The mechanism of hydrogen photoproduction by several algae

Summary The contribution of PS II to H₂ photoproduction by several unicellular green algae was measured both when O₂ evolution and photophosphorylation were unimpaired and also when these processes had been eliminated by Cl-CCP. As judged by the effects of DCMU, a PS II contribution was found under both sets of experimental conditions for several strains of Chlorella, Ankistrodesmus and Scenedesmus. However, H₂ photoproduction by Chlamydomonas moewusii was insensitive to DCMU and thus was entirely due to PS I. With cells treated with Cl-CCP, the relative amount of PS II contribution varied from zero in autotrophically grown Chlamydomonas reinhardii, to 20% in photoheterotrophically grown and 50% in autotrophically grown cells of Ankistrodesmus braunii, Chlorella fusca, Chlorella vulgaris and Scenedesmus obliquus. The dehydrogenation of reduced H-donors by PS II of Scenedesmus treated with Cl-CCP showed the same biphasic kinetics previously described for H₂ photoproduction by PS I of this alga.Abbreviations Cl-CCP carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone - DCMU 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea - ICC Indiana Culture Collection - PS photosystem - SAL salicylaldoxime - SIO Marine Botany Culture Collection, Scripps Institution of Oceanography These studies were supported by contract No. AT-(40-1)-2687 from the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission.     

Light-dependent hydrogen evolution by Scenedesmus

Summary The effect of glucose and the uncoupler Cl-CCP upon hydrogen production was studied in adapted cells of Scenedesmus obliquus D₃. Cl-CCP at 10^-5M concentration completely inhibited the evolution of H₂ in the dark and increased the apparent rate of H₂ evolution in the light. At 10^-5M Cl-CCP, photosynthesis and photoreduction by anaerobically adapted algae were only temporarily inhibited; O₂ evolution reappeared after approximately 1 hr of illumination if CO₂ was present. Increasing the Cl-CCP concentration to 5 x 10^-5M led to a maximum rate of photohydrogen production and fully inhibited H₂ evolution, photoreduction and dark H₂ evolution. H₂ evolution was accompanied by a release of varying amounts of CO₂ in the light, as well as in the dark. Dark CO₂ production was stimulated by Cl-CCP. H₂ evolution in the light was stimulated by adding glucose to autotrophically grown cells or by growing the cells heterotrophically with glucose; starvation had an opposite effect. Adapted cells released ¹⁴CO₂ from the 3 and/or 4 position of specifically labeled glucose, indicating that degradation occurred via the Embden-Meyerhof pathway. The amount of H₂ released by autotrophically grown cells was the same either with continuous illumination or with short periods of light, followed by darkness. Scenedesmus mutant No. 11, which is unable to evolve O₂ was not inhibited in its capacity to evolve H₂ in the light. These data indicate that the evolution of H₂ in the light by adapted Scenedesmus depends upon the degradation of organic material and does not require the production of free O₂ by photosystem II.The following abbreviations are used: Cl-CCP = carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone; DCMU = 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea, DNP = 2,4-dinitrophenol.This work was supported by contract AT-(40-1)-2687 from the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission.     

Efficiency of hydrogen photoproduction by chloroplast-bacterial hydrogenase systems

A comparative study of H₂ photoproduction by chloroplasts and solubilized chlorophyll was performed in the presence of hydrogenase preparations of Clostridium butyricum. The photoproduction of H₂ by chloroplasts in the absence of exogenous electron donors, and with irreversibly oxidized dithiothreitol and cysteine, is thought to be limited by a cyclic transport of electrons wherein methylviologen short-circuits the electron transport in photosystem I. The efficiency of H₂ photoproduction by chloroplasts with ascorbate and NADPH is limited by a back reaction between light-reduced methylviologen and the oxidized electron donors. The use of a combination of electron donors (dithiothreitol and ascorbate), providing anaerobiosis without damage to chloroplasts, makes it possible to avoid consumption of reduced methylviologen for the reduction of oxidized electron donors and to exclude the short-circuiting of electron transfer. Under these conditions, photoproduction of H₂ was observed to occur with a rate of 350 to 400 micromoles H₂ per milligram chlorophyll per hour. In this case, the full electron-transferring capability of photosystem I (measured by irreversible photoreduction of methyl red or O₂) is used to produce H₂.     

Photoproduction of hydrogen by photosystem I of Scenedesmus

Summary Anaerobically adapted and illuminated Scenedesmus evolves molecular hydrogen from endogenous organic compounds. This photoproduction of H₂ does not require photosystem II, since 5x10^-6 M DCMU, which inhibited normal photosynthesis almost completely, did not significantly inhibit the photoevolution of H₂. The relative efficiencies in far-red light of photosynthesis, photoreduction and H₂ production were determined. Photohydrogen evolution was comparatively the most efficient of these three processes. Three mutants of Scenedesmus (isolated and characterized by Dr. N. I. Bishop) were also tested. Mutant PS-50, which lacks cytochrome 552, did not photoproduce H₂. Mutant No. 11, blocked in photosystem II, showed rates of H₂ production comparable to those of the wild type. Cl-CCP, an uncoupler of photophosphorylation, caused an apparent stimulation of H₂ production by mutant No. 11 and wild-type cells. Mutant No. 8, which is partially blocked in photosystem I, showed a diminished photohydrogen production which was inhibited by Cl-CCP. These results suggest that photoproduction of hydrogen by photosystem I is due either to cyclic photophosphorylation, which supplies energy needed for a dark, H₂-yielding reaction, or to a more direct photooxidation of organic compounds by the photosynthetic electron transfer chain.The following abbreviations were used: Cl-CCP=carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone; DCMU=3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea.This work was supported by contract AT-(40-1)-2687 from the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission to Professor H. Gaffron.     

Nitrogen fixation and photoproduction of molecular hydrogen by Thiorhodaceae

Summary Nitrogen fixation has been shown to be a characteristic of two previously untested strains of the purple sulfur bacteriumChromatium sp.Chromatium strains have been shown to produce molecular hydrogen when suppliedD-L malate and bicarbonate in the presence of light and the absence of exogenous ammonia and molecular nitrogen. These results are discussed in relation to current findings on the nitrogen metabolism of the photosynthetic bacteria. Supported in part by grants from the Rockefeller Foundation, the Atomic Energy Commission, and the Research Committee of the Graduate School from funds provided by the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation.     

Increased photoproduction of hydrogen by non-autotrophic mutants of Rhodopseudomonas capsulata.

Non-autotrophic ( Aut -) mutants of Rhodopseudomonas capsulata B10 were tested for their efficiency of nitrogenase-mediated H2 production. Three of these mutants ( IR3 , IR4 and IR5 ) showed an increase stoichiometry of H2 production, mediated by nitrogenase, from certain organic substrates. For example, in a medium containing 7 mM-L-glutamate as nitrogen source, strain IR4 produced 10-20% more H2 than did the wild type with DL-lactate or L-malate as major carbon source, 20-50% more H2 with DL-malate, and up to 70% more with D-malate. Strain IR4 was deficient in 'uptake' hydrogenase activity as measured by H2-dependent reduction of Methylene Blue or Benzyl Viologen. However, this observation did not explain the increased efficiency of H2 production, since H2 uptake (H2 recycling) was undetectable in cells of the wild type. Instead, increased H2 production by the mutant appeared to be due to an improved conversion of organic substrates to H2 and CO2, presumably due to an altered carbon metabolism. The metabolism of D-malate by different strains was studied. An NAD+-dependent D-malic enzyme was synthesized constitutively by the wild type, and showed a Km for D-malate of 3 mM. The activity of this enzyme was approx. 50% higher in strain IR4 than in the wild type, and the mutant also grew twice as fast as the wild type with D-malate as sole carbon source.     

Sustained hydrogen photoproduction by Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: Effects of culture parameters

The green alga, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, is capable of sustained H(2) photoproduction when grown under sulfur-deprived conditions. This phenomenon is a result of the partial deactivation of photosynthetic O(2)-evolution activity in response to sulfur deprivation. At these reduced rates of water-oxidation, oxidative respiration under continuous illumination can establish an anaerobic environment in the culture. After 10-15 hours of anaerobiosis, sulfur-deprived algal cells induce a reversible hydrogenase and start to evolve H(2) gas in the light. Using a computer-monitored photobioreactor system, we investigated the behavior of sulfur-deprived algae and found that: (1) the cultures transition through five consecutive phases: an aerobic phase, an O(2)-consumption phase, an anaerobic phase, a H(2)-production phase and a termination phase; (2) synchronization of cell division during pre-growth with 14:10 h light:dark cycles leads to earlier establishment of anaerobiosis in the cultures and to earlier onset of the H(2)-production phase; (3) re-addition of small quantities of sulfate (12.5-50 microM MgSO(4), final concentration) to either synchronized or unsynchronized cell suspensions results in an initial increase in culture density, a higher initial specific rate of H(2) production, an increase in the length of the H(2)-production phase, and an increase in the total amount of H(2) produced; and (4) increases in the culture optical density in the presence of 50 microM sulfate result in a decrease in the initial specific rates of H(2) production and in an earlier start of the H(2)-production phase with unsynchronized cells. We suggest that the effects of sulfur re-addition on H(2) production, up to an optimal concentration, are due to an increase in the residual water-oxidation activity of the algal cells. We also demonstrate that, in principle, cells synchronized by growth under light:dark cycles can be used in an outdoor H(2)-production system without loss of efficiency compared to cultures that up until now have been pre-grown under continuous light conditions.     

Photoproduction of hydrogen by adapted cells of Chlorella pyrenoidosa

Photoproduction of hydrogen gas by the green alga Chlorella pyrenoidosa was studied in a large scale culture of 2.1. Hydrogen was produced by adding sodium hydrosulfite directly to an algal suspension after anaerobiosis in darkness for activation of hydrogenase. The hydrogen production rate showed a characteristic course of an initial burst of gas then steady production, and this course appeared most clearly at cell concentrations around 0.6–0.7 kg/m³. In the final third phase, the hydrogen production rate gradually decreased until evolution ceased. The steady hydrogen evolution was inhibited 75% by a herbicide, DCMU, which blocks electron flow through photosystem II, indicating that the electron donor for hydrogen production was mainly water. The average light intensity within the culture vessel was measured with a diffusing sphere photoprobe. The rate of hydrogen evolution increased hyperbolically with the average light intensity. The duration of hydrogen photoproduction was shorter at higher light intensity due to the inhibition of hydrogenase by concomitantly released oxygen. The duration was shorter also at higher concentrations of algal suspension. It was foudd that the optimum concentration of algae, about 0.7 kg/m³ in this system, must be selected to maximize the yield of hydrogen.     

Ascorbate as a substrate for photoproduction of hydrogen by photosystem I of chloroplasts

The photoproduction of hydrogen by 2-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea (DCMU)-inhibited chloroplasts from ascorbate under anaerobic conditions was studied in the pH range 5.0 to 7.5 using methyl viologen (MV), N,N,N′,N′-tetramethyl-P-phenylenediamine (TMPD), and excess hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans. (a) At neutral and basic pHs, the photoreduction of MV, which reacted back with photoxidized ascorbate (dehydroascorbate [DHASC]), and the rates of H₂ photoproduction were very low. The slow H₂ photoproduction was explained by the reversible reduction of MV by the photoproduced H₂ (catalyzed by hydrogenase) and its reoxidation by DHASC resulting in H₂ uptake. (b) At pH 5.2, relatively high initial rates of H₂ photoproduction were obtained, which were comparable to the rates of O₂ consumption at pH 5.2 by photosystem I (catalyzed by photoreduced MV). However, accumulation of photoreduced MV under anaerobic conditions was not detected. In the presence of high concentrations of protons, the H₂ uptake by DHASC was very slow because the equilibrium concentration of H₂-reduced MV was very small, thus allowing H₂ evolution mediated by photoreduced MV to compete with the back reaction with DHASC. (c) The continuous accumulation of DHASC, which was generated together with H₂, gradually slowed the H₂ evolution until it stopped after about 3 hours. At high concentrations, DHASC was able to compete with the coupling of photoreduced MV to hydrogenase and H₂ evolution. (d) Dithiothreitol (DTT) reduced the DHASC and consequently competed with the back reaction of the photoreduced and H₂-reduced MV with DHASC. DTT thus prolonged the time period of H₂ photoproduction from ascorbate and abolished the dependence of its rate on pH in the range of 5.2 to 7.5 (e) A study of H₂ uptake by chemically oxidized ascorbate (in the dark) showed that MV and hydrogenase were both required to catalyze electron transfer from H₂ to DHASC. TMPD prevented this H₂ consumption by DHASC (in a chloroplast reaction mixture containing MV and hydrogenase). Illumination restored the H₂ uptake presumably by generating reduced MV which activated the hydrogenase.     

A comparison of hydrogen photoproduction by sulfur-deprived Chlamydomonas reinhardtii under different growth conditions

Continuous photoproduction of H(2) by the green alga, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, is observed after incubating the cultures for about a day in the absence of sulfate and in the presence of acetate. Sulfur deprivation causes the partial and reversible inactivation of photosynthetic O(2) evolution in algae, resulting in the light-induced establishment of anaerobic conditions in sealed photobioreactors, expression of two [FeFe]-hydrogenases in the cells, and H(2) photoproduction for several days. We have previously demonstrated that sulfur-deprived algal cultures can produce H(2) gas in the absence of acetate, when appropriate experimental protocols were used (Tsygankov, A.A., Kosourov, S.N., Tolstygina, I.V., Ghirardi, M.L., Seibert, M., 2006. Hydrogen production by sulfur-deprived Chlamydomonas reinhardtii under photoautotrophic conditions. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 31, 1574-1584). We now report the use of an automated photobioreactor system to compare the effects of photoautotrophic, photoheterotrophic and photomixotrophic growth conditions on the kinetic parameters associated with the adaptation of the algal cells to sulfur deprivation and H(2) photoproduction. This was done under the experimental conditions outlined in the above reference, including controlled pH. From this comparison we show that both acetate and CO(2) are required for the most rapid inactivation of photosystem II and the highest yield of H(2) gas production. Although, the presence of acetate in the system is not critical for the process, H(2) photoproduction under photoautotrophic conditions can be increased by optimizing the conditions for high starch accumulation. These results suggest ways of engineering algae to improve H(2) production, which in turn may have a positive impact on the economics of applied systems for H(2) production.     

Effect of oxygen removal on hydrogen photoproduction in algae

Hydrogen photoproduction from water in Scenedesmus cells requires removal of oxygen by a reagent in contact with the algae. Both deoxyhemoglobin and deoxymyoglobin stimulated hydrogen production by reversible absorption of oxygen. Their effectiveness was greatly increased when other oxygen-combining reagents were present in a separate chamber with deoxyhemoglobin and deoxymyoglobin serving as reversible oxygen transfer agents.     

Long-term endurance and selection studies in hydrogen and oxygen photoproduction by Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Two wild-type strains of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii have been subjected to repeated cycles of anaerobiosis, carbon dioxide deprivation, and irradiation as a means of testing the long-term stability of hydrogen and oxygen photoproduction and the effectiveness of these conditions as selection or adaptation pressures for increasing hydrogen and/or oxygen yields. Simultaneous hydrogen and oxygen photoproduction yields were monitored in each culture for 160 h. The cells were then removed from the reaction chamber and used to inoculate fresh growth medium to produce the culture for the next experiment. This cycle was repeated five times. Yields of hydrogen and oxygen improved after three cycles and declined in the fourth and fifth; unlike the second and third cycles, extended periods of aerobic growth were used for the fourth and fifth cycles. The stability of hydrogen and oxygen photoproduction was greater in the fifth cycle than in any of the previous cycles. These subpopulations had hydrogen and oxygen production rates, at 160 h, which were nearly equal to the rates at the beginning of the fifth-cycle experiments. Time profiles of the relative hydrogen yields from each of the five cycles, prepared at 32, 80, and 120 h, show that the relative yield in each varies with the point in time at which the profile was taken. Chlorophyll retention increased with each successive cycle, indicating selection or adaptation for a more durable population of cells with respect to the light-harvesting component of the photosynthetic apparatus.     

Autotrophic and mixotrophic hydrogen photoproduction in sulfur-deprived chlamydomonas cells

In Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cells, H2 photoproduction can be induced in conditions of sulfur deprivation in the presence of acetate. The decrease in photosystem II (PSII) activity induced by sulfur deprivation leads to anoxia, respiration becoming higher than photosynthesis, thereby allowing H2 production. Two different electron transfer pathways, one PSII dependent and the other PSII independent, have been proposed to account for H2 photoproduction. In this study, we investigated the contribution of both pathways as well as the acetate requirement for H2 production in conditions of sulfur deficiency. By using 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea (DCMU), a PSII inhibitor, which was added at different times after the beginning of sulfur deprivation, we show that PSII-independent H2 photoproduction depends on previously accumulated starch resulting from previous photosynthetic activity. Starch accumulation was observed in response to sulfur deprivation in mixotrophic conditions (presence of acetate) but also in photoautotrophic conditions. However, no H2 production was measured in photoautotrophy if PSII was not inhibited by DCMU, due to the fact that anoxia was not reached. When DCMU was added at optimal starch accumulation, significant H2 production was measured. H2 production was enhanced in autotrophic conditions by removing O2 using N2 bubbling, thereby showing that substantial H2 production can be achieved in the absence of acetate by using the PSII-independent pathway. Based on these data, we discuss the possibilities of designing autotrophic protocols for algal H2 photoproduction.     

Stimulation of hydrogen photoproduction in algae by removal of oxygen by reagents that combine reversibly with oxygen

Hydrogen photoproduction from water by Scenedesmus cells was achieved in the presence of reagents that combine reversibly with oxygen. The oxygen can be subsequently released, and H(2) and O(2) are obtained in the 2:1 ratio expected for H(2)O photolysis. This was accomplished in an experimental design which facilitates rapid transfer of gases and the use of a variety of water-soluble and DMSO-soluble chelates of cobalt which combine reversibly with oxygen.     

Luminescence decay kinetics in relation to quenching and stimulation of dark fluorescence from high and low CO2 adapted cells of Scenedesmus obliquus and Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Two green algal species, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and Scenedesmus obliquus, exhibited a relative maximum during the decay of luminescence, when adapted to low CO₂ conditions that was not observed in high CO₂ adapted cells.From the kinetics of transient changes in the level of dark fluorescence, after illumination and parallel to the luminescence maxima, it was concluded that the maximum in Scenedesmus was mainly related to a decrease in nonphotochemical quenching, whereas in Chlamydomonas the maximum was mainly related to a dark reduction of the primary PS II acceptor Q_A.ATP/ADP ratios from low CO₂ adapted Scenedesmus showed transient high levels after a dark/light transition that was not observed in high CO₂ adapted cells. After 30 s of illumination the ATP/ADP ratios however stabilized at the same steady state level as in high CO₂ adapted cells.Dark addition of HCO₃ ^- to low CO₂ adapted cells of Chlamydomonas resulted in a rapid transient quenching of luminescence that was not observed in low CO₂ adapted cells of neither species.It is concluded that the luminescence maxima present in both low CO₂ adapted Scenedesmus and Chlamydomonas reflect adaptation of the cells to low CO₂ conditions. It is further suggested that the difference in mechanistic origin of luminescence maxima in the two species reflects differences in adaptation.Abbreviations ADP adenosine-diphosphate - ATP adenosine-triphosphate - C_i inorganic carbon - F_D dark fluorescence recorded under dark adapted conditions - F₀ fluorescence with all reaction centers open - FV variable fluorescence - PS I photosystem I - PS II photosystem II - Q_A the first quinone acceptor of PS II     

Photobioreactor with photosynthetic bacteria immobilized on porous glass for hydrogen photoproduction

A photobioreactor was constructed with porous glass as an immobilization matrix. The reactor was a rectangular glass chamber (inner dimensions: 125 × 50 × 2.5 mm) containing a porous glass sheet (125 × 50 × 0.5 mm) on which Rhodobacter sphaeroides RV was immobilized (11.2 mg dry wt./ml porous glass). The maximum rate of hydrogen evolution was 1.3 ml/h/ml porous glass. The conversion efficiency of succinate into hydrogen reached 75%. Stable and efficient hydrogen evolution continued for up to 40 d.     

Actual and potential rates of hydrogen photoproduction by continuous culture of the purple non-sulphur bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus

The influence of (NH₄)₂SO₄ concentration and dilution rate (D) on actual and potential H₂ photoproduction has been studied in ammonium-limited chemostat cultures of Rhodobacter capsulatus B10. The actual H₂ production in a photobioreactor was maximal (approx. 80 ml h⁻¹l⁻¹) at D = 0.06 h⁻¹ and 4 mM (NH₄)₂SO₄. However, it was lower than the potential H₂ evolution (calculated from hydrogen evolution rates in incubation vials), which amounted to 100–120 ml h⁻¹ l⁻¹ at D = 0.03–0.08 h⁻¹. Taking into account the fact that H₂ production in the photobioreactor under these conditions was not limited by light or lactate, another limiting (inhibiting) factor should be sought. One possibility is an inhibition of H₂ production by the H₂ accumulated in the gas phase. This is apparent from the non-linear kinetics of H₂ evolution in the vials or from its inhibition by the addition of H₂; initial rates were restored in both cases after the vials had been refilled with argon. The actual H₂ production in the photobioreactor at D = 0.06 h⁻¹ was shown to increase from approximately 80 ml h⁻¹ l⁻¹ to approximately 100 ml h⁻¹ l⁻¹ under an argon flow at 100 ml min⁻¹. Under maximal H₂ production rates in the photobioreactor, up to 30% of the lactate feedstock was utilised for H₂ production and 50% for biomass synthesis. Received: 22 April 1997 / Received revision: 14 July 1997 / Accepted: 27 July 1997