Collagen fibrillogenesis in vitro: comparison of types I, II, and III

The self-assembly of pepsin-extracted types I, II, and III collagen was studied to determine how differences in the triple-helical structure between collagen types influence in vitro collagen fibrillogenesis. Collagen types I, II, and III were extracted and purified from bovine sources, and were studied in solution by laser light scattering, pH titration, and determination of turbidity-time curves. The molecular weights were between 280,000 and 289,000, while the translational diffusion coefficients and particle scattering factors at 175.5 degrees were consistent with those expected for single collagen molecules. Titration of collagen types I, II, and III between pH 7.0 and 2.0 using HCl indicated that type I collagen had the most titratable carboxylic groups with type II and III having significantly fewer titratable groups. The self-assembly of these collagens was studied in vitro in phosphate-buffered saline. The time course and extent of fibril formation were studied turbidimetrically, and were found to be dependent on collagen type. Apparent rate constants were determined for both the lag and growth phases of fibril formation. The rates of both phases were greater for type III than for type I collagen, with the rates for type II collagen being intermediate. The extent of fibril formation was based on the turbidity per unit concentration (specific turbidity) extrapolated to zero concentration (intrinsic turbidity), which was found to be greater for type I than for type III collagen. Type II collagen had the smallest intrinsic turbidity. The specific and intrinsic turbidity values were consistent with the relative fibril diameters seen in dermis and cartilage by transmission electron microscopy. These observations indicate that helix-helix interactions are important in the regulation of the rate and extent of collagen fibrillogenesis and may be involved in the determination of fibril structure.     

Ultrastructural immunolocalization of cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) in relation to collagen fibrils in the equine tendon.

The structure and organisation of the extracellular matrix, and in particular the axial alignment of type I collagen fibrils, are essential for the tensile strength of tendons. The resident tenocytes synthesize and maintain the composition of the extracellular matrix, which changes with age and maturation. Other components of the extracellular matrix include less abundant collagen types II, III, V, VI, XII, proteoglycans and glycoproteins. Cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) is an abundant non-collagenous pentameric glycoprotein in the tendon, which can bind to collagen types I and II. The function of COMP in the tendon is not clear, but it may act as a catalyst in fibrillogenesis. Its concentration changes with age, maturation and load. The present study delineates the ultrastructural distribution of COMP and its correlation to collagen fibril thickness in different compartments in two flexor tendons from horses of different ages (foetus, 8 months, 3 years, 12 years). The immunolabeling for COMP was higher in the superficial digital flexor tendon compared with the deep digital flexor tendon and it increased with the age of the animal, with the highest concentration in the 3-year-olds. Fibril diameter differed between age groups and a more homogenous fibril population was found in the fetal tendons. A positive correlation between high COMP immunolabeling and the percentage of small fibrils (<60 nm) were present in the SDFT. COMP immunolabeling was enriched at the gap region of the collagen fibril. In situ hybridization revealed the strongest expression in tendons from the 3-year-old horses whereas there was no expression in foetal tendon.     

Collagen fibrillogenesis: fibronectin, integrins, and minor collagens as organizers and nucleators

Collagens are triple helical proteins that occur in the extracellular matrix (ECM) and at the cell-ECM interface. There are more than 30 collagens and collagen-related proteins but the most abundant are collagens I and II that exist as D-periodic (where D=67nm) fibrils. The fibrils are of broad biomedical importance and have central roles in embryogenesis, arthritis, tissue repair, fibrosis, tumor invasion, and cardiovascular disease. Collagens I and II spontaneously form fibrils in vitro, which shows that collagen fibrillogenesis is a selfassembly process. However, the situation in vivo is not that simple; collagen I-containing fibrils do not form in the absence of fibronectin, fibronectin-binding and collagen-binding integrins, and collagen V. Likewise, the thin collagen II-containing fibrils in cartilage do not form in the absence of collagen XI. Thus, in vivo, cellular mechanisms are in place to control what is otherwise a protein self-assembly process. This review puts forward a working hypothesis for how fibronectin and integrins (the organizers) determine the site of fibril assembly, and collagens V and XI (the nucleators) initiate collagen fibrillogenesis.     

The mammalian chitinase-like lectin, YKL-40, binds specifically to type I collagen and modulates the rate of type I collagen fibril formation

YKL-40 is expressed in arthritic cartilage and produced in large amounts by cultured chondrocytes, but its exact role is unclear, and the identities of its physiological ligands remain unknown. Purification of YKL-40 from resorbing bovine nasal cartilage and chondrocyte monolayers demonstrated the existence of three isoforms, a major and minor form from resorbing cartilage and a third species from chondrocytes. Affinity chromatography experiments with purified YKL-40 demonstrated specific binding of all three forms to collagen types I, II, and III, thus identifying collagens as potential YKL-40 ligands. Binding to immobilized type I collagen was inhibited by soluble native ligand, but not heat-denatured ligand, confirming a specific interaction. Binding of the chondrocyte-derived species to type I collagen was also demonstrated by surface plasmon resonance analysis, and the dissociation rate constant was calculated (3.42 x 10(-3) to 4.50 x 10(-3) s(-1)). The chondrocyte-derived species was found to prevent collagenolytic cleavage of type I collagen and to stimulate the rate of type I collagen fibril formation in a concentration-dependent manner. By contrast, the cartilage major form had an inhibitory effect on type I collagen fibrillogenesis. Digestion with N-glycosidase F, endoglycosidase H and lectin blotting did not reveal any difference in the carbohydrate component of these two YKL-40 species, indicating that this does not account for the opposing effects on fibril formation rate.     

Collagen XI nucleates self-assembly and limits lateral growth of cartilage fibrils

Fibrils of embryonic cartilage are heterotypic alloys formed by collagens II, IX, and XI and have a uniform diameter of approximately 20 nm. The molecular basis of this lateral growth control is poorly understood. Collagen II subjected to fibril formation in vitro produced short and tapered tactoids with strong D-periodic banding. The maximal width of these tactoids varied over a broad range. By contrast, authentic mixtures of collagens II, IX, and XI yielded long and weakly banded fibrils, which, strikingly, had a uniform width of about 20 nm. The same was true for mixtures of collagens II and XI lacking collagen IX as long as the molar excess of collagen II was less than 8-fold. At higher ratios, the proteins assembled into tactoids coexisting with cartilage-like fibrils. Therefore, diameter control is an inherent property of appropriate mixtures of collagens II and XI. Collagen IX is not essential for this feature but strongly increases the efficiency of fibril formation. Therefore, this protein may be an important stabilizing factor of cartilage fibrils.     

Collagen fibrillogenesis in tendon development: current models and regulation of fibril assembly

Tendons are collagen-based fibrous tissues that connect and transmit forces from muscle to bone. These tissues, which are high in collagen type I content, have been studied extensively to understand collagen fibrillogenesis. Although the mechanisms have not been fully elucidated, our understanding has continued to progress. Here, we review two prevailing models of collagen fibrillogenesis and discuss the regulation of the process by candidate cellular and extracellular matrix molecules. Although numerous molecules have been implicated in the regulation of collagen fibrillogenesis, we focus on those that have been suggested to be particularly relevant to collagen type I fibril formation during tendon development, including members of the collagen and small leucine-rich proteoglycan families, as well as other molecules, including scleraxis, cartilage oligomeric matrix protein, and cytoskeletal proteins.     

Macromolecular specificity of collagen fibrillogenesis: fibrils of collagens I and XI contain a heterotypic alloyed core and a collagen I sheath

Suprastructures of the extracellular matrix, such as banded collagen fibrils, microfibrils, filaments, or networks, are composites comprising more than one type of macromolecule. The suprastructural diversity reflects tissue-specific requirements and is achieved by formation of macromolecular composites that often share their main molecular components alloyed with minor components. Both, the mechanisms of formation and the final macromolecular organizations depend on the identity of the components and their quantitative contribution. Collagen I is the predominant matrix constituent in many tissues and aggregates with other collagens and/or fibril-associated macromolecules into distinct types of banded fibrils. Here, we studied co-assembly of collagens I and XI, which co-exist in fibrils of several normal and pathologically altered tissues, including fibrous cartilage and bone, or osteoarthritic joints. Immediately upon initiation of fibrillogenesis, the proteins co-assembled into alloy-like stubby aggregates that represented efficient nucleation sites for the formation of composite fibrils. Propagation of fibrillogenesis occurred by exclusive accretion of collagen I to yield composite fibrils of highly variable diameters. Therefore, collagen I/XI fibrils strikingly differed from the homogeneous fibrillar alloy generated by collagens II and XI, although the constituent polypeptides of collagens I and II are highly homologous. Thus, the mode of aggregation of collagens into vastly diverse fibrillar composites is finely tuned by subtle differences in molecular structures through formation of macromolecular alloys.     

Position of single amino acid substitutions in the collagen triple helix determines their effect on structure of collagen fibrils

Collagen II fibrils are a critical structural component of the extracellular matrix of cartilage providing the tissue with its unique biomechanical properties. The self-assembly of collagen molecules into fibrils is a spontaneous process that depends on site-specific binding between specific domains belonging to interacting molecules. These interactions can be altered by mutations in the COL2A1 gene found in patients with a variety of heritable cartilage disorders known as chondrodysplasias. Employing recombinant procollagen II, we studied the effects of R75C or R789C mutations on fibril formation. We determined that both R75C and R789C mutants were incorporated into collagen assemblies. The effects of the R75C and R789C substitutions on fibril formation differed significantly. The R75C substitution located in the thermolabile region of collagen II had no major effect on the fibril formation process or the morphology of fibrils. In contrast, the R789C substitution located in the thermostable region of collagen II caused profound changes in the morphology of collagen assemblies. These results provide a basis for identifying pathways leading from single amino acid substitutions in collagen II to changes in the structure of individual fibrils and in the organization of collagenous matrices.     

Fibril-forming collagens in lamprey

Five types of collagen with triple-helical regions approximately 300 nm in length were found in lamprey tissues which show characteristic D-periodic collagen fibrils. These collagens are members of the fibril forming family of this primitive vertebrate. Lamprey collagens were characterized with respect to solubility, mobility on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, carboxylmethyl-cellulose chromatography, peptide digestion patterns, composition, susceptibility to vertebrate collagenase, thermal stability, and segment long spacing-banding pattern. Comparison with fibril-forming collagens in higher vertebrates (types I, II, III, V, and XI) identified three lamprey collagens as types II, V, and XI. Both lamprey dermis and major body wall collagens had properties similar to type I but not the typical heterotrimer composition. Dermis molecules had only alpha 1(I)-like chains, while body wall molecules had alpha 2(I)-like chains combined with chains resembling lamprey type II. Neither collagen exhibited the interchain disulfide linkages or solubility properties of type III. The conservation of fibril organization in type II/type XI tissues in contrast to the major developments in type I and type III tissues after the divergence of lamprey and higher vertebrates is consistent with these results. The presence of type II and type I-like molecules as major collagens and types V and XI as minor collagens in the lamprey, and the differential susceptibility of these molecules to vertebrate collagenase is analogous to the findings in higher vertebrates.     

Collagen XII and XIV, new partners of cartilage oligomeric matrix protein in the skin extracellular matrix suprastructure

The tensile and scaffolding properties of skin rely on the complex extracellular matrix (ECM) that surrounds cells, vasculature, nerves, and adnexus structures and supports the epidermis. In the skin, collagen I fibrils are the major structural component of the dermal ECM, decorated by proteoglycans and by fibril-associated collagens with interrupted triple helices such as collagens XII and XIV. Here we show that the cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP), an abundant component of cartilage ECM, is expressed in healthy human skin. COMP expression is detected in the dermal compartment of skin and in cultured fibroblasts, whereas epidermis and HaCaT cells are negative. In addition to binding collagen I, COMP binds to collagens XII and XIV via their C-terminal collagenous domains. All three proteins codistribute in a characteristic narrow zone in the superficial papillary dermis of healthy human skin. Ultrastructural analysis by immunogold labeling confirmed colocalization and further revealed the presence of COMP along with collagens XII and XIV in anchoring plaques. On the basis of these observations, we postulate that COMP functions as an adapter protein in human skin, similar to its function in cartilage ECM, by organizing collagen I fibrils into a suprastructure, mainly in the vicinity of anchoring plaques that stabilize the cohesion between the upper dermis and the basement membrane zone.     

Proteomic analysis of Col11a1-associated protein complexes

Cartilage plays an essential role during skeletal development within the growth plate and in articular joint function. Interactions between the collagen fibrils and other extracellular matrix molecules maintain structural integrity of cartilage, orchestrate complex dynamic events during embryonic development, and help to regulate fibrillogenesis. To increase our understanding of these events, affinity chromatography and liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry were used to identify proteins that interact with the collagen fibril surface via the amino terminal domain of collagen α1(XI) a protein domain that is displayed at the surface of heterotypic collagen fibrils of cartilage. Proteins extracted from fetal bovine cartilage using homogenization in high ionic strength buffer were selected based on affinity for the amino terminal noncollagenous domain of collagen α1(XI). MS was used to determine the amino acid sequence of tryptic fragments for protein identification. Extracellular matrix molecules and cellular proteins that were identified as interacting with the amino terminal domain of collagen α1(XI) directly or indirectly, included proteoglycans, collagens, and matricellular molecules, some of which also play a role in fibrillogenesis, while others are known to function in the maintenance of tissue integrity. Characterization of these molecular interactions will provide a more thorough understanding of how the extracellular matrix molecules of cartilage interact and what role collagen XI plays in the process of fibrillogenesis and maintenance of tissue integrity. Such information will aid tissue engineering and cartilage regeneration efforts to treat cartilage tissue damage and degeneration.     

COMP mutations, chondrocyte function and cartilage matrix

Cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) is a large extracellular pentameric glycoprotein found in the territorial matrix surrounding chondrocytes. More than 60 unique COMP mutations have been identified as causing two skeletal dysplasias, pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) and multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (MED/EDM1). Recent studies demonstrate that calcium-binding and calcium induced protein folding differ between wild type and mutant COMP proteins and abnormal processing of the mutant COMP protein causes the characteristic large lamellar appearing rough endoplasimic reticulum (rER) cisternae phenotype observed in PSACH and EDMI growth plate chondrocytes. To understand the cellular events leading to this intracellular phenotype, PSACH chondrocytes with a G427E, D469del and D511Y mutations were grown in 3-D culture to produce cartilage nodules. Each nodule was assessed for the appearance and accumulation of cartilage-specific proteins within the rER and for matrix protein synthesis. All three COMP mutations were associated with accumulation of COMP in the rER cisternae by 4 weeks in culture, and by 8 weeks the majority of chondrocytes had the characteristic cellular phenotype. Mutations in COMP also affect the secretion of type IX collagen and matrilin-3 (MATN3) but not the secretion of aggrecan and type II collagen. COMP, type IX collagen and MATN3 were dramatically reduced in the PSACH matrices, and the distribution of these proteins in the matrix was diffuse. Ultrastructural analysis shows that the type II collagen present in the PSACH matrix does not form organized fibril bundles and, overall, the matrix is disorganized. The combined absence of COMP, type IX collagen and MATN3 causes dramatic changes in the matrix and suggests that these proteins play important roles in matrix assembly.     

Interactions of the neural cell adhesion molecule and the myelin- associated glycoprotein with collagen type I: involvement in fibrillogenesis

To gain insights into the functional role of the molecular association between neural adhesion molecules and extracellular matrix constituents, soluble forms of the myelin-associated glycoprotein (MAG) and the neural cell adhesion molecule (N-CAM), representing most of the extracellular domains of the molecules, were investigated in their ability to modify fibrillogenesis of collagen type I. MAG and N-CAM retarded the rate of fibril formation, as measured by changes in turbidity, and increased the diameter of the fibrils formed, but did not change the banding pattern when compared to collagen type I in the absence of adhesion molecules. Scatchard plot analysis of the binding of MAG and N-CAM to the fibril-forming collagen types I, II, III, and V suggest one binding site for N-CAM and two binding sites for MAG. Binding of MAG, but not of N-CAM, to collagen type I was decreased during fibril formation, probably due to a reduced accessibility of one binding site for MAG during fibrillogenesis. These results indicate that the neural adhesion molecules can influence the configuration of extracellular matrix constituents, thus, implicating them in the modulation of cell-substrate interactions.     

Role of TSP-5/COMP in pseudoachondroplasia

Pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) is a well-characterized dwarfing condition associated with disproportionate short stature, abnormal joints and osteoarthritis requiring joint replacement. PSACH is caused by mutations in cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP). COMP, the fifth member of the thrombospondin (TSP) gene family, is a pentameric protein found primarily in the extracellular matrix of musculoskeletal tissues. Functional studies have shown that COMP binds types II and IX collagens but the role of COMP in the extracellular matrix remains to be defined. Mutations in COMP interfere with calcium-binding and protein conformation. PSACH growth plate and growth plate chondrocytes studies indicate that COMP mutations have a dominant negative effect with both COMP and type IX collagen being retained in large rER cisternae. This massive retention causes impaired chondrocyte function with little COMP secreted into the matrix and premature loss of chondrocytes. Deficiency of linear growth results from loss of chondrocytes from the growth plate. Secondarily, the matrix contains minimal COMP, which may be normal and/or mutant, and little type IX collagen. This deficiency results in abnormal joints that are easily eroded and cause painful osteoarthritis. Unlike other misfolded proteins that are targeted for degradation, much of the retained COMP escapes degradation, compromises cell function, and causes cell death. Gene therapy will need to target the reduction of COMP in order to restore normal chondrocyte function and longevity.     

Role of decorin on in vitro fibrillogenesis of type I collagen

Tendon and corneal decorins are differently iduronated dermatan sulphate/proteoglycan (DS/PG) and the biochemical parameter that differentiates type I collagens is the hydroxylysine glycoside content. We have examined the effect of tendon and corneal decorins on the individual phases (tlag, dA/dt) of differently glycosylated type I collagens fibril formation, at molar ratios PG:collagen monomer ranging from 0.15 : 1 to 0.45 : 1. The results obtained indicate that decorins exert a different effect on the individual phases of fibril formation, correlated to the degree of glycosylation of collagen: at the same PG:collagen ratio the fibril formation of highly glycosylated corneal collagen is more efficiently inhibited than that of the poorly glycosylated one (tendon). Moreover tendon and corneal decorins exert a higher control on the fibrillogenesis of homologous collagen with respect to the heterologous one. These data suggest a possible tissue-specificity of the interaction decorin/type I collagen correlated to the structure of the PG and collagen present in extracellular matrices. This revised version was published online in November 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The C-terminal extrahelical peptide of type I collagen and its role in fibrillogenesis in vitro: effects of ethylurea

Ethylurea was used to weaken hydrophobic interactions during collagen fibrillogenesis in vitro. Intact and enzyme-digested type I collagen was studied. In all preparations, ethylurea decreased the extent and rate of fibril formation, inhibition being greatest in the enzyme-digested collagens. With intact collagen (and probably also with carboxypeptidasedigested collagen), there was no evidence the ethylurea altered the mechanism of fibril growth; in pepsin-digested collagen, however, the growth mechanism was altered by ethylurea, possibly reflecting a conformational change of the “hydrophobic cluster” in the C-terminal peptide. Such a structural change could occur in a hydrophobic environment once the distal portion of the C-terminal peptide (presumed to be essential for its structural stability) is removed by pepsin. The results further emphasize the importance of hydrophobic interactions in collagen fibril nucleation and growth in vitro.     

Cartilage contains mixed fibrils of collagen types II, IX, and XI

The distribution of collagen XI in fibril fragments from 17-d chick embryo sternal cartilage was determined by immunoelectron microscopy using specific polyclonal antibodies. The protein was distributed throughout the fibril fragments but was antigenically masked due to the tight packing of collagen molecules and could be identified only at sites where the fibril structure was partially disrupted. Collagens II and IX were also distributed uniformly along fibrils but, in contrast to collagen XI, were accessible to the antibodies in intact fibrils. Therefore, cartilage fibrils are heterotypically assembled from collagens II, IX, and XI. This implies that collagen XI is an integral component of the cartilage fibrillar network and homogeneously distributed throughout the tissue. This was confirmed by immunofluorescence.     

Candidate cell and matrix interaction domains on the collagen fibril, the predominant protein of vertebrates

Type I collagen, the predominant protein of vertebrates, polymerizes with type III and V collagens and non-collagenous molecules into large cable-like fibrils, yet how the fibril interacts with cells and other binding partners remains poorly understood. To help reveal insights into the collagen structure-function relationship, a data base was assembled including hundreds of type I collagen ligand binding sites and mutations on a two-dimensional model of the fibril. Visual examination of the distribution of functional sites, and statistical analysis of mutation distributions on the fibril suggest it is organized into two domains. The "cell interaction domain" is proposed to regulate dynamic aspects of collagen biology, including integrin-mediated cell interactions and fibril remodeling. The "matrix interaction domain" may assume a structural role, mediating collagen cross-linking, proteoglycan interactions, and tissue mineralization. Molecular modeling was used to superimpose the positions of functional sites and mutations from the two-dimensional fibril map onto a three-dimensional x-ray diffraction structure of the collagen microfibril in situ, indicating the existence of domains in the native fibril. Sequence searches revealed that major fibril domain elements are conserved in type I collagens through evolution and in the type II/XI collagen fibril predominant in cartilage. Moreover, the fibril domain model provides potential insights into the genotype-phenotype relationship for several classes of human connective tissue diseases, mechanisms of integrin clustering by fibrils, the polarity of fibril assembly, heterotypic fibril function, and connective tissue pathology in diabetes and aging.