Use and misuse of nitrogen in agriculture: the German story

Nitrogen (N) fertilization in agriculture has been discussed controversially in Germany for almost two centuries. The agronomist Carl Sprengel, who published his theory on the mineral nutrition of plants in 1828, advocated the use of mineral N fertilizers. Chemist Justus von Liebig, on the other hand, vehemently denied around 1850 the need for N fertilization. Although it soon became evident that Sprengel was right and Liebig was wrong, not much synthetic N fertilizer was used in German agriculture until around 1915, when the Haber-Bosch technique enabled the commercial production of NH3. The use of N fertilizers since then has grown, especially since 1950. To increase agricultural productivity, German governments have promoted, directly and indirectly, the use of N in crop and in animal production. Unfortunately, it was overlooked that N surpluses in agriculture increased rapidly; around 1980 they amounted yearly to more than 100 kg ha(-1). The extensive use of N in agriculture is causing environmental damage and is contributing substantially to the external costs of present agriculture. The main N compounds that affect the environment are N2O, NH3, and NO3. These compounds are considered to contribute one third to the external costs of agriculture. Additionally, the high rate of human intake of animal proteins and lipids has adversely affected the health of the country's population. Fundamental corrections in German farm policy appear inevitable.     

Air and the origin of the experimental plant physiology.

It is well known that oxygen and carbon dioxide are two chemicals which enter the plant metabolism as nutrients. The bases of this nowadays obvious statement were placed in the 18th century by means of the works of ingenious naturalists such as Robert Boyle, Stephen Hales, Joseph Priestley, Jam Ingenhousz, Lazzaro Spallanzani and Theodore De Saussure. Till the end of the 17th century, the atmospheric air was considered as an ineffable spirit, the function of which was of physical nature. Boyle was the first naturalist to admit the possibility that respiration were an exchange of vapours occurring in the blood. Stephen Hales realised that air could be fixed by plants under the influence of solar light. Priestley showed that plants could regenerate the bad air making it breathable. Ingenhousz demonstrated that the green parts of plants performed the complete purification of air only under the influence of the light. Spallanzani discovered that plants respire and guessed that the good air (oxygen) originated from the fixed air (carbon dioxide). Finally, Theodore De Saussure showed that plants were able to adsorb carbon dioxide and to release oxygen in a proportional air. All these discoveries benefited of the results coming from investigations of scholars of the so-called "pneumatic chemistry" (Boyle himself, George Ernst Stahl, Joseph Black, Priestley himself, and many more others. But among all the eminent scientists above mentioned stands out the genius of Antoine Laurent Lavoisier, who revolutionised the chemistry of the 18th century ferrying it towards the modern chemistry.     

Partitioning of nitrogen from biological fixation and fertilizer in Phaseolus vulgaris

Nitrogen uptake, distribution and remobilization in the vegetative and reproductive parts of the plant were studied in bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) cultivars Negro Argel and Rio Tibagi inoculated with either Rhizobium strain C05 or 127 K-17. Greenhouse grown plants were supplied with 2.5 mg N (plant)⁻¹ day⁻¹ as KNO₃ or K¹⁵NO₃ and the relative contribution to total plant nitrogen of mineral and symbiotically fixed nitrogen was determined. Control plants included those entirely dependent on fixed nitrogen as well as uninoculated plants supplied with 10 mg N (plant)⁻¹ day⁻¹. No differences were observed between inoculated treatments in total nitrate reductase activity and in the amount of mineral nitrogen absorbed, but there were considerable differences in the contribution of fixed nitrogen. Nitrogen fixation supplied from 58 to 72% of the total nitrogen assimilated during the bean growth cycle and the symbiotic combinations fixed most of their nitrogen (66 to 78% of total nitrogen) after flowering. Maximum uptake of mineral nitrogen was in the 15-day-period between flowering and mid-podfill (47 to 58% of total mineral nitrogen). Nitrogen partitioning varied with Rhizobium strains, and inoculation with strain C05 increased the nitrogen harvest index of both cultivars. Applied mineral nitrogen had a variable effect and in cv. Negro Argel was more beneficial to vegetative growth, resulting in smaller nitrogen harvest indices. Seed yield was not increased by heavy nitrogen fertilization. In contrast, cv. Rio Tibagi always benefited from nitrogen applications. Among the various nitrogen sources supplying the grain, the most important one was the fixed nitrogen translocated directly from nodules or after a rapid transfer through leaves, representing from 60 to 64% of the total nitrogen incorporated into the seeds.     

Effects of drought on nitrogen fixation in soybean root nodules

Soybean plants [Glycine max (L.) Merr.] were grown in silica sand and were drought stressed for a 4 week period during reproductive development and without any mineral N supply in order to maximize demand for fixed nitrogen. A strain of Bradyrhizobium japonicum that forms large quantities of polysaccharide in nodules was used to determine whether or not the supply of reduced carbon to bacteroids limits nitrogenase activity. A depression of 30–40% in nitrogen content in leaves and pods of stressed plants indicated a marked decline in nitrogen fixation activity during the drought period. A 50% increase in the accumulation of bacterial polysaccharide in nodules accompanied this major decrease in nitrogen fixation activity and this result indicates that the negative impact of drought on nodules was not due to a depression of carbon supply to bacteroids. The drought treatment resulted in a statistically significant increase in N concentration in leaves and pods. Because N concentration and chlorophyll concentration in leaves were not depressed, there was no evidence of nitrogen deficiency in drought‐stressed plants, and this result indicates that the negative impact of drought on nodule function was not the cause of the depression of shoot growth. At the end of the drought period, the concentration of carbohydrates, amino nitrogen, and ureides was significantly increased in nodules on drought‐stressed plants. The overall results support the view that, under drought conditions, nitrogen fixation activity in nodules was depressed because demand for fixed N to support growth was lower.     

Plant symbiotic mutants as a tool to analyse nitrogen nutrition and yield relationship in field-growth peas (Pisum sativum L.)

Pisum sativum L. is known for high seed and protein yields but also for.yield instability. Because legumes utilize two sources of nitrogen (atmospheric N₂ fixed in nodules and assimilation of soil mineral N), studies on their nitrogen nutrition is more complex than in other plants. In this work, pea symbiotic mutants (with no nodules at all ([Nod^-]), with inefficient nodules ([Nod⁺Fix^-]) or showing an hypernodulating and a ‘nitrate-tolerant symbiosis’ character ([Nod⁺⁺Nts]), their semi-leafless isogenic homologues and the parental control line cv Frisson were fertilized with three levels of mineral nitrogen (0, 25 or 50 g N m^-2) to generate a range of mineral nitrogen regimes in the same genetic background. Impact of the source and level of nitrogen nutrition was measured on reproductive development, growth, nitrogen accumulation and seed yield. It was shown that a N deficiency induced flowering termination. It also led to a large decrease in the number of seeds produced and the amount of N accumulated in forage and in seeds, when little effect was observed on the progression rates of reproductive stages along the stem. The single seed weight and the amount of dry matter accumulated in forage neither responded strongly to N deficiency. The source of nitrogen was shown to be of little importance to yield but the application of about 50 g N m^-2 was necessary to reach the yield of the control cv Frisson when exclusive assimilation was ensuring the N requirements of the plant. Despite the fact that the nitrate-tolerant and hypernodulating mutant P64 used in this study did not yield as well as the parent cv Frisson, it is proposed that [Nod⁺⁺Nts] characters could act as a yield regulating factor.     

Nitrogen fixation in several grain legume species with contrasting sensitivities to copper nutrition

The nitrogen fixation response to copper nutrition in faba bean, yellow lupin and soybean was studied. Copper nutrition significantly increased the pod yields of all tested grain legumes but faba bean gave the greatest Cu-use efficiency for pod and grain production. The accumulation of dry matter in vegetative parts, nodules, N and leghemoglobin concentration in nodules and nitrogen accumulation in the whole plants were increased by copper supply in faba bean and yellow lupin in contrast with soybean. Cu nutrition significantly increased the Cu concentrations in nodules of all cultivated plants. The differential sensitivity of N₂ fixation in tested grain legume species to copper nutrition could be connected with the level of phenols in nodules and depended on both the host plants and strains of rhizobia, which differ in their ability to produce catechol-like siderophores. Copper requirements by symbiotic N₂ fixation could also depend on the nature of phenols in nodules (presence of o-dihydroxyphenols or number of hydroxyls in molecule).     

Growth, nutrition, and nitrogen fixation in grey alder at varied rate of nitrogen addition

Seedlings of grey alder (Alnus incana Moench), nodulated or unnodulated, were investigated at varied relative addition rate of nitrogen. Nitrogen fixation alone, without addition of mineral nitrogen, resulted in an almost optimum nitrogen status but only about half the maximum relative growth rate, probably mainly because of energy costs of nodulation and fixation. The growth deficit due to nodulation was much more than can be explained by the theoretical energy requirement for the amount of nitrogen fixed. Thus, the nitrogen fixation process was not very efficiently used. The nitrogen fixation rate was strongly stimulated by increasing nitrogen addition rate up to high levels. The fixation rate decreased rapidly close to optimum (maximum relative growth rate) and was negligible at maximum growth. A feed-back of mineral nitrogen on photosynthesis increased fixation rate with time, and the relative importance of fixation over mineral nitrogen nutrition increased. However, nitrogen fixation, also at maximum rate, supplied only a small proportion of the nitrogen amount required for maximum growth. The optimum nutrient solutions contained comparatively high nitrogen concentrations to secure free access to nitrogen. The nodules were damaged by this treatment, and it is concluded that the nitrogen additions must be adjusted to the current consumption of the plants to avoid an increased external nitrogen concentration. Strong linear regressions were found between relative growth rate, nitrogen status expressed as percentage content of fresh weight, and relative growth rate in unnodulated seedlings. There was a greater variability in nodulated seedlings than in unnodulated ones, because of the nitrogen fixation. The reactions of unnodulated grey alder were largely the same as previously reported for birch seedlings, but the maximum growth capacity was lower in grey alder. During an initial period of change in the internal nitrogen status, deficiency symptoms appeared, especially in unnodulated seedlings. As in birch, the leaves turned green again at stable nitrogen status, independent of level. The results are in sharp contrast to data from the literature where the external nitrogen concentration was used as the driving variable for the internal nitrogen status. The measured fixation rates for grey alder are much higher than those previously reported. Still, the maximum fixation rate observed is small compared to the total nitrogen uptake rate required for maximum growth, in contrast to reported relationships. These comparisons indicate that increased external nitrogen concentration obscures the real relations between mineral and fixed nitrogen, on one hand because of rapid inhibition of nitrogen fixation and, on the other hand, because of failure to obtain stable optimum nutrition and maximum growth by means of this treatment variable.     

Malate plays a central role in plant nutrition

Malate occupies a central role in plant metabolism. Its importance in plant mineral nutrition is reflected by the role it plays in symbiotic nitrogen fixation, phosphorus acquisition, and aluminum tolerance. In nitrogen-fixing root nodules, malate is the primary substrate for bacteroid respiration, thus fueling nitrogenase. Malate also provides the carbon skeletons for assimilation of fixed nitrogen into amino acids. During phosphorus deficiency, malate is frequently secreted from roots to release unavailable forms of phosphorus. Malate is also involved with plant adaptation to aluminum toxicity. To define the genetic and biochemical regulation of malate formation in plant nutrition we have isolated and characterized genes involved in malate metabolism from nitrogen-fixing root nodules of alfalfa and those involved in organic acid excretion from phosphorus-deficient proteoid roots of white lupin. Moreover, we have overexpressed malate dehydrogenase in alfalfa in attempts to improve nutrient acquisition. This report is an overview of our efforts to understand and modify malate metabolism, particularly in the legumes alfalfa and white lupin.     

Theoretical and practical approaches to the genetic specificity of mineral nutrition of plants

Summary Mineral nutrition of plants is one of the most important factors controlling biomass production. However, the efficiency of utilizing certain elements of mineral nutrition in biomass production is highly related to the genetic specificity of plants. The present paper deals with problems and former results regarding plant mineral nutrition presented from the genetic aspects. Particular attention has been devoted to the increased efficiency of using both the natural fertility of soils and mineral fertilizers by creating and utilizing suitable cultivars and hybrids, increased efficiency of using mineral nutrients under certain ecological conditions, plant-specific role of microorganisms in enriching soil with nitrogen and soluble forms of other elements, role of genetic specificity of mineral nutrition in plants in solving the problems of environmental pollution, principles of evaluating the genetic specificity of mineral nutrition in plants, genotype features influencing uptake of mineral nutrients, criteria for evaluating the genetic specificity of mineral nutrition of plants, and also to the methods for selecting genotypes for specific soil types, and mineral nutrition.     

Influence of boron and calcium on the tolerance to salinity of nitrogen-fixing pea plants

The effects of different levels of B (from 9.3 to 93 M B) and Ca (from 0.68 to 5.44 mM Ca) on plant development, nitrogen fixation, and mineral composition of pea (Pisum sativum L. cv. Argona) grown in symbiosis with Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae 3841 and under salt stress, were analysed. The addition of extra B and extra Ca to the nutrient solution prevented the reduction caused by 75 mM NaCl of plant growth and the inhibition of nodulation and nitrogen fixation. The number of nodules recovered by the increase of Ca concentration at any B level, but only nodules developed at high B and high Ca concentrations could fix nitrogen. Addition of extra B and Ca during plant growth restored nodule organogenesis and structure, which was absolutely damaged by high salt. The increase in salt tolerance of symbiotic plants mediated by B and Ca can be co-related with the recovery of the contents of some nutrients. Salinity produced a decrease of B and Ca contents both in shoots and in nodulated roots, being increased by the supplement of both elements in the nutrient solution. Salinity also reduced the content in plants of other nutrients important for plant development and particularly for symbiotic nitrogen fixation, as K and Fe. A balanced nutrition of B and Ca (55.8 M B, 2.72 mM Ca) was able to counter-act the deficiency of these nutrients in salt-stressed plants, leading to a huge increase in salinity tolerance of symbiotic pea plants. The necessity of nutritional studies to successfully cultivate legumes in saline soils is discussed and proposed.     

Non-leguminous root nodules in Japan

Summary Among plants native to Japan, nodule formation is confirmed in 14 species and varieties of Alnus, 10 of Elacagnus, 2 of Myrica and 1 of Coriaria, in a number of instances for the first time. Plants of 20 foreign species, in 8 genera, which bear nodules in their native countries, were raised in the nursery in Tokyo; only species of Alnus, Myrica and Ceanothus formed nodules. No nodules were found on native plants ofDryas octopetala var.asiatica. In a trial extending over 12 years evidence was obtained that the growth ofPinus thunbergii was benefited by underplanting withMyrica rubra, a result attributed to nitrogen fixation in the root nodules of the latter species. In the attempted isolation of the endophytes from the nodules of Alnus and other non-legume Angiosperms, although actinomycetes peculiar to the host species were usually obtained from the nodules, none of the isolates induced nodules in re-inoculation tests. Also from Podocarpus nodules actinomycetal and bacterial strains were commonly isolated; re-inoculation tests with these are in progress.     

Rapid assimilation of recently fixed N2 in root nodules of Myrica gale

In Myrica gale L. plants the assimilation of ammonia released by symbiotic Frankia was observed by ¹⁵N₂ labelling and subsequent analysis of the isotopic enrichment of nodule amino acids over time by single ion monitoring gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. In detached nodules of Myrica , glutamine was the first amino acid labelled at 30 s and subsequently the amino acids glutamate, aspartate, alanine and γ-amino butyric acid (GABA) became labelled. This pattern of labelling is consistent with the incorporation of ammonium via glutamine synthetase [GS; EC 6.3.1.2]. No evidence for the ammonium assimilation via glutamate dehydrogenase [GDH; EC 1.4.1.2] was observed as glutamate became labelled only after glutamine. Using attached nodules and pulse-chase labelling, we observed synthesis of glutamine, glutamate, aspartate, alanine, GABA and asparagine, and followed the transport of fixed nitrogen in the xylem largely as glutamine and asparagine. Estimation of the cost of nitrogen fixation and asparagine synthesis in Myrica nodules suggests a minimum of one sucrose required per asparagine produced. Rapid translocation of recently fixed nitrogen was observed in Myrica gale nodules as 80% of the nitrogen fixed during a 1-h period was translocated out of the nodules within 9 h. The large pool of asparagine that is present in nodules may buffer the transport of nitrogen and thus act to regulate nitrogen fixation via a feedback mechanism.     

The role of copper in nitrogen fixation in Lupinus luteus L.

The effect of copper nutrition on symbiotic N₂ fixation in Lupinus luteus L. was studied. Copper nutrition increased the yield, total nitrogen content and dry weight of nodules. The control plants did not produce pods. Copper deficiency limited iron uptake and its translocation to the nodules. Nodules of copper-deficient plants contained less than half the leghaemoglobin concentration of copper-adequate plants and about one third the polyphenol oxidase activity, tested with catechol as a substrate.     

Past, present and future of organic nutrients

Background

Slowing crop yield increases despite high fertiliser application rates, declining soil health and off-site pollution are testimony that many bioproduction systems require innovative nutrient supply strategies. One avenue is a greater contribution of organic compounds as nutrient sources for crops. That plants take up and metabolise organic molecules (‘organic nutrients’) has been discovered prior to more recent interest with scientific roots reaching far into the 19th century. Research on organic nutrients continued in the early decades of the 20th century, but after two world wars and yield increases achieved with mineral and synthetic fertilisers, a smooth continuation of the research was not to be expected, and we find major gaps in the transmission of methods and knowledge.

Scope

Addressing the antagonism of ‘organicists’ and ‘mineralists’ in plant nutrition, we illustrate how the focus of crop nutrition has shifted from organic to inorganic nutrients. We discuss reasons and provide evidence for a role of organic compounds as nutrients and signalling agents.

Conclusion

After decades of focussing on inorganic nutrients, perspectives have greatly widened again. As has occurred before in agricultural history, science has to validate agronomic practises. We argue that a framework that views plants as mixotrophs with an inherent ability to use organic nutrients, via direct uptake or aided by exoenzyme-mediated degradation, will transform nutrient management and crop breeding to complement inorganic and synthetic fertilisers with organic nutrients.     

Production process in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salicornia europaea</Emphasis> plants as a prospective phototrophic constituent in bioregenerative life support systems

Plant productivity of a common glasswort Salicornia europaea L. was investigated in relation to the type of nitrogen nutrition and as a function of macronutrient concentrations mimicking the mineral composition of human urine. The source of nutrient nitrogen had no substantial effect on productivity of Salicornia europaea. In plants grown on media with amide as a nitrogen source, the content of nitrogenous substances, including glutamic and aspartic amino acids, was higher than in plants grown with nitrate. In plants grown on media with mineral composition analogous to that of human urine, the shoots accumulated Na and K in almost equally high amounts, on the background of high and nearly equal Na and K concentrations in the nutrient media.     

Justus Liebig and the Plant Physiologists

In his book Organic Chemistryin its Application to Agriculture andChemistry, Justus Liebig attacked ``the plantphysiologists' for their support of the humustheory and for their general ignorance ofchemistry. Two leading botanists, MatthiasSchleiden and Hugo von Mohl, responded bysharply criticizing Liebig for his lack ofknowledge of plants and his misrepresentationof the views of plant physiologists. The originand character of this debate can be understoodin part through the temperaments of Liebig andSchleiden, but can be viewed also as a contestfor control between the well-establisheddiscipline of chemistry and a potentialdiscipline of plant physiology that had as yetacquired no stable institutional foundations.     

The effect of cobalt on the growth of young lucerne on a siliceous sand

Summary The nodulation and growth of young lucerne plants on a moderately acid siliceous sand were greatly increased by inoculation and the application of lime. In addition cobalt treatment significantly increased the yield of nitrogen per nodulated plant and the amount of nitrogen fixed per nodulated plant but had no effect on non-nodulated plants. Cobalt significantly increased the fresh weight of nodules per plant, due to greater nodule size. Furthermore the amount of nitrogen fixed per unit fresh weight of nodular tissue was substantially increased. The effects of cobalt on symbiotic nitrogen fixation led to significant increases (29 to 77 per cent) in the dry-matter yield of lucerne tops.     

Genetic specificity of nitrogen nutrition in leguminous plants

Summary Mineral nitrogen did not increase grain yield and seed protein levels ofVicia faba L. andLupinus luteus L. in field trials and pot experiments. Fixed N₂ was substituted by mineral nitrogen in these cases because of inhibition of N₂ fixation by mineral nitrogen. Contrary to these results mineral nitrogen increased grain yields and seed protein amounts ofLupinus albus L.,Pisum sativum L., andGlycine max. (L.) Merr. The nitrogen effect was caused at an early stage by saving energy due to inhibition of N₂ fixation (measurement of gas exchange by means of IRGA). In case of the N application after flowering grain, yields and seed protein levels increased because the mineral N was an additional nitrogen source for plants. At this stage the plants had ceased fixing atmospheric nitrogen. The high sink activity of growing fruits induced a lack of assimilates in nodules (determined by means of¹⁴CO₂ application). The N effect was therefore the consequence of the lower assimilate pool for supplying root nodules in these plants in comparison withVicia faba L. andLupinus luteus L. Hence it follows that response to mineral nitrogen can be a criterion for discovering more effective Rhizobium-host combinations.     

Thrombolytic activity of Bacillus mesentericus at different conditions of nitrogen nutrition of a culture

The work is concerned with studying the effect exerted by different sources of nitrogen nutrition on the biosynthesis of proteinases with a thrombolytic activity by a variant of Bacillus mesentericus, strain 64, obtained with the aid of analytical selection. Protein substrates taken as a nitrogen source stimulate the synthesis of proteinases by the bacterial culture. These enzymes have a high caseinolytic and thrombolytic activity, and the level of their activity correlates with the amount of a protein substrate added to the medium. Ammonium acetate and succinate are the best stimulants for the formation of proteinases when the salts of mineral and organic acids are used as a source of nitrogen nutrition. In that case, the enzymes have a high thrombolytic activity and a low caseinolytic activity. A semi-synthetic medium with the aforementioned nitrogen-containing compounds as a source of nitrogen nutrition is proposed for the synthesis of thrombolytic proteinase by the variant of B. mesentericus.     

Symbiotic leghemoglobins are crucial for nitrogen fixation in legume root nodules but not for general plant growth and development

Hemoglobins are ubiquitous in nature and among the best-characterized proteins. Genetics has revealed crucial roles for human hemoglobins, but similar data are lacking for plants. Plants contain symbiotic and nonsymbiotic hemoglobins; the former are thought to be important for symbiotic nitrogen fixation (SNF). In legumes, SNF occurs in specialized organs, called nodules, which contain millions of nitrogen-fixing rhizobia, called bacteroids. The induction of nodule-specific plant genes, including those encoding symbiotic leghemoglobins (Lb), accompanies nodule development. Leghemoglobins accumulate to millimolar concentrations in the cytoplasm of infected plant cells prior to nitrogen fixation and are thought to buffer free oxygen in the nanomolar range, avoiding inactivation of oxygen-labile nitrogenase while maintaining high oxygen flux for respiration. Although widely accepted, this hypothesis has never been tested in planta. Using RNAi, we abolished symbiotic leghemoglobin synthesis in nodules of the model legume Lotus japonicus. This caused an increase in nodule free oxygen, a decrease in the ATP/ADP ratio, loss of bacterial nitrogenase protein, and absence of SNF. However, LbRNAi plants grew normally when fertilized with mineral nitrogen. These data indicate roles for leghemoglobins in oxygen transport and buffering and prove for the first time that plant hemoglobins are crucial for symbiotic nitrogen fixation.