Metal ion catalysis during the exon-ligation step of nuclear pre-mRNA splicing: extending the parallels between the spliceosome and group II introns

Mechanistic analyses of nuclear pre-mRNA splicing by the spliceosome and group II intron self-splicing provide insight into both the catalytic strategies of splicing and the evolutionary relationships between the different splicing systems. We previously showed that 3'-sulfur substitution at the 3' splice site of a nuclear pre-mRNA has no effect on splicing. We now report that 3'-sulfur substitution at the 3' splice site of a nuclear pre-mRNA causes a switch in metal specificity when the second step of splicing is monitored using a bimolecular exon-ligation assay. This suggests that the spliceosome uses a catalytic metal ion to stabilize the 3'-oxyanion leaving group during the second step of splicing, as shown previously for the first step. The lack of a metal-specificity switch under cis splicing conditions indicates that a rate-limiting conformational change between the two steps of splicing may mask the subsequent chemical step and the metal-specificity switch. As the group II intron, a true ribozyme, uses identical catalytic strategies for splicing, our results strengthen the argument that the spliceosome is an RNA catalyst that shares a common molecular ancestor with group II introns.     

Branch-point attack in group II introns is a highly reversible transesterification, providing a potential proofreading mechanism for 5'-splice site selection.

By examining the first step of group II intron splicing in the absence of the second step, we have found that there is an interplay of three distinct reactions at the 5'-splice site: branching, reverse branching, and hydrolytic cleavage. This approach has yielded the first kinetic parameters describing eukaryotic branching and establishes that group II intron catalysis can proceed on a rapid timescale. The efficient reversibility of the first step is due to increased conformational organization in the branched intermediate and it has several important mechanistic implications. Reversibility in the first step requires that the second step of splicing serve as a kinetic trap, thus driving splicing to completion and coordinating the first and second step of splicing. Facile reverse branching also provides the intron with a proofreading mechanism to control the fidelity of 5'-splice site selection and it provides a kinetic basis for the apparent mobility of group II introns.     

Dynamics in the U6 RNA intramolecular stem-loop: a base flipping conformational change

The U6 RNA intramolecular stem-loop (ISL) structure is an essential component of the spliceosome and binds a metal ion required for pre-messenger RNA splicing. The metal binding internal loop region of the stem contains a partially protonated C67-(+)A79 base pair (pK(a) = 6.5) and an unpaired U80 nucleotide that is stacked within the helix at pH 7.0. Here, we determine that protonation occurs with an exchange lifetime of approximately 20 micros and report the solution structures of the U6 ISL at pH 5.7. The differences between pH 5.7 and 7.0 structures reveal that the pH change significantly alters the RNA conformation. At lower pH, U80 is flipped out into the major groove. Base flipping involves a purine stacking interaction of flanking nucleotides, inversion of the sugar pucker 5' to the flipped base, and phosphodiester backbone rearrangement. Analysis of residual dipolar couplings as a function of pH indicates that base flipping is not restricted to a local conformational change. Rather, base flipping alters the alignment of the upper and lower helices. The alternative conformations of the U6 ISL reveal striking structural similarities with both the NMR and crystal structures of domain 5 of self-splicing group II introns. These structures suggest that base flipping at an essential metal binding site is a conserved feature of the splicing machinery for both the spliceosome and group II self-splicing introns.     

Group II introns in wheat mitochondria have degenerate structural features and varied splicing pathways

Mitochondrial introns in flowering plant genes are virtually all classified as members of the group II ribozyme family although certain structural features have degenerated to varying degrees over evolutionary time. We are interested in the impact that unconventional intron architecture might have on splicing biochemistry in vivo and we have focused in particular on intronic domains V and VI, which for self-splicing introns provide a key component of the catalytic core and the bulged branchpoint adenosine, respectively. Notably, the two transesterification steps in classical group II splicing are the same as for nuclear spliceosomal introns and release the intron as a lariat. Using RT-PCR and circularized RT-PCR, we had previously demonstrated that several wheat mitochondrial introns which lack a branchpoint adenosine have atypical splicing pathways, and we have now extended this analysis to the full set of wheat introns, namely six trans-splicing and sixteen cis-splicing ones. A number of introns are excised using non-lariat pathways and interestingly, we find that several introns which do have a conventional domain VI also use pathways that appear to exploit other internal or external nucleophiles, with the lariat form being relatively minor. Somewhat surprisingly, several introns with weakly-structured domain V/VI helices still exhibit classical lariat splicing, suggesting that accessory factors aid in restoring a splicing-competent conformation. Our observations illustrate that the loss of conventional group II features during evolution is correlated with altered splicing biochemistry in an intron-distinctive manner.     

RS domain-splicing signal interactions in splicing of U12-type and U2-type introns

Serine-arginine (SR) proteins are general metazoan splicing factors that contain an essential arginine/serine-rich (RS) domain. On typical U2-type introns, RS domains contact the branchpoint and 5' splice site to promote base-pairing with U small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs). Here we analyze the role of SR proteins in splicing of U12-type introns and in the second step of U2-type intron splicing. We show that RS domains contact the branchpoint and 5' splice site of a U12-type intron. On a U2-type intron, we find that the RS domain contacts the site of the U6 snRNA-5' splice site interaction during the first step of splicing and shifts to contact the site of the U5 snRNA-exon 1 interaction during the second step. Our results reveal alternative interactions between the RS domain and 5' splice site region that coincide with remodeling of the spliceosome between the two catalytic steps.     

The spliceosome: a ribozyme at heart?

The spliceosome, the multi-megadalton molecular machine that performs splicing, consists of over 200 different proteins and five small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs). Extensive mechanistic and structural similarities to self-splicing group II introns, large ribozymes found in prokaryotes and lower eukaryotes that catalyze an identical reaction, strongly suggest that the spliceosomal RNAs are in fact the catalytic components of the spliceosome. Of the five spliceosomal RNAs, U2 and U6 are the only ones that are absolutely required for both steps of splicing. These two snRNAs form an elaborate base-paired complex that might in fact constitute the active site of the spliceosome.     

Effect of deletions at structural domains of group II intron bI1 on self-splicing in vitro

Some group II introns can undergo a protein-independent splicing reaction with the basic reaction pathway similar to nuclear pre-mRNA splicing and the catalytic functions of some of the structural components have been determined. To identify further functional domains, we have generated an ensemble of partial and complete deletions of domains I, II, III and IV of the self-splicing group II intron bI1 from yeast mitochondria and studied their effects on the splicing reaction in vitro. Our results indicate that domains II and IV, which vary considerably in length and structure among group II introns, do not play a direct role in catalysis but mainly help to ensure the proper interaction between upstream and downstream catalytically active structural elements. Deletions of sub-domains of domain I and domain III indicate that these elements are involved in 5' cleavage by hydrolysis and in a reaction in trans (exon reopening), and that this function can be inhibited without affecting the normal 5' cleavage by transesterification. Yet, we infer that the helical structures affected by the mutational alterations might not contribute to this reaction mode per se but that changes within local secondary structures perturb the internal conformation of the ribozyme. Furthermore, we have designed an abbreviated version of intron bI1, with a length of 542 nucleotides, which is still catalytically active.     

Investigation of the proposed interdomain ribose zipper in hairpin ribozyme cleavage using 2'-modified nucleosides

The hairpin ribozyme achieves catalytic cleavage through interaction of essential nucleotides located in two distinct helical domains that include internal loops. Initial docking of the two domains is ion dependent and appears to be followed by a structural rearrangement that allows the ribozyme to achieve a catalytically active state that can undergo cleavage. The proposed structural rearrangement may also be ion dependent and is now of increased importance due to recent evidence that docking is not rate limiting and that metal ions are unlikely to be involved in the chemical cleavage step. An initial structural model of the docked hairpin ribozyme included a proposal for a ribose zipper motif that involves two pairs of hydroxyl groups at A(10) and G(11) in domain A pairing with C(25) and A(24) in domain B, respectively. We have used a chemical functional group substitution technique to study whether this proposed ribose zipper is likely to be present in the active, conformationally rearranged ribozyme that is fit for cleavage. We have chemically synthesized a series of individually modified hairpin ribozymes containing 2'-analogues of nucleosides, that include 2'-deoxy and 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro at each of the four nucleoside positions, 2'-amino-2'-deoxy, 2'-deoxy-2'-thio, and 2'-arabino at position C(25), and 2'-oxyamino at position A(10), as well as some double substitutions, and we studied their cleavage rates under both single- and multiple-turnover conditions. We conclude that at least some of the hydrogen-bonding interactions in the ribose zipper motif, either as originally proposed or in a recently suggested structural variation, are unlikely to be present in the active rearranged form of the ribozyme that undergoes cleavage. Instead, we provide strong evidence for a very precise conformational positioning for the residue C(25) in the active hairpin. A precise conformational requirement would be expected for C(25) if it rearranges to form a base-triple with A(9) and the essential residue neighboring the cleavage site G(+1), as recently proposed by another laboratory. Our results provide further support for conformational rearrangement as an important step in hairpin ribozyme cleavage.     

In silico evidence for DNA polymerase-beta's substrate-induced conformational change

Structural information for mammalian DNA pol-beta combined with molecular and essential dynamics studies have provided atomistically detailed views of functionally important conformational rearrangements that occur during DNA repair and replication. This conformational closing before the chemical reaction is explored in this work as a function of the bound substrate. Anchors for our study are available in crystallographic structures of the DNA pol-beta in "open" (polymerase bound to gapped DNA) and "closed" (polymerase bound to gapped DNA and substrate, dCTP) forms; these different states have long been used to deduce that a large-scale conformational change may help the polymerase choose the correct nucleotide, and hence monitor DNA synthesis fidelity, through an "induced-fit" mechanism. However, the existence of open states with bound substrate and closed states without substrates suggest that substrate-induced conformational closing may be more subtle. Our dynamics simulations of two pol-beta/DNA systems (with/without substrates at the active site) reveal the large-scale closing motions of the thumb and 8-kDa subdomains in the presence of the correct substrate--leading to nearly perfect rearrangement of residues in the active site for the subsequent chemical step of nucleotidyl transfer--in contrast to an opening trend when the substrate is absent, leading to complete disassembly of the active site residues. These studies thus provide in silico evidence for the substrate-induced conformational rearrangements, as widely assumed based on a variety of crystallographic open and closed complexes. Further details gleaned from essential dynamics analyses clarify functionally relevant global motions of the polymerase-beta/DNA complex as required to prepare the system for the chemical reaction of nucleotide extension.     

snRNAs as the catalysts of pre-mRNA splicing

The spliceosome, the gigantic molecular machine that performs pre-mRNA splicing in eukaryotes, contains over 200 different proteins and five RNA molecules. The central role played by the spliceosomal RNAs in splicing has led to the hypothesis that, like the ribosome, the spliceosome is an RNA-centric enzyme and a relic from the RNA world. Recent structural studies have provided the first glimpses of the structural features of spliceosomal RNAs, and mutational analyses in vivo and in vitro have uncovered new functional roles for a catalytically essential domain. An emerging model for the active site of group II introns, a closely related class of natural ribozymes, is likely to provide a wealth of insights on structure and function of the active site of the spliceosome.     

The two steps of group II intron self-splicing are mechanistically distinguishable.

The two transesterification reactions catalyzed by self-splicing group II introns take place in either two active sites or two conformations of a single active site involving rearrangements of the positions of the reacting groups. We have investigated the effects on the rates of the chemical steps of the two reactions due to sulfur substitution of nonbridging oxygens at both the 5' and 3' splice sites as well as the deoxyribose substitution of the ribose 2' hydroxyl group at the 5' splice site. The data suggest that the two active sites differ in their interactions with several of these groups. Specifically, sulfur substitution of the pro-Sp nonbridging oxygen at the 5' splice site reduces the chemical rate of the step one branching reaction by at least 250-fold, whereas substitution of the pro-Sp oxygen at the 3' splice site has only a 4.5-fold effect on the chemical rate of step two. Previous work demonstrated that the Rp phosphorothioate substitutions at both the 5' and 3' splice sites reduced the rate of both steps of splicing to an undetectable level. These results suggest that either two distinct active sites catalyze the two steps or that more significant alterations must be made in a single bifunctional active site to accommodate the two different reactions.     

Group II intron in Bacillus cereus has an unusual 3' extension and splices 56 nucleotides downstream of the predicted site

All group II introns known to date fold into six functional domains. However, we recently identified an intron in Bacillus cereus ATCC 10987, B.c.I4, that splices 56nt downstream of the expected 3′ splice site in vivo (Tourasse et al. 2005, J. Bacteriol., 187, 5437–5451). In this study, we confirmed by ribonuclease protection assay that the 56-bp segment is part of the intron RNA molecule, and computational prediction suggests that it might form a stable stem-loop structure downstream of domain VI. The splicing of B.c.I4 was further investigated both in vivo and in vitro. Lariat formation proceeded primarily by branching at the ordinary bulged adenosine in domain VI without affecting the fidelity of splicing. In addition, the splicing efficiency of the wild-type intron was better than that of a mutant construct deleted of the 56-bp 3′ extension. These results indicate that the intron has apparently adapted to the extra segment, possibly through conformational adjustments. The extraordinary group II intron B.c.I4 harboring an unprecedented extra 3′ segment constitutes a dramatic example of the flexibility and adaptability of group II introns.     

Linking the branchpoint helix to a newly found receptor allows lariat formation by a group II intron

Like spliceosomal introns, the ribozyme-containing group II introns are excised as branched, lariat structures: a 2'-5' bond is created between the first nucleotide of the intron and an adenosine in domain VI, a component which is missing from available crystal structures of the ribozyme. Comparative sequence analysis, modelling and nucleotide substitutions point to the existence, and probable location, of a specific RNA receptor for the section of domain VI that lies just distal to the branchpoint adenosine. By designing oligonucleotides that tether domain VI to this novel binding site, we have been able to specifically activate lariat formation in an engineered, defective group II ribozyme. The location of the newly identified receptor implies that prior to exon ligation, the distal part of domain VI undergoes a major translocation, which can now be brought under control by the system of anchoring oligonucleotides we have developed. Interestingly, these oligonucleotides, which link the branchpoint helix and the binding site for intron nucleotides 3-4, may be viewed as counterparts of U2-U6 helix III in the spliceosome.     

The receptor for branch-site docking within a group II intron active site

The distinguishing feature of group II introns, and the property that links them with spliceosomal catalysis, is their ability to undergo splicing through branching. In this reaction, the 2'-hydroxyl group of a specific adenosine within intron domain 6 serves as the nucleophile for attack on the 5' splice site. We know less about branching than any other feature of group II intron catalysis, largely because the receptor structure for activating the branch site is unknown. Here, we identify the intronic region that binds the branch site of a group IIB intron. Located in domain 1, close to receptors for intron domain 5 and both splice sites, we demonstrate that the branch-site receptor is a functional element required for transesterification. Furthermore, we show that crosslinked branch sites can carry out both steps of splicing, suggesting that the conformational state of the intron core is set early and that it persists throughout the entire splicing process.     

A ribonuclease III domain protein functions in group II intron splicing in maize chloroplasts

Chloroplast genomes in land plants harbor approximately 20 group II introns. Genetic approaches have identified proteins involved in the splicing of many of these introns, but the proteins identified to date cannot account for the large size of intron ribonucleoprotein complexes and are not sufficient to reconstitute splicing in vitro. Here, we describe an additional protein that promotes chloroplast group II intron splicing in vivo. This protein, RNC1, was identified by mass spectrometry analysis of maize (Zea mays) proteins that coimmunoprecipitate with two previously identified chloroplast splicing factors, CAF1 and CAF2. RNC1 is a plant-specific protein that contains two ribonuclease III (RNase III) domains, the domain that harbors the active site of RNase III and Dicer enzymes. However, several amino acids that are essential for catalysis by RNase III and Dicer are missing from the RNase III domains in RNC1. RNC1 is found in complexes with a subset of chloroplast group II introns that includes but is not limited to CAF1- and CAF2-dependent introns. The splicing of many of the introns with which it associates is disrupted in maize rnc1 insertion mutants, indicating that RNC1 facilitates splicing in vivo. Recombinant RNC1 binds both single-stranded and double-stranded RNA with no discernible sequence specificity and lacks endonuclease activity. These results suggest that RNC1 is recruited to specific introns via protein-protein interactions and that its role in splicing involves RNA binding but not RNA cleavage activity.     

Protein-free spliceosomal snRNAs catalyze a reaction that resembles the first step of splicing

Splicing of introns from mRNA precursors is a two-step reaction performed by the spliceosome, an immense cellular machine consisting of over 200 different proteins and five small RNAs (snRNAs). We previously demonstrated that fragments of two of these RNAs, U6 and U2, can catalyze by themselves a splicing-related reaction, involving one of the two substrates of the first step of splicing, the branch site substrate. Here we show that these same RNAs can catalyze a reaction between RNA sequences that resemble the 5' splice site and the branch site, the two reactants of the first step of splicing. The reaction is dependent on the sequence of the 5' splice site consensus sequence and the catalytically essential domains of U6, and thus it resembles the authentic splicing reaction. Our results demonstrate the ability of protein-free snRNAs to recognize the sequences involved in the first splicing step and to perform splicing-related catalysis between these two pre-mRNA-like substrates.