A closer look at prion strains

Prions are infectious proteins that are responsible for transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) and consist primarily of scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc), a pathogenic isoform of the host-encoded cellular prion protein (PrP^C). The absence of nucleic acids as essential components of the infectious prions is the most striking feature associated to these diseases. Additionally, different prion strains have been isolated from animal diseases despite the lack of DNA or RNA molecules. Mounting evidence suggests that prion-strain-specific features segregate with different PrP^Sc conformational and aggregation states.

Strains are of practical relevance in prion diseases as they can drastically differ in many aspects, such as incubation period, PrP^Sc biochemical profile (e.g., electrophoretic mobility and glycoform ratio) and distribution of brain lesions. Importantly, such different features are maintained after inoculation of a prion strain into genetically identical hosts and are relatively stable across serial passages.

This review focuses on the characterization of prion strains and on the wide range of important implications that the study of prion strains involves.     

Different antigenicities of the N‐terminal region of cellular and scrapie prion proteins

Limited information is available about conformational differences between the abnormal isoform of prion protein (PrP^Sc) and cellular prion protein (PrP^C) under native conditions. To clarify conformational differences between these two isoforms, PrP‐deficient mice were immunized with brain homogenates of normal and scrapie‐infected animals. All mice generated anti‐PrP antibodies. Peptide array analysis of these serum samples revealed a distinctive epitope of PrP^Sc consisting of QGSPGGN (PrP41–47) at the N‐terminus. This study demonstrated a conformational dissimilarity at the N‐terminus between PrP^Sc and PrP^C, a finding that may provide novel information about conformational features of PrP^Sc.     

Structural conservation of prion strain specificities in recombinant prion protein fibrils in real-time quaking-induced conversion

ABSTRACT

A major unsolved issue of prion biology is the existence of multiple strains with distinct phenotypes and this strain phenomenon is postulated to be associated with the conformational diversity of the abnormal prion protein (PrP^Sc). Real-time quaking-induced conversion (RT-QUIC) assay that uses Escherichia coli-derived recombinant prion protein (rPrP) for the sensitive detection of PrP^Sc results in the formation of rPrP-fibrils seeded with various strains. We demonstrated that there are differences in the secondary structures, especially in the β-sheets, and conformational stability between 2 rPrP-fibrils seeded with either Chandler or 22L strains in the first round of RT-QUIC. In particular, the differences in conformational properties of these 2 rPrP-fibrils were common to those of the original PrP^Sc. However, the strain specificities of rPrP-fibrils seen in the first round were lost in subsequent rounds. Instead, our findings suggest that nonspecific fibrils became the major species, probable owing to their selective growth advantage in the RT-QUIC. This study shows that at least some strain-specific conformational properties of the original PrP^Sc can be transmitted to rPrP-fibrils in vitro, but further conservation appears to require unknown cofactors or environmental conditions or both.     

Infectivity-associated PrPSc and disease duration-associated PrPSc of mouse BSE prions

ABSTRACT

Disease-related prion protein (PrP^Sc), which is a structural isoform of the host-encoded cellular prion protein, is thought to be a causative agent of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. However, the specific role of PrP^Sc in prion pathogenesis and its relationship to infectivity remain controversial. A time-course study of prion-affected mice was conducted, which showed that the prion infectivity was not simply proportional to the amount of PrP^Sc in the brain. Centrifugation (20,000 ×g) of the brain homogenate showed that most of the PrP^Sc was precipitated into the pellet, and the supernatant contained only a slight amount of PrP^Sc. Interestingly, mice inoculated with the obtained supernatant showed incubation periods that were approximately 15 d longer than those of mice inoculated with the crude homogenate even though both inocula contained almost the same infectivity. Our results suggest that a small population of fine PrP^Sc may be responsible for prion infectivity and that large, aggregated PrP^Sc may contribute to determining prion disease duration.     

Implications of prion adaptation and evolution paradigm for human neurodegenerative diseases

There is a growing body of evidence indicating that number of human neurodegenerative diseases, including Alzheimer disease, Parkinson disease, fronto-temporal dementias, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, propagate in the brain via prion-like intercellular induction of protein misfolding. Prions cause lethal neurodegenerative diseases in humans, the most prevalent being sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD); they self-replicate and spread by converting the cellular form of prion protein (PrP^C) to a misfolded pathogenic conformer (PrP^Sc). The extensive phenotypic heterogeneity of human prion diseases is determined by polymorphisms in the prion protein gene, and by prion strain-specific conformation of PrP^Sc. Remarkably, even though informative nucleic acid is absent, prions may undergo rapid adaptation and evolution in cloned cells and upon crossing the species barrier. In the course of our investigation of this process, we isolated distinct populations of PrP^Sc particles that frequently co-exist in sCJD. The human prion particles replicate independently and undergo competitive selection of those with lower initial conformational stability. Exposed to mutant substrate, the winning PrP^Sc conformers are subject to further evolution by natural selection of the subpopulation with the highest replication rate due to the lowest stability. Thus, the evolution and adaptation of human prions is enabled by a dynamic collection of distinct populations of particles, whose evolution is governed by the selection of progressively less stable, faster replicating PrP^Sc conformers. This fundamental biological mechanism may explain the drug resistance that some prions gained after exposure to compounds targeting PrP^Sc. Whether the phenotypic heterogeneity of other neurodegenerative diseases caused by protein misfolding is determined by the spectrum of misfolded conformers (strains) remains to be established. However, the prospect that these conformers may evolve and adapt by a prion-like mechanism calls for the reevaluation of therapeutic strategies that target aggregates of misfolded proteins, and argues for new therapeutic approaches that will focus on prior pathogenetic steps.     

Prion formation,but not clearance,is supported by protein misfolding cyclic amplification

Prion diseases are fatal transmissible neurodegenerative disorders that affect animals including humans. The kinetics of prion infectivity and PrP^Sc accumulation can differ between prion strains and within a single strain in different tissues. The net accumulation of PrP^Sc in animals is controlled by the relationship between the rate of PrP^Sc formation and clearance. Protein misfolding cyclic amplification (PMCA) is a powerful technique that faithfully recapitulates PrP^Sc formation and prion infectivity in a cell-free system. PMCA has been used as a surrogate for animal bioassay and can model species barriers, host range, strain co-factors and strain interference. In this study we investigated if degradation of PrP^Sc and/or prion infectivity occurs during PMCA. To accomplish this we performed PMCA under conditions that do not support PrP^Sc formation and did not observe either a reduction in PrP^Sc abundance or an extension of prion incubation period, compared to untreated control samples. These results indicate that prion clearance does not occur during PMCA. These data have significant implications for the interpretation of PMCA based experiments such as prion amplification rate, adaptation to new species and strain interference where production and clearance of prions can affect the outcome.     

Prion protein—Semisynthetic prion protein (PrP) variants with posttranslational modifications

Deciphering the pathophysiologic events in prion diseases is challenging, and the role of posttranslational modifications (PTMs) such as glypidation and glycosylation remains elusive due to the lack of homogeneous protein preparations. So far, experimental studies have been limited in directly analyzing the earliest events of the conformational change of cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc) that further propagates PrP^C misfolding and aggregation at the cellular membrane, the initial site of prion infection, and PrP misfolding, by a lack of suitably modified PrP variants. PTMs of PrP, especially attachment of the glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor, have been shown to be crucially involved in the PrP^Sc formation. To this end, semisynthesis offers a unique possibility to understand PrP behavior invitro and invivo as it provides access to defined site‐selectively modified PrP variants. This approach relies on the production and chemoselective linkage of peptide segments, amenable to chemical modifications, with recombinantly produced protein segments. In this article, advances in understanding PrP conversion using semisynthesis as a tool to obtain homogeneous posttranslationally modified PrP will be discussed.     

Conformational Stability of Mammalian Prion Protein Amyloid Fibrils Is Dictated by a Packing Polymorphism within the Core Region

Mammalian prion strains are believed to arise from the propagation of distinct conformations of the misfolded prion protein PrP^Sc. One key operational parameter used to define differences between strains has been conformational stability of PrP^Sc as defined by resistance to thermal and/or chemical denaturation. However, the structural basis of these stability differences is unknown. To bridge this gap, we have generated two strains of recombinant human prion protein amyloid fibrils that show dramatic differences in conformational stability and have characterized them by a number of biophysical methods. Backbone amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange experiments revealed that, in sharp contrast to previously studied strains of infectious amyloid formed from the yeast prion protein Sup35, differences in β-sheet core size do not underlie differences in conformational stability between strains of mammalian prion protein amyloid. Instead, these stability differences appear to be dictated by distinct packing arrangements (i.e. steric zipper interfaces) within the amyloid core, as indicated by distinct x-ray fiber diffraction patterns and large strain-dependent differences in hydrogen/deuterium exchange kinetics for histidine side chains within the core region. Although this study was limited to synthetic prion protein amyloid fibrils, a similar structural basis for strain-dependent conformational stability may apply to brain-derived PrP^Sc, especially because large strain-specific differences in PrP^Sc stability are often observed despite a similar size of the PrP^Sc core region.     

Pressure-assisted dissociation and degradation of “proteinase K-resistant” fibrils prepared by seeding with scrapie-infected hamster prion protein

The crucial step for the fatal neurodegenerative prion diseases involves the conversion of a normal cellular protein, PrP^C, into a fibrous pathogenic form, PrP^Sc, which has an unusual stability against heat and resistance against proteinase K digestion. A successful challenge to reverse the reaction from PrP^Sc into PrP^C is considered valuable, as it would give a key to dissolving the complex molecular events into thermodynamic and kinetic analyses and may also provide a means to prevent the formation of PrP^Sc from PrP^C eventually in vivo. Here we show that, by applying pressures at kbar range, the “proteinase K-resistant” fibrils (rHaPrP^res) prepared from hamster prion protein (rHaPrP [23–231]) by seeding with brain homogenate of scrapie-infected hamster, becomes easily digestible. The result is consistent with the notion that rHaPrP^res fibrils are dissociated into rHaPrP monomers under pressure and that the formation of PrP^Sc from PrP^C is thermodynamically controlled. Moreover, the efficient degradation of prion fibrils under pressure provides a novel means of eliminating infectious PrP^Sc from various systems of pathogenic concern.     

蛋白质感染颗粒与二价铜离子

蛋白质感染颗粒（PrP）的错误折叠被认为是引起一些神经退化性疾病的主因,但其正常构象（PrP^C）的功能却一直不为人所知．近年来研究发现,在正常细胞中,尤其是脑细胞中,细胞膜PrP^C可通过内吞作用进入细胞质而将Cu²⁺载运至SOD1,从而参与调节SOD1 的活性及细胞铜代谢．另有研究表明,Cu²⁺对于PrP^Sc（错误构象）的蛋白水解酶K抗性的恢复及不同“病株”的形成也有很重要的作用.     

Protein Misfolding Cyclic Amplification of Prions

Prions are infectious agents that cause the inevitably fatal transmissible spongiform encephalopathy (TSE) in animals and humans^9,18. The prion protein has two distinct isoforms, the non-infectious host-encoded protein (PrP^C) and the infectious protein (PrP^Sc), an abnormally-folded isoform of PrP^{C 8}.One of the challenges of working with prion agents is the long incubation period prior to the development of clinical signs following host inoculation¹³. This traditionally mandated long and expensive animal bioassay studies. Furthermore, the biochemical and biophysical properties of PrP^Sc are poorly characterized due to their unusual conformation and aggregation states.PrP^Sc can seed the conversion of PrP^C to PrP^Scin vitro¹⁴. PMCA is an in vitro technique that takes advantage of this ability using sonication and incubation cycles to produce large amounts of PrP^Sc, at an accelerated rate, from a system containing excess amounts of PrP^C and minute amounts of the PrP^Sc seed¹⁹. This technique has proven to effectively recapitulate the species and strain specificity of PrP^Sc conversion from PrP^C, to emulate prion strain interference, and to amplify very low levels of PrP^Sc from infected tissues, fluids, and environmental samples^6,7,16,23 .This paper details the PMCA protocol, including recommendations for minimizing contamination, generating consistent results, and quantifying those results. We also discuss several PMCA applications, including generation and characterization of infectious prion strains, prion strain interference, and the detection of prions in the environment.     

Propagation of RML Prions in Mice Expressing PrP Devoid of GPI Anchor Leads to Formation of a Novel, Stable Prion Strain

PrP^C, a host protein which in prion-infected animals is converted to PrP^Sc, is linked to the cell membrane by a GPI anchor. Mice expressing PrP^C without GPI anchor (tgGPI^- mice), are susceptible to prion infection but accumulate anchorless PrP^Sc extra-, rather than intracellularly. We investigated whether tgGPI⁻ mice could faithfully propagate prion strains despite the deviant structure and location of anchorless PrP^Sc. We found that RML and ME7, but not 22L prions propagated in tgGPI⁻ brain developed novel cell tropisms, as determined by the Cell Panel Assay (CPA). Surprisingly, the levels of proteinase K-resistant PrP^Sc (PrP^res) in RML- or ME7-infected tgGPI⁻ brain were 25–50 times higher than in wild-type brain. When returned to wild-type brain, ME7 prions recovered their original properties, however RML prions had given rise to a novel prion strain, designated SFL, which remained unchanged even after three passages in wild-type mice. Because both RML PrP^Sc and SFL PrP^Sc are stably propagated in wild-type mice we propose that the two conformations are separated by a high activation energy barrier which is abrogated in tgGPI⁻ mice.     

A systems approach to prion disease

Prions cause transmissible neurodegenerative diseases and replicate by conformational conversion of normal benign forms of prion protein (PrP^C) to disease‐causing PrP^Sc isoforms. A systems approach to disease postulates that disease arises from perturbation of biological networks in the relevant organ. We tracked global gene expression in the brains of eight distinct mouse strain–prion strain combinations throughout the progression of the disease to capture the effects of prion strain, host genetics, and PrP concentration on disease incubation time. Subtractive analyses exploiting various aspects of prion biology and infection identified a core of 333 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) that appeared central to prion disease. DEGs were mapped into functional pathways and networks reflecting defined neuropathological events and PrP^Sc replication and accumulation, enabling the identification of novel modules and modules that may be involved in genetic effects on incubation time and in prion strain specificity. Our systems analysis provides a comprehensive basis for developing models for prion replication and disease, and suggests some possible therapeutic approaches.     

The Strain-Encoded Relationship between PrPSc Replication,Stability and Processing in Neurons is Predictive of the Incubation Period of Disease

Prion strains are characterized by differences in the outcome of disease, most notably incubation period and neuropathological features. While it is established that the disease specific isoform of the prion protein, PrP^Sc, is an essential component of the infectious agent, the strain-specific relationship between PrP^Sc properties and the biological features of the resulting disease is not clear. To investigate this relationship, we examined the amplification efficiency and conformational stability of PrP^Sc from eight hamster-adapted prion strains and compared it to the resulting incubation period of disease and processing of PrP^Sc in neurons and glia. We found that short incubation period strains were characterized by more efficient PrP^Sc amplification and higher PrP^Sc conformational stabilities compared to long incubation period strains. In the CNS, the short incubation period strains were characterized by the accumulation of N-terminally truncated PrP^Sc in the soma of neurons, astrocytes and microglia in contrast to long incubation period strains where PrP^Sc did not accumulate to detectable levels in the soma of neurons but was detected in glia similar to short incubation period strains. These results are inconsistent with the hypothesis that a decrease in conformational stability results in a corresponding increase in replication efficiency and suggest that glia mediated neurodegeneration results in longer survival times compared to direct replication of PrP^Sc in neurons.     

Brain delivery of AAV9 expressing an anti-PrP monovalent antibody delays prion disease in mice

Prion diseases are caused by a conformational modification of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into disease-specific forms, termed PrP^Sc, that have the ability to interact with PrP^C promoting its conversion to PrP^Sc. In vitro studies demonstrated that anti-PrP antibodies inhibit this process. In particular, the single chain variable fragment D18 antibody (scFvD18) showed high efficiency in curing chronically prion-infected cells. This molecule binds the PrP^C region involved in the interaction with PrP^Sc thus halting further prion formation. These findings prompted us to test the efficiency of scFvD18 in vivo. A recombinant Adeno-Associated Viral vector serotype 9 was used to deliver scFvD18 to the brain of mice that were subsequently infected by intraperitoneal route with the mouse-adapted scrapie strain RML. We found that the treatment was safe, prolonged the incubation time of scrapie-infected animals and decreased the burden of total proteinase-resistant PrP^Sc in the brain, suggesting that scFvD18 interferes with prion replication in vivo. This approach is relevant for designing new therapeutic strategies for prion diseases and other disorders characterized by protein misfolding.     

Small Protease Sensitive Oligomers of PrPSc in Distinct Human Prions Determine Conversion Rate of PrPC

The mammalian prions replicate by converting cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into pathogenic conformational isoform (PrP^Sc). Variations in prions, which cause different disease phenotypes, are referred to as strains. The mechanism of high-fidelity replication of prion strains in the absence of nucleic acid remains unsolved. We investigated the impact of different conformational characteristics of PrP^Sc on conversion of PrP^C in vitro using PrP^Sc seeds from the most frequent human prion disease worldwide, the Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD). The conversion potency of a broad spectrum of distinct sCJD prions was governed by the level, conformation, and stability of small oligomers of the protease-sensitive (s) PrP^Sc. The smallest most potent prions present in sCJD brains were composed only of∼20 monomers of PrP^Sc. The tight correlation between conversion potency of small oligomers of human sPrP^Sc observed in vitro and duration of the disease suggests that sPrP^Sc conformers are an important determinant of prion strain characteristics that control the progression rate of the disease.     

Lipopolysaccharide induced conversion of recombinant prion protein

The conformational conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) to the β-rich infectious isoform PrP^Sc is considered a critical and central feature in prion pathology. Although PrP^Sc is the critical component of the infectious agent, as proposed in the “protein-only” prion hypothesis, cellular components have been identified as important cofactors in triggering and enhancing the conversion of PrP^C to proteinase K resistant PrP^Sc. A number of in vitro systems using various chemical and/or physical agents such as guanidine hydrochloride, urea, SDS, high temperature, and low pH, have been developed that cause PrP^C conversion, their amplification, and amyloid fibril formation often under non-physiological conditions. In our ongoing efforts to look for endogenous and exogenous chemical mediators that might initiate, influence, or result in the natural conversion of PrP^C to PrP^Sc, we discovered that lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a component of gram-negative bacterial membranes interacts with recombinant prion proteins and induces conversion to an isoform richer in β sheet at near physiological conditions as long as the LPS concentration remains above the critical micelle concentration (CMC). More significant was the LPS mediated conversion that was observed even at sub-molar ratios of LPS to recombinant ShPrP (90–232).     

Brain delivery of AAV9 expressing an anti-PrP monovalent antibody delays prion disease in mice

Prion diseases are caused by a conformational modification of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into disease-specific forms, termed PrP^Sc, that have the ability to interact with PrP^C promoting its conversion to PrP^Sc. In vitro studies demonstrated that anti-PrP antibodies inhibit this process. In particular, the single chain variable fragment D18 antibody (scFvD18) showed high efficiency in curing chronically prion-infected cells. This molecule binds the PrP^C region involved in the interaction with PrP^Sc thus halting further prion formation. These findings prompted us to test the efficiency of scFvD18 in vivo. A recombinant Adeno-Associated Viral vector serotype 9 was used to deliver scFvD18 to the brain of mice that were subsequently infected by intraperitoneal route with the mouse-adapted scrapie strain RML. We found that the treatment was safe, prolonged the incubation time of scrapie-infected animals and decreased the burden of total proteinase-resistant PrP^Sc in the brain, suggesting that scFvD18 interferes with prion replication in vivo. This approach is relevant for designing new therapeutic strategies for prion diseases and other disorders characterized by protein misfolding.     

Biochemical Properties of Highly Neuroinvasive Prion Strains

Infectious prions propagate from peripheral entry sites into the central nervous system (CNS), where they cause progressive neurodegeneration that ultimately leads to death. Yet the pathogenesis of prion disease can vary dramatically depending on the strain, or conformational variant of the aberrantly folded and aggregated protein, PrP^Sc. Although most prion strains invade the CNS, some prion strains cannot gain entry and do not cause clinical signs of disease. The conformational basis for this remarkable variation in the pathogenesis among strains is unclear. Using mouse-adapted prion strains, here we show that highly neuroinvasive prion strains primarily form diffuse aggregates in brain and are noncongophilic, conformationally unstable in denaturing conditions, and lead to rapidly lethal disease. These neuroinvasive strains efficiently generate PrP^Sc over short incubation periods. In contrast, the weakly neuroinvasive prion strains form large fibrillary plaques and are stable, congophilic, and inefficiently generate PrP^Sc over long incubation periods. Overall, these results indicate that the most neuroinvasive prion strains are also the least stable, and support the concept that the efficient replication and unstable nature of the most rapidly converting prions may be a feature linked to their efficient spread into the CNS.     

Abnormalities in Stress Proteins in Prion Diseases

1. Prion diseases include kuru, Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease (CJD), Gerstmann–Sträussler–Scheinker disease (GSS), and fatal familia insomnia (FFI) of humans, as well as scrapie and bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) of animals.2. All these disorders involve conversion of the normal, cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into the corresponding scrapie isoform (PrP^Sc). PrP^C adopts a structure rich in -helices and devoid of -sheet, in contrast to PrP^Sc, which has a high -sheet content and is resistant to limited digestion by proteases. That a conformational transition features in the conversion of PrP^C into PrP^Sc implies that prion diseases are disorders of protein conformation.3. This concept has been extended by our studies with heat shock proteins (Hsp), many of which are thought to function as molecular chaperones. We found that the induction of some Hsps but not others was profoundly altered in scrapie-infected cells and that the distribution of Hsp73 is unusual in these cells.4. Whether the conversion of PrP^C into PrP^Sc is assisted by molecular chaperones, or if the accumulation of the abnormally folded PrP^Sc is complexed with Hsps remains to be established.