Communications between the high-affinity cyclic nucleotide binding sites in E. coli cyclic AMP receptor protein: effect of single site mutations

The binding of adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) and its nonfunctional analogue, guanosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cGMP), to the adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate receptor protein (CRP) from Escherichia coli was investigated by means of fluorescence and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) at pH 7.8 and 25 degrees C. A biphasic fluorescence titration curve was observed, confirming the previous observation reported by this laboratory (Heyduk and Lee (1989) Biochemistry 28, 6914-6924). However, the triphasic titration curve obtained from the ITC study suggests that the cAMP binding to CRP is more complicated than the previous conclusion that CRP binds sequentially two molecules of cAMP with negative cooperativity. The binding data can best be represented by a model for two identical interactive high-affinity sites and one low-affinity binding site. Unlike cAMP, the binding of cGMP to CRP exhibits no cooperativity between the high-affinity sites. The effects of mutations on the bindings of cAMP and cGMP to CRP were also investigated. The eight CRP mutants studied were K52N, D53H, S62F, T127L, G141Q, L148R, H159L, and K52N/H159L. These sites are located neither in the ligand binding site nor at the subunit interface. The binding was monitored by fluorescence. Although these mutations are at a variety of locations in CRP, the basic mechanism of CRP binding to cyclic nucleotides has not been affected. Two cyclic nucleotide molecules bind to the high-affinity sites of CRP. The cooperativity of cAMP binding is affected by mutation. It ranges from negative to positive cooperativity. The binding of cGMP shows none. With the exception of the T127L mutant, the free energy change for DNA-CRP complex formation increases linearly with increasing free energy change associated with the cooperativity of cAMP binding. This linear relationship implies that the protein molecule modulates the signal in the binding of cAMP, even though the mutation is not directly involved in cAMP or DNA binding. In addition, the significant differences in the amplitude of fluorescent signal indicate that the mutations also affect the surface characteristics of CRP. These results imply that these mutations are not perturbing specific pathways of signal transmission. Instead, these results are more consistent with the concept that CRP exists as an ensemble of native states, the distribution of which can be altered by these mutations.     

Photoaffinity labeling of the adenosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate receptor protein of Escherichia coli with 8-azidoadenosine 3',5'-monophosphate

Photoaffinity labeling of the cAMP receptor protein (CRP) of Escherichia coli with 8-azidoadenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (8-N3cAMP) has been demonstrated. 8-N3cAMP is able to support the binding of (3H)d(I-C)n by CRP, indicating that it is a functional cAMP analogue. Following irradiation at 254 nm, (32P)-8-N3cAMP is photocross-linked to CRP. Photolabeling of CRP by (32P)-8-N3cAMP is inhibited by cAMP but not by 5'AMP. The data indicate that (32P)-8-N3cAMP is covalently incorporated following binding at the cAMP binding site of CRP. The (32P)-8-N3cAMP-CRP digested with chymotrypsin was analyzed by NaDodSO4-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Of the incorporated label, one-third remains associated with the amino-proximal alpha core region of CRP [Eilen, E., Pampeno, C., & Krakow, J.S. (1978) Biochemistry 17, 2469] which contains the cAMP binding domain; the remaining two-thirds of the label associated with the beta region are digested. Limited proteolysis of the (32P)-8-N3cAMP-CRP by chymotrypsin in the presence of NaDodSO4 shows the radioactivity to be distributed between the molecular weight 9500 (amino-proximal) and 13,000 (carboxyl-proximal) fragments produced. These results suggest that a part of the carboxyl-proximal region is folded over and close enough to the cAMP binding site to be cross-linked by the photoactivated (32P)-8-N3cAMP bound at the cAMP binding site.     

An equilibrium study of the cooperative binding of adenosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate and guanosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate to the adenosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate receptor protein from Escherichia coli

The binding of adenosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate (cAMP) and guanosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate (cGMP) to the adenosine cyclic 3',5'-monophosphate receptor protein (CRP) from Escherichia coli was investigated by equilibrium dialysis at pH 8.0 and 20 degrees C at different ionic strengths (0.05--0.60 M). Both cAMP and cGMP bind to CRP with a negative cooperativity that is progressively changed to positive as the ionic strength is increased. The binding data were analyzed with an interactive model for two identical sites and site/site interactions with the interaction free energy--RT ln alpha, and the intrinsic binding constant K and cooperativity parameter alpha were computed. Double-label experiments showed that cGMP is strictly competitive with cAMP, and its binding parameters K and alpha are not very different from that for cAMP. Since two binding sites exist for each of the cyclic nucleotides in dimeric CRP and no change in the quaternary structure of the protein is observed on binding the ligands, it is proposed that the cooperativity originates in ligand/ligand interactions. When bound to double-stranded deoxyribonucleic acid (dsDNA), CRP binds cAMP more efficiently, and the cooperativity is positive even in conditions of low ionic strength where it is negative for the free protein. By contrast, cGMP binding properties remained unperturbed in dsDNA-bound CRP. Neither the intrinsic binding constant K nor the cooperativity parameter alpha was found to be very sensitive to changes of pH between 6.0 and 8.0 at 0.2 M ionic strength and 20 degrees C. For these conditions, the intrinsic free energy and entropy of binding of cAMP are delta H degree = -1.7 kcal . mol-1 and delta S degree = 15.6 eu, respectively.     

Cooperative non-specific DNA binding of the N-terminal core of the cyclic AMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli and its modulation by cyclic AMP

The non-specific DNA binding of CRP and its N-terminal core, alpha CRP, to a 298 base pair DNA fragment, in the presence and absence of cAMP, has been studied using the nitrocellulose filter binding technique and analysed quantitatively using the theory of Clore et al. [J. Mol. Biol. (1982) 155, 447-466]. It is shown that both CRP and alpha CRP bind cooperatively to DNA. At an ionic strength of 100 mM and pH 7.5, the intrinsic equilibrium association constant for the binding of alpha CRP to DNA is approximately 10-times smaller than that for CRP, but the cooperativity parameter is approximately 17-times larger for alpha CRP than CRP. cAMP exerts its effect solely on the intrinsic equilibrium constant and does not alter the cooperativity. In the case of alpha CRP, cAMP reduces the intrinsic equilibrium association constant by a factor of 3, in contrast to the case of CRP where cAMP increases it by a factor of 3. The possible location of the DNA binding site present in the N-terminal core of CRP is discussed in the light of crystallographic data on the cAMP . CRP complex [McKay et al. (1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 9518-9524].     

Ligand-modulated binding of a gene regulatory protein to DNA. Quantitative analysis of cyclic-AMP induced binding of CRP from Escherichia coli to non-specific and specific DNA targets

This paper describes a generally applicable method for quantitative investigation of ligand-dependent binding of a regulatory protein to its target DNA at equilibrium. It is used here to analyse the coupled binding equilibria of cAMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli K12 (CRP) with DNA and the physiological effector cAMP. In principle, the DNA binding parameters of CRP dimers with either one or two ligands bound are determinable in such an approach. The change of protein fluorescence was used to measure CRP binding to its recognition sequence in the lac control region and to non-specific DNA. Furthermore, the binding of cAMP to preformed CRP-DNA complexes was independently studied by equilibrium dialysis. The data were analysed using a simple interactive model for two intrinsically identical sites and site-site interactions. The intrinsic binding constant K and the co-operativity factor alpha for binding of cAMP to free CRP depend only slightly on salt concentration between 0.01 M and 0.2 M. In contrast, the affinity of cAMP for CRP pre-bound to non-specific DNA increases with the salt concentration and the co-operativity changes from positive to negative. This results from cation rebinding to the DNA lattice upon forming the cAMP-CRP-DNA complex from cAMP and the pre-formed CRP-DNA complex. The CRP-cAMP1 complex shows almost the same affinity for specific and non-specific DNA as the CRP-cAMP2 complex, and both displace the same number of cations. It is concluded that the allosteric activation of CRP is induced upon binding of the first cAMP. These results are used to estimate the occupation of the CRP site in the lac control region in relation to the cAMP concentration in vivo. Under physiological conditions the lac promoter is activated by the CRP dimer complexed with only one cAMP. Furthermore, a model for the differential activation of various genes expressed under catabolite repression is presented and discussed.     

Functional roles of loops 3 and 4 in the cyclic nucleotide binding domain of cyclic AMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli

Cyclic AMP is a ubiquitous secondary message that regulates a large variety of functions. The protein structural motif that binds cAMP is highly conserved with the exception of loops 3 and 4, whose structure and length are variable. The cAMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli, CRP, was employed as a model system to elucidate the functional roles of these loops. Based on the sequence differences between CRP and cyclic nucleotide gated channel, three mutants of CRP were constructed: deletion (residues 54-56 in loop 3 were deleted), insertion (loop 4 was lengthened by 5 residues between Glu-78 and Gly-79) and double mutants. The effects of these mutations on the structure and function of CRP were monitored. Results show that the deletion and insertion mutations do not significantly change the secondary structure of CRP, although the tertiary and quaternary structures are perturbed. The functional data indicate that loop 3 modulates the binding affinities of cAMP and DNA. Although the lengthened loop 4 may have some fine-tuning functions, the specific function of the original loop 4 of CRP remains uncertain. The function consequences of mutation in loop 3 of CRP are similar to that of site A and site B in the regulatory subunits of cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinases. Thus, the roles played by loop 3 in CRP may represent a more common mechanism employed by cyclic nucleotide binding domain in modulating ligand binding affinity and intramolecular communication.     

Specific DNA binding of the cyclic AMP receptor protein to a synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotide. A circular dichroism study

The interaction of the cAMP receptor protein (CRP) of Escherichia coli with a synthetic DNA undecamer (11 mer) comprising a portion of the specific target site in the gal operon and containing 8 basepairs out of the 10 basepair concensus making up specific CRP sites, has been studied by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The binding constants for the interaction of CRP with the 11 mer in the presence and absence of cAMP have been determined, and it is shown that CRP, both in the presence and absence of cAMP, induces a B-C transition in the conformation of the 11 mer.     

Specific DNA binding of the cAMP receptor protein within the lac operon stabilizes double-stranded DNA in the presence of cAMP

The effects of varying amounts of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) in the presence and absence of cAMP on the melting and differential melting curves of a 301-bp fragment containing the lac control region in 5 mM Na+ have been investigated. The native 301-bp fragment consists of three cooperatively melting thermalites. At 5 mM Na+, thermalite I (155 bp) has a Tm of 66.4 degrees C and the melting transitions of thermalites II (81 bp) and III (65 bp) are superimposed with a Tm of 61.9 degrees C. The specific DNA target site for CRP and the lac promotor are located within thermalite II. CRP alone exerts no specific effects on the melting of the 301-bp fragment, non-specific DNA binding of CRP resulting in a progressive stabilization of the double-stranded DNA by increasing the number of base pairs melting at a higher Tm in a non-cooperative transition. The cAMP-CRP complex, however, exerts a specific effect with a region of approximately 36 bp, comprising the specific CRP binding site and a neighbouring region of DNA, being stabilized. The appearance of this new cooperatively melting region, known as thermalite IV, is associated with a corresponding decrease in the area of thermalites II/III. The Tm of thermalite IV is 64.4 degrees C, 2.5 degrees C higher than that of thermalites II/III. With two or more cAMP-CRP complexes bound per 301-bp fragment, the stabilization also affects the remaining 110 bp now making up thermalites II/III whose Tm is increased by 1 degrees C to 62.9 degrees C. The implications of these findings for various models of the mode of action of the cAMP-CRP complex are discussed.     

Monoclonal antibodies that inhibit activation of transcription by the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein

The properties of the two monoclonal antibodies which were found to inhibit cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP)-stimulated abortive initiation without affecting cAMP binding (Li, X.-M., and Krakow, J. S. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 260, 4378-4383) have been characterized. Binding of monoclonal antibody (mAb) 66C3 to CRP is stimulated by cAMP while CRP binding by mAb 63B2 is not affected by cAMP. Binding of cAMP-CRP-mAb 63B2 to the lac P+ DNA is completely inhibited. Whereas cAMP-CRP forms a stable complex only at the CRP site 1 of the lac P+ promoter fragment, cAMP-CRP-mAb 66C3 binds to both site 1 and site 2. DNase I footprinting using a HpaII fragment carrying only the lac site 2 does not show any protection by cAMP-CRP-mAb 66C3. With the lac L8UV5 promoter, binding is not seen at either the L8 site 1 or the unaltered site 2. In the presence of 25% glycerol, cAMP-CRP-mAb 66C3 binds to both L8 site 1 and site 2. RNA polymerase is unable to bind to the cAMP-CRP-mAb 66C3-lac P+ complex. In the presence of RNA polymerase, cAMP-CRP forms a stable complex at the L8 site 1, the subsequent addition of mAb 66C3 results in the release of CRP. The CRP present in the lac P+ open promoter complex is partially resistant to subsequent incubation with mAb 66C3. The results provide further evidence regarding possible contacts between CRP and RNA polymerase involved in establishing the open promoter complex.     

The binding of the cyclic AMP receptor protein to synthetic DNA sites containing permutations in the consensus sequence TGTGA.

The binding of the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) to symmetrical synthetic DNA-binding sites was investigated with a gel-retardation assay. A set of ten different sequences was employed, comprising all base permutations at positions 2, 4, and 5 of the consensus sequence 5'(TGTGA)3'. We show that: (i) CRP has a higher affinity for the completely symmetrical site than towards the lac wild-type site; (ii) base substitutions at position 2 lead to either a complete loss of specific CRP binding (G----C), a reduction in specific CRP binding (G----A) or only marginal effects on specific CRP binding (G----T); (iii) changes at position 4 abolish (G----C; G----A) or reduce (G----T) specific CRP binding; and (iv) base permutations at position 5 reduce specific CRP binding, but never completely abolish it. Thus position 4, and to a lesser extent position 2, in the DNA consensus sequence are the most crucial ones for specific binding by CRP.     

Interaction between the cyclic AMP receptor protein and DNA. Conformational studies

The binding of the cyclic adenosine 3',5' monophosphate receptor protein (CRP or CAP) of Escherichia coli to non-specific DNA and to a specific lac recognition sequence has been investigated by circular dichroism (c.d.) spectroscopy. The effect of cAMP and cGMP on the co-operative non-specific binding was also studied. For the non-specific binding in the absence of cAMP a c.d. change (decrease of the intensity of the positive band with a shift of its maximum to longer wavelength) indicates that the DNA undergoes a conformational change upon CRP binding. This change might reflect the formation of the solenoidal coil previously observed by electron microscopy. The amplitude of the c.d. change increases linearly with the degree of saturation of the DNA and does not depend on the size of the clusters of CRP bound. From the variation of the c.d. effect as a function of the ionic strength, the product K omega (K, the intrinsic binding constant and omega, the co-operativity parameter) could be determined. The number of ion pairs involved in complex formation between CRP and DNA was found to be six to seven. Experiments performed with several DNAs, including the alternating polymers poly[d(A-T)] and poly[d(G-C)], demonstrated that the conformational change does not depend on the DNA sequence. However, in the presence of cAMP the c.d. spectrum of the DNA shows only a small variation upon binding CRP. In contrast, in the presence of cGMP the conformational change of the DNA is similar to that observed when non-liganded CRP binds. For the specific lac operon binding, the c.d. change is different from those observed for non-specific binding in the presence or absence of cAMP. These results emphasize the high variability of the DNA structure upon binding the same protein.