley.     

Haplotype characterization and markers at the barley Mlo powdery mildew resistance locus as tools for marker-assisted selection.

Recessive mlo alleles of the barley Mlo gene confer resistance to almost all known isolates of the powdery mildew fungal pathogen targeting barley (Hordeum vulgare). To characterize haplotypes present in the Mlo chromosomal region of cultivated Mlo and mlo barley genotypes, we conducted a polymorphism search in 3 predicted low-copy sequence regions adjacent to the Mlo gene by examining a sample of 4 Mlo and 3 mlo cultivars. Eight single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and 1 insertion-deletion (indel) were detected, and easy to use PCR-based markers were developed for typing the SNPs. The PCR markers were used to characterize a collection of 46 Mlo and 25 mlo barley cultivars, identifying 3 distinct mlo-11 haplotypes, 1 mlo-9 haplotype, and 4 Mlo haplotypes. We summarized the haplotype and marker information obtained here and in a previous study to help breeders identify strategies for mlo marker-assisted selection. The ability of the markers to identify mlo-resistant genotypes in segregating populations was demonstrated using 2 resistance-characterized F2 populations derived by 3-way crosses.     

Marker development and characterisation of Hordeum bulbosum introgression lines: a resource for barley improvement

A set of 110 diploid putative introgression lines (ILs) containing chromatin introgressed from the undomesticated species Hordeum bulbosum L. (bulbous barley grass) into cultivated barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) has been identified using a high-copy number retrotransposon-like PCR marker, pSc119.1, derived from rye (Secale cereale L.). To evaluate these lines, 92 EST-derived markers were developed by marker sequencing across four barley cultivars and four H. bulbosum genotypes. Single nucleotide polymorphisms and insertions/deletions conserved between the two species were then used to develop a set of fully informative cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence markers or size polymorphic insertion/deletion markers. Introgressed chromatin from H. bulbosum was confirmed and genetically located in 88 of these lines using 46 of the EST-derived PCR markers. A total of 96 individual introgressions were detected with most of them (94.8%) extending to the most distal marker for each respective chromosome arm. Introgressions were detected on all chromosome arms except chromosome 3HL. Interstitial or sub-distal introgressions also occurred, with two located on chromosome 2HL and one each on 3HS, 5HL and 6HS. Twenty-two putative ILs that were positive for H. bulbosum chromatin using pSc119.1 have not had introgressions detected with these single-locus markers. When all introgressions are combined, more than 36% of the barley genetic map has now been covered with introgressed chromatin from H. bulbosum. These ILs represent a significant germplasm resource for barley improvement that can be mined for diverse traits of interest to barley breeders and researchers. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

RAPD-marking of genomes of representative Hordeum species

Random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD) was used to analyze six species, three populations, and seven regional cultivars of barley. A unique pattern of amplified DNA products was obtained for each species of the genus Hordeum. High polymorphism of barley species was revealed. Specific fragments were found in most RAPD patterns; the fragments can be used as molecular markers of corresponding species and subspecies. Several other DNA fragments were shown to serve as molecular markers of the H genome. Specific RAPD patterns were obtained for each population and each cultivar of H. vulgare sensu lato. In total, variation between the populations and between the cultivars was substantially lower than between species. Cluster analysis (UPGMA) was used to estimate genetic distances between the Hordeum species, between the H. spontaneum populations, and between regional H. vulgare cultivars and a dendrogram was constructed.     

Generation of Large Numbers of Independently Transformed Fertile Barley Plants

A rapid, efficient, and reproducible system to generate large numbers of independently transformed, self-fertile, transgenic barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) plants is described. Immature zygotic embryos, young callus, and microspore-derived embryos were bombarded with a plasmid containing bar and uidA either alone or in combination with another plasmid containing a barley yellow dwarf virus coat protein (BYDVcp) gene. A total of 91 independent bialaphos-resistant callus lines expressed functional phosphinothricin acetyltransferase, the product of bar. Integration of bar was confirmed by DNA hybridization in the 67 lines analyzed. Co-transformation frequencies of 84 and 85% were determined for the two linked genes (bar and uidA) and for two unlinked genes (bar and the BYDVcp gene), respectively. More than 500 green, fertile, transgenic plants were regenerated from 36 transformed callus lines on bialaphos-containing medium; albino plants only were regenerated from 41 lines. T0 plants in 25 lines (three plants per line) were analyzed by DNA hybridization, and all contained bar. Most contained the same integration patterns for the introduced genes (bar, uidA, and the BYDVcp gene) as their parental callus lines. Transmission of the genes to T1 progeny was confirmed in the five families analyzed by DNA hybridization. A germination test of immature T1 embryos on bialaphos-containing medium was useful for selecting individuals that were actively expressing bar, although this was not a good indicator of the presence or absence of bar. Expression of bar in some progeny plants was indicated by resistance to the herbicide Basta. The T1 plants were in soil approximately 7 months after bombardment of the immature embryo.     

Transformation of pasta wheat (Triticum turgidum L. var. durum) with high-molecular-weight glutenin subunit genes and modification of dough functionality

Particle bombardment has been used to transform three cultivars (L35, Ofanto, Svevo) and one breeding line (Latino × Lira) of durum wheat (Triticum turgidum L. var. durum). These varieties were co-transformed with plasmids containing selectable and scorable marker genes (bar and uidA) and plasmids containing one of two high-molecular-weight (HMW) glutenin subunit genes (encoding subunits 1Ax1 or 1Dx5). Ten independent transgenic lines were recovered from 1683 bombarded scutella (transformation efficiency thus 0.6%). Five lines expressed either subunit 1Dx5 or 1Ax1 at levels similar to those of endogenous subunits encoded on chromosome 1B. To identify the effects of the transgenes on the functional properties of grain, three lines showing segregation for transgene expression were used to isolate sibling T₂ plants which were null or positive for the transgene product. Analysis of these plants using a small-scale mixograph showed that expression of the additional subunits resulted in increased dough strength and stability, demonstrating that transformation can be used to modify the quality of durum wheat for bread and pasta making.     

Verification of marker–trait associations in biparental winter barley (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hordeum vulgare</Emphasis> L.) DH populations

In previous genome-wide association studies, marker–trait associations for grain yield and additional traits of agronomic importance were identified in the German winter barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) breeding gene pool. In the present study, seven doubled haploid populations segregating for the relevant alleles at the associated loci were used to get information whether these marker–trait associations can be verified in biparental populations and reliably used in applied barley breeding. The doubled haploid populations were phenotyped in field trials at two to five locations each in 1 year and genotyped by 40 trait-associated single nucleotide polymorphisms using an Illumina VeraCode GoldenGate assay. Large phenotypic variation was observed for all traits within at least one doubled haploid population. For 19 out of 58 marker–trait associations tested, the phenotypic means of both marker classes were significantly (p ≤ 0.005) different, thus confirming the association of the respective marker and the quantitative trait locus detected. For example, doubled haploid lines derived from a cross of ‘Malta’ × ‘Goldmine’ carrying different marker alleles differed by 0.41 t/ha in mean grain yield. The 19 (out of 58) marker–trait associations verified correspond to 10 (out of 27) genomic regions. Markers that were verified to be associated with a quantitative trait locus can be implemented directly in winter barley breeding for the selection of parental lines and marker-assisted pedigree selection.     

Applications of an optimized monocot expression vector in studying transient gene expression and stable transformation of barley

Protoplasts of a barley ( Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Golden Promise) suspension cell line were used for PEG-mediated gene transfer. Transient gene expression in barley protoplasts was studied using a chimeric CaMV 35S cat construct, which was only poorly expressed in barley cells. However, insertion of exon 1 and intron 1 of the maize Shrunken-1 (Sh1) gene in the 5'-untranslated leader of the construct strongly stimulated gene expression. By using the optimized chimeric cat construction the amount of CAT protein that was reached 19 hours after DNA uptake was 0.5% of total protein, which was calculated from western blot data.
As an alternative marker gene for expression studies, we also tested the firefly luciferase gene in barley protoplasts. Low level expression of chimeric CaMV 35S luciferase genes could be highly stimulated when Sh1 exon1 and intron1 were inserted in the 5'-untranslated leader of the constructs. Enhanced luciferase gene expression by Shrunken-1 intronic sequences enabled us to monitor gene integration events early after DNA uptake using a promoterless luciferase marker gene, which could only be expressed after integration behind an endogenous promoter.     

Characterising seedling and adult plant resistance to Puccinia hordei in Hordeum vulgare

A set of 113 genotypes of barley (Hordeum vulgare subsp. vulgare), along with the susceptible control genotype Gus, was tested for response to the barley leaf rust pathogen Puccinia hordei in the greenhouse (as seedlings) and field (as adult plants). The tests revealed that 68 lines carried adult plant resistance (APR), 23 lines carried uncharacterised seedling resistance (USR) and that three lines carried the seedling resistance gene Rph3. Nineteen lines lacked detectable seedling resistance and were also susceptible in the field at adult plant growth stages. The presence of marker bPb‐0837, linked to the APR gene Rph20, in 35 of the 68 lines carrying APR, suggested they carry this gene. The remaining 33 lines, which lacked the Rph20 linked marker, are likely sources of new uncharacterised APR. Pedigree analysis of the 68 lines found to carry APR revealed that 32 were related to cv. Gull and to Hordeum laevigatum; two were related to cv. Bavaria and one related to cvv. Manchuria and Taganrog, suggesting that these genotypes may be the ancestral sources of the APR carried by each.     

Molecular mapping of a gene responsible for Al-activated secretion of citrate in barley

Aluminium (Al) toxicity is an important limitation to barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) on acid soil. Al-resistant cultivars of barley detoxify Al externally by secreting citrate from the roots. To link the genetics and physiology of Al resistance in barley, genes controlling Al resistance and Al-activated secretion of citrate were mapped. An analysis of Al-induced root growth inhibition from 100 F2 seedlings derived from an Al-resistant cultivar (Murasakimochi) and an Al-sensitive cultivar (Morex) showed that a gene associated with Al resistance is localized on chromosome 4H, tightly linked to microsatellite marker Bmag353. Quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis from 59 F4 seedlings derived from an F3 plant heterozygous at the region of Al resistance on chromosome 4H showed that a gene responsible for the Al-activated secretion of citrate was also tightly linked to microsatellite marker Bmag353. This QTL explained more than 50% of the phenotypic variation in citrate secretion in this population. These results indicate that the gene controlling Al resistance on barley chromosome 4H is identical to that for Al-activated secretion of citrate and that the secretion of citrate is one of the mechanisms of Al resistance in barley. The identification of the microsatellite marker associated with both Al resistance and citrate secretion provides a valuable tool for marker-assisted selection of Al-resistant lines.     

Generation of transgenic barley lines producing human lactoferrin using mutant alpha-tubulin gene as the selective marker

The biolistic transformation method was used for genetic improvement of three commercial cultivars of barley (Oksamytoviy, Vodogray, and Hetman). The plasmid pHLFTuBA containing target gene hLF encoding human lactoferrin under the control of the rice glutein B-1 promoter GluB-1 was used for transformation. The gene encoding mutant alfa-tubulin conferring resistance to trifluralin (dinitroaniline herbicide) was used as the selective marker. The screening of different trifluralin concentrations ranging from 0.1–30 μM was used for determination of selective concentration of the agent. Two transgenic barley lines of cultivars Oksamytoviy and Hetman’s callus line were selected after 2–3 months of cultivation on 10 μM of trifluralin. To confirm stable integration of the transformed gene, the PCR analysis of leafs from regenerated plant after their adaptation on the ground was carried out. The 734 bp fragment of the target gene was amplified from both regenerated plants.     

Commercial production of aprotinin in transgenic maize seeds

The development of genetic transformation technology for plants has stimulated an interest in using transgenic plants as a novel manufacturing system for producing different classes of proteins of industrial and pharmaceutical value. In this regard, we report the generation and characterization of transgenic maize lines producing recombinant aprotinin. The transgenic aprotinin lines recovered were transformed with the aprotinin gene using the bar gene as a selectable marker. The bar and aprotinin genes were introduced into immature maize embryos via particle bombardment. Aprotinin gene expression was driven by the maize ubiquitin promoter and protein accumulation was targeted to the extracellular matrix. One line that showed a high level of aprotinin expression was characterized in detail. The protein accumulates primarily in the embryo of the seed. Southern blot analysis showed that the line had at least 20 copies of the bar and aprotinin genes. Further genetic analysis revealed that numerous plants derived from this transgenic line had a large range of levels of expression of the aprotinin gene (0–0.069%) of water-soluble protein in T₂ seeds. One plant lineage that showed stable expression after 4 selfing generations was recovered from the parental transgenic line. This line showed an accumulation of the protein in seeds that was comparable to the best T₂ lines, and the recombinant aprotinin could be effectively recovered and purified from seeds. Biochemical analysis of the purified aprotinin from seeds revealed that the recombinant aprotinin had the same molecular weight, N-terminal amino acid sequence, isoelectric point, and trypsin inhibition activity as native aprotinin. The demonstration that the recombinant aprotinin protein purified from transgenic maize seeds has biochemical and functional properties identical to its native counterpart provides a proof-of-concept example for producing new generation products for the pharmaceutical industry.     

Salinity stress and cytoplasmic factors. A comparison of cell permeability and lipid partiality in salt sensitive and salt resistant cultivars and lines of Triticum aestivum and Hordeum vulgare

Salinity effects on the cell membranes of four lines of wheat ( Triticum aestivum L.). and two cultivars of barley ( Hordeum vulgare L.), differing in salt resistance were investigated. Plants were grown for 10 days in 1/4-strength Hoagland solution and then for 5 more days in 1/4-strength Hoagland with and without NaCl (100 m M ) or (for Hordeum only) polyethylene glycol (PEG). Permeability to three non-electrolytes (urea, methylurea and ethylurea) of subepidermal cells of leaf sheaths ( Triticum ) and coleoptiles ( Hordeum ) was determined and membrane partiality calculated, a parameter which numerically indicates the degree of lipophilicity of a membrane. Non-electrolyte permeability significantly increased and membrane partiality decreased in the salt sensitive cultivars or lines under salt stress. Neither parameter changed significantly in the salt resistant lines and cultivar in a saline environment. Osmotic stress in Hordeum by PEG 10000 had no significant effect on permeability and thus membrane partiality neither in sensitive nor in resistant cultivars.
The osmotic component of salinity stress did not seem to be a major factor causing injury, rather ion toxicity may be a cause of cell damage. The results indicate differences in the membrane between salt sensitive and salt resistant genotypes. Salt resistance seems to be controlled by genetic factors independent of external salinity levels.