An Automated Technique for Double Staining Rat and Rabbit Fetal Skeletal Specimens to Differentiate Bone and Cartilage

Assessment of chemicals for their potential to cause developmental toxicity must include evaluation of the development of the fetal skeleton. The method described here is an improved and fully automated double staining method using alizarin red S to stain bone and alcian blue to stain cartilage. The method was developed on the enclosed Shandon PathcentreTM, and the quality of specimens reported here will be reproduced only if carried out on a similar processor under the same environmental conditions. The staining, maceration and clearing process takes approximately 6 days. The personnel time, however, is minimal since solutions are changed automatically and the fetuses are not examined or removed from the processor until the procedure is completed. Upon completion of processing, the bone and cartilage assessment of the specimens can be carried out immediately if required. Full evaluation of skeletal development in both the rat and the rabbit is necessary to meet the requirements of safety assessment studies. This method allows this to be accomplished on a large scale with consistently clear specimens and in a realistic time.     

Permanent Preservation of Whole Alizarin Red S Skeletons by Clearing and Embedding in Polyester Resins

A one-step clearing and embedding procedure for alizarin red S stained skeletons is described. Embryos are fixed in formalin, skinned and eviscerated. After staining in a 10 mg/liter solution of alizarin red S in 5% aqueous KOH, specimens are dehydrated in a graded series of acetone-polyester monomer solutions. Finally, the specimens are embedded at room temperature in the polyester resin. A special reusable metallic mold is described for embedment of large fetuses. Specimens previously cleared in glycerol can be processed with this method.     

Permanent preservation of whole alizarin red S skeletons by clearing and embedding in polyester resins

A one-step clearing and embedding procedure for alizarin red S stained skeletons is described. Embryos are fixed in formalin, skinned and eviscerated. After staining in a 10 mg/liter solution of alizarin red S in 5% aqueous KOH, specimens are dehydrated in a graded series of acetone-polyester monomer solutions. Finally, the specimens are embedded at room temperature in the polyester resin. A special reusable metallic mold is described for embedment of large fetuses. Specimens previously cleared in glycerol can be processed with this method.     

Simultaneous Differential Staining of Cartilage and Bone in Rodent Fetuses: an Alcian Blue and Alizarin Red S Procedure without Glacial Acetic Acid

Differential staining of cartilage and bone has several applications including developmental toxicology studies of new chemical candidates for pharmaceutical, industrial, and environmental use. It has been more common to stain fetal bone only using the dye alizarin red S: however, failure to evaluate the cartilaginous portion of the skeleton may result in the failure to identify toxicologically important alterations in skeletal morphology. Previously, differential staining of fetal cartilage and bone was best achieved by combining alizarin red S for staining bone with alcian blue to stain cartilage in glacial acetic acid solution: however, occupational hazards posed by the use of glacial acetic acid make these methods undesirable. Replacement of the glacial acetic acid with potassium hydrogen phthalate eliminates these hazards without compromising the quality of the stained specimen.     

Selective staining methods for cartilage of rat fetal specimens previously treated with alizarin red S.

A convenient method for staining cartilage with several basic stains after alizarin red S staining of bone was investigated in rat fetuses. It was found that bromophenol blue was useful and effective for staining of the margin and center areas of cartilage, even in specimens stored in glycerin for over 10 years. The specimens were washed in running tap water for 1 hr, and subsequently were immersed in water or in 70% ethanol at pH 4 for 1 hr or longer. The specimens were then stained with 0.005% bromophenol blue in 40% ethanol adjusted to pH 4 for 2 hr, or with 0.001% bromophenol blue in 40% ethanol adjusted to pH 4 for 24 hr. Furthermore, the bromophenol blue stain color actually faded when the specimens were immersed in water or in 70% ethanol at pH 8. Descending order of the stain-effective action on fetal rat cartilage for the basic stains tested was bromophenol blue, aniline blue, Evans blue, methyl violet, trypan blue, and water blue.     

A Modified Differential Stain for Cartilage and Bone in Whole Mount Preparations of Mammalian Fetuses and Small Vertebrates

Fixation in formol-acetic-alcohol as a prelude to the staining of whole mount vertebrate skeletons with alcian blue and alizarin red S has greatly facilitated the enzyme clearing step of the method outlined by Dingerkus and Uhler. The modified method has been tested on fetal and neonatal mice, and on a variety of vertebrates including bony fish, reptiles, amphibia and birds, and shown to be rapid, reproducible and permanent. The method is not so rapid as that reported by Kimmel and Trammell but is superior at least in certain circumstances. In the present study, optimal results were obtained by fixing in formol-acetic-alcohol for 40 minutes, staining cartilage with alcian blue 8GX, then clearing with trypsin. The time taken to complete the latter step was reduced significantly by incubation at 37 C. The next step was to stain bone using alizarin red S in a weak solution of potassium hydroxide, followed by clearing in a potassium hydroxide-glycerol series.     

A modified differential stain for cartilage and bone in whole mount preparations of mammalian fetuses and small vertebrates

Fixation in formol-acetic-alcohol as a prelude to the staining of whole mount vertebrate skeletons with alcian blue and alizarin red S has greatly facilitated the enzyme clearing step of the method outlined by Dingerkus and Uhler. The modified method has been tested on fetal and neonatal mice, and on a variety of vertebrates including bony fish, reptiles, amphibia and birds, and shown to be rapid, reproducible and permanent. The method is not so rapid as that reported by Kimmel and Trammell but is superior at least in certain circumstances. In the present study, optimal results were obtained by fixing in formol-acetic-alcohol for 40 minutes, staining cartilage with alcian blue 8GX, then clearing with trypsin. The time taken to complete the latter step was reduced significantly by incubation at 37 C. The next step was to stain bone using alizarin red S in a weak solution of potassium hydroxide, followed by clearing in a potassium hydroxide-glycerol series.     

A rapid procedure for routine double staining of cartilage and bone in fetal and adult animals

A simple, rapid procedure for dual staining of cartilage and bone in rodents, particularly in late gestation, has been developed for routine use. The procedure involves rapid, complete skinning of fresh eviscerated specimens following a 30 sec immersion in a 70 C water bath. The unfixed specimen is stained in a mixture of 0.14% Alcian blue and 0.12% alizarin red S in ethanol and glacial acetic acid. Specimens are then macerated in 2% KOH, cleared and hardened in 1:1 glycerin and distilled water, and stored in pure glycerin. Rapid staining of cartilage only is done in a mixture of 0.08% Alcian blue, glacial acetic acid, and ethanol, with subsequent maceration, clearing, and hardening as in the double staining procedure. Rapid staining of bone only, concurrent with maceration of soft tissue, can be done by placing fresh, unskinned specimens in a diluted mixture of alizarin red S in 2% KOH, with subsequent clearing and hardening in 1:1 distilled water and glycerin. Good quality fetal specimens can be prepared for examination by any of these procedures in a minimum of 11/2-2 days as compared to a minimum of 4-5 days for other procedures. Double stained specimens can be examined for abnormalities of the cartilage as well as bone.     

Demonstrating the Osseous Skeleton of Human Embryos and Fetuses

Transparent human embryos and fetuses whose osseous skeletons are stained in toto by alizarin red S are successfully prepared when the KOH clearing of the soft tissues and the alizarin staining of the bones are performed simultaneously instead of independently. This modification minimizes the possibility of macerating and staining the soft tissues. Fetuses over 50 mm. CR length are skinned, eviscerated, decerebrated, defatted by dissection, fixed in 95% alcohol, bleached in H₂O₂, cleared and stained simultaneously in an aqueous solution of KOH (from 2% to 10% depending upon the size of the specimen) and .0001 to .00005% alizarin red S (solution has a pale lavender color). This solution is changed periodically to maintain the concentration of the KOH until the clearing of the tissues is complete and of the alizarin until the bones are properly stained. Tissues are dehydrated in increasing concentrations of glycerin and stored in white glycerin plus thymol.     

High-throughput staining for the evaluation of fetal skeletal development in rats and rabbits

Typical developmental toxicity studies require the assessment of fetal skeletal development. Regulatory guidelines require the assessment of bone ossification and indicate preferences for an assessment of both ossified bone as well as cartilaginous elements. Current manual methods to process fetuses for skeletal examination, whether single or double staining, are laborious and time consuming, and ultimately extend the time before study interpretations. There is a definite need for a quick and efficient, yet reliable, procedure to generate stained fetal skeletons for analysis. A non-automated high-throughput method for single and double staining rat and rabbit fetuses for skeletal evaluations is described, which results in excellent quality specimens ready for evaluations in approximately 3 days for rats and 7 days for rabbits.     

A two-color acid-free cartilage and bone stain for zebrafish larvae

Traditionally, cartilage is stained by alcian blue using acidic conditions to differentiate tissue staining. The acidic conditions are problematic when one wishes to stain the same specimen for mineralized bone with alizarin red, because acid demineralizes bone, which negatively affects bone staining. We have developed an acid-free method to stain cartilage and bone simultaneously in zebrafish larvae. This method has the additional advantage that PCR genotyping of stained specimens is possible.     

Automated Differential Staining for Cartilage and Bone in Whole Mount Preparations of Vertebrates

An automated, rapid procedure for differential staining of cartilage and bone of vertebrates is described. The process involves rapid, complete staining of freshly skinned, eviscerated specimens after 30 sec immersion in a 70 C water bath, fixation in formol acetic alcohol and a rinse in 70% alcohol. Using an automatic tissue processor, the specimen is stained in alcian blue for 24 hr and macerated in 3% potassium hydroxide for 8 hr. Staining in alizarin red with maceration in 3% potassium hydroxide is completed manually. The specimens are cleared and preserved in glycerol. Good quality evenly stained specimens can be examined in less than three days and up to 600 fetuses can be processed in less than five days.     

Automated differential staining for cartilage and bone in whole mount preparations of vertebrates

An automated, rapid procedure for differential staining of cartilage and bone of vertebrates is described. The process involves rapid, complete staining of freshly skinned, eviscerated specimens after 30 sec immersion in a 70 C water bath, fixation in formol acetic alcohol and a rinse in 70% alcohol. Using an automatic tissue processor, the specimen is stained in alcian blue for 24 hr and macerated in 3% potassium hydroxide for 8 hr. Staining in alizarin red with maceration in 3% potassium hydroxide is completed manually. The specimens are cleared and preserved in glycerol. Good quality evenly stained specimens can be examined in less than three days and up to 600 fetuses can be processed in less than five days.     

Cartilage-staining technique for the examination of unskinned fetal rat specimens previously processed with alizarin red S

A novel staining technique has been devised that permits a cartilage examination of unskinned fetal rats that have been previously processed for skeletal examination with alizarin red S. The procedure consists of rinsing alizarin red S-stained specimens in distilled water and placing the specimens in a 3% acetic acid solution. A transfer of the stain from bone to adjacent cartilage occurs, producing purple-stained cartilaginous structures that can be differentiated from still-discernible bone structures.     

A procedure for differential staining of cartilage and bone in whole formalin-fixed vertebrates.

This paper describes a modification of the Simons and Van Horn (1971) procedure for rendering cartilage blue, bone red, and soft tissue translucent or transparent in whole vertebrate specimens. Alcian blue and alizarin red S are used to stain cartilage and bone respectively. In our procedure formalin is used as a fixative. This is a significant modification because formalin is the common fixative for museum specimens. This clearing and staining procedure is thus readily applicable to comparative studies in anatomy, embryology and systematic zoology.     

An Automated Double Staining Procedure for Bone and Cartilage

Differential skeletal staining is an important part of developmental toxicologic studies. Traditionally these studies have required time-consuming differentiation of one or both stains used and careful attention to the maceration step to prevent specimen destruction. We present a fully automated protocol which does not require differentiation of either dye and incorporates a controlled maceration step which is highly reproducible. This has resulted in high quality staining that is reproducible, stable, and can be done in volume with minimal personnel time. The process involves the staining of skinned, eviscerated specimens fixed in 95% ethanol. Using an automated tissue processor, the specimen is stained in alcian blue for 24 hr, macerated in 3% potassium hydroxide for 24 hr and stained with murexide for 24 hr. The specimens are cleared and preserved in glycerol. Within three days specimens have red stained bone and blue stained cartilage. The procedure was developed using 20-day-old Sprague-Dawley rat fetuses to evaluate the feasibility of using the procedure for teratology studies involving the fetal skeleton. Evenly stained specimens can be examined within three days and stored for years without loss of staining.     

Atlas of rat fetal skeleton double stained for bone and cartilage

BACKGROUND: The double staining of fetal skeleton for bone and cartilage is a very useful method to evidence skeletal abnormalities in laboratory animals. However, this method has been rarely used in routine developmental toxicity tests. One reason could be the difficulty of comparing the single skeletal pieces and of having reference points. In this paper the fetal rat skeleton double stained with Alizarin red S and Alcyan Blue is described in detail to produce an atlas for developmental toxicity laboratories.     

Micro-computed tomography and alizarin red evaluations of boric acid–induced fetal skeletal changes in Sprague-Dawley rats

BACKGROUND: Assessment of developmental toxicity has historically included assessment of fetal skeletal morphology after alizarin red staining. X-ray micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) produces high-resolution images of skeletal structures and was investigated as an alternative method. METHODS: Groups of 5 mated Crl:CD (SD) female rats each were administered vehicle or boric acid (40 to 500 mg/kg/day) from GD 6 through 11. On GD 21, all live fetuses were weighed, euthanized, and viscera removed. Each litter was placed into a custom-made polystyrene holder and scanned in the micro-CT imaging system. Raw projection data were acquired in approximately 15 sec (∼20 litters per hour) and reconstructed images at 100-micron cubic voxel dimension could be viewed as early as 20 min later. Fetuses were subsequently stained with alizarin red, and findings recorded separately for each method without knowledge of treatment group. RESULTS: Micro-CT evaluation of fetal rat skeletons detected essentially the same skeletal malformations, variations, and incomplete ossifications as seen by the staining method. The specific skeletal abnormalities that did not match exactly involved the smallest skeletal elements with minimal degrees of ossification (i.e., cervical ribs, hypoplastic 13^th ribs, supernumerary ribs, the 5^th sternebra, and numbers of caudal vertebrae), but the differences did not impact the overall conclusions. Additional measures such as femur length were easily measured by micro-CT. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that micro-CT imaging can effectively assess rat fetal skeletal structures, and for those laboratories with this resource, it may be used to significantly reduce time prior to skeletal evaluation and hazardous wastes associated with staining. Birth Defects Res (Part B) 33:214–219, 2009 © 2009 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Alizarin Red S and Toluidine Blue for Differentiating Adult or Embryonic Bone and Cartilage

This technic has been successfully employed by the author for staining, in toto, the bones and cartilage of mature specimens of Urodela and the developing bone and cartilage of the embryonic human, cat, pig and rat. The differential staining is accomplished by using a modification of Dawson's method of staining bone with alizarin red S following a toluidine blue solution specific for cartilage. Specimens are fixed in 10% formalin, stained one week in a solution of .25 g. of toluidine blue in 100 cc. of 70% alcohol, macerated 5 to 7 days in a 2% KOH solution, counterstained for 24 hours in a 0.001% solution of alizarin red S in 2% aqueous KOH, dehydrated in cellosolve and cleared in methyl salicylate. In the adult and embryonic forms thus treated the soft tissues are cleared while the osseous tissue is stained red, the cartilage blue.     

Large-scale double-staining of rat fetal skeletons using Alizarin Red S and alcian blue

A critical component in the conduct of a prenatal developmental toxicity study is the evaluation of fetal skeletal development. As the developing rodent fetus is typically evaluated at gestation day 20, at a time when ossification of the skeleton is incomplete, a thorough assessment of skeletal development would include both ossified and cartilaginous structures. Current methods to double-stain the fetal skeleton using Alizarin Red S and Alcian Blue are typically described for small sample sizes or using time allotments for each processing step that are unsuitable for industry. In an industrial setting, there is a need for an effective means to double-stain fetal skeletons on a large scale (i.e., hundreds of fetuses simultaneously). This article describes a method used in our laboratory to stain both fetal bone and cartilage using solutions and procedures on an industrial scale.