Filamentous Alphaproteobacteria associated with bulking in industrial wastewater treatment plants

The phylogeny and distribution of filamentous Alphaproteobacteria, morphologically similar to “Nostocoida limicola” and Eikelboom Type 021N that cause the solids separation problem of bulking in industrial activated sludge plants is described here. A combination of culture-dependent and culture-independent molecular methods has characterized 5 novel species. 16S rRNA targeted oligonucleotide probes were designed for their in situ identification by fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) and used to monitor their presence in 86 WWTPs treating different industrial effluents in four European countries. The involvement of these bacteria in bulking in these plants was confirmed. Filaments hybridising with the ALF-968 probe for the Alphaproteobacteria were present in 65% of the WWTPs examined. They were dominant and therefore probably responsible for bulking in 25.5% of them. The heterogeneous filamentous alphaproteobacterial populations in these communities could be completely identified after application of the oligonucleotide probes used in this study in 91% of the plants containing them. The only filamentous Alphaproteobacteria retrieved in pure culture was isolated from three different industrial WWTPs plants. None of these isolates could grow anaerobically on glucose or denitrify, but all grew aerobically and heterotrophically on a range of carbon sources. Although morphologically similar to the Eikelboom Type 021N morphotype, they were not involved in sulphur metabolism. These bacteria accumulated lipidic storage granules that were associated with their presence under the unbalanced growth conditions existing in these plants.     

Isolation,characterization, and abundance of filamentous members of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Caldilineae</Emphasis> in activated sludge

Chloroflexi are currently believed to serve as backbone forming agents in the activated sludge of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). In this study, we isolated and characterized filamentous bacteria in the class Caldilineae of the phylum Chloroflexi in municipal WWTPs. Diversity analysis using Chloroflexi-specific 16S rRNA gene clone libraries showed that 97% of the clones belonged to the subdivision Anaerolineae comprising the two classes Anaerolineae (95%) and Caldilineae (2%). Clones of Caldilineae were related to a thermophilic filament Caldilinea aerophila with 93% 16S rRNA gene sequence similarity. We obtained filamentous isolates classified into the class Caldilineae showing the best match to C. aerophila with 89% 16S rRNA gene sequence similarity. Isolates showed no ability to assimilate glucose or N-acetylglucosamine or to degrade biopolymers which were observed in filamentous Chloroflexi of WWTPs. The assessment of relative abundance based on quantitative PCR of the 16S rRNA gene indicated that members of the class Caldilineae comprised 12–19% of the Chloroflexi in the activated sludge. Additionally, fluorescence in situ hybridization experiments showed that diverse filamentous Caldilineae inhabit the activated sludge of municipal WWTPs. These findings yield insight into the role of filamentous mesophilic Caldilinea in stabilizing flocs of activated sludge in a wide range of WWTPs.     

Change in surface properties of Microthrix parvicella upon addition of polyaluminium chloride as characterized by atomic force microscopy

The filamentous bacterium Microthrix parvicella causes severe separation and foaming problems at wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). An effective control of the bacterium in activated sludge WWTPs can be accomplished by dosage with polyaluminium chloride (PAX-14). The purpose of this study was to investigate whether addition of PAX-14 affects surface properties such as the hydrophobicity of the bacterium and to study the exopolymers of M. parvicella that host surface-associated enzymes. To this end, force measurements by atomic force microscopy were carried out to measure the interactions between hydrophilic and hydrophobized tips and the bacterium surface. Addition of PAX-14 caused no changes in the hydrophobicity of the bacterium surface but the data indicate that it collapsed the polymeric layer likely due to electrostatic screening. It is concluded that the collapse of the polymeric layer may affect the transport of substrates (eg free fatty acids) to the bacterium and hence the competitiveness of M. parvicella compared to the other bacteria present in activated sludge.     

Estimating biodiversity of fungi in activated sludge communities using culture-independent methods

Fungal diversity of communities in several activated sludge plants treating different influent wastes was determined by comparative sequence analyses of their 18S rRNA genes. Methods for DNA extraction and choice of primers for PCR amplification were both optimised using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis profile patterns. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that the levels of fungal biodiversity in some communities, like those treating paper pulp wastes, were low, and most of the fungi detected in all communities examined were novel uncultured representatives of the major fungal subdivisions, in particular, the newly described clade Cryptomycota. The fungal populations in activated sludge revealed by these culture-independent methods were markedly different to those based on culture-dependent data. Members of the genera Penicillium, Cladosporium, Aspergillus and Mucor, which have been commonly identified in mixed liquor, were not identified in any of these plant communities. Non-fungal eukaryotic 18S rRNA genes were also amplified with the primer sets used. This is the first report where culture-independent methods have been applied to flocculated activated sludge biomass samples to estimate fungal community composition and, as expected, the data obtained gave a markedly different view of their population biodiversity compared to that based on culture-dependent methods.     

Sludge Reduction by Predatory Activity of Aquatic Oligochaetes in Wastewater Treatment Plants: Science or Fiction? A Review

Biological aerobic wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) produce a lot of excess sludge. The costs for handling this residual product are increasing, so the search for alternative techniques to reduce the amount of sludge has to be continued. Activated sludge consists of inorganic and organic substances, bacteria, protozoa and metazoa. Due to incomplete biomass conversion, sludge consumption yields less oligochaete biomass. From a technological point of view, the application of aquatic oligochaetes to reduce the sludge production offers interesting perspectives. This paper aims to review the feasibility for the reduction of activated sludge in WWTPs by means of aquatic oligochaetes. Also the current techniques concerning sludge reduction are taken into account. Several of the WWTPs relevant parameters, which may influence predatory activity of aquatic oligochaetes, are discussed: particle size, organic content of substrate, bacteria preference, life cycle and population dynamics of aquatic oligochaetes, temperature, pH, oxygen and process conditions. From the literature it appeared that most research has been performed on laboratory scale. Only a few authors mention a significant reduction of the sludge production by ‘sessile’ species such as Lumbriculus. Vermicultures for the reduction of activated sludge are rather common in developing countries. Incidentally large annelid blooms have been noticed in WWTPs. It remains obscure which factors trigger the initiation of annelid blooms in WWTPs and which are of importance to maintain a stable annelid population in WWTPs. The influence of a considerable worm bloom on the waste sludge production is still under investigation.     

The in situ physiology of Skermania piniformis in foams in Australian activated sludge plants

The in situ physiology of the filamentous bacterium Skermania piniformis frequently seen in activated sludge foams in Australia was investigated. An oligonucleotide probe, Spin1449, targeting the 16S rRNA of S. piniformis was designed for its identification by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), validated with pure cultures and applied successfully to foam samples from two geographically distant Australian plants. While filaments of this bacterium appeared to be comparatively hydrophobic, the organism had no clear preference for hydrophobic or hydrophilic substrates. In both foams examined using microautoradiography (MAR), filaments selectively took up substrates under aerobic and anoxic (NO(3) (-)) but not anaerobic or anoxic (NO(2) (-)) conditions. Skermania piniformis assimilated oleic acid, palmitic acid, glycerol and glycine. Ectoenzyme activities detected suggest that S. piniformis has an ability to assimilate a greater range of substrates than might be concluded from the MAR data obtained here. Based on the substrate uptake data presented here, an anaerobic selector may work for controlling S. piniformis in activated sludge systems.     

Active predation,phylogenetic diversity,and global prevalence of myxobacteria in wastewater treatment plants

The operation of modern wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) is driven by activated sludge microbiota, a complex assemblage of trophically interacting microorganisms. Microbial predation is crucial to fundamental understanding of how biological interactions drive microbiome structuring and functioning of WWTPs. However, predatory bacteria have received little attention regarding their diversity, activity, and ecological function in activated sludge, limiting the exploitation of food web interactions for wastewater microbiome engineering. Here, by using rRNA-stable isotope probing of activated sludge microbiota with ¹³C-labeled prey bacteria, we uncovered diverse as-yet-uncultivated putative predatory bacteria that actively incorporated ¹³C-biomass. Myxobacteria, especially Haliangium and the mle1-27 clade, were found as the dominant active predators, refreshing conventional views based on a few predatory isolates of Bdellovibrionota from WWTPs. The identified predatory bacteria showed more selective predation on prey compared with the protists dominated by ciliates, providing in situ evidence for inter-domain predation behavior divergence in activated sludge. Putative predatory bacteria were tracked over a two-year microbiome monitoring effort at a local WWTP, revealing the predominance of Myxococcota (6.5 ± 1.3%) over Bdellovibrionota (1.0 ± 0.2%) lineages. Phylogenetic analysis unveiled highly diverse myxobacteria inhabiting activated sludge and suggested a habitat filtering effect in global WWTPs. Further mining of a global activated sludge microbiome dataset revealed the prevalence of Myxococcota (5.4 ± 0.1%) species and potential impacts of myxobacterial predation on process performance. Collectively, our findings provided unique insights into the predating activity, diversity, and prevalence of Myxococcota species in activated sludge, highlighting their links with wastewater treatment processes via trophic regulation of enteric and functional bacteria.Subject terms: Microbial ecology, Biodiversity, Environmental microbiology, Microbial ecology, Environmental sciences     

活性污泥微生物菌群研究方法进展

活性污泥是活性污泥法处理污水系统的功能主体。人类对活性污泥微生物菌群的认识随着其研究方法的发展而逐步深入。传统培养方法只能检测到活性污泥中1％～15％的微生物。随着一系列基于免培养的分子生物学技术的出现,活性污泥中菌群的复杂性和多样性以惊人的速度被人们认识,大量依靠传统检测方法未能发现却在活性污泥中起关键作用的微生物逐渐被发现。许多模拟活性污泥菌群生存环境条件的现代培养技术开始发展,且已成功培养了一部分传统培养方法不能培养的细菌类群,这为研究基于免培养方法发现的大量新的微生物菌群的生理特性和作用机制提供了可能,也无疑将把人们对活性污泥菌群的认识推向一个新的层次．主要介绍活性污泥微生物菌群研究的一系列方法,从传统培养方法到基于免培养的现代分子生物学技术,再到现代培养技术,着重论述了现代分子生物学技术及其在活性污泥微生物菌群研究中的进展。     

Effects of synthetic polymer on the filamentous bacteria in activated sludge

Filamentous bulking is one of the solid-liquid separation problems always seen in activated sludge process. The addition of synthetic polymer is always one of the popular ways for the treatment plant operator to immediately solve the poor sludge settling problem. Therefore, it may be interesting to understand the effects of synthetic polymer on the filamentous bacteria in activated sludge. In this study, synthetic polymer was applied to a lab-scale wastewater treatment system with the filamentous bulking problem. The population structure of filamentous bacteria and sludge characteristics were investigated under different conditions. When synthetic polymer was added into the system, it was found that poor sludge settleability caused by filamentous bulking was temporarily solved and filamentous branches growing outside the flocs were damaged or inhibited. However, filamentous growth was still observed inside the flocs. After the addition of polymer was halted, filamentous branches extended out of the flocs immediately. Very serious filamentous bulking occurred and sludge settleability became much worse than that occurring before the addition of polymer. And, it took several weeks for the system to return to normal operation.     

Group-specific small-subunit rRNA hybridization probes to characterize filamentous foaming in activated sludge systems.

Foaming in activated sludge systems is characterized by the formation of a thick, chocolate brown-colored scum that floats on the surface of aeration basins and secondary clarifiers. These viscous foams have been associated with the presence of filamentous mycolic acid-containing actinomycetes. To aid in evaluating the microbial representation in foam, we developed and characterized group-, genus-, and species-specific oligonucleotide probes targeting the small subunit rRNA of the Mycobacterium complex, Gordona spp., and Gordona (Nocardia) amarae, respectively. The use of a universal base analog, 5-nitroindole, in oligonucleotide probe design was evaluated by comparing the characteristics of two different versions of the Mycobacterium complex probe. The temperature of dissociation of each probe was determined. Probe specificity studies with a diverse collection of 67 target and nontarget rRNAs demonstrated the specificity of the probes to the target groups. Whole-cell hybridizations with fluorescein- and rhodamine-labeled probes were performed with pure cultures of various members of the Mycobacterium complex as well as with environmental samples from a full-scale activated sludge plant which experienced foaming. Quantitative membrane hybridizations with activated sludge and anaerobic digester foam showed that 15.0 to 18.3% of the total small-subunit rRNAs could be attributed to members of the Mycobacterium complex, of which a vast majority consisted of Gordona rRNA. Several G. amarae strains made up only a very small percentage of the Gordona strains present. We demonstrated that group-specific rRNA probes are useful tools for the in situ monitoring and identification of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge systems.     

Prevention of Gordonia and Nocardia stabilized foam formation by using bacteriophage GTE7

Most activated sludge treatment plants suffer from the presence of foams on the surfaces of their aeration reactors. These are often stabilized by hydrophobic mycolic acid-synthesizing actinobacterial species. A polyvalent Siphoviridae phage, GTE7, which lysed several Gordonia and Nocardia species, is described here. Its genome has a modular structure similar to that described for Rhodococcus phage ReqiDocB7. In laboratory-scale experiments, we showed that GTE7 prevents stabilization of foams by these Gordonia and Nocardia species.     

Quantitative use of fluorescent in situ hybridization to examine relationships between mycolic acid-containing actinomycetes and foaming in activated sludge plants

The formation of viscous foams on aeration basins and secondary clarifiers of activated sludge plants is a common and widespread problem. Foam formation is often attributed to the presence of mycolic acid-containing actinomycetes (mycolata). In order to examine the relationship between the number of mycolata and foam, we developed a group-specific probe targeting the 16S rRNA of the mycolata, a protocol to permeabilize mycolata, and a statistically robust quantification method. Statistical analyses showed that a lipase-based permeabilization method was quantitatively superior to previously described methods (P < 0.05). When mixed liquor and foam samples were examined, most of the mycolata present were rods or cocci, although filamentous mycolata were also observed. A nested analysis of variance showed that virtually all of the measured variance occurred between fields of view and not between samples. On this basis we determined that as few as five fields of view could be used to give a statistically meaningful sample. Quantitative fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was used to examine the relationship between foaming and the concentration of mycolata in a 20-m(3) completely mixed activated sludge plant. Foaming occurred when the number of mycolata exceeded a certain threshold value. Baffling of the plant affected foaming without affecting the number of mycolata. We tentatively estimated that the threshold foaming concentration of mycolata was about 2 x 10(6) cells ml(-1) or 4 x 10(12) cells m(-2). We concluded that quantitative use of FISH is feasible and that quantification is a prerequisite for rational investigation of foaming in activated sludge.     

Assessment of microbial community structure changes by amplified ribosomal DNA restriction analysis (ARDRA).

Amplified ribosomal DNA restriction analysis (ARDRA) is a simple method based on restriction endonuclease digestion of the amplified bacterial 16S rDNA. In this study we have evaluated the suitability of this method to detect differences in activated sludge bacterial communities fed on domestic or industrial wastewater, and subject to different operational conditions. The ability of ARDRA to detect these differences has been tested in modified Ludzack-Ettinger (MLE) configurations. Samples from three activated sludge wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) with the MLE configuration were collected for both oxic and anoxic reactors, and ARDRA patterns using double enzyme digestions AluI+MspI were obtained. A matrix of Dice similarity coefficients was calculated and used to compare these restriction patterns. Differences in the community structure due to influent characteristics and temperature could be observed, but not between the oxic and anoxic reactors of each of the three MLE configurations. Other possible applications of ARDRA for detecting and monitoring changes in activated sludge systems are also discussed.     

Aluminium,silicon and transition metal dynamics in a non-polluted lake: aquatic concentrations and phytoplankton uptake

Free-swimming Annelida occasionally occur in very high densities in WWTPs (WasteWater Treatment Plants) and are nowadays applied for waste sludge reduction, but their growth is uncontrollable. In order to get more insight in the population dynamics of these free-swimming Annelida, and relate their presence to process characteristics, nine ATs (Aeration Tanks) of four Dutch WWTPs were regularly sampled over a 2.5-year period. For each species, peak periods in worm population growth were defined and population doubling times and half-lives calculated. Peak periods and doubling times were compared to those in natural systems. Process characteristics were obtained from the plant operators and related to the worm populations by multivariate analysis for the first time in large-scale WWTPs. The species composition in the WWTPs was limited and the most abundant free-swimming Annelida were in decreasing order Nais spp., Aeolosoma hemprichi, Pristina aequiseta, Aeolosoma variegatum, Chaetogaster diastrophus, and Aeolosoma tenebrarum.This latter species had never been found before in WWTPs. Worm absence sometimes coincided with the presence of anoxic zones, but this was possibly overcome by higher temperatures in the WWTPs. Worms were present all year round, even in winter, but no yearly recurrences of population peaks were observed, probably as a result of stable food supply and temperature, and the lack of predation in the WWTPs. Peak periods were similar between the ATs of each WWTP. The duration of the peak periods was on average 2–3 months for each species and the population doubling times in the peak periods were short (on average 2–6 days), which also corresponds to a stable favorable environment. The disappearance of worm populations from the WWTPs was presumably caused by declining asexual reproduction and subsequent removal with the waste sludge. Multivariate analysis indicated that 36% of the variability in worm populations was due to spatial and temporal patterns only. In addition, no more than 4% of the variability in worm populations was related to variations in process characteristics only and worm presence was usually associated with better sludge settleability. In conclusion, our data from large-scale WWTPs suggest that growth of free-swimming Annelida still seems uncontrollable and that their effects on treatment processes are unclear, which makes stable application in wastewater treatment for sludge reduction difficult. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Handling editor: K. Martens     

Occurrence of ammonia-oxidizing Archaea in activated sludges of a laboratory scale reactor and two wastewater treatment plants

Aims:  Characterization of the ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA) community in activated sludge from a nitrogen removal bioreactor and wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs).
Methods and Results:  Three primer sets specific for ammonia mono-oxygenase α -subunit ( amoA ) were used to construct clone libraries for activated sludge sample from a nitrogen removal bioreactor. One primer set resulted in strong nonspecific PCR products. The other two clone libraries retrieved both shared and unique AOA amoA sequences. One primer set was chosen to study the AOA communities of activated sludge samples from Shatin and Stanley WWTPs. In total, 18 AOA amoA sequences were recovered and compared to the previous reported sequences. A phylogenetic analysis indicated that sequences found in this study fell into three clusters.
Conclusions:  Different primers resulted in varied AOA communities from the same sample. The AOA found from Hong Kong WWTPs were closely similar to those from sediment and soil, but distinct from those from activated sludge in other places. A comparison of clone libraries between Shatin WWTP and bioreactor indicated the AOA community significantly shifted only after 30-day enrichment.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  This study confirmed the occurrence of AOA in a laboratory scale nitrogen removal bioreactor and Hong Kong WWTPs treating saline or freshwater wastewater. AOA communities found in this study were significantly different from those found in other places. To retrieve diverse AOA communities from environmental samples, a combination of different primers for the amoA gene is needed.     

我国南北区域城市污水处理系统内真菌群落的差异

【背景】微生物是污水处理系统内污染物去除的主体,真菌作为其中不可或缺的一部分,在去除有毒化合物、提高生物转化等方面发挥着重要作用,应引起人们的关注。【目的】明确我国南北区域城市污水处理系统内真菌群落的多样性、组成差异及其影响因素。【方法】采集我国北方23个污水处理厂的90份活性污泥样品和南方37个污水处理厂的121份活性污泥样品,提取上述样本的总DNA,并应用Illumina MiSeq平台进行ITS高通量测序,结合多种数量生态学分析方法对数据进行分析。【结果】我国南北区域城市污水处理系统内真菌群落结构存在显著差异,真菌群落多样性南方显著高于北方;我国南北区域真菌群落的组成差异显著,南方群落以Sordariomycetes和Glomeromycetes为优势菌纲,以Ophiocordycep和Alternaria为优势菌属,北方群落以Tremellomycetes和Saccharomycetes为优势菌纲,以Trichosporon和Saccharomyces为优势菌属,其中Tremellomycetes和Sordariomycetes是常见的病原菌,对下游生物或者人类的健康具有潜在威胁,Trichosporon属的丝状真菌若大量异常增殖会引发污泥膨胀现象,影响系统的稳定运行;地理纬度、年平均气温、进水NH_4~+浓度、进水总氮浓度是导致我国南北区域真菌群落存在差异的重要影响因子。【结论】我国南北区域真菌群落多样性、组成存在显著差异,地理因素、所在城市的气候因素和进水污染物浓度对真菌群落结构影响显著。针对南北区域,应合理调控相应区域内的重要功能菌群,以调控污水处理厂的高效稳定运行,同时密切关注其中的条件致病菌和易引发污泥膨胀的菌群,建立面向种群的优化控制系统以管控风险。     

Bacteriology of activated sludge,in particular the filamentous bacteria

Microscopic examination of bulking activated sludge samples showed the presence of a variety of filamentous microorganisms, some of which have not yet been described in the literature. A method was developed to obtain pure cultures of these threaded bacteria. To date, five clearly different groups of filamentous bacteria may be distinguished by the determination of a few morphological and physiological characteristics of the isolates. A variety of sheathed bacteria are included in Group I. Group II includes non-motile, gram-negative, orange- or yellow-pigmented filamentous bacteria. These microorganisms are thought to be related to some species of the genusFlavobacterium. The gram-negative, threaded bacteria of Group III show a more or less distinct gliding movement and form red colonies on rich agar media. These bacteria may apparently be related to species described in the generaMicroscilla andFlexibacter. The filamentous bacteria of Group IV structurally resemble someCyanophyceae, but do not contain photosynthetic pigments. They are gram-positive and non-motile. A number of unknown, non-motile bacteria which stain gram-positive with a variable number of gram-negative autolyzed cells in the filaments, are assigned to Group V. The properties of the isolated bacteria are described briefly and their occurrence in bulking activated sludge is discussed.     

Ecophysiology of the filamentous Alphaproteobacterium Meganema perideroedes in activated sludge

A comprehensive study of the ecophysiology of the filamentous Meganema perideroedes affiliated to the Alphaproteobacteria, possessing a "Nostocoida limicola Type II" filamentous morphology was conducted. This morphotype often causes serious bulking problems in activated sludge wastewater treatment plants, and hardly anything is known about its physiology. The study was carried out by applying a suite of in situ methods in an industrial activated sludge treatment plant with excessive growth of this species. The experiments revealed a very versatile organism able to take up a large variety of organic substrates under aerobic conditions. It had a remarkably high storage capacity forming polyhydroxyalkanoates from most substrates tested. When nitrate was present as e-acceptor, the number of substrates to be consumed by M. perideroedes was more restricted compared to aerobic conditions. With nitrite as e-acceptor, only acetate and glucose among the substrates tested could be assimilated and used for storage and possibly growth. This indicated that M. perideroedes might be able to denitrify under certain conditions, which is unusual for filamentous bacteria in activated sludge. No substrate uptake or storage was seen under anaerobic conditions. M. perideroedes was relatively hydrophobic, compared to other filamentous bacteria and microcolonies present in the sludge, indicating the presence of a hydrophobic sheath. Several excreted surface-associated exoenzymes were detected in the sludge, but M. perideroedes never showed any activity, except once after a breakdown in the production facility. This confirmed that M. perideroedes mainly grows on soluble substrates. Based on the studies of the ecophysiology of M. perideroedes, potential control strategies are suggested.     

Quantitative Use of Fluorescent In Situ Hybridization To Examine Relationships between Mycolic Acid-Containing Actinomycetes and Foaming in Activated Sludge Plants

The formation of viscous foams on aeration basins and secondary clarifiers of activated sludge plants is a common and widespread problem. Foam formation is often attributed to the presence of mycolic acid-containing actinomycetes (mycolata). In order to examine the relationship between the number of mycolata and foam, we developed a group-specific probe targeting the 16S rRNA of the mycolata, a protocol to permeabilize mycolata, and a statistically robust quantification method. Statistical analyses showed that a lipase-based permeabilization method was quantitatively superior to previously described methods (P << 0.05). When mixed liquor and foam samples were examined, most of the mycolata present were rods or cocci, although filamentous mycolata were also observed. A nested analysis of variance showed that virtually all of the measured variance occurred between fields of view and not between samples. On this basis we determined that as few as five fields of view could be used to give a statistically meaningful sample. Quantitative fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was used to examine the relationship between foaming and the concentration of mycolata in a 20-m³ completely mixed activated sludge plant. Foaming occurred when the number of mycolata exceeded a certain threshold value. Baffling of the plant affected foaming without affecting the number of mycolata. We tentatively estimated that the threshold foaming concentration of mycolata was about 2 × 10⁶ cells ml⁻¹ or 4 × 10¹² cells m⁻². We concluded that quantitative use of FISH is feasible and that quantification is a prerequisite for rational investigation of foaming in activated sludge.